Professional Documents
Culture Documents
F
Objective: The duration of untreated psychosis is associated with poor ailure to make prompt initial
outcomes in multiple domains in the early course of nonaffective psy- treatment contact has been
chotic disorders, although relatively little is known about determinants noted as a pervasive aspect of
of this critical period, particularly health services–level determinants. unmet need for mental health care in
This study examined three hypothesized predictors of duration of un- the United States (1). Regarding psy-
treated psychosis (lack of insurance, financial problems, and broader chotic disorders, the duration of un-
barriers) among urban, socioeconomically disadvantaged African treated psychosis represents the in-
Americans, while controlling for the effects of three patient-level pre- terval of time from the onset of posi-
dictors (mode of onset of psychosis, living with family versus alone or tive psychotic symptoms to the initia-
with others before hospitalization, and living above versus below the tion of adequate treatment (2–4).
federally defined poverty level). Methods: Analyses included data from This treatment delay has been
42 patient–family member dyads from a larger sample of 109 patients shown, through numerous studies
with a first episode of nonaffective psychosis. The duration of untreat- summarized in two independent
ed psychosis and all other variables were measured in a rigorous, stan- meta-analyses (5,6), to be associated
dardized fashion in a study designed specifically to examine determi- with poorer outcomes in the early
nants of treatment delay. Survival analyses and Cox regression as- course of psychosis. Although the ad-
sessed the effects of the independent predictors on time from onset of verse correlates of duration of un-
psychosis to hospital admission for initial evaluation and treatment. treated psychosis are relatively clear-
Results: The median duration of untreated psychosis was 24.5 weeks. ly established and some evidence in-
When the analyses controlled for the three patient-level covariates, pa- dicates that this treatment delay is
tients without health insurance, with financial problems, or with barri- modifiable through broad communi-
ers to seeking help had a significantly longer duration of untreated ty-level informational campaigns and
psychosis. Conclusions: Health services–related factors, such as lack of dedicated early-detection teams
insurance, are predictive of longer treatment delay. Efforts to elimi- (7,8), less is known about the causes
nate uninsurance and underinsurance, as well as minimize barriers to or determinants of treatment delay,
treatment, would be beneficial for improving the prognosis of young particularly in especially vulnerable
patients with emerging nonaffective psychotic disorders. (Psychiatric populations.
Services 60:1489–1494, 2009) Few health services–related pre-
dictors of the delay in treatment for
psychosis have been substantiated in
the literature, although some factors
pertaining to access to care have been
Dr. Compton, Ms. Ramsay, Ms. Goulding, and Dr. Gordon are affiliated with the De-
partment of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Emory University School of Medicine,
explored. A review of studies from
Grady Memorial Hospital, Box 26238, 80 Jesse Hill Jr. Dr., Atlanta, GA 30303 (e-mail: multiple countries found that dura-
mcompto@emory.edu). Dr. Shim is with the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral tion of untreated psychosis is inverse-
Sciences, Morehouse School of Medicine, Atlanta. Mr. Weiss is with the Department of ly correlated with the gross domestic
Biostatistics and Dr. Druss is with the Department of Health Policy and Management, product, presumably because of dif-
both at the Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta. ferences in access to adequate health
PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES ♦ ps.psychiatryonline.org ♦ November 2009 Vol. 60 No. 11 1489
care (9). In that study a strong rela- chiatric units providing services for tients were adequately stabilized to
tionship was observed between dura- patients with no insurance or with allow for informed consent and eval-
tion of untreated psychosis and pur- only public-sector insurance (for ex- uation (for example, in the overarch-
chasing power parity in lower- and ample, Medicaid). The population ing study, 87 of the 109 patients
middle-income countries, which sug- served by these units is predomi- (80%) were assessed between the
gests that the cost of care is a major nantly African American, low-in- third and the tenth hospital day).
determining factor. In a sample of come, and socially disadvantaged. The research assessment with family
525 patients with affective and nonaf- Between July 2004 and June 2008, a members lasted approximately two
fective psychoses hospitalized in psy- total of 281 patients were screened hours and was conducted during the
chiatric facilities in Suffolk County, for study participation, and 192 were patient’s hospitalization or, rarely,
New York, between September 1989 found to be eligible on the basis of within several days of discharge. The
and December 1995, having private the following inclusion criteria: aged study was approved by all relevant
insurance was associated with a 18–40 years, able to speak and read institutional review boards and re-
greater likelihood of being admitted English, absence of known mental search oversight committees. All pa-
to a hospital for psychosis within retardation, a Mini-Mental State Ex- tients and family members gave writ-
three months of onset (10). In that amination (17,18) score ≥23 (indi- ten informed consent before their
study, having private insurance and, cating generally intact orientation participation.
