Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effect of Expiratory Flow Increase Technique On Pulmonary Function of Infants On Mechanical Ventilation
Effect of Expiratory Flow Increase Technique On Pulmonary Function of Infants On Mechanical Ventilation
10(4)213-221(2005)
DOI: 101002/pri.l5
Key words: critical care, expiratory flow increase technique (EFIT), paediatrics
Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd 10: 213-221 (2005)
214 Almeida et al.
mismatch and increased work of breathing 1975; Winning et al., 1975; Mackenzie et
(Oberwaldner, 2000). Several techniques al., 1980); and all diseases that required
can be used for the above-mentioned disor- invasive mechanical pulmonary ventilation
ders and an extensive search of the relevant (Mackenzie et al., 1978; Ruiz et al., 1999;
literature reveals various studies on their Arellano, 2001). These studies analysed
effectiveness. However, few studies refer to postural drainage, vibration, percussion,
patients on invasive mechanical pulmonary cough stimulation and suction, comparing
ventilation and there is no consensus about pulmonary function before and after appli-
the best technique indicated for this condi- cation of the techniques. Recently, some
tion. studies have also evaluated the use of
In the 1970s Barthe described a new manual hyperinflation in adult patients on
technique for removing secretion that is invasive mechanical pulmonary ventilation
referred to as the expiratory flow increase (Clarke et al., 1999; Hodgson et al., 2000;
technique (EFIT). It has been described as a Patman et al., 2000; Barker and Adams,
thoraco-abdominal movement performed 2002; Bemey and Denehy, 2002).
manually by the physiotherapist to clear Very few studies discuss the effects of
airway obstructions. EFIT is used in the chest physiotherapy techniques in children
paediatric intensive care unit (PICU) at the on invasive mechanical pulmonary ventila-
State University of Campinas Medical tion, and most of them refer to neonates
School, Brazil, as it does not require the (Fox et al., 1978; Zach et al., 1981; Reines
patient's collaboration and can easily be et al., 1982; Flenady and Gray, 2001; Main
applied to infants and young children or to et al., 2004; Main and Stocks, 2004). These
intubated patients. Although there are no studies suggest that beneficial effects can be
scientific studies validating this technique, achieved with the use of chest physiotherapy
it is currently the most commonly used tech- but, since they were conducted in children
nique of this kind in France (Conference de with different diseases, an overall analysis
Consensus sur la Kinesitherapie Respira- was impossible. The studies conducted by
toire, 1995). Nevertheless, among the Fox et al (1978), by Main et al (2004) and by
studies mentioning the use of EFIT in paedi- Main and Stocks (2004) measured
atric patients (Grosdemanche et al., 1972; pulmonary function with the objective of
Demont et al., 1991; Postiaux et al., 1991a; evaluating the effect of chest physiotherapy
Postiaux et al, 1991b; Postiaux et al., 1995; techniques.
Ribeiro et al., 2001), only two refer to its use Chest physiotherapy has been carried out
in patients on invasive mechanical in infants with respiratory diseases but some
pulmonary ventilation (Demont et al., 1996; authors do not recommend its use in cases
Bemard-Narbonne et al., 2003). of acute viral bronchiolitis (Perlstein et al.,
Studies have been published on the effect 1999; Oberwaldner, 2000; Kotagal et al.,
of other techniques in adult patients on inva- 2002). However, chest physiotherapy tech-
sive mechanical pulmonary ventilation for niques have not yet been studied in patients
the following conditions: acute lobar atelec- with acute viral bronchiolitis on invasive
tasis (Stiller et al., 1990); after cardiac mechanical pulmonary ventilation. The
surgery (Horiuchi et al., 1997); acute respi- study carried out by Webb et al (1985), in
ratory distress syndrome (Davis et al., infants with acute viral bronchiolitis, found
2001); respiratory failure (Brock-Utne et al.. no significant difference in the hospitaliza-
tion period between the group in which Exclusion criteria consisted of:
postural drainage, percussion and suction
were applied and the control group without • patients paralysed by curare
invasive mechanical pulmonary ventilation. • patients with haemodynamic instability,
Since the effectiveness of chest physio- neuromuscular diseases, cardiac
therapy techniques has not yet been scientif- diseases, post-operative patients, patients
ically proven in paediatric patients on with chronic pneumopathies, severe
invasive mechanical pulmonary ventilation, protein-caloric malnutrition or acute
studies need to be conducted in this popula- respiratory failure due to upper respira-
tion. The purpose of the present study was tory diseases
to evaluate the effect of EFIT on the • patients with chest radiography indi-
pulmonary function of infants on invasive cating atelectasis of more than one-third
mechanical pulmonary ventilation because ofthe lung
of acute obstructive respiratory failure. • patients with a positive end expiratory
pressure (PEEP) >10 cm H^^
METHOD
Materials and procedure
Study design
This was a prospective, non-randomized, Expiratory flow increase technique
non-controlled. Phase II study of infants The EFIT consisted of a passive expiration
who were intubated and ventilated. It was performed using the increase in expiratory
conducted in the PICU of the University flow to move the peripheral secretions of the
Hospital, State University of Campinas, bronchial tree towards the trachea. It was
Brazil, from April 2001 to April 2003. EFIT carried out with one hand on the child's chest
was carried out in all eligible patients. between the sternal furcula and an imaginary
The study was approved by the Institu- inter-mammary line. The hand was
tional Review Board prior to initiation and supported on its outer edge but the contact
the parents gave their written, informed surface varied according to the size of the
consent before their infants were enrolled inchild's chest. The other hand supported the
the study. abdominal region with the thumb and first
finger reaching the lower ribs. The physio-
Subjects therapist carried out EFIT by placing one
Subjects were included in the study if they hand on the patient's chest and applying
were: pressure symmetrically from top to bottom
and from front to back, while the other hand
• between 28 days and 12 months of age supported the upper abdominal region
• intubated and ventilated during the expiratory phase. The manoeuvre
• had a diagnosis of obstructive acute was repeated 40 times in all patients and was
respiratory failure made on the basis of followed by suction.
