You are on page 1of 6

15452263, 2017, 10, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/stc.1985 by Readcube (Labtiva Inc.), Wiley Online Library on [24/03/2023].

See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
Received: 22 June 2016 Revised: 25 October 2016 Accepted: 17 December 2016
DOI: 10.1002/stc.1985

RESEARCH ARTICLE

Detecting structural damage to bridge girders using radar


interferometry and computational modelling
Maizuar Maizuar1,2 | Lihai Zhang1 | Saeed Miramini1 | Priyan Mendis1 |
Russell G. Thompson1

1
Department of Infrastructure Engineering,
University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia Summary
2
Department of Civil Engineering, Malikussaleh The process for assessing the condition of a bridge involves continuously mon-
University, Indonesia itoring changes to the material properties, support conditions, and system con-
Correspondence nectivity throughout its life cycle. It is known that the structural integrity of
Maizuar Maizuar, Department of Infrastructure bridges can be monitored by measuring their vibration responses. However,
Engineering, University of Melbourne, Victoria
3010, Australia.
the relationship between frequency changes and structural damage is still not
Email: mmaizuar@student.unimelb.edu.au fully understood. This study presents a bridge condition assessment framework
which integrates computational modelling and noncontact radar sensor tech-
Funding information niques (i.e., IBIS‐S) to predict changes in the natural frequencies of a bridge
Australian Research Council, Grant/Award Num- girder as a result of a range of parameters that govern its structural performance
ber: ARC IH150100006. Australia‐Indonesia
(e.g., elastomeric bearing stiffness, concrete compressive stiffness, and crack
Centre (TRP 2016)Indonesian Endowment Fund
for Education (LPDP) propagation). Using a prestressed concrete bridge in Australia as a case study,
the research outcomes suggest that vibration monitoring using IBIS‐S is an effi-
cient way for detecting the degradation of elastomeric bearing stiffness and
shear crack propagation in the support areas that can significantly affect the
overall structural integrity of a bridge structure. However, frequency measure-
ments have limited capability for detecting the decrease in the material proper-
ties of a bridge girder.

K E Y WO R D S

bridge girder, elastomeric bearing stiffness, IBIS‐S, shear crack propagation

1 | IN T RO D U C T IO N innovative condition inspection techniques in conjunction


with computer modelling becomes necessary.
With increased demand in freight transport, the structural In recent decades, numerous advanced nondestructive
performance of urban transport infrastructure networks has testing techniques have been developed with the aim of detect-
become a major concern for society globally especially for ing the structural performance of bridge structures in an
its maintenance and replacement. In Australia, articulated accurate and timely manner. Among these, the application of
trucks now represent approximately 80% of freight trans- vibration techniques has been considered to be a cost‐efficient
port.[1] Consequently, the increased volume of articulated way of monitoring the overall structural integrity of a bridge
trucks and their induced dynamic effects could accelerate on the basis of the dynamic characteristics of a structure
the structural deterioration of bridges and so reduce their (e.g., natural frequencies).[5–7] In comparison to modal shape
service life due to the degradation of construction materials measurement that requires multiple locations and is prone to
(e.g., concrete creep, elastomeric bearing degradation, and noise, natural frequency measurement only requires a single
crack propagation).[2–4] As traditional visual inspection tech- measurement point, and therefore, the measured results are
niques may not be able to detect some types of bridge dam- more accurate and reliable.[8,9] Although it is well known that
age (e.g., deep cracks and holes in concrete bridge girders) changes in natural frequencies are also closely correlated to
in a timely and efficiently manner, the development of changes of the overall stiffness of bridge structures,[10] further

Struct Control Health Monit. 2017;24:e1985. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/stc Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 1 of 6
https://doi.org/10.1002/stc.1985
15452263, 2017, 10, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/stc.1985 by Readcube (Labtiva Inc.), Wiley Online Library on [24/03/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
2 of 6 MAIZUAR ET AL.

