Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Consequences of Sick Leave
Consequences of Sick Leave
The possible consequences of sick leave can be measured at different levels in society. This chapter focuses on the
consequences from the perspective of the sick-listed individual. Sick leave may have both positive and negative consequences
for the individual, e.g. regarding disease, health, working life, social life, lifestyle, and emotional aspects. Some of these
factors have been investigated in different studies. However, scientific evidence is insufficient since there are too few studies
on the consequences of sickness absence and disability pension. The lack of relevant studies is the most striking observation
from the review of studies on the consequences of being sick listed.
Eva Vingård, Section of Personal Injury Prevention, Karolinska Institutet, PO Box 12 718, SE-112 94 Stockholm, Sweden.
Tel: z46 8 545 7070, fax: z46 8 653 9413. E-mail: eva.vingard@cns.ki.se
# Taylor & Francis 2004. ISSN 1403-4956 Scand J Public Health 32 (Suppl 63)
DOI: 10.1080/14034950410021899
208 E Vingård et al.
Sickness absence is used as an outcome measure in . Career opportunities and personal finances may be
most studies of sickness absence. From the perspective influenced.
used here, we instead address sickness absence and/or
disability pension as exposures, where a consequence Social life
of sickness absence could be increased sickness
. Social contacts and activities with family, friends,
absence or more permanent absence such as disability
and colleagues may be influenced, for better or
pension.
worse, by sick leave. This may also have conse-
Theoretically, sick leave may have positive or
quences on social integration and participation in
negative consequences for the individual in terms of
society.
the dimensions described below. Most of these
have not been studied, and others may also exist.
Furthermore, it is conceivable that sick leave has no Lifestyle
effect at all on the individual, either desirable or
undesirable. . Both increased and decreased utilisation or abuse of
alcohol, drugs, or pharmaceuticals may be conse-
quences of sick leave.
Disease . Exercise, diet, tobacco use, and risk behaviour may
. The disease or injury leading to sick leave be changed by sick leave.
may improve during the sick-leave spell, or a
progressive course may be delayed due to the sick Emotional aspects
leave, or the disease may become worse because of
sick leave. . Stress and boredom may be a consequence of the
. Another disease may appear as a consequence situation during sick leave.
of sick leave, e.g. a depressed state may develop . Self-confidence, self-image, and self-awareness may
from the situation during sick leave, where be influenced, either positively or negatively from
death, e.g. due to suicide is the most extreme being on sick leave.
consequence.
. For various reasons, sickness absence in itself can Having short, recurrent spells of sick leave or being
lead to continued, prolonged sick leave and possibly placed on long-term sick leave means taking on a
disability pension. ‘‘sick’’ role, in one sense or another. This is often a
. Utilisation of health services and pharmaceuticals prolonged and complicated process, and has been
may increase or decrease as a consequence of sick described recently in two doctoral dissertations using
leave or disability pension. a qualitative approach (1, 2). Sick listing probably has
different consequences depending on whether an
individual has not yet established a sick role, if the
process has just started, or if a sick role is well
Health
established (the sick role is described in greater detail
. Health, e.g. in terms of well-being, ability to take in Chapter 1).
action, sense of meaning, or quality of life may
improve or become worse from a sick-leave spell. STUDIES ON THE CONSEQUENCES OF SICK
LEAVE
years (7,000 households interviewed per year). Basi- population register. Generally, the disability pension
cally, the findings of the study corresponded to those group reported a lower quality of life than the control
presented by Andrén (3), i.e. that long-term sickness group. Forty-five percent of those on disability
absence is associated with poorer wage trends, but pension, versus 83% in the control group, were
only for women according to Hansen’s study. The classified as having a good quality of life. Among
correlation was negative and significant, i.e. the higher those on disability pension, 34% reported that their
the sickness absence expressed in number of sick-leave quality of life had improved following disability
days the greater the reduction in wages. The total pension while 25% thought it had deteriorated.
explained variance was moderate (R2 corrected for Interviews were used to analyze what the study
degrees of freedom was 0.173). It was the subject’s participants included in the quality-of-life concept and
own sickness absence that resulted in lower wages the factors that were most important. Family relation-
after return to work. However, there was no such ships were in first place followed by health, relation-
correlation with absence due to caring for a sick child. ships outside the family and economy. Health aspects
For men, sickness absence or absence to care for a were important, and the lower value in the disability
sick child had no effect on wage trends. pension group can be explained by the lower self-
reported health in this group, not by the disability
pension itself. Adolescents and immigrants on dis-
SUMMARY ability pension were those reporting the lowest values.
