Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chemical Engineering Magazine 2010 - 05
Chemical Engineering Magazine 2010 - 05
Wireless
2010
Communication
in Hazardous
Areas
Page 39
www.che.com
Page 34
At five meters in diameter, 11 meters in length and weighing 90 tons, we are naturally proud of designing and building India’s largest and
highly sophisticated autoclave with quick opening-doors for making large airworthy advanced composite components such as wings, fins,
empennage and fuselage parts. And we supplied it to the prestigious
National Aerospace Laboratories, India. For another company, we made WE ALSO DESIGN AND SUPPLY FOLLOWING CODED EQUIPMENT
autoclaves that were 44 meters in length and three meters in diameter. Customized Equipment Specialised and Proprietary Products
- Heat-Exchangers - Rotary Vacuum Paddle Dryers
Our 100+ expert engineers and more than 400 skilled technicians work - Reaction Vessels - Spherical Paddle Chopper Dryers
- Pressure Vessels - Autoclaves with quick opening doors
with world-class design and simulation technologies in six modern - High Pressure Autoclaves - Rotocone Vacuum Dryers
plants to deliver custom-designed autoclaves for AAC Block, Glass, - Hydrogenators - Conical Screw Dryers
Rubber and Automobile industries. They work with a variety of material - Tall Vertical Columns - Silicon-Carbide Heat Exchangers
of construction to manufacture high performance equipment.
In addition to autoclaves, we also design and supply a variety of coded and customized equipment, plants, systems and skids for a wide
range of process industries, including Pharmaceutical Industries, Chemical & Fertilizers Plants, Oil & Gas Industries, Petrochemical
Industries, Food & Dairy Industries and Desalination Plants for global clients.
Circle 15 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-15
PROCESS INSIGHT
Optimizing CO2 Capture, Dehydration and Compression Facilities
The removal of CO2 by liquid absorbents is widely implemented formulated solvent without implementing any split flow configurations. This is
in the field of gas processing, chemical production, and coal gasification. much less than the reported steam usage for the MEA solvent.
Many power plants are looking at post-combustion CO2 recovery to meet The design of a facility to capture 90% of the CO2 from the flue
environmental regulations and to produce CO2 for enhanced oil recovery gas of a coal fired power plant is based on the specified flue gas conditions,
applications. The figure below illustrates actual data of fuel consumption in CO2 product specifications, and constraints. Using the ProMax® process
2005 and an estimate of energy demand for various fuels from 2010 to 2030. simulation software from Bryan Research & Engineering, CO2 capture units
The world energy demand will likely increase at rates of 10–15% every 10 can be designed and optimized for the required CO2 recovery using a variety
years. This increase could raise the CO2 emissions by about 50% by 2030 of amine solvents. The following figure represents a simplified process flow
as compared with the current level of CO2 emissions. The industrial countries diagram for the proposed CO2 Capture Plant.
(North America, Western Europe and OECD Pacific) contribute to this jump in
emissions by 70% compared to the rest of the world, and more than 60% of
these emissions will come from power generation and industrial sectors.
Despite the strong recommendations from certain governments, The table below presents the main findings for CO2 capture from the
there are very few actual investments in CO2 capture facilities geared toward coal fired power plant and the NGCC power plant, each designed to produce
reducing greenhouse gas emissions mainly because of the high cost of CO2 about 3307 ton per day (3,000 TPD metric). To produce the same capacity of
recovery from flue gas. CO2 capture costs can be minimized, however, by CO2, only one train with smaller column diameters is required in the case of
designing an energy efficient gas absorption process. Based on the findings the coal power plant and two trains with larger column diameters are required
of recent conceptual engineering studies, HTC Purenergy estimated the in the NGCC Power Plant case. This is mainly due to processing a larger
production cost to be US$ 49/ton CO2 (US$ 54/ tonne CO2) for 90% CO2 flue gas with lower CO2 content in the NGCC power plant. Consequently, a
recovery of 4 mole% CO2 content in the flue gas of NGCC power plants. A substantial reduction in the capital and production cost was reported for the
separate study showed the cost for 90% CO2 recovery of 12 mole% CO2 from coal fired power plant CO2 recovery facility.
a coal fired power plant to be US$ 30/ton CO2 (US$ 33/tonne CO2). The cost
of CO2 recovery from coal power plant flue gas is substantially less than that
of NGCC power plant flue gas due to the higher CO2 content in the feed.
