Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1994
Recommended Citation
Ashby, Richard David, "The Production and Characterization of Alginate Produced by Pseudomonas
Syringae." (1994). LSU Historical Dissertations and Theses. 5775.
https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_disstheses/5775
This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at LSU Digital Commons. It
has been accepted for inclusion in LSU Historical Dissertations and Theses by an authorized administrator of LSU
Digital Commons. For more information, please contact gradetd@lsu.edu.
INFORMATION TO USERS
This manuscript has been reproduced from the microfilm master. UMI
films the text directly from the original or copy submitted. Thus, some
thesis and dissertation copies are in typewriter face, while others may
be from any type of computer printer.
In the unlikely event that the author did not send UMI a complete
manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if
unauthorized copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate
the deletion.
UMI
300 N. ZeebRd.
Ann Arbor, MI 48106
THE PRODUCTION AND CHARACTERIZATION
OF ALGINATE PRODUCED
BY PSEUDOMONAS SYRINGAE
A D issertation
in
by
Richard David Ashby
B.S., Brigham Young University, 1987
August 1994
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Page
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.......................................................................... ii
LIST OF TABLES...................................................................................... vi
LIST OF FIGURES..................................................................................... vii
ABSTRACT............................................................................................... xi
INTRODUCTION........................................................... 1
REVIEW OF LITERATURE....................................................................... 3
I. Bacterial Exopolysaccharides: G eneral C h aracteristics.. 3
II. Alginate: O verview ................................................................ 5
1. Compositional Differences,
Seaweed vs Bacterial A lg in ate................................ 5
2. Properties...................................................................... 10
3. A pplications.................... 14
4. Commercial M anufacture.......................................... 15
III. A lginate Biosynthesis........................................................... 21
1. P ath w ay . .................................................................. 21
2. Enzymology................................................................... 25
3. Regulation...................................................... 30
IV. Pseudom onas syringae Alginates.................................... 32
V. Polysaccharide Analysis....................................................... 32
1. D epolym erization........................................................ 32
2. Acid Sensitivity............................................................ 36
VI. Goals of this S tudy................................................................ 38
MATERIALS AND METHODS............................................................... 39
I. Organisms, Growth Conditions, an d M aintenance 39
II. Analytical M ethods................................................................ 40
1. Cell Mass D eterm in atio n ........................................... 40
2. Total C arbohydrate Q uantitation............................. 40
3. Alginate Q uantitation....................... 41
4. Acetyl Q uantitation..................................................... 43
iii
III. O ptim ization of Bacterial A lginate Production............. 45
1. M edia C om position...................................................... 45
A. C arbon Source.................................................... 45
B. N itrogen Source................................................ 45
2. pH a n d T em p eratu re ...................................... 46
3. Agar vs Broth C ulture................................................. 46
IV. Batch Ferm entations............................................................ 48
V. Purification of Bacterial A lginate......................................... 48
VI. D eacetylation of Bacterial Alginate.................................. 49
VII. Alginate Size a n d Q uantity D eterm inations................. 50
VIII. Sugar Sensitivity to Acid................................................... 50
1. Thin Layer C hrom atography.................................... 50
2. Ion C hrom atography.................................................. 51
IX. Identification o f the Acid Hydrolysis Product of
L-Gulose................................................................................... 52
1. Thin Layer C hrom atography ........................... 52
2. Stability of 1,6 A nhydro p-L-Gulopyranose 53
X. Alginate Reductions.................. 53
XI. Alginate Com positions......................................................... 54
XII. P roperties of Bacterial Alginates a n d Effects of
A cetylation............................................................................. 55
1. Viscosity.......................................................................... 55
2. W ater Holding Capacity.............................................. 56
3. Surface T ension.................................................. 56
4. Precipitation by Metal Ions....................................... 57
RESULTS................................................................................................... 58
I. Production o f Bacterial A lginate...................................... 58
1. M edia Compositions an d C onditions ........ 58
2. Agar vs Broth C ulture................................................. 62
iv
III. Functional P roperties......................................................... 76
1. Viscosity.......................................................................... 76
2. Physical Effects.............................................................. 85
3. Cation Precipitation by Alginates.............................. 94
DISCUSSION............................................................................................ Ill
REFERENCES............................................................................................ 125
VITA........................................................................................................... 141
v
LIST OF TABLES
Page
Table 1. The stru ctu res o f some bacterial exopolysaccharides. 6
vi
LIST OF FIGURES
Page
Figure 1. Structures of the uronic acids of alginates................... 8
vii
Figure 13. The effect of tem p eratu re on cell mass, a n d
alginate accum ulation by P. syringae ATCC 19304
at 48 h o u rs....................................................... 65
viii
Figure 24. Percent difference in w ater holding capacity of
M acrocystis alginate gels m ade w ith ferric iron,
an d lead, as com pared to calcium alginate g e ls .. . . 87
Figure 25. Percent difference in w ater holding capacity of
acetylated P. syringae alginate gels m ad e w ith
ferric iron, an d lead, as com pared to calcium
alginate gels....................... 89
Figure 26. Percent difference in w ater holding capacity of
d eacetylated P. syringae alginate gels m ad e w ith
ferric iron, a n d lead, as com pared to calcium
alginate gels...................................................................... 90
ix
Figure 33. Precipitation of M acrocystis alginate, acetylated
P. syringae alginate, an d deacetylated P. syringae
alginate b y calcium (Ca2+) io n s............................. 101
x
ABSTRACT
xi
INTRODUCTION
1
2
3
4
th e a b ility to p ro d u c e EPS is w id e s p re a d , u n d e r la b o ra to ry
conditions this ability is often un stab le an d lost on re p e a te d cu ltu re
(17).
Bacterial EPS varies enorm ously in stru ctu re a n d com position,
ra n g in g fro m sim p le h o m o p o ly sacc h arid es to com plex, h ig h ly
su b stitu te d a n d b ran ch e d h etero p o ly sacch arid es (Table 1). These
polysaccharides can be divided in to five distinct groups: 1 ) d ex tran s
a n d levans, o r h o m o p o ly sacch arid es p ro d u c e d b y b a c te ria using
sucrose as a specific su b strate, 2 ) hom opolysaccharides o th e r th a n
d e x tr a n a n d le v a n , i.e., cellu lo se, 3) h e te ro p o ly s a c c h a rid e s
containing m ore th an one type of m onosaccharide synthesized from
a specific ca rb o n su b strate, 4) h etero p o ly sacch arid es fo rm ed from
re p e a tin g u n it s tr u c tu r e s , i.e., x a n th a n gum , and 5)
heterop o ly sacch arid es com posed of two types o f m o n o m er w ith no
rep eatin g unit, i.e., alginate (134).
