Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bernie M Bissett PhD, Jiali Wang MSc, Teresa Neeman PhD, I Anne Leditschke
MBBS, Robert Boots PhD & Jennifer Paratz PhD
To cite this article: Bernie M Bissett PhD, Jiali Wang MSc, Teresa Neeman PhD, I Anne
Leditschke MBBS, Robert Boots PhD & Jennifer Paratz PhD (2019): Which ICU patients benefit
most from inspiratory muscle training? Retrospective analysis of a randomized trial, Physiotherapy
Theory and Practice, DOI: 10.1080/09593985.2019.1571144
Article views: 3
Which ICU patients benefit most from inspiratory muscle training? Retrospective
analysis of a randomized trial
Bernie M Bissett PhDa,b, Jiali Wang MScc, Teresa Neeman PhDc, I Anne Leditschke MBBSd,e, Robert Boots PhDf,g,
and Jennifer Paratz PhDf,g,h
a
Discipline of Physiotherapy, University of Canberra, Canberra, Australia; bPhysiotherapy Department, Canberra Hospital, Canberra, Australia;
c
Statistical Consulting Unit, Australian National University, Canberra, Australia; dIntensive Care Unit, Mater Hospital, Brisbane, Australia;
e
Mater Research Institute, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia; fIntensive Care Unit, Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital, Brisbane,
Australia; gSchool of Medicine, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia; hSchool of Health Sciences, Griffith University, Gold Coast,
Australia
CONTACT Bernie Bissett Bernie.Bissett@canberra.edu.au Discipline of Physiotherapy, University of Canberra, Bruce, A.C.T. 2617, Australia
Color versions of one or more of the figures in the article can be found online at www.tandfonline.com/iptp.
© 2019 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
2 B. M. BISSETT ET AL.
ventilator-dependent phase (e.g., due to sedation or delir- conducted using a threshold device with a training range of
ium). Thus, IMT may not be feasible for many patients until 9–41 cmH2O. Intensity was increased daily such that the
they are weaned from mechanical ventilation. patient could just complete the sixth breath in each set.
In 2016, we published the first randomized trial of IMT Where necessary, the IMT device was connected to the
in ICU patients in the postweaning phase of recovery patient’s tracheostomy if this was still in situ, using
(Bissett et al, 2016b). This study demonstrated that, in a connector (Figure 1), and training performed with the
patients who had been invasively ventilated for 7 days or tracheostomy cuff inflated. Otherwise, training was per-
longer, those who participated in daily IMT for 2 weeks formed through a mouthpiece with a noseclip in situ. IMT
following successful weaning increased their inspiratory was commenced in ICU and continued into the ward for
muscle strength (mean difference 11% of predicted max- 2 weeks. Both groups continued to receive usual physiother-
imum inspiratory pressure (MIP). Furthermore, those who apy interventions (including mobilization, airway clearance
trained their inspiratory muscles had greater improvements techniques, and exercise).
in quality of life scores (mean difference 12% on the EQ5D
scale). However, our primary analysis grouped all respon-
ders together and given the heterogeneity of the response to Outcomes
training, we sought to further scrutinize the data to gain
Primary outcome
some insights into which patients are most likely to benefit
For the purpose of this secondary analysis, we created
from IMT in the postweaning period, in order to guide
a new primary measure of change in maximum inspira-
physiotherapists in prioritizing and optimizing treatment
tory pressure (ΔMIP), where ΔMIP equals the difference
for ICU survivors. Thus, in patients who have been recently
between MIP measured at the end of the study and MIP
weaned from invasive mechanical ventilation of 7 days’
on enrolment (where MIP is expressed as a % of predicted
duration or longer, the research questions we sought to
values). MIP was measured by research nurses, blinded to
answer were (1) Which patients are likely to benefit most
group allocation, using a standardized protocol recom-
from IMT in terms of change in inspiratory muscle
mended in the American Thoracic Society/European
strength? and (2) Can any factors measured at the point of
Respiratory Society guidelines (ATS, 2002). MIP was
ventilatory weaning (within 48 h) predict improvements in
measured using a handheld respiratory pressure meter
inspiratory strength with 2 weeks of daily IMT?
Intervention
The IMT protocol has been described previously in detail
(Bissett, Leditschke, Paratz, and Boots, 2012; Bissett et al,
2016b). A physiotherapist supervised five sets of six breaths Figure 1. Attachment of IMT device to tracheostomy via
at an intensity which was at least 50% of MIP. IMT was connector.