research work is required to accurately identify a range of 2 | METHODS


different types of structural damage for bridges.
Dynamic monitoring of structures under operational condi- 2.1 | FE modelling for concrete bridges
tions using noncontact sensors has gained popularity in recent
years. Testing of various civil engineering structures worldwide A 3D FE model of the prestressed concrete Super T‐girder was
has demonstrated the significant advantages of nondestructive developed using commercial software package COMSOL
testing techniques over traditional methods.[11,12] Newly devel- 5.0[23] to simulate changes in natural frequencies of the bridge
oped noncontact radar sensors such as IBIS‐S (i.e. Image By girders as a result of their structural performance deterioration.
Interferometric Survey of Structures) are capable of remotely COMSOL is a commercial FE package, which becomes increas-
monitoring static and dynamic measurements of a structure ingly popular in modelling reinforced concrete structures.[24,25]
with high accuracy by detecting changes in natural frequencies In COMSOL, the concrete can be modelled using solid ele-
of bridge structures and therefore can detect damage to a bridge ments, while individual steel rebars may be modelled by adding
under operational conditions in a convenient and efficient a truss interface to the solid interface used for the concrete.
way.[13,14] Although previous studies have mainly focused on The geometric and material properties of the Super T‐
comparing the measurement results of radar sensors (IBIS‐S) girder were based on the “as built” construction drawings
with that of various other types of instruments (e.g., accelerom- provided by VicRoads, Australia (Figure 1 and Table 1). As
eters), there are relatively few studies that have validated and shown in Figure 1a, the Super T‐girder is supported by elas-
interpreted IBIS‐S results by developing computational tomeric bearings that are modelled as two elastic springs in
models.[15–17] Our recent study on monitoring the dynamic this study with compressive stiffness K1 and K2, respectively.
behaviour of a full‐scale prestressed concrete bridge using In addition, to investigate the effects of crack propagation on
noncontact sensors (IBIS‐S) under daily traffic loading showed changes in natural frequencies of the Super T‐girder, it is
that the natural frequency of the bridge measured by IBIS‐S and assumed that there are two shear cracks near the supports
the maximum vertical displacement of the bridge girders are
consistent with that obtained from numerical simulation.[18,19]
However, it is still not fully understood how changes in natural
frequencies are correlated to changes in a series of key param-
eters (e.g., support conditions and crack propagation near the
zone of supports) that govern the overall structural performance
of a bridge structure. For example, it has been shown that crack
propagation on a cantilever beam could potentially decrease the
natural frequency of the beam by 16%.[20–22]
The purpose of this study is to integrate advanced inter-
ferometric radar techniques (IBIS‐S) and numerical model-
ling to investigate changes in natural frequencies of a bridge
due to the deterioration of structural performance under vari-
ous conditions (e.g., degradation of elastomeric bearings and
concrete compressive strength and propagation of shear
cracks in the support zones). The Merlynston Creek bridge
located on the M80 Ring Road in Melbourne, Australia,
was used in this study. This prestressed concrete bridge was
initially constructed in 1996 with a length of 41 m and width
of 12 m. To accommodate the increased amount of traffic and
to reduce traffic congestion during peak hours, the bridge was
upgraded in 2012. The bridge deck is supported by two types
of bridge girders (i.e., Normal T‐girder and Super T‐girder).
This study mainly focusses on changes in natural frequencies
of the Super T‐girders as a result of structural performance
deterioration. For this purpose, we first developed a three‐
dimensional (3D) finite element (FE) model of the bridge.
The model predictions were then validated by conducting
field testing using IBIS‐S. Finally, a series of parametric stud-
ies were carried out to investigate changes in natural frequen-
cies of the bridge as a result of a decrease in elastomeric FIGURE 1 Schematic diagram of Super T‐girder for finite element
bearing stiffness and concrete compressive strength, as well modelling. (a) Super T‐girder modelling. (b) Cross section details.
as shear crack propagation, respectively. (c) Tetrahedral solid elements of Super T‐girder
15452263, 2017, 10, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/stc.1985 by Readcube (Labtiva Inc.), Wiley Online Library on [24/03/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
MAIZUAR ET AL. 3 of 6