Aa
A bbreviations: Gal, galactose; Glc, glucose; GlcA, glucuronic acid; GulA, guluronic acid; Man,
m annose; ManA, m annuronic acid; GlcNAc, N-acetylglucosamine; OAc, O-acetyl; Pyr, pyruvate.
a A= (-3«lM an(O A c)2hlG lcA 4lilM an4-Pyr)
7
C-(i
ooc
a-L -g u lu ro n ate
th e y a re co m p o sed p re d o m in a n tly of ra n d o m se q u e n c e s. In
addition, the m an n u ro n ic acid residues are highly O -acetylated ( 2 1 ,
125). T he stru ctu re, as well as th e position of acety latio n in these
alginates, has b een extensively stu d ied . The O-acetyl g ro u p s are
associated exclusively w ith th e C-2 a n d /o r C-3 p o sitions of th e D-
m a n n u r o n a te r e s id u e s . n u c le a r m a g n e tic reso n a n ce
sp e c tro m e try (NMR) re v e a le d th a t som e of th e m a n n u ro n a te
resid u es w ere 2,3 di-O -acetylated, alth o u g h the m ono-O -acetylated
form s w ere m ore com m on (21, 125, 127). The re a so n fo r th e O-
ac e ty la tio n in b a c te ria l alg in ates is n o t e n tire ly clear. It was
suggested th a t acetylation m ay be p a rt of a control m echanism th a t
o p e ra te s d u rin g b io sy n th e sis th a t c o n tro ls th e M /G ra tio b y
p re v e n tin g ep im eriza tio n of th e c a rb o x y l g ro u p o n th e C-5
m a n n u ro n a te ca rb o n (128). A lternatively, it m ay p lay a ro le in
dictating the solution p ro p erties of the polysaccharide (129).
Seaw eed a n d b ac teria l alginates d iffer in th e ir M /G ratio s.
M ost alginates isolated fro m the brow n seaw eeds show M/G ratio s
in th e ran g e of 0.45 (Laminaria hyperborea) to 1.85 (A scophyllum
nodosum , 117). The m ost com m on in d u strially available alginate is
extracted from the brow n alga, M acrocystis pyrifera. This p olym er
contain s 60% 4-linked m an n u ro n a te a n d 40% 4-linked g u lu ro n ate
residues giving an M/G ratio of 1.5. The alginates p ro d u c e d b y P.
aeruginosa co n tain 80% 4-linked m a n n u ro n a te a n d 20% 4-lin k ed
guluron ate residues, giving an M/G ratio of 4.0 (150).
H aw orth pro jectio n s o f th e (5-D -m annuronate a n d th e a-L-
g u lu ro n a te resid u es show little d ifferen ce in th e two stru c tu re s.
Epim erization of th e carboxyl group at C-5 does, how ever p ro d u ce a
10
2. Properties
The physical com position of alginates dictates th e solution an d
gelling p ro p e rtie s o f th e p o ly m e rs. A lg in ate is a s tr u c tu ra l
com ponent in the brow n seaw eeds w here it co n trib u tes to b o th th e
tensile stren g th a n d th e flexibility of th e algal tissue (64, 143). In
A. vin la n d ii it serves a stru c tu ra l fu n ctio n fo r th e m etab o lically
d o rm an t cysts. Evidence exists th a t it is an im p o rtan t com p o n en t of
b o th th e cyst exine an d in tin e, w hich are m icroscopically d istin ct
reg io n s o u tsid e th e c e n tra l b o d y of th e cy st (1 1 5 ). A lg in ate
11
Ca++
S^°-V
3. Applications
W hile alginate p ro d u ctio n is w idespread am ong m em b ers of
th e brow n seaw eed (Phaeophyceae), only a few species of brow n
seaw eed are used for com m ercial production. The p rin cip al source
o f th e w o rld 's su p p ly o f alg in ate is th e g ian t kelp, M acrocystis
pyrifera. O ther seaweeds th a t are used in alginate m an u factu re are
A scophyllum no dosum a n d species of Laminaria an d Ecklonia.
A lg in a te is u s e d in fo o d s a n d fo r g e n e ra l in d u s tria l
applications because of its unique colloidal beh av io r a n d its ability
to thicken, stabilize, em ulsify, suspend, fo rm films, a n d p ro d u c e
gels. T he p rim a ry p ro p e rtie s o n w hich th e w id esp re ad use of
15
4. Commercial M anufacture
M acrocystis p yrifera grows in relativ ely calm m a rin e w aters
in large, dense beds. It is a v ery rap id ly growing p la n t th a t allows
for up to four cuttings p e r year. At the tim e of harvesting, a dense
16
Water a n d
Dissolved
Impurities
Figure 4. Flow diagram for th e extraction of sodium alginate from seaw eed (117).
20
% U. S. ConsumDtiona
Polysaccharide Food Industrial Retail Price
(p er 1 0 0 g)b
fructose 6-phosphate
Phosphomannose isorerase
Mannose 6-phosphate
Phosohomannonutase
Mannose 1-phosphate
GDP-mannose
GDP-nannose denvcrooenasc
GDP-nannuromc acid
Pol viiierase
Epinerase
Acetyl transferase-
ALGI NATE
F igure 5. T he p ro p o s e d b io sy n th e tic p a th w a y o f a lg in a te in
A zo to b a cter vinlandii a n d P seudom onas aeruginosa. T he firs t 4
enzym atic step s h av e b e e n id e n tifie d in b o th o rg an ism s. The
p o ly m e ra se a n d ep im erase h av e been id e n tified in A. vin la n d ii
only, an d the acetyl tran sferase has not yet been identified in eith er
organism .
