Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Seminar Report
Submitted to
Degree of
Bachelor of Engineering
By
Dr. V. B. Padole
2021-2022.
Department of Electronics and Telecommunication Engineering
P. R. Pote Patil Education & Welfare Trust's Group of Institutions,
College of Engineering & Management.
Amravati – 444605 (M. S.)
2021 – 2022.
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the Seminar report entitled
Submitted by
In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of Degree of Bachelor of Engineering in
Electronics and Telecommunication Engineering by Sant Gadge Baba Amravati University & is a
bonafied work carried out during the session 2021-2022.
i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
torchbearers, who have rendered valuable guidance during the preparation of our Seminar.
First of all, we extend our deepest gratitude to our revered Principal Dr. A.V. Kale
without whose support; our Seminar could not have been transformed into present form.
Engineering Department; and guide Dr. V. B. Padole for providing immense support and
guidance. We are beholden for guiding us at every step in the Seminar. He has most honestly
guided me throughout; never leaving me unanswered for any of our doubts. It was his
ii
Abstract
The role of defense against nuclear missile has been a heated military and political
topic for several decades. However, missile defense is no longer limited to interception of
strategic nuclear weapons. The terms “Missile Defense System” broadly means a system that
provides any defense against any missile type (conventional or nuclear) by any country. Any
mechanism which can detect and then destroy a missile before it can any harm is called a
missile defense system (MSD).
The gradual development and proliferation of missile technology has blurred and line
between the technologies for the interception of tactical missile (usually short to intermediate
range with non-nuclear payloads) and the interception of strategic missile (usually long
ranged with nuclear payloads). Missile defense can be divided into categories based on the
various characteristics: Types/range of missile interception, the trajectory phase where the
intercept occurs, and whether intercepted inside the Earth’s atmosphere). High-performance
tactical ballistic missile carrying non-nuclear payloads now have the ability to affect strategic balance
in conflict zones. Likewise, high-performance tactical missile defense system can now influence force
deployment strategies.
iii
TABLE OF CONTENT
Acknowledgement ii
Abstract iii
Table of content iv
List of figure v
1 Introduction 1
1.1 Introduction 1
1.3 Mechanisms 3
2 System Overview 4
2.1 History 4
2.2 Countermeasures 5
2.3 Features 6
3.1 Strategic 7
3.2 Theater 7
3.3 Tactical 8
3.4 Endoatmospheric 8
3.5 Exoatmospheric 9
4 A System Of Elements 11
iv
4.3 Terminal phase 12
5 Working Principal 13
5.2 Elements 15
5.3 Advantages 17
5.4 Disadvantages 17
6 Conclusion 19
References 20
v
LIST OF FIGURE
2 MIM-104 Patriot 8
4 Working Of System 14
vi
Missile Defense System
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Missile Defense System are a type of missile defense intended to shield a country
against income missiles, such as intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBMs) or other
ballistic missile. The United States, Russia, India, France, Israel, Italy, United
Kingdom and China have all developed missile defense system.
Any mechanism which can detect and then destroy a missile before it can cause any
harm is called a missile defense system (MDS). The role of defense against nuclear
missiles has been a heated military and political topic for several decades. However,
missile defense is no longer limited to interception of strategic nuclear weapons. The
gradual development and proliferation of missile technology has blurred the line
between the technologies for the interception of tactical missile (usually short to
intermediate range with non-nuclear payload) and the interception of strategic
missiles (Usually long ranged with nuclear payloads). High-performance tactical
ballistic missile carrying non-nuclear payloads now have the ability to affect strategic
balance in conflict zones. Likewise, high-performance tactical missile defense system
can now influence force deployment strategies. Missile defense can be divided into
categories based on various characteristics: type/range of missile intercepted, the
trajectory phase where the intercept occurs, and whether intercepted inside or outside
the Earth's atmosphere. These types/ranges include strategic, theater and tactical. Each
entails unique requirements for intercept, and a defensive system capable of
intercepting one missile type frequently cannot intercept others. However, there is
sometimes overlap in capability.