to a lesser extent, having public and basic cognitive functioning), ab- As reported previously (14,19) du-
health insurance increased the likeli- sence of medical conditions that ration of untreated psychosis was de-
hood that a patient had received out- could compromise ability to partici- fined as the number of weeks from
patient care before the first hospital- pate, no prior antipsychotic treat- the onset of positive psychotic symp-
ization. Although some patient- and ment lasting for more than three toms until first hospital admission
family-level predictors of treatment months, no previous hospitalization and was measured in a systematic
delay have been studied, little re- for psychosis more than three way by using selected items from the
search has identified these or other months before the index hospitaliza- semistructured Course of Onset and
health services–level determinants, tion, and able to provide written in- Relapse Schedule/Topography of
despite the fact that they clearly play formed consent. Eighty-three pa- Psychotic Episode (CORS/TOPE)
a role in expediting or delaying care tients did not participate because of interview (20), as well as the Symp-
seeking. Regarding established pa- refusal (N=52, 63%) or discharge tom Onset in Schizophrenia (SOS)
tient- and illness-level predictors of from the hospital before an assess- inventory (21). Onset of positive
duration of untreated psychosis, pre- ment could be conducted (N=31, symptoms was operationalized as the
vious research suggests that the mode 37%). Those who did not participate date on which hallucinations or delu-
of onset of psychosis, which indicates did not differ from the 109 partici- sions met the threshold for a Positive
how quickly psychotic symptoms de- pants with regard to age, gender, or and Negative Syndrome Scale (22)
velop, is a replicated determinant of race or ethnicity. score of ≥3, and systematic methods
this critical variable (11–14). Of the 109 participants in the over- were used to resolve difficulties in
This report presents data on the ef- arching study, 44 (40%) referred to obtaining exact dates for the onset of
fects of three health services–level the study a family member who had psychotic symptoms. Cross-refer-
variables: whether or not a patient been actively involved in initiating encing with milestones and memo-
with a first episode of nonaffective care. These family members provided rable events was used to enhance the
psychosis had insurance, the presence detailed data on a number of family- accuracy of dating. Consensus-based
of financial problems as reported by and health services–related variables. best estimates of duration of untreat-
the patient’s family member, and the Two Caucasian informants were ex- ed psychosis were derived using all
family member’s endorsement of sev- cluded to enhance homogeneity of the available information, including a
eral barriers to seeking help beyond fi- sample, so the analyses presented thorough chart review, discussions
nancial problems. This analysis focuses here included data from 42 African- with treating clinicians, an in-depth
on health services–level predictors American patient–family member patient interview, and a detailed in-
among urban, socioeconomically dis- dyads. When compared on 26 so- terview with family members (also
advantaged African Americans. Work ciodemographic and clinical variables, based on selected CORS/TOPE
in this area is crucial because of the patients with a participating family items and the SOS inventory).
widely recognized persistence of race- member were significantly different Mode of onset of psychosis was
based disparities in mental health do- from those without a participating categorized, again based on all avail-
mains that adversely affect African family member only in terms of hav- able information, using five subtypes
Americans (15,16). ing a longer length of hospital stay and put forth by the World Health Orga-
an earlier age at onset of psychosis. nization’s International Pilot Study
Methods of Schizophrenia (23): sudden, pre-
Setting and sample Procedures and materials cipitous, subacute, gradual, and in-
Hospitalized patients with first- Clinical research assessments with sidious. For the analysis presented
episode nonaffective psychosis were patients typically lasted about four here, mode of onset of psychosis was
recruited from three inpatient psy- hours and were conducted once pa- trichotomized as acute, subacute, or
1490 PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES ♦ ps.psychiatryonline.org ♦ November 2009 Vol. 60 No. 11
chronic. Along with mode of onset, (Compton MT, Gordon TL, Gould- the mean educational attainment was
we also included data on two other ing SM, et al., unpublished manu- 12.8±2.5 years. Most (N=31, 74%)
patient-level covariates—who the script, 2009). For survival analyses, were mothers, with the remainder
patient lived with before hospitaliza- onset of psychosis was the entry being fathers (N=3, 7%), sisters (N=
tion and living above or below the point and hospital admission was the 3, 7%), or close second-degree rela-
federal poverty level. The latter was end point. Survivor functions repre- tives (N=5, 12%) who were actively
determined on the basis of the pa- senting survival rate as a function of involved in initiating care for pa-
tient’s report of annual household in- time (Kaplan-Meier survival curves) tients. The majority of informants
come and the number of people liv- were constructed to represent the (N=31, 74%) were currently or previ-
ing in the household, using pub- cumulative probability of hospital- ously married, and just over half
lished federal guidelines for the year ization over time in different groups. (N=25, 60%) were unemployed dur-
in which the patient was assessed. Log-rank tests assessed whether the ing the month before the patient’s
These three variables were used as probability of first hospitalization hospitalization.