23
6-Phosphogluconate
ALGINATE
Fructose 1,6-diphosphate
2-Keto 3-deoxy
phosphogluconate
Di h y d r o x y a c e t o n e Glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate
phosphate
Pyruvate
TCA
cycle
2. Enzymology
O nly fo u r of th e seven p ro p o se d en zy m atic step s in th e
biosynthetic pathw ay of alginate fro m fru cto se 6 -p h o sp h ate to th e
m a tu re p o ly m er h av e b ee n positively id e n tified in Pseudom onas
aeruginosa (9 8 ). Six o f th e ste p s h a v e b e e n id e n tif ie d in
A zotobacter vinlandii ( 8 6 ). The first fo u r enzym es in th e path w ay
h av e b ee n fo u n d in b o th organism s a n d h av e b een th e subject of
m u ch in v e stig a tio n . In P. aeruginosa th e genes en co d in g these
e n z y m es a re lo c a te d a t a p p ro x im a te ly 34 m in u te s o n th e
chrom osom e linkage m ap (89, Fig. 7). W hat is know n a b o u t these
enzym es is sum m arized below.
P h o s p h o m a n n o s e is o m e ra s e : T his en zy m e cataly ses th e
re v e rsib le c o n v e rsio n o f fru c to se 6 -p h o sp h a te to m a n n o se 6 -
p h o sp h a te . The en zy m e is th e p ro d u c t of th e algA g en e in P.
aeruginosa, a n d has a m olecular w eight of approxim ately 56,000 on
th e b a s is o f s o d iu m d o d e c y l s u lf a te - p o ly a c ry la m id e gel
electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE, 82). O verexpression o f th e algA gene
p ro d u c e s in c re a s e d ac tiv ity of th e n e x t tw o en z y m e s o f th e
p a th w a y , i.e., p h o s p h o m a n n o m u ta s e and GDP m a n n o s e
p y r o p h o s p h o ry la s e (4 8 , 114). In th e o v e re x p re sse d state,
phosphom annose is o m e ra s e w as s e p a ra te d from
p h o sp h o m a n n o m u ta se b u t co uld n o t be s e p a r a te d fro m GDP
m annose p y ro p h o sp h o ry lase (114). The inability to sep arate these
two activities has led to the proposal that, in P. aeruginosa, th e algA
gene encodes a single p ro te in having p h o sp h o m an n o se isom erase
an d GDP m annose pyrophosphorylase activities.
26
Switching
G enes" v
P o s it i v e
Effectors
algA
r~Z------------- \
Structural
Genes
3. Regulation
In th e lungs o f cystic fibrosis p a tie n ts Alg (-) stra in s of P.
aeruginosa usually convert to the m ucoid Alg (+) form . In vitro, the
Alg (+) p h en o ty p e is u n stab le a n d Alg (-) re v e rta n ts a p p e a r o ver
tim e. Genetic m apping experim ents have show n th a t sp o n tan eo u s
alginate conversion is b ased on th e gene p ro d u cts of th e algB, algR,
algS, a n d algT genes (42, 45, 79, 90). The p rim a ry genetic ev en t
th a t regulates th e " o n /o f f switch in alginate p ro d u ctio n is handled
p rim arily by th e algS a n d algT genes located a t ap p ro x im ately 6 8
m inutes on th e chrom osom al linkage m ap of P. aeruginosa (89, Fig.
7).
Spontaneous conversion betw een th e m ucoid an d nonm ucoid
state is the resu lt of a genetic alteratio n a t th e algS gene locus. The
algS gene is a genetic sw itch th a t co n tro ls th e expression of algT
(42). Form ation of th e A lgS p ro tein resu lts in th e activation of the
algT gene. The gene p ro d u c t of algT acts as a reg u lato ry p ro te in in
th e biosynthesis of b acterial alginate in P. aeruginosa by prom oting
th e activ atio n of th e stru c tu ra l genes involved in th e bio sy n th etic
pathw ay (42, 43).
Along w ith its ro le in reg u la tio n of th e stru c tu ra l genes in
alginate pro d u ctio n , th e algT gene p ro d u c t also is involved in the
exp ressio n of th e algB gene (149). T he algB gene is lo c a te d at
approxim ately 12 m in u tes o n th e chrom osom e m ap (Fig. 7). Its
gene p ro d u ct is n o t directly involved in th e biosynthetic p ath w ay of
31
V. Polysaccharide Analysis
1. Depolym erization
C h a ra c te riz a tio n o f a n y p o ly s a c c h a rid e s ta r ts w ith a
com positional analysis. Acid hydrolysis is com m on to m ost m ethods
33
2. Acid Sensitivity
M onosaccharides are d eg rad ed b y acid to a g re a te r o r lesser
ex ten t d ep en d in g on the sugar a n d stren g th of th e acid (119). In
ad d itio n to d e g ra d a tio n , acids m ay co n v ert sugars in to a n h y d ro
derivatives. Spontaneous conversion to a 1,6 an h y d ro ald o p y ran o se
occurs in acidic solutions of several aldoses a n d ketoses having the
id o (1 0 0 , 102, 146), a ltro (101, 112), a n d g ulo (1 3 1 , 132)
configurations. In d ilu te acid solutions those sugars o f th e gluco,
m anno, and g a la c to c o n fig u ra tio n s a re a lm o s t com pletely
h y d ro ly z e d to th e free aldoses. Reeves (111) first suggested an
ex p lan atio n fo r this d iffe re n t b eh av io r in term s of conform ational
in teractio n s. He show ed th a t (3-D-idose, w ith all h y d ro x y l groups
eq u a to rial, h as a h ig h e r p ro p en sity to fo rm 1 ,6 a n h y d rid e s th a n
d o es p-D-glucose w hose h y d ro x y l groups a re all o rie n te d axially.
This system rep resen ts a good exam ple of conform ational control of
37
ido > altro, gulo > talo > alio > galacto > m anno > gluco
39
40
3. Alginate Q uantitation
A lginate co n c e n tra tio n s w ere d e te rm in e d b y two d iffe re n t
m ethods. These m eth o d s inclu d ed the uronic acid assay d escrib ed
by B lum enkrantz an d A sboe-H ansen (10), a n d th e carb azo le assay
o f K nutson a n d Jean es (69). Each m e th o d h a s its b en efits. T he
uronic acid assay is rap id , b u t is only accu rate u p to 150 itig/ml of
uronic acid. The carbazole assay takes m uch longer to p erfo rm , b u t
it is accu rate up to 1 0 0 0 ng/ml.
