Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CURRENT
OPINION Hypertension and the eye
Lazaros Konstantinidis and Yan Guex-Crosier
Purpose of review
Hypertension is the primary risk factor for cardiovascular disease and mortality that consists a major public
health issue worldwide. Hypertension triggers a series of pathophysiological ocular modifications affecting
significantly the retinal, choroidal, and optic nerve circulations that result in a range of ocular effects.
The retina is the only place in the body where microvasculature can be directly inspected, providing
valuable information on hypertension related systemic risks.
The aim of this review is to provide an update on latest advances regarding the detection and significance
of hypertension related eye signs.
Recent findings
It’s been shown that measurable retinal microvascular changes may precede progression of systemic
microvascular disease.
Last years, there are emerging advances in the field retinal imaging and computer software analysis that
have enabled the objective and accurate assessment of retinal vascular caliber, while in association with
latest epidemiological studies several other retinal vascular features have been recognized, such as
vascular length-to-diameter ratio, and wall-to-lumen ratio that may also be associated to hypertension.
Additionally, recent genetic studies have provided some insight to vascular pathophysiological processes
having correlated new chromosome’s loci to hypertensive retinopathy signs.
Summary
Assessment of hypertensive retinopathy signs may convey additional prognostic information on the risk of
end-organ damage and may alert for urgent systemic management or even preventive systemic therapies.
Further development of retinal vascular imaging and computerized system may provide a significant tool to
improve the diagnosis, prognosis, and management of hypertension in clinical practice.
Keywords
hypertensive retinopathy, retina, systemic hypertension
1040-8738 Copyright ! 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-ophthalmology.com 515
[43]. A recent study demonstrated that choroidal Scanning laser Doppler flowmetry
thickness, measured with spectral-domain optical Scanning laser Doppler flowmetry demonstrated
coherence tomography, decreases in patients with that BP emerged as an independent determinant
systemic arterial hypertension. This was attributed of the wall-to-lumen ratio of retinal arterioles [33].
to arteriolar sclerosis and vascular contraction In conclusion, while retinal image analysis pro-
caused by high intravascular pressure in the choroid vided exciting possibilities to study the pathogen-
[44]. esis of these diseases, its direct applicability in a
In contrast to these findings though, Gök et al. clinical setting as a ‘test’ to predict cardiovascular
[45] reported that systemic hypertension did not diseases is yet to be established, particularly within
influence subfoveal choroidal thickness in compari- the context of being used as a population screening
son to healthy controls. tool [28].
In another study, severe hypertension was Nevertheless, further development of retinal
associated to SRF accumulation, and increased cho- vascular analyses and standardized measurement
roid thickness. Furthermore, the presence of SRF was protocols, evaluation of the clinical use of retinal
associated with choroidal thickening and with poor vascular imaging in assessing cardiovascular risk
visual outcome in patients with severe hyperten- prediction, and using retinal vascular imaging to
sion. Thus, OCT may be useful to document test antihypertensive treatments may allow the
hypertensive retinopathy and choroidopathy translation of retinal vascular imaging as a tool to
severity [10]. improve the diagnosis, prognosis, and management
of hypertension in clinical practice [51]. Addition-
ally, new preventive therapeutic strategies could be
Adaptive optics
envisaged in hypertension that are targeted specially
High resolution imaging of retinal vessels by adap- at improving microvascular structure.
tive optics allows quantitative microvascular phe-
notyping, which may contribute to a better
understanding of the link between retinal vessels GENETIC STUDIES
and hypertension [46–49]. Genetic studies may provide some insight to vascu-
An increase of the wall-to-lumen ratio (WLR) is a lar pathophysiological processes linked to hyper-
hallmark of hypertensive microangiopathy and is tensive retinopathy signs.
predictive of end-organ damage [32,50]. New data from various studies indicate a signifi-
The idea of assessing the WLR ratio of retinal cant genetic contribution to retinal vascular caliber,
arterioles as an in-vivo parameter of vascular dam- an area that is under investigation [52–54].
age goes back to the finding that remodeling of In 2010, a population-based genome-wide
arterioles and small arteries, indicated by the association study demonstrated four novel loci
increase in the media to lumen ratio of the periph- (19q13, 6q24, 12q24, and 5q14) associated with
eral arterial resistance vessel, represents an early retinal venular caliber, an endophenotype of the
step, possibly the earliest step, in hypertension- microcirculation associated with clinical cardiovas-
associated vascular damage and target organ cular disease. Of these four loci, the locus on locus
disease [32]. 12q24 was also associated with coronary heart dis-
Adaptive optics imaging of retinal arterioles ease and hypertension [55].