The energy efficiency of a CO2 capture plant depends primarily on
the performance of the solvent and optimization of the plant. In traditional flue
gas plant designs, MEA was the primary solvent and was limited to 20 wt% to
minimize equipment corrosion. Recent developments in controlling corrosion
and degradation has allowed an increase in the solvent concentration to
about 30 wt% thus decreasing the required circulation and subsequent steam
demand. A recent DOE study shows the steam consumption for an existing
CO2 plant using 18 wt% MEA (Kerr McGee Process) is 3.45 lb of steam per
lb of CO2 for amine regeneration. A modern process that uses 30 wt% MEA
is expected to use 1.67 lb of steam per lb of CO2 for amine regeneration. The
HTC formulated solvent is a proprietary blend of amines and has a lower
steam usage than the conventional MEA solvent. Based on the material and
energy balances for the plant designed in the recent study, the reboiler steam For more information about this study, see the full article at
consumption is estimated at about 1.47 lb steam/lb CO2 using the proposed www.bre.com/support/technical-articles/gas-treating.aspx.
Commentary
5 Editor’s Page
Recognizing a
distillation icon
www.che.com CE echoes the praise
given to Dr. Karl Ch-
Cover story uang at the AIChE
34 Cover Story Hydrogen Spring meeting in
Generation by Steam San Antonio, Tex. this
Reforming Steam reforming March. A longtime
of natural gas at petroleum University of Alberta
refining facilities is the pre- (Canada) professor,
dominant means of produc- Chuang made numer-
ing hydrogen in the chemical ous contributions to
process industries (CPI). the field in a distin-
Hydrogen needs are guished career that is
as high as ever, so under- ongoing
standing steam reforming
and hydrogen purification departments
can be useful
Letters . . . . . . . . . 6
news Bookshelf . . . . . 7, 9
11 Chementator A new pro- Who’s Who . . . . . 32
cess for bio-based gasoline;
50 Solids Processing Agglomeration Reader Service
“green” jet fuel; Bioethanol as a feedstock
Technology: Equipment Selection Take
for polymers; Revamped hydrotreater allows page . . . . . . . . . . 70
more than product attributes into account
co-processing bio-based and petroleum Economic
when choosing agglomeration equipment
feeds; New distillation downcomer design; Indicators . . . 71, 72
A surface-structured RO membrane; and
equipment & serviCes
more
30 Focus Pumps This self-priming pump advertisers
21 Newsfront A 'Perfect Storm' for U.S. is available for water and wastewater
Petroleum Refining Industry? Refiners processing; This discharge pump ensures Gulf Coast Advertis-
are anxious about excess capacity, lower continuous flow of highly viscous fluids; ing Section . . .55–64
sales and the prospect of greenhouse gas Magnetic-drive pump provides a “zero- Product
regulations leakage” option for operators; This pump Showcase . . . . . . 65
25 Newsfront Bioalcoholic Fuels The U.S. provides accurate delivery of chemicals
during water treatment; and more Classified
is turning to bioethanol as one of its sav- Advertising . . .66–68
iors from foreign oil, but another alcohol is 32D-1 New Products (Domestic edition)
emerging that may be a better renewable Get on-demand nitrogen with these gener- Advertiser Index . 69
fuel supplement: butanol ators; A chlorine dioxide analyzer with au-
tomatic flow control; Manage GHG report-
Coming in June
engineering ing with this package; Clean “on the fly”
with this drawer magnet; Reduce heat loss Look for: Feature
33 Facts At Your Fingertips Burner Op-
by 49% with this insulation; Handle heavy Reports on Piping
erating Characteristics This one-page
slurries with this knife gate valve; New rules Design for Hazardous
reference guide outlines a set of equations
in vacuum drying: the Planex System; These Fluids; and Specifying
that can help calculate burner parameters
compact pumps are ideal for applications Pressure Vessels; an
such as flame length, flame diameter and
with space restrictions; and more Environmental Man-
flameout conditions
32I-1 AchemAsia 2010 Show Preview ager article on Seals
39 Feature Report Wireless Communi- (International Edition) AchemAsia 2010 and Gaskets; Focus
cation in Hazardous Areas Consider on Computer Model-
will be held June 1–4, in Beijing, China, and
these criteria in deciding where wireless ing; News articles on
is expected to boost chemical engineering
technology fits in today’s plants and the Corrosion Monitoring
in China. Products and services on display
explosive atmospheres often found there and Process Cooling;
include: Seals from this sintered SiC are
Facts at Your Finger-
44 Engineering Practice Spiral Plate Heat self-lubricating; A mixer for processing a
wide range of viscous products; Clean hot tips on Column tray
Exchangers: Sizing Units for Cooling
gas streams with these scrubbers; A more design; and more
Non-Newtonian Slurries This article
presents step-by-step guidance to demys- efficient system for making compressed air;
tify the sizing of these exchangers and more Cover: David Whitcher
Letters
Postscripts, corrections
January, Updating The Rules for Pipe Sizing, pp. 48–50:
State-of-the-art quality demands state-of-the-art Several values in Table 1 do not match exactly with the val-
technology and a clear eye for sustainable developments ues published in the referenced article (CE, May 1999, pp.
