Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled, Randomised Study of Single Dose Effects of ADAPT-232 On Cognitive Functions
Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled, Randomised Study of Single Dose Effects of ADAPT-232 On Cognitive Functions
Phytomedicine
journal homepage: www.elsevier.de/phymed
a r t i c l e in f o a b s t r a c t
The aim of this study was to assess the effect of a single dose of ADAPT-232 (a standardised fixed
Keywords: combination of Rhodiola rosea L., Schisandra chinensis (Turcz.) Baill., and Eleutherococcus senticosus
Adaptogens Maxim) extracts on mental performance, such as attention, speed and accuracy, in tired individuals
Rhodiola rosea performing stressful cognitive tasks.
Schisandra chinensis The pilot study (phase IIa) clinical trial took the form of a double-blind, placebo-controlled,
Eleutherococcus senticosus randomised, with two parallel groups. Forty healthy females aged between 20-68 years, who claimed to
Mental performance have felt stressed over a long period of time due to living under psychologically stressful conditions
Attention
were selected to participate in the pilot study. In addition, a Stroop Colour-Word test (Stroop CW) was
Accuracy
used to exhaust/prepare the volunteers prior to the d2 test used for assessment of cognitive function of
Speed
patients.
The participants were randomised into two groups, one (n = 20) of which received a single tablet of
ADAPT-232 (270 mg), while a second (n =20) received a single tablet of placebo.
The effects of the extract were measured prior to treatment and two hours after treatment using the
d2 Test of Attention (d2). The results of the d2 test showed a significant difference (p o 0.05) in
attention, speed, and accuracy (TN-E scores) between the two treatment groups. The subjects in the
ADAPT-232 group quickly (two hours after verum was taken) gained improved attention and increased
speed and accuracy during stressful cognitive tasks, in comparison to placebo. There was also a
tendency of ADAPT-232 to reduce percentage of errors, which means better accuracy, quality of the
work, and degree of care in the volunteers under stressful conditions. No serious side effects were
reported, although a few minor adverse events, such as sleepiness and cold extremities, were observed
in both treatment groups.
& 2010 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
Introduction (Panossian et al., 1999; Olsson et al., 2009; Panossian et al., 2007;
Panossian and Wikman, 2008; Panossian and Wikman, 2010).
A group of herbal preparations known collectively as adapto- A single dose application of adaptogens is important in situations,
gens (Brekhman and Dardymov, 1969; Panossian et al., 1999; which requires a rapid response to tension or to a stressful
Panossian, 2004) can increase tolerance to mental exhaustion and situation (Panossian and Wagner, 2005). Additionally, a single
may enhance attention in cases of decreased performance, such as administration of these adaptogens increases mental performance
in fatigue and in the sensation of weakness (Olsson et al., 2009; and physical working capacity in humans (Panossian and Wagner,
Panossian and Wikman, 2009; Panossian and Wikman, 2010). The 2005).
beneficial effects of multi-dose administration of adaptogens are The use of herbal preparations derived from Rhodiola rosea L,
mainly associated with the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, a Schizandra chinensis (Turcz.) Baill. and Eleutherococcus senticosus
part of the stress-system that is believed to play a primary role in Maxim. is not generally associated with deleterious side effects. In
the reactions of the body to repeated stress and adaptation contrast, traditional stimulants may cause addiction, tolerance
and abuse, and give rise to negative effects on sleep structure,
thus cause rebound hypersomnolence or ’’come down’’ effects.
n
ADAPT-232 is a standardised fixed combination of extracts of
Corresponding author:
E-mail addresses: gayane@pharm.am (G. Aslanyan), elmira@pharm.am
R. rosea, S. chinensis and E. senticosus. The aim of the present
(E. Amroyan), egabri@pharm.am (E. Gabrielyan), ma.n@swipnet.se (M. Nylander), double-blind, parallel-group, randomised, pilot (phase IIa) study
christina.holm@shi.se (G. Wikman), alexander.panossian@shi.se (A. Panossian). was to evaluate the effect of a single dose of ADAPT-232 on
0944-7113/$ - see front matter & 2010 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.phymed.2010.02.005
ARTICLE IN PRESS
G. Aslanyan et al. / Phytomedicine 17 (2010) 494–499 495
mental performance, such as attention, speed, and accuracy, on three days was carefully explained to all volunteers. The selected
tired subjects performing stressful cognitive tasks. participants, who also accepted the trial protocol, were included
in the double-blind comparative study. Written informed consent
was obtained from each participant in accordance with the
Subjects and Methods revised declaration of Helsinki (World Medical Association
Declaration of Helsinki, 2000).