the following clinical and radiological
criteria: history of wheezing and
coughing; diffuse wheezes or prolonged Procedure
expiration during pulmonary ausculta- The patients were intubated using a non-
tion; and chest radiography with signs of cuffed tracheal tube with an internal diam-
air trapping. eter of 3.5-4.5 mm. The mechanical
at a mean of five minutes before and after During EFIT, patients showed no signs
the technique. of respiratory distress (retractions, nasal
The mean, standard deviation (SD) and flaring) decrease in oxygen saturation by
p values of the variables analysed in the pulse oximetry, bradycardia, tachycardia,
study are presented in Table 2. pneumothorax or bone fractures. All
patients evolved to extubation and were
A statistically significant increase was dischargedfromPICU.
observed in RR, SatO^and PaO/PAO^
values and a statistically significant DISCUSSION
decrease in P(A-a)O2/PaO2 after EFIT
(p<0.05). Similarly, no statistically signifi- In the present study there was no change in
cant difference was found in the mean PaOj or PaOj/FiO^ however, an improve-
values of PaO^, PaCO^, PaO/FiO^, VT • ment was observed in SatO^, V{K-a)0J?&0.^
VT^,^, VE, VA, VD^^, VD^,^, VD, VD/VT, and PaOj/PAOj following EFIT (p<0.05).
This suggests that EFIT improves certain
Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd 10: 213-221 (2005)
218 Almeida etal.
TABLE 2: Position and distribution measurements (mean 6 SD) of pulmonary function variables and compar-
ison of two evaluation times of 22 infants on invasive mechanical pulmonary ventilation, using analysis of vari-
ance corrected for weight
RR = respiratory rate; PaOj = arterial pressure of oxygen; PaCOj = arterial pressure of carbon dioxide;
PaOjFiOj = arterial pressure of oxygen/inspired fraction of oxygen ratio; P(A-a)Oj/PaO2 = alveolar-arterial
pressure difference of oxygen/arterial pressure of oxygen; PaO2/PAO2 = arterial pressure of oxygen/alveolar
pressure of oxygen; SatO^ = aterial saturation of oxygen; VT^^^ = expiratory tidal volume; VT^j^ = alveolar tidal
volume; VA = alveolar ventilation; VE = minute ventilation; VD^^ = airway dead space volume; VD , = alve-
olar dead space volume; VD = total dead space volume; VD/VT = dead space volume/tidal volume ratio; Rj__ =
inspiratory resistance; R^^^ = expiratory resistance; C^^^ = dynamic compliance.
*Level of significance <0.05.
Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd 10: 213-221 (2005)
Effect of EFIT on pulmonary function of infants on IMPV 221
Postiaux G, Ladha K, Lens E. Proposition d'une SAS System for Windows (Statistical Analysis
kinesitherapie respiratoire confortee par l'equa- System), versao 8.2. SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC,
tion de Rohrer. Annales Kinesitherapie 1995; 22: USA; 1999-2001.
342-354. Stiller K, Geake T, Taylor J, Grant R, Hall B. Acute
Randolph AG, Meert KL, O'Neil ME, Hanson JH, lobar atelectasis: a comparison of two chest phys-
Luckett PM, Amold JH et al. The feasibility of iotherapy regimens. Chest 1990; 98: 1336-1340.
conducting clinical trials in infants and children Webb MSC, Martin JA, Cartlidge PHT, Ng YK,
with acute respiratory failure. American Joumal Wright NA. Chest physiotherapy in acute bron-
of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine 2003; chiolitis. Archives of Disease in Childhood 1985;
167: 1334-1340. 60: 1078-1079.
Reines HD, Sade RM, Bradford BF. Chest physio- Winning TJ, Brock-Utne JG, Goodwin NM. A simple
therapy fails to prevent postoperative atelectasis clinical method of quantitating the effects ofchest
in children after cardiac surgery. Annals of physiotherapy in mechanically ventilated patients.
Surgery 1982; 195: 451-454. Anaesthesia and Intensive Care 1975; 3: 237-238.
Ribeiro MAGO, Cunha ML, Etchebehere ECC, Zach M, Oberwaldner B, Purrer B. Thoraxphysiother-
Camargo EE, Ribeiro JD, Condino Neto A. apeutische behandlung bronchopulmonaler
Effects of cisaprida and chest physical therapy on erkrankungen des kindesalters. Monatsschr
the gastroesophageal reflux of wheezing babies Kinderheilkd 1981; 129: 633-636. (abstract).
based on scintigraphy. Jomal de Pediatria (Rio de
Janeiro) 2001; 77: 393-400. Address correspondence to: Celize Cruz Bresciani
Ruiz VC, Oliveira LC, Borges F, Crocci AJ, Rugolo Almeida, Department of Pediatrics, State University
LMSS. Efeito da fisioterapia respiratoria conven- of Campinas Medical School, Rua Jasmim, n. 750,
cional e da manobra de aspirafao na resistencia e Torre 1, Apt. 84, Zip Code 13087-460, Campinas,
na satura^ao de O^ em pacientes submetidos a Sao Paulo, Brazil (E-mail: celize@directnet.com.br).
ventilagao mecanica. Acta Fisiatrica 1999; 6:
64-69. (Submitted January 2005; accepted July 2005)
Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd 10: 213-221 (2005)