Professional Documents
Culture Documents
$#"##""#!#$!#
"#!"#!#
!!!!*:"8.,2*4
-5262:;9*;797/;1."##
'!!-.,.*:.-
4*26;2//
=
*:.7 CIV-23-129-GLJ
!$#'
""!",$!#
$#'
,$!#$#'"!
%!'
$#'##&"$
$#' $#
$#'%"#!'*6-
&!!
./.6-*6;:
#
(=2:?E:77 2C32C2 2CC:4< O(=2:?E:77P 2D +A64:2= 5>:?:DEC2E@C @7 E96 DE2E6 @7 @33J
2=6 2CC:4< O2CC:4<P @C O64656?EP 96C63J 3C:?8D E96 7@==@H:?8 42FD6D @7 24E:@? 282:?DE
676?52?ED @2C5 @7 @F?EJ @>>:DD:@?6CD @7 %4FCE2:? @F?EJ '<=29@>2 O'P
%4FCE2:? @F?EJ +96C:77 #6G:? =2C5J O=2C5JP 6AFEJ %2EE96H #2D32F> O#2D32F>P
6AFEJ )F6?E:? $66 O$66P 6AFEJ #6G:? +E@CJ O+E@CJP 2?5 /2C56? %2C< 2??29
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 2 of 23
@7,F=D2@F?EJ '<=29@>2
2AA@:?E652D+A64:2=5>:?:DEC2E@C@7E96DE2E6@7@33J2=62CC:4<E96ODE2E6P2?5
:?DE2?E=2HDF:E
7*9-7/7<6;@7552::276.9:7/,<9;*267<6;@34*175*
,96@2C5@7@F?EJ@>>:DD:@?6CD@7%4FCE2:?@F?EJ '<=29@>2O'P:DE96
49:6725>:?:DEC2E:G63@5J7@C%4FCE2:?@F?EJO@F?EJP 2A@=:E:42=DF35:G:D:@?@7E96
+E2E6@7'<=29@>2'RDAC:?4:A2=A=246@73FD:?6DD:D=@42E65:?E96:EJ@7!5236=
E964@F?EJ@7D62E@7%4FCE2:?@F?EJ '<=29@>2
':D@3=:82E65E@4@?5F4E:ED6=7:?24@?DE:EFE:@?2=>2??6CH:E9C6DA64EE@2?J24E:@?
:EE2<6D2?5@CC6DA@?D:3:=:EJ:E5:D492C86DE9C@F89E96A6CD@??6=@7E96%4FCE2:?@F?EJ
+96C:77O%+P
E2==E:>6D5FC:?8E962CC6DE@764656?E@?%2C49 H9:496?56564656?ERD
562E9 E96 @F?EJ H2D C6DA@?D:3=6 !%*( #! 7@C AC6G6?E:?8 %+ 56AFE:6D 7C@> FD:?8
4@?DE:EFE:@?2==J6I46DD:G67@C46FA@?64656?E 2?57@C6?DFC:?8E92E2?J%+56AFE:6D
H9@H6C6AC6D6?E7@C2?5@CA2CE:4:A2E65:?E962CC6DE@764656?EE@@<C62D@?23=6DE6ADE@
AC@E64E64656?E7C@>36:?8DF3;64E65E@4@?DE:EFE:@?2==JF?C62D@?23=66I46DD:G67@C462E
E9692?5D@72?J@E96C=2H6?7@C46>6?EA6CD@??6=
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 3 of 23
4C62E:@?2?5:>A=6>6?E2E:@?@72AAC@AC:2E62?5=2H7F=FD6@77@C46A@=:4:6D2?5AC24E:46D
2?57@C6?DFC:?8E92E%+H2DAC@A6C=JEC2:?:?82?5DFA6CG:D:?8:ED56AFE:6D2?5@E96C
A6CD@??6=:?DF49C682C5
(FCDF2?EE@E96AC:@CCF=:?8D@7E9:D@FCE ':DAC@A6C=J?2>65:?E9:D=2HDF:E
@C 6I2>A=6 :? /% , & &+%*/ &$$2() & +)"& & -+ :DE E
0,196 DF77:4:6?4J @7 2?J 2==682E:@?D 282:?DE %FD<@866 ' 2C6 DF3;64E E@ E96
D2>62?2=JD:D2D:7E962==682E:@?D925366?>256282:?DEE96%FD<@866@F?EJ
+96C:77:?9:D@77:4:2=42A24:EJ!#(* ,#,#%&&&&$$2()
/$/'<=29@=5:?8E92EOE96DF77:4:6?4J@7E962==682E:@?D
282:?DE0E964@F?EJD96C:771:?9:D@77:4:2=42A24:EJ:DDF3;64EE@E96D2>62?2=JD:D2D
2AA=:423=6 E@ E96 @2C5 0@7 @F?EJ @>>:DD:@?6CD1 P 2?5 56?J:?8 >@E:@? E@
5:D>:DD L 4=2:> O32D65 @? 2? F?4@?DE:EFE:@?2= A@=:4J @C AC24E:46P !*!%
&),! ()&% 5
:C
&(%,%"%&-%
+()
/$&'<=29@=5:?8O2DF:E282:?DEE96D96C:77:?
9:D@77:4:2=42A24:EJ:7E96D2>62D?2>:?8E964@F?EJP
!?:ED&*!&% %FD<@866'2C8F6DE92EO:?@C56C7@C(=2:?E:77DE@AC6G2:=@?
E96:CL4=2:>D282:?DEE96@2C5 E96J>FDED9@HE92E2?@77:4:2=A@=:4J@C
6DE23=:D9654FDE@>@7E96@2C542FD65E962==68654@?DE:EFE:@?2=C:89EDG:@=2E:@?P
!? +&!),&(&&+%*/&$$2()&/)&"#
/$
& '<=2 9@H6G6C E96 4@FCE C6;64E65 E96 D2>6 2C8F>6?E ?@H >256 3J
%FD<@866' 9@=5:?8
,9:D@FCEDC625:?8@75@6D?@EDFAA@CE'RD2C8F>6?E0E92E:E
:D?@E2AC@A6CA2CEJE@36DF65F?56CL13642FD6E96724ED:?
