Professional Documents
Culture Documents
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
Abstract
Transportation planners often stress the need to plan for “complete streets.” A complete street is
a planning and design concept that enables safer access for users of all ages and ability levels.
(Complete Streets, 2022.) Complete streets include planning for forty million disabled
Americans and other transportation challenged individuals. While strides have been made in part
due to the Americans with Disabilities Act, (ADA) much work remains to be done to increase
and improve transportation access for the disabled. Many transit systems across the United
States are still not ADA accessible. Existing literature has studied necessary initiatives and
improvements that have been made or will be made. This research examines existing legislation
that aims to ensure disabled individuals have equitable access to transportation and studies
existing barriers that prevent such access and uses the Charleston, South Carolina, and Mount
Pleasant South Carolina region as a case study to further determine steps that cities and
communities are taking to ensure transportation access for both disabled and non-disabled users.
Lastly, limitations of this research and recommendations for future study are discussed.
Introduction
A disability is defined as impairment that significantly limits or effects one or more life
activities. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.9) Individuals with disabilities face many life barriers, among the
biggest being access to transportation services. Individuals with significant disabilities are
substantially more prone to exclusion from transportation services. (Bascom & Christensen,
2017, p.227). This unequal access to transportation is coupled with unequal access to
employment opportunities, education, and healthcare among other community resources. When
1
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
planning their communities and streets, transportation planners and elected officials must
account for the fact that nearly a third of disabled people describe inadequate transportation
access as problematic. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.5) Further, many transportation systems have large
accessibility gaps. Accessibility is defined as the ability of people to reach desired services and
activities. (Litman, 2022, p.2) Accessible design guidelines in the United States designate the
minimum required dimensions for areas within buildings which include public access routes,
ramps, doors, stairs, escalators and also describe the requirements for transport facilities
including bus stops, railway platforms, and railway stations. (Sze & Christensen, 2017, p.67)
The main legislation that exists to protect disabled Americans is the 1990 Americans with
Disabilities Act which prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.11)
The ADA requires that public and private transportation companies provide accessible services
in both new and existing vehicles. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.11; & Equity in Transportation for people
with Disabilities) Still, the ADA was never intended to specify how to make transit functionally
accessible and usable. (Bayless & Davidson, 2019, p.16) Twenty-five years after the adoption of
the ADA, the Fast Act was codified in 2015 which provided long-term funding and investment in
transportation disadvantaged individuals. ( Remillard, et. al, 2022, p.5) Legislation enacted
before the ADA included the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 which ensured the right to protection
against discrimination due to disability under any United States Department of Transportation
(USDOT) program. (Remillard, et. al, 2022, p.2) However, the ADA expanded this protection to
include all public entities irrespective of any federal financial aid, and by expanding the types of
2
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
Improving accessibility for the disabled includes infrastructure improvements, increasing access
While progress has been made much works remains to be done. 18% of transit stations lack
ADA compliance and 30% of individuals with disabilities still have trouble accessing public
transportation. (Byington, 2011; Bezyak et.al, 2017,p.3) Further, the needs of disabled
passengers are often not prioritized. Additionally, since the ADA only addresses public
transportation, disabled individuals living in rural areas or other locations with limited or no
public transportation have few options. (Equity in transportation, n.d., p.1) Per, (Wright &
Johnson-Wright, 2018) many agencies and planners view planning for the disabled as a “last
minute” project and are only focused on meeting the minimum ADA requirements.
Disability advocates have been fighting for increased and improved transit accessibility for
decades dating back to the 70’s. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.11). There is an array of literature addressing
the issue of transportation access for the disabled and strategies to address the problem.
Research from Bascom and Christensen (2017) explored the impacts that limited transportation
access for the disabled had on their social participation. Their research found that 70% of
disabled individuals report that their social life is hindered by their transportation needs. (p.227)
Increasing transportation access is viewed as a primary way to improve the independence and
(2017, p.3) reveals that 560,000 people do not leave home due to a transportation disability.
3
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
Bascom and Christensen (2017) further studied the mode choices of disabled travelers and found
that physically disabled travelers rely more on public transportation than those with other types
of disability. (p.232) In fact, only 32.9% of individuals with disabilities utilized private vehicles.
Disabled individuals who utilized public transit were found to be lower income than individuals
Lindsay (2018) examined accessible transportation in disabled children and reported that
disabled youth mainly rely on public transportation, school buses, or rides from parents and
friends. (p.1131). This differs from the pattern of elderly disabled travelers who rely mainly on
personal vehicles and less on public transportation, paratransit, and other transit. (Remillard et.
al, 2022). Issues with paratransit include the requirement of 24–48-hour advanced notice, inexact
pickup times, and costs of up to ten times that of fixed route service. (Alderton, 2020) Lindsay’s
(2018) research found that among disabled youth, barrier free access means lack of both physical
Park & Chowdhury (2018), found that disabled people make fewer trips on average, travel
shorter distances, and use fewer modes. (p.362) Further, Travel patterns of America (2022)
found that 70% of disabled adults reduce their travel due to their disability. Those most likely to
reduce their travel are individuals with severe mobility impairments caused by spinal cord
injuries, cerebral palsy, multiple sclerosis, and muscular dystrophy. (Allu, et. al, n.d.) Those
with cognitive impairments such as a traumatic brain injury or Alzheimer’s disease were also
hesitant to leave home due to difficulty with typical transportation modes. Research from
Ruvolo (2020,p.25) found that the disabled are likelier to travel as passengers. Further research
4
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
by Bayless & Davidson (2019, p.10) found that one third of disabled people are not active
Myers et.al (2022) studied the transportation patterns of disabled adults in urban and rural areas
and found that people with disabilities are both less likely to take trips, and less likely to travel in
a personal vehicle which can further restrict their travel behavior. (p.2)
To substitute for traveling, people with disabilities utilize online purchases for activities such as
buying groceries. (Brumbaugh, 2018 p.9) Still, travelers with mobility disabilities spend $58.2
Much research has been conducted on barriers facing disabled travelers. These include both the
quality and quantity of infrastructure, a lack of education and understanding of the needs of the
disabled population, inaccessibility of transit systems and unaffordability. Often, the biggest
barrier is lack of funding. (J. Aton, personal communication, October 18, 2022) Further, while
demand for accessible travel is increasing, supply is not keeping pace. (Jainchill, et. al, 2022)
Other barriers include providing equitable service to those with disabilities. (S. Cox & J.