The uronic acid assay was used p red o m in ately w ith alginates
p ro d u ced in b ro th cultures. This assay allow ed d irec t testing o f the
su p e rn a ta n t w ithout color in terferen ce from th e rem ain in g salts in
solution. The protocol was as follows:
42
4. Acetyl Q uantitation
T h e p e rc e n t a c e ty la tio n w as d e te rm in e d b y th e m e th o d
d escrib ed b y McComb a n d M cCready (80). A s ta n d a rd cu rv e fo r
p erce n t acetylation was p re p a re d w ith glucose p e n taac eta te (Sigma
C hem ical Co., St. Louis, MO). P rio r to assay , all sam p les w ere
d esalte d b y dialysis fo r 48 h o u rs against d eio n ized w ater a t ro o m
tem p eratu re. The protocol was as follows:
1) One volum e of 9.4% (w /v) sodium hyd ro x id e was a d d e d to
one volum e of 3.75% (w/v) hydroxylam ine solution.
2) To 2 m l of th e above m ixture, 0.5 ml of the sam ple solution
was ad d e d w ith agitation.
3) A fter 5 m inutes, 0.5 m l of acid m eth an o l was ad d e d w ith
agitation, th e n 1.3 m l of th e ferric p erch lo rate solution was
added.
44
B. N itrogen Source
P. syrin g a e was te ste d fo r its ab ility to p ro d u c e acetylated
b a c te ria l a lg in ate o n d iffe re n t n itro g e n so u rces. T he n itro g e n
sources tested w ere am m onia, [(NH4 )2 9 0 4 ], n itrate, (KNO3 ), n itrite,
(KNO2 ), a n d u rea. Each DF b ro th was m ade b y in co rp o ratin g only
the test co m p o u n d as a p o ten tial n itro g en source fo r th e organism .
Each n itro g e n so u rc e w as p la c e d in to th e m e d iu m a t in itia l
co n cen tratio n s of 2 mM, 5 mM, 9 mM, 12 mM, a n d 15 mM (w /v).
Gluconic acid was used as the carb o n source a t a final co n cen tratio n
46
of 2% (w /v). After inoculation, (3%, v /v ), from stan d ard ized sta rte r
cu ltu res, P.syringae was in c u b a te d fo r 48 h o u rs w ith shaking as
d escrib ed previously. At th e a p p ro p ria te tim e th e c u ltu re b ro th
w as c e n trifu g e d to rem o v e b a c te ria l cells, a n d th e cell m ass
d e te rm in e d as d escrib ed previously. T he b ro th was an a ly z e d b y
th e uronic acid assay for alginate production.
2. pH an d T em perature
The effect of pH on bacterial cell yield a n d alginate p ro d u ctio n
was investigated in DF b ro th . The initial pH's w ere 6.0, 6.2, 6.4, 6 .6 ,
6 .8 , 7.0, an d 7.2. Cell yield an d alginate p ro d u ctio n w ere m easu red ,
beef extract (Difco Lab. D etroit, MI), m edia containing 5 g/L peptone
(Difco Lab. D etroit, MI), a n d m ed ia containing a m ix tu re of 3 g/L
b eef ex tract an d 5 g/L p eptone. All m edia w ere su p p lem en ted w ith
2% gluconic acid (w /v). The gluconic acid was sterilized sep arately
by autoclaving as a stock solution of 2 0 % (w /v), a n d a d d e d to the
c u ltu re m e d ia a sep tic ally a fte r ste riliz atio n . A gar m e d ia w ere
p re p a re d w ith 15 g/L agar. The pH of each test m ed ia was betw een
6.9 a n d 7.0 p r io r to ste riliz a tio n . All in o c u la w ere fro m a
sta n d a rd iz e d 48 h o u r s ta rte r c u ltu re o f P. syrin g a e grow n in DF
b ro th a t 30°C w ith shaking as described previously. Liquid cultures
w ere in o cu lated from th e stan d ard ized 48 h o u r sta rte r cu ltu re to a
fined con cen tratio n of 2% (v/v). Solid cu ltu res w ere in o cu lated w ith
0.1 m l of th e sam e sta n d a rd iz e d s ta rte r c u ltu re p e r 100 x 15 m m
p e tri dish containing 25 m l of m edium . T he in o cu lu m was sp rea d
using a flam e sterilized , b e n t glass ro d . All te st c u ltu re s w ere
allow ed to grow fo r 48 h o u rs a t 30°C. T he liq u id cu ltu res w ere
in cu b ated w ith shaking as described previously. At th e ap p ro p riate
tim e, th e cell yield an d alg in ate p ro d u c tio n of each c u ltu re w ere
m e a s u re d as d e s c rib e d p re v io u sly . A lg in ate p ro d u c tio n was
m e asu red by th e uronic acid assay. T otal alg inate p ro d u ctio n on
solid m ed ia was m e asu red by scraping th e b ac teria l grow th fro m
h a lf of a p e tri dish (allowing 2 m easu rem en ts p e r p e tri dish) an d
resu sp en d in g th a t grow th in 10 m l of d eio n ized w ater. T he cells
w ere th e n rem oved by centrifugation a n d the cell m ass d eterm in ed ,
as d escrib ed previously. A lginate p ro d u c tio n was assayed by the
u ro n ic acid assay. The to ta l a lg in ate p ro d u c tio n fo r th e solid
cultures was rep o rted in (.ig/cm2 .
