You are on page 1of 6

COMMENTARY

MILITARY MEDICINE, 186, 5/6:123, 2021

Prolonged Field Care Research Approach and Its Relevance


to Civilian Medicine

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/milmed/article/186/5-6/123/5917413 by guest on 04 September 2022


Adam B. Cohen, MD*,†; COL Michael Davis, MD, USA‡; Sarah E. M. Herman, PhD*

ABSTRACT In early March 2020, Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Lab hosted an Association of Mili-
tary Surgeons of the United States regional conference to address medical demands of the future battlefield for which
prolonged field care is expected. Arising from this conference, we propose here an approach to prolonged field care
research—and also summarize the major concepts discussed at the conference. We draw parallels to prolonged field care
investments and advancements that apply beyond the combat environment. The exceedingly daunting medical challenges
of the future battlefield, on land and at sea, must be addressed to maintain an effective force able to compete with modern
highly capable adversaries. Since the human element, and its health, will allow future mission success, we propose here
an approach to making soldier health-related research most impactful.

INTRODUCTION to hours of injury. Soldiers equipped with Tactical Combat


The conference focused on medical technology; however, Casualty Care (TCCC)2 skills can manage common casualty
other components will be needed to optimize prolonged field conditions during this typical field care window. They pro-
care, including doctrine, organization, training, materiel, vide immediate lifesaving care while temporarily stabilizing
leadership, education, personnel, and facilities. The confer- the patient until evacuation to equipped care facilities that pro-
ence aimed to highlight prolonged field care gaps—and req- vide more definitive care. Denied or unavailable evacuation
uisite areas of innovation to address the gaps across the array typically results in a prolonged field care scenario. In that
of expected combat-related injuries and illnesses (Table I). situation, the patient’s clinical condition demands capabili-
The speakers and panelists (Table II) spanned military and ties unavailable in the field, thereby increasing morbidity and
academic research, technology, operational, and research mortality risk.
domains. The evolution of civilian care from the hospital and clinic
Prolonged field care refers to “field medical care, applied toward the patient draws important parallels to prolonged field
beyond ‘doctrinal planning time-lines’ by a Special Opera- combat care, which aims to bring effective care closer to the
tions Combat Medic or higher, in order to decrease patient solider. Such parallels must be recognized in order to identify
mortality and morbidity. Utilizes limited resources, and is areas of overlap whereby innovation and research investments
sustained until the patient arrives at an appropriate level of in one domain will benefit the other. For the military, in par-
care.”1 It is a state of care in which the patient remains in the ticular, civilian and industry interest may be required in order
field beyond the time when capabilities to evacuate and care to garner the degree of investment and resources needed to
for the patient are severely limited. Recent battlefield medi- sustain desired innovations.
cal evacuations are typically rapid, occurring within minutes Although much of U.S. civilian medicine occurs in well-
resourced settings, much does not. Further, with rapid
* National Health Mission Area, Asymmetric Operations Sector, advancements in digital and mobile health, in concert with
The Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory, Laurel, other aspects of health technology, medicine will increasingly
MD, 20723, USA move toward patients in their own settings, progressively out-
† Department of Neurology, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore,
side hospitals and clinics. Such advancements offer patients,
MD, 21287, USA
‡ U.S. Army Medical Research & Development Command, Frederick, families, and available providers more capability to manage
MD, 21702 health. For example, the coronavirus pandemic produced sce-
The views expressed are solely those of the authors and do not reflect the narios in which patients and clinicians required support that
official policy or position of the Johns Hopkins University, U.S. Army, U.S. could not be delivered within the current healthcare paradigm.
Navy, U.S. Air Force, the Department of Defense, or the U.S. Government. Capability brought to the forward environment, via new meth-
doi:10.1093/milmed/usaa352
© The Association of Military Surgeons of the United States 2020.
ods and modes of communication, for example, have been
All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: journals. necessary.
permissions@oup.com.

