Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ricci Ferraris Ejed Minimally Invasive Approach - 2011 - 01 - s0034
Ricci Ferraris Ejed Minimally Invasive Approach - 2011 - 01 - s0034
No Co
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n
n
A Minimally Invasive Approach ss e n c e
fo r
Andrea Ricci
Private practice, Florence, Italy
Federico Ferraris
Private practice, Alessandria, Italy
34
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
RICCI/FERRARISopyrig
No C
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te for otn
n
Abstract order to obtain the necessary space
ss e n c e
fo r
replacement materials.
The objective of dental treatment is the Similar objectives could however be
elimination of the etiologic factors, the achieved through an alternative therapy
rehabilitation of function and esthetics, where the esthetic remodeling of the
and, when possible, the maintenance teeth and the closure of the interproximal
of vitality and structure of the natural spaces is obtained with composite resin
dentition. After the loss of the periodon- materials. The objective of this article is
tal support, as a consequence of peri- to present an alternative protocol to op-
odontal disease, it may be necessary timize the functional and esthetic result
to splint the residual teeth in order to of periodontally treated cases, where
improve their stability, and sometimes the most frequent complication is the
it is also necessary to modify the mor- increased length of the clinical crown.
phology to optimize the final esthetic This is obtained by utilizing a different
outcome. In many periodontally treated conservative approach, which has as
teeth, prosthodontic treatment on the its main objective the stabilization of the
residual dentition will be required with residual teeth, the maintenance of their
an important loss of tooth structure as vitality, and the achievement of the best
an unavoidable consequence. This pro- esthetic result possible.
cedure frequently requires endodontic
treatment of the residual abutments in (Eur J Esthet Dent 2011;6:34–49)
35
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
CLINICAL APPLICATION pyrig
No Co
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n
n
Restoration of periodon- dontic treatment is required in order to
ss e n c e
fo r
obtain the necessary reduction of the
tally treated teeth
abutments to allow proper space for the
Although implant therapy has dramati- restorative materials and, as a conse-
cally changed treatment planning, still quence, adequate emergence profiles.
today the best therapeutic option for Obviously, these solutions have a very
periodontal treatment is to maintain the high “biologic price.”
residual natural teeth that have a good For this reason, an alternative to the
prognosis. prosthodontic rehabilitation of the abut-
Limiting our considerations to perio- ments, in order to obtain the splinting ef-
dontally susceptible patients, the surviv- fect and to modify the morphology of the
al of prosthodontically rehabilitated teeth clinical crown, is the use of composite
after 10 years is 89%,1 while in the same resins. Sometimes in fact it is necessary
patients implant survival is approximate- to present patients simplified treatment
ly 84%.2-5 From the literature available it planning when physical, psychological,
is not possible to conclusively establish or economic limitations are present. Oth-
if maintenance of natural teeth through erwise, a more conservative approach
periodontal treatment is a more predict- is preferred to meet the “minimally inva-
able therapeutic option compared to im- sive” philosophy of treatment.
plant therapy. Naturally, in these cases the opti-
After periodontal treatment, the most mal outcome could be more difficult to
serious esthetic consequences are achieve as well as predictability and
lengthening of the clinical crown, gin- long-term stability.
gival recessions, teeth migration and
flaring, alteration of free gingival mar-
gin levels, alveolar crest collapse and Adhesive and restorative
alteration of interproximal tissue volume
techniques
and, as a consequence, the opening of
the so-called “black triangles.” Adhesion to tooth structures has been
These esthetic problems must be investigated thoroughly in past years,
solved by means of a multidisciplinary leading to consistent scientific evidence
approach, which in the majority of cases on the possibility of utilizing adhesion
will involve orthodontics, endodontics, between composite resins and natural
operative dentistry, and in many cases teeth by means of modern adhesive
prosthodontics. resin materials.