The study protocols were reviewed and approved by the
Ethics Committee of the Armenian Drug and Medical Technology
Agency of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Armenia. Study drugs
The pilot study involved 40 patients and was carried out at the
Department of Clinical Pharmacology of the National Institute The study drugs were manufactured according to Good
of Health (Yerevan, Armenia) between January and February Manufacturing Practice (GMP) by the Swedish Herbal Institute
2008. (Gothenburg, Sweden) and presented in the form of tablets.
The ADAPT-232 (batch 1121) tablets comprised a fixed combina-
Study population tion of dried extracts from roots of R. rosea (drug extract
ratio 2.8:1; extraction solvent 70% ethanol), berries of S. chinensis
The study population included healthy female volunteers (drug extract ratio 1.4:1; extraction solvent 95% ethanol) and
(nurses, doctors and teachers), which were recruited from a roots of E. senticosus (drug extract ratio 10.5:1; extraction solvent
polyclinic, a school and a hospital close to the Department of 70% ethanol), and had been standardised with respect to
Clinical Pharmacology. The included individuals, aged between rhodioloside (0.32%), rosavin, (0.5%), tyrosol (0.05%) schizandrin
20-68 years, had experienced stress over a long period of time due (0.37%), g-schizandrin (0.24%) and eleutherosides B and E (0.15%).
to living under psychologically stressful conditions. The verum was presented as a single 420 mg tablet, which
Pregnant or breast-feeding subjects; individuals with identi- contains 270 mg of ADAPT-232.
fied medical conditions (e.g. HIV, cancer or cardiovascular, joint, The amounts of the active ingredients were determined by
liver, kidney or psychiatric diseases); those diagnosed with analytical RP-HPLC using an acetonitrile-water gradient system as
psychiatric problems; those presenting allergic reactions to herbal mobile phase. The peaks were detected by UV-PAD (Fig. 1) and the
products; those who had used adaptogens within the previous analytes were quantified at 221 nm (rhodioloside and tyrosol),
two months or corticosteroids within the previous 6 months; 252 nm (rosavin), 220 nm (eleutheroside B), and 210 nm
those misusing tranquillisers, pain killing drugs or narcotics; (eleutheroside E, schizandrin and g-schizandrin). All the
those suffering from caffeine withdrawal syndrome or were heavy analytical methods were validated for selectivity, peak purity,
coffee drinkers; and those subjects who were deemed to be precision (RSD o5%) and accuracy in the range 50 - 150% of the
unwilling to cooperate or unable to participate in the study were target amounts of analytes in accordance with International
excluded. Conference on Harmonisation (ICH) guidelines (International
The strict requirement to avoid coffee during the complete Conference on Harmonization, 1995) using Effi Validation 3
period of the trial and to abstain from alcohol and caffeine for software (version 1.03) for testing and calibration laboratories
a minimum of one day prior to the testing session on the subject to EN ISO/IEC 17 025:2001 (International Organisation for
morning of the first day of the trial and throughout the following Standardisation, 2001).
CH3O OCH3
Triandrin Rt
0.18 HO
O
OCH3
10.43 O
HO OMe
0.16 HO OH γ-Schizandrin Rt 75.21
0.14 H
CH3
Rosavin Rt 23.56 OH
0.12 HO
O O
CH3O CH3
Eleutheroside B OH
0.10 O O
Rt 10.88 OH CH3O
0.08 MeO HO CH3O
HO CH3O OCH3
0.06 Glc-O OH OH OCH3
0.04 MeO
0.02
0.00
250.00
300.00
λ.
nm
350.00
5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 35.00 40.00 45.00 50.00 55.00 60.00 65.00 70.00 75.00 80.00
Minutes
Study design
Evaluation of primary and secondary endpoints,
The selected participants were divided into two equal evaluation of the affect of learning and degree
groups (n= 20) using a simple randomisation procedure. Group of tiredness
A received tablets containing ADAPT-232, whilst the negative
control (Group B) received identical-looking tablets containing
placebo. The identification number of each participant and the
drug code number (this was encoded in a table of random
numbers, which were generated at the production site under the ADAPT Placebo
control of quality assurance personnel and kept unbroken
until the end of the study) were recorded in a protocol and in
the Case Report Form (CRF), in order to allow subsequent
identification. Information about the placebo and the verum Administration of single dose
became known to the statistician, investigators and volunteers
only after completion of the study and final statistical analysis of
the results.