MILITARY MEDICINE, Vol. 186, May/June 2021 123


Prolonged Field Care Research

TABLE I. Example Combat Casualty Conditions: Past, Current, and Future Battlefields

Abdominal trauma Musculoskeletal injury

Airway compromise Nerve injury


Burn Ocular and optic nerve trauma
Complex chest trauma Pain
Complex extremity trauma Pelvic and genitourinary trauma
Directed energy weapon injuries Pneumothorax
Environmental exposure (e.g., Arctic, subterranean, prolonged sea) Sleep disorders
Hearing loss and tinnitus Spinal cord trauma
Hemorrhage Spine injury
Infection Toxic exposure

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/milmed/article/186/5-6/123/5917413 by guest on 04 September 2022


Maxillofacial trauma Traumatic brain injury
Mental health conditions Wounds

TABLE II. Speakers and Panelists From the AMSUS Regional Conference on Prolonged Field Care Technology Needs, Listed in Order
of Presentations

Speaker/panelist Affiliation

Brigadier General (retired) John Cho Association of Military Surgeons of the USA
Adam Cohen, MD The Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory
Colonel Mike Davis, MD U.S. Army Medical Research and Development Command, Combat Casualty Care Research Program
Colonel Stacy Shakleford, MD Joint Trauma System
Sarah Herman, PhD The Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory
Brian Telfer, PhD Massachusetts Institute of Technology Lincoln Laboratory
Colonel Vikhyat Bebarta, MD Colorado University Anschutz Center for Combat Medicine and Battlefield (COMBAT) Research
Colonel (retired) Ronald Poropatich, MD University of Pittsburgh Center for Military Medicine Research
Scott Gearhart The Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory
Colonel Jerome Buller, MD U.S. Army Institute of Surgical Research
Colonel Robert O’Connell, MD Walter Reed Army Institute of Research
Lieutenant Colonel Sean Hipp, MD U.S. Army Medical Department Brooke Army Medical Center
Kathy Berst Defense Health Agency

In varied military and civilian scenarios, patient needs CURRENT PRACTICE AND IMPLICATIONS FOR
may exceed available capabilities—because of limited skills, PROLONGED FIELD CARE
experts, or resources. Researches to develop new technolo- Tactical Combat Casualty Care, first introduced in the 1990s
gies to improve care across these domains require similar by U.S. Special Operations Command, refers to a standard
approaches. of care for prehospital battlefield medicine.5 The provider is
The future battlefield is projected to be different than typically a field medic or a casualty “buddy.” Conditions span
what was experienced in prior conflicts because of a rapidly common forms of combat-related injury and illness, includ-
changing adversary. Our future military will less likely face ing compressible and noncompressible hemorrhage, loss of
small, disorganized armies in rural settings. It will more likely airway, tension pneumothorax, and burn, some of which
face large, well-organized, and well-resourced armies in both represent causes of potentially survivable death.6
remote and congested urban settings or new environments, In the field, available resources include the provider’s
such as extreme cold, subterranean domains, and prolonged skills, acquired through training, experience, and review of
maritime engagements.3 In addition to contested air superi- the TCCC Guideline2 and the limited number of medical
ority, the combat zone may be different in other ways, as supplies able to fit into a medical backpack. Depending on
well. There may be evolving and highly mobile battlefields, telecommunications availability, remote experts may also
dispersed operations, large casualty volumes (e.g., > 10,000 assist by telemedicine.
over 60 days), more lethal weapons producing new injury Prolonged field care data remain scarce since medical doc-
patterns such as those from directed energy, disrupted com- umentation and other forms of data capture during combat
munications, highly challenging logistics and resupply issues, and transport are limited or absent. To address this, DeS-
and more rapid attrition and movement of medical assets.4
oucy and colleagues collected recall-based surveys on 54 such
This perfect storm of challenges will extend field care from
experiences occurring between 2001 and 2016.7 In that study,
the current duration of hours to a future period of days, indi-
cating a need for a paradigm shift for combat casualty care prolonged field care referred to care delivered on the battle-
strategy. field (role-of-care 1) or prehospital environment that lasted

