Arthur Butterworth
Arthur Butterworth was born in New Moston,
Manchester, on 4th August 1923. From 1947 to 1949
he studied composition with Richard Hall at the Royal
Manchester College of Music, where he also received
‘trumpet and conducting lessons. Disillusioned with lack
of opportunities for orchestral playing at the RMCM,
he left college a year early to begin his professional
career as a trumpet player with the Scottish National
Orchestra in 1949. In 1955, he joined the Hallé Orchestra
as trumpeter under Sir John Barbirolli, a post he
relinquished 1962. In that year he was appointed
associate conductor of the Huddersfield Philharmonic
Society; where from 1964 to 1993, he was their
permanent conductor. He has guest conducted many
other orchestras, especially the BBC Northern
‘Symphony; the BBC Scottish and the BBC Concert
Orchestras, with whom he has performed several of his
own compositions.
Early works, including the Romanza for hom and
‘orchestra of 1954 (CBC Records SMCD 5186), were
heavily influenced by Ralph Vaughan Williams. ‘The
first symphony (1957) was the culmination of
Butierworth's previous creative output and the work
which put his name on the musical map, (Classico
CLASSCD 274), Premiered by Barbirolliand the Hallé
at the 1957 Cheltenham Festival, this vibrant depiction
of the far north west of Scotland, finds the composer at
his most instantly communicative. Since then he has
written many other large-scale orchestral compositions,
including three more symphonies (1965, 1979 and 1986)
and concertos for bassoon, organ, violin, viola, cello,
guitar and trumpet. Of these, the very fine Viola
Concerto of 1983 is his most personal statement, whilst
the sultry and hugely enjoyable Guitar Concerto (2000),
has a Hispanic flavour which is unusual from this,
composer. The impressive Piano Trio (1983), written
at the behest of Sir John Manduell, marked a new
departure: he had previously writen few chamber
works, preferring to express himself witha full orchestral
palette, Of his vocal output, the Moorland Symphony
(1967) and Haworth Moor for chorus and piano
accompaniment (2000) are two highly representative
works.
Some of his most successful pieces in any genre were
written for brass band, including Three Impressions
(1968), which has received performances throughout
the world. Other significant works include Odin, a
brilliant symphony for brass commissioned by Black
Dyke in 1986, Caliban, a scherzo malevolo written for
the Brighouse and Rastrick Band (1978) and a work
recently composed for the Black Dyke Band, the
nostalgic Sinfonia Concertante (2001). These idiomatic
compositions all benefit from the experienced ear of an
accomplished trumpet player whilst reflecting the
composer's two main influences: Sibelius and the highh
moorlands of northern England. These twin inspirations
licbehind his most characteristic works such as A Dales
Suite (1965) and his most popular orchestral piece, The
Path Across the Moors (1959), a delicately evocative
miniature fone poem he later arranged for brass band
(ASV CD WHL 2126). Compositions such as these
share with so many of Arthur Butterworth’s hundred
plus opus numbers an utterly authentic and distinctive
voice.
Paul ConwayNicholas J. Childs MA, FLCM, ARCM (Hons)
Principal Conductor and Director Music
From the age of eight - when Nicholas started his
musical career on euphonium with Tredegar Junior
Band - to the present day, it is fair to say that he has
been ‘upwardly mobile’. Benefiting from the expert
guidance and tuition given to him by his gifted father,
John and the early example set by his elder brother
Robert, Nicholas quickly made his mark as one of the
world's finest brass instrumentalists
‘This sublime level of excellence manifested itself in a
variety of ways: as Champion Euphonium Player of
Great Britain, Welsh National Solo Champion; the first
cuphonium player to win the Champion of Cham
award; the 1986 Euphonium Player of the Year. Asa
soloist he has performed to great critical acclaim all
around the world and as.a member of the sensational,
Childs Brothers duo, Nicholas has played Euphonium
and Tenor Tuba on many occasions with The BBC
Philharmonic and Hallé Orchestras, under Yan Pascal
‘Tortelier and Kent Nagano.
in great demand as an educator and for many
“years was Professor of Euphonium atthe Royal Norther
College of Music, University of Salford and Tutor for
the National Youth Brass Band of Great Britain, Wales
and Switzerland. He gained a Fellowship from the
London College of Music; is an Associate of the Royal
College of Music; and hasa Master of Arts degree where
he majored in Conducting, Nicholas was also Music
Director of the National Youth Brass Band of Denmark,
and in the year 2000 has accepted a new appointment as
Associate Conductor with Elgar Howarth and the
National Youth Brass Band of Great Britain.
