You are on page 1of 6

Comparison of Key International Arbitration Rules

Key International Arbitration Rules

USA Europe Far East Middle East International

Element
JAMS International
ICDR Rules 2021 LCIA Rules 2020 ICC Rules 2021 SCC Rules 2017 HKIAC Rules 2018 SIAC Rules 2016 JCAA Rules 2021 DIAC Rules 2022 UNCITRAL Rules 2013
Arbitration Rules 2021

Location New York with regional California with international London, with regional Paris, with regional centres Stockholm. Hong Kong. Singapore. Tokyo. Dubai. N/a (UNCITRAL is based in
centres in Bahrain, Mexico headquarters in London. centres in New Delhi and in Hong Kong, New York and New York and Vienna).
City and Singapore. Mauritius. Singapore.
Commencement Article 2 Article 2 Article 1 Article 4 Article 8 Article 4 Article 3 Article 14(6) Article 4 Article 3
The date the ICDR (as the The date on which JAMS The date the Request and The date the Request is The date the Request for The date the Notice of The date the Notice of The date the Request for The date the Request and The date the notice of
“Administrator” in all cases) issues a Commencement registration fee are received by the ICC Arbitration is received by Arbitration is received by Arbitration is delivered to Arbitration is received by the Registration Fee is arbitration is received by
receives the Notice of Letter. received by the LCIA Secretariat. the SCC. HKIAC (with a copy to the the SIAC Registrar (with a the JCAA. received by DIAC. the respondent.
Arbitration (which also Registrar. Respondent). copy to the Respondent).
amounts to the Statement
of Claim).
Deadline for Article 3 Article 4 Article 2 Article 5 Article 9 Article 5 Article 4 Article 18(1) Article 5 Article 4
Response 30 days after the 30 days from the 28 days from the 30 days from the The deadline for the 30 days from the 14 days from the Within 4 weeks from the Within 30 days from the 30 days from the receipt of
Administrator confirms commencement of the Commencement Date. Respondent’s receipt of the Answer is set by the SCC Respondent’s receipt of the Respondent’s receipt of the Respondent’s receipt of the Respondent’s notice of the notice of arbitration by the
commencement of the arbitration. Request from the ICC Secretariat. Notice of Arbitration. Notice of Arbitration. notice of the Request for Request (as provided by respondent.
arbitration. Secretariat. Arbitration (as provided by DIAC).
the JCAA).
Article 12 Article 7 Article 5 Article 12 Article 16 Article 6 Article 9 Article 26(2) Article 10 Article 7
Default number of
Sole arbitrator. Sole arbitrator. Sole arbitrator. Sole arbitrator. No default - SCC will No default - HKIAC will Sole arbitrator. Sole Arbitrator. Sole arbitrator. Three Arbitrators.
Arbitrators
Administrator may appoint JAMS may appoint three LCIA may appoint three The ICC Court may appoint determine if the case determine if the case The SIAC Registrar may DIAC may appoint three
(where parties
three arbitrators if it sees arbitrators if it sees fit. arbitrators if it sees fit. three arbitrators if it sees warrants one or three warrants one or three appoint three arbitrators if arbitrators if it sees fit.
have not agreed)
fit. fit. arbitrators. arbitrators. it sees fit.
Article 15 Article 9 Article 10 Article 14 Article 19 Article 11 Article 14 Article 34(3) Article 15 Article 13
Time limit for
challenging 15 days from being notified 15 days from being notified 14 days from the formation 30 days from being notified 15 days from becoming 15 days from the 14 days from being notified 14 days from being notified 15 days from the formation 15 days from being notified
Arbitrator of the appointment or of the appointment or of the Tribunal or becoming of the appointment or aware of the relevant confirmation of the of the appointment or of the appointment or of the Tribunal or becoming of the appointment or
becoming aware of the becoming aware of the aware of the relevant becoming aware of the circumstances. arbitrator by HKIAC or becoming aware of the becoming aware of the aware of the becoming aware of the
relevant circumstances. relevant circumstances. circumstances. relevant circumstances. becoming aware of the relevant circumstances. relevant circumstances. circumstances. relevant circumstances.
relevant circumstances.
Article 21 Article 17 Article 23 Article 6 Articles 11-12 Article 19 Article 28 Article 47 Article 6 Article 23
Jurisdictional