On Day 1, the subjects were examined medically and assessed
for base-line primary and secondary stress-related endpoints Two hours later,
by psychometric tests conducted in the morning (9 - 10 am) evaluation of primary endpoints and single dose effect
when patients were not tired (Tm1). On day 2, the tests were
repeated in the morning (Tm2) and afternoon ( 4 pm
when subjects were supposedly tired; Ta2), and the degree of
tiredness was evaluated by comparing the results of Tm2 and Ta2,
while the effects of learning were assessed by comparison of the
results of Tm1 and Tm2. In the afternoon ( 4 pm) of day 3, a single Monitoring of data.
dose of the study drug (ADAPT-232) or of placebo was Analysis of results.
administered and the effects were evaluated 2 h later by Report of study.
psychometric tests (Ta3). A schematic diagram of the trial is
displayed in Chart 1. Chart 1. Schematic diagram of the design of the trial .
d2 test
Methodology
This test is a valid measure of selective attention and is
sensitive to the speed and quality of performance (Brickenkamp
The efficacy of the treatment was evaluated by psychometric and Zillmer, 1998) with following parameters:
tests, which assessed the state of functional components of
mental activity, such as short-term memory, attention (stability
and intensity), speed and accuracy. Participants were set the task (i) Total number of items processed (TN) – is a quantitative
of completing forms, with a pencil, associated with the d2 Test of measure of performance in terms of all items processed (both
Attention (d2) and the Stroop Colour-Word (Stroop CW) tests. relevant and irrelevant). TN is highly reliable and measures
Stroop CW is a cognitive aspects of mental disorders such as brain attention, processing speed, amount of work completed, and
damage, attention deficit, hyperactivity disorder, dementias. It is motivation. Keys 1 and 2 were used for scoring.
also used as a stressfull cognitive task for measuring stress (ii) Errors of omission (E1 - under-inclusion) - occur when
response, such as arterial blood pressure, heart rate, etc. relevant items (’’d’’ with two dashes) are not crossed out.
(Facchinetti et al., 2002). At the start of the test, subjects signed Under-inclusion is a relatively common mistake and is
their forms and were given the appropriate instructions. A strict sensitive to attention control, rule compliance, accuracy of
time limit (measured using a stop-watch) was allowed for the visual scanning and quality of performance. Key 1 was used
completion of the tests. Subsequently, the results were checked to determine the number of mistakes of omission.
with the help of keys, which have scales in the upper and the (iii) Errors of commission (E2 – over-inclusion) - occur when
lower lines that make it possible to read numbers of processed irrelevant letters are crossed out in contravention of the
letters easily and quickly. instructions. Over-inclusion is related to ability to focus, rule
ARTICLE IN PRESS
G. Aslanyan et al. / Phytomedicine 17 (2010) 494–499 497
compliance, accuracy of visual scanning, care, and cognitive Clinical Practice (GCP) by an independent monitor that visited the
flexibility. Key 2 was used to score the errors of commission. study site on the first and third day of the trial. Thus, adherence to
(iv) Raw error score (E= E1+ E2) – represents the total number of the study protocol, performance of the psychometric tests,
errors committed and is a preliminary statistic for computing completeness and accuracy of the CRFs, and the overall conduct
other parameters. of the trial was verified.
P P
(v) Percentage of errors (E%= 100 (E1+ E2)/ N) - is a variable
measuring the qualitative aspects of performance and Statistical methods
proportion of errors made, in terms of all items processed.
The smaller the value of E%, the better is the accuracy, quality
Standard methods were used to calculate the mean, standard
of the work, and degree of care.
error of the mean and standard deviation values of the scores in
(vi) Total number of items processed minus raw error score (TN – E)
the psychometric tests. The significance of differences between
– is a highly reliable parameter that measures the amount of
groups A and B were evaluated using Student t-tests. The
work completed after a single correction for errors, in terms
significance of the differences in test scores (day 1 versus day 2;
of ability to focus, and the relationship between speed and
morning versus afternoon on day 2; day 2 versus day 3) within
accuracy.
each group, and of the mean test scores (both before and after
treatment) between groups, were determined using one-way
Stroop CW test ANOVA with Tukey multiple comparison post tests. Data manage-
ment and calculations were performed with GraphPad (San Diego,
Stroop CW is used to measure stressful cognitive tasks and CA, USA) Prism software (version 3.03 for Windows).