These treatment approaches require Different adhesive materials can be
sound know-how of the dentist and a utilized during restorative procedures
consistent psychological and economic with composite resins, but the “gold
commitment of the patient. standard” is still considered an etch-
In addition, if the treatment plan in- and-rinse system in three steps (etch-
cludes splinting of the residual dentition ing, primer, and bond). Otherwise, in
by means of a prosthodontic rehabilita- order to achieve good results, especially
tion, in most of the anterior teeth endo- with dentin, a self-etch two-step system
36
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
RICCI/FERRARISopyrig
No C
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n
n
could be preferred (acidic primer and microinfiltration, as occurs with Black’s
ss e n c e
fo r
bonding).6 Class V restorations.
As a consequence of periodontal dis- One of the most frequent problems
ease, the patient often ends up with al- that one can encounter is marginal in-
tered tooth length that can expose radic- filtration due to bonding efficacy, op-
ular cement to the oral environment. erating technique and material, as it
Consequently, adhesion to these struc- has been well demonstrated in the lit-
tures is often required. It has been dem- erature.15–17 Today there is evidence
onstrated that the hybrid layer depth that that an adequate marginal seal can
can be obtained in cementum is compa- be obtained with different bonding
rable to dentin.7 agents.18
In the proposed protocol, a three-step Isolation of the field and absence of
bonding system has been preferred moisture is absolutely recommended
(etching, primer, and bonding). In re- during adhesive and operative proce-
gard to the cervical lesions of periodon- dures, and for this reason the use of a
tally compromised teeth, it is important rubber dam is advisable.19–21
to underline that hard tooth structure is Another aspect that has to be con-
represented only by radicular dentin, sidered is that in this type of restoration,
most often without the radicular cemen- if possible, an approach that does not
tum, due to non-surgical and surgical include tooth preparation is preferred.
periodontal procedures that these teeth This protocol allows clinicians to ap-
have been subjected to. In addition, in proach the case in a real non-invasive
these areas, a more sclerotic type of treatment but, on the other hand, one
dentin can be noticed. does not have a defined finish line and
Many studies have demonstrated consequently it is more difficult to avoid
how bonding systems’ resin infiltration overhangs on the restoration margins. A
into sclerotic dentin is shallower com- good control of composite stratification
pared to normal dentin.8-11 As a conse- and finishing of the material is manda-
quence, this difference between normal tory.
and sclerotic dentin has resulted in the The margin location should be supra-
reduction of shear bond strength from gingival or equa-gingival in order to
45% to 20% with modern bonding sys- avoid overhangs that would be very dif-
tems.12,13 ficult to finish properly and, as a conse-
However it must be considered that quence, facilitate plaque accumulation
these types of restorations are not and determine inflammation of the mar-
stressed by direct masticatory proc- ginal tissues.
esses as normal Black Class IV caries, The use of magnification systems dur-
and if a rigid adhesive protocol is fol- ing the stratification and finishing phase
lowed14, an excellent clinical outcome is highly recommended for better control
can be achieved both for resistance and of the margin accuracy.22
37
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
CLINICAL APPLICATION pyrig
No Co
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
ti
te being on ot
n
Clinical protocol for epithesis offers the advantage of
ss e n c e
fo r
inexpensive and solves the functional
non-splinted teeth
and esthetic deficiency with an expe-
After completion of periodontal treat- dited treatment, but most often needs
ment, it is most likely that the interproxi- to be redone every two/three years. An-
mal volume of tissues will have changed, other disadvantage of this option is that
with a consequent appearance of the it is removable. Today, more and more
so-called “interproximal black triangles.” patients prefer fixed restorations.
Many times, the morphology of the teeth The protocol that is described in this
is not favorable, since the shape is ex- article to treat situations with these char-
tremely triangular and the interproximal acteristics is represented by a conserva-
contact point is very incisal. Following tive approach utilizing direct composite
Tarnow’s guidelines,23 the chances of resins.
having a complete fill of the interproxi- After all the steps necessary to obtain
mal space by the soft tissues is depend- proper adhesion of the bonding agents,
ent on the distance from the interproxi- the morphology of the teeth is modi-
mal height of bone and the teeth contact fied without any removal of healthy and
point. Sometimes, also due to the shape sound enamel (Figs 7 to 10).
