Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BY
17/31QD020
SUPERVISOR
OCTOBER, 2021
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Case Study One (1): Guangzhou Opera House, Guangzhou, China ................................ 11
Case Study Two (2): Sydney Opera House, Sydney, Australia. ...................................... 22
Case Study Three (3): Harbin Opera House, Harbin, Heilongjiang, China ..................... 26
Case Study Four (4): The National Theatre Orile, Iganmu, Lagos. ................................. 32
Case Study Five (5): Obafemi Awolowo University Theatre, Ile-Ife, Osun. ................. 36
References ................................................................................................................................ 40
2
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 3.4: Floor Plan at level 0 meter of Guangzhou Opera House ....................................... 15
Figure 3.5: Floor Plan at level 5 meter of Guangzhou Opera House ....................................... 16
Figure 3.6: Floor Plan at level 11 meter of Guangzhou Opera House ..................................... 16
Figure 3.7: Floor Plan at level 16 meter of Guangzhou Opera House ..................................... 17
Figure 3.8: Floor Plan at level 16 meter of Guangzhou Opera House ..................................... 17
Figure 3.19: Second floor plan Figure 3.20: Roof plan ................................................. 29
3
LIST OF PLATES
Plate 3.8: Interior view of the hall Plate 3.9: Interior view of the hall ...................... 25
Plate 3.13: Interior views showing materials used for good acoustics .................................... 30
LIST OF TABLES
Table 3.1 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings. ......................... 21
Table 3.2 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings. ......................... 25
Table 3.3 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings. ......................... 31
Table 3.4 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings. ......................... 35
Table 3.5 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings. ......................... 38
4
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction
This chapter seeks to examine research methods on the subject matter of this thesis;
these being Acoustics and Sound production with the central theme being Opera house and
Theatre. It reviews previously built buildings on the central theme and combinations of such
individual components.
Research methods are the strategies, processes or techniques utilized in the collection of data
or evidence for analysis in order to uncover new information or create better understanding of
1. Quantitative Methods
Quantitative research methods emphasize objective measurements and the statistical,
Quantitative research focuses on gathering numerical data and generalizing it across groups of
I. Survey Research
5
2. Qualitative Methods
Qualitative research involves collecting and analyzing non-numerical data to understand
problem or generate new ideas for research. It is a method which collects data using
conversational methods, usually open-ended questions. The responses collected are essentially
non-numerical.
I. One-to-one Interview
V. Case Study
A. Primary Sources
iv. Photographs
B. Secondary Sources
i. Books
ii. Journals
6
3.3.1 Instruments of Data Collection
The instruments of data collection are the tools that assist in carrying out the research, for
effective assessment of the variables used in the research. The instruments of data collection
I. Photographs
Photographs of relevant case studies are to be taken to determine the passive design
strategies and the extent, to which they were applied, that is to say, if their extent of
II. Sketches
Sketches were made of some parts of the selected case studies. These sketches showed
III. Notes
These notes where in form of field forms outlining the variables of passive design
These involved visits to two local case studies and taking a visual analysis based on
Acoustical properties used in the theatres and opera houses. These buildings were then
However, the foreign case studies were gotten through the internet and their analysis
well.
7
3.4 Case Study Approach
Case study refers to an event, an entity, an individual or even a unit of analysis. It is an empirical
inquiry that investigates a contemporary phenomenon within its real life context using multiple
sources of evidence. A case study is an appropriate research design when you want to gain
concrete, contextual, in-depth knowledge about a specific real-world subject. It allows you to
explore the key characteristics, meanings, and implications of the case. The research
methodology and methods of data collection in conducting this thesis is qualitative analysis of
case studies.
There are a few different types of case studies that researchers might utilize:
1. Collective case studies: These involves the study of a group of individuals. Researchers
people.
2. Descriptive case studies: These involve starting with a descriptive theory. The subjects
are then observed and the information gathered is compared to the pre-existing theory.
