Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Rolf Bernander, Magnus Lundgren & Thijs J. G. Ettema (2010) Comparative
and functional analysis of the archaeal cell cycle, Cell Cycle, 9:4, 795-806, DOI: 10.4161/
cc.9.4.10674
Key words: archaea, caulobacter, cell cycle, cell division, chromosome replication, crenarchaeota, cytokinesis, genome segregation,
mitosis, saccharomyces, sulfolobus
The temporal and spatial organization of the chromosome replication, genome segregation and cell division processes
is less well understood in species belonging to the Archaea, than in those from the Bacteria and Eukarya domains. Novel
insights into the regulation and key components of the Sulfolobus acidocaldarius cell cycle have been obtained through
genome-wide analysis of cell cycle-specific gene expression, followed by cloning and characterization of gene products
expressed at different cell cycle stages. Here, the results of the transcript profiling are further explored, and potential
key players in archaeal cell cycle progression are highlighted in an evolutionary context, by comparing gene expression
patterns and gene conservation between three selected microbial species from different domains of life. We draw
attention to novel putative nucleases and helicases implicated in DNA replication, recombination and repair, as well as to
potential genome segregation factors. Focus is also placed upon regulatory features, including transcription factors and
protein kinases inferred to be involved in the execution of specific cell cycle stages, and regulation through metabolic
coupling is discussed.
The archaeal and eukaryal replication machineries display In the following, we discuss proteins and genes that, based on
remarkable conservation, to the exclusion of bacteria4 (Fig. 2). integrative analysis of cell cycle-specific expression data, homol-
Only the respective DNA polymerase sliding clamp subunits of ogy searches, phylogenetic distribution patterns, and experimen-
the archaeal/eukaryal (PCNA) and bacterial (beta subunit of tal and comparative genomics data,26,27 are likely to constitute
bacterial DNA Pol III) systems fall into the same orthologous novel players in the archaeal cell cycle. The examples are orga-
group (COG0592). Deep common ancestry between other nized according to phylogenetic conservation, starting with pro-
components has also been suggested, as indicated by the similar teins specific to S. acidocaldarius or (cren)archaea and ending
tertiary structure of the DnaA and Cdc6 proteins.21 Conversely, with cell cycle factors found in all three domains of life. It should
the Mcm and DnaB helicases work in mechanistically different be noted that all genes discussed display cell cycle-specific expres-
fashions, e.g., by translocating on different DNA strands, sug- sion in S. acidocaldarius, whereas conservation in other organisms
gesting independent origins.22 In eukaryotes, the origin recogni- only refers to gene presence or absence (conservation of expres-
tion complex (ORC) remains bound to the origin throughout sion patterns is discussed above).
the cell cycle,23 and is activated in early G1 to recruit additional
factors for the pre-replicative complex (pre-RC) in a highly reg- (Cren)Archaeal-Specific Patterns
ulated manner. Cdc6 and Cdt1 are central components of the
pre-RC and bind ORC independently. In contrast to the eukary- This class comprises synapomorphic features of the (cren)archaeal
otic system, the genes for the origin-recognizing Cdc6-1, Cdc6-3 cell cycle. Interestingly, among genes that fit this phylogenetic
and WhiP24 proteins in Sulfolobus are transcribed just in time distribution are those with the highest cell cycle-dependent
for replication.9 The order and manner of replisome assem- induction levels observed in the entire S. acidocaldarius data set,9
bly in archaea is not known, nor how the process is regulated, e.g., Saci_0276 (NOG75842)28 (NOG; non-supervised ortholo-
though protein phosphorylation is likely to play a role, analogous gous group) and Saci_0277 (COG2248), as well as Saci_0743
to cyclin-dependent kinases in eukaryotes, as indicated by cell and Saci_0744 (NOG12498), both organized into putative
cycle-specific transcription of several protein serine-threonine operon structures. Saci_0277 has orthologs in all crenarchaea,
kinases in Sulfolobus.9 The expression of different central repli- several euryarchaea, as well as in the highly reduced genome of
cative factors, such as helicases, replicative polymerase and pro- the parasitic archaeon Nanoarchaeum equitans, and encodes an
cessivity components is, to varying degree, cell cycle-dependent uncharacterized protein of the metallo-beta-lactamase superfam-
in all three organisms, as is that of several additional factors ily. Saci_0276, Saci_0743 and Saci_0744, of which the former
(Fig. 2). In certain cases only one or a few subunits of a multi- two display the highest differential expression and thus would
subunit protein are cyclically expressed, reminiscent of the “just- be anticipated to play pivotal roles in mitosis, cytokinesis or early
in-time” complex assembly employed by different eukaryotes,25 replication events, encode proteins that are restricted to S. acido-
possibly to simplify regulation. Notably, most factors associated caldarius (Saci_0743), or to the Sulfolobales order (S. acidocal-
with lagging strand replication in all three domains do not dis- darius, S. islandicus, S. tokodaii, S. solfataricus and Metallosphaera
play cyclic transcription (Fig. 2), in agreement with a role in sedula). Ironically, all three gene products lack similarity to any
other, cell cycle-independent, processes, such as DNA repair, protein of known function.