PHYSIOTHERAPY THEORY AND PRACTICE 3
which has excellent reliability in non-ventilated partici- patients in the both treatment and control groups was
pants(Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC) 0.83–0.90) 59 years, with 71% male in the treatment group and
(Dimitriadis et al., 2011). 58% male in the control group. Mean APACHE II
scores were 20 and 23, respectively. Sepsis and multi-
Secondary outcomes (factors) trauma were the most common diagnoses, and mean
Measures available at baseline (prior to group alloca- duration of mechanical ventilation was 11 days in the
tion) were treated as factors in this analysis. Baseline treatment group and 10 days in the control group. In
MIP was measured as described above in cmH2 the treatment group, compliance with the intervention
O. Quality of life was measured by research nurses was 85% and no adverse effects were reported during or
using the EQ5D-3L tool (under license EuroQol immediately after the training.
International) which has been used in other studies of
ICU survivors (Granja, Teixeira-Pinto, and Costa-
Analysis of factors associated with changes in
Pereira, 2002). Physical function was calculated by the
inspiratory muscle strength
treating physiotherapist using the Acute Care Index of
Function (ACIF) tool (Roach and Van Dillen, 1988; The results of the regression analysis are presented in
Van Dillen and Roach, 1988), whereby a score of 1.00 Table 1. Treatment group was a significant factor for
indicates completely independent physical function, ΔMIP (p = 0.006). In the treatment group, baseline MIP
and a score of 0.00 represents a patient who requires was significantly associated with ΔMIP, and this was
complete assistance even to roll over in bed. The ACIF different from the control group (p = 0.025). In the
tool has excellent inter-rater reliability and validity in treatment group, positive ΔMIP scores were most com-
ICU patients (Bissett et al., 2016a). monly observed where baseline MIP was greater than
28 cmH2O (Figure 2). Similarly, in the treatment group,
baseline EQ5D scores were associated with positive
Data analysis ΔMIP scores, which was significantly different from
The dependent variable was defined as ΔMIP (MIP the control group (p = 0.029). For EQ5D scores, the
completion − MIP enrolment.). Linear regression mod- most positive ΔMIP scores occurred in patients whose
els were used to assess which factors at baseline were baseline EQ5D scores were 40 or higher (Figure 3).
significantly associated with ΔMIP scores. Factors The relationship between baseline MIP and EQ5D
included age, sex, disease severity (APACHE II), base- scores and ΔMIP is further described in Table 2. For
line functional score (ACIF), baseline quality of life example, a patient with a baseline MIP of 19 cmH2
score (EQ5D), and treatment group (IMT group or O who completed 2 weeks of IMT typically increased
control). Interaction terms were also included in the MIP by only 8% (noting 95% confidence interval [CI]
model (treatment group × APACHE II, treatment −1, 18), which is not different from a patient who
group × baseline MIP, treatment group × baseline
ACIF, treatment group × baseline EQ5D) to test the Table 1. Regression analysis for ΔMIP in patients undergoing
differences of the associations between the secondary inspiratory muscle training (treatment) or usual care following
outcomes and ΔMIP in the treatment group and con- ventilatory weaning.
trol group. Two-sided tests were considered statistically Regression analysis
significant where p < 0.05. Statistical analyses were Coefficient (95% confidence
Factor interval) p-Value
conducted using Statistical Packaging for the Social Age 0.000 (−0.003, 0.003) 0.819
Sciences (SPSS 23, IBM Corporation, NY, USA) and Sex (female) −0.041 (−0.134, 0.053) 0.391
Treatment group −0.543 (−0.931, −0.155) 0.006**
R Statistical Package (R Foundation for Statistical Disease severity (APACHE II) 0.000 (−.007, 0.007) 0.909
Computing, Vienna, Austria)(version 3.0.2). Baseline MIP score −.001 (−0.005, 0.003) 0.542
Baseline ACIF score −0.291 (−0.587, 0.004) 0.053
Baseline EQ5D score 0.000 (−0.002, 0.003) 0.855
APACHE II × treatment 0.005 (−0.005, 0.016) 0.327
Results group
Baseline MIP × treatment 0.006 (0.001, 0.010) 0.025*
Participant characteristics group
Baseline ACIF × treatment 0.407 (−0.066, 0.881) 0.091
group
The participant characteristics and flow of participants Baseline EQ5D × treatment 0.004 (0.000, 0.008) 0.029*
have been published previously (Bissett et al., 2016b). group
Thirty-four patients were allocated to the treatment MIP = maximum inspiratory pressure; APACHE = Acute Physiology and
Chronic Health Evaluation tool; EQ5D = quality of life tool;
group and 36 to the control group, with a loss to ACIF = Acute Care Index of Function.
follow-up of six in each group. The mean age of *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001.