offers an opportunity to explore microvascular Narrow arterioles in the retina have been shown
changes in vivo at a near-histology level and to predict hypertension as well as other vascular
could be considered an excellent tool to assess diseases, likely through an increase in the peripheral
WLR ratio and other characteristics of retinal resistance of the microcirculatory flow. In 2013, a
arterioles. genome-wide association study in 18 722 unrelated
In a recent study [47] using adaptive optics individuals of European ancestry identified one new
imaging BP was associated to increased WLR of locus on chromosome 5 which harbor variants con-
retinal arterioles by thickening arterial wall. What’s vincingly associated with retinal arteriolar caliber.
more, remodeling reversal observed in treated and The locus associated with retinal arteriolar caliber
controlled hypertensive patients comprising WLR on chromosome 5 spanned about 80 kb between
normalization associated with combined wall TMEM161B and MEF2C. Although, this study did
decrease and lumen dilatation. not manage to demonstrate associations between
Therefore, adaptive optics imaging of retinal the locus for retinal arteriolar and any macrovascu-
arterioles could provide biomarkers that may lar disease endpoints, including hypertension
improve stratification of the risk of end-organ maybe due to the limited power of the study to
damage [46]. detect associations with clinical outcomes [56].
1040-8738 Copyright ! 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-ophthalmology.com 517
A recent study using 24 000þ multiethnic is not only related to chronic exposure to hyperten-
participants from 7 discovery cohorts and 5000þ sion, but might precede the development of hyper-
subjects of European ancestry reported 4 new loci tension. In four longitudinal studies (6 247 adults)
associated with central retinal venule diameter, with follow-up periods ranging from 3 to 7 years
one of which is also associated with central retinal consistently showed that generalized retinal arterio-
arteriole diameter. The four single-nucleotide poly- lar narrowing was associated with an increased risk
morphisms were rs7926971 in TEAD1, rs201259422 of incident hypertension [62].
in TSPAN10, rs5442 in GNB3 and rs1800407 in Another more recent meta-analysis involving
OCA2. The latter single-nucleotide polymorphism, six prospective cohort studies among 10 229
rs1800407, was also associated with central retinal individuals provided a reliable demonstration and
arteriole diameter. Regarding phenotype relations, confirmatory evidence that changes in retinal vas-
single-nucleotide polymorphism rs201255422 was cular caliber, specifically retinal arteriolar narrowing
associated with both systolic and diastolic BPs [57]. and venular widening, are associated with an
The role of microRNAs (miRs) in hypertension increased risk of hypertension, developing over
and in several hypertension-related pathologies median follow-up periods of 2.9–10 years. The
have been investigated by several studies [58]. associations persist in those with optimal BP at
In 2011, a study showed a miR signature in baseline. On the basis of baseline and the follow-
plasma of patients with essential hypertension, up systolic BP (SBP) measurements, each 20-mm
which differed from their healthy counterparts: decrease on retinal arteriolar caliber at baseline is
27 miRs were differentially expressed [59]. associated with a 1.12 mmHg greater increase in SBP
In another study, the interplay between miR- over 5 years [63].
155 expression, þ1166C polymorphism, and AT1R These findings are consistent with the hypoth-
protein expression was associated with the regula- esis that generalized microvascular dysfunction,
tion of BP [60]. seen in the retinal vasculature, precedes the onset
Likewise, it’s been showed that the description and development of hypertension and possibly
of a genetic variant in the 30 untranslated region reflecting more widespread systemic peripheral
of vacuolar Hþ ATPase ATPV0A1 creates a miR-637- vasoconstriction.
binding motif related to hypertension risk by inter- Another interesting issue emerged from epide-
fering with the fine-tuning of several vasoactive miologic studies is that the impact of elevated BP on
substances, including chromogranin A as precursor the retinal microcirculation occurs in early life.
of catestatin, an inhibitor of catecholamine In a study concerning very young children 4 to 5
release [61]. years of age, higher SBP was associated with nar-
In conclusion, genetic studies may elucidate rower retinal arterioles and wider retinal venules
some aspects of hypertension pathophysiology suggesting that elevated BP may affect the retinal
and its relation to end organ damage, though, it microvasculature from early childhood [64].
needs to be affirmed that the contribution of arterial In another study of preschool-aged children
hypertension itself to end-organ damage is multi- each 10 mmHg increase in SBP was associated with
factorial, and is a combination of genetic suscepti- a 1.70 mm narrower retinal arteriolar calibre. Accord-
bility and environmental factors [58]. Further trials ingly, SBP demonstrated inverse linear associations
are required to clarify the significance of genetic with retinal arteriolar caliber, during early child-
factors in macrovascular disease endpoints, includ- hood suggesting that the influence of BP on small
ing hypertension. vessels is continuous and commences early in
life [65].