48
X. Alginate Reductions
A lginates w ere chem ically red u ced p rio r to acid hydrolysis of
th e polym ers. The m e th o d used fo r th e re d u c tio n o f th e u ro n ic
acids in alginates to th e co rresp o n d in g n e u tra l sugars was th a t of
T aylor e t al (140). An aqueous solution of alginate containing 100
m icroequivalents of carboxylic acid in 10 ml of deio n ized w ater was
ad ju sted to pH 4.75 w ith 0.1 M NaOH. One m illim ole of 1-eth y l-3 -
(3 -d im eth y lam in o p ro p y l)carb o d iim id e was a d d e d to th e alg in ate
solution to co n v ert the u ro n id es to esters. The pH of the reactio n
m ix tu re was m ain tain ed a t 4.75 b y titra tio n w ith 0.1 M HC1. The
reactio n was allow ed to continue u n til h y d ro g en ion u p tak e ceased
(45-60 m inutes). Then, 25 m l of a 3 M NaBH4 solution was ad d e d
dropw ise o ver a 1 h o u r p erio d to red u ce th e u ro n id es to th e m ore
read ily hydrolyzable n eu tra l polym ers. The pH was m a in ta in ed at
54
3. Surface Tension
The relativ e surface ten sio n s o f b ead s w ere m e asu red using
b e a d d ia m e te r, th e sm a lle r th e b e a d d ia m e te r th e h ig h e r th e
surface ten sio n o n th e b ead . Gel b ead s w ere m ad e as d escrib ed
p rev io u sly in 0.5 M CaCl2 . U pon fo rm atio n , 1 /3 of ea ch b ea d
sam ple was w ashed in d eionized w ater fo r 5 m in u tes a n d allow ed
to d ry fo r 5 m in u tes p rio r to d ia m e te r m e asu rem e n t w ith a dial
calip er (L. S tarre tte Co., Athol, MA). The second p o rtio n of each
sam ple was in cu b ated a t 4°C fo r 24 h o u rs in deionized w ater prior
to m easurem ent, an d th e final th ird of each sam ple was in c u b ate d
57
58
59
2 1000
Cell mass (mg dry weight/ ml broth)
d
-800
o
*3
d
d
ad
tyig/ml broth)
-600
o
1 d
3
-400 d
d
tuo
d
-200
o
H
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
T im e (h r)
Carbon Cell Yield Yield T otal EPS % A lginatee Yield A lginate % AcetylationS
Sourcea >b (m g /m l)c O ig/m l)d (ng/m g cell)f
a C ultured in DF b ro th su p p lem en ted w ith 2% carbon source, an d grow n for 48 hours a t 30°C
w ith shaking a t 180 rpm .
b Fructose was also te sted b u t th e re was no growth.
c Cell yield was m easu red as mg cell d ry w eig h t/m l b roth.
d Yield of total EPS was m e asu red as ng EPS/ml broth.
e The p erce n t of to tal EPS th a t was alginate.
f Yield of alginate was m easu red as [ig alg in ate/m g cell d ry weight.
8 The fimolar ratio (%) o f acetyl to uronic acid.
61
1400
3
©
* d
& 1200
©
-
S
a
s P
A
txo Is
na
'H - 1000
3 -
- 800 %
b©
a 00 a
rt5 "
w 0.8 -600
w -
3
rt ©
2 H
© 0.6 400
L> i 9 12 15
Figure 10. The effect of the initial am m onium co n cen tratio n on cell
m ass (♦), a n d total alginate (uronic acid) accu m u latio n (□), by P.
syTingae ATCC 19304 at 48 hours.
62
3 00 0
Specific alginate accum ulation
tyig/mg cell dry w eigh t)
2000
1000
0 t '-----------1
----------- 1
------------'-----------1
------------'-----------r
2 5 y 12 15
500
Cell mass (mg dry w eight/m l broth)
1.6 -
d
3
400 to
h
* 2
-3 0 0 « &
s a
.2
3>
0.8 -
CO
-200
3
0.6 o
H
0 .4 100
6.0 6.2 6 .4 6.6 6.8 7 .0
In itia l pH
2 .7 5 500
fl 2 .5 0
©
P d
Xi 2 .2 5 ©
3
a 2.00
«i
qpag
s
•p
jd
&o 1.75
-4 0 0
as
d ©
© p
1 .5 0 -
s s
1 .25 -
p
t? 1.0 0 - d &o
&Q 300
a 0 .7 5 -
S 5'
rt
0)
CO 0 .5 0 - 5
©
a 0 .2 5 - H
© 0.00 —1" —r- —r~ —r~ 200
©
24 26 28 30 32 34
T em p. (°C)
a C ultures w ere grow n a t 30°C fo r 48 h o u rs. Liquid c u ltu re s w ere sh a k en a t 180 rp m . All
cultures w ere su p p lem en ted w ith 2% (w/v) gluconic acid.
t> Beef ex tract was u sed a t a 3 g/L co n cen tratio n an d Peptone was used a t a 5 g/L concentration.
Beef extract, Peptone, an d N u trien t m edia w ere from Difco Labs., D etroit, ML
c Specific p ro d u ctio n was m easu red as ng alg in ate/m g cell d ry weight.
d Total p ro d u ctio n in liquid cu ltu re was m easu red as fig alg in ate/m l broth.
e Total p ro d u ctio n on solid cu ltu re was m easured as fig alginate/cm 2 of ag ar surface.
68
2000
Specific alginate accum ulation
(pg/mg cell dry w eigh t)
1000 -
2. M olecular W eight
T he w eig h t av erag e m o le cu lar w eig h t (Mw ) a n d n u m b e r
a v e ra g e m o le c u la r w e ig h t (Mn) w e re d e te r m in e d fo r b o th
acety lated a n d d eacety lated b acterial alginates b y gel p e rm e a tio n
c h ro m a to g ra p h y (GPC). T he Mw a n d th e Mn o f th e seaw eed
alginate w ere ap p ro x im ately 65% sm aller th a n th e n ativ e b acterial
alginate. D eacetylation w ith sodium h y d ro x id e d id n o t a lte r th e
m olecular w eights appreciably. Upon deacetylation, th e Mw of th e
bacterial alginate d ecreased by 6%, an d th e Mn d ec re ase d by 11%.
In e a c h case, th e p o ly d isp e rsity was ap p ro x im a tely 3.00. T his
in d ic a te d th a t th e re was a w ide ran g e of m o lecu lar sizes in each
alginate sam ple (Table 7).
70
3. Composition
T he d e te rm in a tio n of alg in a te co m p o sitio n re q u ire d th e
red u ctio n of the uronic acids to th e ir co rresponding n e u tra l sugars
p rio r to acid hydrolysis of th e polym er. This red u ctio n facilitated
the acid hydrolysis of th e glycosidic bonds by conversion of th e acid
resistan t glycosyluronic acid bonds to th e m ore acid labile glycosyl
bo nds. The acid sensitivities o f D -m annose a n d L-gulose (Sigma
C hem ical Co., St. Louis, MO) w ere s tu d ie d u sin g th in la y e r
chrom atography (TLC) an d ion chrom atography. TLC in d icated th at
D -m annose a n d L-gulose h av e m a rk e d d ifferen ces in th e ir acid
sensitivity. Acid h y d ro ly zed (HC1) D -m annose resu lted in only one
spot on TLC (Rf=.40). The in ten sity o f this spot rem a in ed co n stan t
b e tw e e n 0 a n d 4 h o u rs h y d ro ly sis tim e (Fig. 15). L-gulose
p ro d u ced a second spot (Rf=.56) afte r m ore th a n 1 h o u r hydrolysis.
