Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SSRN Id2772081
SSRN Id2772081
ABSTRACT
The Indian consumer has evolved since 1991, when multinationals entered India, offering products
and services which were not available earlier. He now has a large number of options to choose from
and globalisation has aided the cultural movement due to which the western lifestyles, products and
services are demanded by a typical upper middle class young consumer. He looks beyond product
utility, to seek intangibles like style statement associated with the product. But can a service become a
lifestyle statement? Can companies think of sustainable innovative business models? This paper
attempts to answer these questions with the example of an Indian Company called Kaya Skin Clinic, a
leading lifestyle brand in the professional skin care segment. The aim of the paper is to develop a
conceptual model and illustrate with example the role and relevance of innovation in creating niche,
urbane, and yet sustainable business. Kaya Skin Clinic has been able to create a whole new market
segment of scientific approach driven skincare solutions. What was once a supplementary service
offered by traditional beauty salons, has now become a thriving business model. Armed with a robust
proprietary Information and Technology architecture that facilitates Customer Relationship
Management, Loyalty and Referral Marketing, Kaya has created a lifestyle brand from what was once
a basic service. (Here - Lifestyle brands create a certain degree of style statement for consumers).
The case study shows that developing innovative business model by industry convergence, backed by
creation of entry barriers can give sustainable competitive advantage to firms and develop consumer
lifestyles.
1 INTRODUCTION
The Indian consumer has evolved since 1991, when multinationals entered India, offering products and
services which were not available earlier. He now has a large number of options to choose from and
globalisation has aided the cultural movement due to which the western lifestyles, products and
services are demanded by a typical upper middle class young consumer. He looks beyond product
utility, to seek intangibles like style statement associated with the product. Socio-cultural,
psychographic and geo-demographic reasons have lead to this altered lifestyle (Joseph and Singh
2013) [1]. An average Indian today is younger, with a higher disposable income and a dispensation to
spend on sophisticated products and services which reflect his current lifestyle or the style he aspires
for than an Indian consumer a decade and half ago. (ASA & Associates, 2013) [2]. Wellness industry
is one the sectors which has witnessed a substantial positive impact of rising consumerism in India. As
per FICCI report by PWC, (2011) [3] report, „Riding the Growth Wave: Wellness‟, the overall size of
the wellness market in India stands at INR 490 bn and wellness services alone comprise 40% of this
market leading to the entry of a large number of domestic and international players in the market who
are trying novel and innovative methods to target customers offering a value proposition along with a
branded lifestyle which leads to dual satisfaction. The report further asserts that the future of the
wellness industry in India looks even more promising as the industry will grow at a CAGR of 20% to
reach INR 875 billion. Consumers and their needs will continue to evolve, driving the transition from
remedial care to a more holistic view on preventive care.
A domestic Indian company, Marico Industries, has been an early entrant into the wellness market in
India has been offering beauty and wellness services under the brand name of Kaya Skin Clinic and
the current paper attempts to study the innovative practice adopted by Kaya Skin Clinic to tap the
Electronic copy
Electronic copy available
available at:
at:https://ssrn.com/abstract=2772081
http://ssrn.com/abstract=2772081
potential growth opportunities offered by the market .
2 THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
2.1.1 Ambience in which service is offered: Powe, (2006) [4] indicated that lifestyle service
providers of the current times need to be very particular about the non-tangible consumptions. The
display or arrangement understood as the physical environment of the service area is a critical factor in
deciding how satisfied a consumer would be with the service offered and therefore impacting the
sustainability of the service (Bitner, 1992) [5]. The music, lighting, odour, sophistication and courtesy
expressed by the service staff impacts the consumers consumption and satisfaction from the service
(Baker, et.al, 2002) [6].
2.1.2 Service Term and Offerings Made: Most customers look at long term service agreement where
the service price and term is bundled in such a way that he can use uninterrupted long service without
having to invest too much into maintaining the service. The average Indian customer is price sensitive
and looks out for service options in the market before consuming a service. Therefore service
providers need to consciously watch out for various factors like service duration offered, maintenance
efforts needed for uninterrupted services, customer involvement in and finally the competitive prices
(The Marketing Association of Australia and New Zealand) [7]
2.1.3 Busy Lifestyle of the New Age Generation: Indian consumers are growingly getting busy and
involved in their jobs. There is a mass movement of workers to the cities where they lack any social
support system for care and consultation and therefore there is a dramatic rise in the services offered in
the cities. The busy life style brings along additional income but repercussions on health and therefore
an average urbane middle class Indian consumer is oriented towards consuming non-essential, lifestyle
oriented products and services.
2.1.4 Financially independent Self Conscious Woman: The population of working women has
increased and today over 26% of the working population are women (PWC) [8] leading to an addition
in the number of women who are financially independent and enjoy the confidence and freedom to
spend their earnings in consuming products and services which satiate their need to better leading a
happy self contended life. Sustainable development of services is only possible when women are
financially independent and manage to take decisions on their own (Eyben et al., 2008) [9]. A few
services which have witnessed an immediate and direct growth due to additional number of financially
independent women in the population are beauty and wellness sector; hospitality and day care services
and fashion industry.