3. Explanatory case studies: These are often used to do causal investigations. In other
words, researchers are interested in looking at factors that may have actually caused
4. Exploratory case studies: These are sometimes used as a prelude to further, more in-
depth research. This allows researchers to gather more information before developing
5. Instrumental case studies: These occur when the individual or group allows researchers
6. Intrinsic case studies: This type of case study is when the researcher has a personal
interest in the case. Jean Piaget's observations of his own children are good examples
8
of how an intrinsic cast study can contribute to the development of a psychological
theory.
I. Suitability: The case studies used in this study of this chapter were selected due to their
level of suitability i.e. they are either opera houses or theatre with good acoustic
II. Security: The local case studies were all selected within a close range and proximity
III. Availability: Opera houses are not commonly found in Nigeria thereby making it hard
9
3.4.2 Analysis of Case studies
Case study research in Architecture goes beyond the documentation and description of the
case study is the most equipped method used to review a particular topic or group of topics
which enables the research to see the situation of a particular sample of the similar topic thereby
assessing and analyzing it. The case studies selected for this thesis were sampled purposively.
Several case studies have been chosen for the purpose of this study. The case studies have been
properly appraised to serve as tool for the realization of the set goals and objectives. Therefore,
the process of arriving at a suitable design solution for a sustainable opera house involves a
careful research and graphic documentation of selected and related schemes, which have direct
bearing in relation to the proposal. The case studies selected for use in this project are selected
below:
10
Case Study One (1): Guangzhou Opera House, Guangzhou, China
Background
The municipality of Guangzhou announced its plans in 2002 to build an Opera House that
would be unique not only for its architectural features but also for its innovation. It
commissioned Zaha Hadid Architects with the task of creating a work that would be perfectly
integrated aesthetically with the surrounding environment. Zaha Hadid designed the opera
house in 2002 and after the construction work was contracted to China Construction Third
Engineering Bureau Co. Ltd, the work began and lasted from 2003 - 2010. The work was to
have been completed in 2010, but the inauguration was postponed to February 2011 after a fire
that broke out on the site. The acoustics construction and design was done by Marshall Day
Acoustics with Sir. Harold Marshall as the engineer. It is located in Guangzhou, Guangdong,
China
Architectural features
The opera house is designed as two large pebble-shaped structures washed onto the banks of
Pearl River. The structures appear as twin boulders taken from the riverbed and smoothed by
erosion in a stream. The design evolved from the concepts of a natural landscape and the
fascinating interplay between architecture and nature; engaging with the principles of erosion,
geology and topography. Custom molded glass-fiber reinforced gypsum (GFRC) units have
been used for the interior of the auditorium to continue the architectural language of fluidity
and seamlessness. The tessellated, triangular glass sections provide internal lighting and open
up to the public areas. It also emphasises the crystalline nature of the Opera House.
The Opera House is a pair of asymmetric structures with the dome and curtain wall integrated
together. The irregular structural joint has a complex non-geometric design. It is about 43m tall
and the external shell has a maximum length of 120m. Three-direction skew folded steel plates
were used to create 64 faces and 47 corners to the structural façade. The latticed cladding
11
required precise founding, positioning and joining of each steel sub-section. The façade is made
of granite and glass and is supported by a steel frame. The larger building is clad in charcoal-
coloured granite with a rough texture while the smaller structure used lighter white colour. The
moulded panels of the main theatre used glass fibre reinforced gypsum (GRG) for the interior
surface. The walls and ceilings of the auditorium are made of about 50mm GRG moulds fixed
to a steel frame. he folded and flowing surface is treated for a golden and glossy appearance.
The split-level terraced seating is copper-toned. Ceiling lighting is designed with 4,000 white
LEDs.
Facilities
Some of the spaces and facilities present in the Guangzhou opera house are listed below.
I. 1,800-seat auditorium.
IV. Stage
V. Stage storage
VIII. Offices
12
XVI. Refreshments area
XVII. Kitchen
XIX. Plaza
Pictures
14
Figure 3.3: Site Plan of Guangzhou Opera House
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
15
Figure 3.5: Floor Plan at level 5 meter of Guangzhou Opera House
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
16
Figure 3.7: Floor Plan at level 16 meter of Guangzhou Opera House
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
17
Figure 3.9: North view of Guangzhou Opera House
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
18
Figure 3.12: West view of Guangzhou Opera House
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
19
Plate 3.3: Views of lobby and circulation space
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
20
Appraisal
Merits
I. The auditorium is equipped with the latest acoustic technology for superior sound
clarity.
