Professional Documents
Culture Documents
130
115
35
5 10 10 10 0
Communication Innovation Knowledge Risk
Impact
Organisation
MERCER
Complexity Teams Environment
Contribution Breadth
Frame
10
IPE Methodology Overview
Position Class
Total Point Range Position Class Total Point Range Position Class Total Point Range Position Class
26 - 50 40 426 - 450 56 826 - 850 72
51 - 75 41 451 - 475 57 851 - 875 73
76 - 100 42 476 - 500 58 876 - 900 74
101 - 125 43 501 - 525 59 901 - 925 75
126 - 150 44 526 - 550 60 926 - 950 76
151 - 175 45 551 - 575 61 951 - 975 77
176 - 200 46 576 - 600 62 976 - 1000 78
201 - 225 47 601 - 625 63 1001 - 1025 79
226 - 250 48 626 - 650 64 1026 - 1050 80
251 - 275 49 651 - 675 65 1051 - 1075 81
276 - 300 50 676 - 700 66 1076 - 1100 82
301 - 325 51 701 - 725 67 1101 - 1125 83
326 - 350 52 726 - 750 68 1126 - 1150 84
351 - 375 53 751 - 775 69 1151 - 1175 85
375 - 400 54 776 - 800 70 1176 - 1200 86
401 - 425 55 801 - 825 71 1201 - 1225 87
General Staff
MERCER
Professional
Management
Top Management
11
Impact Factor
MERCER
Impact Factor
Overview
- Determining the type of impact the position holder has on the organisation
13
Impact Factor
Organisation
Impact
Contribution
MERCER
14
Impact Factor
Organisation Dimension
MERCER
27
Sizing an Organisation
Step 2: Determine Nature of Organisation and Calculate Multiplier
in eIPE System
From Economic volume (Net Sales Turnover, Assets) To final
origin Number of employees (Capital or People intensive) consumer
MERCER
Sizing an Organisation
Step 2: Determine Nature of Organisation and Calculate Multiplier
in eIPE System
From Economic volume (Net Sales Turnover, Assets) To final
origin Number of employees (Capital or People intensive) consumer
MERCER
Sizing an Organisation
What major steps in the products organization generates added-value
Primary research. Typically includes basic research and development activities where the
Basic Research eventual product and/or market potential is unknown. Generally characterized by a
1 4.0
& Development relatively modest rate of success (e.g., 20% of research eventually results in new products).
Product Development
Product development. Includes targeted R&D activities to develop a specific new product
or enhancement of an existing product where the eventual market potential is more
2
Applied Research 2.0
& Development defined.
Typically includes development of preliminary product specifications and pre-
production prototypes. Go-to-market decisions are generally made at this stage of
development.
1.5
Production design. Final engineering of production-ready specifications and
3 Engineering manufacturing processes.
Supply. Specific function responsible for obtaining manufacturing inputs, including raw
materials and intermediate manufactured products. Generally responsible for all contract 2.0
Procurement / negotiation, vendor management and spot market transactions. Supply management.
4
Inbound Logistic Management of inbound materials, including delivery scheduling, transportation, warehousing
and inventory management.
Production
Basic manufacturing. Production of intermediate or final goods from raw materials. May 2.0
include intermediate manufactured products as part of the production process. Characterised
5 Production by the conversion of materials to a new product with different characteristics (e.g., molding of
plastic into auto parts).
Assembly of previously manufactured goods for market. Includes final assembly and packaging 2.5
6 Application/Assembly of two or more manufactured products (e.g., assembly of auto parts into a complete
automobile). May include limited intermediate finishing of inputs.
1.0
Independent of sales. Function responsible for internal market analysis and planning
7 Marketing and external communications, such as public relations, advertising and marketing
1.5
Sales and Service
collateral.
MERCER Excluding marketing. Includes management of direct and indirect sales forces. Does
8 Sales
not include oversight of third-party distributors. 1.5
Outbound logistics. Includes warehousing and outbound transportation of goods to third-
9 Distribution
party distributors and/or final customers. 2.0
After-sale service. Includes customer call centres and repair, service and support. Service
10 Service
may be offered on warranty, contract or fee-for-service basis. 19
Sizing an Organisation
What major steps in the services organization generates added-value
Intellectual capital and/or technology development. Typically includes basic research
and development activities where the eventual service and/or market potential for that
Development
Product
Service definition. Includes the development of the service that will be offered and the
2 Generate Application specifics around that service, such as tools and processes for service delivery. May 2.0
also include the development of new markets for existing service lines.
s
Operation
Independent of sales. Function responsible for internal market analysis and planning
4 Marketing 1.5
and external communications, such as public relations, advertising and marketing
collateral.