challenges The Tribunal has the power The Tribunal has the power The Tribunal has the power The Tribunal has the power Challenges to be made to The Tribunal has the power The Tribunal has the power The Tribunal has the power The Tribunal has the power The Tribunal has the power
to rule on its own to rule on its own to rule on its own to rule on its own the SCC Board which is to rule on its own to rule on its own to rule on its own to rule on its own to rule on its own
jurisdiction and the validity jurisdiction and the validity jurisdiction and authority jurisdiction (and may refer empowered to dismiss a jurisdiction and the validity jurisdiction and the validity jurisdiction and the validity jurisdiction and the validity jurisdiction and the validity
of the arbitration of the arbitration and the validity of the to the ICC Secretary case if the SCC manifestly of the arbitration of the arbitration of the arbitration of the arbitration of the arbitration
Agreement. Agreement. arbitration agreement. General) and the validity of lacks jurisdiction. Agreement. Agreement. Agreement. Agreement. Agreement.
Challenges to the Tribunal’s Challenges should be raised Challenges should the arbitration agreement. Challenges should be raised Challenges should be raised Challenges should be raised
jurisdiction should be no later than the Statement be raised as soon as in the Answer to the Notice no later than the Statement no later than in the
submitted no later than the of Defence or the Reply possible and not of Arbitration, and shall be of Defence or in Reply to Statement of Defence or
filing of the Answer to the (although a late objection later than the Statement of raised no later than the the Counterclaim. Reply to Counterclaim.
claim, counterclaim or can be admitted if the Defence. Statement of Defence.
setoff giving rise to the Tribunal considers the
objection. delay justified in the
circumstances).
Article 39 Article 35 Article 24 Article 1 (Appendix III) Article 51 Article 41 Article 34 Article 82(2) Appendix I – Article Article 43
Non-payment of
the The ICDR will inform the If a party fails to provide a In the event that a party A party that has already If one party fails to pay, the If either party fails to pay A party is free to pay the If a party fails to make 3 If the required deposits are
parties if the costs are not deposit as directed by the fails to make a payment on paid in full its share of the SCC Secretariat will give the its share the other party unpaid costs should the payments intended to If either party fails to pay not paid in full within 30
Advance on Costs
paid in full so that one or Administrator, JAMS may account of costs the LCIA advance on costs fixed by other party the opportunity may pay the missing other party fail to pay its cover arbitrator(s)’ its share the other party days the Tribunal shall
more of them can make the direct the other party to may direct the other party the ICC Court may pay the to pay. amount failing which the share. remuneration and/or may pay that share, and inform the parties so that
required payment. pay to allow the arbitration to pay to allow the unpaid portion of the If one party makes the Tribunal may order If a party fails to pay, the expenses, the Tribunal, will be entitled to one or more can make the
The failure of a party to proceed (subject to any arbitration to proceed. advance owed by the required payment and the suspension or termination Tribunal may suspend its upon the JCAA’s request, reimbursement from the required payment.
asserting the claim or Award on costs). The party making the defaulting party by posting other party does not, the of the proceedings. work and the SIAC shall suspend or terminate other party. If such payment is not
counterclaim to pay the The Tribunal has discretion substitute payment can a bank guarantee. Tribunal may, upon Secretariat may suspend the arbitral proceedings made, the Tribunal may
unless the other party pays Where a request for an
required deposit can be to treat the failure to pay request an order to allow it request, make a separate the arbitration, or impose a advance on costs is not suspend or terminate the
deemed a withdrawal of the required deposit as a to recover that amount as a Award for reimbursement deadline for payment such unpaid amount proceedings.
instead. complied with, the DIAC
the respective claim or withdrawal of the debt (with interest) of that payment. beyond which the claim will Court may impose a
counterclaim. immediately due from the be considered withdrawn. deadline for payment