T he in te n sity of this sp o t in creased w ith h y d ro ly sis tim e. At th e
sam e tim e, th e in te n sity o f th e gulose sp o t (Rf=.37) d e c re a se d
p ro p o rtio n a lly (Fig. 16). Both D -m annose a n d L-gulose re a c te d
sim ilarly in HC1 an d H 2 SO4 (Table 8 ).
The relative acid sensitivity of each sugar was m e asu red by
D ionex ion ch ro m ato g rap h y . D-M annose was acid stable. A fter 4
h o u rs o f HC1 o r H 2 SO4 h y d ro ly sis, 98% o f th e o rig in al su g ar was
recovered. L-gulose was relatively stable fo r 1 h o u r, afte r w hich it
began to rap id ly breakdow n. After 4 h o u rs hydrolysis, only 22% of
the original sugar was recovered (Fig. 17).
The acid breakdow n p ro d u c t of L-gulose was n o t definitively
identified. TLC of this com pound show ed a m igration (Rf=.58) equal
to 1,6 an h y d ro p-D -m annopyranose (Rf=.58), an d v ery close to 1,6
72
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Figure 15. Thin layer chrom atograph of HC1 hydrolyzed D-m annose.
Lane 1= unhydrolyzed D -m annose in H20, Lane 2= u n h y d ro ly zed D-
m annose in HC1, Lanes 3-7= hydrolyzed D -m annose in HC1 fo r 0 .5 ,1 ,
2 ,3 , a n d 4 h o u rs respectively at 100°C
73
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
120
100
H
W
kH 80
o
>
o
o
o
Pi GO
u
rt
oo
i/j 40
20
1 7 3 4
H y d ro ly sis T im e (h r)
§ •
a V alues w ere o b ta in ed using SYBYL m o lecu lar m odeling softw are (Tripos Assoc. Inc., St. Louis,
MO).
b 1 fem tosecond equals 1 0 " 15 seconds.
c All en erg y values are m easu red in kcal/m ol.
80
50
40 -
■O
Im
o
► 30 -
o
o
4>
P4
to 20 -
©
53
O
M 10 -
I
4
H y d ro ly sis T im e (h r)
10
(N/No)
8
Comparative Viscosity
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200
2.0
(N/No)
Comparative Viscosity
1.6 -
1.4-
0 50 100 150
A c e ty la tio n (%)
6
(N/No)
Comparative Viscosity
1
30 32 38 42 44 50 52 58 04 08 74 78 80 84
T e m p e ra tu re (°C)
Figure 23. The effects of tem p eratu re on the com parative viscosity,
(N/No), of Macrocystis alg in ate (0), acety lated P. syringae alginate
(I), a n d d eacety lated P. syringae alginate (♦).
85
2. Physical Effects
The affects of acetylation on gelation, w ater holding capacity,
surface tension, an d gel porosity w ere d eterm ined. Calcium induced
gelation was altered b y b o th acetylation, an d calcium concentration.
T he gels p r o d u c e d fro m a c e ty la te d b a c te ria l a lg in a te h e ld
approx im ately 100 g w a te r/g d ry alg in ate gel c o m p a re d to th e
deacety lated b acterial alg inate gel w hich h eld ap p roxim ately 3 2 g
w a te r/ g d ry alginate gel (Table 10). As th e co n cen tratio n of CaCl2
increased from 0.05 M to 0.50 M, the w ater holding capacity of each
Ca-alginate gel d ecreased linearly. The w ater holding capacities of
bacterial alginate gels m ad e w ith 0.50 M CaCl2 w ere approxim ately
54% th a t of gels m ad e w ith 0.05 M CaCl2. In co n trast, Ca-alginate
gels m ad e w ith seaw eed alginate show ed a 41% d ecrease in w ater
holding capacity over th e same calcium ion increase.
T he w ater holding capacities of b o th Fe-alginate (ferric), a n d
P b -a lg in ate gels w ere d e te r m in e d fo r seaw eed a lg in a te a n d
acety lated a n d d eacety lated b acterial alginates. The resu lts w ere
com pared to those o b tain ed from Ca-alginate gels. In each case, Fe-
alg in ate gels h e ld less w ater th a n th e ir C a-alginate counterparts,
b u t m ore th a n Pb-alginate gels. The w ater holding capacity of Fe-
a lg in ate (0.05 M FeCl3 ) gels m a d e w ith seaw eed a lg in a te w as
approxim ately 82% th a t of C a-alginate gels. P b-alginate (0.05 M
PbCl2) gels h eld w ater a t 67% th a t of Ca-alginate gels (Fig. 24). As
th e c o n c e n tra tio n of m etal (Fe^+ o r Pb2+) in c re ase d , th e w ate r
holding capacity of the resulting gels decreased. By increasing the
m etal con cen tratio n fro m 0.05 M to 0.50 M in increm ents of 0.05 M,
th e w ater h o ld in g cap acity in Fe-alginate gels d e c re a se d b y a n
86
Calcium Concentration^
M acrocystis 65 47 36 27
( ±3) (±4) ( ±4) ( ±3)
A cetylated 100 85 69 56
P. syringae (±6) ( ±5) (±5) ( ±5)
D eacetylated 32 26 24 17
P. syringae (±3) (± 2) (±2) (± 1)
90
of Calcium)
80 -
70 -
{%
Water Holding
6 0 ■■
50 -
40
.0 5 M .1 M .25 M .5 M
M etal c o n c e n tr a tio n
90
(% of C alcium )
80 -
70 -
60 -
Water Holding
50 -
40 -
30
.05 M 1 M .25 M .5 M
M etal c o n c e n tr a tio n
80
of Calcium)
70 -
60 -
{%
Water Holding
50 -
40 -
30
.05 M ] M .2 5 M .5 M
M etal c o n c e n tr a tio n
■N
fed Q
a •©
is
O
as 4
« ,£
rt
£ M
Im
&
to
3
0 10 20 30
T im e (m in.) a t 50 C
Figure 27. Rate of w ater loss of calcium alg in ate gels m ad e from
M acrocystis alginate, I slope l= 4.6 x 10"2 (□), ac ety late d P. syringae
alg in ate, I slope 1= 6.8 x 10"~ (♦), an d d e a c e ty la te d P. syringae
alginate, I slope 1= 5.2 x 10"2 (I), as a function of in cu b atio n tim e at
50°C.
