GA DRAWING OF LIQUID NITROGEN TANKS

HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORPORATION LIMITED

VISAKH REFINERY

ENGINEERS INDIA LIMITED, NEW DELHI

(A Govt. of India Undertaking)

LINDE INDIA LIMITED, KOLKATA

THEIS DRAWING AND THE VISAKH REFINERY MODERNIZATION

COPYRIGHT THEREIN ARE
PROJECT PROJECT (VRMP)
THE PROPERTY OF BOC INDIA
LIMITED AND ALL COMPRESSED AIR & CRYOGENIC NITROGEN
INFORMATION WHICH IT PLANT PLANT PACKAGE
CONTAINING IS CONFI-
DENTIAL THE DRAWING EIL JOB NO B016
MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED
EIL TENDER
OR DISCLOSED NOR MUST B016-609-80-43-PF-T-4010
ANY INFORMATION TAKEN NO
THERE FROM BE DISCLOSED
WITHOUT THE PRIOR DOC.TITLE GA DRAWING OF LIQUID NITROGEN TANKS
CONSENT IN WRITING OF BOC
INDIA LIMITED
Internal do
&BB 7189 B-ZC-609-T-101A~E(EN)
no.
01-MAY-2018
DOC. No HPCL-47000189-ME-016
AJEET KUMAR (B565)
DOC.
R REV 1
CATEGORY

Page 1 of 19
 Linde CLARIFICATION SHEET

DOCUMENT GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF LIQUID NITROGEN STORAGE VESSEL (HPCL-47000189-ME-016_R0)

Doc. No. SR NO. Comments by Client (EIL) Linde to reply

All dimensions/ details shown in the GA drawing shall be

as per approved mechanical design calculation.
1 Comments marked on the mechanical design calculation Noted.
shall also be suitably incorporated in GAD. M/s Lined/
Inox to ensure the same.

Site Specific Seismic Spectra (Doc. no. B016-000-16-54-

DB-0001) shall also be considered for mechanical design
2 Noted and Incorporated in calculations
calculation/GAD preparation. Accordingly, reference of
the above document shall be mentioned in GAD.
Include LIN Tank Tag No., Quantity and indicate net Tag no included. Net capacity is already indicated in inner vessel design
3
capacity of the LIN Tanks in the table. data.
Lined/ Inox to clarify how the weight of Inner Vessel is
Inner vessel weight is transferred to outer vessel through strap supports.
4 transferred to the skirt? Support details of Inner Vessel
Strap support is shown in elevation view.
shall be included in the drawing.
Lined/ Inox to clarify how equal spacing/ concentricity
Inner vessel and outer vessel concentricity is maintained through pipe
between two vessels is maintained to have uniform
5 suspension at bottom & top part of inner vessel. Same is shown in
thickness of perlite insulation? Please furnish details in
Elevation view.
the drawing.
Lined Nozzle Tag No. & INOX Nozzle Tag No. for a given
INOX has established philosophy for Nozzle no. Hence INOX & LINDE
service shall be same. Nozzle corresponding vessel (Inner
nozzle tag no. is provided in Nozzle table.
6 Vessel or Outer Vessel) shall also be indicated against
Outer vessel nozzle no. will be included in drawing.
each nozzle. Also, include nozzle load details in the
Please provided Nozzle load to be considered for design.
drawing.
Location of nozzles shall also be shown in the elevation It is not possible to show nozzles in GA drawing. Request to refer
7
view of the tank. Individual vessel drawing (inner vessel & outer vessel).
Reference EIL Standards/ Specification/ Documents shall
8 Noted.
also be listed.
Inspection shall be carried out in line with approved item
9 Noted.
categorisation plan.
V21110A-V-001_R0 Lined to ensure that orientation plans of the tank shown
10 is in line with approved plot plan for compressed air & Noted
Cryogenic N2 Plant.
11 Other comments as marked. Noted.
Inner vessel Operating Pressure
As per design out of 5 Tanks one will be in filling and other will be in
The LIN storage tank operating pressure is indicated as
withdrawal mode. The tank which will be in filling mode will be kept at
8.5 kg/cm2(g) where as cold box outlet LIN pressure
12 6.5 Kg/cm2g and the tank which will be in consumption mode will be kept
(downstream of sub-cooler) is 7.2 kg/cm2(g). Lined to
at pressure at 8.5 Kg/cm2g. This operation philosophy will facilitate in
clarify how LIN flow from cold box to LIN storage tank is
filling and consumption at two different pressures.
possible in this scenario.
Inner Vessel Design Temp:
13 Noted.
+65 Deg C as per approved PFD. Please check & correct.
14 CCOE/ PESO/ Noted.
As per clause no. 5.4 of EIL spec 6-12-0001 Rev.5. Min. spot radiography of
5% is required. Hence INOX has considered 100% radiography for L-seam,
15 1 for full radiography, check & correct? T joints & Dish end and 5% for all c-seams.
Accordingly joint efficiency is 1 for all L-seam & dish joints and 0.85 for all
c- seam except backing strip joint and 0.8 for backing strip c-seam.
16 INOX+TPI (TPI name to be also mentioned) Noted. BV is the TPI and Indicated in the drawing
Outer Vessel Design Temp:
17 Noted.
+65 Deg C as per approved PFD. Please check & correct.
18 +TPI (TPI name to be also mentioned) Noted. BV shall be indicated.
Note #
Check? Extent of Radiography of C-Seam shall be
19 considered as per code requirement. Indicated Joint Refer our reply in Sr. no. 15.
efficacy for C-Seam shall be accordingly checked &
corrected.
Note ##
20 Refer our reply in Sr. no. 15.
1 for full radiography, check & correct?
DOCUMENT GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND DETAIL OF INNER VESSEL (HPCL-47000189-ME-016B_R0)