1
Comparison of Key International Arbitration Rules

Key International Arbitration Rules

USA Europe Far East Middle East International

Element
JAMS International
ICDR Rules 2021 LCIA Rules 2020 ICC Rules 2021 SCC Rules 2017 HKIAC Rules 2018 SIAC Rules 2016 JCAA Rules 2021 DIAC Rules 2022 UNCITRAL Rules 2013
Arbitration Rules 2021

respective claim or defaulting party when the beyond which the claim will
counterclaim. Tribunal is constituted. be considered withdrawn.
The failure of a party
asserting the claim or
counterclaim to pay the
required deposit can be
deemed a withdrawal of
the respective claim or
counterclaim.
Confidentiality Article 40 Article 16 Article 30 Article 8 (Appendix I) Article 3 Article 45 Article 39 Article 42 Article 38 Article 28, 34
Confidential information The Tribunal, the parties, The deliberations of the The work of the ICC Court is The SCC, the Tribunal and Unless the parties agree The parties and the Arbitral proceedings shall Unless otherwise agreed by The hearings are
disclosed during the the Administrator and Tribunal remain of a confidential nature any administrative otherwise, no party (nor Tribunal (including any be held in private, and all the parties or the law of the confidential unless the
arbitration shall not be JAMS must maintain the confidential to the which must be respected secretary of the Tribunal the Tribunal) may publish, person appointed by the records thereof shall be seat requires otherwise, parties otherwise agree.
divulged by an Arbitrator or confidentiality of the members of the Tribunal by everyone who will maintain the disclose or communicate Tribunal) shall at all times closed to the public. The the parties and the The Award may be made
the ICDR unless otherwise arbitration. and any Tribunal secretary participates in that work in confidentiality of the Award any information relating to treat all matters relating to arbitrators, the parties, members of the Tribunal public if agreed by the
agreed by the parties or The Award remains (if appropriate). whatever capacity. The ICC unless otherwise agreed by the arbitration or any the proceedings and the their counsel and undertake as a general parties or required by law.
required by applicable law. confidential unless all the The parties undertake as a Court lays down the rules the parties. Award made in the Award as confidential. assistants, the JCAA’S principle to keep all
An Award can only be made parties consent to general principle to keep regarding the persons who arbitration unless it is to officers and other staff, and Awards, orders, materials
public with the consent of publication or otherwise confidential all Awards in can attend the meetings of pursue a legal right or other persons involved in and documents created for
all parties, or as required by required by law. the arbitration save if the ICC Court and its enforce or challenge the the arbitral proceedings the purpose of the
law. disclosure is required as committees and who are Award. The deliberations of shall not disclose facts arbitration confidential
part of a legal duty, to entitled to have access to the Tribunal shall remain related to or learned save for the extent to
The ICDR can publish materials related to the confidential. through the arbitral which disclosure is required
redacted versions of pursue a legal right or to
challenge the Award in work of the ICC Court and The HKIAC may publish an proceedings and shall not by legal duty, to pursue a
selected Awards, orders, the ICC Secretariat. express any views as to legal right or to challenge
decisions and rulings, legal proceedings. The Award only if the parties’
parties shall seek the same names are redacted, or no such facts, except where the Award in legal
unless a party objects disclosure is required by proceedings.
within 6 months from the undertaking of party objects to the
confidentiality from any publication. law or in court proceedings,
date of the Award. or based on any other
third parties they involve in
Unless the parties agree the arbitration. justifiable grounds.
otherwise, the Tribunal can
make orders concerning the The LCIA will not publish
confidentiality of the any Award (or part thereof)
arbitration and any matters without the consent of the
in connection with the parties and the Tribunal.
arbitration.
Timeframe for Article 33 Article 33 Article 15 Article 31 Article 43 Article 31.2 Article 32 No set timeframe. Article 35 No set timeframe.
issuing the Award The Award should be made The dispute should be The Tribunal shall seek to Within 6 months from the 6 months from the date of Within three months from Draft Award to be However, Article 43.1 notes 6 months from the date of
no later than heard and submitted to the make its final Award as date of the last signature of Referral to the SCC. Can be the closure of the submitted to the SIAC that the arbitral Tribunal the transmission of the file
60 days after the closing of Tribunal for decision within soon as reasonably possible the Terms of Reference, extended by the SCC Board proceedings or relevant Registrar 45 days from the shall use reasonable efforts to the Tribunal by DIAC.
the hearing (unless nine months after the and shall endeavor to do so unless the ICC Court has upon a reasoned request phase of the proceedings. date on which the Tribunal to render an arbitral Award
within nine months from Can be extended at any
otherwise agreed by the preliminary conference no later than three months fixed a different time limit from the Tribunal or if This time limit may be declared the proceedings time by (a) agreement of
parties, specified by law or required by Article 22, with after the last submission based on the procedural otherwise deemed extended by the HKIAC or closed. the date when it is
constituted, and to the parties, or (b) by the
determined by the ICDR). the final Award rendered from the parties (whether timetable established by necessary. both parties in agreement. Can be extended by the DIAC Court, upon request
within three months made orally or in writing), the Tribunal. implement Article 43.1, the
If the International parties or by the SIAC arbitral Tribunal shall by the Tribunal or on its
Expedited Procedures apply thereafter. in accordance with a Can be extended upon Registrar. own initiative.
timetable notified to the consult with the parties,
the Award must be made reasoned request from the and make a schedule of the
within 30 days from the parties and the LCIA Tribunal or on the ICC
Registrar as soon as arbitral proceedings in
date of closing (unless Court’s own initiative. writing to the extent
otherwise agreed by the practicable.
necessary and feasible as
parties, specified by law or early as practicable.
determined by the ICDR)
(Article E-10).
Correction / Article 36 Article 37 Article 27 Article 36 Article 47 Articles 38 - 40 Article 33 Articles 68-70 Article 37 Articles 37-39
Interpretation of Within 30 days after receipt Within 30 days after the Within 28 days of receipt of Within 30 days from receipt Within 30 days of the Within 30 days after receipt Within 30 days of receipt of A party, within 4 weeks Within 30 days of receipt of Within 30 days after receipt
the Award, and of the Award, any party may receipt of the Award, any the Award, a party may by of the Award, any party receipt of the Award, a of the Award, either party the Award, a party may by from its receipt of the the Award, a party may by of the Award, a party with
additional Awards request the Tribunal, with party may request the written notice to the LCIA may request, by application party may, upon notice to may, with notice to the written notice to the SIAC arbitral Award, may written notice to the notice to the other parties