2C65:776C6?EE92?E9@D6AC6D6?E6596C6 !?E96A=2:?E:775:5?@E?2>6
E963@2C5@74@F?EJ4@>>:DD:@?6CD3FE?2>65E9C66:?5:G:5F2='<=29@>2
@F?EJ @>>:DD:@?6CD 2D 5676?52?ED ,96 A=2:?E:77 D@F89E E@ 9@=5 E96
D96C:772?5E9@D64@>>:DD:@?6CD=:23=6:?E96:C:?5:G:5F2=42A24:E:6DF?56C2
E96@CJ@7DFA6CG:D@CJ=:23:=:EJ !?2?2=JK:?8E9@D64=2:>D E96,6?E9:C4F:E
96=5 E92E H9:=6 E96 D96C:77 4@F=5 36 96=5 :?5:G:5F2==J =:23=6 :? 9:D
DFA6CG:D@CJ42A24:EJ@?E966G:56?46AC6D6?E65 E964@>>:DD:@?6CD4@F=5
?@E3696=5=:23=67@CE9656AFE:6DR2==6865FD6@76I46DD:G67@C46 3642FD6
E96 3@2C5 @7 4@F?EJ 4@>>:DD:@?6CD 925 ?@ 5FEJ F?56C '<=29@>2 =2H E@
9:C6 EC2:? DFA6CG:D6 @C5:D4:A=:?6E964@F?EJD96C:77D@CE96:C56AFE:6D !?
D9@CE 3642FD6E964@>>:DD:@?6CD24E:?8@?E963@2C5925?@C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ
7@CDFA6CG:D:?82?5EC2:?:?856AFE:6D:?E96FD6@77@C46 E964@>>:DD:@?6CD
4@F=5?@E3696=5=:23=626-2=2-<*44@F?56C2DFA6CG:D@C=:23:=:EJE96@CJ
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 4 of 23
H9:49
C6=J:?A2CEFA@?12?6IE6?D:@?@7E92E2AA62CD:?4@?D:DE6?EH:E9
:ED 24EF2= 9@=5:?8
6>A92D:D25565
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 5 of 23
,<9;*267<6;@"1.92//.=264*9-@
676?52?E #6G:? =2C5J :D 2 C6D:56?E @7 %4FCE2:? @F?EJ '<=29@>2 +:?46
=2C5J92D96=5E96A@D:E:@?@7%4FCE2:?@F?EJ+96C:77
E2==E:>6DC6=6G2?EE@E964=2:>D2DD6CE6596C6:? =2C5JH2D24E:?8F?56C4@=@C@7DE2E6
=2H
(=2:?E:77RD 4=2:>D 7@C C6=:67 :? E9:D &$'#!%* 2C6 3C@F89E 282:?DE =2C5J :? 9:D @77:4:2=
42A24:EJ2D%4FCE2:?@F?EJ+96C:77
O4=2:>282:?DE28@G6C?>6?E24E@C:?9:D@77:4:2=42A24:EJ:D6DD6?E:2==J2?@E96CH2J@7
,9FD ?2>:?8%4FCE2:?@F?EJ+96C:77#6G:?=2C5J:?9:D@77:4:2=42A24:EJ:?E9:D24E:@?
:DE967F?4E:@?2=6BF:G2=6?E@7DF:?8%4FCE2:?@F?EJ&(%,%"%&-%+()
/$ &'<=2 9@=5:?8 O2 DF:E 282:?DE E96 D96C:77 :? 9:D @77:4:2=
42A24:EJ:DE96D2>62D?2>:?8E964@F?EJP/% ,&&+%*/&$$2()&+)"&
@2C5 @7 @F?EJ @>>:DD:@?6CD @7 %FD<@866 @F?EJ 6IAC6DD=J 4@?46565 E92E E96
%FD<@866 @F?EJ +96C:77 O5@6D ?@E 6?;@J 2 D6A2C2E6 =682= 6I:DE6?46 7C@> %FD<@866
@F?EJP
%4FCE2:?@F?EJO>2J3696=5=:23=67@C2?24E:E92D@77:4:2==JD2?4E:@?65 797@CE96
24E:@?D @7 2? @77:4:2= H:E9 7:?2= A@=:4J>2<:?8 2FE9@C:EJP ,!## , #%0 +FAA5
D %4FCE2:? @F?EJ +96C:77 =2C5J :D 2 4@F?EJ O@77:4:2= H:E9 7:?2= A@=:4J>2<:?8
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 6 of 23
55:E:@?2==J =2C5J D6CG6D 2D 92:C>2? @7 E96 %4FCE2:? @F?EJ "2:= ,CFDE @2C5 @7
D96C:77
DC6A@CE65:?E96%4FCE2:?2K6EE6@?@C23@FE646>36C
4@?E:?F:?8 AC@3=6> 2E 2?J 286?4J @C 6?E:EJ @A6C2E65 3J 2?5@C F?56C E96 2FE9@C:EJ @7
%4FCE2:?@F?EJ+96C:77#6G:?=2C5J :?4=F5:?8E96%4FCE2:?@F?EJ+96C:77RD'77:46
2?5E96%4FCE2:?@F?EJ"2:=
*;;1.>*:+*<5
676?52?E %2EE96H #2D32F> :D FA@? :?7@C>2E:@? 2?5 36=:67 2 C6D:56?E @7 %4FCE2:?
@F?EJ '<=29@>2
42CC:65@FEE965FE:6D@7DF49A@D:E:@?:?H9@=6@C:?A2CE2E%+
E2==E:>6DC6=6G2?E96C6E@ #2D32F>H2D24E:?8F?56C4@=@C@7DE2E6=2H
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 7 of 23
<26;76..