2.1.5 Made for You: Papathanassiou (2004) [10] clearly stated that there is an increasing demand for
customized products and services which exactly fits the customers‟ needs. Contemporary customer is
highly conscious of his needs and expectations and therefore draws higher satisfaction from products
and services which are tailor-made to his needs. De Koning, Does, & Bisgaard, (2008) [11] reported
that competing services often use customization and individualization as a tool to tap a bigger market
share. Therefore services need to be become conscious of the fact that enhanced flexibility in design
and offering and a prompt response time are two basic essentials for their long-term sustainability in
the market Piller & Müller, (2004) [12].
Electronic copy
Electronic copy available
available at:
at:https://ssrn.com/abstract=2772081
http://ssrn.com/abstract=2772081
Apart from the consumer perspective there stand a few macro factors which impact the sustainability
quotient of an organization. A strategically designed organization keeps the following aspects in mind
while designing its internal and external structures.
The research was exploratory in nature seeking to elicit top management‟s perspective on the strategic
rationale of entering the wellness sector and then to analyse the theoretical conceptions which back the
practitioner‟s perspectives. An in-depth interview was conducted after a discussion guide was
developed. The telephonic interview was conducted at a time of ease and convenience which was
fixed through a prior appointment with the-then CEO of Kaya, Mr. Ajay Pahwa (November 2009 to
April 2013). The interview lasted over 80 minutes with a break after about 50 minutes which the
respondent asked for. Respondent was encouraged to talk as much, or as little as he wished, only
probing to seek clarification and to explore in detail their comments. The responses were recorded and
then transcribed.
Within the context of the aim of the study, the author noted patterns and a theme to the inputs, drawing
linkages with literature. To extend the sustainability perspective study further, financial data of 5 years
was used to gauge the financial performance of the firm and then compared with financial
performance of Marico Ltd. (Financial year 2007-08 to 2012-13).
4.1 Introduction:
Marico Limited is one of India's leading consumer products & services companies operating in the
beauty and wellness space. Currently present in 25 countries across emerging markets of Asia and
Africa, Marico has nurtured multiple brands in the categories of hair care, skin care, health foods, male
grooming, and fabric care. Charting an annual turnover of Rs. 46 billion (Financial year 2012-2013)
across their portfolio, Marico's sustainable growth story rests on an ecosystem that promotes
innovation and value creation.
The company has identified three core differentiators – an in-house dermatologist, Offerings in the
form of personalized skin treatments, research based products and services which suit the Indian skin
type and weather which Kaya communicates effectively through various mediums. Its
communications strategy targets a typical modern day financially independent Indian woman who
looks after herself in a refined way. Kaya targets high end customers in socio-economic class A with
age group of 18-60 years across metros and mini metros in the country. The objective is to provide
result oriented, personalized, non surgical skin care solutions in a serene zen-like environment. (AR
2009-10). [18]
4.4 Growth:
Kaya has been growing and has increased its reach to 81 clinics across the country, in the metro as
well tier 2 cities. They also have 14 clinics in the Middle East and 2 clinics in Bangladesh in Dhaka. In
May 2010, Kaya acquired the aesthetics business of the Singapore based Derma Rx Asia Pacific Pte.
Ltd. (Derma Rx). During the course of this journey, Kaya now has over 600,000 customers which has
constantly risen over a period of time indicating sustainability which us backed by innovative
practices.
Kaya Skin Clinic was launched in December 2002 when there was no other organized player in the
market. The skin care market was dominated by individual dermatologists who provided limited
offerings with rudimentary technology. Kaya has revolutionalized wellness market in India, it has also
provided credibility and trust to the industry with specific reference to cosmetic dermatology leading
to an emergence of regional brands with a few clinics and individual doctors offering similar services.
However, no one has the scale or the range of technology and services that Kaya offers. The chain has
increased its focus on specialized service categories like laser hair removal, pigmentation, anti-ageing
and acne treatments, which has led to the average bill size increasing to Rs. 14,000 currently compared
with Rs. 12,000 a year ago indicating sustainable growth. The contribution of these specialized
skincare services to overall business has grown to 61% from 50%. The organization still offers regular
1. Economies of Scale:
A national brand that enjoys over 80% plus brand awareness, built on the back of national
mass media, digital and social media
A robust proprietary IT architecture that facilitates CRM, Loyalty and Referral Marketing
State-of-the-art technology – often exclusive to Kaya in India
Products- Manufacturing, distribution and retail of proprietary range of products
Through industry convergence, Kaya Skin Clinic developed an innovative business model in the
Indian Wellness Industry in the skin care market for women in such a way that going to a Kaya Skin
Clinic is a fashion as it has created a lifestyle statement. The business model of the company
comprises of offering skin care solutions to its customers who are largely financially independent
women capable of taking decisions and focussed on the „self‟. The service revenue includes packaged
services for which the consideration is collected upfront towards services to be availed by the
customers over a period of time ensuring a long term service agreement and commitment. These
advances are non-refundable and hence are designed to constitute revenue at some point of time in the
future. With strategic parenting from Marico, the company is in a position to sustain its advantage as
the pioneer in this field.
Sustainability of their advantage, despite of negative financial performance till date, can be attributed
to the corporate parenting available with the firm in the form of Marico Ltd. Now that the company
has been spun off as a separate entity, it remains to be seen whether the restructured company with
ideally an entrepreneurial approach can sustain financially become self-sustainable.
There is further scope for research to gauge whether a pure-play new entrant through industry
convergence can come up with a sustainable innovation which can create and change lifestyle trends
of consumers around in India and around the world.