14/02/2023, 19:15 Brazil dam collapse: five arrested including three mining firm staff | Brazil | The Guardian

Brazil

This article is more than 4 years old

Brazil dam collapse: five arrested including

three mining firm staff
Three employees of Vale and two subcontracted engineers held
over Brumadinho disaster

01:08

Rescuers sift through toxic mud in search of Brazil dam victims – video report

Dom Phillips in Brumadinho

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/29/brazil-dam-collapse-brumadinho-five-arrested-including-three-mining-firm-staff 1/6
14/02/2023, 19:15 Brazil dam collapse: five arrested including three mining firm staff | Brazil | The Guardian

Tue 29 Jan 2019 15.17 GMT

Brazilian police have arrested five people in an investigation into the

causes of the Brumadinho dam disaster.

The dam break on Friday at an iron ore mining complex operated by the
minerals firm Vale killed at least 65 people, and a further 279 are missing.

Federal and state prosecutors said 30-day arrest warrants had been issued
“aiming to establish criminal responsibility for the rupture of dams at the
Córrego de Feijão mine maintained by Vale”.

Arrests were carried out in São Paulo and Belo Horizonte on Tuesday
morning, prosecutors said. Searches were carried out at a Vale building in
Nova Lima and a subcontracted company in São Paulo that provided
services and consultancy to Vale.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/29/brazil-dam-collapse-brumadinho-five-arrested-including-three-mining-firm-staff 2/6
14/02/2023, 19:15 Brazil dam collapse: five arrested including three mining firm staff | Brazil | The Guardian

Before After

“Three Vale employees directly employed and responsible were arrested.

In addition, subcontracted engineers who recently attested to the stability
of the dam were arrested,” the prosecutors said.

Last Friday, after the dam broke, Vale said it had “declarations of the
condition of stability” from TÜV SÜD, a German company with
headquarters in São Paulo, given on 13 June and 26 September last year.

The news site G1 named the arrested engineers as Makoto Namba and
André Yum Yassuda. It said Namba, a civil engineer and geo-technician,
was one of the signatories to the September declaration of stability.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/29/brazil-dam-collapse-brumadinho-five-arrested-including-three-mining-firm-staff 3/6
14/02/2023, 19:15 Brazil dam collapse: five arrested including three mining firm staff | Brazil | The Guardian

Another news site, R7, named the Vale employees held as Rodrigo de
Melo, Ricardo de Oliveira and César Granchamp. It said Granchamp also
signed the September declaration.

In a statement, TÜV SÜD said its Brazilian arm had

carried out two assessments at the dam on behalf of Vale: “a periodic
review of dam safety (June 2018) and one regular inspection of dam safety
(September 2018). Due to ongoing investigations TÜV SÜD Brasil cannot
comment further on this case at the moment. The company collaborates
with the authorities providing all requested information.”

Its website says TÜV SÜD is the “the world’s No 1 brand of choice for
premium quality, safety and sustainability solutions that add tangible
value to your business”.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/29/brazil-dam-collapse-brumadinho-five-arrested-including-three-mining-firm-staff 4/6
14/02/2023, 19:15 Brazil dam collapse: five arrested including three mining firm staff | Brazil | The Guardian

Before After

Vale said on Tuesday it was fully cooperating with the authorities and
would continue to support the investigations into the disaster.

Three years ago, a similar disaster in the same state, Minas Gerais, at a
mine run by Samarco, a joint-venture between Vale and BHP Billiton,

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/29/brazil-dam-collapse-brumadinho-five-arrested-including-three-mining-firm-staff 5/6
14/02/2023, 19:15 Brazil dam collapse: five arrested including three mining firm staff | Brazil | The Guardian

killed 19 people, poisoned the drinking water of hundreds of thousands

and sent mining waste down the river Doce to the sea.

Brazil’s regional development minister, Gustavo Canuto, said on Tuesday

that nearly 4,000 dams in Brazil were classified as having “high damage
potential” or being at high risk. He added that 205 of those dams
contained mineral waste,

Most viewed

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/29/brazil-dam-collapse-brumadinho-five-arrested-including-three-mining-firm-staff 6/6