5 Sales Excluding marketing. Includes management of direct and indirect sales forces. 3.0
Sales and Service
7 Customer Service Support. Includes customer call centers and post-service support. 1.5
MERCER
20
Sizing an Organisation
Step 2: Value chain weighting in eIPE System
MERCER
Sizing an Organisation
Step 3: Calculate the adjusted revenue
4.0 2.0 1.5 2.0 2.0 2.5 1.0 1.5 1.5 2.0
¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ¨
Example: Sales & Technical Service Organisation with 150 head count
Sales Volume: US$ 40 million
Multiplier: 6
Adjusted Revenue: US$ 240 million Economic
Size
Reference to the Economic Size Table, Table
=>
MERCER
Degree level for Size : 4
22
Sizing an Organisation
Step 4: Determine degrees using adjusted revenue and no. of
employees with the organisation size table
Step 4b –
Determine
Step 4a – degree
Determine for # of
degree for employees
economic
size
MERCER
23
Sizing an Organisation
Calculated Degree Level
MERCER
24
Impact Factor
Organisation
Impact
Contribution
MERCER
Impact factor
Nature of Impact and Contribution Matrix in eIPE system - Example
Level of Contribution
1 2 3 4 5
NATURE OF
Limited Some Direct Significant Major
IMPACT
3 Tactical
4 Strategic
MERCER
5 Visionary
26
Impact factor: Impact dimension
Impact levels
Nature of
Area of Impact Type of Impact Impact
Within specific
Job area standards and 1. Delivery
guidelines
Within operational
Job Area(s) targets or service 2. Operational
standard
New products/
Business processes based on 3. Tactical
Unit/Function organisation strategy
Longer-term plans
Organisation level based on 4. Strategic
organisation vision
27
Impact dimension
Cascade from Group to Division and down to Business Unit level
Group Level
Visionary
Division
Level
Strategic
Business
Unit
MERCER Tactical
28
Impact Factor
Organisation
Impact
Contribution
MERCER
Impact factor: Contribution dimension
The spectrum of contribution levels
Level of Contribution
Limited Some Direct Significant Major
Propose Decide
Contribution must be assessed in the context of the impact level determined
Delivery Consider the level of autonomy within job area (e.g., Accounts Payable)
Operational Consider the level of autonomy within job or operational area (e.g., Accounting)
Tactical Consider the relative contribution to short- and mid-term functional or operational plans (e.g., Finance)
Strategic Consider the relative contribution to long-term business strategy
MERCER
30
Impact degree 5: Visionary
Contribution to organisation's vision
Subsidiaries / Free
Global Line of Business
Operational Companies Standing
Organisation
s
MERCER
31
Impact degree 4: Strategic
Contribution to organisation’s business strategy
Level of Contribution
< 10%
10 - 15%
15 - 20% 20 - 30% > 30%
MERCER
When evaluating Impact degree 3, “Tactical”, and 4, “Strategic”, establish the direct accountability for
qualitative and quantitative contribution to the organization’s overall result (100%).
32
Communication Factor
MERCER
Communication factor
Overview
- Defining the most difficult and challenging communication that the job holder encounters
- Determining how frequently the most difficult and challenging communication occurs
Frame
MERCER 46
Communication Factor
Communication
Frame
MERCER
Communication factor: Communication dimension
Communication levels
Statements, Understanding of
1. Convey
suggestions information
Acceptance of a
Affect change
concept, practice or 3. Influence
without commands
approach
Acceptance through
Strategic shorter- discussion and 4. Negotiate
term communication compromise
Important long-term
MERCER
Acceptance of 5. Negotiate Long
communication strategic agreement Term
48
Communication factor: Communication dimension
Frequency of communication
Level of
Frequency
Communication
1. Frequent
1. Convey
1.5 Continuous
Continuous
1.5 Occasional Daily
2. Adapt and Frequent
2. Frequent Regular but
Exchange
2.5 Continuous Occasional not daily
Few times a
2.5 Occasional month
3. Influence 3. Frequent
3.5 Continuous
3.5 Occasional
4. Negotiate 4. Frequent
4.5 Continuous
5. Negotiate Long
MERCER 4.5 Occasional
Term 5. Frequent
49
Communication Factor
Communication
Frame
MERCER
Communication factor: Frame dimension
Internal vs. external audience
Internal
External
MERCER 51
Communication factor: Frame dimension
Nature of interests
Shared Divergent
Common goals Conflicting objectives
Aligned interests Contradicting interests
Mutual desire Differing points of view
Willingly compromise Reluctantly compromise
Discuss Debate
Win-Win Risk of Win-Lose
MERCER 52
Communication factor: Frame dimension
Organisational frame
Frame
1 2 3 4
Intern Extern Internal External
al al Diverge Diverge
Share Shared nt nt
d
Interests Interests
Interests Interests
Interests Interests
Interests Interests
MERCER 53
Innovation Factor
MERCER
Innovation factor
Overview
Innovation relates to the requirements of the position to identify and make improvements to
procedures, services, or products.