94
w a te r a p p ro x im a te ly 2 fo ld f a s te r th a n th e ir C a -a lg in a te
co u n terp arts, indicating a m ore open structure. The gels p ro d u ced
by th e a c ety late d b a c te ria l alg in ate show ed a ra te of w ate r loss
a p p ro x im a tely eq u al to th a t of C a-alginate gel b ead s in d icatin g
com parable p ore sizes betw een these gels (Fig. 28).
110
Ui
B
100 -
art d§
Q °
S3 90 -
tt o
rs W°i
WH
S3 4> 80 -
12 bo
2o rtd
28 70 -
JS S
fld
Et
GO
0 10 20 30
T im e (m in .)
Figure 28. Com parison of the w ater loss of ferric iro n alginate gels
of M acrocystis alg inate (D), acety lated P. syringae alginate ( ♦ h a n d
deacetylated P. syringae alginate (I), co m p ared to calcium alginate
gels as a function of incubation tim e at 50°G
96
concentration of 5 mM (Fig. 29). Cupric ion reac ted m uch the sam e
way, precipitating 98% of th e d eacetylated bacterial alginate a t 2.5
mM copper, an d g reater th a n 90% of acetylated b acterial alginate a t
a m etal co n cen tratio n of 5 mM (Fig. 30). Lead in d u c ed gelation of
b acterial alginates was least affected by acetylation. G reater th a n
90% o f b o th a c e ty la te d a n d d e a c e ty la te d b a c te ria l alginates
p recip itated in the presence of 1 mM lead chloride (Fig. 31). Ferric
io n s p re c ip ita te d b o th a c e ty la te d a n d d e a c e ty la te d b a c te ria l
alginate. A cetylation in creased th e p recip itab ility of th e bacterial
p o ly m e r b y fe rric ion. A p p ro x im ately 90% o f th e a c e ty la te d
b a c te ria l p o ly m e r p re c ip ita te d w ith 1 mM fe rric ch lo rid e. In
c o n tra st, 90% of th e d ea c e ty la te d b ac teria l alg in ate p re c ip ita te d
w ith 2 mM ferric chloride (Fig. 32).
A h ig h affinity of calcium ions for p o ly g u lu ro n ate resid u es is
th e basis fo r th e c u rre n t gelling th e o ry (the "egg box m odel") fo r
seaw eed alg in ates. As ex p ected , alm o st 100% of th e seaw eed
a lg in a te was p re c ip ita te d by 5 mM calcium c h lo rid e (Fig. 33).
C alcium p re c ip ita tio n w as less efficien t fo r b a c te ria l alg in ates,
p ro b a b ly d u e to th e ab sen ce of extensive po ly g u lu ro n ate blocks.
T he a m o u n t of b a c te ria l alg in ate p re c ip ita te d b y calciu m io n s
in c re ase d as th e calcium co n c en tratio n increased . A pproxim ately
95% of the deacetylated bacterial alginate an d 65% of th e acety lated
bacterial alginate precip itated with 60 mM calcium chloride.
As m ight be expected from its chem ical sim ilarity to calcium,
stro n tiu m was also an effective p re c ip ita n t of b o th acety lated an d
deacetylated bacterial alginate. As w ith calcium , stro n tiu m show ed
a g r e a te r a b ility to p re c ip ita te d e a c e ty la te d th a n a c e ty la te d
97
100
■0 80 -
$
B
a
60 -
o
k0H
&
3 40 -
rt
a
bjo
< 20 -
0 1 2 3 4 (> 7 8 9 10
U ra n iu m c h lo rid e (mM)
120
100 -
3
B 80 -
a
o
60 -
£
$
rt
a 40 -
ao
<
20 -
0+
0 2 4 6 8 10
120
100 -
’O
$
B 80 -
‘8.
o
o
Wn GO -
&
B
«
a 40 -
GJO
<
20 -
0 ■*
0 1 2 4
100
■o 80 -
B
$
Gk- 60 -
o
<b
u
O h
O
4-> 40 -
(0
a
&0
VN
<
20 -
7 4 6 8 10
100
*0 80 -
B
&
Q. 60 -
o
O
b*
a,
Bca 40 -
d
bo
< 20 -
0 •#
0 20 40 60 80
120
100
T>
$
S 80
a,
o
<L>
3
rt
a 40
&o
<
M 20
0
0 20 40 GO 80
120
100 -
•o
$
JS
•N
p 80 -
&
•H
o
O
lM 60 -
&
co
o 40 -
&
pN
o
<
20 -
0 20 40 60 80
120
100 -
x?
B 80 -
B
o 60 -
O
u
&
Brt 40 -
a4
•^
ao 20 -
<
- 20
0 50 100 150 200 250
M a n g a n e se c h lo rid e (mM)
120
100 -
•0
$
80 -
B
ft
•vM
o GO -
4
kn
&
40 -
&
rt
a
euo 20 -
<
- 20
0 50 100 150 200
■e
is
5
»aoH
3
kH
6
is
a
&0
fN
1
<
1
0 20 40 60 80
100
90
80
■o
8 70
8
a 60
o
O 50
a
40
8rt
30
a
CUD 20
<
M
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
D eacetylated bacterial alginate: Pb2+=Fe3+=U(5+ > Cu2+ > Sr2+ > Ca2+ >
Zn2+ > Mn2+ > Cq 2+ > Mg 2+ =Cs 1+=Rb 1+
110
111
112
w o u ld be in te r r u p te d a n d le a f sp o ts w o u ld o c c u r d u e to th e
inability of th e p lan t to m ake energy for chlorophyll biosynthesis.
T h e n a tiv e a lg in a te s o f P. sy rin g a e ATCC 1 9 3 0 4 w ere
p o ly d isp erse. This in d ic a te d th a t th e re w as a h ig h d e g re e o f
variability in size of th e alginate p ro d u ced by th e biological system.
T he Mw fo r th e n ativ e b a c te ria l p o ly m er was 1.3 x 1 0 $. U pon
deacetylation, th e Mw d ro p p ed approxim ately 6 % to 1.2 x 105. This
d ro p was d u e to th e loss o f th e acetyl groups at C-2 a n d /o r C-3 of
th e m a n n u ro n ic acid resid u es w ithin th e polym er. By m onitoring
th e difference in the acid stability of D -m annose a n d L-gulose from
th e acid h y d ro ly ze d , re d u c e d alg in ates, m o re a c c u ra te a lg in ate
com positions w ere o b tain ed fo r th e bacterial polym er. The alginate
p ro d u ced b y P. syringae ATCC 19304 h ad a final com position of 82%
m an n u ro n ic acid an d 18% guluronic acid. This com position was in
co n tra st w ith th e p reviously re p o rte d com position o f g re a te r th a n
95% m a n n u ro n ic acid a n d less th a n 5% g u lu ro n ic acid w h ere th e
relative acid sensitivity of each sugar was n o t considered (38).