TABLE 1 Parameters used in this study 2.2 | Monitoring the dynamic behaviour of bridges
Parameter Value using interferometric radar technique
Mass density of concrete (kg/cm3) 2,400 To validate the FE model developed in Section 2.1, a series
Poisson's ratio of concrete 0.2 of field tests were carried out using IBIS‐S.[26] The IBIS‐S
Concrete compressive strength f ′c of 50 instrument was located underneath the bridge as shown in
girder (MPa) Figure 2 to capture the strong reflected signals from the
Concrete compressive strength f ′c of 40 target girder with a configuration of 4.3 m height (h) at
bridge deck (MPa)
mid of span of the girder and a distance resolution of
Modulus elasticity of bridge girder 34.8 × 104
(MPa) 0.75 m.
Modulus elasticity of bridge deck (MPa) 32.8 × 104 Dynamic response measurement using IBIS is based
Mass density of rebar (kg/cm ) 3
7,850 on two well‐known radar techniques, that is, the stepped‐
Poisson's ratio of rebar 0.3 frequency continuous wave technique and the interferometry
Young's modulus of steel bar (MPa) 2 × 106 technique. The stepped‐frequency continuous wave technique
Cross section area of steel bar (mm ) 2
14 × 113.04 enables the detection of different target points along the line
Mass density of prestressing steel 7,850 sight of radar measurement through transmitting short‐time
(kg/cm3) duration (τ) pulses to achieve high‐range resolution (ΔR),
Poisson's ratio of prestressing steel 0.33 which is the minimum distance between two points on the
Young's modulus of prestressing steel 2 × 106 structure that can be determined in term of pulse duration
(MPa)
(τ = 1/B) as follows:
Cross section area of prestressing steel 22 × 98.6
(mm2) cτ
ΔR ¼ ; (1)
Prestressing force Pt (kN) 187 2
6
Elastic spring stiffness K1 and K2 (N/m) 168 × 10
where c is speed of light in free space. The frequency band-
o
with a length of d in 45 as shown in Figure 1a. Using Eigen width B of N monochromatic pulses with set of frequency
frequency analysis, the steel bars were modelled using truss step Δf emitted by radar is given by
elements, and the concrete girder was modelled using 6,581
tetrahedral solid elements (Figure 1c). B ¼ ðN−1ÞΔf : (2)

FIGURE 2 Dynamic monitoring of Merlynston Creek bridge using noncontact sensors IBIS‐S. (a) View of Merlynston Creek bridge during the in‐field test
using noncontact sensors IBIS‐S. (b) Configuration of IBIS‐S
15452263, 2017, 10, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/stc.1985 by Readcube (Labtiva Inc.), Wiley Online Library on [24/03/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
4 of 6 MAIZUAR ET AL.

It should be noted that the main frequencies of large civil values in descending order. If the mode shapes are orthogo-
engineering structures (e.g., bridges, buildings, and towers) is nal, there will only be one term in Equation 6. Thus, the
in the range of 0–30 Hz. Thus, the configuration of IBIS‐S spectral matrix can be estimated by a rank‐one matrix as
with an acquisition rate at 30 Hz is able to meet the require- follows:
ments of sampling frequency of dynamic testing.[27] In addi-
tion, an unambiguous range measurement is obtained if the Gð f r Þ≈ σ 1 ð f r Þu1 ð f r ÞuH
1 ð f rÞ (8)
range of the targets is restricted to the maximum measured
distance (Rmax), that is, Δf is required to be less than For this case, the first singular vector u1( fr) becomes an
150 KHz for a 1,000 m unambiguous target range. estimate of the mode shape while the first singular scalar
value σ1( f ) at each frequency represents the strength of the
c
Rmax ¼ : (3) dominating vibration mode. Most importantly, the first singu-
2Δf
lar function can be used as a modal indication function to
estimate resonant frequencies. The remaining singular values
By substituting Equation 1 and Equation 2 into Equation
may contain either noise or modes close to the dominant
3, the maximum sampling rate (fmax) can be obtained
mode.
cΔR
f max ¼ : (4)
4R2max 3 | R E S U LTS AN D D I S CU S S I ON

