(713) 943-9100
February
2005 aoe
sation from Turbo Components & Engineer
BEARING JOURNAL
ig + Vol VI, No. 3
When to perform a rotordynamics analysis
There are three primary situations where the turbomachinery
end-user needs to have a lateral andor torsional rotordynamies
analysis performed on their equipment. These are when a new
machine is purchased, when a machine is upgraded or otherwise
altered, and as a tool to solve persistent vibration problems and
improve the reliability of the machine
‘New machinery is almost always analyzed by the manufacturer.
However, there are cases where the end-user should consider a
parallel independent rotordynamics analysis audit. The
independent audit is good insurance that nothing has been
overlooked. It is far less expensive to alter a design before a
‘machine is manufactured than later when itis in the field. Mar
less-than-optimum designs have been improved in this way with
litle or no additional capital cost.
It is not uncommon to upgrade existing machines with new
impellers, improved blading, new seals, or couplings. Changing
‘any component can significantly alter the rotordynamics. For
example, replacing oil seals with gas seals often removes an
important damping mechanism and has caused serious vibration
problems. Even if the supplier
Of the new pars is doing some
analysis, an independent study
good idea and often allows
for a bearing or seal
‘optimization that could not be
previously justified. This same
reasoning applies when
changing the service of a
machine, changing speeds or
“A rotordynamics
study and
optimization can
pinpoint the causes
of the excessive
vibrations and
upgrading the intemal pars. A recommend design
complete. train analysis is 5
called for to select new changes.
couplings and bearings for the
highest reliability.
There are many machines that are maintenance headaches.
Bearings and seals don't last, vibration is high and downtime is,
costly. Excessive vibration can not only damage bearings and
seals but cause premature wear to other components. This may
bbe due to operation near a critical speed, passing through critical
speeds with high amplification factors, or instability manifested
as subsynchronous vibration. In most cases, a rotordynamies
study and optimization can pinpoint the causes of the excessive
vibrations and recommend design changes. Sometimes a simple
bearing modification will suffice or a completely new bearing
‘must be designed. Other times more radical changes to rotors or
other components are needed. This approach has been applied
successfully many times and taken machines that were high cost
items to machines that run so well that they only need routine
inspection at long intervals.
Figure 1- Finite Element Model of Turbine-Compressor Train
Data required to perform an analysis
In order for the machinery user to have a rotordynamics
analysis performed either in-house or by a consultant, a great