Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vladimir Udovik,
Candidate of Historical Sciences, Senior Research Fellow, National Library ,
@u kr. no , UK district
The research is related to the study of the organization, formation and preservation of the documentary
heritage of US presidents. Historical discussions and current views on the prospects of organizing the
activities of presidential libraries are discussed, with the exception of the change of the sustainable model
formed in the late 1930s. Art. The scientific noveltytoofthe
theorganization,
work lies in highlighting
preservationthe
and
different
promotion
approaches
of the
documentary legacy of the presidency. Due to the development of information technologies, a new model
of the Presidential Library is being formed in the United States, which ensures the preservation of
documentary and information resources of the US Presidency
access
Institute.
to them
in one
through
place the
andworld
providing
wide digital
web,
and in addition - reduces the cost of the federal budget for the maintenance of a separate resident library.
Presidential libraries, museums, and funds are being set up in many countries around the world to preserve
the documentary heritage of the head of state and to promote its research.
thereforeand
thepopularization,
American evidence
and is
valuable to these countries.
So
the USA Although at the beginning of the twentieth century. The Library of
Congress has been working on the collection and preservation of documentary
resources of presidential presidents, but this tradition was finally formed in the
late 1930s. in the writings of F. Roosevelt's Presidential Library. And F.
Roosevelt's initiative was enshrined in the Law on Presidential Libraries of 1955.
However, for more than 80 years and a century of presidential libraries in
the United States, discussions about the integrity and design of the same
system of presidential libraries - decentralized - have not subsided. storage in
one place of archives, library and museum funds. This is the purpose of this
article - to cover the historical discussion on the organization of the system of
presidential libraries and to identify trends in the development of its
transformation in the XI century. These questions are mainly addressed by
American researchers of presidential libraries [5, archival
6 1 0], collaborators
, system of theofUnited
the
States [9], as well as various
system scientists.
[2] and thewho
rightstudied
to ensure
the the
American
functioning
presidential
, archival
libraries of
[4].
However, a comprehensive study of this issue, aimed at highlighting the
current state of the system of presidential libraries, taking into account the
development of information technology
,
not yet.
In the traditional system of presidential libraries, the United States has its
Obama B. Obama's supporters own.and
Thecritics
examplewill of
report
the President
on the search
of the
forBible
the and
optimal model of functioning for
providing access to information resources for researchers. The experience of
the American system of presidential libraries and the trends of its development
at the present stage will be useful for native scholars in the field of
documentation and information.
The US Presidential Library System currently consists of 14 Presidential
Libraries, which are integrated into the Presidential Library System and
administered by the National Archives and the US Administration of Documents
(NAPA). In addition to them, there are more than a dozen presidential libraries
and museums, but their activities are directed by private foundations,
universities or historical associations. these pits. According to the tradition,
founded by F. Roosevelt, the construction and arrangement of presidential
libraries is carried out at the expense of private funds from the charity fund,
which begins form more than a year
63
Machine Translated by Google
ISSN 2224-9516. Scientific works of the National Library of Ukraine named after VI Vernadsky. 2020. Vip. 60
until the end of the presidential term. After the construction of the premises
and the opening of the library and museum, their management is transferred
to NAPA, but the ownership of land, buildings and library funds remains with
the President. good deeds of the fund, and ownership of archival documents
- under the US government in accordance with the law of 1978 [4, p. 143].
Today, presidential libraries gather a large number of visitors to museum
collections from around the world, and their activities are aimed at the younger
generation in order to cultivate patriotism and popularized by the history of
the United States. However, the main goal of the creation is to provide
researchers with access to information resources to study the period of a
president's rule. Thus, thanks to a study by historians of transcripts of
meetings at the White House, it was possible to dispel the myths about
President D. Eisenhauer, as an influential politician, which were widespread
in public opinion. from the critical political discussion on the war in Vietnam
during the presidency of L. John Son [14].
Thus, the entire library of documents coming from the White House and
related to the Presidential Libraries and Museums of the United States
preserves, processes, and promotes with the political activities of the
presidents, using their constitutional obligations, as well as materials from the
personal archives of the presidents and members of their families, The wives
are happier, and the closest officials, friends, and colleagues. Museum
collections, which are an integral part of the Presidential Library, in addition
to documents, photographs, eo films, sound recordings and personal files.
These include numerous gifts received by the President and members of his
family during their time in the White House. The book fund, as a rule, is small
in size, consists of literature, on the issue of the institute of the presidency,
between the native relations, the historical period ode to the president's rights.
At the same time, the Presidential Library is also a research and research
center, focusing on the study of the activities of presidents, especially on the
formation of materials of "oral history", etc. . The cultural, educational and
informational activities of these institutions are aimed at fostering respect for
history, state symbols, democratic values, especially among young people.
generation.