that offer a pathway to the future. This is why ALTANA 153–156, Table 2): 1) The value of K for 1998 does not match
conducts extensive research – to develop truly innovative as it should with the value of the original article issued in
processes and products. May 1999. Specifically, in Table 2 of the 1999 article, K =
0.07 for 1998 prices, while in Table 1 of the 2010 article K
Specialty chemicals are our business. A business we is equal to 0.04 for 1998 prices; 2) In the 1999 article (Table
pursue with passion and dedication in more than 100 2), the value of M is 0.575 for 1998 prices, while in Table 1
countries. Four specialized divisions work together of the 2010 article, M = 0.102 for 1998 prices. In both cases,
to ensure that ALTANA‘s unrivalled competence and the older article is in error. Meanwhile, the author further
service excellence continue to improve and expand. notes that the value of K, energy cost (0.04), for 1998 year is
With a clear vision of what our customers expect of us, correct in the 2010 article but has been rounded. The value
it is our ambition at all times to develop solutions that of 0.0448 was used to obtain the corresponding value of M
turn opportunities into future reality. (0.102) for 1998. Also, the value of K for 2008 prices (0.07)
was rounded. Considering more decimals (0.0716), the corre-
sponding value of M was obtained (0.064) for 2008 prices.
Circle 5 on p. 78 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-05
&(B(7B$XJHBB[B663B(1LQGG
Bookshelf
Liquids to Value
Facilities Planning, Fourth edition.
By James A. Tompkins, John A.
White, Yavuz A. Bozer and J.M.
Tanchoco. John Wiley and Sons
Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ
07030. Web: www.wiley.com. 2010.
854 pages. $167.95.
C
ould facilities planning become a new paradigm in
chemical engineering?
Engineering has long been enriched by apply-
ing science, mathematics and other fields to industrial
pursuits. Chemical engineering began as an offshoot of
industrial chemistry and mechanical engineering. Unit
processes, unit operations, thermodynamics and chemical
kinetics are among the paradigms that helped define the
emerging discipline of chemical engineering in the first
half of the 20th century. The history of chemical engineer-
ing is peppered with examples where advancing science
was applied to industry and had profound impact. BL Renewable Resources
Facilities planning — an integral part of commercial-scale
chemical process operations — continues to evolve as a disci-
pline, drawing on expertise and best practices from industrial
engineering, manufacturing engineering, business manage-
Hit the Road to
ment and operations research. Chemical engineers practice
facilities planning in designing a process plant, but chemical
New Fields of Profit
engineering texts have not formally and comprehensively
addressed the area. For example, one classic book on plant
Renewable resources open up many opportunities to
design devotes less than six pages to two major facilities
recover, process and refine foodstuffs, but also to substitute
planning issues — plant location and plant layout develop-
fossil fuels. Sustainable treatment of natural resources
ment. Similarly, useful AIChE guidelines on facility siting
is a pressing need of the age we live in. We now offer a
and layout cover process safety during siting, plant layout
platform for forward-looking solutions by concentrating
and equipment arrangement, but (appropriately for a process
our process know-how for oils and fats, starch, proteins,
safety guidelines book), provides limited coverage of many
fermentation products and biofuels in our Business
other crucial aspects of facilities planning.
Line Renewable Resources.
“Facilities Planning” (4th ed.) by Tompkins and others is a
comprehensive text on industrial engineering, with numer-
The Business Line Renewable Resources remains your
ous examples and references. The book discusses the full
market expert for tried-and-tested processes, while at
scope of strategic planning of the enterprise supply chain,
the same time being a centre of competence for innovative
from raw materials to customer products. It introduces sev-
ideas and visions. We support you with the latest process
eral useful qualitative and quantitative tools, and would be
technology, right from laboratory testing through to
a valuable reference for chemical engineers involved with
enterprise planning, project planning and plant design. implementation on an industrial scale.
The text begins by introducing the concept of strategic
facilities planning as plant requirements are defined. The Your direct route to 24 / 7 service:
introductory section addresses facilities design, personnel www.westfalia-separator.com / service
requirements, as well as topics such as activity relation-
ships and space requirements. The remainder of the book
includes chapters on such topics as materials handling,
layout planning models and quantitative facilties planning
models. It concludes by discussing preparation, implemen-
tation and maintenance of facilities plans. GEA Mechanical Equipment
The book may help foster the formal incorporation of GEA Westfalia Separator GmbH
facilities planning principles into chemical engineering
WSPC-2-30-021
The Yearbook also helps you locate process information in our PEP reports and reviews. SRIC’s PEP
reports provide in-depth, independent technical and economic evaluations of both commercial and
emerging technologies for the chemical and refining industries.
The 2009 PEP Yearbook includes six separate volumes: US Gulf Coast, Germany, Japan, and China,
with limited processes for Canada and Saudi Arabia.