Given the immense variety by which a defense system can operate (targeting nuclear-
armed intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs), tactical, and theater missiles), there
are some unarguably effective atmospheric (outside the Earth's atmosphere)
countermeasures an attacking party can use to deter or completely defend against
certain types of defense systems, ranges of ACBM's, and intercept locations. Many of
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 1
Missile Defense System
defenses to these countermeasures have been implemented and taken into account
when constructing missile defense systems, however, it does not guarantee their
effectiveness or success. The U.S. Missile Defense Agency has received scrutiny in
regards to their lack of foresight of these countermeasures, causing many scientists to
perform various studies and data analysis as to the true effectiveness of these
countermeasures.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 2
Missile Defense System
The integrated air- and missile-defense battle command system (ICBS) is seen as the
future for command and control systems for U.S. Army defense systems. It is
designed to integrate data relay between weapon launchers, radars, and the operators,
which allows air-defense units to fire interceptors with information being relayed
among radars. The advantage of such a system is it can increase the area an air unit
can defend. More importantly, it can reduce interceptor waste by reducing the
probability that more than one air defense unit would launch unnecessary interceptors
towards the same target. The IBCS is intended to replace other command and control
systems already in use. The IBCS is also capable of being comparable with that of
foreign military. There are some intentions for the use of IBCS on a global level with
the global C2BMC system.
1.3 MECHANISMS
Active Layered Theater Ballistic Missile Defense System is "ALTBMD" for short. As
of early 2010, the Alliance has an interim capability to protect troops in a specific area
against short-range and medium-range ballistic missiles (up to 3,000 kilometers). The
end system consist of a multi-layered system of systems, comprising low- and high-
altitude defenses (also called lower- and upper-layer defenses), including Battle
Management Command, Control, Communications and Intelligence (BMC3I), early
warning sensors, radar, and various interceptors. NATO member countries provide
the sensors and weapon systems, while NATO has developed the BMC3I segment
and facilitate the integration of all these elements.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 3
Missile Defense System
Chapter 2
SYSTEM OVERVIEW
2.1 HISTORY
The problem was first studied during the last year of the Second World War. The
only countermeasure against the V-2 missile that could be devised was a massive
barrage of anti-aircraft guns. Even if the missile's trajectory were accurately
calculated, the guns would still have a small probability of destroying it before impact
with the ground. Also, the shells fired by the guns would have caused more damage
than the actual missile when they fell back to the ground. Plans for an operational test
began anyway, but the idea was rendered moot when the V-2 launching sites in the
Netherlands were captured.
In the 1950s and 1960s, missile defense meant defense against strategic (usually
nuclear-armed) missiles. The technology mostly centered around detecting offensive
launch events and tracking inbound ballistic missiles, but with limited ability to
actually defend against the missile. The Soviet Union achieved the first nonnuclear
intercept of a ballistic missile warhead by a missile at the Sary Shagan antiballistic
missile defense test range on 4 March 1961. Nicknamed the “Griffon” missile system,
it would be installed around Leningrad as a test. Throughout the 1950s and 1960s, the
United States Project Nike air defense program focused initially on targeting hostile
bombers before shifting focus to targeting ballistic missiles. In the 1950s, the first
United States anti-ballistic missile system was the Nike Hercules, which had the
ability to intercept incoming short-range ballistic missiles, but not intermediate-range
ballistic missiles (IRBMs) or ICBMs.
This was followed by the Nike Zeus, which was capable of intercepting ICBMs by
using a nuclear warhead, upgraded radar systems, faster computers, and control
systems that were more effective in the upper atmosphere. However it was feared the
missile's electronics may be vulnerable to x-rays from a nuclear detonation in space.
A program was started to devise methods of hardening weapons from radiation
damage.[18] By the early 1960s the Nike Zeus was the first anti-ballistic missile to
achieve hit-to-kill (physically colliding with the incoming warhead).
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 4
Missile Defense System
2.2 COUNTERMEASURES
A common countermeasure that attacking parties use to disrupt the efficacy of Missile
Defense Systems are the simultaneous launching of decoys from the primary launch
site or from the exterior of the main attacking missile itself. These decoys are usually
small, lightweight dud rockets that take advantage of the interceptor sensors tracking
and fool it by making many different targets available in an instant. This is
accomplished via the releasing of decoys in certain phases of flight. Because objects
of differing weights follow the same trajectory when in space, decoys released during
the midcourse phase can prevent interceptor missiles from accurately identifying the
warhead. This could force the defense system to attempt to destroy all incoming
projectiles, which masks the true attacking missile and lets it slip by the defense
system.
This categorization of decoy is the most similar to the standard understanding of what
a missile decoy is. These types of decoys attempt to mask the attacking ICBM via the
release of many similar missiles. This type of decoy confuses the missile defense
system by the sudden replication the sheer amount of similar targets there are.
Knowing that no defense system is 100% reliable, this confusion within the targeting
of the defense system would cause the system to target each decoy with equal priority
and as if it was the actual warhead, allowing the real warheads chance of passing
through the system and striking the target to increase drastically.