Laying the foundations for the future system of presidential libraries, US
President F. Roosevelt wanted to see new institutions open to researchers
and citizens, so the name was chosen. it is the "library" and not the "archive",
because the basis of the funds were archival materials. However, the
difference between archival and library institutions is that the library has more
mobile access to documents and materials.
64
Machine Translated by Google
The President of the United States under three had the US Archbishop R.
Connor, who in his article "The Franklin D. Roosevelt Library" (1940) continued
the idea of F. Roosevelt. the transfer of presidential documents to federal
control and the decentralized preservation of them in a separate institution [2,
p. 499].
Later, experts identified the advantages of the existing system of presidential
libraries. Thus, in 1973, J. O'Neill, the former director of the Presidential Library
of F. Roosevelt, considered that despite some shortcomings (limited access
and slow pace of paperwork) co-workers), the documentary legacy of the
presidents, as the only consolidated resource, was gathered in one place with
minimal losses; this set of documents became the legal property of the US
government with open access for all researchers on equal terms, and finally,
the presence of a museum exhibition became necessary a condition for
popularizing the idea of presidency among the population [2, p. 501].
In the early 90's of the twentieth century. U.S. Archivist D. Wilson identified
the role of presidential libraries as a quick access to presidential documents
and to spread the positive image of presidential power among broad masses
of society. Professor R. Koch, a researcher in archival and biblical affairs in the
United States, also emphasizes the educational functions of these institutions
[6, p. 46].
At the beginning of the XXI century. The issue of presidential libraries is
reactivated, connected with a number of scandals concerning the dissection of
documents of Presidents R. Reagan and J. Bush-star shogo [2, p. 505–506].
In 2006, the Journal of the Public Historian began a discussion on the
perspectives of the functioning of the presidential library system, devoting
several issues to this topic. In one of the publications, S. Fawcett, Assistant to
the US Archivist for Presidential Libraries, emphasized the development of
museum and educational functions in raising historical literacy. population,
conducting scientific and popular events in the premises of the library [9].
In his dissertation and research paper on the Presidential Library of George
W. Bush, he emphasizes the superiority of the system of presidential libraries.
The Research Library points to the specialization of the Presidential Library
staff during the presidency of President George W. Bush, which would be
impossible. with the centralized storage of all presidential archives in one place.
In addition, it points to the geographical unity of the museum-archive and library
collection with the memorial sites of the presidential personality, which facilitates
the work of researchers and changes. their costs [10, p. 256, 281].
65
Machine Translated by Google
ISSN 2224-9516. Scientific works of the National Library of Ukraine named after VI Vernadsky. 2020. Vip. 60
Among the first public archival and library institutions, they began to create
Internet portals and fill them with information resources themselves. For the
first time, G. Truman's Presidential Library involved young people in their
educational activities, creating educational programs on a permanent basis,
which served as a model for other institutions. Presidential libraries J.
Kennedy, F. Roosevelt and J. Ford began remote access to digital and
electronic collections [15].
However, criticism of the traditional system of presidential libraries has its
arguments. For example, T. Gallina, a researcher in legal information at the
University of North Carolina, believes that the best option might be a model
that provides for centralized collection. archival depository. He believes that
the decentralized network of presidential libraries adds difficulties for
researchers due to the impossibility of reviewing the documents of several
presidents at once and the need to overcome large from the state for
acquaintance with archival materials [11, p. 248].
ISSN 2224-9516. Scientific works of the National Library of Ukraine named after VI Vernadsky. 2020. Vip. 60
cation of financial income to the funds of presidential libraries [13]. The issue
of the maturity of presidential donations was raised by the Obama
Presidential Library Foundation, which stated that 68 donors donated more
than $ 1 million, while did not disclose their data. The jury also noted in a
letter from K. Evers-Hilstrum that donors include good funds and, therefore,
a real source of contribution to the house [7].
Legislators demanded not only the disclosure of donations to presidential
funds, but also the limitation of their number, as libraries are becoming
increasingly financially costly for the federal budget. The Law on Presidential
Libraries of 1986 introduced a mandatory share of NARA compensation
from the funds of presidential libraries in the amount of 20% of the
construction amount. and equipping the premises for storage and use of
library and archival funds. Later, in 2008, according to the Law on
Preservation of Presidential Historical Documents, the share of compensation
was increased to 60%, but it should take effect from the presidency. B.
Obama [16]. In addition, since 1986, restrictions on the location of up to 70
thousand square meters have been introduced. feet, which was transferred
to NARA. However, George W. Bush was able to circumvent these
restrictions and build a library that exceeded the law, but transferred only
69.99 square meters to NARA. feet [5].