covariates because they are patient- over time differed between defined In the subsample of 42 patients,
level variables discovered to be sig- groups, and Cox regression (which the median duration of untreated
nificant predictors of duration of un- predicts survival time from covari- psychosis was 24.5 weeks (mean=
treated psychosis in the larger study ates) quantified associations in terms 87.1±150.3 weeks, range=0–839.0
(Compton MT, Gordon TL, Gould- of hazard ratios. As such, hazard ra- weeks). For the overall sample of
ing SM, et al., unpublished manu- tios of <1 indicated a longer duration 109 patients, the median duration of
script, 2009). of untreated psychosis on average, untreated psychosis was 22.3 weeks
Data on the three hypothesized and hazard ratios of >1 indicated a (mean=67.5±126.1 weeks, range=0–
health services–level predictors were shorter duration of untreated psy- 839.3 weeks). The duration of un-
collected as part of a detailed struc- chosis (a hazard ratio of 1 would in- treated psychosis did not differ be-
tured interview with the family dicate no difference in survival time tween the subsample and the overall,
members. The first variable of inter- between groups). Following the con- larger sample. For the three hypoth-
est, whether or not the patient had vention of most researchers, the me- esized health services–level predic-
insurance or Medicaid, was queried dian (in addition to mean) duration tors, 33 family members (79%) re-
directly using closed-ended items. of untreated psychosis was reported ported that the patient did not have
The second variable, the presence of in this study, because of the highly health insurance; 24 family members
financial problems, was assessed by positively skewed distribution of this (57%) endorsed financial problems
asking, “In your opinion, was seeking duration measure. A recent system- as a barrier to seeking help for the
help for your family member diffi- atic review and meta-analysis con- patient; and 13 family members
cult to do because of financial prob- cluded that the mean duration of un- (31%) endorsed zero or one barrier
lems?” Regarding the third hypothe- treated psychosis is unsuitable for to seeking help, 14 family members
sized predictor, more general barri- benchmarking services, as it is too (33%) endorsed two or three barri-
ers to accessing health care, the fam- heavily influenced by a small propor- ers, and 15 family members (36%)
ily member’s report of several barri- tion of patients with remarkably long endorsed four to six barriers. Of note,
ers to seeking help in addition to fi- treatment delays (24). although not having health insurance
nancial problems was assessed by the was significantly related to financial
aforementioned question and five Results problems endorsed as a barrier to
others that asked about transporta- The mean±SD age of the 42 patients seeking help (χ2=4.32, df=1, Fisher’s
tion problems, not knowing where to in the subsample was 22.1±4.1 years, exact p=.05), this relationship was
go, having difficulty getting time off and the mean educational attainment not absolute. For example, 11 pa-
work, resistance from the patient, was 11.0±2.1 years. Most (N=31, tients (26%) did not have health in-
and insurance problems. Responses 74%) were men, nearly all (N=40, surance but did not endorse financial
of the family members were tri- 95%) were single or never married, problems as a barrier. On the other
chotomized on the basis of the en- and most lived with family members hand, not having health insurance
dorsement of zero or one, two or (N=33, 79%) and were unemployed was not significantly related to the
three, or four to six barriers. (N=26, 62%) during the month be- number of endorsed barriers to seek-
fore hospitalization. Structured Clini- ing help, indicating that these two
Data analyses cal Interview for DSM-IV Axis I Dis- variables are in fact independent.