2
Comparison of Key International Arbitration Rules

Key International Arbitration Rules

USA Europe Far East Middle East International

Element
JAMS International
ICDR Rules 2021 LCIA Rules 2020 ICC Rules 2021 SCC Rules 2017 HKIAC Rules 2018 SIAC Rules 2016 JCAA Rules 2021 DIAC Rules 2022 UNCITRAL Rules 2013
Arbitration Rules 2021

notice to the other party, to Tribunal, with notice to the Registrar (copied to other to the ICC Secretariat, the the other party, request the other parties request the Registrar and the other request the arbitral Tribunal and other party, may request the Tribunal to
(a) interpret the Award other parties, to (a) parties) request the Tribunal to (a) provide an Tribunal to (a) provide an Tribunal to (a) give an party, request the Tribunal Tribunal to (a) give an request the Tribunal to (a) (a) give an interpretation of
and/or (b) correct any interpret the Award and/or Tribunal to (a) correct any interpretation of the Award interpretation of a specific interpretation of the to (a) give an interpretation interpretation of the give an interpretation of the Award, and/or (b)
clerical, typographical or (b) correct any clerical, error in computation, and/or (b) to correct a point of the Award, and/or Award, and/or (b) correct of the Award, and/or (b) to Award, and/or (b) correct the Award, and/or (b) to correct any error in
computational errors, and/or typographical or clerical or typographical clerical, computational or (b) correct any clerical, any errors in computation, correct any error in any errors in computation, correct any clerical, computation, any clerical or
(c) make an additional Award computational errors, error, any ambiguity or typographical error or any typographical or any clerical or computation, any clerical or any clerical or typographical or typographical error or
as to claims, counterclaims, and/or (c) make an mistake of a similar nature, errors of similar nature in computational errors in the typographical errors or typographical error or any typographical errors or computational errors in the omission of a similar
or setoffs presented but additional Award as to or (b) make an additional the Award. The Tribunal Award, and/or (c) make an errors of a similar nature, error of a similar nature, errors of a similar nature, Award, and/or (c) to make nature, and/or (c) make an
omitted from the Award. claims presented but Award as to any claim or may make corrections on additional Award on claims and/or (c) make an and/or (c) to make an and/or (c) make an an additional Award in Award or an additional
The Tribunal may correct any omitted from the Award. cross-claim presented in its own initiative within 30 presented in the arbitration additional Award as to additional Award as to additional Award as to respect of claims or Award as to claims
error or make an additional If the Tribunal considers the arbitration but not days of the notification of but not determined in the claims presented in the claims presented in the claims presented in the counterclaims presented in presented in the arbitral
Award on its own initiative such a request justified, decided in any Award. the Award to the parties. Award. arbitration but omitted arbitration but not dealt arbitration but omitted the arbitration but not proceedings but not
within 30 days of the date of after considering the If the Tribunal considers The Tribunal shall submit its After giving the other party from the Award. The with in the Award. The from the Award. dealt with in any Award. decided by the arbitral
the Award. contentions of the parties, such a request justified, decision on the application an opportunity to comment Tribunal may make Tribunal may make The Tribunal may also The Tribunal may make Tribunal.
it shall comply with the after consulting the parties, in draft form to the ICC on the request, and if the corrections on its own corrections on its own correct any errors on its corrections on its own The Tribunal may make
If the Tribunal considers such initiative within 30 days of initiative within 30 days of
request within 30 days it shall make the correction Court no later than 30 days Tribunal considers the own initiative. initiative within 30 days corrections on its own
a request justified after the date of the Award. the date of the Award.
after the request. within 28 days of receipt of after the expiration of the request justified, it shall after issuing the Award. initiative within 30 days
consulting the parties, it shall
The Tribunal may correct the request (56 days with time limit for receipt of any make the correction or give The Tribunal shall make any If the Tribunal considers the If the Tribunal considers the after issuing the Award.