Historian A. Clark notes that over time (after declining attention to the
post of President), large areas of presidential libraries are transformed into
"empty tombs". Federal funds are needed to maintain them, but these
premises are used by the President's private funds to promote the individual
president, and not always the object. in relation to the historical reality.
According to the statistical data of the analytical services of the Congress,
in the first year of operation of the Presidential Library, its average attendance
is about 300 thousand visitors, but for over the next five years, this number
decreases by more than 36% [16]. Thus, the maintenance of cumbersome
premises falls on the shoulders of American taxpayers, and they cannot
influence the domestic policy of presidential libraries, as well as museum
and about secular activities carried out in the interests of certain politicians.
A. Clark also notes that over the last decade, presidential library funds,
using the political weight of ex-presidents, have influenced hearings in the
Congress on Presidents. libraries, as well as the appointment of NARA
officials and deadlines from open access to presidential documents [5].
Therefore, the system of presidential libraries in the United States has
remained unchanged until recently.
68
Machine Translated by Google
ISSN 2224-9516. Scientific works of the National Library of Ukraine named after VI Vernadsky. 2020. Vip. 60
in washing tone. The Obama Foundation finances their scans and systems
[8].
Obama Foundation Executive Director R. Cohen was one of the factors
that influenced the decision to create a private digital presidential library:
increasing NARA's share of compensation from the President up to 60% of
the Children's Fund in accordance with the law from 2008, as well as the rules
of access to archival documents from NARA. For example, researchers do
not have access to the original documents if there is a digital copy. Thus, as
R. Cohen points out, even if the Presidential Library of B. Obama preserved
paper originals, after their digitization - access to them still remained digital.
roÿ vim [14].
Thus, for the long history of the Presidential Library System in the United
States and the ongoing discussions on the model of its operation, NARA,
thanks to the development of information technology He found the most
optimal model of the Presidential Library in the form of the future Presidential
Library of Obama. The new model ensures the preservation of documentary
information resources of the Institute of Presidency in one place and the
provision of digital access to them through the world wide web, and also
reduces the costs of the federation. of the budget for the maintenance of the
building of the separate presidential library and maintenance of its funds,
because the placement of the new Presidential Library or the Presidential
Center will increase owned by the President's Fund. However, in the new
environment, NARA, even formally, cannot influence the policy of the new
presidential library, its cultural and educational activities and the coverage of
the post of the US president and the period. his rights laziness. Today,
presidential libraries, museums, and funds are being organized in many parts
of the world to preserve both the documentary heritage of the head of state
and to promote it. its research and popularization, and therefore, the American
experience is valuable for researchers and staff of these institutions.
4. Chepurenko Ya. O. Legal support of the formation of funds and the use of
information and resources of the Presidential Libraries of the United States. Archive
Of Ukraine. 2001. ÿ 4–5. Pp. 136–149.
5. Clark A. What you don’t know about presidential libraries – and the scandalous
way in which they are operated. URL: https://historynewsnetwork.
org/article/161804.
6. Cox R. J. America’s pyramids: Presidents and their libraries. Government
Information Quarterly. 2002. Vol. 19, no. 1. pp. 45–75. https://doi.org/10.1016/
S0740–624 X(01)00094–6.
7. Evers-Hillstrom K. Shining a light on presidential libraries – the unrenowned pay-
to-play. URL: https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2019/03/
shining-a-light-on-presidential-libraries-the-unrenowned-pay-to-play-scandal.
8. Fact Sheet: The Obama Presidential Archives. URL: https://www.obama.
org/updates/obama-presidential-archives-fact-sheet.
9. Fawcett S. K. Presidential Libraries: A View from the Center.
The Public Historian. 2006. Vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 13–36. https://doi.org/10.1525/
tph.2006.8.3.13.
10. Frink J. S. The George Bush Presidential library center at Texas A and M
University. URL: https://oaktrust.library.tamu.edu/bitstream/
handle/1969.1/ETD–TAMU–2009–08–7026/FRINK–DISSERTATION.
pdf?sequence=3&isAllowed=y.
11. Gallina T. J. The Future of Presidential Lbraries: Assessing Alter native
Models from a Legal Research Perspective. Legal Reference Services Quarterly.
2010. Vol. 29, no. 4. pp. 229–254. https://doi.org/10.1080/027031
9 X.2010.527780.
12. Glennon M. The Obama Center Can Aff ord More Than $1 Rent. URL:
https://historynewsnetwork.org/article/169772.
13. H. R. 1063–Presidential Library Donation Reform Act of 2019. URL:
https://www.congress.gov/bill/116 th-congress/house-bill/1063.