124 MILITARY MEDICINE, Vol. 186, May/June 2021


Prolonged Field Care Research

longer than 4 hours and required evacuation of the patient to face, but those related to emerging threats such as preci-
a higher level of care. sion weapons, nuclear and nonnuclear strategic weapons, and
Most prolonged field care (74%) was provided outdoors directed energy weapons, as well as new environments such
or in hardened nonmedical structures. Cases were comprised as dense urban, arctic, subterranean, and prolonged maritime
mainly of life-threatening injury or illness (67%). Fifteen environments. It will also likely see the cascade of events and
percent had limb or eyesight-threatening problems. There complications that ensue not over hours, but over days from
was an even distribution of battle injuries (32%), nonbattle the initial injury. Previously benign or mundane injuries, such
injuries (33%), and medical illness (35%). Most cases (70%) as varied types of musculoskeletal conditions, which could be
were attended by Air Force Special Operations Pararescue- easily managed under historical settings, will draw more on-
men, Special Forces Medical Sergeants, or Special Operations site resources, potentially evolve into more grave conditions,
Independent Duty Corpsmen. A physician was on the scene and adversely affect mission success. Further, a clinical cas-

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/milmed/article/186/5-6/123/5917413 by guest on 04 September 2022


24% of the time and teleconsultation occurred in 15% of cade may ensue, which would have been previously averted
cases (typically by a remote surgeon) so 39% of patients had or managed at higher echelons of care. Thus, modeling
physician consultation. clinical natural histories will reveal what needs to be pre-
Potential gaps identified by the providers and authors in vented or addressed in a prolonged care setting. The goal is to
this case series included contingency planning for medic identify what capabilities are most critical to push forward
incapacitation, inadequate documentation (e.g., tourniquet into the future prolonged field care setting.
placement time), TCCC training (e.g., tourniquet conversion, Because resources are limited, a constructive approach
patient hygiene, pain medicine protocols), medical evacuation identifies priorities, and what will not be pursued. A prior-
planning and rehearsals, knowledge of in-country medical itization methodology should capture the importance of the
assets, equipment shortfalls (e.g., oxygen concentrator, mon- problems, but also the feasibility of solving them, cost, and
itors, blood products, intravenous fluids, field laboratory, or relevance to civilian matters. This latter military-civilian com-
ultrasound), and lacking teleconsultation. ponent favors pursuits with industry interest, which makes the
solution more likely to last. Much of the ongoing innovation
PLANNING FOR FUTURE BATTLEFIELD AND in civilian healthcare, including that related to coronavirus
RESOURCE-CONSTRAINED MEDICINE disease of 2019, also aims to bring care closer to the patient.
Best available care typically requires the delivery of patients Thus, prolonged field combat care may draw from the inno-
to capabilities housed within a medical facility. At the facility, vations with civilian and vice versa. These include advance-
the full complement of resources, including trained medical ments toward autonomous care, reduction in care blind spots
staff paired with ample equipment, some of which are bulky (e.g., at home between clinical encounters), early interven-
and immobile, can easily deliver high-level care. tion, and empowerment of lower skilled providers or patients
The prolonged field care setting, which by definition does themselves. Most of the sensors, artificial intelligence, and
not allow casualty delivery to hospitals, requires capabilities other ingredients needed in the civilian sector are also required
to be delivered to the patient. Thus, the major gaps in care and with envisioned prolonged field care technologies.
research center on recreating hospital-like capabilities in the Second, identify the clinical gaps by determining the spe-
field. Since most current hospital capabilities are impractical cific concepts of operations in which the clinical problems are
for the field, the major innovations must replace or match tra- being addressed. The gaps relevant to the hyperacute phase
ditional capabilities but with much smaller footprints and less of field care when physicians are unavailable include clinical
logistical burden. situational unawareness, diagnostic disability, limited equip-
Two additional driving features of the future prolonged ment, and limited expertise to perform procedures. These gaps
field care setting generate requirements. The first is the lack greatly differ from those applicable to other concepts of opera-
of necessary medical personnel, who may be either physi- tions like the subacute phase of care in a fully staffed hospital.
cally or virtually unavailable. The second is the expectation Thus, the specific setting, available resources, and goal must
of mass casualties. With either challenge present, the avail- be understood in order to identify the clinical gaps and narrow
able medical resources become overwhelmed and acceptable the research pursuits.
alternatives must be fast, pervasive, and with some level of There are many clinical gaps and potential operational con-
automation. In essence, the great challenge is to provide effec- cepts related to noncompressible hemorrhage, for example.
tive care without doctors or traditional medical equipment. Research could explore new biomarkers to assess physiologi-
Improving clinical outcomes in future battlefield casu- cal impact, new blood production methods or oxygen-delivery
alties, with the above challenges and constraints in mind, fluids, automated means to collect vital signs, and an end-
depends on thoughtful planning now. Five tenets of planning less list of other potentially important and useful avenues.
(Fig. 1) will maximize success. To maximize impact, a directed approach isolates a high-
First, determine and prioritize the specific problems to priority clinical gap, such as obtaining vascular access, for a
be solved. There will be differences between the battlefield specific operational concept, such as for hyperacute manage-
medical problems of today and tomorrow. The future bat- ment by an inexperienced medic caring for many casualties
tlefield will see not only the medical problems we currently simultaneously. Then, research options are considered only

