Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Respt Pulpar Al Calor Externo
Respt Pulpar Al Calor Externo
I. B. Bender, Editor
This study was supported by Research Grant D-00530, Kationnl Institute of Dental Re-
search, United States Public Health Service.
*Assistant Professor of Pathology, College of Dentistry, New York University.
“*Section Chief, Prosthodontia, Dental Department, Veterans Hospital, New York, N. Y.
515
The measured rises in intrapnlpal tempcratln-c ~v~~I*cd(~libct~;rtt:l~~ k~I)f, wit Ill11
the range of heat rises which might bc anticipatctl during operntivcb 1II~~w~~~IW.
\VC have re;p~l%~l individual instancxcs 01’ i(~nrl>(‘riltliI’c inrl*(>;ls(ls ])(‘;t killg :IS
high as Go 8’. within the pulp aftti- 20 SccWnds ol’ irppIic2tion of ill1 air-t tirbin(a -
impelled bur using air as the onIy cooIant.!’ 12 SO0 E’. risct was adol)tcd as the
maximum t,o be assayed histologicall- in this study, so that corl*clatcls with a
broader range of clinical opcrativc dental procednros could be considcrctl.
Multichannel
Telethermometer
Thermistor Bead t
Encased in 22ga sealed needle
The animals wcrc killed by bilatcLra1 perfusion of the carotitl artc:rics wit II
Bouin’s picratc-formalin solution. This technique minimixcs fixation artcfaet
Tooth-bearing blocks of full-thickness mandible and maxilla W(W further fixcttl
and then decalcified in neutral buffered EDTA (sodium salt). Paraffin sections
were cut at 7 microns and stained wit,h hematoxylin-eosin, alcian. blue-PAS
( Schiff) , and Weigert’s reticulin stains. Control sections were also preparrcl
from each animal, using teeth to which external heat was not applied.
RESULTS
lntrapulpal temperature increase of 4O F.
After 2 days this modest temperature increase produced only minimal intra-
pulpal changes confined to the odontoblasts in continuity with the area of ap-
plication of the soldering iron tip. A few small interodontoblastic vacuoles (V)
were evident just below the predentine (PD), as shown in Fig. 2. These micro-
blisters were directly attribut,able to heat rise at a low range. No other changes
were found; the stroma was normal and the predentine was unaffected. Sec-
tions taken at subsequent intervals of 7 days to 3 months after external heat
application disclosed normal pulps with no trace of increased secondary dentine
elaboration. These specimens were histologically unidentifiable from control
unheated specimens.
Fig, 5.
Pi!/. 6.
Fiy. 5 Ten lperaturr increase of 10” F., after 1 week. Odontoblastic dt ~bris is being en-
gulfed hv ‘histic jcytes (H). Parked blood vessels (BP) are seen in the rdemz ttous St,1roma ( F).
(Magnifi;:: tti “11, x210 ; reduced :ys.)
Fig. 6 Tern tperature inarease of 10” F., after 2 weeks. Repair has begs m in th .e zone Of
Weil (ZW 5 wit ;h proliferation of preodontoblasts (PO). Predentine (P. j) is i iOl-1 ned wl hile
aspirated odont oblasts persist. (Magnification, x750; reduced :ys.l
Volume 19
Number 4
Rig. Y. Temperature increase of 10” F., after 8 weeks. A thick plaque of scar dentine
(ID) below the calciotraumatic line (CL) is evidence of healing. Pulpodental membrane (Paw)
is re-formed. Lingual wall area (LW) shows relative inactivity. (Magnification, x60 ; re-
duced Vs.)
Fig. 8. Temperature increase of 20” F., after 2 days. Odontoblasts (0) destroyed and
dcntine rich in ectopic nuclei (AO). Blood vessels (BV) are engorged. (Magnification, rlW;
reduced l/s.)
522 Zach and Cohen
Fi g. 3. Temperature increase of 20” F., after 1 meek. Stroma is rich with histiocytes (U)>
while odontoblastic dehris (PO) is “fixed” in the injured pulp. (Magnification, x750 ; re-
dUCd %.I
Pi g. 10. Temperature increase of 20” F., after 2 wwks. Rrpair is proceeding as de tntine
matrix : (RD) is elaborated and preodontoblasts (PR) move into position. Trapped od lonto-
l~lxsts cI’0) persist. Frw pulps withstood a 20 degree rise. (Magnification, x750; rrduwd %.I
O.S., 0.M. c 0.1’.