comply with the request
any error on its own respect to an additional comments from the other the interpretation within 30 corrections or request to be justified, it request justified, it shall If the Tribunal considers the
within 30 days after receipt
initiative within 30 days of Award or addendum). party or within such other days of the receipt of the interpretation it deems shall make the correction make the correction or request justified, it shall
of the parties’ last
the date of the Award. The Tribunal may also period as the ICC Court may request (within 60 days appropriate (after within 30 days of receipt of interpretation within 30 make any correction or
submissions regarding the
correct any error or make decide. with respect to an consulting the parties) the request, subject to an days of receipt of the interpretation within 45
request.
an additional Award upon additional Award, subject within 30 days after receipt extension if needed (within request (within 60 days for days of receipt of the
its own initiative within 28 to extension). of the request, subject to 45 days with respect to an additional Award, after request, and any additional
days of the date of the The Tribunal may make an extension if needed interpretations or an consulting the parties). Award within 60 days of
Award, after consulting the corrections on its own (within 60 days with additional Award). receipt of the request
parties. initiative within 30 days of respect to an additional (subject to an extension if
the date of the Award. Award). needed).
Expedited Article 1 (and Articles E-1 Article 21 Articles 9A and Article 14 Article 30 and Article 1 Not available under these Article 42 Article 5 Article 84 Article 32 Not available.
procedure to E-10) A party may apply in Expedited formation of the (Appendix VI) rules but a separate set of Expedited Procedure Expedited procedure Expedited arbitration Expedited procedure
The International Expedited writing to the Tribunal available on The Expedited Procedure rules for SCC Expedited applies upon application to available on application to procedures (set out at available on application to
Procedure is available Administrator for the application in cases of Rules may apply if (a) the Arbitrations are available. the HKIAC if (a) the amount the SIAC Registrar, (a) if the Articles 83-90) apply where the DIAC Court, (a) if the
where there is no claim or proceedings to be exceptional urgency. parties so agree; or (b) the in dispute does not exceed aggregate amount in the aggregate amount in aggregate amount in
counterclaim exceeding conducted according to the A Tribunal may make any amount in dispute does not the amount set by the dispute does not exceed dispute does not exceed dispute does not exceed
US$500,000 (exclusive of expedited procedures, procedural order it exceed US$2m (if the HKIAC at the time the S$6m, (b) if the parties JPY300m, or the parties AED1m (excl. interest and
interest and the costs of where either: (a) the considers appropriate with arbitration agreement was request is submitted, (b) agree, or (c) in cases of agree. costs) (or such other sum
the arbitration), unless aggregate amount in regard to the fair, efficient concluded between 1 the parties agree, or (c) in exceptional urgency. determined by DIAC), (b) if
agreed by the parties or dispute does not exceed and reasonable conduct of March 2017 and 1 January cases of exceptional the parties agree, or (c) in
otherwise determined by US$5m, (b) the parties the arbitration. 2021), or US$3m (if the urgency. cases of exceptional
the ICDR. agree, or (c) in cases of arbitration agreement was urgency.
parties may also agree to exceptional urgency (as concluded on or after 1
use the expedited determined by JAMS). January 2021).
procedure in other cases.
Where no party’s claim or
counterclaim exceeds
US$100,000 (exclusive of
interest and the costs of
the arbitration) the dispute
shall be decided on the
basis of written
submissions alone, unless
the arbitrator determines
that an oral hearing is
necessary.
Summary A party may request leave Article 25 Article 22.1(viii) No summary dismissal Article 39 Article 43 Article 29 No summary dismissal No summary dismissal No summary dismissal
dismissal from the Tribunal to apply The Tribunal may permit The Tribunal has an express provisions specified. A party may request that A party may request that A party may apply to the provisions specified. provisions specified. provisions specified.
provisions for early disposition of any any party to file an power for early the Tribunal decide one or the Tribunal determines Tribunal for the early