For more information and pricing, contact Angela Faterkowski at +1 281 203 6275
afaterkowski@sriconsulting.com
www.sriconsulting.com/PEP
MENLO PARK HOUSTON BEIJING NEW DELHI RIYADH SEOUL TOKYO ZÜRICH
Circle 46 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-46
Bookshelf
Scott Jenkins
Circle 30 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-30
ChemiCal engineering www.Che.Com may 2010 9
er
ution of ov
nd distrib
k of sales a
Y H W R keep trac
“We KD s of equipment glob
ally…
ce
18,000 pie
DQ G
get the right parts, to the right place,
at the right time
DQ G G per
automate more processes
D Q si e r a n
ize ea improved R
d cheaI
O
custom or
ns f
solutio
Microsoft Dynamics® CRM integrates information from different sources and puts it in one place,
at one time, so everyone in your company sees the information needed to make better decisions
faster. It’s simple for your sales and support people to use, and it’s ready to fit your company right
away. So you can spend less time on service calls and more time building stronger relationships.
To learn more about the efficiencies Microsoft Dynamics CRM can create for your business,
go to microsoftdynamics.com/manufacturing
Circle 32 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-32
Edited by Gerald Ondrey May 2010
Process heat
This new process makes Lignin C1–C4
Gasoline
biogasoline from carbohydrates
Alkanes
Polysaccharides H2 Kerosene
cilities of Virent Energy Systems, Inc. (www. C5 & C6
Isoalkanes
jet fuel
Soluble sugars Aqueous phase Base catalyzed Hydrode-
virent.com). The demonstration plant — part sugars furans reforming condensation oxygenation
of a joint R&D collaboration of Virent and phenolics
acids H2
Shell (The Hague, the Netherlands; www. Sugar
Starches
shell.com) — has the capacity to produce alcohols
10,000 gal/yr of biogasoline from beet sugar Diesel
or other sucrose sources using Virent’s pat-
Hydro- Alkanes
ented BioForming platform technology. genation Dehy- Alkene Alkene
dration oligomer- saturation
The BioForming platform (flowsheet) ization
combines Virent’s core aqueous-phase re-
forming (APR) technology with conventional
catalytic processing technologies, such as
hydrotreating, condensation, dehydration genation, hydrogenolysis and cyclization. In
and alkylation depending on the desired situ generation of hydrogen is one key as- A new Cl2 process
hydrocarbon product (gasoline, kerosene or pect of the process, says Virent. Oxygen-depolarized cathodes
diesel). The production of biogasoline in the The process can utilize a broad range of (ODCs) will be used for the first
demonstration plant includes feed prepara- carbohydrates, including those derived from time to produce chlorine on an
tion, hydrogenation, aqueous-phase reform- non-food biomass. The technology offers an industrial scale in a 20,000 met-
ing and acid condensation. alternative to fermenting biomass-derived ric ton per year (m.t./yr) electro-
The APR step uses proprietary heteroge- sugars into bioethanol, thereby eliminating lyzer at the Krefeld-Uerdingen
neous catalysts in series and parallel reac- the need for specialized infrastructure, en- chemical park in Germany.
tors operating at moderate temperatures gine modifications and blending equipment The plant will be constructed
for Bayer MaterialScience AG
(450–575K) and pressures (10–90 bar) to needed for gasoline using more than 10%
(BMS; www.bayermaterial-
reduce the oxygen content of the carbohy- ethanol, says the companies. (For more on sciences.com) by Uhde GmbH
drate feedstock. Reactions include reform- bioethanol, see the news story on pp. 25–29). (Dortmund, both Germany;
ing to make hydrogen, dehydrogenation of Gasoline produced in the new plant will www.uhde.eu), and is slated for
alcohols, hydrogenation of carbonyls, deoxy- be used for engine and fleet testing. startup in the first half of 2011.
ODCs are O2-consuming,
gas-diffusion electrodes that
A process that makes ‘green jet fuel’ (Continues on p. 16)
is slated for commercialization
H oneywell’s UOP LLC (Des Plaines, Ill.;
www.uop.com) has developed a pro-
cess that makes a renewable, “drop-in”
performs selective cracking to yield
shorter-chained (C10–C14) synthetic
paraffinic kerosene (SPK) needed for
toll manufacturing facility in Texas.