during cell cycle periods other than S phase.3,9
Another gene of significant interest is Saci_0721 (COG1628). pendens endonuclease V, Tpen_0682, at an e-value of 4E-04).
The gene is located in a potential operon with the replication Additional iterations retrieve other significant hits with endonu-
initiator cdc6-1 (Saci_0722; COG1474), and both genes display clease V proteins, revealing a robustness of homology between
virtually identical temporal patterns of cyclic induction at the these distant protein families. The proposed relatedness is further
onset of S phase, although the Saci_0721 response is lower in supported by the significant similarity of 3D structures of AF1433,
magnitude. Detailed homology searches reveal that Saci_0721 the Archaeoglobus fulgidus representative of COG1628 (2QH9)29
orthologs are present in all archaeal genomes and that the protein and the Thermotoga maritima endonuclease V (Tm-EndoV;
is distantly homologous to endonuclease V (COG1515), which is COG1515; 2W36;30 Fig. 3A and B). Apart from the structural
involved in removal of deaminated bases (e.g., uracil, hypoxan- conservation, some of the residues that form the active site pocket
thine and xanthine) from damaged DNA, and displays activity in Tm-EndoV are conserved in AF1433, including those involved
towards base pair mismatches, flap- and pseudo-Y structures as in the interaction with the 5'-end of the phosphate groups of the
well as to small insertions/deletions in DNA molecules. A PSI- nicked product DNA (Asp43, Lys139 and His214 in Tm-EndoV;
BLAST search seeded with Saci_0721 (BLOSUM62 matrix, Fig. 3A), supporting a role in DNA repair for AF1433 and its
e-value inclusion threshold 0.005, low complexity filter enabled) orthologs. Yet, the strand-separating PYIP wedge (Pro79, Tyr80,
starts retrieving significant (e-value < 0.005) hits with proteins Ile81 and Pro82 in Tm-EndoV) which is a strongly conserved
belonging to COG1515 in the third iteration (e.g., Thermofilum element within proteins belonging to the EndoV family, seems to
be absent from COG1628 members, indicating mechanistic dif- Saci_0203 (NOG09521) is a candidate gene for involvement
ferences between COG1628 and EndoV proteins. In conclusion, in genome partition. The gene, located in a putative operon with
given the structural and distant sequence homology to EndoV in the ParA-encoding gene Saci_0204 (see below), displays dis-
conjunction with the cell cycle-dependent induction at early S tinct cyclic induction at the mitotic cell cycle stage similar to
phase, as well as the observed clustering with cdc6-1, it is tempt- Saci_0204, although at lower magnitude. Whereas parA appears
ing to speculate that the Saci_0721 gene product is involved in to be ubiquitous in archaea, Saci_0203 is restricted to members
DNA repair during genome replication and, as such, represents a of the Sulfolobales and certain methanogens. Interestingly, those
novel archaeal replisome component. species that do contain an Saci_0203 ortholog, this gene is always
Saci_1228 and Saci_1229 exhibit a phylogenetic distribution located directly adjacent to the ParA-encoding gene (Fig. 4A).