Similar to replica decoys, these types of decoys also take advantage of the limitations
in number within the missile defense systems targeting. However, rather than using
missiles of similar build and trace to the attacking warhead, these types of decoys all
have slightly different appearances from both each other and the warhead itself. This
creates a different kind of confusion within the system; rather than creating a situation
where each decoy (and the warhead itself) appears the same and is therefore targeted
and treated exactly like the "real" warhead, the targeting system simply does not know
what is the real threat and what is a decoy due to the mass amount of differing
information. This creates a similar situation as the result of the replica decoy,
increasing the chance that the real warhead passes through the system and strikes the
target.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 5
Missile Defense System
2.3 FEATURES
Protecting people, places and the principle of sovereignty itself takes vision. It takes
precision. It takes technologically advanced sensors, command-and-control
systems, satellites and interceptors, working in layers to defeat all types of threats,
from short-range missiles to hypersonic warheads hurtling through space.
They mean command-and-control systems can process data faster. And they mean
operators can employ interceptors to engage their targets with even greater
precision. The missile has the capability to shoot down targets moving at 10 km per
second in orbits as high as 1,200 km. Sensors that track and target warheads aboard
the kinetic kill vehicle may have trouble distinguishing the "real" warhead from the
decoys, but several tests that have included decoys were successful.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 6
Missile Defense System
Chapter 3
3.1 STRATEGIC
Targets long-range ICBMs, which travel at about 7 km/s (15,700 mph). Examples of
currently active systems: Russian A-135 system which defends Moscow, and the
U.S. Ground-Based Midcourse Defense system that defends the United States from
missiles launched from Asia. Geographic range of strategic defense can be regional
(Russian system) or national (U.S. system).
3.2 THEATER
Targets medium-range missiles, which travel at about 3 km/s (6,700 mph) or less. In
this context, the term "theater" means the entire localized region for military
operations, typically a radius of several hundred kilometers. Defense range of theater
defensive systems is usually on this order. Examples of deployed theater missile
defenses: Israeli Arrow missile, American THAAD, and Russian S-400.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 7
Missile Defense System
3.3 TACTICAL
Targets short-range tactical ballistic missiles, which usually travel at less than
1.5 km/s (3,400 mph). Tactical anti-ballistic missiles (ABMs) have short ranges,
typically 20–80 km (12–50 miles). Examples of currently-deployed tactical ABMs:
American MIM-104 Patriot and Russian S-300V.
3.4 ENDOATMOSPHERIC
Advantages:
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 8
Missile Defense System
Disadvantages:
3.5 EXOATMOSPHERIC
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
The Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) system is used to combat
missile threats in the terminal phase. The THAAD system consists of a RADAR,
interceptors, launchers, and fire control system that is truck deployable. The
THAAD system is designed to combat short and medium range ballistic
missiles. The THAAD is the newest BMD system in the United States arsenal
and currently has a 100% success rate during flight testing.
The Patriot Advanced Capability-3 (PAC-3) system is the final BMD system in
the United States arsenal. The PAC-3 is used to combat missile threats in the
terminal phase. You may be familiar with the original Patriot missile system used
during the first Persian Gulf War. The Patriot system is the most mature BMD
system in the arsenal. The PAC-3 system is designed to combat short and
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 9
Missile Defense System
medium range ballistic missiles and. The PAC-3 can intercept missiles at lower
altitudes than the THAAD systems.
The most reliable defense against ballistic missile attack is the United States
Aegis Ballistic Defense. The Aegis RADAR is manufactured by Lockheed
Martin and integrated with the broader Command and Control and weapon
systems aboard Aegis Class destroyers. The Aegis system is also available in
land based systems. The Aegis system is designed to combat short and medium
range ballistic missiles throught use or RADAR tracking and interceptor
launch. The Aegis system has an approximately 80% intercept success rate.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 10
Missile Defense System
Chapter 4
A SYSTEM OF ELEMENTS
Ballistic missile trajectories are commonly divided into three phases of flight: boost,
midcourse, and terminal. Each element will play an important role in a robust system
intended to defend against hostile missiles in any phase of flight.
The boost phase defenses can defeat ballistic missiles of all ranges including
Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles (ICBMs), but it is the most difficult phase in which
to engage a missile. The intercept "window" is only from one to five minutes.
Although the missile is easiest to detect and track in the boost phase because its
exhaust is bright and hot, missile defense interceptors and sensors must be in close
proximity to the missile launch. Early detection in the boost phase allows for a rapid
response and intercept early in its flight, possibly before any countermeasures can be
deployed.