of the clinical crowns, this distance is Following the presented protocol, the
excessive and as a consequence it will shape of the teeth can be modified to
be almost impossible to expect filling of transform the contact point into an area
the space by the papilla (Figs 1 to 4). with the apical part much closer to the in-
This excessive space can determine terproximal bone peak, getting as close
phonetic problems as well as an es- as possible to the 5 mm suggested in
thetic problem, especially if the patient the literature23 (Figs 11 to 15).
presents a high smile line. The therapeu- The emergence profiles of the teeth
tic options in this case that allow mod- can be much more prominent compared
ification of the shape of the teeth and to untouched natural teeth and may in-
the interproximal contact point are es- terfere with the hygiene procedures, but
sentially two: one will require prosthetic these can still be successful with appro-
treatment, the second an operative ap- priate tooth brushing and flossing tech-
proach. Obviously, having an extremely niques (Figs 17 and 18).
triangular shape, in order to have the re- It is advisable to take post-treatment
quired space for an esthetic result with radiographs in order to better evaluate
an appropriate emergence profile of the the appropriateness of the restorations
restoration, an endodontic treatment of (Fig 16) and the recall appointments
teeth could be required. There could be are very important to evaluate the res-
also a third option, which is a removable torations and the soft tissue conditions
flexible gingival epithesis.24 The gingival (Figs 19 and 20).
38
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
RICCI/FERRARISopyrig
No C
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te n ot
n
ss e n c e fo r
Figs 3 and 4 Excessive interproximal spaces and the presence of the “black triangles” are noticeable.
The objective of the treatment is to improve esthetics and phonetics.
39
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
CLINICAL APPLICATION pyrig
No Co
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n
n
ss e n c e
fo r
Fig 7 and 8 The adhesive procedures (etch-and-rinse system) are limited to the cervical and interproxi-
mal hard tissues; the use of rubber dam is advisable.
Fig 9 and 10 Tooth-by-tooth remodeling (if necessary with an additional clamp), with dentin and enamel
composite materials.
40
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
RICCI/FERRARISopyrig
No C
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te n ot
n
ss e n c e fo r
Fig 13 Fig 14
Fig 17 and 18 Flossing procedures are guaranteed despite the increased emergence profile.
41
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
CLINICAL APPLICATION pyrig
No Co
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n
n
ss e n c e
fo r
42
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
RICCI/FERRARISopyrig
No C
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te n ot
n
Clinical protocol for ss e n c e fo r
splinted teeth
When a patient presents excessive mo-
bility of the residual teeth that would im-
pede the ideal masticatory function and
limit the patient’s comfort, splinting of
the dentition is recommended. In fact,
frequently, in spite of proper periodon-
tal treatment and occlusal equilibra-
tion, periodontal tissues are not able to
bear the occlusal functional forces and Fig 23 Clinical view after perio-prosthetic treat-
ment. After proper perio-prosthetic treatment neces-
above all the parafunctional ones.25-29
sary for the rehabilitation of function and esthetics,
These circumstances can be avoided the patient is enrolled in a strict supportive perio-
by splinting the teeth with a composite dontal treatment and recall prosthetic program.
ligature or with a removable splint.30
The therapeutic options that allow
modification of the crown morphology
and at the same time splinting the re-
sidual teeth, which is critical with se-
verely reduced periodontal attachment
(Fig 34), are again essentially two: a
prosthetic or operative approach. Due
to the root anatomy, in order to obtain
the appropriate emergence profile of an
eventual fixed partial denture avoiding
overhangs, most likely an endodontic
treatment of the mandibular teeth could
be required to allow appropriate space
for dental materials.
43
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
CLINICAL APPLICATION pyrig
No Co
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te ot n
n
ss e n c e
fo r
Fig 26 Rubber dam application retained by two Fig 27 Adhesive procedures on teeth to be re-
clamps on distal teeth. modeled and splinted.
Fig 30 Fig 31
44
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
RICCI/FERRARISopyrig
No C
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te n ot
n
ss e n c e fo r
Fig 32 Selection of size of the mandibular teeth Fig 33 Occlusal view of splinted mandibular nat-
fiber-reinforced composite splinting. ural teeth.