3
Comparison of Key International Arbitration Rules

Key International Arbitration Rules

USA Europe Far East Middle East International

Element
JAMS International
ICDR Rules 2021 LCIA Rules 2020 ICC Rules 2021 SCC Rules 2017 HKIAC Rules 2018 SIAC Rules 2016 JCAA Rules 2021 DIAC Rules 2022 UNCITRAL Rules 2013
Arbitration Rules 2021

issue, in advance of the application for summary determination of claims or more issues of fact or law one or more points of law dismissal of a claim on the
hearing on the merits. disposition of a particular defences that are by summary procedure. or fact on the basis that basis that: (a) a claim or
claim or issue, either by manifestly outside the Such issues may concern they are (i) manifestly defence is manifestly
agreement of all interested jurisdiction of the Tribunal, jurisdiction, admissibility or without merit, (ii) without merit; or (b) a
parties or at the request of or are inadmissible or the merits. manifestly outside of the claim or defence is
one party, provided other manifestly without merit. Tribunal’s jurisdiction, or manifestly outside the
interested parties have (iii) even if such points of jurisdiction of the Tribunal.
reasonable notice to law or fact are submitted
respond to the request. The by another party and are
requesting party must assumed to be correct, no
satisfy the Tribunal that the Award could be rendered in
proposed motion is likely to favour of that party.
succeed and dispose of or
narrow the issues in the
case.
Interim measures Article 7 Article 3 Article 9B Article 28 and Article 29 Appendix II Article 23 and Schedule 4 Article 30.2 and Schedule 1 Articles 75-79 Appendix II – Article 2 Not available.
prior to A party may apply for A party may apply for the and Appendix V A party may apply for the A party may apply for A party may file an A party may apply for A party may apply for
A party may apply for
constitution of emergency relief prior to the emergency relief prior to immediate appointment of A party may apply to any appointment of an urgent interim or application for emergency urgent interim or emergency interim relief
Tribunal appointment of the Tribunal. the appointment of the a temporary sole arbitrator judicial authority for any emergency arbitrator until conservatory relief prior to interim relief before the conservatory relief prior to prior to the appointment of
An emergency arbitrator Tribunal. An emergency to conduct emergency interim or conservatory the case has been referred the constitution of the constitution of the Tribunal. the constitution of the the Tribunal. If the
shall be appointed by the arbitrator (usually proceedings pending measures before the case to the Tribunal. The arbitral Tribunal. An An emergency arbitrator arbitral Tribunal. If the application is accepted,
ICDR within 1 day of receipt appointed within 24 hours formation of the Tribunal. file is transmitted to the emergency arbitrator shall emergency arbitrator shall shall determine the application is successful, DIAC will seek to appoint an
of a valid application for of the application) shall This emergency arbitrator Tribunal, without infringing determine the application determine the application, application and has the the JCAA will use emergency arbitrator
emergency relief. The determine the application shall determine the or waiving the arbitration for interim relief and has and may order or Award power to order or Award reasonable efforts to within 1 day of receipt of
emergency arbitrator shall and shall enter an order or application and may make agreement or affecting the the power to order or any interim measures it any interim relief that they appoint an emergency the application.
have all the authority vested Award granting or denying any order or Award which powers of the Tribunal. Award any interim relief deems necessary or deem necessary. arbitrator within two An application for
in a Tribunal under Article 21 the relief sought. the Tribunal could make. Any party may apply for an that they deem necessary. appropriate. business days from the emergency interim relief
(Arbitral Jurisdiction). The The emergency arbitrator emergency arbitrator receipt of the application. can be made on an ex parte
emergency arbitrator shall will decide the claim for before the constitution of The emergency arbitrator basis (i.e. without notice to
determine the application, emergency relief within 14 the Tribunal and, if the will make reasonable the other party), if the
and has the power to order days of appointment. application is successful, an efforts to decide on the applying party reasonably
or Award any interim or emergency arbitrator will application within 2 weeks believes that giving notice
conservancy measures that usually be appointed within from their appointment. to the other party may
they deem necessary. 2 days from the ICC jeopardise the efficacy of
Secretariat’s receipt of the the application for
application. The emergency emergency interim relief
arbitrator shall determine and the procedural law
the application, and their applicable to the seat of the
determination shall take arbitration permits such
the form of an order. applications without notice
to the other party or
parties (Appendix II –
Article 2.2).
Interim measures Article 27 Article 31 Article 25 Article 28 Article 37 Article 23 Article 30 Article 71 Appendix II – Article 1 Article 26
after constitution The Tribunal may grant any The Tribunal may grant any The Tribunal has the power Unless otherwise agreed, The Tribunal may grant any The Tribunal may grant any The Tribunal may grant any The Tribunal may grant any The Tribunal may grant any The Tribunal may grant any
of Tribunal interim measure it deems interim measure it deems to (i) order the parties to the Tribunal may order any interim measure it deems interim measure it deems interim measure it deems interim measure it deems interim measure it deems interim measure it deems
appropriate. appropriate. pay security for costs, (ii) interim or conservatory appropriate. appropriate. appropriate. appropriate. appropriate. appropriate.
make orders concerning measure it deems
the preservation, storage, appropriate.
sale or other disposal of
property, and/or (iii) grant,
on a provisional basis, any
other relief that the
Tribunal would have the
power to make in an
Award.
Arbitration costs Article 37-38 Article 35 Article 28 Article 38 Article 49 Schedule 1 Article 35 Article 93 Article 36 and Appendix I – Article 40-41
Article 4

4
Comparison of Key International Arbitration Rules

Key International Arbitration Rules

USA Europe Far East Middle East International

Element
JAMS International
ICDR Rules 2021 LCIA Rules 2020 ICC Rules 2021 SCC Rules 2017 HKIAC Rules 2018 SIAC Rules 2016 JCAA Rules 2021 DIAC Rules 2022 UNCITRAL Rules 2013
Arbitration Rules 2021