Research by (Remillard et. al, 2022) examined transportation challenges for the disabled elderly
population. This research found that many disabled older adults lack access to adequate
transportation (p.2) These included physical barriers such as transferring between the vehicle
and stairs, limited access to accessible vehicles, wheelchair access and storage and a lack of
handicap spaces. (p.5) Disassembling wheelchairs and a lack of wheelchair accessible bus
5
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
spaces and vehicle parking spaces created a further inconvenience and larger travel barrier. (p.3)
In fact, mobility disability is the most prevalent disability among older adults. (p.1)
Other barriers faced by disabled travelers include both public transportation and ridesharing
services as demonstrated by Ruvolo’s (2020) research using a case study in San Francisco which
showed that barriers to Uber and Lyft included unaffordability, safety concerns and physical
access to a vehicle. (p.19) For Ubers that were physically accessible the wait time is often four
times that of a car equipped for an able-bodied rider. (Kunkle,2018) These barriers are despite
the fact that taxi and wheelchair services were desired. (Remillard et. al, 2022, p.5) In late 2021,
the U.S. Department of Justice filed a federal lawsuit against Uber claiming discrimination by
Uber against disabled riders. (Hawkins, 2022). The lawsuit describes how Uber charges a “wait
time” fee for those entering the vehicle even though those with physical disabilities often need
more time to enter a vehicle. Eventually, Uber paid $2 million as part of a settlement agreement
and agreed to waive the wait time fee for those passengers certifying that themselves or a
companion need more time to enter and exit a vehicle due to disability. (Shapero, 2022)
Additional barriers included lack of enforcement (Equity in Transportation p.4) and uneven or
broken sidewalks. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.24) Infrastructure or lack thereof, such as lack of lighting is
also problematic because it hides potential trip hazards to travel safety and makes reading signs
more difficult for the visually impaired. (Park & Chowdhury, 2018, p.362) To combat this, real
time information displays should be large enough for people to read. (Nakat &Babinard, 2013,
p.7) Park and Chowdhury (2018) further found that lack of crossings and audio announcements,
construction work and background noise to be obstructive to those with hearing issues.
Upgrades to older stations are especially challenging because of their age, and lack of consistent
6
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
design. (Schruth, 2018) As it is, according to (Ruvolo,2020, p.25) disabled passengers are
increasingly vulnerable to traffic fatalities and sexual assault by drivers. Additionally, there are
not many options for larger wheelchairs and developing infrastructure for larger wheelchairs is
quite expensive. (S. Cox & J. Lambert, personal communication, October 14, 2022)
Bezyak et. al (2017) examined barriers disabled passengers faced specifically pertaining to fixed
bus route service. Barriers found included inoperable lifts and ramps, false claims of inoperable
lifts and ramps to discourage a disabled passenger from boarding, failure to yield to disabled
passengers, poor attitudes among drivers, steep slopes for ramp usage, failure to clear wheelchair
securement zones for the disabled, and a lack of stop announcements that provide route and
Bezyak et. al’s (2017) research further examines barriers preventing accessible paratransit
service which include untimely pickups, excessive trip lengths, and missed trips. (p.5) This is
partly due to the fact that when utilizing paratransit, individuals requesting the service must
make advance plans and schedule their activities far enough ahead to receive transit services.
(p.18). Paratransit is also only required in municipalities where there is a public transit system.
(National Express Transit, 2017) Eligibility criteria for paratransit can also exclude some people
(Jainchill et. al, 2022) reported on the travel experience specifically for disabled travelers in
airports and airplanes. Their research included a report from the US Government Accountability
Office which finds that intricate terminal layouts, and long distances between gates are
problematic for those with physical impairments. As for the airplane itself, wheelchair access is a
7
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
primary worry as disabled travelers oftentimes cannot travel in their own chair and instead are
transferred to a narrow airline chair. This is largely due to the Federal Aviation Administration’s
failure to approve wheelchairs on flights. (Plank, 2021) Research has found that out of
wheelchair customers who have never flown, 44% say the primary reason is for fear of having
their wheelchair damaged. (Wintersgill & Wood, 2021) The same study found that out of those
who previously flew but no longer fly, the biggest reason was personal injury, and even among
disabled users in wheelchairs who continue to fly, their biggest concern is fear of their
wheelchair being damaged or lost. In 2019, airlines lost or broke more than 10,000 wheelchairs
or scooters which equated to more than 1% of what they handled. (Plank, 2021) However,
airlines are required by federal law to provide assistance loading and stowing assistive devices.