Another noteworthy issue emerged from
LATEST EPIDEMIOLOGICAL FEATURES epidemiologic studies is that retinal venular
Some interesting aspects concerning hypertensive diameter, not traditionally considered part of the
ocular signs have emerged last years from epidemio- spectrum of hypertensive retinopathy signs, may
logical studies. convey additional information regarding the state
There is good evidence that some signs, of the retinal vasculature and systemic health [6].
particularly generalized retinal arteriolar narrowing, A meta-analysis in 2014 [63] confirmed findings
may precede the development of hypertension [36]. in several studies [35–37,66], which have reported
In 2012, a meta-analysis of five cross-sectional an association between retinal venular widening
studies (including 19 633 subjects) showed that and incident hypertension. Retinal venular widen-
arteriolar calibre decreased by 3.07 mm for every ing has been hypothesized to be a general marker of
10-mmHg increase in arterial BP. Furthermore, it retinal ischemia and hypoperfusion secondary to
has been demonstrated that retinal artery narrowing microvascular rarefaction. The ensuing reduction
in blood vessels can cause a significant increase in For example, retinal arteriolar narrowing was associ-
peripheral vascular resistance and can exacerbate ated with lacunar stroke, while retinal hemorrhages
an initial increase in blood flow or pressure. In were linked with cerebral hemorrhages [72].
addition, retinal venular widening may reflect endo- Other studies showed that copper wiring and
thelial dysfunction [1] and thereby increase leuko- silver wiring predict atherosclerotic cerebral infarc-
cyte adhesion, which, in turn, is involved in tion [73], whereas signs of hypertensive arteriolar
microvascular remodeling [67]. However, retinal disease predict lacunar infarction [74].
venular widening may have pleiotropic associations In the Rotterdam study [75], larger retinal ven-
with cardiovascular risk factors and diseases, but not ular caliber is associated with an increased risk for
be a specific biomarker for hypertension [63]. stroke in the general population and, in particular,
The significance of retinal venular dilation in with an increased risk for intracerebral hemorrhage.
association to hypertension should be further If retinal microvascular changes precede
evaluated. progression of cerebral microvascular disease, this
might indicate a point at which preventive thera-
pies, for example, aimed at control of hypertension
Hypertensive retinopathy signs and risk of might be implemented which could even lead to
end-organ damage reduction in brain microvascular disease. Future
The retina is the one place in the body where the studies might evaluate the utility of retinal screen-
physician can actually directly inspect the body’s ing as an indicator of a need for more aggressive
microvasculature, the tissue most directly at risk vascular risk factor control [71].
from hypertension [68].
Cardiovascular disease
Cerebral microvascular disease The presence of hypertensive retinopathy signs is
Retinal and cerebral small vessels share similar associated with multiple markers of subclinical athe-
embryological origin, anatomical features, and rosclerotic diseases, including coronary artery calci-
physiological properties; thus the easily accessible fication, aortic stiffness, LV hypertrophy, and
evaluation of retinal vasculature has been carotid intima-media thickness [6].
considered a window on the brain [68,69]. Retinopathy signs were associated with cardio-
Retinopathy was shown to be predictive of vascular disease including increased coronary heart
cerebrovascular-related deaths. The presence of disease risk [76] and congestive heart failure [77].
retinopathy phenotype in association to increased Presence and severity of retinopathy were also
BP could identify patients at higher risk of fatal associated with increased risk of development
stroke [70]. of cardiovascular disease in patients with chronic
Additionally, cross-sectional studies demon- kidney disease [78].
strated a correlation between retinal microvascular Furthermore, another study showed that in the
changes and dementia, cognitive impairment, and presence of chronic kidney disease, retinopathy is a
brain imaging abnormalities [69]. strong predictor of mortality [79].
Ong et al. [4] studied 2907 participants in the In another note, the capacity of retinal arterioles
Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study, who to dilate in response to flicker light was demon-
were free of diabetes mellitus, stroke, or coronary strated as an independent predictor of the presence
artery disease at baseline, and were followed for of coronary artery disease and may suggests that
13 years. They found that even among patients retinal microvascular endothelial dysfunction is a
who were well controlled on antihypertensive marker for underlying coronary artery disease [80].
medication, moderate/severe retinopathy carried a In conclusion, the presence of hypertensive
nearly three-fold increase in the risk of stroke. retinopathy may convey additional prognostic
Retinal signs of hypertensive retinopathy that information on the risk of cardiovascular disease
include arteriovenous (AV) nicking, focal arteriolar and may alert for preventive systemic therapies.
narrowing, and any retinopathy as well as its
components were associated with leukoaraiosis
progression and brain microvascular disease [71]. CONCLUSION
Other studies further demonstrated that specific Hypertension has widespread effects on the ocular
hypertensive retinopathy signs might allow further vasculature. The presence of hypertensive retinop-
refinement and subtyping of stroke. athy may convey additional prognostic information
In a multicenter study of patients with on the risk of end-organ damage and may alert for
acute stroke, different hypertensive retinopathy urgent systemic management or even preventive
signs were associated with specific stroke subtypes. systemic therapies. Further development of retinal
1040-8738 Copyright ! 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-ophthalmology.com 519