'<=29@>2
@FEE965FE:6D@7DF49A@D:E:@?:?H9@=6@C:?A2CE2E%+
E2==E:>6DC6=6G2?E96C6E@ $66H2D24E:?8F?56C4@=@C@7DE2E6=2H
.=26";79.@
'<=29@>2
E 2== E:>6D C6=6G2?E 96C6E@ +E@C6J H@C<65 2E %+ 96=5 E96 A@D:E:@? @7 6AFEJ 2?5
42CC:65@FEE965FE:6D@7DF49A@D:E:@?:?H9@=6@C:?A2CE2E%+
E2==E:>6DC6=6G2?E96C6E@ +E@C6JH2D24E:?8F?56C4@=@C@7DE2E6=2H
*93*66*1
'<=29@>2
E2==E:>6DC6=6G2?E96C6E@ 2??29H2D6>A=@J652D22>6/2C56?H:E9E96'<=29@>2
6A2CE>6?E@7/:=5=:76@?D6CG2E:@?
E2==E:>6DC6=6G2?E96C6E@ 2??29H2D24E:?8F?56C4@=@C@7DE2E6=2H
,96;FC:D5:4E:@?@7E9:D@FCE:D:?G@<65AFCDF2?EE@-+LE@D64FC6AC@E64E:@?
@72?5E@C65C6DD56AC:G2E:@?D@7C:89EDD64FC653JE96@FCE9>6?5>6?EE@E96-?:E65
2==A6CD@?D:?E96:C4:G:=C:89ED2?5E96C65C6DD@756AC:G2E:@?@7C:89EDF?56C4@=@C@7=2H
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 8 of 23
,96 ;FC:D5:4E:@? @7 E9:D @FCE :D 2=D@ :?G@<65 F?56C -+ L E@ C6D@=G6 2
4@?EC@G6CDJ2C:D:?8F?56CE96@?DE:EFE:@?2?5=2HD@7E96-?:E65+E2E6D A2CE:4F=2C=JE96
@FCE9>6?5>6?EE@E96-?:E65+E2E6D@?DE:EFE:@?2?5-+L
.6?F6 :D AC@A6C F?56C -+ L3 3642FD6 2 DF3DE2?E:2= A2CE @7 E96 6G6?ED @C
@>:DD:@?D8:G:?8C:D6E@(=2:?E:77RD4=2:>D@44FCC65:?E9:D;F5:4:2=5:DEC:4E
'?%2C49
2E2AAC@I:>2E6=J
A> 6AFE:6D%2EE96H#2D32F>2?5)F6?E:?
$66H6C65:DA2E4965E@$@C:RD@C?6C+E@C62?56=::?28=6E@H? '<=29@>2
44@C5:?8E@E96!?G6DE:82E:G6&2CC2E:G6AC6A2C653J%+6AFEJ*:492C5/:==:2>D@?
:DA2E4925G:D65E92EE96>2?0=2E6C:56?E:7:652D64656?E@33J2CC:4<1925CF?
E9C@F89E96324<5@@C@7E96DE@C6H9:=64@?EC24E@CDH6C6H@C<:?8@?E964=@D65
3FD:?6DDM0,196DFDA64E9253C@<6?E968=2DD@FE@7E967C@?E5@@C2?5925CF?
:?E@E969:89H2JM2EE6>AE:?8E@DE@A2D6>:
EC24E@CEC2:=6C:?E96C@252?5925
;F>A65@?E@2H@>2?RD42C,96H@>2?:?E9642C0E96?15CF8E96>2?0324<1:?E@
E96DE@C6A2C<:?8=@E
(
8 )D9@CEE:>6=2E6C #2D32F>H2D:?7@C>653J
5:DA2E49E92EE964@?EC24E@CD925366?7:89E:?8H:E92CC:4<2?5E92EE96J?@H9252CC:4<
E:65FA:?E96A2C<:?8=@E
44@C5:?8E@9:DDE2E6>6?E #2D32F>O2CC:G65@?E96D46?6E@7:?502CC:4<1=2J:?87246
92?54F7765 9:> E@ 56E2:? 7@C :?G6DE:82E:@? P 96 @3D6CG65 E92E 2CC:4<RD OHC:DE 2?5 766E
02?519:D92?5DH6C6EFC?:?8AFCA=67C@>E96E:89E?6DD@7E96DEC2ADP
#2D32F>RDDE2E6>6?E4@?E:?F6D
DD@@?2D6AFEJ$662CC:G65;FDED64@?5D369:?5>6 962DD:DE65>6:?C6>@G:?8
E96DEC2AA:?82?596=A65>686E02CC:4<RD1A@4<6ED4=62C65H:E92A2E5@H?D62C49
2?5 FA E@ 0$66RD1 A2EC@= F?:E /9:=6 2EE6>AE:?8 E@ F?E:6 2?5 :56?E:7J 02CC:4<1
4@>>6?EDH6C636:?8>256E@H2C502CC:4<3JE96G:8:=2?E6D1C682C5:?8E2<:?89:D
>@?6J2?5<:4<:?89:>:?9:D962501@C02CC:4<RD1AC@E64E:@?2EE92EA@:?E !