14. Schuessler J. The Obama Presidential Library That Isn’t. URL: https://
www.nytimes.com/2019/02/20/arts/obama-presidential-center-library national-
archives-and-records-administration.html.
15. Testimony of David S. Ferriero Archivist of the United States before the House
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure and the House Committee on
oversight and government reform on «Presidential libraries: their missions and future
direction». URL: http://www.archives.gov/congress/
testimonies/house-transportation-oversight-pres-lib-hearing-archivist-tes timony-02–
28–2011.pdf.
16. The Presidential Libraries Act and the Establishment of Presidential
71
Machine Translated by Google
ISSN 2224-9516. Scientific works of the National Library of Ukraine named after VI Vernadsky. 2020. Vip. 60
References
3. Prezidentskaia biblioteka Baraka Obamy uzhe stala tcifrovoi [The Presi dential
Library of Barack Obama has already become digital]. (2019). novos tiliteratury.ru.
Retrieved from https://novostiliteratury.ru/2019/04/novosti/
prezidentskaya-biblioteka-baraka-obamy-uzhe-stala-cifrovoj [in Russian].
4. Chepurenko, Ya. O. (2001). Pravove zabezpechennia formuvannia fondiv ta
vykorystannia informatsiinykh resursiv prezydentskykh bibliotek SShA [Legal Basis
for Collection Development and Use of Information Resources by US Presidential
Libraries]. Arkhivy Ukraine – Archives of Ukraine, 4–5,
136–149 [in Ukrainian].
5. Clark, A. (2016). What you don’t know about presidential libraries – and the
scandalous way in which they are operated. historynewsnetwork.org.
Retrieved from https://historynewsnetwork.org/article/161804 [in English].
6. Cox, R. J. (2002). America’s pyramids: Presidents and their libraries.
The Government Information Quarterly, 19(1), 45–75 [in English]. https://doi.
org/10.1016/S0740–624 X(01)00094-6.
7. Evers-Hillstrom, K. (2019). Shining a light on presidential libraries – the
unrenowned pay-to-play scandal. opensecrets.org. Retrieved March 13, 2019 from
https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2019/03/shining-a-light-on presidential-libraries-
the-unrenowned-pay-to-play-scandal [in English].
8. Fact Sheet: The Obama Presidential Archives (2019). obama.org.
Retrieved from https://www.obama.org/updates/obama-presidential-archives fact-
sheet [in English].
9. Fawcett, S. K. (2006). Presidential libraries: A view from the center. The Public
Historian, 28(3), 13–36 [in English]. https://doi.org/10.1525tph.2006.28.3.13.
10. Frink, J. S. (2010). The George Bush Presidential Library Center at Texas A
and M University (Doctoral dissertation, Texas A & M University).
72
Machine Translated by Google
Volodymyr Udovyk,
PhD (History), Senior Researcher,
V. I. Vernadsky National Library of Ukraine
3 Holosiivskyi Ave., Kyiv 03039, Ukraine
email: udovik@ukr.net
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7749-8095
Presidential Libraries of the USA: Historical Discussions and Trends
The study is related to the study of the forms of organization of the formation and
preservation of the documentary heritage of the US presidents, and examines historical
discussions and modern views on the prospects of organizing the activities of presiden
tial libraries, including the change of a sustainable model, formed in the late 1930 s.
73
Machine Translated by Google
ISSN 2224-9516. Scientific works of the National Library of Ukraine named after VI Vernadsky. 2020. Vip. 60
Today the US Presidential Library System consists of 14 Presidential libraries that are integrated into the
Presidential Library System and administered by The U. S. National Archives and Records Administration. The
scientifi c novelty of the work is the cover age of discussions among American archivists, librarians and politicians
which touched various approaches to organization preservation and popularization of the documentary heritage of
the presidential power. The article discusses the idea of introducing a new type of presidential library in digital
format. Researchers note that presidential library collections lobby parliamentary committees to preserve the
traditional system of presi dential libraries and prevent its reform. But with the development of information tech
nologies, in the United States a new model of the Presidential Library is emerging, in the form of the forthcoming
Obama Presidential Library, ensuring that the docu mentary information resources of presidency are stored in one
place and provided digi tal access to them through Internet. And also new model reduces the federal budget’s
costs for maintaining a separate presidential library, since the new building of the new Presidential Library will be
fully owned by the Obama Foundation and maintain at its expenses. Today, many countries establish presidential
libraries and museums that are intended to preserve Presidents documentary legacies and enable its promotion
Keywords: USA; the president and; pres i de ntial lib rary; ob ama presi dential rid and .
74