As soon as practicable after The Tribunals’ fees will be The costs shall be The costs of the arbitration Before making the final HKIAC’s administrative fee The SIAC Registrar will Arbitrators’ remuneration The Award will fix the costs The fees and expenses of
commencement of the calculated by reference to determined by the LCIA on shall include the fees and Award the Tribunal will will be determined based determine the costs of the based on an hourly rate. and fees in accordance with the Arbitrators will be
arbitration the ICDR shall work done by its members a time basis in accordance expenses of the arbitrators request that the SCC Board upon the Schedule to the arbitration in accordance The upper limits of the DIAC Table of Fees and reasonable in the
designate appropriate rates and charged at rates with the LCIA Schedule of and the ICC administrative finally determines the Rules which takes into with the SIAC Schedule of arbitrators’ remuneration Costs. circumstances.
of compensation for the appropriate for the Costs. The amount shall be expenses fixed by the ICC arbitration costs in account the aggregate Fees, and specify the total are set according to the A registration fee of The Tribunal shall fix costs
Arbitrators, in consultation circumstances of the case. fixed in the Award. Court, in accordance with accordance with the SCC amount in dispute. in the Award. amount of the claim. DHS500 is payable. in the Award.
with the parties and the A Filing Fee of US$1,750 in Registration Fee of £1950 is the scales in force at the Schedule of Costs. The HKIAC rules provide Case Filing Fee of S$2,140
Arbitrators. The costs of the time of the commencement An administrative fee is The Tribunal’s fee is based
two-party cases and payable. Registration Fee of separate Schedules for for Singapore parties and also due from the Claimant on the amount in dispute,
arbitration shall be fixed in US$3,000 in cases involving of the arbitration. EUR3000 is payable determination of S$2,000 for Overseas
the Award. at the time the Request for and DIAC will also take into
3 or more parties is payable A Filing Fee of US$5,000 is (EUR2500 if using the Rules arbitrators’ fees and parties is payable. Arbitration is submitted, on account the diligence,
Initial Filing Fee payable as by the claimant. A Filing payable. for Expedited Arbitrations). expenses based on hourly Arbitrators’ fees are a fixed scale dependent on speed and efficiency of the
per Fee Schedule, the cost Fee of US$1,750 is also rate, and based on sum in determined according to the value of the claim Tribunal.
will be in the range of required for a dispute. the sum in dispute. (Article 103).
US$1,000 - US$12,650 (plus counterclaim. The Registration Fee is
a proportion of the claim currently set at HKD 8,000.
amount), depending on the
claim amount.
The ICDR may request that
the parties deposit
appropriate amounts as an
advance for costs (Article
39 (Deposits)).
Cost allocation Article 37 Article 30, 36 Article 28 Article 37 Article 50 Article 34 Article 37 Article 80 Article 36 Article 42
The Tribunal may allocate The Tribunal may apportion The parties shall be jointly The Tribunal has discretion The Tribunal is empowered The Tribunal will decide the The Tribunal has authority The arbitral Tribunal may The apportionment of costs The costs of the arbitration
the costs between the arbitration costs among the and severally liable to the as to how to allocate the to order one party to pay apportionment of costs of to order that legal and apportion costs between between the parties shall are, in principle, borne by
parties if it deems parties if it considers such LCIA and the Tribunal for costs between the parties any reasonable costs the arbitration in its Award other costs of one party are the parties, taking into be fixed in the Award. the unsuccessful party but
allocation reasonable, apportionment reasonable, the arbitration costs, and and shall take into account incurred by the other party. based upon its judgement paid by the other. account the parties’ the Tribunal can apportion
taking into account the taking into account the the Tribunal will decide the such circumstances as it of what is reasonable in the conduct throughout the if appropriate.
circumstances of the case. circumstances of the case. proportions in which the considers relevant including circumstances. course of the arbitral
In apportioning costs the parties shall bear such the extent to which each proceedings, the
Tribunal may take into costs. party has conducted the determination on the
account a party’s bad faith The Tribunal has the power arbitration in an merits of the dispute, and
conduct. to order that legal or other expeditious and cost- any relevant circumstances.
expenses incurred by a effective manner.
party be paid by another
party and will base its
decision on the general
principle that costs should
reflect the parties’ relative
success.
Perceived Rules promote mediation Access to the JAMS Long established institution The ICC is sometimes Perceived neutrality of the One of the most used Relative speed - the Award The rules expressly A flexible set of arbitration Perceived neutrality of the
advantages and permit parties to agree electronic filing system for and widely respected. considered the leading institution. institutions outside of ought to be provided in recognise that arbitrators rules used in the UAE and institution.
to mediate at any time filing, serving and accessing Rules particularly well institution in terms of the Historically often used for Europe. draft in 45 days. cannot delegate decision- elsewhere in the Middle Useful where parties
during arbitration arbitration documents. suited to London-seated volume and significance of disputes involving Russian, Institution is used to and Arbitrator appointments making to third parties, East. cannot agree on a set of
proceedings, encouraging Mediator-In-Reserve policy arbitrations because they cases. CIS and other Eastern capably deals with parties are made from a panel. such as Tribunal A number of DIAC rules or a designated
early settlement. encouraging early are drafted to fit with the The Terms of Reference can European counter parties. from the Mainland. secretaries, without Arbitrators have specialised institution.
Perceived neutrality parties’ consent
The Notice also comprises settlement. UK Arbitration Act 1996. help narrow the issues in The pool of Arbitrators Good record of compared to other arbitral construction experience. Possible reduced
the Statement of Claim Specialist team of insurance Calculation of cost on a dispute early in the includes several with enforcement in the institutions in China. The availability of an The rules impose a administrative costs
which makes the procedure arbitrators and mediators. time rather than value of process. Russian fluency. Mainland. expedited procedure, confidentiality undertaking because it is not run
quicker. claims basis is sometimes Scrutiny of the Award by New claims can be which can be used in on the parties. through an arbitral
Specific requirement for higher-value disputes if the
Availability of expedited parties to maintain thought to lead to lower the ICC Court which consolidated on request by Emergency interim relief institution.
procedure under which the costs. ensures a high standard of a party in certain parties agree.
confidentiality, as well as can be applied for without
Award should be rendered the Tribunal and The Tribunal’s general Award writing, albeit circumstances. Arbitrator fees are payable notice to the other party.
within 30 days from closing. Administrator. power includes making scrutiny does not usually on an hourly rate but are
Any party can request that orders to expedite the extend to the substance of subject to a cap depending
a consolidation Arbitrator is procedure, and specifies the decision. on the value of the dispute.
appointed. The