Doc. No. SR NO. Comments by Client (EIL) INOX Reply

NOTE B1:
01-MAY-2018 Impact test temp of -196 Deg C & min. lateral expansion of 0.38 mm shall
V21110A-V-023_R0 1 IMPACT TEST CONDITINS LIKE TEMPERATURE, IMPACT
be indicated.
ENERGY ETC. SHALL ALSO BE SPECIFIED.
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 2 of 19
01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 3 of 19
01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 4 of 19
01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 5 of 19
01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 6 of 19
Page 7 of 19

CLIENT : LINDE, INDIA

DATE : 24.03.2018
CLARIFICATION SHEET

DOCUMENT GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND DETAIL OF INNER VESSEL (HPCL-47000189-ME-016B_R0)

Issue
Doc. No. SR NO. Comments by Client (EIL) INOX Reply Client Reply
(Open / Close)
NOTE B1:
Impact test temp of -196 Deg C & min. lateral expansion of 0.38 mm shall
V21110A-V-023_R0 1 IMPACT TEST CONDITINS LIKE TEMPERATURE, IMPACT
be indicated.
ENERGY ETC. SHALL ALSO BE SPECIFIED.

01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)
01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 8 of 19
01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 9 of 19
 Refer attached commented drawing.

01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 10 of 19
 GA DRAWING OF LIQUID NITROGEN TANKS

HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORPORATION LIMITED

VISAKH REFINERY

ENGINEERS INDIA LIMITED, NEW DELHI

(A Govt. of India Undertaking)