In addition, the interferometry technique enables the


3.1 | Model validation
radial displacement (dr) of the scatter objects of the structure
illuminated by the antenna beam by equating phase the shift The thermal signal‐to‐noise ratios as a function of range pro-
of the electromagnetic waves reflected by the object in vari- file of the bridge girder is shown in Figure 3a, while the range
ous time intervals to be remotely measured. That is, bin‐polar coordinates at test point represent the quality of the
acquired signals are shown in Figure 3b. The natural frequen-
λ cies were identified through analysing the datasets acquired
dr ¼ − Δθ; (5)
4π by IBIS‐S using the Frequency Domain Decomposition tech-
nique shown in Figure 3c. The results indicate that the
where λ is the wavelength of the electromagnetic signal, and
resonant frequency and the second mode of natural frequency
Δθ is the phase shift. Hence, the actual displacement of dif-
of the bridge girder are 9.4 Hz and 15.5 Hz, respectively.
ferent targeted point can be easily determined by way of geo-
Most importantly, it demonstrated that FE modelling results
metric projection.
agree remarkably well with the IBIS‐S measurements
The resonant frequency of a bridge can be obtained by
(Table 2).
extracting the data sets based on the Frequency Domain
Decomposition technique in the frequency domain. The
power spectral density function matrix is decomposed into a 3.2 | Parametric study
set of auto spectral density functions using singular value After validation, the model developed was implemented to
decomposition, with each function corresponding to an indi- investigate the interrelationship between changes in natural
vidual frequency mode.[28,29] frequencies and the structural performance deterioration of
For a linear dynamic system, the response spectral den- a bridge girder through conducting a series of parametric
sity matrix subjected to a white‐noise random excitation studies. Specially, this study focused on studying the
may be expressed as: effects of the degradation of elastomeric bearings stiffness
and concrete compressive strength as well as shear crack
Gð f Þ ¼ ΦGqq ð f ÞΦH ; (6) propagations in the support zones of the bridge girder
on the dynamic characteristics of the bridge girders.
where Φ and Gqq( f ) are the mode shapes matrix and the spectral
matrix of the modal coordinates, respectively. The superscript H
3.2.1 | Degradation of concrete compressive strength
represents the complex conjugate matrix transpose. The spectral
In this study, the natural frequencies were theoretically
matrix should be composed of diagonal terms with the auto‐
predicted assuming that the concrete compressive strength
spectral densities and the other terms with the cross‐spectral
degradation of the bridge girder is reduced by 80%,
densities. Taking the singular value decomposition at each fre-
64%, and 50%, respectively. The simulation results pre-
quency, the output power spectral density G( f ) becomes
sented in Figure 4 showed that degradation of the concrete
Gð f Þ ¼ U ð f ÞΣð f ÞU H ð f Þ; (7) compressive strength of the bridge girder would generally
lead to a decrease in the natural frequencies of the girder.
where U is a unitary matrix of the singular vector uij, Σ con- However, the impact of concrete compressive strength
tains a diagonal matrix of the real positive singular scalar degradation on natural frequencies is apparently not
15452263, 2017, 10, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/stc.1985 by Readcube (Labtiva Inc.), Wiley Online Library on [24/03/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
MAIZUAR ET AL. 5 of 6

FIGURE 4 Changes in natural frequencies due to concrete compressive


strength degradation. Concrete compressive strength is normalized to its initial
value (i.e., 50 MPa) while the reference value of natural frequency is 9.37 Hz

3.2.2 | Degradation of elastomeric bearings


The deterioration of the mechanical stiffness of elastomeric
bearings could be modelled by either decreasing both K1
and K2 or decreasing only one of them. It can be seen from
Figure 5 that elastomeric bearings stiffness degradation is
significantly correlated to the natural frequency of the girder.
For example, changes in natural frequencies decrease by 45%
when the stiffness of both elastomeric bearings stiffness is
decreased by 20%, simultaneously. Further, it showed that
decreasing either K1 or K2 also has a significant impact on
the natural frequencies of the girder. These results indicate that
monitoring natural frequencies is an effective way of detecting
changes in the mechanical stiffness of elastomeric bearings.