April, 1965
Fig. 11. l’m~pcrature increase of 20” I’., after 8 ~ceks. Note successful healing aftct
great stress, with odontoblastic debris (PO) wtrapped within atres3 dentine (ED). Odonto-
blasts (0) have re-formed. (Magnification, x450 ; rcduwd ‘A.)
remained (Fig. 12) as a pcrmant~nt stigma of the thermal trauma (ED). The
pulpodenta,l membrane (Pdl) had Betsy re-formed, and there was reversion to
the elaboration of normal prcdcntint (PD) with regular tubules. The adjacent
stroma was richly vascular, reflcctinp 11le heightened metabolic requirements of
this hyperactive area of pulp.
Teeth which failed to respond with a reparative reaction to this critical level
of a 20° F. intrapulpal heat incremc~nt almost invariably demonstrated an intra-
pulpal abscess. Fig. 13 is typical of the t,hirtccn specimens (out of twenty-one)
so deranged at 20° F. as to respond with irreparable necrosis. The pulp-horn
abscess (A) was bordered by a i’ecble attempt at fibrous walling-off, but thch
deeper stroma was liberally infiltrated with I)c~lymorphonuclear leukocytes (PI;).
Fig. II. Temperature increase of 20” F., after 12 weeks. End result of hraling with pm-
tuberant scar of stress dentine (RD). Tubular predentine (PD) and pulpodental membrane
(PX) now normal. (Magnification, x200 ; retluacd 3/s.)
had undergone liquefaction. Fig. 15 shows an essentially empty pulp with only
a few necrotic strands persisting in the liquefied mass after 14 days. The deep
burn reaction in dentine at the point of heat application is evident (B). Several
test animals in both this 30 degree series and the 20 degree series experienced
severe dentoalveolar abscesses and had to be maintained with tetracyclines prior
to death. No histologically recognizable pulps were recovered after intrapulpal
heating to 30° F.
A corollary finding in teeth heated to this excessive int.rapulpal measurement
is shown in Fig. 16. On the heated labial wall of the tooth, the root in the region
of the alveolar crest (1lC) showed small lacunar defects (L) which had eroded
through cementum and begun to encroach upon dentine. These eaten-out arcas
were lined by large, osteoclast,-like cells (OC). Vessels in the submucosa ant1
periodontal membrane were swollen. This lytic phenomenon at a site distant
from the point of heat application resembled Bernicr’s “rebound reaction.“3
It is a further example of the potentially powerful effects of severe thermal
irritation.
DISCUSSION
The accumulation of evidence indicating that dental ptllp is a hardier tissue
thiln had been previously b4icvcd has cont,ribnlc~l to t lI(l (5pansion, icl1lal’l> pil’t
526 %ach und Cohen
Fig. 1s. Temperat ure increase of 20” F., after 1 week. More custc ma I’Y rrs[ lonse to 1this
tennperaturr incremrnl with pulp-horn abscess (A) and arutca inflame :01‘?’ PX udat e II ‘L )
in the surrc mnding stl ‘oma. (Magnification, x50 ; reduced IA.)
Fig. 14. Trmpernt ure increase of 30” F., after 2 days. Total net ,ros is as esvidel riced l,Y
obl !iteration of all nor ma1 pulp with hemorrhagic and fragmented dehl *is (1 ‘11)). ( iif? tgnifi irn-
tio II, x250; reducrd Q .)
v01un10 19
Sumlrcr 4
16. Temperature increase of 30” F., after 2 weeks. Totally necrotic pu IlP stor nary
zie s, with intense burn response on buccal dentine. (Magnification, x40; re :ed 143.1
16. Temperature increase of 30” F., after 2 weeks. Lacunae in root, $1 1 I at line
lar crest, (AC’). Areas linrd by osteoclast-like cells (06’). (Magnificatil :,n. LOO; re-
Stortin
Level
Safe
-3 > Range
-5
-7
-9
-II
-13
-15
-I 7
0 5 IO I5 20 25 30 35
.tBur Contact
SECONDS OF RUN
Pig. 17. Intrapulpal temperature rises produced by* four types of operative technique.