LINDE INDIA LIMITED, KOLKATA

THEIS DRAWING AND THE VISAKH REFINERY MODERNIZATION

COPYRIGHT THEREIN ARE
PROJECT PROJECT (VRMP)
THE PROPERTY OF BOC INDIA
LIMITED AND ALL COMPRESSED AIR & CRYOGENIC NITROGENDrawing Revision No. marked
INFORMATION WHICH IT PLANT PLANT PACKAGE here is not matching with what
CONTAINING IS CONFI- is marked on the drawings.
DENTIAL THE DRAWING EIL JOB NO B016
MUST NOT BE REPRODUCED Please check & correct to
EIL TENDER
OR DISCLOSED NOR MUST B016-609-80-43-PF-T-4010 maintain uniformity.
ANY INFORMATION TAKEN NO
THERE FROM BE DISCLOSED
WITHOUT THE PRIOR DOC.TITLE GA DRAWING OF LIQUID NITROGEN TANKS
CONSENT IN WRITING OF BOC
INDIA LIMITED
Internal do
&BB 7189 B-ZC-609-T-101A~E(EN)
no.
01-MAY-2018
DOC. No HPCL-47000189-ME-016
AJEET KUMAR (B565)
DOC. RECORDS REV
R 1
CATEGORY

Page 11 of 19
 Linde CLARIFICATION SHEET

DOCUMENT GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF LIQUID NITROGEN STORAGE VESSEL (HPCL-47000189-ME-016_R0)

Doc. No. SR NO. Comments by Client (EIL) Linde to reply

All dimensions/ details shown in the GA drawing shall be

as per approved mechanical design calculation.
1 Comments marked on the mechanical design calculation Noted.
shall also be suitably incorporated in GAD. M/s Lined/
Inox to ensure the same.

Site Specific Seismic Spectra (Doc. no. B016-000-16-54-

DB-0001) shall also be considered for mechanical design
2 Noted and Incorporated in calculations
calculation/GAD preparation. Accordingly, reference of
the above document shall be mentioned in GAD.
Include LIN Tank Tag No., Quantity and indicate net Tag no included. Net capacity is already indicated in inner vessel design
3
capacity of the LIN Tanks in the table. data.
Lined/ Inox to clarify how the weight of Inner Vessel is
Inner vessel weight is transferred to outer vessel through strap supports.
4 transferred to the skirt? Support details of Inner Vessel
Strap support is shown in elevation view.
shall be included in the drawing.
Lined/ Inox to clarify how equal spacing/ concentricity Include strap support
Inner vessel and outer vessel concentricity is maintained through pipe
between two vessels is maintained to have uniform
5 suspension at bottom & top part of inner vessel. Same is shown in details in the drawing.
thickness of perlite insulation? Please furnish details in
Elevation view.
the drawing.
Lined Nozzle Tag No. & INOX Nozzle Tag No. for a given
INOX has established philosophy for Nozzle no. Hence INOX & LINDE
service shall be same. Nozzle corresponding vessel (Inner
nozzle tag no. is provided in Nozzle table.
6 Vessel or Outer Vessel) shall also be indicated against
Outer vessel nozzle no. will be included in drawing.
each nozzle. Also, include nozzle load details in the
Please provided Nozzle load to be considered for design.
drawing.
LINDE to update their
Location of nozzles shall also be shown in the elevation It is not possible to show nozzles in GA drawing. Request to refer
7 documents considering same
view of the tank. Individual vessel drawing (inner vessel & outer vessel).
Reference EIL Standards/ Specification/ Documents shall nozzle nos. as considered by
8 Noted.
also be listed.
Inspection shall be carried out in line with approved item INOX. Also, nozzle load details
9 Noted.
categorisation plan. to be included in the drawing.
V21110A-V-001_R0 Lined to ensure that orientation plans of the tank shown
10 is in line with approved plot plan for compressed air & Noted
Cryogenic N2 Plant.
11 Other comments as marked. Noted.
Inner vessel Operating Pressure
As per design out of 5 Tanks one will be in filling and other will be in
The LIN storage tank operating pressure is indicated as
withdrawal mode. The tank which will be in filling mode will be kept at
8.5 kg/cm2(g) where as cold box outlet LIN pressure
12 6.5 Kg/cm2g and the tank which will be in consumption mode will be kept
(downstream of sub-cooler) is 7.2 kg/cm2(g). Lined to
at pressure at 8.5 Kg/cm2g. This operation philosophy will facilitate in
clarify how LIN flow from cold box to LIN storage tank is
filling and consumption at two different pressures.
possible in this scenario.
Inner Vessel Design Temp:
13 Noted.
+65 Deg C as per approved PFD. Please check & correct.
14 CCOE/ PESO/ Noted.
As per clause no. 5.4 of EIL spec 6-12-0001 Rev.5. Min. spot radiography of
5% is required. Hence INOX has considered 100% radiography for L-seam,
15 1 for full radiography, check & correct? T joints & Dish end and 5% for all c-seams.
Accordingly joint efficiency is 1 for all L-seam & dish joints and 0.85 for all
c- seam except backing strip joint and 0.8 for backing strip c-seam.
16 INOX+TPI (TPI name to be also mentioned) Noted. BV is the TPI and Indicated in the drawing
Outer Vessel Design Temp:
17 Noted.
+65 Deg C as per approved PFD. Please check & correct.
18 +TPI (TPI name to be also mentioned) Noted. BV shall be indicated.
Note #
Check? Extent of Radiography of C-Seam shall be
19 considered as per code requirement. Indicated Joint Refer our reply in Sr. no. 15.
efficacy for C-Seam shall be accordingly checked &
corrected.
Note ##
20 Refer our reply in Sr. no. 15.
1 for full radiography, check & correct?
DOCUMENT GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND DETAIL OF INNER VESSEL (HPCL-47000189-ME-016B_R0)

