You are on page 1of 6

The Potential and Challenges of DC Microgrids in

the Future of Energy Distribution

1st Yassine LACHHAB 2nd Omar JELLOULI


Laboratoire des Energies Renouvelable et Matériaux Avancés, Laboratoire des Energies Renouvelable et Matériaux Avancés,
Université Internationale de Rabat (UIR), Université Internationale de Rabat (UIR),
Rocade Rabat-Salé, Rocade Rabat-Salé,
Rabat-Sala El Jadida, 11100, Morocco Rabat-Sala El Jadida, 11100, Morocco
yassine.lachhab@uir.ac.ma omar.jellouli@uir.ac.ma

3rd Radouane OULADSINE 4th Adil MEHDARY


Laboratoire des Energies Renouvelable et Matériaux Avancés, Hassania School of Public Works,
Université Internationale de Rabat (UIR), department of electrical engineering
Rocade Rabat-Salé, Hassan II University of Casablanca UH2C
Rabat-Sala El Jadida, 11100, Morocco Casablanca, Morocco
radouane.ouladsine@uir.ac.ma adil.mehdary@uh2.ac.ma

Abstract—Distribution networks represent a crucial paradigm particularly when seen in the context of contemporary smart
shift that will inevitably shape the future of the energy mix. power distribution systems.
Formerly, these electrical grids were distinguished by their AC These microgrids have the potential to be employed in
transmission, but technological advancements are now making
DC transmission a viable alternative. In fact, the use of DC a variety of applications due to the numerous benefits they
equipment for loads, storage systems, and renewable energy can offer, as well as the aforementioned shift in types and
sources is rapidly growing, leading to the examination of several utilization of storage systems. This type of microgrid could
situations involving this type of equipment. DC networks are be particularly beneficial in improving the lives of many
gaining significance due to the need for the quick inclusion of people , especially those living in remote towns and villages,
this technology into the current electrical network. Furthermore,
the growth of such networks is crucial not only because of the in- particularly given the nature of off-grid systems.
crease in the number of DC equipment, but also because they are DC microgrids have emerged as a promising alternative to
thought to be more effective and dependable than conventional AC infrastructures, given the advancement of current tech-
AC transmission systems. DC networks do not have concerns with nology and the changing landscape of electrical generation
reactive power, frequency regulation, or synchronization. Despite and consumption. As a result, AC and DC infrastructures
extensive study in this area, some technological components have
yet to be established as standards, and this uncertainty hampers are expected to become complimentary solutions in the near
the quick shift to this kind of network. future. Against this backdrop, this study explores the potential
Index Terms—AC microgrids, DC microdgrids, Architechture for DC microgrids in the coming years.
DC infrastructures present several challenges that need
to be addressed, including the need for standardization and
I. I NTRODUCTION clear definitions. Additionally, there are several areas that
require further development, such as the establishment of new
In recent years, a new paradigm for electrical distribution standards and laws.
networks has emerged,with the usage of DC networks emerged This article will present the technology behind DC micro-
as a more advantageous alternative as compared to the tra- grids and their potential applications, building upon the various
ditional AC networks that are particularly connected with benefits mentioned earlier. While many of these applications
micro and mini grids. One of the elements has to do with have yet to be fully realized, we will also explore new and
distributed generation (DG), which is connected to renewable emerging uses for this type of microgrid. Additionally, the
energy sources. The usage of energy storage devices, the authors will share their vision for various applications and
dependability of electric networks, and high-energy-efficiency associated solutions. Finally, we will address the challenges
loads are further considerations. These factors have led to the that must be overcome to implement this technology and offer
current perception of DC networks as being quite alluring, our perspective on the future development of DC microgrids.
Distribution power networks are increasingly incorporating
Identify applicable funding agency here. If none, delete this. renewable energy sources (RES) such as photovoltaic (PV)
panels and energy storage systems (ESS). As these sources
generate electricity at DC voltage, exploring their integration
into DC microgrids. However, since the power output of each
RES is highly unpredictable due to weather variations, a DC
microgrid system requires an interface with the AC grid to
increase power availability and reliability. methods available
for DC microgrid to an AC grid. .
II. A RCHITECTURES AND C ONFIGURATIONS :
The type of architecture that ought to be used or is best
suited for a particular application is an area that has not
yet been standardization. In fact, there are a several different
architectures that could be applied to create a DC microgrid.
The following are some of the various constructions:
Single bus configuration : This architecture is the simplest, Fig. 1. Structure of DC Microgrid System with Radial Configuration.
consisting of just one DC bus to which every generator,
storage device, and load is connected. There are two common
instances of this topology, one operating in islanded mode
and the other linked to the electrical grid. This architecture