Survival analyses were employed to orders (25) diagnoses were as follows: The median duration of untreated
examine the hypothesized health schizophreniform disorder (N=9, psychosis for participants without in-
services–level predictors of duration 21%), schizophrenia (N=27, 64%), surance was 42.5 weeks (mean=
of untreated psychosis. All analyses schizoaffective disorder (N=3, 7%), 107.1±167.5), compared with 22.5
controlled for the effects of the one brief psychotic disorder (N=1, 2%), weeks (mean=27.3±14.8) for those
relatively well-established patient- and psychotic disorder not otherwise with insurance. Patients without
level predictor of this variable, mode specified (N=2, 5%). health insurance had a significantly
of onset of psychosis (13,14), as well Regarding family members, the longer duration of untreated psy-
as the two other patient-level factors mean age was 46.3±10.1 years, and chosis (χ2=3.92, df=1, p=.05, hazard
PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES ♦ ps.psychiatryonline.org ♦ November 2009 Vol. 60 No. 11 1491
Figure 1 number of endorsed barriers to seek-
Survival curves for duration of untreated psychosis, stratified by insurance status ing help, all based on the family
member’s report) impedes patients
1.00 and their families from seeking treat-
Survival distribution function
No insurance
ment for emerging nonaffective psy-
.75 Public insurance chotic disorders. These variables are
predictive of a longer treatment de-
.50
lay, which in turn may contribute to
poorer clinical outcomes and greater
.25
family burden. These results support
.00
a previous report that lack of insur-
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 ance predicts a longer duration of un-
Weeks treated psychosis (10), and they are
consistent with literature showing
that uninsured adults are less likely
than those with insurance to obtain
ratio=.34) when the analysis con- likely as those with financial problems care for substance abuse and mental
trolled for the three covariates. This to be hospitalized at any given point illnesses (26).
indicates that at any given point in in time. The survival distribution Some U.S. studies of the duration
time, patients with insurance were, function is shown in Figure 2. of untreated psychosis report a
on average, about three times as like- The presence of four to six barriers longer period of treatment delay
ly (1/.34=2.94) to be hospitalized as (χ2=9.40, df=1, p=.002, hazard ra- than estimates from European stud-
those without insurance. The dura- tio=.18) was predictive of treatment ies. One possible explanation is that
tion of untreated psychosis survival delay (compared with endorsing prolonged delay may be due to dif-
distribution function pertaining to pa- none or only one barrier) when the ferences in health services delivery
tients who did not have insurance ver- analysis controlled for the three co- across countries. The number of
sus those who had public insurance is variates, meaning that, on average, adults who do not have health insur-
shown in Figure 1. patients with none or only one barri- ance in the United States increased
The median duration of untreated er were about 5.5 times as likely as by six million from 2000 to 2004, and
psychosis for participants whose fam- those with four to six barriers to be young adults (19–34 years of age) ac-
ily members endorsed financial prob- hospitalized at any given point in counted for half of this increase (27).
lems was 59.0 weeks (mean=139.9± time. The survival distribution func- Poverty is another key considera-
186.3), compared with 18.0 weeks tion for duration of untreated psy- tion—two-thirds of the growth in the
(mean=25.1±34.9) for those without chosis pertaining to patients with uninsured was among Americans
financial problems. The presence of four to six barriers versus two or whose income is 200% below the
financial problems as reported by three barriers versus zero or one bar- federal poverty level (27). The asso-
family members was predictive of the rier is shown in Figure 3. ciation that we found between lack
duration of untreated psychosis of insurance and a longer duration of
(χ2=10.17, df=1, p=.001, hazard ra- Discussion untreated psychosis is consistent
tio=.24) when the analysis controlled The findings presented here suggest with data indicating that when analy-
for the three covariates. Thus, on av- that an accumulation of barriers (pa- ses controlled for socioeconomic fac-
erage, patients without financial tient’s lack of insurance, the presence tors, patients who had lost their in-
problems were about four times as of financial problems, and a higher surance were more likely to delay
seeking care within the four months
after visiting an emergency depart-
ment than people whose health in-
Figure 2
surance status did not change (28),
Survival curves for duration of untreated psychosis, stratified by financial as well as with data showing that
problems compared with persons with insur-
1.00 ance the uninsured were less likely
Survival distribution function