MILITARY MEDICINE, Vol. 186, May/June 2021 125


Prolonged Field Care Research

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/milmed/article/186/5-6/123/5917413 by guest on 04 September 2022


FIGURE 1. Proposed approach to prolonged field care research. Steps 2 to 5 rely on successful output of prior steps.

against this specific gap and operational concept instead of hobble the most promising ones. Without such an approach,
all potential clinical gaps and operational concepts related to endless dollars will be consumed with scores of disconnected
noncompressible hemorrhage. efforts without transitioning any to impact. Note that the gap
Third, identify the research and technology development sequencing method identifies key requisite components of a
gaps for which gap closure will address the specific chal- solution early in the research and development process such
lenge within an operational concept. For the aforementioned as power and size requirements, which are considered from
hemorrhage example, such gaps include rapid and passive the start to guide research selection.
means to detect and localize hemorrhage, hemorrhage source In addition to a focused research road map, a higher-level
localization, bleeding control (if tourniquets are inadequate research plan establishes how successive focused research
or unavailable), blood volume (or a physiological equivalent) road maps tackle increasingly difficult problems and produce
reconstitution, and downstream ischemia and reperfusion more complex solutions. For example, the higher-level
injury avoidance. Note that these gaps are agnostic to a research plan begins with no autonomy, but proceeds through
solution approach or specific type of research undertaking. the varied levels of autonomy, ultimately to achieve a fully
Fourth, develop a research road map such that research and autonomous system. Thus, an early set of research objectives
technology development gaps are placed in order to sequen- may aim to improve a medic’s ability to cannulate the femoral
tially tackle each challenge. The sequence is dictated by vein using telemedicine assistance. A later set of objectives
potential dependences whereby later gaps cannot (or should may focus on augmenting the medic’s effectiveness through
not) be addressed before earlier gaps are closed. For exam- machine assistance to identify anatomic targets with aug-
ple, research to establish mild traumatic brain injury objective mented reality, which also helps her navigate procedural and
standards and definitions should precede research to develop clinical checklists with clinical decision support algorithms.
new sensors to detect mild traumatic brain injury. Research objectives at the end of the plan aim to cannulate the
For each research and technology development gap, can- femoral vein without human intervention, focusing on a fully
didate research options are identified and prioritized. The autonomous medical system that perceives the problem (e.g.,
complete array of potential research approaches for each gap via on-patient sensors), diagnoses the condition, and takes
should be explored. Then, only the ones most likely to be use- necessary actions by gathering and using appropriate tools.
ful and deployed are pursued. Again, pursuing all options will In this way, the high-level research plan outlines the research

126 MILITARY MEDICINE, Vol. 186, May/June 2021


Prolonged Field Care Research

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/milmed/article/186/5-6/123/5917413 by guest on 04 September 2022


FIGURE 2. Technology research pursuit areas for prolonged field care.