has low costs and maintenance needs, in addition to being
straightforward.
Radial configuration : The radial configuration is an ex-
pansion of the single bus topology. It offers multiple DC
buses, as shown in the figure, and each bus tis utilized to link
generators, storage systems, and loads. There are wo typical
two configurations available: series and parallel. The first
configuration connects two or more DC microgrids in series,
while the second links them in parallel. This topology retains
some of its simplicity and supports various voltage levels, and
also improves dependability. However, the islanding option
may pose potential issues with instability.
In this configuration, electricity travels along the single
channel to the loads from a DC bus that is connected to an AC
grid at one end. Because of this, there is only one path between
each load and the AC grid interface. The radial DC microgrid Fig. 2. Series-connected radial structure for multi-DC microgrid systems.
system is depicted in Figure 1 as a single line diagram, with a
number of RES, ESS, and loads (both AC and DC) connected
to the DC bus. Depending on the application and requirements, Radial DC microgrid topologies in a multi-bus architecture
this bus may be unipolar or bipolar. In residential structures, offer several benefits, such as simplicity, multi-voltage levels
where low voltage DC buses are preferred to match the voltage (in bipolar), and the ability to share power from nearby buses.
level of numerous appliances and save additional DC-DC However, the series radial design can be inflexible in fault
conversion stages, this design is usable. Furthermore, with situations. For instance, a single breakdown in a single bus
such systems, the AC grid interface and loads can be placed system can affect all customers linked to it. When a defective
near to one another to cut down on distribution losses. bus is isolatedby circuit breakers in a series radial multi-bus
This type of configuration is particularly useful in multi- system, the buses before and after the problematic bus will
story buildings or neighborhoods where each microgrid may not be able to share their power with the entire system.
consist of different RES and ESS with various loads. Depend- The ring or loop configuration of a DC microgrid offers
ing on the structure of the buildings or communities, the DC a solution to the limitations of a radial configuration. In this
bus within each microgrid can be connected in series or in topology, generators, storage devices, and loads are looped
parallel. In this way, each building acts as a cluster of the together into the same DC bus, allowing for power to flow
microgrid and can either draw power from or supply it to through multiple routes between the AC grid interface and
nearby microgrids. The parallel radial design can improve the consumers, as shown in Figure 4. This provides more
system reliability by isolating only the faulty buses in the reliability than the earlier radial configurations, as it is possible
event of failures and allowing the healthy buses to continue to operate in a single bus configuration in the event of a DC
their normal operation. However, the series radial architecture bus fault. However, the ring topology is more complex than
could have some stability issues during islanding modes. the radial topology.
AC grid supplies, customers can be provided with an alternate
AC grid supply in the event of a failure in one or more feeders.
The Interconnected configuration can be implemented in two
potential architectures: the Mesh Type DC Microgrid System
and the Zonal Type DC Microgrid System. The Mesh Type
DC Microgrid System involves multiple interconnections with
the AC main grid, while the Zonal Type DC Microgrid System
connects the DC bus to multiple AC grid supplies in different
geographic zones.
The mesh configuration is a complex topology that incorpo-
rates an integrated ring (or rings) to radial topologies, resulting
in a more reliable and versatile structure. In a mesh type DC
microgrid, also known as a multi-terminal grid, an AC-DC
converter links each of the multiple AC grid interfaces to the
DC grids. Various DC microgrid topologies are possible based
on this topology, where multiple DC and AC power supplies
are connected to the DC feeders. Figure 5 illustrates one
such design. The MTDC system is more dependable than the
radial or ring DC grids since additional feeders are available
to supply power to different system components. Similar
architectural designs are used in High Voltage Direct Current
Fig. 3. Parallel Configuration of Radial Architecture for Multi-DC Microgrid (HVDC) systems, such as underground urban subtransmission
System. and distribution networks and offshore wind farms.
To identify and isolate the problematic DC bus and restore
the MTDC system, a ”handshaking” technique has been pro-
Each DC bus in the ring configuration has fast DC switches
posed that does not require any internal connection between
at both ends, which can be used to isolate a problematic
the system’s AC-DC converters.
bus from the rest of the system. The Intelligent Electronic
Device (IED) manages the interaction between each bus and
its neighbors, and in the event of a failure, the IED first locates
and isolates the problematic bus before offering an alternate
channel for consumers to receive electricity.
While both radial and ring DC microgrid systems depend
on the AC grid for power, the ring topology is more reliable.
However, a problem in the AC feeder can still prevent the DC
microgrid system from receiving the required power from the
AC grid.