Fig 34 Detailed view of unrestored mandibular Figs 35 and 36 Views of completed case after
anterior teeth after non-surgical periodontal treat- direct composite restorations of mandibular anterior
ment. teeth.
Fig 36
45
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
CLINICAL APPLICATION pyrig
No Co
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te otn
n
ss e n c e
fo r
Fig 37 Radiographs of completed composite application. From a radiographic point of view it can be
noticed how the splinting of the teeth has been obtained as well as maintaining the vitality of the residual
teeth. The improvement of the hard periodontal tissues is evident, compared to the initial situation.
46
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
RICCI/FERRARISopyrig
No C
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
te n ot
n
these restorations in the clinical circum-
ss e n c e fo r
stances that have been presented. At
present the only data available are re-
lated to class V restorations.
Esthetic results: they can be less ideal
compared to fixed partial dentures.
In any case, even with conventional
approaches, advanced periodontal
cases will not allow ideal esthetics.
The remodeling of long teeth and the
color integration with direct composite
resin application require a thorough Figs 38 and 39 Lateral views of smile after treat-
knowledge of the characteristics of ment. The black triangles on the mandibular teeth
are resolved.
the materials used, as well as good
manual dexterity. As a matter of fact,
it is not always possible to avoid small
imperfections in the adaptation of the
material on the unprepared teeth, but
these are not recognizable without
magnification devices.
47
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
CLINICAL APPLICATION pyrig
No Co
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
teK, ot n
n
References 8. Van Meerbeek B, Braem M,
Lambrechts P, Vanherle G.
17. Ferrari M, Yamamoto
ss e n c e
fo r
Vichi A, Finger WJ. Clinical
Morphological characteriza- and laboratory evaluation of
1. Pjetursson BE, Tan K, Lang tion of the interface between adhesive restorative sytems.
NP, Brägger U, Egger M, resin and sclerotic dentine. J Am J Dent 1994;7:217-219.
Zwahlen M. A systematic Dent 1994;22:141-146. 18. Ferrari M, Mannocci F,
review of the survival and 9. Kwong SM, Tay FR, Yip HK, Cagidiaco MC, Kugel G.
complication rates of fixed Kei LH, Pashley DH. An Short-term assessment of
partial dentures (FPDs) after ultrastructural study of the leakage of class V composite
an observation period of application of dentine adhe- restorations placed in vivo.
at least 5 years. Clin Oral sives to acid-conditioned Clin Oral Investig 1997;1:61-
Implants Res 2004;15:667- sclerotic dentine. J Dent 64.
676. 2000;7:515-528. 19. Plasmans PJ, Creugers NH,
2. Brocard D, Barthet P, Bay- 10. Prati C, Chersoni S, Mongior- Hermsen RJ, Vrijhoef MM.
sse E et al. A multicenter gi R, Montanari G, Pashley Intraoral humidity during
report on 1,022 consecu- DH. Thickness and morphol- operative procedures. J Dent
tively placed ITI implants: a ogy of resin-infiltrated dentin 1994;22:89-91.
7-year longitudinal study. Int layer in young, old, and 20. Strydom C. Handling pro-
J Oral Maxillofac Implants sclerotic dentin. Oper Dent tocol of posterior compos-
2000;15:691-700. 1999;24:66-72. ites Rubber Dam. SADJ
3. Hardt CR, Gröndahl K, 11. Sakoolnamarka R, Burrow 2005;60:292-293.
Lekholm U, Wennström JL. MF, Tyas MJ. Micromorpho- 21. Dörfer CE, Schriever A,
Outcome of implant therapy logical study of resin-dentin Heidemann D, Staehle HJ,
in relation to experienced interface of non-carious Pioch T. Influence of rubber-
loss of periodontal bone sup- cervical lesions. Oper Dent dam on the reconstruction
port: a retrospective 5 year 2002;27:493-499. of proximal contacts with
study. Clin Oral Implants Res 12. Kwong SM, Cheung GS, Kei adhesive tooth-colored