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 9 of 23
H2?E65 E@ 86E 9:> :?E@ E96 F?:E 2D BF:4<=J 2D A@DD:3=6 E@ 56
6D42=2E6 E96 2?86C
E@H2C5D9:>7C@>E96=2C864C@H52C@F?5FDM%C2CC:4<H2DH2=<65@G6C2?5
A=2465:?E@E96324<D62E@76AFEJ$66RD2865F?:E2?5D64FC65@?=J3J92?54F77D
2EE92EA@:?E
C@F?5E9:DE:>6 2>6/2C56?%2C< 2??29 H9@AFCA@CE65=J925366?2=6CE653J9:D
?6:893@CE92EOE96C6H2D29F867:89E2E$@C:RD@C?6C+E@C6:?28=6E@H? P2CC:G652EE96
D46?62?52D<656AFE:6D$662?5#2D32F>:7E96J?665652?J96=A
#2D32F>2D<65 2??29E@2EE6>AEE@=@42E6E968C66?96GC@=6EIE92E925C6A@CE65=J
5C@AA65 2CC:4< @77 ?62C $@C:RD @C?6C +E@C6 2??29 5:5 2D C6BF6DE65 3FE 925 ?@
DF446DD7F==@42E:?8E96ECF4<
02CC:4<12D962AA62C65E@36F?56CE96:?7=F6?46@7D@>6:==:4:EDF3DE2?46P44@C5:?8
E@ 2??29
!4@F=5962C02CC:4<1D4C62>:?82?5J6==:?8:?D:56E9656AFEJRDECF4< 6H2D2=D@
42FD:?8E96ECF4<E@C@4<324<2?57@CE9-A@?%+2CC:G2= #2D32F>2?5$66
2D<65>6E@2DD:DEE96>:?86EE:?802CC:4<17<;@7E96ECF4<'?46#2D32F>@A6?65
E965@@C 02CC:4<1H2DJ6==:?8O 6=A>6,96J2C68@:?8E@<:==>6P
,96DE2E6>6?EDE92EH6C6=2E6C@3E2:?657C@>E96@77:46CD2?5%+A6CD@??6=AC6D6?E2EE96
D46?6AC@G:565:776C:?8244@F?ED:?56D4C:3:?8E966G6?EDE92EE@@<A=246?6IE
#2D32F>4=2:>DE92EH96?96@A6?65E965@@C 2CC:4<H9@D692?5DH6C6DE:==D64FC6=J
4F7765 369:?5 9:D 324< ODAF? 9:D 766E 2C@F?5 2?5 2EE6>AE65 E@ <:4< @FE @7 E96 5@@CP
7E6C D@>6 C6A@D:E:@?:?8 #2D32F> OAC6DD65 09:D1 FAA6C 3@5J :?E@ 02CC:4<RD1 42FD:?8
EC2AA65:?E965@@C;2>@7E96324<D62E01P
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 10 of 23
H6C6167;8@:?8E@=6E2CC:4<6I:EE96G69:4=6 P2?5E96A9JD:42=DECF88=6E92E6?DF65H2D
6DA:E6E96#2D32F>2?5$66RD4=2:>E92E2CC:4<H2D5:D@36J:?8=2H6?7@C46>6?E3J
2EE6>AE:?8E@6I:E$66RDG69:4=6 %+6AFEJ*:492C5/:==:2>D@?6IAC6DD=J?@E65:?9:D
O2D<652CC:4<D6G6C2=E:>6DE@6I:EE96G69:4=6P
+:>:=2C=J E9@F89%,#2JE=J??(@H6CDD2:5E96@77:46CDE@=52CC:4<OE@AFE9:D766E324<
:? E96 G69:4=6P 2?5 H6C6 OECJ0:?81 E@ AFD9 02CC:4<1 324< :? E96 G69:4=6 P A2CE
E:>6
7:C6>2?A2CE
E:>6 %, ,2E6 2D2?@G2 E@=5 2 5:776C6?E DE@CJ C6=2J:?8 E92E OE96 =2H
6?7@C46>6?E@77:46CD2D<6502CC:4<1D6G6C2=E:>6DE@A62467F==J.?2;E96G69:4=6 E@H9:49
02CC:4<1J6==65Q96=AR2?5QE96J2C6ECJ:?8E@<:==>6R2E%+P2DE96@77:46CDO6IEC24E65
02CC:4<17C@>E96G69:4=6P
+:?46 2CC:G:?8 @? E96 D46?6 6AFEJ #2D32F>RD =2A6= 42>6C2 925 366? EFC?65 @? 2?5
C64@C5:?8E966G6?ED@7E966G6?:?8
366?C64@C5:?89:D4@?G6CD2E:@?D2?5:?E6C24E:@?DH:E9G2C:@FD3JDE2?56CD
EFC?65@77
44@C5:?8 E@ $66 O#2D32F>RD G:56@ H2D 5:D6?82865 *,,2-.6;*44@ P 2?5 $66 H9@ 925
EFC?659:D@77367@C68@:?8E@C6EC:6G62CC:4<7C@>E96324<@79:DG69:4=6 O5:5?@E6?8286
9:DG:56@H96?E9624E:G6C6D:DE2?463J2CC:4<H2D92AA6?:?8P$667FCE96CDE2E65E92E
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 11 of 23
$66 2?5 2??29 2=C625J DECF88=:?8 H:E9 2CC:4< O5:5 ?@E 6?8286 9:D G:56@ :? H9@=6
5FC:?8E9624E:G6C6D:DE2?46P
-A@? :?7@C>2E:@? 36=:67 #2D32F> @C @?6 @7 E96 =2H 6?7@C46>6?E A6CD@?2= AC6D6?E
:?DECF4E65E96@E96C@77:46CDE@5624E:G2E62==42>6C2D
$66 E2D65 2CC:4< H9@ H2D DE:== :? 92?54F77D ?@ 76H6C E92? 7@FC E:>6D 2?5 H:E9 E96
E@72==72465@H?@?E96A2C<:?8=@E
7@C46E@2CC:4<RD=@H6C6IEC6>:E:6D
7E6C 2CC:4< H2D C6DEC2:?65 :? E9:D >2??6C 676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5
2??29 2?J @7 E96> @C D@>6 4@>3:?2E:@? E96C6@7 4@?E:?F65 E@ FD6 A9JD:42= 7@C46 :?
2 @?E:?F:?8E@AFEDF3DE2?E:2=@CD:8?:7:42?EAC6DDFC6@?2CC:4<RD324<H9:=696H2D
:?27246
5@H?AC@?6A@D:E:@?2?592?54F7765
3@?E:?F:?8E@D:E2?5@C<?66=@?E96A@DE6C:@C2DA64E@72CC:4<RDE@CD@
4 @?E:?F:?8 E@ D:E <?66= =:6 2?5@C @E96CH:D6 A=246 9:DE96:C 3@5J H6:89E @?