Fig. 5. DC microgrid architecture based on a mesh topology.

The Zonal Type DC Microgrid System is designed to


enhance the dependability of the system. The system is divided
into several zones, each having two redundant DC buses
connected by AC grid and dispersed DC and AC energy
sources. This design provides improved dependability and
availability of loads through one of the feeders. In case of
a failure in the upper bus of Zone-1, the switches at the
top side will be turned off while the switches at the lower
Fig. 4. The DC microgrid system in ring bus architecture. side are maintained on, allowing power to be transmitted to
the loads through other feeders. The ZTDC grid has a larger
The Interconnected configuration is defined by multiple number of switches, making it more flexible and modular,
interconnections with the AC main grid, which increases and thus, suitable for distribution planning. The ZTDC grid
system reliability. By connecting the DC microgrid to multiple offers several options for powering loads, where several buses
may supply power concurrently, sequentially, or only from DC generation and storage systems:
one bus. However, taking electricity from multiple buses may • Direct connection of electronic loads: Electronic loads
make the design and operation of the distribution system more require a DC voltage source and connecting them to
challenging. To overcome this, a bus selection approach has an AC network requires the use of a rectifier, which
been suggested, where the load receives energy from the bus decreases load efficiency and increases cost. DC networks
with the highest voltage level, and may migrate to another bus can directly serve electronic loads, improving efficiency
if necessary. This design is frequently used in shipboard power and reducing costs.
supply. • Increased efficiency: DC infrastructure networks have
been effectively built in certain applications, resulting in
efficiency gains of between 12 percent and 18 percent.
This is due to the direct connection of decentralized
generators and storage systems, which often generate and
receive DC power.
• Greater reliability: DC microgrids may be more reliable
than AC networks, particularly when using a bipolar
construction that allows the grid to continue operating
even if one of the poles develops a fault.
• Compatibility with electric cars: The ability to eliminate
the rectifier by connecting an electric car directly to the
grid can further increase the effectiveness of the global
system.
• Improved power quality: DC microgrids can prevent com-
mon AC grid-related power quality issues such as voltage
sags and swells, flashing, harmonics, and imbalances.
• No need for reactive power and synchronization with the
Fig. 6. The architecture of a DC microgrid in a zonal configuration. utility grid.
• Reduced losses and cable sizes: The absence of skin
The two most popular configurations for microgrid systems
are the unipolar and bipolar configurations. effect enables current to be distributed evenly along the
The two most popular configurations for microgrid systems distribution cable, reducing losses or allowing for the use
are the unipolar and bipolar configurations. The unipolar of smaller section cables.
configuration is the simplest because it only requires two • Increased dependability: DC microgrids have a large ca-