stress responses, such as arterial blood pressure and heart rate,
etc. (Facchinetti et al., 2002). In the present study, a test or
manual (30150M) for clinical and experimental application was Results
employed (Golden and Freshwater, 2002). This test was based on
three pages, which each contained five columns of 20 items, in A total of 40 females aged between 20 and 68 (mean age
total 100 items. The following parameters were employed: ADAPT-232: 42.7; mean age placebo: 45.4) completed the trial
and none reported adverse reactions to the medication adminis-
(i) Word score (W) - is the number of items (words) completed tered. Although, one subject from the ADAPT group reported cold
in a set time (45 s). The ‘‘word page’’ consists of the words extremities after treatment and one subject from each of the
’’RED’’, ’’GREEN’’ and ’’BLUE’’, which were arranged randomly groups claimed that treatment had caused severe sleepiness. In
and printed in black ink on a white background. The objective addition, one subject from the treatment group reported an
was to choose the word that matched the colour printed at improvement in sleep following medication.
the top of the page. All participants were submitted to stressful cognitive tasks
(ii) Colour score (C) - is the number of items (coloured symbols) (Stroop CW and d2 tests), four times over three consecutive days
completed in a set time (45 s). The ‘‘colour page’’ consists of (Day 1: in the morning when subjects were not tired; Day 2: in
100 items, all written as XXXX, printed in either red, green, or the morning when subjects were not tired and in the afternoon
blue ink on a white background. The objective was to choose when subjects were tired; Day 3: in the afternoon, two hours after
the coloured symbols that matched the word at the top of the treatment with ADAPT or placebo, when subjects were tired).
page. Repeated testing in the mornings of days 1 and 2 allowed the
(iii) Colour-word score (CW) - is the number of items (coloured effect of learning (Table 1; Fig. 2), which were subsequently
words) completed in a set time (45 s). The ‘‘colour-word excluded from the overall results. The degree of tiredness in the
page’’ consists of words from the ‘‘word page’’ printed in afternoon of day 2 was assessed by comparing these results with
colours from the ‘‘colour page’’. The objective was to choose those obtained in the morning of the same day (Table 2; Fig. 2). It
the colour in which the word at the top of the page was was seen that there was a concomitant increase in the d2 test
written, rather than the colour that the word names. score due to learning and that tiredness decreased the score in the
afternoon test. These two effects tended to neutralise each other,
Patient compliance and withdrawals
Table 1
All blister packs were collected at the end of the trial to ensure Evaluation of the efficacy of learning in the 40 participants of the phase IIa trial.
patient compliance. The lower limit for compliance was set to
Test and Time of application of test Tm1 versus Tm2p
100%. It was seen that all participants that were included in the
parameter value (statistical
study completed the observation period. significance)
1st day/morning 2nd day/morning
(Tm1) (Tm2)
Data management procedures
Stroop-CW test
All information relevant to the study, including the results of W score 35.65 7 17.13 37.15 715.98 0.3310 (ns)
the d2 and the Stroop CW tests, was entered carefully and C score 46.77 7 11.89 49.4 711.55 0.1702 (ns)
CW score 72.757 12.97 72.23 7 15.40 0.8293 (ns)
accurately into the CRF for each participant, which were
recognized by their number and trial identification. Data were d2 test
subsequently entered on a participant-by-participant basis into a TN-E score 485.4 7103.0 535.8 788.37 0.0216 (n)
TM E% score 31.83 722.00 20.73 714.89 0.0099 (nnn)
Microsoft Excels 2000 database, for further analysis.
Values are means 7 SD.
Monitoring of the study Significance of differences between means analysed by unpaired t-test is indicated
by:
n
p o 0.05, nn p o0.01, nnn po 0.001.
The trial was monitored in accordance with the ICH (Interna- ns
Indicates no significant difference (p 40.05) between the scores before and after
tional Conference on Harmonisation, 2000) guidelines for Good treatment.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
498 G. Aslanyan et al. / Phytomedicine 17 (2010) 494–499
References Olsson E.M.G., von Schéele B., Panossian A.G., 2009. A randomized double-blind
placebo controlled parallel group study of SHR-5 extract of Rhodiola rosea roots
as treatment for patients with stress related fatigue. Planta Med. 75, 105–112.