5
Comparison of Key International Arbitration Rules

Key International Arbitration Rules

USA Europe Far East Middle East International

Element
JAMS International
ICDR Rules 2021 LCIA Rules 2020 ICC Rules 2021 SCC Rules 2017 HKIAC Rules 2018 SIAC Rules 2016 JCAA Rules 2021 DIAC Rules 2022 UNCITRAL Rules 2013
Arbitration Rules 2021

consolidation Arbitrator will examples of potential steps Proceedings can be Introduction of a separate
have the power to to that end. consolidated on request by set of “Interactive
consolidate two or more Tribunals have an express a party in certain Arbitration Rules”, to apply
arbitrations. power to determine early circumstances. where the parties agree.
any claims that are The rules aim to encourage
manifestly without merit. settlement of a dispute by
The first of the main Rules requiring the Tribunal to
to require Tribunals to communicate preliminary
consider whether any views about the dispute
specific information twice during the
security measures and proceedings.
means to address the
processing of personal data
should be adopted.
Proceedings can be
consolidated in certain
circumstances subject to
the approval of the LCIA.
Perceived Perceived as US- centric, Perceived as US- centric. Perceived as London- Costs and time are Swedish courts can be slow Perceived as Asia- centric. No institutional scrutiny of Historically, the JCAA's The successful party will The lack of institutional
disadvantages with lists of Arbitrators centric. increased by the need for to grant interim remedies. No institutional scrutiny of the Award. caseload has been small, ultimately need to go to the administration (unless
consisting of a majority of No institutional scrutiny of Terms of Reference and the Appointment by SCC the Award. The rules provide that the and has been used Dubai courts for on-shore adopted by agreement) can
domestic candidates. No institutional scrutiny of scrutiny of the Award by principally for Japan-related enforcement in the UAE. result in delay.
the Award. the Award. Institute, but no Panel. Tribunal and SIAC keep the
the ICC Court. arbitration confidential but international transactions. No institutional scrutiny of The lack of an institutional
No institutional scrutiny of The Rules do not expressly
Awards. require Tribunals to Terms of Reference may do not impose a No set time frame for issue the Award. rate of fees can result in
consider whether they cause challenge/ confidentiality requirement of the Award following the increased cost.
The rules provide that the
should exercise their power enforcement problems. on the parties. closing of the arbitral The rules make the
Tribunal and ICDR keep the
to order expedition or any No express duty of proceedings. hearings confidential but
arbitration confidential but
do not impose a of the eight specified confidentiality is imposed No institutional scrutiny of do not impose a
confidentiality requirement measures; or to consider on the parties. the Awards, although confidentiality requirement
on the parties. whether they should order Sometimes said to be parties can request that the on the parties.
early determination. bureaucratic. Tribunal interpret the No set time frame for issue
Award within 4 weeks of of the Award.
No summary dismissal receipt of the Award.
provision specified. No institutional scrutiny of
the Awards, although
parties can request that the
Tribunal ‘interpret’ the
Award.

You might also like