(Traveling with a Disability, 2022) Another issue disabled airline passengers face are airplane
bathrooms which are often small and inaccessible leading to disabled passengers booking
connecting flights, so they have bathroom access in the airport. (Jainchill et. al, 2022) Airplane
bathrooms are often still inaccessible because unlike buses and trains which are mandated to
comply with ADA, airplanes are exempted because they still follow the Air Carrier Act which
was passed four years before the ADA was enacted. (Plank, 2021) Further research revealed that
72% of disabled adults reported major obstacles with airlines and 65% reported major issues
with airports. (Cerchiai & Lieberman, 2018) However, travelers who encounter few problems
will likely travel more in the future. (Chun-Chang & Fu-Chen, 2011, p.529) For individuals with
disabilities traveling on aircraft, negative attitudes were often the most challenging barriers to
overcome. (p.531) Additional barriers to traveling by air include waiting in line, no barrier free
8
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
The National Highway and Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has focused greatly on
adapted vehicles as a tool to help disabled mobility. However, adapted vehicles are often very
expensive and NHTSA estimates the potential cost of adapted vehicles at $80,000. (Adapting
your Vehicle) Limited insurance coverage of mobility devices outside the home makes
Modifications are often made based on the specific disability. (Perry, 2022) Common adaptations
include automatic transmission and button-less features. Other modifications include manual
ramps, vehicle lifts, reduced effort brakes, and steering knobs. (Paulus, 2022) Helpful vehicle
adaptations should include steering aids with easy grip devices for people with upper limb
difficulties, (Nakat & Babinard, 2013, p.40) Individuals with lower limb difficulties should have
pedals shifted away from these limbs. Transferring the rear brake controls and gear changing
Autonomous vehicles have been proposed as a potential solution to enable those with disabilities
to have greater accessibility to transit systems. According to (Wolf, n.d.) autonomous vehicles
could enable as many as two million more people with disabilites to attain employment
opportunities. Fully autonomous vehicles would largely take the human element out of the
equation making the ability to drive not as essential. However, disabled people are not interested
in fully autonomous vehicles partially due to the need for help in boarding the vehicle.
(Etminani-Ghasrodashti et. al, 2021, p.12) This research further states that those with special
mobility needs would be among the first to utilize autonomous vehicles. (p.2) The disabled
population would be willing to pay a significantly higher amount due to perceived usage to them.
9
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
(Kassens-Noor, et. al, 2021, p.387) Further research indicates that individuals with visual
impairments value AVs for the freedom it grants them to travel. (Etminani-Ghasrodashti, 2021,
p.3) According to (Greig, 2021) autonomous vehicles support disabled seniors maintaining their
independence while also providing a less invasive method of re-evaluating their driving skills as
they age. Further benefits include more flexibility, more efficient scheduling, and increased
availability. Autonomous vehicles will also allow disabled individuals to access essential
services. ( Kassens-Noor, et. al, 2021, p.386) Autonomous vehicles combined with machine
learning and artificial intelligence will allow autonomous vehicles to understand oral
Technology such as lasers, camera and radar could enable the creation of a 3D Map which
merges this information with traffic and geographic data to determine the best boarding location
and identifying potential objects. The autonomous vehicle company Waymo has launched an
initiative that could give the disabled a greater say in how autonomous vehicles are developed by
working with member organizations such as the American Association of People with
Disabilites, the National Federation of the Blind, and the Epilepsy Foundation of America to
conduct research, perform product testing, and allow Waymo to expand its existing offering of
accessible design features, which include audio cues, screen readers and support chats. (Hope,
2022)
However, challenges remain towards AV’s becoming a feasible option. The biggest among them,
is the fear of technological errors reducing the sense of safety. (Bennett et. al, 2019, p.12) As it
stands now, acceptance of AV technology is far from guaranteed. (p.2) However, for more than a
third of disabled travelers the integration of specialized technology into the autonomous vehicle
10
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
would be a prerequisite to their utilization. (Cordts, et. al, 2022, p.4) Disabled populations are
likely to face increased anxiety compared to their nondisabled counterparts concerning the safety
of autonomous vehicles. (Kassens-Noor, et al, 2021, p.387) These fears include feeling alone
following a collision and an uncertainty of knowing how to escape a damaged vehicle. (Bennett
et. al, 2019, p.3) Nearly one third of disabled passengers stated that they would prefer to have a
human driver with the AV technology to feel safe. (Cordts, et. al, 2022, p.4) Additional
challenges include alleviating fears of the disabled about how the technology would work.
(Greig, 2021) Other security concerns including vulnerability to hacking wherein someone
would remotely take over the vehicle still exist. (Allu, et. al, n.d.) Planning, political,
technological, and ethical debates all remain, and recent findings suggest that the disabled may
face further discrimination when attempting to purchase or operate an autonomous vehicle either
due to existing laws or the vehicles themselves. (Kassens-Nor, et. al, 2021, p.387) Other troubles
include skepticism among the disabled due to the struggles of the autonomous vehicle industry,
and the broken promises of tech companies in the past. (Reardon, 2021) There is also some
worry, that built environments might not be accessible to AV’s. (Dicianno et. al, 2021, p.5)
Different AV service models may also be required to match the needs of those with different
types of disability.