Bogatova, R.I., Shlyakova, L.V., Malozemov, V.V., Narinskaja, A.L., Roslyakova, N.A., Panossian, A., Hambartsumyan, M., Hovanissian, A., Gabrielyan, E., Wikman, G.,
Shangin, A.L., 1994. Experimental trials of phytoadaptogen effect on the 2007. The adaptogens Rhodiola and Schizandra modify the response to
quality of operators’ activity, mental and physical working capacity. Final immobilization stress in rabbits by suppressing the increase of phosphorylated
Report on ADAPT 232. Institute of Medical and Biological Problems (IMBP), stress-activated protein kinase, nitric oxide and cortisol. Drug Target Insights
Moscow, pp. 1–151. 1, 39–54. Available at /http://www.la-press.com/the-adaptogens-rhodiola-
Bogatova, R.I., Shlyakova, L.V., Salnitsky, V.P., Wikman, G., 1997. Evaluation of the and-schizandra-modify-the-response-to-immobili-a260S.
effect of a single dose of a phytoadaptogen on human subjects’ work ability Panossian, A., Wagner, H., 2005. Stimulating effects of adaptogens: an overview of
during long isolation. Aerospace Environ. Med. 31, 51–54. clinical trials of adaptogens with particular reference on their efficacy at single
Brekhman, I.I., Dardymov, I.V., 1969. New substances of plant origin which dose administration. Phytother Res. 19, 819–838.
increase non-specific resistance. Annu. Rev. Pharmacol. 9, 419–430. Panossian, A., Wikman, G., Andreeva, L., Boykova, A., Nikiforova, D., Timonina, N.,
Brickenkamp, R., Zillmer, E., 1998. The d2 Test of Attention 1st Edition Hogrefe and 2008. Adaptogens exert a stress protective effect by modulation of expression
Huber Publishers, Göttingen 1-72. of molecular chaperons. Planta Med. 74, 1018.
Facchinetti, F., Neri, I., Tarabusi, M., 2002. Eleutherococcus senticosus reduces Panossian, A., Wikman, G., Kaur, P., Asea, A., 2009. Adaptogens exert a stress
cardiovascular stress response in healthy subjects: a randomized, placebo- protective effect by modulation of expression of molecular chaperons.
controlled trial. Stress Health 18, 11–17. Phytomedicine, 16, 617–622.
Golden, C.J., Freshwater, S.M., 2002. The Stroop Color and Word Test. A Manual for Panossian, A., Wikman, G., Wagner, H., 1999. Plant adaptogens III: Earlier and more
Clinical and Experimental Uses. Stoelting Co., Chicago 1-68. recent aspects and concepts on their modes of action. Phytomedicine 6, 287–300.
International Conference on Harmonisation, 2000. ICH Harmonised Tripartite Panossian, A., Wikman, G., 2008. Pharmacology of Schisandra chinensis Bail.: An
Guideline. Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R1). Current Step 4 version overview of Russian research and uses in medicine. J. Ethnopharmacol. 118,
dated 10 June 1996. Available at /http://www.ich.org/LOB/media/MEDIA482. 183–212.
pdfS. Panossian, A., Wikman, G., 2009. Evidence based efficacy of adaptogens in fatigue
International Conference on Harmonization (ICH). Topic Q2 (R1), Validation of and molecular mechanisms related to their stress protective action. Curr. Clin.
Analytical Procedures: Text and Methodology, Step 5, Note for Guidance for Pharmacol. 4, 198–219.
Validation of Analytical Procedure4 Text and Methodologies. CPMP/ICH/381/ Panossian, A.G., 2004. Adaptogens: tonic herbs for fatigue and stress. Altern.
95, June 1995. Available at /http://www.emea.europa.eu/pdfs/human/ich/ Complement. Ther. 9, 327–332.
038195en.pdfS. Panossian, A., Wikman, G., 2010. Effects of adaptogens on the central nervous
International Organisation for Standardisation. EN ISO/IEC 17 025:2001 Standard system and the molecular mechanisms associated with their stress-protective
Accreditation Requirements for QC Laboratories Operating under the GxP activity. Pharmaceuticals 3, 188–224 http://www.mdpi.com/1424-8247/3/1/
Compliance Requirements 2001. Available at /http://www.effichem.comS. 188/pdf.
Narimanian, M., Badalyan, M., Panosyan, V., Gabrielyan, E., Panossian, A., Wikman, World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki. Ethical principles for medical
G., Wagner, H., 2005. Impact of ChisanR (ADAPT 232) on the Quality – of - life research involving human subjects 2000. 18th WMA General Assembly,
and its Efficacy as an Adjuvant in the treatment of Acute Non-specific Helsinki (Finland) June 1964 and 52nd WMA General Assembly, Edinburgh
Pneumonia. Phytomedicine 12, 723–729. (Scotland), October 2000.