wires, and all generators, loads, and storage devices are pacity for island mode operation, increasing their overall
linked to the same poles. The bipolar configuration is more dependability.
complicated because it requires three wires (positive, neutral, While switching to DC microgrids has its advantages, there
and negative poles) and allows for various ways to link are also certain challenges that need to be addressed, including
generators, loads, and storage systems to different poles. It additional fees and the need for a shift in thinking. However,
also enables connection to different voltages between the poles the compatibility of electronic loads with DC networks and
or between one of the poles and the neutral pole. An example the potential cost savings may persuade consumers and in-
of the bipolar configuration is provided, where one system is vestors to make the switch. The DC microgrid’s voltage level
connected to the grid while the other runs in island mode. should be higher than the required AC voltage for electronic
The bipolar DC microgrid has several advantages over equipment, and the use of bipolar DC microgrids can enhance
the unipolar configuration, such as a wider voltage range, security by allowing for a reduction in the voltage level of the
improved efficiency, higher quality power supply, and greater pole(s).
dependability due to the availability of multiple lines. How- IV. S TRUGGLES :
ever, there are also some drawbacks to the bipolar design, such
as the requirement for additional cables and the potential for The standards are crucial for the development of DC
voltage imbalance between bipolar terminals. This imbalance microgrids. One important aspect is the specification and
may arise due to different loads connected to all the terminals, standardization of voltage levels for different DC microgrids.
or due to the way generators such as PV connect to just one Although there has been some research on ideal voltage levels,
pole through DC/DC conversion. Despite these drawbacks, they have not yet been regulated by legislation. The security of
there are techniques available to mitigate or eliminate the people and installations is another key component that requires
imbalance issue. new norms and regulations.
Researchers have studied isolated DC microgrids in recent
III. A DVANTAGES : years, but there are still issues that need to be resolved, such
DC microgrids offer a number of advantages over AC as inertial control. Voltage fluctuation is a problem in DC
networks, particularly in the context of distributed renewable microgrids due to negative damping performance, interactions
between the microgrid and converters, and positive feedback becoming prosumers by utilizing renewable energy sources.
in DC voltage control loops. However, it has been observed that many prosumers do not use
Control of islanded DC microgrids without storage systems the energy they generate during peak hours. Some prosumers
is a challenge that needs to be addressed, particularly in under- sell energy, but the prices are often not favorable. In the
developed and rural areas. PV generators can provide enough future, the use of storage systems is anticipated to address this
energy for small loads like water pumps, but backup power issue. Second-life batteries, which are expected to be available
supply from diesel or biofuel generators may be necessary. with the widespread use of electric cars, can be used for this
However, these generators have a slow reaction time, and grid purpose. A parallel arrangement of an AC network and a DC
stability and inertia analyses are required to ensure stability network may be the best option, as it can supply the AC
and prevent faults. networks without the addition of an extra power electronic
The control and stability of DC microgrids are other im- converter (DC to AC).
portant topics that need more research. DC microgrids are Overall, there are various potential applications for DC
susceptible to faults and instability issues due to factors such as microgrids, including infrastructure for electric car charging
input power fluctuations, load changes, and the lack of natural systems, residential buildings, offices, LV electrical networks,
current zero crossing. The absence of specific standards adds and rural regions. In each application, a parallel infrastruc-
to the complexity of the issue, and more work is needed to ture that includes both AC and DC networks might be the
address these challenges. most effective solution. For instance, in residential homes,
V. V ISION : a parallel infrastructure may consist of a DC infrastructure
that links to sustainable energy producers, storage systems,
There are numerous applications for DC microgrids, and and electric car charging systems, while also connecting to
as was previously mentioned, their installation can provide the AC grid through several connecting points. This could
significant advantage over traditional AC grids or microgrids. improve the system’s reliability and efficiency, while enabling
However, to date, only a limited number of DC microgrid power flow optimization and additional services to be offered
applications have been put into practice, and some have only to the AC grid. In rural regions, where there are no adjacent
been included in research studies or used as part of an AC infrastructures, DC microgrids may be essential and can
experiment. While data centers are one of the uses for DC include renewable energy sources, fuel cells, storage devices,
microgrids that have already been discussed, there are many and pumping systems, among other components. Ultimately,
other potential uses for DC microgrids that could be highly the adoption of DC microgrids may offer several benefits over
beneficial. traditional AC grids or microgrids, and their potential uses are
One area where DC microgrid adoption is anticipated is still being explored.
in the infrastructure for electric car charging systems. There
DC microgrids have a wide range of potential applications
are several viewpoints on the best approach for this. One
beyond those discussed earlier. For example, they can be used
viewpoint is that the bipolar DC microgrid, as shown in
in the transportation industry, where they are expected to see
a graphic, is ideally suited for this situation. The graphic
significant adoption on ships and in supplying power to trains.
clearly illustrates the suitability of a bipolar design in this
Another promising application is in data centers, where DC
application. However, there are also several viewpoints that
microgrids have already been successfully deployed and are
advocate for the use of a unipolar DC microgrid. An important
expected to become even more common in the future.
consideration in these infrastructures is the ease with which a
storage system can be integrated, as storage devices may be This paper presents several suggestions for the potential
crucial to mitigate potential load surges. Adding sustainable development of DC electrical distribution infrastructure, which
energy sources, such as PV producers, is also a possible and could greatly impact the current electricity distribution system.
straightforward process in these systems. Most of these concepts aim for coexistence with the AC
One interesting approach for DC microgrids is the coupling electrical distribution network, rather than its elimination. By
of a low-voltage DC grid with a medium-voltage DC grid. considering these strategies, we may be able to achieve a
This can be particularly beneficial if there are sustainable more efficient and reliable electrical distribution system that
energy-producing parks of sufficient size that can be linked to incorporates renewable energy sources and energy storage
the medium-voltage DC grid, which is often near residential systems.
users. In this case, a transformer is required since the home This paragraph presents a list of potential applications for
customers are connected to the LV grid. However, using DC microgrids, along with relevant references for each use.
solid-state transformers (SST) is highly recommended in this The first application is to serve as an electrical foundation
specific scenario. The layout of the LV grid is also important for individual residential and commercial buildings, where the
and can be advantageous. grid is only integrated if renewable energy sources are unavail-
Another application area for DC microgrids is in residential able [9], [3], [2], [10],cite Another potential use is to make
buildings. With the increasing prevalence of solar generators remote areas self-sufficient by establishing DC microgrids [5],
in homes, DC microgrids can be deployed in these buildings [6], [8]. DC microgrids are also planned for deployment in
very effectively. This is a good example of how customers are ships and trains [1], [4], [7].
VI. C ONCLUSION : [8] Chitaranjan Phurailatpam, Bharat Singh Rajpurohit, and Lingfeng Wang.
Planning and optimization of autonomous dc microgrids for rural and
In conclusion, DC microgrids have the potential to sig- urban applications in india. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,
82:194–204, 2018.
nificantly transform the way electricity distribution networks [9] Vitor Fernão Pires, Armando Pires, and Armando Cordeiro. Dc mi-
operate in the future. With the increasing transition from crogrids: Benefits, architectures, perspectives and challenges. Energies,
centralized production to decentralized renewable generation 16(3):1217, 2023.
[10] Fengyan Zhang, Chao Meng, Yun Yang, Chunpeng Sun, Chengcheng
and the importance of energy storage systems, the development Ji, Ying Chen, Wen Wei, Hemei Qiu, and Gang Yang. Advantages
and adoption of DC microgrids are likely to accelerate. In and challenges of dc microgrid for commercial building a case study
addition, the conversion of traditional AC loads to DC loads from xiamen university dc microgrid. In 2015 IEEE First International
Conference on DC Microgrids (ICDCM), pages 355–358. IEEE, 2015.
can also contribute to this transition. This article has focused
on the issues surrounding the conversion of AC loads to
DC microgrids and has shown that common AC loads can
be utilized directly in DC microgrids without the need for
converters or equipment alterations, resulting in significant
cost savings.
Moreover, this article has discussed the technology un-
derlying DC microgrids and their potential applications in
various sectors, such as individual residential buildings, zones
far from the grid, transportation industries, and data centers.
While some of these applications have already been put
into use, others require further research and development to
become feasible solutions. In addition, the establishment of
new standards and regulations for DC microgrids is crucial to
ensure their safe and efficient operation.
Overall, the future of DC microgrids looks promising, but
there are still several challenges that need to be addressed.
These include the need for further research and development,
the creation of new standards and regulations, and the adoption
of DC loads by various industries. With continued efforts and
advancements, DC microgrids have the potential to revolution-
ize the electricity distribution system and pave the way for a
more sustainable and efficient future.