Methodology
This research was conducted over a ten-week span during Fall 2022. It involved secondary
research from websites and journal articles. Research also involved two interviews conducted in
October 2022. The first interviewees are currently, a Senior Transportation Planner for the
11
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
coordinator from BCDCOG. The second interviewee is an Operations Division Chief in the
Mount Pleasant, South Carolina Transportation Department. All interviewees were recruited via
email and were chosen via a work connection, and research on their background, job titles, areas
of expertise and proximity to Charleston and Mount Pleasant. Questions to guide research
include how these governments provide transportation access for the disabled, barriers faced in
attracting disabled populations, strategies that have been effective and ineffective, future
initiatives towards improving access, how a complaint is handled, and how public input effected
town decision making. The information gathered mainly pertains to the Charleston, South
Carolina and Mount Pleasant, South Carolina region and the initiatives these particular
Results
Research has found that access is improved and increased via infrastructure improvements
including weather proofing ramps in cold winter climates due to freezing and damage from road
salt, (Lindsay, 2020, p.1133) and the inclusion of ramps and pedestrian bridges (Dipetrillo et. al,
2016, p.11). Infrastructure improvements can also be found in the form of low floor buses,
ramps, large destination signs, floor markings, grab bars, audible stop announcements, and
monitors showing upcoming stops. (Equity in transportation, n.d.) Creating accessible parking
spaces has also proven to be effective in helping disabled people optimize use of private
Educational improvements are also needed, and a lack of education is often one of the biggest
barriers preventing disabled riders from accessing transit as there is little familiarity with existing
12
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
transportation options. S. Cox & J. Lambert, personal communication, October 14, 2022)
Training programs designed to equip public and private transportation providers more effectively
with knowledge regarding availability of federal programs and resources that can aid in
improving access is vital. (Remillard, et. al, 2022, p.8) Additionally, it is paramount to educate
planning staff and employees in other departments about ADA standards and universal design
principles, (Wright & Johnson-Wright, 2018) which detail design methods that ensure the
greatest amount and availability of access by people as possible regardless of age, size or
disability. (What is Universal Design, 2020) A critical next step is ensuring that these concepts
are integrated into zoning codes, development standards, and comprehensive plans. (Wright &
Improved funding will also improve and increase disabled access to transit. (Lindsay, 2018,
p.1133) Training for public transportation and school bus drivers in handling disabled passengers
transportation systems and districts, vehicle modifications and other adaptive technology,
ridesharing programs, and apps will all help to enable and improve access. Further adaptive
technology could include intelligent transportation, artificial intelligence, and object detection
passengers particularly those with vision impairments was seen as critical according to research
Working with volunteer groups have been proven effective in helping those with disabilities. (S.
13
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
Research by Lindsay (2018), revealed that the biggest priorities among individuals with
disabilities were funding and support for purchasing modified vehicles and mobility devices,
enhancing vehicle access through resources and improved accessibility of transportation stations
and shared vehicles, and increased training for public transportation and school bus drivers.
(p.1133) Other priorities among the disabled included training youth to navigate public
transportation, (p.1134), travel training acquired through high school credit (p.1134), and
increased government support or loan programs for purchasing and learning how to drive a
Case Study
The Charleston, South Carolina region is one of many in the United States with a high
population of both seniors and those with disabilities and therefore serves as the case study for
this research partly because they have worked extensively to increase and improve access for
disabled people to transit. The organization charged with transportation planning in the
which serves as the Metropolitan Planning Organization for the region. BCDCOG administers
the $500,000 in annual funding they receive as part of the Federal Transit Administration’s
(FTA’s) Section 5310 program. (Transportation Coordination Plan, 2022, p.5). The Section 5310
program is an annual formula grant for urban areas that is administered to Council of
Governments and Metropolitan Planning Organizations such as BCDCOG. (S. Cox & J.
Lambert personal communication, October 14, 2022) Human services agencies are the primary
applicants for this funding. This money is then suballocated out to different areas of each
region. Rural Section 5310 funding works differently. Rural Section 5310 funding goes directly
14
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
from the FTA to the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT). SCDOT is then
tasked with performing the allocation. Activities eligible for federal funding include wheelchair
lifts, transit related technology for scheduling and routing, wayfinding signage and technology,
and mobility management programs that lessen reliance on paratransit services. (Transportation
The Charleston Area Regional Transportation Authority (CARTA) which serves the Charleston
area partnered with Uber to launch CARTA on Demand to provide subsidized transportation to
expanded its staff to hire an employee focused on bus stop amenities and accommodations. (p.8)
Additionally, between 2016 and 2021 CARTA installed 54 shelters, 31 benches, 9 bike racks, 14
digital signs, 130 solar lights and 4 new park &ride lots made possible through public-private
partnerships with local businesses and municipalities. (p.8) Additional initiatives to encourage
disabled rider access included reduced fees on CARTA buses, (p.31) and in 2020 the installation
of automatic audio announcement systems on the newer fixed-route vehicles when approaching a
stop. (p.39) Desired infrastructure improvements include the installation of message boards on
buses that prompt riders about the next stop, and an audible crosswalk button for high usage
areas in certain communities. (S. Cox & J. Lambert personal communication, October 14, 2022)
Further, all CARTA buses have lifts to accommodate wheelchairs and other mobility devices.
(CARTA Accessibility, 2022) Buses also have the ability to lower to the curb to ease the
boarding process. Priority seating at the front of every bus is available for those with disabilities
and all buses permit service animals. However, there are some “legacy” stops that were
15
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
implemented prior to the ADA’s passage in 1990 that have not been updated to meet ADA
requirements. (S. Cox & J. Lambert, personal communication, October 14, 2022)
CARTA has a set aside Tel-A-Ride service specifically for those with disabilities who cannot
access regular public transit. (Tel-A-Ride Service, 2022) To obtain eligibility for the Tel-A-Ride
service, riders must have a specific disability restricting their mobility. An application which is
receiving services. The service is available during the same hours that the regular CARTA bus
service is offered on fixed-route service and within ¾ miles on either side of fixed system routes.
The service area encompasses the Charleston peninsula including James Island, West Ashley,
Mount Pleasant, Sullivan’s Island, Isle of Palms and North Charleston. Riders are not restricted
by trip purposes and riders often use Tel-A-Ride for non-emergency services such as going to the
movies or visiting a friend. Further, those who have regular travel requirements for work, school
or medical appointments may apply for subscription services. Passengers are also able to bring
along a personal care attendant whose assistance is required for completing the trip. However,
riders must make their reservations at least one day before the desired travel date but no earlier
than two weeks before. Drivers are also unable to assist disabled passengers up the stairs or
BCDCOG also has a complaint process for the disabled to make their concerns heard. The type
of complaint determines who it is heard by. Complaints about overall service go to customer
service while those specifically related to ADA violations go to the compliance administrator. (S.