Ellis says the technology is now ready
for commercialization, and UOP is al-
jet fuel from sustainable oils, including jet fuel, explains Graham Ellis, UOP’s ready performing engineering for AltAir
camelina, tallow, jatropha or algae. Simi- biorenewable energy business manager. Fuels (Seattle, Wash.) for a 100-million
lar to the the UOP/Eni Ecofining process The SPK produced by the process gal/yr production facility to be located
for making Green Diesel fuel (CE, May meets all the necessary specifications at the Tesoro oil refinery in Anacortes,
2007, p. 18), the Renewable Jet Process (flash point, freeze point and stabil- Wash. Scheduled for startup in 2012,
is a two-stage process. In the first step, ity) of petroleum-derived aviation fuel. the plant will produce renewable fuel
the natural oils are first hydroprocessed However, it contains no aromatics, so from camelina oil sourced from Sustain-
to remove oxygen from the triglycerides to make a drop-in fuel, the SPK must able Oils (Bozeman, Mont.), which has
to form straight-chained C16–C18 paraf- be blended with conventional jet fuel the largest camelina research program
fins, and propane as a byproduct. The (up to 50 vol.%), says Ellis. The fuel has in North America. Last December AltAir
wax-like paraffins are then isomerized been tested in a number of aircraft over Fuels signed a memorandum of under-
into branched paraffins to improve cold- the past two years — most recently by standing with 14 major airlines from the
flow properties and reduce the cloud the U.S. Air Force last month — using U.S., Mexico, Canada and Germany for
point. But unlike the Ecofining process a 50:50 blend of conventional JP-8 fuel the sale of up to 750 million gallons of
for making diesel, this second step also with Green Jet produced by a 100-bbl/d renewable jet fuel.
Note: For more information, circle the 3-digit number
on p. 70, or use the website designation. CHeMiCAl enGineerinG www.CHe.COM MAy 2010 11
Oxygen
Preheater
C hementato R Ethanol
Reactor
Engineering advanced
Circle 13 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-13 © 2010 Chemstations, Inc. All rights reserved. | CMS-22-1 04/10
12 ChemiCal engineering www.Che.Com may 2010
650821 © 2010 Tranter, Inc.
Circle 40 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-40
C hementato R
Make up +
Circle 19 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-19
14 ChemiCal engineering www.Che.Com may 2010
Circle 36 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-36
C hementato R (Continued from p. 11)
separate caustic from the O2
side. The O2 diffuses into the
Destroy HFCs and recover CaF2 with this process porous electrode structure to
catalyst centers and reacts
A process that destroys hydrofluorocarbons materials, such as CaO and CaCO3. The with cathodic water to produce
(HFCs) and recovers high-purity calcium products are then heated to 700°C, which hydroxide ions (CE, May 2007,
fluoride has been developed by chemical- burns away the carbons, then dissolved in pp. 50–55). Because the ODC
allows the electrolyzer to oper-
engineering professor Hideki Yamamoto at a mixture of HCl and HF acids. The HCl
ate at lower voltages, energy
Kansai University (Suita City, Osaka; www. reacts with CaO and CaCO3 to form CaCl2, requirements for producing
cheng.kansai-u.ac.jp/Process) in cooperation which then reacts with HF to form CaF2 — a Cl2 are reduced by up to 30%,
with Shiraishi Kogyo Kaisha Ltd. (Amaga- sparingly soluble salt that precipitates. Ya- says BMS. The commercial unit
saki City, Osaka; both Japan; www.shirai- mamoto has recovered CaF2 with 95–98% will use ODCs in NaCl-based
shi.co.jp/kogyo). purity using the method. electrolyzer cells developed by
The technology is based on calcium hy- A patent for the technology has been ap- by Uhde and UhdeNora S.p.A.
droxide, a byproduct from the process used to plied for, and the researchers are planning to (Milan, Italy; www.uhdenora.
purify natural calcium carbonate. A mixture demonstrate the process in compact reactors com). BMS has also used its
of Ca(OH)2 and HFCs is first decomposed suitable for companies that manufacture ODC technology based on
hydrochloric-acid electrolysis
at 500–550°C into CaF2, carbon-based resi- HFCs as alternatives for chlorofluorocar-
at the Bayer Integrated Site
dues, water and CO2 along with unreacted bons (CFCs), as well as for treating CFCs. Shanghai in China, and in
Brunsbüttel, Germany.
Hydrotreater (Continued from p. 14) and fuel consumption are lower. Overall,
Biomass to SNG
Haldor Topsøe S/A (Lyngby,
Egeberg says the reactor operates at es- the process economics are “very favorable,”
Denmark; www.topsoe.com)
sentially the same conditions of tempera- he says, and the revamp will be paid back will participate in the design of
ture and pressure as a standard diesel “in a short time.” Egeberg says the design what is said to be the world’s
fuel hydrotreater. Hydrogen consumption allows for processing other triglyceride first plant for producing sub-
ADD414 PR.pdf 1 4/6/2010 4:50:40 PM
is “significantly higher,” due to the hydro- feeds, including animal fat, oil from algae
(Continues on p. 18)
deoxygenation reactions, but heater duty and used oils.