Only a few of the possible consequences of sickness Individuals who reported that they were placed on
absence have been investigated. The only study that disability pension against their will had the lowest
addressed consequences such as inactivity, social quality of life.
isolation, depressed mood, and lower self-confidence
is an explorative, qualitative, cross-sectional study (2, Alcohol consumption and well-being
25). It shows that there is good reason to conduct Seventy-eight alcoholics who received disability pen-
studies on such aspects. A retrospective study on the sion between January 1978 and July 1979 were
risk factors for suicide (23), showing sick leave to be a examined when placed on disability pension and
risk factor in men, is such a study. again after two years (21). Two control groups were
The two Swedish studies on career and salary trends included in the study. One consisted of 30 non-
after sickness absence present mixed results. One of pensioned alcoholics and the other of 27 individuals
the studies shows that the greater the number of on disability pension for other diagnoses. After
sickness absence days, the lower the wage trend is for two years, 56, 29, and 23 subjects, respectively were
women (5). The other study found no association re-examined.
between sickness absence and wage per hour worked, During the follow-up period, alcohol consumption
but between sickness absence and the number of hours had declined somewhat among the alcoholics on
worked (3). Possibly, the lower working time is more a disability pension. They drank less frequently and
consequence of the health condition than a conse- consumed lower quantities. Self-reported well-being
quence of sickness absence. However, the results of had also increased after they had been placed on
the study are somewhat contradictory. disability pension. There were no major medical changes,
and social problems remained. The situation for the two
Evidence control groups had not changed more than marginally
Evidence on the consequences of sickness absence is between the two points of measurement.
insufficient because of too few studies.
Health, health service utilization, and alcohol
consumption
DISABILITY PENSION
An interview study from the early 1980s of 96 people
Quality of life on disability pension aged 45 – 64 years showed that
A Swedish study investigated the association between self-reported health was better following disability
disability pension and quality of life, measured as pension (24). Fifty percent of the men and 33% of the
self-reported, global quality of life (19). The study women reported this. Health service utilization also
group consisted of 450 individuals aged 25 – 59 years declined, as did self-reported alcohol consumption.
who were placed on full-time disability pension in A prospective Danish register study from 1989 – 1990
1986 – 1990 because of musculoskeletal disorders. investigated health service utilization during the year
Equally as many control individuals of the same age prior to application, the year of application and the year
without disability pension were selected from the following the application in individuals applying for
disability pension (20). The study covered 144 patients background variables change over time and are
diagnosed with chronic pain, in most cases of a non- different in different societies and social groups. The
specific nature. Health service utilization was high in available scientific studies should therefore be viewed
the year prior to disability pension application, as part of the period and context within which they
declined during the application time and declined have been conducted.
further in those who were granted pension. The It is often suggested in the current debate that long-
individuals who did not receive disability pension or term sick leave has a negative impact on the
did not receive pension at the level for which they had individual. From a scientific standpoint this assertion
applied increased their utilization of health services is poorly supported. Neither has it been demonstrated
again. that the current level of sick leave has a positive effect
on health.
Regarding the factors investigated in the studies
SUMMARY included here, questions can be raised about gener-
The results from these few studies point in different alisability and the strength of the associations.
directions as regards quality of life and well-being. Regarding career opportunities and economy, avail-
The study populations in the different studies are able studies indicate a negative impact from sick leave.
selected in different ways, regarding both diagnosis However, studies are few and of low quality, and
and gender. The largest study clearly showed that the hence there is no evidence supporting an association.
consequences varied among individuals, 34% reported, The Danish study that investigated risk factors for
e.g. that their quality of life had improved and 25% suicide was well executed, but it reflects the limitations
reported that it had deteriorated. of register studies (23). The evaluation of what the
study subjects were exposed to is relatively general
and covers only some of the information available
Evidence
in official registries. The number exposed was not
Evidence on the consequences of disability pension is reported, only the odds ratios. Regarding the
insufficient because of too few studies. association with sickness absence, it is unclear whether
the sickness absence itself, or the underlying disease
for which the individual is sick listed, is of
DISCUSSION
importance.
As discussed, sickness absence has consequences at In a study of alcoholics, improved well-being and
different structural levels. Here the focus is on quality of life was a consequence of disability pension
consequences for the sick-listed individual, i.e. the (21). According to another study of individuals with
type of consequences, advantages and disadvantages musculoskeletal disorders, the consequences of dis-
that the sick-listing physician must directly address. ability pension were lower quality of life for some, and
Sick leave is a relatively common prescription/ better quality of life for others (19). Since self-
intervention for disease, injury, and ill health. There perceived health is such an important part of the
may be several reasons that one chooses sick quality-of-life measure used, it is difficult to isolate the
leave, e.g.: consequences for quality of life relative to sick leave
or disability pension per se, from the consequences
. The disease or injury makes it impossible for the
from the disease that led to the sick leave or disability
patient to work.
pension. Being placed on disability pension against
. Sick leave enables rest and recovery.
one’s will had the greatest negative consequences.
. Sick leave enables the patient to participate in
In two studies, health service utilization declined
examinations, treatment, and/or rehabilitation
when sick leave progressed to disability pension (20,
interventions.