restricted to the Sulfolobales and Thermoproteales orders, and are Saci_0203 and its archaeal orthologs lack significant similarity to
organized into a putative operon structure that is highly induced other proteins, and among the Saci_0203 orthologs the homology
at the mitotis/cytokinesis stage. The Saci_1228 gene product is restricted to the C-terminal domain (not shown). Intriguingly,
and its archaeal orthologs contain an AAA+ ATPase domain and the N-terminus of the Saci_0203 ortholog in Methanobrevibacter
display distant homology to ATP-dependent HrpA-like helicases smithii (Msm_1240) displays weak similarity to the partition pro-
(COG1643), which are involved in RNA unwinding in a num- tein ParB (Fig. 4B). Although true ParB orthologs are present in
ber of processes, including mRNA processing and rRNA matura- most archaeal genomes, the S. acidocaldarius ParB-encoding gene
tion. Interestingly, HrpA-like RNA helicases are not encoded by (Saci_1498, COG1475) does not display a cell cycle-dependent
archaeal genomes, and hence the Saci_1228 gene product might expression pattern. Irrespective of putative ParB similarities, the
constitute an archaeal HrpA counterpart that affects cell cycle conserved clustering of Saci_0203 orthologs with ParA-encoding
progression. genes, as well as the observed induction during mitosis, strongly
implicate Saci_0203 and its orthologs in genome partition.
similar to eukaryotic counterparts.52 However, the Pcna sliding between methionine metabolism and cell cycle progression
clamp is required for catalytic function, an association that could has been observed in other organisms, but is currently not well
have the same role as the missing helicase domain, and indicates a understood. For example, methionine deprivation is widely used
function for the Saci_0604 gene product in repair of replication- as an anti-cancer treatment in human, as this has been shown
associated DNA damage,53 supported by the S-phase-specific to arrest the cell cycle,54 and methionine exposure has been
transcriptional activation. reported to induce G1 arrest in Schizosaccharomyces pombe.55 Yeast
protein MET16, which in S. acidocaldarius is closest related to
Universal Factors Saci_2202, has been shown to interact with the cytoplasmic
thioredoxin iso-enzymes TRX1 and TRX2, which protect
The hallmark example of a universally conserved cell cycle reg- cells against both oxidative and reductive stress.56 The S. acido-
ulated gene is ribonucleotide reductase (above; Fig. 1A). The caldarius genome contains 5 such thioredoxin-encoding genes
S-phase-coupled expression of both this and the likewise con- (Saci_0041, Saci_0340, Saci_0791, Saci_1485, Saci_1823).
served DNA polymerase sliding clamp are easily understood as Notably, Saci_1823 shows strong cell cycle-dependent reduc-
an increased demand for DNA synthesis precursors and replica- tion of expression in S phase, indicative of a coupling between
tion factors. In contrast, other examples of cell cycle-specificially methionine metabolism, stress responses and cell cycle progres-
expressed genes in S. acidocaldarius that show conservation also sion also in this organism. Altogether, the observation that genes
in the other two domains of life are less readily explained. involved in methionine metabolism in S. acidocaldarius display
Among the genes that showed cell cycle dependent expres- cell cycle dependent regulation, as in other organisms (Fig. 7),
sion in S. acidocaldarius, as well as universal conservation, alludes to a role in prevention of oxidative damage to the cell,
were those belonging to COG0175, which includes Saci_2202 presumably at the DNA level.