2CC:4<RDFAA6CE@CD@
5@?E@CE:?82CC:4<RD3@5J5FC:?8E96AC@46DD@7A=24:?89:>:?=68C6DEC2:?ED E9FD
AC6G6?E2CC:4<7C@>36:?823=6E@=:64@>A=6E6=JAC@?6@?E968C@F?5
6 @C4:?82CC:4<RD7246:?E@E968C@F?5
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 12 of 23
7 @?E:?F:?8E@2AA=J249@<69@=5@C@E96C?64<C6DEC2:?E
8'E96CH:D6C6DEC:4E:?82CC:4<RD23:=:EJE@3C62E96
9-?C62D@?23=J FD:?8 2 32E@? E@ DEC:<6 2CC:4< 2?5@C E@ DF3;64E 9:> E@ OA2:?
4@>A=:2?46E649?:BF6DP
,+*H62A@?E92E:D?@EC68:DE6C65H:E9%+2?5@?H9:49%+5@6D?@EEC2:?
:ED56AFE:6D
<'E96CH:D6A9JD:42==J23FD:?82CC:4<
FCE96C 676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5 2??29 :8?@C65 2CC:4<RD 2EE6>AE 2E
4@>>F?:42E:?8E92E96H2D27C2:5E92E96H2D8@:?8E@5:62?5E@O(=62D65@?RE<:==>6P
,96FD6@77@C46FA@?64656?E3JE9623@G6
:56?E:7:65:?5:G:5F2=D @C2?J@7E96> H2D
?6:E96C 2 8@@5 72:E9 677@CE E@ C6DEC2:? 64656?E ?@C ?646DD2CJ E@ >2:?E2:? 4@?EC@= @7
64656?E
%,2?5:46/J2EEC6A@CE65E92EH9:=6E9C66@7E9623@G6
?2>65676?52?EDH6C6=J:?8
@?E@A@72CC:4<2?52?@E96C@77:46CH2D2AA=J:?8255:E:@?2=C6DEC2:?ED 2CC:4<DE@AA65
=:<624E:G:EJ 6H2DDF3D6BF6?E=JEC2?DA@CE65E@%4FCE2:?%6>@C:2=
2CC:4<H2D5:D492C8657C@>%4FCE2:?%6>@C:2=G:22:CG24E@(2C:D*68:@?2=%65:42=
6?E6C 7@C 2 9:896C =6G6= @7 42C6 @? >6492?:42= G6?E:=2E:@? A@DE C6DA:C2E@CJ 2CC6DE 2?5
42C5:242CC6DE H96C696F=E:>2E6=J5:65
%+92D2=@?8
DE2?5:?84F=EFC62?5AC24E:46@75:DC682C5:?8:EDHC:EE6?A@=:4:6D
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 13 of 23
%+92D29:DE@CJ@7A6C>:EE:?8:EDA6CD@??6=E@6?8286:?F??646DD2CJ F?C62D@?23=62?5
6I46DD:G67@C46@?2CC6DE66DH9@A@D6?@E9C62E
%+ 6>A=@J66D 92G6 DE2E65 E96:C C6D6?E>6?E 7@C >6>36CD @7 E96 &2E:G6 >6C:42?
4@>>F?:EJ:?2C24:2=>2??6C36=:6G:?8E96JC646:G6DA64:2=EC62E>6?E
%+2=D@92D2=@?8
DE2?5:?84F=EFC6 AC24E:46 2?59:DE@CJ@7EC2:?:?82?5@CA6C>:EE:?8
:ED=2H6?7@C46>6?E@77:46CDE@>2:?E2:?D64C64J2?5@CE@72=D:7JC6A@CEDC682C5:?8DF49
23FD6D
,9623@G6
DF>>2C:K6524ED2?5@>:DD:@?DH6C6:?7FCE96C2?46@7 2?54@?D:DE6?EH:E9 E96
:>A=6>6?E65 @3D6CG65 >2:?E2:?65 2?5@C E@=6C2E65 @C :? H9:49 %+ 925 @E96CH:D6
AC6G:@FD=J24BF:6D465
/96E96C7@C>2=@C:?7@C>2= E9623@G6
C676C6?465A@=:4:6D 4FDE@>D 2?5AC24E:46D@7E96
%4FCE2:?@F?EJ+96C:77! %4FCE2:?@F?EJH6C6H6==
D6EE=652?5A6C>2?6?E
,96 %4FCE2:? @F?EJ +96C:77 2?5 E9FD %4FCE2:? @F?EJ 92D 2 =@?8 566A
D62E65
9:DE@CJ2?5F?232E654FDE@>@76I46DD:G67@C46
$
$
%
$"
%
$"A
@C96C:CDE2FD6@74E:@? (=2:?E:77C6
2==686D2?5:?4@CA@C2E6D3JC676C6?462==@7E96
7@C68@:?8A2C28C2A9D 2?57FCE96CDE2E6D
,96,6?E9:C4F:E92DO4=62C=J6DE23=:D965E92EAFEE:?8DF3DE2?E:2=@CD:8?:7:42?EAC6DDFC6
@?2DFDA64ERD324<H9:=6E92EDFDA64E:D:?27246
5@H?AC@?6A@D:E:@?27E6C36:?8DF35F65
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 14 of 23
:C
:C H9:49OH2C?650A@=:461?@EE@D:E@?E96324<@72A6CD@?E96J2C6ECJ:?8E@
@7D6G6C2=A6CD@?D@?@?6RD324<42?5@P
% !$ 5 :C H9:49 96=5 E92E E96 A@=:46 2?5 O2?J
:?5:G:5F2=A=625:?87@C2:CO:?G@=G6D2568C66@77@C46E92E:D8C62E6CE92?C62D@?23=6P
55:E:@?2==J E96,6?E9:C4F:E92DC64@8?:K65E92EH96?2DFDA64E:DO2=C625J92?54F7765
4@?E:?F65FD6@72,+*@?E96DFDA64E >2J4@?DE:EFE625:DAC@A@CE:@?2E6FD6@77@C46
