The Impact of Local Health Integration Networks on Emergency Room Wait Times in

Ontario: A Policy Analysis and Recommendations for Improvement

Issue
The problem of extended wait times in Ontario emergency rooms has become increasingly
critical, as recent data reveals that a staggering 88% of patients experience delays exceeding the
target duration for their stay (DeClerq, 2022). This pressing issue can be traced back to multiple
contributing factors, such as the challenges that older adults face in securing appropriate alternate
levels of care (ALC) (Ahmed, 2019), and the insufficient follow-up care provided to patients
who receive diagnoses of atrial fibrillation, heart failure, and hypertension in emergency
departments (Atzema et al., 2018). The establishment of Local Health Integration Networks
(LHIN) and their eventual transition to Home and Community Care Support Services (HCCSS)
have been instrumental in shaping the current state of affairs.
Ontario's emergency rooms are grappling with an unprecedented crisis as the majority of patients
experience wait times that surpass the designated targets for their care, reflecting the strain on the
healthcare system (DeClerq, 2022). Older adults, who often require alternate levels of care
(ALC) to suit their unique needs, face significant hurdles in accessing appropriate services,
further exacerbating the problem of prolonged wait times (Ahmed, 2019).
Moreover, the lack of proper follow-up care for patients diagnosed with conditions such as atrial
fibrillation, heart failure, and hypertension in emergency departments compounds the issue
(Atzema et al., 2018). Inadequate follow-up care can lead to the recurrence of health issues,
causing patients to return to emergency departments and contributing to increased wait times.
The Local Health Integration Networks (LHIN) were initially established to address these
concerns by coordinating and integrating healthcare services across Ontario. However, their
effectiveness has been called into question, as they have been unable to adequately address the
underlying factors contributing to long wait times in emergency rooms. In an attempt to rectify
these shortcomings, LHINs were replaced by Home and Community Care Support Services
(HCCSS), which sought to streamline the delivery of healthcare services (Tea & Toast, 2021).
Despite the transformation from LHINs to HCCSS, the issue of extended wait times in Ontario
emergency rooms persists. The ongoing challenges faced by older adults in accessing alternate
levels of care and the insufficiency of follow-up care for patients diagnosed with critical
conditions in emergency departments continue to burden the healthcare system, emphasizing the
need for more effective policy solutions.
Background
The establishment of Local Health Integration Networks (LHIN) in 2007 aimed to streamline the
organization and delivery of health care services in Ontario (Canadian Mental Health
Association, n.d.). As non-profit organizations, LHINs were responsible for planning,
coordinating, and funding local health services, with a focus on integrating and improving the
quality of care provided to patients (MacLeod, 2015).
Despite these ambitious goals, concerns arose regarding the effectiveness and clarity of LHINs'
purpose. MacLeod (2015) argued that there was a need to build upon the initial goals of LHINs
to ensure they could adequately address the complex health care landscape in Ontario. In
particular, LHINs were called upon to engage more effectively with stakeholders, increase
transparency, and focus on delivering value for patients.
However, since their inception, LHINs faced criticism for not meeting performance benchmarks.
According to Migneault (2015), several LHINs failed to achieve key performance indicators in
areas such as emergency department wait times, access to primary care, and hospital readmission
rates. These shortcomings highlighted the need for a more comprehensive and effective approach
to organizing health care services in Ontario.
In response to these concerns, the Ontario government restructured the province's health care
system by transitioning from LHINs to Home and Community Care Support Services (HCCSS).
This new organizational model aimed to enhance the delivery of health care services by
providing a more streamlined approach to planning, funding, and integrating health care services
within local communities. However, as the issues of long wait times in emergency departments
persist, the effectiveness of HCCSS in addressing these challenges remains uncertain.
Current Status
As of April 2021, the Local Health Integration Networks (LHIN) were restructured and renamed
as Home and Community Care Support Services (HCCSS) with the intention of streamlining the
delivery of healthcare services in Ontario (Tea & Toast, 2021). Despite the change, the HCCSS
still grapples with issues of accountability and effectiveness in the home and community care
sector (Gray et al., 2014). Moreover, the COVID-19 pandemic has introduced additional
challenges, resulting in shifts in home care assessment and service delivery in the province (Sinn
et al., 2022).
Tea & Toast (2021) reports that the transition from LHIN to HCCSS aimed to provide a more
coherent approach to healthcare services, including subsidized home care and long-term care
home placement. However, the HCCSS has not yet fully addressed the accountability concerns
within the home and community care sector. Gray et al. (2014) argue that there is a need for a
stronger focus on performance measurement and reporting to ensure the effective functioning of
HCCSS.
Adding to these challenges, the COVID-19 pandemic has substantially impacted home care
services in Ontario. Sinn et al. (2022) found that the pandemic has led to changes in the patterns
of home care assessment and service provision, with variations in the types of services provided
and the frequency of assessments conducted. This has further complicated the efforts to
streamline home care and improve emergency room wait times in the province.
