Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://jdr.sagepub.com/
Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com
On behalf of:
International and American Associations for Dental Research
Additional services and information for Journal of Dental Research can be found at:
Subscriptions: http://jdr.sagepub.com/subscriptions
Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav
Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
What is This?
Downloaded from jdr.sagepub.com at University of Hong Kong Libraries on October 22, 2014 For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION
Since considerable shrinkage stress develops
during the curing of dental composites, various
soft-start photocuring protocols, aiming to lower
D imethacrylate-based dental restorative composites have become
increasingly popular with the support of facile photopolymerization
techniques. Highly crosslinked polymeric restorations with excellent tooth-
stress but not compromise conversion, have been like appearance are formed on command under ambient conditions.
proposed. We hypothesized that utilizing soft-start However, constrained shrinkage during polymerization densification
photocuring will result in not only reduced stress, generates polymerization shrinkage stress, which is one of the most
but also decreased conversion. We evaluated the significant concerns during the highly technique-sensitive clinical placement
impact of 3 protocols (soft-start, pulse, and of composite restorations (Carvalho et al., 1996; Davidson and Feilzer,
standard) on the stress development and 1997). Although polymerization shrinkage has been significantly reduced in
polymerization extent of an experimental modern dental composite formulations, largely through the addition of
composite. A novel set-up capable of inorganic filler, the induced shrinkage stress remains too high to allow direct
simultaneous shrinkage stress, conversion, and filling to be applied in some large posterior restorations (Dietschi and
temperature measurements on the same specimen Krejci, 2001).
was utilized. Analysis of the data shows that stress Since the detrimental shrinkage stress tremendously weakens the
rises dramatically as a function of conversion in performance and longevity of dental composites, numerous approaches have
the vitrified state, and the utilization of soft-start been proposed to decrease and minimize the shrinkage stress through
or pulse curing results in specimens with reduced manipulation of curing protocols and placement techniques. Among these
final conversion and shrinkage stress, compared approaches, soft-start curing (irradiation begins with a low-intensity,
with specimens cured according to the standard followed by a full-light intensity) and pulse curing (similar to soft-start
full-intensity protocol. Finally, this study curing except that a dark interval is included between the initial low-
demonstrates that the predominant reason for the intensity and the following full-intensity curing) have attracted extensive
reduced shrinkage stress attained with soft-start or investigations. One hypothesis for advocating these types of curing
pulse curing is a modest decrease in final protocols is that the initial low-light intensity could facilitate a certain
conversion. degree of polymer chain relaxation, such that a portion of the shrinkage
stress relaxes while the system has not yet reached the vitrification stage. It
KEY WORDS: shrinkage stress, conversion, curing has been claimed that the soft-start curing method partially relieves
protocol, dental composite. shrinkage stress, and achieves improved integrity of the composite/tooth
interface, without compromising the final double-bond conversion or
mechanical properties of the cured dental composite (Uno and Asmussen,
1991; Feilzer et al., 1995; Mehl et al., 1997; Lim et al., 2002). However,
whether this approach significantly reduces shrinkage stress without
decreasing the final conversion and mechanical properties is still under
extensive debate, and the real benefit of soft-start curing has not being
confirmed clinically (Friedl et al., 2000; Asmussen and Peutzfeldt, 2003;
Soh and Yap, 2004).