R EFERENCES

[1] Shantha Gamini Jayasinghe, Lasantha Meegahapola, Nuwantha Fer-


nando, Zheming Jin, and Josep M Guerrero. Review of ship microgrids:
System architectures, storage technologies and power quality aspects.
inventions, 2(1):4, 2017.
[2] Jing Kang, Bin Hao, Yutong Li, Hui Lin, and Zhifeng Xue. The
application and development of lvdc buildings in china. Energies,
15(19):7045, 2022.
[3] Jayanthi Kathiresan, Senthil Kumar Natarajan, and Gnanavadivel Joth-
imani. Energy management of distributed renewable energy sources
for residential dc microgrid applications. International Transactions on
Electrical Energy Systems, 30(3):e12258, 2020.
[4] Stefano Menicanti, Marco di Benedetto, Davide Marinelli, and Fabio
Crescimbini. Recovery of trains’ braking energy in a railway micro-
grid devoted to train plus electric vehicle integrated mobility. Energies,
15(4):1261, 2022.
[5] Mashood Nasir, Saqib Iqbal, Hassan A Khan, Juan C Vasquez, and
Josep M Guerrero. Sustainable rural electrification through solar pv dc
microgrids—an architecture-based assessment. Processes, 8(11):1417,
2020.
[6] Mashood Nasir, Hassan Abbas Khan, Arif Hussain, Laeeq Mateen, and
Nauman Ahmad Zaffar. Solar pv-based scalable dc microgrid for rural
electrification in developing regions. IEEE Transactions on sustainable
energy, 9(1):390–399, 2017.
[7] Filipe Perez, Alessio Iovine, Gilney Damm, Lilia Galai-Dol, and Paulo F
Ribeiro. Stability analysis of a dc microgrid for a smart railway station
integrating renewable sources. IEEE Transactions on Control Systems
Technology, 28(5):1802–1816, 2019.

You might also like