Circle 14 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-14
Distillation-tray downcomer design
improves mass transfer efficiency
A new approach to the design of the
downcomer portion of distillation
column trays — presented at the recent
American Institute of Chemical Engi-
neers (AIChE) Spring 2010 meeting (San
Antonio, Tex.; March 21–25) — promotes
a uniform fluid flow pattern, which im-
proves mass transfer efficiency. Inside the AMT Downcomer Distribu- Dispersion Valve (ADV) Trays has dem-
The Downcomer Distributor was de- tor (diagram), liquid is distributed ac- onstrated efficiency increases of 24%
veloped through a joint research pro- cording to pre-determined proportions and 29%, respectively, for liquefied pe-
gram between AMT International Inc. by “uniquely arranged, slanted and troleum gas (LPG) and depropanizer
(Plano, Tex.; www.amtintl.com) and Pet- triangle-shaped discharge ports” that columns of a large-scale commercial
ronas (Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia; www. initiate and maintain a uniform plug- gas plant.
petronas.com.my) with an objective to flow pattern. In addition to increasing mass-
eliminate deviations from an ideal fluid- In testing, the Downcomer Distribu- transfer efficiency, the elimination of
flow pattern that occur on typical distil- tor consistently resulted in approxi- stagnant zones of liquid on the trays
lation trays, which result from recycling mately 5–10% greater tray efficiency extends the column runtime, since stag-
of fluid on the tray and by the existence compared to existing downcomer con- nant zones tend to foul in dirty service,
of stagnant regions of liquid. figurations under normal tray operat- says the manufacturer.
The Downcomer Distributor technol- ing conditions and with the same active The Downcomer Distributor technol-
ogy results in directional flow and dis- valve tray. AMT says that combining ogy has been applied at several commer-
tribution within the downcomer itself the Downcomer Distributor technology cial distillation columns, starting in 2008,
and as the liquid exits the downcomer. with its high-performance Advanced including at several Petronas plants.
T O T A L S A F E T Y
READY FOR
ANYTHING
When it comes to safety, we’re on the job.
From chemical and petrochemical facilities to refineries, Total Safety delivers
state-of-the-art gas detection solutions to help you increase safety and keep
your operations profitable.
With Total Safety’s gas detection solutions, you can:
Rent premium gas detection systems and instruments at a reasonable price
and optimize your investment in gas detection equipment
Get unsurpassed quality of service and repair, including testing and
calibration support you can trust
Access the world’s largest fleet of gas detection perimeter monitor systems
Total Safety is ready to provide the top quality equipment and unprecedented
support you need to keep workers safe.
Circle 39 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-39
888.44.TOTAL (888.448.6825) | TotalSafety.com/services | mail@totalsafety.com
C hementato R
Circle 3 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-03
18 ChemiCal engineering www.Che.Com may 2010
An eye
for detail ...
Circle 8 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-08
(Continued from p. 16)
C hementato R
stitute natural gas (Sng) from
biomass. The project, owned
by the gothenburg Biomass
These microfluidic sensors can be made gasification (goBigas) con-
with a sewing machine sortium, with main owner göte-
borg energi aB (Sweden, www.
goteborgenergi.se), aims to
We are
.HHQO\)RFXVHG
on towers and trays
This specialization allows us to be more responsive and more innovative in solving tower issues
that have habitually plagued the industry. By focusing on our core competency of providing field
services specifically for vessels, drums, towers and trays, we can address your exact needs. And, we
can meet or exceed your safety, quality, time and budget requirements.
We provide complete retrofits and modifications for vessel internals on a scheduled or emergency
basis. We’ve completed over 173 projects in the past four years alone. Part and parcel of our
services are those ancillary skills that you would expect from a team of highly trained specialists;
skills such as engineering services, design analysis, integrity analysis, re-rating, and welding (both
“R” and “U” stamps), to name a few. This complete range of services is met to assure that your job
is done right the first time.
Put the highly focused eyes of the tigers on your next project and you will be rewarded with an
uncanny and rare level of excellence.
3012 FARRELL ROAD, HOUSTON, TX 77073 • PHONE: 281-951-2500 • FAX: 281-951-2520 • www.tigertowerservices.com
Circle 37 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-37
20 ChemiCal engineering www.Che.Com may 2010
Newsfront
Jacobs Consultancy
Regulations will affect the demand for fuel,
especially gasoline
..#1%
TUBOEBSET )ZESPDBSCPOQPSUJPO
BOEDIBOHJOH PGHBTPMJOF
lower sales, and the DPOTVNFS
IBCJUT
PGEJFTFM
r-PX$BSCPO
L
'VFM
ess than two years ago, U.S. petro- 4UBOEBSET -JRVJE'VFMT4VQQMZBOE%JTQPTJUJPO&*""OOVBM&OFSHZ0VUMPPL&BSMZ3FMFBTF
leum refiners were in the middle -$'4
3FQPSU%0&&*"
3FMFBTF%BUF%FDFNCFS
asphaltenes) to about 50% diesel fuel, invented way before its time, but now concentration in the combustion air
15% naphtha and 30% vacuum gas-oil. its time has come.” to 22–23%. This boosts the furnace
In the first stage, feed is slurried with a firing rate without exceeding process
proprietary nonmetallic additive in an New process improvements limits and increases H2 production by
ebullated bed at 180–200 bar and more Despite the turndown and the decline 10–15%, says Gregory Panuccio, a de-
than 400°C. The second stage employs in the supply of heavy crude oil, the de- velopment associate with Praxair.