One reason leading to this perplexity is that the interrelationships among
double-bond conversion, polymerization rate, and polymerization shrinkage
stress in composite dental restoratives are not well-understood. Since the
double-bond conversion is related directly to the amount of polymerization
shrinkage (Patel et al., 1987) and the material's mechanical properties
Received December 15, 2003; Last revision May 17, 2005; (Lovell et al., 2003; Steeman et al., 2004), it is crucial that one follow the
Accepted June 1, 2005
real-time conversion while monitoring the shrinkage stress development of
A supplemental appendix to this article is published the same specimen. In evaluations of the effects of various curing protocols
electronically only at http://www.dentalresearch.org. on conversion and shrinkage stress development, it can be misleading if the
822 Downloaded from jdr.sagepub.com at University of Hong Kong Libraries on October 22, 2014 For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
conversion measurement and shrinkage stress measurement are NIR spectra by configuring 2 optical fibers (wavelength from 350
performed on different specimens, or the two measurements are to 2400 nm) to a Fourier transform-infrared spectrophotometer
performed at different times, since slight differences in sample (Nexus 670, Nicolet Instrument, Madison, WI, USA) through a
size, configuration, or irradiation conditions can significantly NIR fiberport. During the dynamic measurement of stress
diminish the validity of a direct correlation of the data from evolution, NIR signal was transmitted via fiber optic cables (1 mm
these two distinct experiments. Unfortunately, this aspect has diameter) through the diameter aspect of the specimen mounted in
been overlooked in most studies associated with curing the tensometer. Conversion was monitored by real-time NIR in
protocol and shrinkage stress, not to mention in numerous other series collection mode, with a temporal resolution of 0.46 sec
studies where the assessment of double-bond conversion was between spectrum collections. The series run collects peak area
not performed at all. data from the region of 6232 to 6101 cm-1, so that the decay of the
In this investigation, we hypothesized that utilizing soft- methacrylate double-bond concentration during polymerization can
start curing would result in not only reduced shrinkage stress, be monitored. A detailed description of this simultaneous
but also decreased double-bond conversion. The impact of measurement technique has been discussed previously (Lu et al.,
three photocuring protocols (soft-start, pulse, and standard) on 2004b), and illustrations are also available online as Appendices.
simultaneous stress and conversion development was examined Curing Protocols
with a novel experimental technique that is capable of
measuring the real-time stress and conversion concurrently on We used a halogen dental lamp, variable intensity polymerizer
the same specimen. The results were further elucidated (VIP, BISCO, Schaumburg, IL, USA), to introduce the different
regarding fundamental relationships among polymerization curing protocols. The quartz rod ends were treated with silane
kinetics, network evolution, temperature change, and shrinkage bonding agent to ensure stable adhesion to the composite specimen
stress development. during photopolymerization. Light intensity at the specimen
interface of the lower quartz rod, which is used to conduct the
curing light, was measured with a radiometer (Model 100,
MATERIALS & METHODS Demetron Research, Danbury, CT, USA). Three different curing
protocols were investigated: STAN_irradiate at a constant light
Materials
intensity of 450 mW/cm2 for 60 sec; SOFT_start at 100 mW/cm2
An experimental composite containing 70 wt% resin and 30 wt% for the first 5 sec, followed immediately by another 60 sec of
silanized filler was used in this study. Since stress is predicated on irradiation at 450 mW/cm2; and PULSE_start at 100 mW/cm2 for
the shrinkage of the resin component, the filler used was the first 5 sec, wait for 2 min, then irradiate for another 60 sec at
minimized for a clear indication of how various clinically used 450 mW/cm 2 . All experiments were performed at ambient
photo-curing protocols may affect the development of stress. The temperature (23 ± 1°C). The internal temperature of the composite
resin was composed of 2,2-bis[4-(2-hydroxy-3-methacryloxyprop- during polymerization was monitored with an embedded K-type
1-oxy)phenyl]propane (Bis-GMA, Esstech, Essington, PA, USA) miniature thermocouple (diameter 0.127 mm; Omega Engineering,
and the reactive diluent triethyleneglycol dimethacrylate Stamford, CT, USA). For each set of experiments, 3 replicate runs
(TEGDMA, Polysciences, Warrington, PA, USA) at 70:30 weight were conducted. Results were analyzed by one-way analysis of
ratio, along with 0.3 wt% camphorquinone (CQ, Aldrich Chemical, variance (ANOVA) and Tukey's HSD post hoc test, with a
Milwaukee, WI, USA) as the visible-light initiator and 0.8 wt% significance level of 0.05.