Discussion and Analysis
The persistent issue of long wait times in Ontario emergency rooms highlights the need for a
critical examination of the existing health policy programs, specifically the transition from Local
Health Integration Networks (LHIN) to Home and Community Care Support Services (HCCSS).
While the intention behind the shift from LHINs to HCCSS was to streamline healthcare delivery
and improve patient outcomes, the ongoing challenges in addressing prolonged wait times
suggest that these goals have not been fully realized.
One of the key factors contributing to the extended wait times is the difficulty older adults face
in accessing appropriate alternate levels of care (ALC) (Ahmed, 2019). This issue indicates a gap
in the services provided by HCCSS, as the organization has not been able to effectively
coordinate and integrate healthcare services for this vulnerable population. The lack of adequate
follow-up care for patients diagnosed with critical conditions in emergency departments further
compounds the problem, resulting in increased strain on the healthcare system and longer wait
times (Atzema et al., 2018).
Furthermore, the concerns surrounding the effectiveness and accountability of HCCSS remain
unresolved (Gray et al., 2014). The organization has not been able to consistently meet
performance indicators, such as emergency department wait times, access to primary care, and
hospital readmission rates (Migneault, 2015). Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic has created
new challenges for HCCSS, as it has significantly impacted home care services and assessments
in Ontario (Sinn et al., 2022).
Recommendations
In order to tackle the issue of extended wait times in Ontario emergency rooms and boost the
effectiveness of HCCSS, several policy recommendations are proposed
It is essential to foster the coordination and integration of healthcare services for older adults,
with a focus on providing appropriate alternate levels of care (ALC). This could entail fostering
improved collaboration with long-term care facilities, community-based organizations, and
primary care providers to guarantee timely access to suitable care options.
Secondly, enhancing follow-up care for patients diagnosed with critical conditions in emergency
departments is crucial. This might involve strengthening communication between emergency
departments and primary care providers, as well as implementing care pathways to ensure that
patients receive prompt and appropriate follow-up care.
Also, the accountability and performance measurement of HCCSS should be improved by
implementing a robust performance management framework. This would encompass regular
reporting of key performance indicators and external evaluations of the organization's
effectiveness.
In addition, addressing the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on home care services is
necessary. This can be achieved by developing targeted strategies that ensure the continuity and
quality of care for patients receiving home care services during public health emergencies.
Lastly, fostering innovation and promoting the adoption of digital health technologies can
enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of healthcare services. This has the potential to reduce
wait times and improve patient outcomes.
 References
AHMED, D. 2019. The challenge of alternate level of care (ALC) facing older adults in Ontario:
Implications for government and policy makers using a descriptive data analytics
approach.
ATZEMA, C. L., YU, B., IVERS, N. M., ROCHON, P. A., LEE, D. S., SCHULL, M. J. &
AUSTIN, P. C. 2018. Predictors of obtaining follow-up care in the province of Ontario,
Canada, following a new diagnosis of atrial fibrillation, heart failure, and hypertension in
the emergency department. Canadian Journal of Emergency Medicine, 20, 377-391.
Canadian Mental Health Association. (n.d.). Local Health Integration Networks (LHIN) -
CMHA Fort Frances. CMHA Fort Frances. https://fortfrances.cmha.ca/lhin#:~:text=Local
%20Health%20Integration%20Networks%20(LHIN)%20is%20a%20network%20of
%20not,health%20services%20in%20April,%202007
DeClerq, K. (2022, December 8). Average er wait times in Ontario reaches New High, data
shows. Toronto. Retrieved January 19, 2023, from https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/average-er-
wait-times-in-ontario-reaches-new-high-data-shows-1.6185804#:~:text=On%20average
%2C%20about%2088%20per,first%20assessment%20by%20a%20doctor.
Gray, C. S., Berta, W., Deber, R. B., & Lum, J. (2014). Home and community care sector
accountability. Healthcare Policy, 10(SP), 56.
MacLeod, H. (2015, November). Local health integration networks: build on their purpose. In
Healthcare Management Forum (Vol. 28, No. 6, pp. 242-246). Sage CA: Los Angeles,
CA: SAGE Publications.
Migneault, J. (2015). LHIN falls short of performance indicators. Sudbury.com.
https://www.sudbury.com/local-news/lhin-falls-short-of-performance-indicators-259279
Sinn, C. L. J., Sultan, H., Turcotte, L. A., McArthur, C., & Hirdes, J. P. (2022). Patterns of home
care assessment and service provision before and during the COVID-19 pandemic in
Ontario, Canada. PLoS One, 17(3), e0266160.
Tea & Toast. (2021). Local Health Integration Network Gets a New Name | Blog | Tea & Toast.
Tea & Toast | Assisted Living & Retirement Search - Ottawa, ON.
https://www.teaandtoast.ca/blog/lhin-new-name#:~:text=Effective%20April
%201,%202021,%20subsidized,and%20Community%20Care%20Support%20Services.