a standard nickel-molybdenum hy- mand for hydrogen has continued to be The additional O2 may be premixed
drotreating catalyst in a fixed bed. robust, says David Burns, director of with the combustion air by a sparger
In contrast, conventional ebullated- global business development for hydro- or injected into the furnace’s combus-
bed hydrocrackers achieve less than gen with Praxair Inc. (Danbury, Conn.; tion zone by lances (usually one lance
80% conversion, and most fixed-bed www.praxair.com). “The market for hy- per burner — see Figure 2). A sparger
resid hydrocrackers obtain only about drotreating has continued to increase requires a single penetration into the
20% conversion, says Anand Subrama- and we anticipate good future growth air ductwork, whereas lances require
nian, KBR’s vice president of refining. for that market,” says Burns, who is lo- multiple penetrations into the furnace,
He adds that another advantage of cated in Houston. (For more on hydro- says Panuccio. However, a sparger
the VCC slurry-phase method is that gen, see cover story, pp. 34–38.) “slightly increases” the production
it avoids the fouling problem seen in A relatively simple modification of thermal NOx (oxides of nitrogen),
conventional ebullated-bed and fixed- that allows a refiner to increase H2 while a lance installation will not.
bed hydrocrackers. production from an existing steam Either system can be installed with
The economic threshold for VCC is a methane reformer (SMR) without a one-day plant outage at a cost of
crude price of $60/bbl, says Subrama- adding capacity is available from $500,000–$1.5 million, depending on
nian, “and we believe the pressure on Praxair. Praxair’s solution, called the configuration of the SMR. This
crude prices will be only higher in the oxygen enhanced reforming (OER), compares with $7–10 million for a pre-
future because of [tighter] supply and involves the injection of oxygen into reformer retrofit for a 100-million-scf/d
demand. The technology was probably the SMR furnace to increase the O2 SMR, says Panuccio. The cost of incre-
mental H2 is similar to the baseload
H2 cost. Praxair has field-tested the
process on a 5-million-scf/d SMR and
plans to start up the first commercial
system, of similar size, next year.
In a related development, Praxair is
ready to commercialize a refinery gas
processor (RGP) that conditions refin-
ery fuel streams for the production of
H2 from an SMR. Panuccio notes that
refinery gases are often not suitable
for SMR feed without further process-
ing because their olefin content causes
coking of the SMR catalyst. The ole-
fins may be hydrogenated to paraffins
before going to the SMR, he says, “but
if the olefin content is 6% or more you
can’t use traditional hydrotreating be-
cause of the exotherm.”
Praxair’s RGP solves this problem by
using a noble metal-based catalyst to
hydrogenate the olefins. The catalyst
can tolerate temperatures of more than
1,000°F, versus 700–800°F for a con-
ventional hydrogenation catalyst, says
Panuccio. The process has been tested
in a refinery at a scale of 5,000 scf/h, he
says, and the company is negotiating
with several potential customers.
Meanwhile, Air Liquide and its
Lurgi subsidiary are offering a new
generation of steam methane reform-
ers, designed to capture more CO2
from the offgas. The new SMRs will
Circle 18 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-18
22 ChemiCal engineering www.Che.Com may 2010
The regulaTory ThickeT
of greenhouse gases
P
etroleum refiners, among other industries, were alarmed when the U.S. House of
Representatives passed the American Clean Energy and Security Act in June 2009.
The Act, commonly known as Waxman-Markey (after its sponsors), called for tough
cap-and-trade rules on emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs) by industry. However,
there was a loud outcry against the legislation and lack of support in the Senate, which
is now working on a less-stringent bill. As a result, Waxman-Markey is generally con-
sidered a “dead” issue, says Jon Moretta, of Jacobs Consultancy.
Nevertheless, it seems likely that a climate-change bill will be approved by Congress
this year, says Randall Lack, chief marketing officer for Element Markets, LLC (Hous-
ton; www.elementmarkets.com). “The Senate bill is gaining Republican support and,
once that has passed, the House will probably match it with a toned-down version of
Waxman-Markey,” he says. However, he notes that the regulatory outlook is compli-
cated by the fact that GHG regulations have already been implemented or are under
development by a number of states and by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
(Washington, D.C.; www.epa.gov).
Under a cap-and-trade program, a limit (cap) is set on a plant’s emissions. The emis-
sions are also expressed as “allowances,” which for GHG, are measured in metric tons
of CO2 equivalent, notes Lack, whose company develops and supplies environmental
credits. Companies that emit less pollution than their limit may sell (trade) their allow-
ances to those that exceed their limit. Over time, the cap is gradually reduced.