The midcourse phase begins when the enemy missile's booster burns out and it begins
coasting in space towards its target. This phase can last as long as 20 minutes,
allowing several opportunities to destroy the incoming ballistic missile outside the
earth's atmosphere. Any debris remaining after the intercept will burn up as it enters
the atmosphere. The Ground-based Midcourse Defense element is now deployed in
Alaska and California to defend the U.S. homeland against a limited attack from
rogue nations. This system can only defend against intermediate and long-range
ballistic missiles.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 11
Missile Defense System
hostile missile, destroying with hit-to-kill technology. These sensors and radars
include transportable X-band radars, as well as advanced radars aboard Aegis cruisers
and destroyers capable of operating in the world's oceans.
The terminal phase is very short and begins once the missile reenters the atmosphere.
It is the last opportunity to make an intercept before the warhead reaches its target.
Intercepting a warhead during this phase is difficult and the least desirable of the
phases because there is little margin for error and the intercept will occur close to the
intended target. Terminal phase interceptor elements include the Terminal High
Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) now being delivered to the U.S. Army, the Aegis
BMD near-term Sea-Based Terminal Defense capability using the SM-2 Block IV
missile, and the U.S. Army's PATRIOT Advanced Capability-3 (PAC-3) now
deployed worldwide. These mobile systems defend against short- to medium-range
missiles.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 12
Missile Defense System
Chapter 5
WORKING PRINCIPAL
• Payload Vehicle (PLV) - Flight tests have been conducted with a PLV
designed by Lockheed Martin. It consists of the second and third stages of
retired Minuteman II boosters. The Minuteman II PLV will later be replaced
with a more advanced model for one-site coverage of the entire United States.
In addition to the two booster stages on the PLV, there is also a payload
shroud attached to the top. The payload shroud contains the EKV.
• Exoatmospheric Kill Vehicle (EKV) - The kill vehicle is the bullet of NMD's
weapon system. This device is intended to impact the targeted missile at a
velocity of 15,000 mph (24,140 kph). The force of the collision should destroy
any ballistic missile, according to defense officials. The process of
pinpointing, aiming an interceptor at and then killing the target with an EKV is
very complex. There are many components that have to be coordinated in real
time, and the entire procedure is completed less than 30 minutes after the
enemy missile takes off.
The Ground-Based Midcourse Defense (GMD) system can be utilized during the
midcourse phase of flight. The GMD system tracks initial and projected
trajectory of the missile with radar data and then launches interceptor missiles
from locations in Alaska or California. These interceptor missiles reach space
and collide with the warhead. The system has approximately a 50% success rate
during operational testing.
Together, space-based satellites and ground- or sea-based radars create a monitoring
system that contribute to offensive missile detection (detecting a missile after it has
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 13
Missile Defense System
Each system has a combination of the below mentioned sensors, radars, interceptors,
kill vehicles, and largely use the networked command and control. The above systems
rely on the below equipment and components:
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 14
Missile Defense System
5.2 ELEMENTS
Radars:
• X-Band Radars
o Sea-based X-Band Radar
o Army Navy (AN) Transportable Radar Surveillance (AN/TPY 2), the
Transportable X-band Radar
• COBRA DANE Radar
• Upgraded Early Warning Radars (UEWR)
• Army Navy (AN) SPY-1 Radar (part of the initial missile defense capability—
used aboard Aegis cruisers/destroyers)
• (Under Development) Air and Missile Defense Radar (AMDR), also known as
the Army Navy (AN) SPY-6 Radar
• (Under Development) Long Range Discrimination Radar
Radar (Radio Detection and Ranging) is a detection system that uses radio waves to
determine the distance (range), angle, or velocity of objects. It can be used to
detect aircraft, ships, spacecraft, guided missiles, motor vehicles, weather formations,
and terrain. A radar system consists of a transmitter producing electromagnetic
waves in the radio or microwaves domain, a transmitting antenna, a receiving antenna
(often the same antenna is used for transmitting and receiving) and
a receiver and processor to determine properties of the object(s).