@749@<69@=5H2DO6I46DD:G62?5>2=:4:@FDPH96?FD6527E6CG:4E:>H2DO>2?24=65P2?5
O67764E:G6=JC6DEC2:?65P
,96 ,6?E9 :C4F:E 92D DA64:7:42==J 255C6DD65 E96 52?86CD A@D65 3J ,+* H62A@?D
C64@8?:K:?8E92EE96C62D@?23=6?6DD@72A2CE:4F=2CFD6@77@C4642?@7E6?56A6?5 :?A2CE
@?H96E96C=2H6?7@C46>6?E@77:46CD<?6H@CD9@F=592G6<?@H?E92E2?:?5:G:5F2=925
DA64:2=492C24E6C:DE:4D>2<:?89:>>@C6DFD46AE:3=6E@92C>7C@>E96FD6@72A2CE:4F=2C
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 15 of 23
:C
&@E:46D:DDF653J,+*!?E6C?2E:@?2=92G6H2C?65=2H6?7@C46>6?E@77:46CDH9@FD6
:?4=F5:?8E9@D6F?56CE96:?7=F6?46@75CF8D OD:?46E96:C3@5:6D2C62E28C62E6CC:D<@7
92C>7C@>DF4956G:46DP
:?2==J E96 ,6?E9 :C4F:E 92D 6IAC6DD=J 96=5 E92E O@77:46CD >2J ?@E 2AA=J E96 9@8
E:6
E649?:BF6H96?2?:?5:G:5F2=RD5:>:?:D96542A24:EJ:D2AA2C6?EP5F6E@E96D:8?:7:42?E=J
:C
O!?DF49D:EF2E:@?D 2?:?5:G:5F2=RD4@?5:E:@?>2?52E6DE96FD6@7=6DDC6DEC:4E:G6>62?D7@C
A9JD:42=C6DEC2:?EP
!?(+0 E96,6?E9:C4F:E6IAC6DD65:EDF?56CDE2?5:?8E92E2O9@8E:6P:?G@=G6DE963:?5:?8
@7@?6RD2?<=6D2?5HC:DED369:?5E96324< H:E9EH6=G6:?496D@C=6DD@7D6A2C2E:@?
,96D2>65625=J67764E>2J36249:6G653J9@=5:?82DFDA64ERD3@F?5HC:DED282:?DE9:D
H2:DE H9:=6D:>F=E2?6@FD=J36?5:?8E96DFDA64ERD=68D2EE96<?662E2?2?8=6=6DDE92?
568C66D E@H2C5D 9:D H2:DE DF49 E92E E96C6 C6>2:?D 2 DA2? @7 EH6=G6 :?496D @C 76H6C
D6A2C2E:?8E96DFDA64ERDHC:DED7C@>9:D2?<=6D
$,E62496DE92EE962AA=:42E:@?@7E96O9@8E:6P4@?7:8FC2E:@?@?2DFDA64E
H:E9@C
H:E9@FE FD:?8 2 492:? @C @E96C 72DE6?:?8 56G:46 E@ 3:?5 E96 DFDA64ERD HC:DED 2?5 2?<=6D
E@86E96CN:DAC@9:3:E65
J G:CEF6 @7 E96 27@C6>6?E:@?65 9@=5:?8D =2H 6?7@C46>6?E A6CD@??6= :? E96 +E2E6 @7
'<=29@>292G6366?AFE@??@E:46E92EFE:=:K:?82?J@7E9627@C6>6?E:@?65E649?:BF6D@?
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 16 of 23
6I9:3:E:?8D:8?D@7C6DA:C2E@CJ5:DEC6DD>2J4@?DE:EFE625:DAC@A@CE:@?2E6FD6@77@C46 C6DF=E
=2HP
)**&&&"(,&$0 5
:C
7E6C O5C2808:?81 %C 2CC:4< M @FE 7C@> F?56C E96 ECF4<P 2?5@C 2H2J 7C@> :E
676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5 2??29 O<6AE 02CC:4<1 7246 5@H? @? E96
A2G6>6?EP2?59:DHC:DEDD64FC6=J72DE6?65:?92?54F77D369:?59:D324<
7E6C 2CC:4< H2D C6DEC2:?65 :? E9:D >2??6C 676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5
2??29 2?J @7 E96> @C D@>6 4@>3:?2E:@? E96C6@7 4@?E:?F65 E@ FD6 A9JD:42= 7@C46 :?
= @?E:?F:?8E@AFEDF3DE2?E:2=@CD:8?:7:42?EAC6DDFC6@?2CC:4<RD324<H9:=696H2D
:?27246
5@H?AC@?6A@D:E:@?2?592?54F7765
>@?E:?F:?8E@D:E2?5@C<?66=@?E96A@DE6C:@C2DA64E@72CC:4<RDE@CD@
?@?E:?F:?8 E@ D:E <?66= =:6 2?5@C @E96CH:D6 A=246 9:DE96:C 3@5J H6:89E @?
2CC:4<RDFAA6CE@CD@
@@?E@CE:?82CC:4<RD3@5J5FC:?8E96AC@46DD@7A=24:?89:>:?=68C6DEC2:?ED E9FD
AC6G6?E2CC:4<7C@>36:?823=6E@=:64@>A=6E6=JAC@?6@?E968C@F?5
A@C4:?82CC:4<RD7246:?E@E968C@F?5
B@?E:?F:?8E@2AA=J249@<69@=5@C@E96C?64<C6DEC2:?E
C 'E96CH:D6C6DEC:4E:?82CC:4<RD23:=:EJE@3C62E96
D -?C62D@?23=J FD:?8 2 32E@? E@ DEC:<6 2CC:4< 2?5@C E@ DF3;64E 9:> E@ OA2:?
4@>A=:2?46E649?:BF6DP
,+*H62A@?E92E:D?@EC68:DE6C65H:E9%+2?5@?H9:49%+5@6D?@EEC2:?