III. Use of materials with good acoustic properties for the rehearsal rooms, auditoriums and
Demerits
I. Over reliance on artificial lighting in the auditorium.
Checklist
Table 3.1 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings.
21
Case Study Two (2): Sydney Opera House, Sydney, Australia.
Background
In designing the Sydney Opera House, architect Jørn Utzon took a leaf from nature's book. The
Utzon Design Principles cite inspiration from sources including the harbour setting and nature's
organic forms, colours and textures. Headlands, palm leaves, snow & ice, shells, clouds,
waves, ribs — these are some of the diverse elements that can be recognised in this remarkable
constructed 1959-1973 the building includes many features that are today recognised as
Architectural features
The façade was built with precast concrete shell panels. Other materials used in the building
Facilities
I. Concert hall.
III. Foyer.
VIII. Library.
X. Opera theatre.
XII. Restaurant.
22
XIII. Stage.
Pictures
23
Figure 3.15: Section 1
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
24
Plate 3.8: Interior view of the hall Plate 3.9: Interior view of the hall
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011. Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
Appraisal
Merits
I. Good and pleasing landscape using organic architecture.
III. The shape of the auditorium is designed to enable effective sound production.
Demerits
I. Inadequate car parks.
Checklist
Table 3.0.2 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings.
25
Case Study Three (3): Harbin Opera House, Harbin, Heilongjiang, China
Background
The history of this opera house began in 2010 when MAD won the open international
competition for Harbin Cultural Island, a master plan to build an opera house, a cultural
center in the midst of the wetlands along the Songhua River in Harbin, China. The proposal
of a sinuous opera house as the focal point of the Cultural Island caught the attention and
modern landmark buildings in Chinese cities which are often towering and imposing. The
wetlands, waterways, and snowy terrain. The architect envisioned Harbin Opera House as a
cultural center of the future, a tremendous performance venue, as well as a dramatic public
space that embodies the integration of human, art and the city identity. Construction began in
April, 2011 and ended in 2015. The sinuous opera house is the focal point of the Cultural
Island, occupying a building area of approximately 850,000 square feet of the site’s 444
Architectural features
The opera house clad entirely in white aluminum panels swoops and curls against the bleak
yurt. This opera house is covered with white aluminum panels that fully blend with the
background when it snows. A detail that stands out in this lobby is the crystalline glass curtain
wall made of glass pyramids. Everything is a reference to the snow and the icy weather that
On the exterior, the architecture references the sinuous landscape of the surrounding area. The
resulting curvilinear façade composed of smooth white aluminum panels becomes the poetry
26
of edge and surface, softness and sharpness. Presenting a warm and inviting element, the grand
theater is clad in rich wood, emulating a wooden block that has been gently eroded away.
Sculpted from Manchurian Ash, the wooden walls gently wrap around the main stage and
theater seating. From the proscenium to the mezzanine balcony the grand theater’s use of
simple materials and spatial configuration provides world-class acoustics. The grand theater is
illuminated in part by a subtle skylight that connects the audience to the exterior and the passing
of time.
Facilities
I. 1600 seats Grand theater
V. Plaza
VI. parking
Pictures
27
Plate 3.10: Ariel view showing landscape
Source: Google maps
28
Figure 3.19: Second floor plan Figure 3.20: Roof plan
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011. Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
29
Figure 3.22: Transverse section
Source:www.archdaily.com, 2011.
Plate 3.13: Interior views showing materials used for good acoustics
Source: www.archdaily.com, 2011.
30
Appraisal
Merits
I. The curved shape of the auditorium allows sound waves to reverberate.
Demerits
I. Inadequate car park
Checklist
Table 3.0.3 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings.
PARAMETERS POOR FAIR EXCELLENT
Size 1600 seats
Shape Curvilinear
Material used Rich wood
for wall
Material used Rich wood
for floor
Reverberation
time
Source: Author’s field work, 2021.
31
Case Study Four (4): The National Theatre Orile, Iganmu, Lagos.