Group I, air turbine, water-cooled; Group II, air turbine, dry; Group III, low-speed, water-
rooled; Group IV, low-speed, dry.
CONCLUSIONS
It is evident from this study that the intact dental pulp responds to mea-
surcd incrcascs in applied heat in a fairly const,ant, predictable manner. Factors
which would serve to modify the thermal response, such as thickness of remain-
ing dentSine, coolant, pre-existing disease, etc., were eliminated in favor of
studying the unmodified “pure” response. It is further evident that many opcra-
tivc procedures performed with little regard for thermal shock result in heat
insult t,o the pulp which enters the critical range. Especially implicated as no-
tcntial thermal irrit.ants are drilling techniques which do not make use of ade-
quatc coolants. Quantity as well as intensity of heat applied to the pulp may
be important. In this regard, it may be fruitful to investigate the effect of the
530 Zaclz md Cohen
\\‘ork continues at this and other laboratories in dforts to dcfinc~ pulpal I*(‘-
sponse and, particularly, the mechanisms involved in pulpal repair. Regeneril-
tion of odontoblasts and formation of the: amorphous scar arc the rcp;lir mwI~-
anisms which are fundamental in retaining vitalit,v of the pulp. Means 01’ unclcr-
standing and perhaps affecting thew prowsscs arc’ important awits 01’ i ti-
vostigation.
The authors wish to thank Mrs. Gloria Turocr and Mrs. Hilde Schmidl, rwearch assistants,
and Miss Elsie Dallas, laboratory twhnician, for their efforts in tissue processing. The
photomicrographs were taken by Mr. Antol Herskovits, staff photographer, ,\ontefiore Hns-
pital, New York. The diagrams were prepared l)y Mrs. Marie Yaw, staff artist, 1furrp and
Loonic Guggenheim Foundation Inst,itutg’ for I)cnntal Rcwarch, Sew York 7:nivcrsitp (‘ollego
of Dentistq.
REFERENCES
1. Br6nnstr6m, M. : Dentinal and Pulpal Rwponsr, ORAT. SLVRG., ORAL 1\IED. & ORAL I'ATH.
15: 203, 1962.
2. Seltzer, S., Bender, I. B., and Kaufman, J. J.: Histologic Changes in Dental Pulps of
Dogs and Monkeys Following Application of Pressure, Drugs and Micro-Organisms on
Prepared Cavities, ORAL SURG., ORAL MED. & ORAL PATH. 14: 327, 1961.
3. Bernier, J. L., and Knapp, M. J.: A New Pulpal Besponse to High-Speed Dental Instru-
ments, ORAL SURG., ORAL MED. & ORAL PATH. 11: 167, 1958.
4. Langeland, K.: Tissue Changes Incident to Cavity Preparation; an Evaluation of Romcx
Dental Engines, Acta odont. scandinav. 19: 397, 1961.
5. Zarh, L., and Cohen, G.: Biology of High-Speed Rotary Operative Procedures: Correla-
tion of Tooth Volume Removed and Pulpal Pathology, J. D. Res. 37: 6i, 1958.
6. Robinson, H. B. G., and Lefkonitz, IV.: Operative Dentistry and the Pulp, J. Pros. I)~~nt.
12: 987, 1962.
7. Hartnett J. E., and Smith, W. F. : The Production of Hc,at in the Dent,al Pulp by .X’s<,
of the Ajr Turbine, J. Am. Dent. A. 63: 210, 1961.
8. PostIt,, H. H., Lefkomitz, W., and McConnell, D.: Pulp Response to Heat, J. I). Xrs. 37:
740, 1959.
9. Zach, and Cohen,
I+ G.: Thermogenesis in Operative Twhnics: Comparison of Four
Methods, J. Pros. Dent. 12: 977, 1962.
10. Jarby, 8. : On Temperature Measurements iu Teeth, Odont. ‘I’idskr. 66: 3Zj 19%.