16
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
On-time performance as is the case with regular transit service, has been an issue for Tel-A-Ride.
Mount Pleasant, South Carolina is currently soliciting feedback for different aspects of its
comprehensive plan through a series of seven “Public Input Matters” meetings. One of these
aspects is the transportation and mobility aspect. The town is using these meetings to learn about
existing issues they don’t know about. (J. Aton, personal communication, October 18, 2022)
Community feedback is integral in helping Mount Pleasant target areas for improvement. A
barrier that Mount Pleasant is working to overcome is upgrading traffic signals and audible
pedestrian push buttons. The ability to target these areas for improvement, specifically acquiring
the necessary funds is often at the whims of Mount Pleasant Town Council. (J. Aton, personal
This research is limited due to a primary focus on improving the public transit system.
Information obtained does not discuss making cities as a whole more accessible to disabled
populations, specifically open public spaces. The case study referring to the Charleston, South
Carolina region is not necessarily representative of other similar cities, smaller towns, or rural
including in public squares. Additionally, more work needs to be done to address disabled
individuals that live in rural communities or other areas where public transit is limited or does
not exist. Literature is limited in addressing these groups who are even more limited than
disabled individuals in more urban and suburban communities. Moving forward, transportation
17
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
planners should coordinate with planners in other communities and jurisdictions as colleagues to
develop solutions and gain inspiration from projects and initiatives that have been kickstarted in
planners must utilize this technology to aid the disabled and other vulnerable groups in accessing
transit and their overall communities. Lastly, further research should be done to address those
with visual and hearing disabilities along with those who have intellectual disabilities as a
majority of the literature focuses on those with physical impairments or mobility issues.
Conclusions
Improving and increasing transportation access for the disabled is an ongoing goal of the
disability community that dates back to the 1970’s. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.11) While the passage of
the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) has helped there remains much work to be done.
awareness and training remain. Further, people with disabilities are generally unhappy with their
current level of transportation access. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.12) A lack of transportation access leads
to social isolation, reduced employment opportunities, lack of access to quality healthcare, and
reduced participation in society. (Bascom & Christensen, 2017, p.227) Strategies identified
range from increased funding and awareness training for public transit drivers, (Lindsay, 2018,
p.1133) to increased advocacy and public awareness for disabled populations. (p.1135)
Additional improvements including ramps, marked crosswalks, signage, and improved lighting,
18
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
will improve the ability of disabled passengers to safely access both public and private
transportation. (Dipetrillo et. al, p.11; & Park & Chowdhury, 2018)
According to the American Planning Association, the planning process exists to serve the public
interest. This mission includes the 40 million Americans with disabilities. (Ruvolo, 2020, p.9)
Ensuring our transportation systems are accessible for those with disabilities is essential towards
Works Cited
7 Things You Probably Didn't Know About Paratransit. (2017, December 28). National Express
Transit Blog. https://www.nationalexpresstransit.com/blog/7-things-you-probably-didnt-know-
about-paratransit/
Accessibility [Fact sheet]. (2022). CARTA.
https://www.ridecarta.com/services/accessibility/#:~:text=All%20CARTA%20fixed%20route%2
0buses,Disabilities%20Act%20(ADA)%20requirements.
Adapted Vehicles [Fact sheet]. (n.d.). NHTSA. https://www.nhtsa.gov/road-safety/adapted-
vehicles
Alderton, M. (2020, June 26). Nearly 30 years after the ADA, the nation's transit agencies report
successes and shortfalls. The Washington Post.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/trafficandcommuting/nearly-30-years-after-ada-nations-
transit-agencies-report-successes-and-shortfalls/2020/06/25/76e102d8-af22-11ea-8758-
bfd1d045525a_story.html
Allu, S., Jaiswal, A., Lin, M., Malik, A., Ozay, L., & Prashanth, T. (n.d.). Accessible Personal
Transportation for People with Disabilities Using Autonomous Vehicles (B. S. Duerstock, Dr.,
Ed.). https://docs.lib.purdue.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1000&context=ugcw
Bascom, G. W., & Christensen, K. M. (2017). The impacts of limited transportation access on
persons with disabilities' social participation. Journal of Transport & Health, 7(B), 227-
234.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214140517300075
Bayless, S. H., & Davidson, S. (2019, April). Driverless Cars and Accessibility: Designing the
Future of Transportation for People with Disabilities. https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/64474
Bennett, R., Vijaygopal, R., & Kottasz, R. (2019). Attitudes towards autonomous vehicles
among people with physical disabilities. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice,
127,1-17. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0965856418308917?via%3Dihub
Bezyak, J. L., Sabella, S., & Gattis, R. H. (2017). Public Transportation: An Investigation of
Barriers for People With Disabilities. Journal of Disability Policy Studies, 1-25.