3.2.3 | Propagation of shear cracks in support zones of bridge


girders
Recent studies have revealed that natural frequencies are gener-
ally insensitive to bending crack propagation.[30] However, the
propagation of shear cracks that commonly occur near the sup-
ports of a bridge girder, which are subjected to relatively larger
FIGURE 3 Results generated from IBIS‐S measurements. (a) Thermal
shear forces may have a significant impact on the natural frequen-
signal‐to‐noise ratio (SNR) as a function of range profile of the bridge. (b)
The range bin‐polar coordinates at test point (TP) representing the quality of cies of the girder, and so are worthy of further investigation.[31]
the acquired signals. It can be seen that good acquisition data was obtained as
acquired signals are coherent (i.e., concentrate at a fixed distance from the
centre of the polar graph). (c) Natural frequencies generated from
experimental datasets

TABLE 2 Comparing natural frequencies from FE predictions with that


from IBIS‐S measurements

Natural frequency (Hz)


Method First mode Second mode

IBIS‐S measurements 9.4 15.5


FE prediction 9.37 15.74

Notes. FE = finite element.

significant. For example, 20% decrease of concrete com- FIGURE 5 Changes in natural frequencies due to degradation of elastomeric
pressive strength only reduces the natural frequency of bearings stiffness. Elastomeric bearings stiffness is normalized to its initial value
the girder around 2%. (i.e., 168 × 103 kN/m) while the reference value of natural frequency is 9.37 Hz
15452263, 2017, 10, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/stc.1985 by Readcube (Labtiva Inc.), Wiley Online Library on [24/03/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
6 of 6 MAIZUAR ET AL.