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 17 of 23
:ED56AFE:6D
G'E96CH:D6A9JD:42==J23FD:?82CC:4<
FCE96C 676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5 2??29 :8?@C65 2CC:4<RD 2EE6>AE 2E
4@>>F?:42E:?8E92E96H2D27C2:5E92E96H2D8@:?8E@5:62?5E@O(=62D65@?RE<:==>6P
6249C64@8?:K652CC:4<RD5:>:?:D96542A24:EJ
D6C:@FDC6DA:C2E@CJ5:DEC6DD5F6E@E96>2??6C:?H9:49E96J:?:E:2==J6?4@F?E6C659:>!
362E6?2?59@8E:653JE96G:8:=2?E64C@H5
8@@572:E9677@CEE@C6DEC2:?2CC:4<@C@E96CH:D6E@>2:?E2:?4@?EC@=
+E@C6J 2?5 2??29 H2D 5@?6 >2=:4:@FD=J D25:DE:42==J 2?5@C @C E96 G6CJ AFCA@D6 @7
42FD:?892C>E@2CC:4<
676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5 2??29 @C 2?J @7 E96> <?6H @C D9@F=5 92G6
<?@H? E92E E96 6I46DD:G6 A9JD:42= 7@C46 FD65 282:?DE 2CC:4< H@F=5 C6DF=E :?
2CC:4<DF776C:?8D6C:@FD92C>@C562E9
@?2CC:4< 2CC:4<H2D?@=@?86C6I9:3:E:?82?J>62?:?87F=A9JD:42=C6D:DE2?46E@D2:5
676?52?ED
@?2CC:4< 2CC:4<H2D2=C625JC6DEC2:?65E@DF492568C66E92E96H2DA9JD:42==J:?42A23=6
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 18 of 23
@7>62?:?87F==JC6D:DE:?8D2:5676?52?ED
@?2CC:4< E96C6H2D?@?6657@CE962AA=:42E:@?@7DF497@C46
@? (=2:?E:77 676?52?ED 5:5 ?@E C62D@?23=J A6C46:G6 (=2:?E:77 2D A@D:?8 D@>6 E9C62E
H2CC2?E:?8E962AA=:42E:@?@77@C46
7@C467F=C6DA@?D6
(=2:?E:77F??646DD2C:=JDF776C65A2:?2?5562E92D25:C64E2?5AC@I:>2E6C6DF=E@7E967@C46
2??29H6C624E:?8F?56C4@=@C@7DE2E6=2H
,96 24ED :? H9:49 676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5 2??29 6249 6?82865 H6C6
:?4:56?E2=E@D@>6D6CG:4636:?8A6C7@C>657@CE96:C6>A=@J6CD
=E6C?2E:G6=J E96 24ED :? H9:49 676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5 2??29 6249
6?828652C@D6@FE@72?6>@E:@?2=C6DA@?D6E@24E:@?D36:?8E2<6?7@CE96:C6>A=@J6CD
(=2:?E:77:D6?E:E=65E@E96C64@G6CJ@752>286D:?E9:D42D62D2C6DF=E@7E967@C8@:?824ED
E92E:E2H2C5(=2:?E:772==2G2:=23=6A64F?:2CJ2?5?@?
64@?@>:452>286D:?2?2>@F?E6I4665:?8
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 19 of 23
@CDF49@E96CDA64:7:4DF>4@?D:DE6?EH:E9E966G:56?46E92E(=2:?E:772?E:4:A2E6D
H:== 36 AC6D6?E65 :? E9:D 42D6 (=2:?E:77 2=D@ AC2JD 7@C AF?:E:G6 52>286D 282:?DE 676?52?ED
2==2EE@C?6J766D2?54@DEDC62D@?23=J:?4FCC653J(=2:?E:77:?96CAC@D64FE:@?@7E9:D24E:@? 2?52?
E92EE9:D@FCE566>D;FDE2?5AC@A6C
E967@C68@:?8A2C28C2A9D 2?57FCE96CDE2E6D
2CC:4<
6I46DD:G6 2?54@?DE:EFE:@?2==JF?C62D@?23=67@C46FA@?2CC:4<
&6G6CE96=6DD 676?52?ED #2D32F> $66 +E@C6J 2?5 2??29 6249 72:=65 E@ E2<6
C62D@?23=6DE6ADE@AC@E64E2CC:4<7C@>E96FD6@76I46DD:G67@C463J@?6@C>@C6@7E96
C6>2:?:?8E9C66676?52?ED
(=2:?E:77:D6?E:E=65E@E96C64@G6CJ@752>286D:?E9:D42D62D2C6DF=E@7E967@C8@:?824ED
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 20 of 23
E92E:E2H2C5(=2:?E:772==2G2:=23=6A64F?:2CJ2?5?@?
64@?@>:452>286D:?2?2>@F?E6I4665:?8
@CDF49@E96CDA64:7:4DF>4@?D:DE6?EH:E9E966G:56?46E92E(=2:?E:772?E:4:A2E6D
H:== 36 AC6D6?E65 :? E9:D 42D6 (=2:?E:77 2=D@ AC2JD 7@C AF?:E:G6 52>286D 282:?DE 676?52?ED
2==2EE@C?6J766D2?54@DEDC62D@?23=J:?4FCC653J(=2:?E:77:?96CAC@D64FE:@?@7E9:D24E:@? 2?52?
E92EE9:D@FCE566>D;FDE2?5AC@A6C
#
%
$"A
@C96C,9:C52FD6@74E:@? (=2:?E:77C6
2==686D2?5:?4@CA@C2E6D3JC676C6?462==@7E96
7@C68@:?8A2C28C2A9D 2?57FCE96CDE2E6D
,9623@G6
C676C6?4654@?DE:EFE:@?2=G:@=2E:@?DE@H9:4964656?EH2DDF3;64E65H6C6:?