approach to achieve each level of autonomy whereby the first the horizon. Yet, the components are being developed. These
research and technology development road map achieves a include small physiological sensors, intelligent robotics, arti-
low level of autonomy, and the later ones aim for higher levels ficial intelligence algorithms to detect clinical problems and
of autonomy. guide clinical actions, a standard20 architecture by which tech-
Fifth, prioritize research undertakings that advance as nologies interact, and computers powerful enough to store,
many high-priority problems (and clinical gaps) as possible. move, and process the data. Short of a fully autonomous
If the problem relates to noncompressible hemorrhage, for medical system, the individual components will first exist
example, the development of a pertinent novel sensor may be on an earlier research road map that aims to team machines
relevant to other high-priority problems such as small bone with available onsite personnel, enhancing their capabilities
fracture and pneumothorax. Thus, one research lane may cut to enable effective care.
across problem spaces, potentially making it more preferable
to pursue. It is also preferable to design a research program MILITARY-CIVILIAN CHALLENGES TACKLED
such that each successive research output provides real-world TOGETHER
use and clinical impact—instead of a program unlikely to Pertinent to prolonged battlefield care are various other
produce useful outputs until every related gap is closed. prolonged care environments. Research gaps cut across
The varied research pursuit areas of the prolonged field these domains, which include wilderness care, space travel
care community were highlighted in our conference (Fig. 2). medicine, and civilian care in remote settings or during
At a basic level, the research pursuits follow the basic com- extended medical transport.8–12 Additionally, if material or
ponents of patient care: assess, diagnose, treat, and reassess. human resources become limited in standard civilian care set-
Each of these components, from the technology perspective, tings, such as during a pandemic, an effective prolonged field
falls into three broad categories: perceive, decide, and act care state emerges. Identifying research gaps relevant to both
(Fig. 2). prolonged battlefield and civilian care serves the interests of
Consider again a problem like extremity hemorrhage in both by: focusing strategy, funding, resources, investigators,
a setting without fully capable medical personnel whereby industry, and regulatory bodies.
the operational goal is a fully autonomous care system. First, Consider a soldier requiring urgent intubation and pro-
the problem must be perceived. In other words, the hemor- longed mechanical ventilation in the field whereby medi-
rhage cannot be addressed without being recognized. Clinical cal evacuation is unavailable or denied. Perhaps a medic is
observation paired with physiological and lab data allow both available, but without intubation or mechanical ventilation
recognition of the hemorrhage and its initial complications experience. His rucksack does not have an intubation kit or
like hypotension and effect on patient function (e.g., cog- ventilator. Thus, the medic needs supplies but even if on hand,
nition). Second, the observer then must decide what to do. requires assistance with both intubation and managing the
Options include obtaining more data, gathering supplies, or ventilator.
performing a clinical intervention like applying a pressure Now consider a civilian hospital overwhelmed with
dressing. Third, an action is taken that executes the decision. severely ill patients with coronavirus disease of 2019.13
A fully autonomous, intelligent field-based medical system Although anesthesiologists, critical care physicians, and high-
to manage acute traumatic hemorrhage is currently beyond end medical equipment are on site, all have been consumed by

MILITARY MEDICINE, Vol. 186, May/June 2021 127


Prolonged Field Care Research

the initial wave of admissions. Remaining personnel lack rel- REFERENCES


evant management skills and the ventilator supply is depleted. 1. Keenan S, Riesberg JC: Prolonged field care: beyond the “golden
In both scenarios, available providers need medical guid- hour”. Wilderness Environ Med 2017; 28(2S): S135-9.
ance. If telemedicine is unavailable or unreliable, machine 2. TCCC guidelines 2019; Available at: https://books.allogy.com/web/
tenant/8/books/b729b76a-1a34-4bf7-b76b-66bb2072b2a7/; accessed
sensing and decision assistance would be invaluable. For July 10, 2020
ventilators, not only would low-cost, small, easy-to-use 3. Summary of the 2018 National Defense Strategy of the United States
versions be ideal in each environment, but closed-loop of America; 2018. Department of Defense, Washington DC
autonomous machine-based control could replace skills nor- 4. Command USATAD: The U.S. Army in Multi-Domain Operations
mally contained within respiratory therapists and critical 2028; 2018. Department of Defense, Washington DC
5. Butler FK, Hagmann J, Butler EG: Tactical combat casualty care in
care physicians. Recent research is exploring all such special operations. Mil Med 1996; 161(Suppl Chapter 1): 3-16.
potential solutions in the form of automated respiratory 6. Eastridge BJ, Mabry RL, Seguin P, et al: Death on the battlefield (2001-