Both th e solution a n d gelling p ro p erties of b acterial alginate
w ere a lte re d b y th e d eg ree o f acety latio n o n th e p o ly m er. T he
v is c o s ity o f th e a c e ty la te d p o ly m e r w as h ig h e r th a n th e
d e a c e ty la te d b a c te r ia l o r se a w e e d a lg in a te s a t e q u iv a le n t
concentrations. The n ativ e b acterial alginates w ere acety lated w ith
a n a v e ra g e o f 1.2 ac ety l u n its p e r u ro n ic acid re sid u e . T his
p ro d u c e d a 6 p e rc e n t in c re a se in Mw a n d a 26% in c re a se in
viscosity a t a co n c e n tra tio n of 1 m g /m l. A cetylation re p o rte d ly
increases th e viscosity of alginate solutions (129). T hese in creases
m a y be d u e to th e in c re a se in to ta l m o le c u la r w eig h t o f th e
117
p o ly m e r, o r a lte re d co n fo rm atio n s of th e p o ly m e r in aq u eo u s
solution. A lginates h igh in m an n u ro n ic acid ex h ib it a flat rib b o n
like con fo rm atio n . High am o u n ts of g u lu ro n a te p ro d u c e a m ore
p u ck e re d stru c tu re . It is possible th a t th e in tro d u c tio n of acetyl
gro u p s shifts th e co n fo rm atio n al en e rg y w ith o u t in creasin g th e
accessible surface of th e m olecules, eventually p roducing a flexible
p olym er w ith an in creased n u m b e r of conform ations. Because the
a c e ty la te d p o ly m e r show ed a 4 fo ld in c re a se in v isco sity o v er
m olecular w eight, it is p ro b ab le th a t b oth factors play a role.
A cetylation a lte re d th e affin ity o f th e p o ly m e r fo r m a n y
cations, in clu d in g calcium . Except fo r ferric a n d to som e e x te n t
co p p er ions, th e ability of m ultivalent cations, p articu larly calcium,
to in d u c e g elatio n of th e alg in ate was re d u c e d in th e ac ety late d
polym er. In p arallel, th e re was a m ark ed decrease in th e stren g th
of th e gels. The effects o f acety latio n o n the gelling p ro p e rtie s of
b ac teria l alg in ates w ere seen in th e w ater h o ld in g capacities, th e
surface tensions, a n d th e relative porosities of the Ca-alginate gels.
A cetylation p ro fo u n d ly affected the rigidity of the Ca-alginate
gels a n d th e ir ab ility to h o ld w ater. G enerally, th e v o lum e of an
ionic gel is d e p e n d e n t u p o n a p o sitiv e osm otic p re ssu re . The
osm otic p ressu re of th e gel is d u e m ainly to th e positive e n tro p y of
th e mixing of co u n terio n s w ith w ater, w hich is c o u n terb ala n ced at
e q u ilib riu m b y a n eg ativ e p re ss u re d u e to th e elasticity of th e
n etw o rk (139). For C a-alginate gels, w hich a re en th alp ic r a th e r
th a n e n tro p ic (3), th e elasticity d e p e n d s o n th e n u m b e r a n d
stren g th of th e crosslinks. Since th e in tro d u ctio n of acetyl groups
im p airs th e co o p erativ e b in d in g of calcium ions, th e n u m b e r of
118
3. A n d re s e n , I. L., a n d O. S m id s ro d . 1977. T e m p e ra tu re
d e p e n d e n c e o n th e elastic p r o p e r tie s o f a lg in a te gels.
C arbohydr. Res. 5 8 :2 7 1 -2 7 9 .
125
126
18. C o ste rto n , J. W., C heng, K. L., G eesey, G. G., L add, T. I.,
N ick el, J. C., D a s g u p ta , M., a n d T. J. M a rrie . 1987.
B acterial biofilm s in n a tu re a n d disease. Ann. Rev. M icrobiol.
4 1 :4 3 5 -4 6 4 .
127
25. D e n t i n i , M ., C r e s c e n z i, V ., a n d D. B la s i. 1984.
C onform ational p ro p e rtie s of x a n th a n d e riv a tiv e s in d ilu te
aqueous solution. Int. J. Biol. Macromol. 6:9 3 -9 8 .
72. L e e , J. W. ( L o u i s ia n a S ta te U n i v e r s i t y ) . 1993.
A cetylation of seaw eed alg in ate b y P seudom onas syringae.
Ph.D. Dissertation, p. 43.
79. M acG eorge, J., K orolik, V., M organ, A. F., A she, V., a n d
B. H o llo w a y . 1 9 8 6 . T ra n s fe r o f a ch ro m o so m al locus
resp o n sib le fo r m ucoid colony m o rp h o lo g y in Pseudom onas
aeruginosa is o l a te d fro m c y s tic f ib ro s is p a t ie n t s to
Pseudom onas aerusinosa PAO. J. Med. Microbiol. 2 1 :3 3 1-336.
134. S u t h e r l a n d , I. W. 19 8 2 . B io sy n th e sis o f m ic ro b ia l
exopolysaccharides. Adv. Micro. Physiol. 2 3 :7 9 -1 4 2 .
136. S u t h e r l a n d , I. W. 19 9 0 . B io te c h n o lo g y o f m icrobial
exopolysaccharides. Cam bridge U niversity Press, Cam bridge.
144. W e lls, J. 1977. E x tracellu lar m icro b ial p o ly sacch arid es, a
c ritic a l overview . In S an d fo rd , B., a n d A. Laskin (ed s.),
Extracellular M icrobial Polysaccharides, p. 299-313. A m erican
Chemical Society, W ashington D. C.
141
DOCTORAL EXAMINATION AND DISSERTATION REPORT
Major Field: M i c r o b i o l o g y
Appro?
f % K._
Major Professor and Chaxrman
EXAMINING COMMITTEE:
y g.-y
r, . ■v/M
^.u f H 'L Jk l
j2 /^ P u ,
Date of Examination:
June 2 1 , 1994