Doc. No. SR NO. Comments by Client (EIL) INOX Reply

NOTE B1:
01-MAY-2018 Impact test temp of -196 Deg C & min. lateral expansion of 0.38 mm shall
V21110A-V-023_R0 1 IMPACT TEST CONDITINS LIKE TEMPERATURE, IMPACT
be indicated.
ENERGY ETC. SHALL ALSO BE SPECIFIED.
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 12 of 19
 Hydrotest pressure shall be minimum
1.3 times of the design pressure.
Please check & correct. Design
Calculation shall also be accordingly
checked & corrected.

Weld seams of all dished ends shall be 100% radiographed after forming & heat
treatment, if any as per EIL Standard Specification No. 6-12-0001/6-12-0030.
Please check & correct.

Add the following in the table: "Standard Specification for

pressure vessels for package items (Document No.
6-12-0030, Rev. No. 7".

B016
0

Strap Support for

Inner Vessel?
Furnish the details
of the same.

Show cleat details for all external

attachments.

Refer & incorporate EIL Comment marked earlier regarding

01-MAY-2018
nozzles. Nozzles specific to Outer Vessel only shall also be clearly
AJEET KUMAR (B565) identified.

Page 13 of 19
 Add reference of Site Specific
Seismic Spectra (Doc. No.
B016-000-16-54-DB-0001)
also in the table.

01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 14 of 19
 Refer & incorporate EIL Comment marked
earlier regarding nozzles. Also Nozzles
N11 to N16 are not appearing in the Linde
Drawing No. HPCL-47000189-ME-016.
Please check/ correct.

01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 15 of 19
01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 16 of 19
Page 17 of 19

CLIENT : LINDE, INDIA

DATE : 24.03.2018
CLARIFICATION SHEET

DOCUMENT GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND DETAIL OF INNER VESSEL (HPCL-47000189-ME-016B_R0)

Issue
Doc. No. SR NO. Comments by Client (EIL) INOX Reply Client Reply
(Open / Close)
NOTE B1:
V21110A-V-023_R0 1 IMPACT TEST CONDITINS LIKE TEMPERATURE, IMPACT
Impact test temp of -196 Deg C & min. lateral expansion of 0.38 mm shall Noted
be indicated.
ENERGY ETC. SHALL ALSO BE SPECIFIED.

01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)
 Refer & incorporate EIL Comment marked earlier
regarding nozzles. Nozzles specific to Outer Vessel
only shall also be clearly identified.

01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 18 of 19
01-MAY-2018
AJEET KUMAR (B565)

Page 19 of 19