and Saci_0474 and counterparts in S. cerevisiae (MET16) and Another interesting universal class of cell cycle-regulated pro-
C. crescentus (CC1121; Fig. 7). COG0175 encompasses enzymes teins is represented by Saci_0046 and Saci_2119, which display
implicated in sulphate assimilation steps in methionine metab- distant homology to various members of the SMC protein fam-
olism (CysD and CysH) and in FAD biosynthesis. Linkage ily. SMC proteins are a large, diverse, family of ATPases that
participate in different aspects of higher-order chromosome orga- euryarchaeal Hel308 homolog (Hjm) has been shown to partially
nization and dynamics. The N-terminal domain of Saci_0046, complement the replication fork-remodelling RecQ helicase in
which displays induction during the S/G2 transition, displays E. coli.57 The S. solfataricus Hel308 ortholog is able to remove
distant homology to the (AAA+) ATPase domain of SMC pro- proteins and complementary DNA from the lagging strand of a
teins, including conservation of residues critical for ATPase activ- replication fork in the 3'-5' direction, enabling replication restart
ity (Fig. 8A). Detailed analysis of the C-terminal part suggests a or recombination initiation.58 Furthermore, Sulfolobus tokodaii
left-handed coiled-coil structure with a periodicity of about 3.5 Hel308 has been shown to associate with the Holliday junction-
residues (not shown). The Saci_2119 gene product also shows specific endonuclease Hjc59 which, together with the observed
distant homology to SMC proteins and is also induced during cyclic transcription of Saci_0263 during cell cycle progression,
the S/G2 transition, resembling Saci_0046 in terms of expression with upregulation in early S phase, supports a function for the
kinetics. The N-terminal region of Saci_2119 is dominated by a Sulfolobus orthologues in replication-coupled repair.
highly charged 14 amino acid repeat (NTKAI(A/I)ELRK(M/Q)
TEE) (Fig. 8B), again predicted to adopt a coiled-coil structure The Archaeal Cell Cycle goes Full Circle
(not shown). Together, the observed (distant) homology to SMC-
like ATPases, as well as the induction during the S/G2 transi- To obtain a comprehensive picture of the archaeal cell cycle, pro-
tion stage, indicate a potential involvement in the chromosome cesses and factors that remain unexplored require increased atten-
condensation and segregation processes for the Saci_0046 and tion. Comparative investigations of cell cycle components and
Saci_2119 gene products. expression patterns between organisms from all three domains
The Saci_0263 (COG1204) protein is similar to Hel308, of life provide valuable tools for further evaluation of existing
a member of the superfamily class 2 (SF2) helicases which are data sets, and the genes and proteins highlighted here are candi-
widely distributed across all three domains of life, as well as in dates to fulfil pivotal, yet unexplored, roles in archaeal cell cycle
viruses. Eukaryotic Hel308 has been shown to be involved in progression. Further investigation of these thus open up exciting
genome maintenance by stabilizing stalled replication forks and possibilites to fill in major remaining gaps in our understand-
removing recombination intermediates and recent biochemi- ing, such as the molecular details and regulatory features of the
cal data from other organisms support this RecQ-like role. A elusive archaeal mitotic process. Elucidation of the fundamental
regulatory signals and networks that govern archaeal cell cycle classification of the cell cycle-dependent genes was assigned using
progression is also within reach, and would have far-reaching the COG data base classification scheme downloaded from ftp://
implications both for fundamental aspects of archaeal biology ftp.ncbi.nih.gov/pub/COG/COG/.60
and for the cell cycle field in general. In particular, the extensive Protein sequence and structure analysis. Protein homology
similarities between archaea and eukaryotes suggest that insights searches were performed using PSI-BLAST using default settings
into core features of the eukaryotic cell cycle, including cancer- except that the low-complexity filter was enabled. Multiple
related issues, may be gained from results obtained with archaeal sequence alignments were performed using Kalign61 followed by
model systems. Several surprising findings have been reported manual adjustment whenever necessary. Comparisons of protein
during recent years, including the first example of multiple chro- structures, including structural alignments and structural super-
mosome replication origins in prokaryotes and a novel cell divi- imposition was based on 3D structural data obtained from PDB
sion mechanism, and we are confident that additional unexpected (http://www.rcsb.org/pdb/) 62 and performed using the Swiss
findings with wide implications are likely to emerge from the rap- PDB viewer.63
idly progressing archaeal cell cycle field. Supplementary data. A file comprising a dataset of cell cycle-
dependently regulated genes in S. acidocaldarius, C. crescentus
Materials and Methods and S. cerevisiae is available as a Supplementary file.