24). This can reflect the fact that applicants must
. Because of the disease, e.g. infection, the patient
prove their functional impairment by seeking care
should not be at the workplace even if the work
prior to the application. Likewise, when it is not
ability is not impaired.
approved, they must visit a physician to receive
. Conditions at the workplace cause disease in the
further sickness certificates. Also, the psychological
patient.
stress of sick listing, and uncertainty about having it
The scope and consequences of sick leave are prolonged or having the application rejected, may
influenced by, e.g. factors in society, such as norms, cause problems that require more health services.
labor market conditions, the social situation of the In people with severe alcohol abuse, alcohol intake
individual, and the attitudes of health care providers declined after being placed on disability pension (21).
toward the disease or injury and its treatment. These There may be many reasons for this, but the most
prominent is thought to be the increased security and The few studies that have been conducted have
social position that disability pension brings to this several qualitative deficiencies. However, from the
vulnerable group. Another study also reported lower studies available, there is reason to assume that
alcohol consumption after subjects were placed on the consequences can vary with the individual’s
disability pension (24). The extent to which this is a situation in terms of diagnosis, age, gender, ethnicity,
consequence of disability pension itself, of having less co-morbidity, and life situation. The consequences
money, of another social life, of reduced tolerance studied need to be more clearly operationalised. The
due to advanced alcoholism, or due to other serious study design should be developed in terms of
disease that makes alcohol consumption impossible, differentiating the consequences of sick leave/disability
has not been studied. pension from the consequences of, e.g. disease or
injury that led to sick leave. To be useful, the exposure
factors, i.e. sickness absence or disability pension,
need to be further clarified as regards, e.g. degree and
CONCLUSIONS AND SUMMARY
duration as well as type of activity/intervention during
The few studies available on the consequences of sick sick leave.
leave are mainly small, low-quality, register studies Many practicing physicians prescribe sick leave
conducted years ago, and in most cases directed at every day. The intervention is costly for society and
the consequences of disability pension. The factors for most individuals. Hence, it is remarkable that
studied in relation to the consequences of sick leave there is virtually no evidence-based information for
for the individual are: personal finances, career decision making or about the consequences of sick
opportunities, inactivity, isolation, quality of life, leave itself.
self-reported health, health service utilization, and
substance abuse. In all of these studies, the association
with sick leave is not beyond dispute. There are too Need for specific knowledge
few studies in each area to build a foundation of Most of the studies assessed have measured the
scientific evidence demonstrating either positive or consequences of sick leave at a very general level.
negative consequences of sick leave or disability Both physicians and patients need more scientific
pension for the individual. information at a more specific level. What are the
The research field addressing ‘‘consequences of sick potential positive and negative consequences for
leave’’ is inadequately investigated. However, this field patients – considering age, gender, occupation,
is difficult to study since the consequences of the work tasks, and with a particular disease and degree
underlying functional impairments or diseases that of severity – of being sick listed, e.g. one versus three
lead to sick leave are difficult to distinguish from the weeks? Full time or part time? When can one expect
consequences of the sick leave itself. Furthermore, to see the potentially negative effects? How can they
sick leave and disability pension can be of different be identified and counteracted? It is also possible that
levels and duration, which further complicates the consequences vary substantially among different
research efforts. individuals.
Author, Year
(Ref no.) Design
Country Data Study period Exposure Outcome No. in study population Results Quality
Andrén 2001 Prospective cohort. 1983 – 1991 Sick leave Annual salary, 1,688 randomly Long-term sick leave Low
(3) Sweden Register hours worked, selected, with influences income
hourly wage sickness benefit after return-to-work,
insurance, 16 – 64 y not due to lower
hourly wage but due to
less time worked
Edén 1998 Case – control. 1986 – 1990 Disability Quality of life 450 on disability pension Quality of life Low
(19) Sweden Survey Interviews pension 450 controls in a survey lower in those with
and later interview of 29 disability pension
subjects with higher than in controls.
quality of life and Quality of life improved
26 subjects with lower after disability pension
quality of life
Hansen 2000 Prospective cohort. 1991 – 1992 Sick leave Annual salary 7,000 households/year Longer sick leave Low
(5) Sweden Register resulted in lower
salary for women
but not for men
after return-to-work.
No effect on salary
213
Scand J Public Health 32 (Suppl 63)
214
E Vingård et al.
Table 9.I. (Continued )
Author, Year
(Ref no.) Design
Country Data Study period Exposure Outcome No. in study population Results Quality
Judiesch 1999 Prospective cohort. 1990 – 1995 Sick listing Career 11 762 managers Absence periods Low
(22) USA Register had negative effect
on career
Ockander 2001 Cross-sectional. 1994 – 1996 Sick-listingw60 Inactivity and 82 women with long-term Sick leave eventually Low
(25) Sweden Interview, survey, days or isolation sick leave or disability resulted in inactivity,
qualitative analyses disability pension pain, and isolation
pension
Qin 2000 Retrospective 1982 – 1994 Sick leavew3 Suicide 811 suicide cases Sick leave increased Medium
(23) Denmark case – control. weeks 79,871 controls suicide risk in men
Register but not in women
Svenman 1984 Cross-sectional. 1979 – 1980 Disability Health, activity, 96 on disability pension, Somewhat better Low
(24) Sweden Structured pension economy, 45 – 64 y health after disability
interviews alcohol use pension, otherwise no
differences
Consequences of being on sick leave 215