REFERENCES
[1] D. Mitchell, Australasian Transport Research Forum 2010, 1.
[2] L. Zhang, P. Mendis, W. C. Hon, S. Fragomeni, N. Lam, Y. Song, Comput.
Concr. 2013, 12(6), 739.
[3] C. G. Koh, K. K. Ang, L. Zhang, Eng. Struct. 1997, 19(1), 2.
[4] R. Karoumi, J. Wiberg, A. Liljencrantz, Eng. Struct. 2005, 27(12), 1813.
[5] P. A. Gudmundson, J. Mech. Phys. Solids. 1982, 30(5), 339.
[6] W. M. Ostachowicz, M. Krawczuk, Comput. Struct. 1990, 36(2), 245.
[7] R. Wei‐Xin, G. De Roeck, J. Struct. Eng. 2002, 128(1), 87.
[8] S. C. Siriwardane, CaseStud. Eng. Fail. Anal. 2015, 4, 50.
[9] O. S. Salawu, Eng. Struct. 1997, 19(9), 718.
[10] Z. Zhang, X. Ma, R. Rao, J. Vibroeng 2016, 18(1), 214.
[11] C. Gentile, G. Bernardini, Struct Infrastruct E: Maintenance, Management,
FIGURE 6 Changes in natural frequencies due to shear cracks
Life‐Cycle Design & Performance 2010, 6(5), 521.
propagations. The reference value of natural frequency is 9.37 Hz
[12] C. Gentile, NDT & E International 2010, 43(3), 231.
[13] C. Gentile, IV ECOMAS Thematic conference on Smart Structures and mate-
Figure 6 shows the natural frequency of the bridge girder as a rials 2009, 1.
function of the geometry of a shear crack (i.e., d/H from 0– [14] C. Gentile, IABSE Symposium 2010, 15.
0.6). It can be seen that shear crack propagation generally has a [15] M. Pieraccini, M. Fratini, F. Parrini, C. Atzeni, G. Bartoli, NDT & E Interna-
tional 2008, 41(4), 258.
significant impact on changes of natural frequencies of a bridge
[16] F. N. Shimoi, C. Cuadra, IEEE Conf. Contr. Appl. (CCA) 2015, 2015,
girder due to the damage of the girder supports. Most impor-
595.
tantly, the rate of decrease is significantly higher as the ratio of
[17] A. M. Alani, M. Aboutalebi, G. Kilic, J. Appl. Geophys. 2013, 97, 45.
d/H increases from 0 to 0.2. This outcome indicates that the mea-
[18] B. Kafle, L. Zhang, P. Mendis, M. Maizuar, C. Duffield, R. Thompson, Int.
surement of the dynamic characteristics of a bridge using IBIS‐S J. Appl. Mech. (Accepted) 2016.
is an effective way of monitoring the propagation of shear cracks [19] L. Zhang, M. Maizuar, P. Mendis, C. Duffield, R. Thompson, Appl Mech
in the support areas. Mater 2016, 846, 225.
[20] I. Negru, G. R. Gillich, Z. I. Praisach, M. Tufoi, N. Gillich, J. Phys : Confer-
ence Series 2015, 628(1), 1.
4 | C O NC LUS I O N S
[21] W. M. Ostachowicz, M. Krawczuk, J Sound Vib 1991, 150(2), 191.
In this study, we investigated the relationship between differ- [22] D. Tran, S. Fragomeni, Dynamic characteristics of reinforced concrete
ent types of structural damage on a bridge girder and its beams, in Incorporating Sustainable Practice in Mechanics and Structures
of Materials, (Eds: S. Fragomeni, S. Venkatesans), Taylor and Francis
impact on the natural frequencies of the girder by developing
Group, London 2011 303.
computational models in conjunction with IBIS‐S testing.
[23] R. W. Pryor, Multiphysics modeling using COMSOL: a first
The major findings were principles approach, Jones and Bartlett Publishers, United States of
America 2011.
• The bridge condition assessment framework proposed in
[24] A. Michel, A. O. S. Solgaard, M. R. Geiker, H. Stang, J. F. Olesen, Proceed-
this study can both effectively and efficiently monitor
ings of 7th International Conference on Fracture Mechanics of Concrete and
the overall structural integrity of a bridge structure. Concrete Structures (FraMCoS‐7) 2010, 944.
• The stiffness of elastomeric bearings is one of the most [25] D. P. Bentz, E. J. Garboczi, Y. Lu, N. Martys, A. R. Sakulich, W. J. Weiss,
Cem. Concr. Compos. 2013, 38, 65.
important parameters that govern the natural frequency
[26] IDS, IBIS Surveyor v.01.00‐User Manual, IDS, Italy 2013.
of a girder. The degradation rate of elastomeric bearing
[27] M. Pieraccini, F. Parrini, M. Fratini, C. Atzeni, P. Spinelli, M. Micheloni,
stiffness leads to the significant decrease in the structural
NDT & E International 2007, 40(3), 208.
performance of bridge girders.
[28] R. Brincker, L. Zhang, P. Andersen, 18th international modal analysis con-
• Changes in the natural frequencies of a bridge girder are ference (IMAC‐XVIII) 2000, 2, 717.
also very sensitive to shear crack propagation in the sup- [29] C. Gentile, G. Bernardini, NDT&E Int. 2008, 41, 544.
port zone of the girder, especially when the ratio of d/H [30] J.‐T. Kim, Y.‐S. Ryu, H.‐M. Cho, N. Stubbs, Eng. Struct. 2003, 25, 57.
increases from 0 to 0.2. [31] M. Zakaria, T. Ueda, Z. Wu, L. Meng, J. Adv. Concrete Technol. 2009, 7(1),
79.
• The degradation of the compressive strength of the
concrete of a bridge girder has little impact on the natural
frequencies of the girder.
How to cite this article: Maizuar M, Zhang L,
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Miramini S, Mendis P, Thompson RG. Detecting struc-
The authors wish to thank the Australian Research Council tural damage to bridge girders using radar interferometry
(ARC IH150100006), Australia‐Indonesia Centre (TRP 2016) and computational modelling. Struct Control Health
and Indonesian Endowment Fund for Education (LPDP) for Monit. 2017;24:e1985. https://doi.org/10.1002/stc.1985
their supports.

You might also like