ethyl 4-dimethylaminobenzoate (EDAB, Aldrich Chemical) as the
co-initiator. A nanofiller (OX-50, Degussa AM, Frankfurt,
Germany) was selected to maintain a relatively high degree of RESULTS
translucency in the uncured and cured composite materials. The As revealed in conversion vs. time plots for specimens cured
filler was treated with 5 wt% silane coupling agent ␥ - with the three protocols—STAN, SOFT, and PULSE (Fig.
methacryloxypropyl trimethoxysilane (Aldrich Chemical), before 1a)—polymerization proceeds rapidly, and specimens cured in
being blended with the Bis-GMA/TEGDMA resin. All chemicals STAN mode reached the highest final conversion (at 20 min
were used as received. from the start of irradiation), with an average of 67.5 ± 2.4%.
Specimens cured with the SOFT protocol achieved an average
Simultaneous Shrinkage Stress of 61.9 ± 0.4% final conversion, while specimens cured in
and Conversion Measurement PULSE mode reached an average of 60.4 ± 0.7% final
The shrinkage stress measurement device, referred to as a conversion. Between SOFT and PULSE curing protocols, no
tensometer, was designed and fabricated at the Paffenbarger statistically significant difference for final conversion was
Research Center of the American Dental Association Health found (Table).
Foundation. This device is based on the cantilever beam theory Shrinkage stress development as a function of time is
that tensile force generated by a shrinking sample causes the presented in Fig. 1b. The final shrinkage stress values obtained
cantilever of known beam constant to deflect. The shrinkage stress with the STAN, SOFT, and PULSE curing protocols were 2.18
is then obtained by dividing the shrinkage force by the cross- ± 0.04 MPa, 1.87 ± 0.03 MPa, and 1.77 ± 0.08 MPa,
sectional area of the disk-shaped sample (6.0 mm in diameter and respectively (Table). Compared with the final shrinkage stress
2.5 mm in thickness). The detailed description, experimental of specimens cured with STAN mode, the final shrinkage stress
procedure, and characterization of the tensometer have been of SOFT and PULSE specimens decreased significantly, by
discussed in previous papers (Lu et al., 2004a,b). 14% and 19%, respectively. However, as noted, their final
In situ, real-time monitoring of the polymerization kinetics is conversions are also significantly lower than the final
enabled by means of near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy, coupled conversion obtained in STAN mode.
with a fiber optic remote sensing technique. We obtained serial As shown in real-time temperature vs. time profiles (Fig.
Downloaded from jdr.sagepub.com at University of Hong Kong Libraries on October 22, 2014 For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Downloaded from jdr.sagepub.com at University of Hong Kong Libraries on October 22, 2014 For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
REFERENCES Lovell LG, Newman SM, Donaldson MM, Bowman CN (2003). The
effect of light intensity on double bond conversion and flexural
Anseth KS, Kline LM, Walker TA, Anderson KJ, Bowman CN strength of a model, unfilled dental resin. Dent Mater 19:458-465.
(1995a). Reaction kinetics and volume relaxation during Lu H, Stansbury JW, Dickens SH, Eichmiller FC, Bowman CN
polymerizations of multiethylene glycol dimethacrylates. (2004a). Probing the origins and control of shrinkage stress in
Macromolecules 28:2491-2499. dental resin-composites: I. Shrinkage stress characterization
Anseth KS, Newman SM, Bowman CN (1995b). Polymeric dental technique. J Mater Sci-Mater M 15:1097-1103.
composites: properties and reaction behavior of multimethacrylate Lu H, Stansbury JW, Dickens SH, Eichmiller FC, Bowman CN
dental restorations. Adv Polym Sci 122:177-217. (2004b). Probing the origins and control of shrinkage stress in
Asmussen E, Peutzfeldt A (2003). Two-step curing: influence on dental resin composites. II. Novel method of simultaneous
conversion and softening of a dental polymer. Dent Mater 19:466- measurement of polymerization shrinkage stress and conversion. J
470. Biomed Mater Res B 71:206-213.
Bowman CN, Anseth KS (1995). Microstructural evolution in Lu H, Stansbury JW, Bowman CN (2004c). Towards the elucidation of
polymerizations of tetrafunctional monomers. Macromol Symp shrinkage stress development & relaxation in dental composites.