• Space Tracking and Surveillance System (STSS) and Space Tracking and
Surveillance System-Demonstrators (STSS-D) constellation operated by the
Missile Defense Agency
• Space-based Kill Assessment (SKA) hosted on commercial satellites
• Near Field Infrared Experiment (NFIRE) technology project, operated by the
Missile Defense Agency
• Defense Support Program (DSP), constellation of satellites operated by the
U.S. Air Force Space Command
• (Under Development) Space-based Infrared System (SBIRS), constellation of
integrated satellites operated by the U.S. Air Force Space Command
o SBIRS-LEO (Low Earth Orbit), incorporated into the STSS program in
2001 with the Missile Defense Agency
o (Under Development) SBIRS-GEO (Geosynchronous orbit), intended
to replace Defense Support Program (DSP)
o (Under Development) SBIRS-HEO (High Elliptical orbit), intended to
replace DSP
Interceptors:
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 15
Missile Defense System
Kill Vehicle:
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 16
Missile Defense System
5.3 ADVANTAGES
The Department of Defense requires a capability to both negate and deter the use of
theater ballistic missiles in future conflicts. To meet this need, the United States Air
Force is developing a revolutionary new weapon system call the Airborne Laser and
employing one aspect of information warfare; the near real time transfer and use of
theater ballistic missile launch point data. The Air Force theater missile defense
program seeks to bring the battle to the enemy by engaging the launched threat as
early as possible in its flight path. Additionally, it denies the enemy the use of their
theater ballistic missile infrastructure through destruction and deterrence. Due to their
inherent inaccuracy, however, many countries are increasing their lethality by
developing warheads equipped with these warheads of mass destruction.
The most often cited rationale given for defense against theater missiles is that they
are capable of employing nuclear, biological or chemical (NBC) weapons.
• It is essential to defend against theater missiles is that they threaten our
capability to effectively wage war.
• The main missile threats that missile defense systems have aimed to defend
against have been ballistic missiles, but more recently, greater emphasis has
been placed on defending against other types of missiles as well.
• It create a monitoring system that contribute to offensive missile detection
(detecting a missile after it has been launched), discrimination (what is a threat
versus a decoy or other countermeasures), and tracking (keeping the missile
“in sight” so that an interceptor can find it and eliminate the threat).
• Because they are designed to defeat incoming missile attacks, missile defense
systems can save lives and protect civilian infrastructure from damage or
destruction. More important, missile defense plays a critical role in strategic
deterrence.
5.4 DISADVANTAGES
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 17
Missile Defense System
volume they occupy, fissile material, the core of a Ballistic Missile weighs more
per unit of volume than most other materials.
• They have a lot of tech in them, so if one fails to explode, then you
potentially have just granted access to your tech to the enemy.
• They cost tons of money for kg explosives delivered.
• The proliferation of nuclear, chemical and biological weapons,
combined with missile capability, is the greatest threat that people
will face in the coming years, The weapons of mass destruction can
be delivered by aircraft and also on the ground by terrorists, most of
whom will find it easier to use conventional firearms and explosives.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 18
Missile Defense System
Chapter 6
CONCLUSION
With missile defense, having a system in place could prevent an enemy attack from
ever reaching many places. It’s peace of mind worth investing in. Missile defense is a
critical component of the national security architecture that enables every country
military efforts and can protect national critical infrastructure, from population and
industrial centers to politically and historically important sites. It can strengthen
diplomatic and deterrence efforts and provide both time and options to senior
decision-makers amid crises involving missiles flying on both ballistic and non-
ballistic trajectories (e.g., cruise missiles and hypersonic weapons). Because they are
designed to defeat incoming missile attacks, missile defense systems can save lives
and protect civilian infrastructure from damage or destruction. More important,
missile defense plays a critical role in strategic deterrence. The ability to deter an
enemy from attacking depends on convincing him that his attack will fail, that the cost
of carrying out a successful attack is prohibitively high, or that the consequences of an
attack will be so painful that they will outweigh the perceived benefit of attacking.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 19
Missile Defense System
REFERENCES
1. "Interceptor missile scores 'direct hit'". The Hindu. 7 December 2007. Archived
from the original on 26 October 2012. Retrieved 6 December 2012.
https://www,interceptormissile.com/WCES2010.html.
2. US-Japan military successfully intercept a ballistic missile target with SM-3 Block
IIA.
3. "Japan backs out of costly US missile system despite 'imminent threat' from
North Korea". The Guardian. 26 June 2020. Retrieved 27 June 2020.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missile_defense_system.
4. "Missile defense systems: Arrow". Claremont InstituteMissileThreat.com.
Archived from the original on 14 October 2009. Retrieved 19 August 2009.
5. "Development of Ballistic Missile Defence System: Year End Review" (Press
release). Ministry of Defence (India). 28 December 2007. Retrieved 26
January 2008.
6. Missile defense system at a glance
https://E:/Missile%20Defense%20Systems%20at%20a%20Glance%20_%20Arms
%20Control%20Association.html
7. Air Force Theater Missile Defense-Advantages and Challenges Maj Stewart
Kowall : file:///E:/kowall.pdf.
8. Missile Defense System By Country Wikipedia .
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missile_defense_systems_by_country .
9. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missile_defense.
EXTC/PRPCEM/2021-22 20