19
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
Byington, L. (2021, July 26). Disabled Face Transit Barriers Decades After Landmark Law
(1).Bloomberg Government. https://about.bgov.com/news/infrastructure-bill-seen-as-means-to-
force-transit-accessibility/
Cerchiai, A., & Lieberman, M. (2018, August 9). This is What It's Like to Travel With a
Disability in the United States. Thepointsguy.com. https://thepointsguy.com/guide/traveling-
with-a-disability-in-the-united-states/
Chang, Y. C., & Chen, C. F. (2012). Meeting the needs of disabled air passengers: Factors that
facilitate help from airlines and airports. Tourism Management, 33(3), 529-536.
https://pdf.sciencedirectassets.com/271716/1-s2.0-S0261517711X00079/1-s2.0-
S0261517711001130/main.pdf?X-Amz-Security-
Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEDoaCXVzLWVhc3QtMSJGMEQCIADAKWQMgO8ccjiYJ%2Fq
XL3ZjUAtSG
QuqLg6jksZuGACNAiAbTZZ%2BHCucPCQHtzOI3w8sI5hmYWU0NUPFDV25JSZyRSrMB
AhTEAUaDDA1OTAwMzU0Njg2NSIMH9tE1jR1t%2BH4UutjKqkEaMGsYMVvAU9CYDO
2uNwO1XGOlMBcPkVG%2B9lQtJuSuEZvEuqvrLk6noOFlv1E7SeI7bbNpiSBY81QzlKLmBx
C5wlws0r3nudHbNaKEp4FFPBfCcPqgbtJlx0BJIrgosMA321zuprnm65TlRPql3FECGthExVM8
BIUptZ%2BJmhvw1ciSEsICbddvYhOahyu8yJxgSNKmhNFibJW2fbxYV6UT%2Bz9jrTZQ81p
NELXWLx5KsQ8Ood0CfN7SnogQ1KfTGoSA3WJfJvfQA2P1tRTS4JKLHIxWhPrkC1kFG3zz
LkhNR9SinhRgtfR%2BvyJIt5h7s3J8AyNkGcac5m4Bwoa%2F2n4FnXlePQblUV2RkrpYlIFb02
sXHO2swaY4AycY73Z9EEHEJCUny7rbOAQ5bSv%2FKtVjgphklbvNr7p942O2eXfUFJRjSjw
cWBu6ZB6WxCVdXC%2Fx%2FQV0SrjIjeViC%2FmNlDiuX0LXa%2FP5y0X%2F2Z%2BEm
Igyl0yE6TMVBcL1P3oJmK22PvtkhDxH912aAKmsgdRZ4%2F43ZKiqCUMlHOILAECoLSxb
m7mEzHDszigBdyUv7lOQwhRJCeCBdkCVZiSJaudt3AbKdg86UQ6uKFa0ym1cFpzySuewm
mLYID2c8QL5Z1BYS0M9gZ%2FAhOxP1689syKPv5cAovffl46%2FJKGB4vQ35e91xWQ4pz
oOB0X384S9orl7W6uRhM0Cr9HMIS4ZwrODiTwL5Of4RtF0dqBojC7zpWcBjqqAfA%2BxaT
PyLhkgUoOH1zLREsheKyzKRgv%2BOdBlPAJKeqzOg2PPnO2t%2FACEB3ICcjx1yjJk8DZd
Lv4jG1N%2F5LQMg5cI67ZK8HemwQjR7oiFsf95j1Qt3HGwBWLARs%2FaVDYGDDZ3jvaq
1ZPExGfpSMgmTHEWjsafQr7dvTGTKXE7nvt2DskAwEC22jcrokmKbIS%2FVyK5kaT%2Fu
gNYJfwRGV116o6XAM%2F9q6wq7uv&X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-
Amz-Date=20221129T025523Z&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Expires=300&X-Amz-
Credential=ASIAQ3PHCVTY7MGFRRGS%2F20221129%2Fus-east-
1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-
Signature=61d594607f5da76308981bc1c0b13e9bc7d47807d93a1d5e65a6982d4014299d&hash=
a941dff84873d9a74a24bd45299350839684aad0f426970673b5d3f2214f22ef&host=68042c9435
91013ac2b2430a89b270f6af2c76d8dfd086a07176afe7c76c2c61&pii=S0261517711001130&tid
=spdf-71d7daf2-daca-46e5-ba78-
ad6789d73950&sid=6e123cfd4719f04f2d3b4b01962f42ecd029gxrqa&type=client&ua=5550535
b5f50580c52&rr=7718106b29742233
20
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
Cordts, P., Cotten, S. R., Qu, T., & Bush, T. R. (2021). Mobility challenges and perceptions of
autonomous vehicles for individuals with physical disabilities. Disability and Health
Journal,14(4), 1-6. https://pdf.sciencedirectassets.com/276914/1-s2.0-S1936657421X00040/ 1-
s2.0-S1936657421000777/ main.pdf?X-Amz-Security-
Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEDsaCXVzLWVhc3QtMSJGMEQCIE9KIidMJVEPu%2B3i1z%2B
pO1VD%2Bruqve%2FA4qp2azGp2jKGAiBmsakEkcqfJSw9Abz9fJev5n2%2FNfnG%2FftUqEt
fOw4b0SrMBAhUEAUaDDA1OTAwMzU0Njg2NSIM
PI2s8VZrgLAcrTFyKqkEyUE9tksao3DKAr%2BtmdOuuk%2FiJ3CrHF1arGCiRV6QKs2S4Vz
wbRDrzoIhaItdbrbo3mCxlNOPZ0mmNJq2tk26nXmUlaXWwLQR6qQScZQAhS2%2BHZCkI
V7761ePphST1MwR8hcU0Xa%2Fep%2F%2FzGoj8lP6%2B52OPUpURDUrCfMMwvg6dMW
oZZb45tSo0AiVxojQ6rDnKn1Q9O2S5lpSfpCB1HtAUjFnGd%2Fs6uWB%2B%2FDN5muzpq
1ERDZv3pfjBRkYuYH1Dl7Qg5fktnugMEoHBVYMnusjVUPXmpGWosdGCIA9mn8zzDR%2
FH4OBqCBlH0yAo9LYLiNA1r52Lo%2FNhid6CfceFw6NpPmt5GBye022syMIDN4vWSKdD
2bM1jnTVIkM88JOzHynfZ5lYsQmP2uhTNuKu9yAMdEWzGtfsdndXy0HrW6vmFgZalcvL6Z
zq5con7ktT%2BVvxzUG6Ywd%2BOddqRD4qYCSq1isiD4Ih%2F5dqoQLXcJ5tphYklqDlOIRj
BagykElv2NSZxEqQkNqCoYtZW%2F%2BaQAVbqJ%2FGYJo%2F0l6UocS5yyUpCc%2F48
%2Bt5GXM1Mkt73Mxf18TrdbAuNr7GKqgR8kYRR0c85jByssUKV24WoJf2YIhOYV9gK9e4
Kd86eVcJLNQmiggVzYZe
VO5E8npAHMPg4glk32wFvl8X%2BcDWNfVXXMPd6QaiiWGr9r2%2FwRem3ZkW7qT0sW
NZJCRpo3b95I9A1p5JRh5jO2%2BPtbL1zCs6JWcBjqqATFHP3SAfo5kp%2Ff4BnGUuXxzB