4 B. M. BISSETT ET AL.
Figure 2. Changes in inspiratory muscle strength (ΔMIP) rela- Figure 4. Changes in inspiratory muscle strength (ΔMIP) rela-
tive to baseline inspiratory muscle strength (MIP) scores, com- tive to baseline physical function (ACIF) scores, comparing
paring treatment (IMT) and control groups. treatment (IMT) and control groups.
weakness), and the patient’s quality of life and will- This study is the first to identify which patients may
ingness to participate in training, which is far more benefit most from threshold-based IMT in the postwean-
likely to predict success with IMT. Although arguably ing period. Patients with at least moderate inspiratory
difficult to quantify, this interaction would be valuable muscle strength, and moderate to high quality of life
to examine in future studies. scores at the point of ventilatory weaning, are likely to
An important limitation of this analysis is that the achieve significant gains in inspiratory muscle strength
IMT device used in this study had a limited training with 2 weeks of daily supervised IMT. Threshold-based
range. Patients who failed to improve their ΔMIP IMT is less likely to produce large gains within 2 weeks in
scores at the lowest end of the spectrum may have patients with inspiratory muscle strength less than
struggled to open the valve of the device at its lowest 28 cmH2O (MIP) or quality of life scores below 40
setting (9 cmH2O) as this would have been well in (EQ5D). Alternative approaches may be better for these
excess of 50% of their MIP. Thus, the spring-loaded subgroups, and this deserves further exploration.
training device is not ideal for patients at the lowest end
of the inspiratory strength spectrum. Future studies
should explore whether electronic inspiratory muscle Conclusions
trainers (Tonella et al., 2017) (capable of training at
In patients recently weaned from prolonged mechanical
1 cmH2O) may provide more optimal training for the
ventilation, 2 weeks of daily IMT is likely to produce
weakest ICU patients in the postweaning period, and
greatest strength benefits in patients with moderate
particularly with respect to the magnitude of changes in
inspiratory muscle strength (>28 cmH2O) and moder-
MIP observed in the first 2 weeks. Furthermore, this
ate to high quality of life (EQ5D > 40). Physiotherapists
study has only focused on the first 2 weeks following
should target these patients as ideal candidates for IMT
ventilatory weaning. This analysis may underestimate
in the postweaning rehabilitation period.
the benefits of IMT in the longer term, and a more
realistic training regime (e.g., 6 weeks or longer) should
be explored to better guide clinicians about ideal train-
Acknowledgments
ing methods.
To apply our findings in practice, clinicians need to The authors wish to gratefully acknowledge the Canberra
be aware of patients’ inspiratory muscle strength imme- Hospital Private Practice and Auxiliary Research Funds for
diately following ventilatory weaning; however, mea- making this research possible, as well as the staff of the Acute
Support Physiotherapy Department for their assistance with
surement of MIP is not yet standard practice. One the intervention.
barrier to MIP measurement may be the availability of
a respiratory pressure meter. However, new electronic
inspiratory muscle trainers provide MIP measurement Conflict of interest
as a feature, and this has been shown to be a reliable
method of measuring MIP in patients with acute stroke The authors state that there is no conflict of interest.
(Lee, Kim, Jeong, and Lee, 2016). Adoption of this
technology in the ICU may reduce barriers to identifi-
cation and training of suitable patients for IMT. Ethics approval
Our findings suggest that quantification of patients’ This study was approved by the Australian Capital Territory
quality of life scores at the point of successful ventilatory Health Human Research Ethics Committee (ETH.10.10.370)
weaning may be important in planning their rehabilita- and the University of Queensland Medical Research Ethics
Committee (2010001488).
tion. To our knowledge, quality of life scores are not
routinely measured in many ICUs outside of a research
environment. Compared to other quality of life tools we
have used in ICU research, the EQ5D tool has the Funding
advantage that it is fast and feasible to administer. As We gratefully acknowledge the Canberra Hospital Private
all quality of life tools are proprietary in nature, we Practice Fund and the Canberra Hospital Auxiliary
acknowledge the challenges of translation into practice Research Fund.
in financially constrained health-care environments.
However, where feasible, we recommend that quality of
life measures should be incorporated into the routine Prior presentation
care of ICU patients, particularly those who have experi- Australia New Zealand Intensive Care Society Scientific
enced prolonged mechanical ventilation. Meeting, Gold Coast, Australia, October 2017.
6 B. M. BISSETT ET AL.