Innovation also relates to the requirements to develop new ideas, methods, techniques,
services and products.
Complexity
MERCER 56
Innovation Factor
Innovation
Complexity
MERCER
Innovation factor: Innovation dimension
Overview
Constrained by • Follow
existing
policies • Check
Focused on • Modify
improvements • Improve
58
Which Degree of Innovation?
INNOVATION
Follow Limited changes expected from the position holder, eg. Accounts Clerk.
Check Make minor changes with help of existing procedures, processes, eg. HR Officer,
Accountant responsible for reconciliation, Quality control responsible for checking
products for defects on assembly line.
Modify Resolve issues / problems by modifying / enhancing existing working method, eg.
Accounting Manager responsible for changing accounting procedures in order to
reduce errors.
Change/prevent issues/ problems by significantly improve entire process systems
Improve or products eg. General Manager responsible for changing the organization to
reflect new environment conditions and corporate goals.
Create / Create new methods, techniques or products, eg. Position devising new financial
Conceptualize strategies to gain access to untapped sources of fund.
Scientific/Technical Develop new and unprecedented scientific or technical ideas, eg. High level
Breakthrough
MERCER research in R&D.
59
Innovation Factor
Innovation
Complexity
MERCER
Innovation factor: Complexity dimension
Levels of complexity
Complexity
Defined Difficult Complex Multi-dimensional
In either In either In any two of three In all three
Operational, Operational, dimensions i.e., dimensions -
Financial or Human Financial or Human Operational, Operational,
area - Easily area - Not easily Financial and Financial and
understood understood Human area Human
Involved directly in all
three dimensions
MERCER 62
Knowledge Factor
MERCER
Knowledge factor
Overview
Knowledge
Teams Breadth
MERCER 65
Knowledge Factor
Knowledge
Teams
Breadth
MERCER
Knowledge factor: Knowledge dimension
Levels of knowledge
67
Which degree of Knowledge ?
MERCER
Knowledge factor: Teams dimension
Team positions
Team positions
and and
MERCER
70
Team (Degree)
Typical Examples
71
Knowledge Factor
Knowledge
Teams
Breadth
MERCER
Knowledge factor: Breadth dimension
Breadth degrees
Domestic
Regional
Global Regional
Africa
MERCER
74
Knowledge factor: Breadth dimension
Location examples
Global
Multipl
Breadth Domestic Sub-Region Regional All major
e
time
Region
zones
s
Degree 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
Application
Locations within a
of
country or
knowledge Multiple countries Minimum two All regions of
neighbouring Continental region
with diverse Continental the world
countries with
Manage cultures regions
similar culture
and/or apply
results
locally
MERCER
75
Position Class
MERCER
Position class
Sample role: Regional sales manager
Degree Points
Size 12
Impact Impact 3 179
Contribution 2
Communication 3.5
Communication 88
Frame 4
Innovation 3
Innovation 45
Complexity 2
Knowledge 4
Knowledge Teams 2 130
Breadth 1.5
Total Points 442
Position Class ?
MERCER
77
Position class
Sample role: Regional sales manager (continued)
MERCER
78
Position class
Sample role: Regional sales manager
Degree Points
Size 12
Impact Impact 3 179
Contribution 2
Communication 3.5
Communication 88
Frame 4
Innovation 3
Innovation 45
Complexity 2
Knowledge 4
Knowledge Teams 2 130
Breadth 1.5
Total Points 442
Position Class 56
MERCER
79
#200++
voters
Comparative Study of Point Factor Method in Job Evaluation
Global Grading
International Position Evaluation System (GGS) Factor Evaluation JobLink AON Contoh di Juknis Permenaker No.1
Hay Job Evaluation (HJE) STRATA PWC World at Work
(IPE) Mercer Willis Tower System (FES) Hewitt Thn 2017
Watson (WTW)
Factor Sub-Factor Factor Dimension Factor Factor Sub-Factor Factor Factor Factor Faktor
Technical Functional Knowledge & Technical Preparation and Knowledge &
Know How Impact Organization Knowledge Keahlian
Knowledge Knowledge Skills Knowledge Training Application
Physical
Breadth
Environment
Sensory
Risk Risk
Attention