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/milmed/article/186/5-6/123/5917413 by guest on 04 September 2022


physiology sensors, computerized clinical decision support 2011) implications for the future of combat casualty care. J Trauma
algorithms, artificial intelligence to guide sensing and deci- Acute Care Surg 2012; 73(Suppl 6): S431-7.
sions, and autonomous intubation and closed-loop ventilatory 7. DeSoucy E, Shackelford S, DuBose JJ, et al: Review of 54 cases of
prolonged field care. J Spec Oper Med 2017; 17(1): 121-9.
systems.14–17 Many more military-civilian overlap scenarios 8. Thibeault C, Evans AD, Pettyjohn FS, Alves PM: AsMA medical
exist, including mobile diagnostic imaging, and remote and guidelines for air travel: in-flight medical care. Aerospace Med Hum
autonomous triage and management.18,19 Perform 2015; 86(6): 572-3.
The problems in the combat arena that require prolonged 9. Stepanek J, Blue RS, Parazynski S: Space medicine in the era of
care are analogous to those across civilian healthcare beyond civilian spaceflight. Reply. N Engl J Med 2019; 380(11): e50.
10. Bogomolov VV, Castrucci F, Comtois J-M, et al: International space
pandemics and the scenarios already outlined. Medicine is station medical standards and certification for space flight participants.
quickly becoming increasingly digital, whereby care will Aviat Space Environ Med 2007; 78(12): 1162-9.
be increasingly delivered to the patient—instead of patients 11. Scoles S: A new kind of space camp teaches the art of Martian
being delivered to the source of care. medicine. Available at: https://www.wired.com/story/a-new-kind-of-
The trend is toward continuously more capabilities of for- space-camp-teaches-the-art-of-martian-medicine/. Published June 25,
2019; accessed May 2, 2020.
ward personnel (and patients themselves), which enables 12. Langford S: The Leading Edge. Apollo Books; 2015. UWA Publish-
more care to be delivered out of traditional care facilities and ing; Crawley, Western Australia
less on-site expert dependency. Given the great magnitude 13. Grasselli G, Pesenti A, Cecconi M: Critical care utilization for the
of resources required to tackle the challenges facing pro- COVID-19 outbreak in Lombardy, Italy: early experience and forecast
longed battlefield care, identifying and collaborating on those during an emergency response. JAMA March 2020. 323:1545-1546
14. Johannigman JA, Muskat P, Barnes S, Davis K, Branson RD:
that extend outside the battlefield are imperative to future Autonomous control of ventilation. J Trauma 2008; 64(4 Suppl):
missions. S302-20.
15. Morris AH: Treatment algorithms and protocolized care. Curr Opin
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Crit Care 2003; 9(3): 236-40.
The authors thank the AMSUS regional conference organizers and lead- 16. Tehrani FT, Roum JH: Intelligent decision support systems for
ers, including Susan Bachenheimer and Lori Lawrence and Dr. John Cho. mechanical ventilation. Artif Intell Med 2008; 44(3): 171-82.
They also thank the conference speakers; Johns Hopkins University Applied 17. Carlson JN, Das S, la Torre De F, et al: A novel artificial intelligence
Physics Laboratory staff Sarah Toth Johnson, Theresa Myers, and Suzy system for endotracheal intubation. Prehosp Emerg Care 2016; 20(5):
Kennedy; and U.S. Army Combat Casualty Care Research Program staff 667-71.
Dr. Therese West and LTC David Johnston. 18. Vetrugno L, Bove T, Orso D, et al: Our Italian experience using lung
ultrasound for identification, grading and serial follow-up of sever-
ity of lung involvement for management of patients with COVID-19.
FUNDING Echocardiography 2020; 37(4): 625-7.
19. Swaminathan S, Toro B, Wysham N, Mark N: CovidX: Remote screen-
This effort received no grant support.
ing, surveillance, triage, and management of novel Coronavirus. https:/
/covidx.vironix.ai. covidxvironixai
20. The Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory. April 2020. Med-
CONFLICT OF INTEREST STATEMENT ical Device Interoperability Reference Architecture. Accessed on
None declared. September 10, 2020. https://secwww.jhuapl.edu/mdira.

128 MILITARY MEDICINE, Vol. 186, May/June 2021

You might also like