Background
The National Theatre is the primary centre for the performing arts in Nigeria designed by
Techno Exporstroy (Alhaji Sule Katagum). Its construction was completed in 1976 in
preparation for the Festival of Arts and Culture in 1977. The theatre which is about a half an
hour drive from Lagos Island, is one of the best masterpieces of Nigeria and a major Lagos
attraction with an auditorium that has the capacity to seat around 3,000 persons, and a
conference hall that can accommodate around 800 people. The hall is equipped with facilities
for simultaneous translation of 8 languages among others. The building also houses two cinema
halls, a restaurant and a bar. The National Theatre is the primary center for the performing arts
in Nigeria. The National Arts Theatre was built during the military regime of Olusegun
Obasanjo. Its exterior is shaped like a military hat. The National Arts Theatre was designed
and constructed by Bulgarian construction companies and resembles the Palace of Culture and
Sports in Varna, Bulgaria (completed in 1968), the National Arts Theatre Lagos being the
Architectural features
The National Theatre exterior was designed, shaped and built to look like a military hat. The
Facilities
It originally has capacity for a 5,000-seater Main Hall with a collapsible stage, and two capacity
cinema halls, all of which are equipped with facilities for simultaneous translation of 8
languages; among others. Some of the spaces in the theatre are listed below:
32
iii. 2 Cinema halls (about 350 seats capacity each)
v. Lobby
vi. Lawns
x. Gate house
Pictures
33
Plate 3.14: Front view Plate 3.15: Side view
Source: nairametrics.com, 2011 Source: nairametrics.com, 2011
34
Appraisal
Merits
I. There is proper layout of the site
Demerits
I. No natural lighting and ventilation in the Auditorium
Checklist
Table 3.0.4 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings.
PARAMETERS REMARK POOR FAIR EXCELLENT
Size 3000 seats
Shape Curve
Material used Concrete
for wall
Material used Rug
for floor
Reverberation
time
Source: Author’s field work, 2021.
35
Case Study Five (5): OAU Performing Arts Theatre, Ile-Ife, Osun.
Background
The theatre was designed by Arieh Sharon, a well-known Israeli architect in 1961. A 5,000
seaters’ capacity built alongside Oduduwa Hall at the centre of the university. Constructed
from 1972 to 1976, is the Core’s most flamboyant building. It has a dramatic shallow-steps
approach from the plaza. The theatre can house an audience of 3500. The theatre was
originally built as an open amphitheater but has now been covered with a roof.
Architectural features
Its exterior includes organic forms in white against a darker concrete. While this pattern is not
particularly Yoruba, it is pseudo-African in its abstraction, part of a limited intent to make the
architecture site-specific. Other Sharon inclusions, such as the concrete column and striated
surface treatments, are also intended as references to the ancient city that became the
university’s home.
Facilities
Some of the facilities available in the theatre includes:
i. 3500 seat theatre.
ii. Stage.
v. Dressing rooms.
36
Pictures
37
Plate 3.21: Back view of the theatre
Source: Author’s field work, 2021.
Appraisal
Merits
i. The seats are arranged in a manner that enabled good sound production and receiving.
Demerits
i. Poor maintenance of the building.
ii. The interior of the hall uses materials with poor acoustic properties.
Checklist
Table 3.5 showing some acoustic properties of the theatre and their ratings.
PARAMETERS REMARK POOR FAIR EXCELLENT
Size 3500 seat
Shape Curve
Material used Concrete
for wall
Material for Concrete
floor
Reverberation
time
Source: Author’s field work, 2021.
38
3.5 Deductions from Case studies
The methods used in achieving good acoustics came as an afterthought and were not
originally put in place during the design stage. This is evident in the use of rug for good
Acoustic engineers and consultants were part of the building team and therefore acoustics and
1. The auditorium should welcome great number of people without obstructing their
2. Circulation spaces should be smooth and free without any obstruction. Cross circulation
4. The interior of the theatre should have a curved shape for good acoustics.
39
References
(n.d.). Retrieved from archdaily: www.archdaily.com
https://www.webuildvalue.com/en/infrastructure/guangzhou-opera-house.html
Oluigbo. (2010).
40