UMKK%2BX7t%2Bevz5123WGDLE17dJbgIk7ZOazkGq5HjIoJiFE9YjT%2BCxwkyEyG%2B
vaM%2Bw8PjH3nd%2FxUaLq1i2GsrY3cWYO7NDMowI6JZiAdx0irZKu%2FwjoPsweoNhZx
FESse3gkF4yMFw87%2FbblgrsLnqIdfy9rSYgI7GdtxKD1UmGoQ02n01JlnJXLRMHWEK3C
YTqwi45reOy%2B&X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-
Date=20221129T034607Z&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Expires=300&X-Amz-
Credential=ASIAQ3PHCVTY7DGCIDHG%2F20221129%2Fus-east-
1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-
Signature=39e338818d5dbb9af58d15e7c172e0974567de3e9c93752e32021bdc080bf397&hash=
73e4f9356f7ea552723200e33b1574fda28083836fb761a09b0e53d9db4e87f7&host=68042c9435
91013ac2b2430a89b270f6af2c76d8dfd086a07176afe7c76c2c61&pii=S1936657421000777&tid
=spdf-fe90df0a-df3a-45f5-919c-
e96ee433cc0e&sid=6e123cfd4719f04f2d3b4b01962f42ecd029gxrqa&type=client&ua=5550535
b5b010c0c52&rr=77185abb2fb0b715
Dicianno, B. E., Sivakanthan, S., Sundaram, S. A., Satpute, S., Kulich, H., Powers, E., Deepak,
N.,Russell, R., Cooper, R., & Cooper, R. A. (2021). Systematic review: Automated vehicles and
services for people with disabilities. Neuroscience Letters, 761, 1-
18.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/piiS030439402100481X?casa_token=ts16e96v
aqEAAAAA:1915N4m7pjpmb0PcYI0t1hYlp5SpWSTMLY6aIhbCvfe-GzHMJhrBuhxt3-
tz3W0TMpGIPSstjLM
DiPetrillo, S., Lubin, A., Loukaitou-Sideris, A., Salehian, C., Gibson, S., Williams, K., & Green,
T. T. (2016, August). Improving Pathways to Transit for Persons with Disabilities.
https://transweb.sjsu.edu/sites/default/files/1233-transit-access-for-persons-with-disabilities.pdf
21
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
Etminani- Ghasrodashti, R., Patel, R. K., Kermanshachi, S., Rosenberger, J. M., Weinreich, D.,
& Foss, A. (2021). Integration of shared autonomous vehicles (SAVs) into existing
transportation services: A focus group study. Transportation Research Interdisciplinary
Perspectives, 12,1-15. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259019822100186X
Equity in Transportation for People with Disabilities. (n.d.).
civilrightsdocs.info.https://www.civilrightsdocs.info/pdf/transportation/final-transportation-
equity-disability.pdf
Greig, J. (2021, April 19). How autonomous vehicles could help the elderly and disabled in the
near future. techrepublic.com. https://www.techrepublic.com/article/how-autonomous-vehicles-
could-help-the-elderly-and-disabled-in-the-near-future/
Hawkins, A. J. (2022, July 11). How the ride-sharing revolution failed passengers with
disabilities.theverge.com. https://www.theverge.com/23199117/ride-sharing-disabled-
passengers-accessibility-uber-lyft
Hope, G. (2022, October 11). Waymo Launches AV Initiative for People with
Disabilities.iotworldtoday.com. https://www.iotworldtoday.com/2022/10/11/waymo-launches-
av-initiative-for-people-with-disabilities/
Jainchill, J., Jelski, C., & Silk, R. (2022, September 19). State of Accessible
Travel.travelweekly.com. https://www.travelweekly.com/Travel-News/Travel-Agent-
Issues/State-of-accessible-travel-2022-part-1
Kassens-Noor, E., Cai, M., Kotval-Karamchandani, Z., & Decaminada, T. (2021). Autonomous
Vehicles and mobility for people with special needs. Transportation Research Part A, 385-
397.https://innovationcenter.msu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/ Autonomous-vehicles-and-
mobility-for-people-with-special-needs.pdf
Kunkle, F. (2018, May 26). Uber, Lyft and other ride-hailing apps are 'useless' for disabled
riders, NYC advocates say. The Washington Post.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/tripping/wp/2018/05/26/uber-lyft-and-other-ride-hailing-
apps-are-useless-for-disabled-riders-nyc-advocates-say/
Lindsay, S. (2020). Accessible and inclusive transportation for youth with disabilites: exploring
innovative solutions. Disability and Rehabilitation, 42(8), 1131-
1140.https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09638288.2018.1517194?casa_token=4ThtT
c4VYrkAAAAA%3AWviMBvNVaIIUMmykIT_wOUdQo4ZpDnXcr2JpC053H4NK3TieKZ6B
hQTbxf_sLaSfKI8s8PJOIujXNg
Litman, T. (2022, October 19). Evaluating Accessibility for Transport Planning.