93:269-276. Dent Mater 20:979-986.
Carvalho RM, Pereira JC, Yoshiyama M, Pashley DH (1996). A Macosko CW, Miller DR (1976). A new derivation of average
review of polymerization contraction: the influence of stress molecular-weights of nonlinear polymers. Macromolecules 9:199-
development versus stress relief. Oper Dent 21:17-24. 206.
Davidson CL, Feilzer AJ (1997). Polymerization shrinkage and Maffezzoli A, Terzi R (1998). Effect of irradiation intensity on the
polymerization shrinkage stress in polymer-based restoratives. J isothermal photopolymerization kinetics of acrylic resins for
Dent 25:435-440. stereolithography. Thermochim Acta 321:111-121.
Decker C (1996). Photoinitiated crosslinking polymerisation. Prog Mehl A, Hickel R, Kunzelmann KH (1997). Physical properties and
Polym Sci 21:593-650. gap formation of light-cured composites with and without 'soft
Dietschi D, Krejci I (2001). Adhesive restorations in posterior teeth: start-polymerization'. J Dent 25:321-330.
rationale for the application of direct techniques. Oper Dent Odian G (1991). Principles of polymerization. 3rd ed. New York: John
26:191-197. Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Feilzer AJ, Dooren LH, de Gee AJ, Davidson CL (1995). Influence of Patel MP, Braden M, Davy KW (1987). Polymerization shrinkage of
light-intensity on polymerization shrinkage and integrity of methacrylate esters. Biomaterials 8:53-56.
restoration-cavity interface. Eur J Oral Sci 103:322-326. Sakaguchi RL, Shah NC, Lim BS, Ferracane JL, Borgersen SE (2002).
Ferracane JL (1995). Current trends in dental composites. Crit Rev Dynamic mechanical analysis of storage modulus development in
Oral Biol Med 6:302-318. light-activated polymer matrix composites. Dent Mater 18:197-
Friedl KH, Schmalz G, Hiller KA, Markl A (2000). Marginal adaption 202.
of Class V restorations with and without "softstart- Soh MS, Yap AU (2004). Influence of curing modes on crosslink
polymerization". Oper Dent 25:26-32. density in polymer structures. J Dent 32:321-326.
Kloosterboer JG (1988). Network formation by chain crosslinking Stansbury JW, Dickens SH (2001a). Network formation and
photopolymerization and its applications in electronics. Adv Polym compositional drift during photo-initiated copolymerization of
Sci 84:1-61. dimethacrylate monomers. Polymer 42:6363-6369.
Lange J (1999). Viscoelastic properties and transitions during thermal Stansbury JW, Dickens SH (2001b). Determination of double bond
and UV cure of a methacrylate resin. Polym Eng Sci 39:1651-1660. conversion in dental resins by near infrared spectroscopy. Dent
Lim BS, Ferracane JL, Sakaguchi RL, Condon JR (2002). Reduction Mater 17:71-79.
of polymerization contraction stress for dental composites by two- Steeman PAM, Dias AA, Wienke D, Zwartkruis T (2004).
step light-activation. Dent Mater 18:436-444. Polymerization and network formation of UV-curable systems
Lovell LG, Newman SM, Bowman CN (1999). The effects of light monitored by hyphenated real-time dynamic mechanical analysis
intensity, temperature, and comonomer composition on the and near-infrared spectroscopy. Macromolecules 37:7001-7007.
polymerization behavior of dimethacrylate dental resins. J Dent Uno S, Asmussen E (1991). Marginal adaptation of a restorative resin
Res 78:1469-1476. polymerized at reduced rate. Scand J Dent Res 99:440-444.
Downloaded from jdr.sagepub.com at University of Hong Kong Libraries on October 22, 2014 For personal use only. No other uses without permission.