2002;13:488-494. LH et al. Micro-tensile bond restorations. J Adhes Dent
4. Karoussis IK, Salvi GE, strengths to sclerotic dentin 2001;3:169-175.
Heitz-Mayfield LJ, Brägger using a self-etching and a 22. Frankenberger R, Krämer N,
U, Hammerle CH, Lang NP. total-etching technique. Dent Pelka M, Petschelt A. Internal
Long-term implant prognosis Mater 2002;18:359-369. adaptation and overhang for-
in patients with and without a 13. Yoshiyama M, Sano H, Ebisu mation of direct Class II resin
history of chronic periodon- S et al. Regional strengths of composite restorations. Clin
titis: a 10-year prospective bonding agents to cervical Oral Investig 1999;3:208-
cohort study of the ITI Dental sclerotic root dentin. J Dent 215.
Implant System. Clin Oral Res 1996;75:1404-1413. 23. Tarnow DP, Magner AW,
Implants Res 2003;14:329- 14. Cefaly DF, Tapety CM, Mon- Fletcher P. The effect of the
339. delli RF, Lauris JR, Phantum- distance from the contact
5. Evian CI, Emling R, Rosen- vanit P, Navarro MF. Three- point to the crest of bone on
berg ES et al. Retrospective year evaluation of the ART the presence or absence
analysis of implant survival approach in Class III and V of the interproximal den-
and the influence of peri- restorations in permanent tal papilla. J Periodontol
odontal disease and immedi- anterior teeth. Caries Res 1992;63:995-996.
ate placement on long-term 2006;40:389-392. 24. Iselin W, Meier C, Lufi A,
results. Int J Oral Maxillofac 15. Barnes DM, Thompson VP, Lutz F. The flexible gingival
Implants 2004;19:393-398. Blank LW. Microleakage in epithesis. The practical pro-
6. De Munck J, Van Landuyt K, Class V in vivo and in vitro cedure, laboratory technics
Peumans M et al. A criti- composite resin restorations and clinical experience. Sch-
cal review of the durability (abstract 86). J Dent Res weiz Monatsschr Zahnmed
of adhesion to tooth tissue: 1993;72:114. 1990;100:966-979.
methods and results. J Dent 16. Ferrari M, Cagidiaco MC, 25. Lindhe J, Nyman S. The role
Res 2005;84:118-132. Gesi A, BaBeri P. Preliminary of occlusion in periodontal
7. Tanaka S, Sugaya T, Kawa- report of an experimental disease and the biologic
nami M et al. Hybrid layer design for in vivo testing of rationale for splinting in the
seals the cementum/4-META/ bonded restorations applied treatment of periodontitis.
MMA-TBB resin interface. J to a new enamel-dentinal Oral Sci Rev 1977;10:11-43.
Biomed Mater Res B Appl bonding agent. J Prosthet
Biomater 2007;80:140-145. Dent 1993;70:465-467.
48
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011
RICCI/FERRARISopyrig
No C
ht
t fo
rP
by N
ub
Q ui
lica
tio
teTooth ot n
n
26. Rosemberg S. A new method 29. Mosedale RF. Current indica- 31. Rapelli G, Putignano A.
for stabilization of periodon- tions and methods of peri- ss e n c e
fo r
splinting with fiber-reinforced
tally involved teeth. J Period- dontal splinting. Dent Update composite materials: achiev-
ontol 1980;51:469-473. 2007;34:168-170, 173-174, ing predictable aesthetics.
27. Serio FG, Hawley CE. Peri- 176-178 passim. Pract Proced Aesthet Dent
odontal trauma and mobility. 30. Pollack RP. Non-crown 2002;14:495-500.
Diagnosis and treatment and bridge stabilization of 32. Strasseler HE, Serio CL.
planning. Dent Clin North Am severely mobile, periodontal- Esthetic Considerations
1999;43:37-44. ly involved teeth. A 25-year when splinting with fiber-rein-
28. Serio FG. Clinical rationale perspective. Dent Clin North forced composites. Dent Clin
for tooth stabilization and Am 1999;43:77-103. North Am 2007;51:507-524.
splinting. Dent Clin North Am
1999;43:1-6.
49
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY
VOLUME 6 • NUMBER 1 • SPRING 2011