7FCE96C2?46 @7 4@?D:DE6?E H:E9 2?5 42FD2==J 4@??64E65 E@ E96 A@=:4:6D 4FDE@>D 2?5
AC24E:46D E92E '%+ 925 AC6G:@FD=J 4C62E65 :>A=6>6?E65 @3D6CG65 >2:?E2:?65
/96E96C 7@C>2= @C :?7@C>2= E96 27@C6>6?E:@?65 A@=:4:6D 4FDE@>D 2?5 AC24E:46D @7
(=2:?E:77RD4=2:>D2C632D65
DF3;64E65 2C@D6 F?56C 4:C4F>DE2?46D E92E 4@?DE:EFE6 FDF2= 2?5 C64FCC:?8 D:EF2E:@?D H:E9
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 21 of 23
H9:49%+56AFE:6D2?5A6CD@??6=>FDEC@FE:?6=J562=2?5@C92G6C68F=2C=J@CAC6G:@FD=J
562=E
'%+ 72:=65 E@ 256BF2E6=J EC2:? DFA6CG:D6 2?5@C 4@?EC@= %+ 56AFE:6D 2?5
A6CD@??6=C682C5:?8E96:C@3=:82E:@?DF?56CE96@FCE9>6?5>6?EE@C67C2:?7C@>FD:?8
7@C46 E92E :D 4@?DE:EFE:@?2==J 6I46DD:G6 F?C62D@?23=6 2?5@C 5:DAC@A@CE:@?2E6 F?56C
4=62C=J
6DE23=:D965,6?E9:C4F:E=2H
'%+ 72:=65 E@ 256BF2E6=J EC2:? DFA6CG:D6 2?5@C 4@?EC@= %+ 56AFE:6D 2?5
A6CD@??6=C682C5:?8E96:C@3=:82E:@?DF?56CE96@FCE9>6?5>6?EE@AC@E64EDFDA64ED2?5
2CC6DE66D 7C@> 36:?8 DF3;64E65 E@ 4@?DE:EFE:@?2==J 6I46DD:G6 F?C62D@?23=6 2?5@C
5:DAC@A@CE:@?2E67@C462EE9692?5D@7@E96C=2H6?7@C46>6?EA6CD@??6=
5:C64E 2?5 42FD2= =:?< 6I:DED 36EH66? E96 A2:? 2?5 562E9 F??646DD2C:=J DF776C65 3J
64656?E@33J2CC:4<2?5E9672:=FC63J'%+E@256BF2E6=JEC2:?%+56AFE:6D
2?5A6CD@??6=
-A@? :?7@C>2E:@? 2?5 36=:67 '%+ 925 AC:@C <?@H=6586 E92E E96 EJA6 @7
4@?DE:EFE:@?2=G:@=2E:@?D255C6DD6596C6:?23@G6H6C62H:56DAC6252?54@?E:?F:?8AC@3=6>
2E 2?J 286?4J @C 6?E:EJ @A6C2E65 3J 2?5@C F?56C E96 2FE9@C:EJ @7 %4FCE2:? @F?EJ
+96C:77#6G:?=2C5J :?4=F5:?8E96%4FCE2:?@F?EJ+96C:77RD'77:462?5E96%4FCE2:?
@F?EJ"2:=
56D4C:36596C6:? H6C6DF3DE2?E:2==J46CE2:?E@C6DF=E:?E96G:@=2E:@?@7E964@?DE:EFE:@?2=
C:89ED @7 2?J@?6 2CC6DE65 56E2:?65 @C :?42C46C2E65 :? %4FCE2:? @F?EJ :?4=F5:?8
64656?E
%@C6@G6C 8:G6?E9623@G6
56D4C:3659:DE@CJ@74@?DE:EFE:@?2=G:@=2E:@?D H9:49:D=6?8E9J
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 22 of 23
C6DF=E :? G:@=2E:@?D @7 E96 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= C:89ED @7 2CC6DE65 56E2:?65 @C :?42C46C2E65 :?
%4FCE2:?@F?EJ :?4=F5:?864656?E
C:D<@7D6C:@FD92C>E@H9:49%+56AFE:6DH6C6DF3;64E:?8E9@D6:?5:G:5F2=DH9@92G6
:?4=F5:?864656?E
'%+ E9C@F89 :ED 4@?E:?F65 6?4@FC286>6?E C2E:7:42E:@? 2AAC@G2= 2?5@C
>2:?E6?2?46 @7 E96 27@C6>6?E:@?65 A@=:4:6D 4FDE@>D 2?5@C AC24E:46D :? DA:E6 @7 E96:C
<?@H? 2?5 @3G:@FD :?256BF24:6D 2?5 52?86CD 92D 366? 56=:36C2E6=J :?5:776C6?E E@ E96
962=E92?5D276EJ@7E9@D6:?5:G:5F2=DH9@92G6366?@CH@F=5:?E967FEFC6362CC6DE65
52>286D
282:?DE 676?52?ED @2C5 @7 @F?EJ @>>:DD:@?6CD @7 %4FCE2:? @F?EJ '<=29@>2 2?5
%4FCE2:?@F?EJ+96C:77#6G:?=2C5J7@C2==2G2:=23=652>286D:?4=F5:?8A64F?:2CJ2?5?@?
64@?@>:452>286D:?2?2>@F?E6I4665:?8 @CDF49@E96CDA64:7:4DF>4@?D:DE6?E
H:E9E966G:56?46E92E(=2:?E:772?E:4:A2E6DH:==36AC6D6?E65:?E9:D42D6(=2:?E:772=D@AC2JD7@C
AC6
;F58>6?E :?E6C6DE 2EE@C?6J 766D 2?5E964@DED @7 E9:D 24E:@? E@ 36 E2I65 282:?DE D2:5
6:23-cv-00129-GLJ Document 2 Filed in ED/OK on 04/20/23 Page 23 of 23
676?52?ED 2=@?8 H:E9 2? 2H2C5 @7 2== @E96C C6=:67 H96E96C =682= 6BF:E23=6 @C 3@E9 E@ H9:49
%'5-0-/)
0%-/'%03/%9*-40+0%-/'20
%1(
""#
66241):5*24/%-16-**%4&%4%%44-'.