Refinery operators can undertake various measures to control CO2 emissions before
resorting to carbon capture, says Moretta, thereby avoiding or reducing the scale and
cost of CO2 removal. For example, a plant operator may increase energy efficiency by
installing heat-recovery systems or replacing grid power by less costly cogeneration,
potentially producing offsets from the reduction in electricity use Generation .2
As for CO2 capture, Moretta says the first step is to work with existing sources of
concentrated CO2, such as hydrogen plants and coke gasifiers. The conventional way New well-proven actuators
to scrub CO2 from gas streams is to use monoethanolamine (MEA), but many other
technologies are available or under development (see main story and CE, December
2008, pp. 16–20). ❏ What seems to be a contradiction at first is
the result of continuous optimisation of a
well-proven design principle. For identical
capture 63–92% of the CO2, versus sonic waves cause cavitation to pro-
59% for current units, says Dennis mote oxidation. sizing, you will receive unrivalled perfor-
Vauk, senior international energy ex- SulphCo has tested several diesel mance including:
pert for the Energy Market Group of and gasoline feeds and has consis-
Air Liquide Large Industries U.S. LP tently reduced the sulfur content to � Improved handling and operation
(Houston; www.airliquide.com). below 10%, says Florian Schatten- � Intelligent diagnostic functions and
Two options for capture technol- mann, vice president and chief tech- sensor system
ogy are offered: amine contacting and nology officer. “For example, we have
cryogenic purification. Also, the pre- oxidized all the sulfur compounds in a � Optimised modulating behaviour and
reformer, reformer furnace and shift diesel fuel from 500 ppm to 5 ppm in a extended output speed range
section are optimized to reduce CO2 single pass.” The residence time is less � Longer lifetime
production. Vauk notes that amine than 500 ms, at ambient temperature
contacting is done upstream of the and pressure, he says, and the oxida- � Flexible valve connection
SMR pressure swing adsorption (PSA) tive reaction is so fast “a reactor the � Compatible with previous models
unit, while the cryogenic system size of a soft-drink can could process
captures CO2 from the PSA tail gas, 4,000 bbl/d of fuel.” In contrast, he AUMA automates valves
where the CO2 is more concentrated. notes, hydrodesulfurization requires
The cryogenic method, which is less high heat and pressure, and removal
expensive, will capture 63–73% of the of the final 1% of sulfur consumes 40%
gas at a cost of $30–40/(short) ton for a of the total H2 used. AUMA Riester GmbH & Co. KG | P.O. Box 1362
large SMR, says Vauk. An amine may The economic benefit of the oxida- 79373 Muellheim, Germany | www.auma.com
be used for higher removal rates. tive system depends on the avail- AUMA Actuators, Inc. | Canonsburg, pa 15317,
An ultrasound-assisted oxidative ability of H2 at a refinery and on the mailbox@auma-usa.com | www.auma-usa.com
desulfurization process that removes amount of refractory compounds in
sulfur from gasoline and diesel fuels the feed. Schattenmann says the most
without the use of H2 has been de- economical use of the system is to
veloped by SulphCo (Houston; www. treat refractories after the “easy” sul-
sulphco.com). Fuel is mixed with hy- fur compounds have been removed by
drogen peroxide and a proprietary hydrotreating. In these cases, the es-
oxygen-transfer catalyst in a static timated net benefit is $0.70–1.00/bbl.
mixer, then passes through an ultra- SulphCo is testing product streams
sonic chamber, where 18-kHz ultra- for several potential customers. Circle 7 on p. 70 or go to adlinks.che.com/29250-07
BASF’s Distributed Matrix Structure alyst system that allows refiners FIGURE 2. Praxair’s oxygen-enhanced
(DMS), while Stamina is based on the to switch more rapidly between reforming technology increases hydrogen
company’s Proximal Stable Matrix and the production of gasoline and production from a steam methane reformer by
Zeolite (Prox-SMZ) technology. diesel fuel in response to market injecting oxygen into the SMR furnace
In both cases the zeolite and active demand and prices. The co-cata-
matrix of the catalyst are created si- lyst system consists of three compo- tablishes the core performance of the
multaneously in a single step, rather nents: a Prox-SMZ catalyst (HDUl- FCC (that is, it is not optimized for
than being synthesized separately and tra) that maximizes the production of either gasoline or LCO).
physically combined into particles, says light cycle oil (LCO); a DMS catalyst, When more distillate is required,
Fabian Florez, global marketing man- called Converter, for gasoline produc- 30% of the base catalyst is replaced
ager for refining catalysts. This allows tion; and a base FCC catalyst that es- by HDUltra, says Tim McGuirk,
marketing manager for FCC addi-
tives, who is located in Houston. For
increased gasoline production, 30%
is replaced by Converter. The switch
!DVANCED 0ROCES S 3O L U T I O N S from one product to another takes
,%!$).'