https://www.vtpi.org/access.pdf
Myers, A., Ipsen, C., & Standley, K. (2022, April 27). [Transportation Patterns of Adults With
Travel-Limiting Disabilities in Rural and Urban America]. frontiersin.org.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fresc.2022.877555/full
Nakat, Z., & Babinard, J. (2013, May). Improving Accessibility to Transport for People with
Limited Mobility.
https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/17592/Accessibility0Report0Final
.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
Park, J., & Chowdhury, S. (2018). Investigating the barriers in a typical journey by public
transport users with disabilities. Journal of Transport & Health, 10, 361-
368.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214140517309246?casa_token=VzQfg
22
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
ADSWbIAAAAA:g6IyBIkxDQ7vxSNRYLS4pP2qypPJE6j4fQUufphgc_meba_DGbmU8KEzo
9mRsn1MnDB8wHLAHZs
Passengers with Disabilities: Airport Accessibility Barriers and Practices and DOT's Oversight
of Airlines' Disability-Related Training. (2021, April 14). https://www.gao.gov/products/ gao-
21-354
Paulus, N. (2022, September 20). Disability Accessibility Through Adapted Vehicles: A Guide
from Vehicle Modification to Insurance. moneygeek.com.
https://www.moneygeek.com/insurance/auto/resources/people-with-disabilities/
Perry, T. (2022, March 8). Adapted Mobility Vehicles Coming in More Varieties With Added
Capability. Newsweek. https://www.newsweek.com/adapted-mobility-vehicles-coming-more-
varieties-added-capability-1685017
Plank, L. (2021, July 11). How the airline industry still refuses to accommodate disability.
MSNBC. https://www.msnbc.com/opinion/how-airline-industry-still-refuses-accommodate-
disability-n1273650
Reardon, C. (2021, December 20). Disabled passengers were promised autonomous vehicles —
they're still waiting. theverge.com. https://www.theverge.com/22832657/autonomous-vehicles-
disabled-accessible-challenges-design
Regional Human Services Transportation Coordination Plan. (2022, June).Berkeley-Charleston-
Dorchester Council of Governments. https://bcdcog.com/wp-
content/uploads/2022/06/TransportationCoordinationPlan_2022.pdf
Remillard, E. T., Campbell, M. L., Koon, L. M., & Rogers, W. A. (2022). Transportation
challenges for persons aging with mobility disability: Qualitative insights and policy
implications. Disability and Health Journal, 15(1), 1-10.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1936657421001825
Ruvolo, M. (2020, June). Access Denied? Perceptions of New Mobility Services Among Disabled
People in San Francisco. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/6jv123qg
Saripalli, S. (2017, October 9). Are Self-Driving Cars The Future Of Mobility For Disabled
People?today.tamu.edu. https://today.tamu.edu/2017/10/09/are-self-driving-cars-the-future-of-
mobility-for-disabled-people/
Schruth, S. (2018). Despite Progress, True Public Transit Accessibility Remains. Metro
Magazine.https://www.metro-magazine.com/10007269/despite-progress-true-public-transit-
accessibility-remains-elusive
Shapero, J. (2022, July 18). Uber settles lawsuit with DOJ over alleged disability violations.
Axios. https://www.axios.com/2022/07/18/uber-settles-doj-disability-violations
Sze, N., & Christensen, K. M. (2017). Access to urban transportation system for individuals with
disabilities. IATSS Research, 41(2), 66-73.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/piiS0386111217300444
Tel-A-Ride Service [Fact sheet]. (2022). CARTA. https://www.ridecarta.com/services/tel-a-ride/
Traveling with a Disability [Fact sheet]. (n.d.). transportation.gov.
https://www.transportation.gov/individuals/aviation-consumer-protection/traveling-
disability#:~:text=Airlines%20are%20also%20required%20to,the%20loading%20and%20stowin
g%20of
23
Aaron Bennett
12/8/22
URP 6716- Transportation Policy/Planning
Improving and Increasing Transportation Access for the Disabled
Travel Patterns of American Adults with Disabilities. (2022, January 3). Bureau of
Transportation Statistics. https://www.bts.gov/travel-patterns-with-disabilities
Wintersgill, J., & Wood, C. (2021, March 25). Flying as a wheelchair user: it's time for airlines
to listen and make changes. disabilityhorizons.com.
https://disabilityhorizons.com/2021/03/flying-as-a-wheelchair-user-its-time-for-airlines-to-listen-
and-make-change/
What is Universal Design. (n.d.). https://universaldesign.ie/what-is-universal-design/
Wolf, M. (n.d.). How Autonomous Vehicles Can Affect People with Disabilities. The NCSL
Blog.https://www.ncsl.org/blog/2019/12/10/how-autonomous-vehicles-can-affect-people-with-
disabilities.aspx
Wright, S., & Johnson-Wright, H. (2018, February). Inclusive Mobility. Planning
Magazine.https://www.planning.org/planning/2018/feb/inclusivemobility/
Yousuf, M., & Fitzgerald, M. (2012, October). The New Frontier in Accessible Transportation.
US Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration.
https://highways.dot.gov/public-roads/septemberoctober-2012/new-frontier-accessible-
transportation
24