‘The skill and musical understanding gleaned from his
international solo career have been harnessed in his,
exceptionally successful conducting career, winning the
‘Welsh, French, Norwegian and the 1999 National Brass
Band Championships of Great Britain.
In July, 2000 Nicholas accepted the position of Principal
Conductorand Music Director of the world famous Black
Dyke Band. He is regarded as one of the finest
conductors in the band world today, His musical talent
is evident in the quality of performances that he
conduets, bringing to the forefront inspirational
‘musical aspects. Prior to joining Black Dyke Nicholas
was Principal Conductor of The Fodens Band. The
insight Nicholas has always exhibited in his musical
endeavours have also found an outlet in his
entrepreneurial activities. He has elevated Doyen
Recordings Lid. to a pre-eminent position in the world
of Brass and Wind Band Recordings, and is in great
demand as a producer for the BBC and other leading
recording labels,Black Dyke Band (1855)
In 1816 a brass and reed band was founded by Peter
Wharton in Queenshead, Yorkshire - later to become
Queensbury. John Foster, founder of Black Dyke Mills,
played French Horn in this band, The band went out of
existence through loss of members and in 1833 a new
band ~ "Queenshead Band" - was formed. On 15th
September 1855 the Halifax courier recorded
"Qucenshead Band formed carly in the century by
residents came into difficulties. John Foster & Son, having
lately become acquainted with the depressed state of the
band determined to make an effort themselves to raise it
up again, Accordingly they have purchased from that
eminent maker, Mr Joseph Higharn of Manchester, anew
set of instruments which have this week been delivered
to the band, which in future is to be denominated Black
Dyke Mills Band. A new and talented leaderas well as
several performers, have been added to the band which
now comprises 18 musicians. Messts. Fosters have
provided forthema comfortable room in which they will
‘meet for practising”
Thus the Black Dyke Band was formed . Most of its
musicians both lived in Queensbury and worked at the
mill, soaclose link between the band and the communit
was formed which remains to this day. ‘The Band has.
always been at the forefront of Brass Band activity.
making one of the earliest recordings in 1904 and
‘embarking on a five month tourot Canada and the United
States in 1906, Since then the band has toured in many
countries, including Germany, Austra, Italy, Switzerland,
Russia, Belgium, Sierra Leone, Spain, Australia, Japan,
Denmurk, Sweden and Nosthern Ireland,
The Band has made over 50 recordings. In 1996 they
‘won The Music Industries Association Award forthe Best
CD in the Orchestral category. In. 1999 the allburn that
4
the Band recorded with Evelyn Glennie was nominated
in the ‘Crossover Classical Section’ for a Grammy
Award, and there was an Oscar nomination for the best
song in a film (That'll Do, from Babe 2) with vocalist
Peter Gabriel and backing by Black Dyke. The band
provide the background music to the popular UK
television programme ‘Ground Force!
Jn addition to touring and recording, the musical life
of the band has included television shows, films,
broadcasts, concerts at Music festvals, Universities, The
Proms, Fanfare into Europe and Songs of Praise,
covering the whole musical spectrum and appearing
with Leskey Garret, Elton John, Evelyn Glennie, James
Mortison, Phil Smith and many more. In 1993 Black
Dyke Band was the first British Brass band to perform
a the Camegie Hall, New York and in 1994 the first to
perform at the Royal College of Music
Over the years the Black Dyke Band has produced
and abundance of famous instrumentalists. Jack
Pinches, Solo Trombone, became Principal Trombone
inthe BBC Symphony Orchestra. Two former Principal
Comets, William Lang and Maurice Murphy.achieved
the position of Principal Trumpet at the London
Symphony Orchestra. A former Comet player, Rod
Franks, is also Principal Trumpet with the London
Symphony Orchestra, Conductors of the Band have
included Alexander Owen, John Gladney, Arthur
O.Pearee, Harry Mortimer, Alex Mortimer, Major
George Wilcocks, Major Peter Parkes and James
Watson.
‘The Band was awarded the Honorary Freedom of the
City of Bradford in 1976 in recognition of itscontinucd
success, services fo music in general and the region in
particular, In 1997 the band was very proud to become
Brass Band in Residence at The Royal Academy ofMusic, London, The band Jogo of the stag's head and
Latin quotation are taken from the armorial bearings,
granted in 1857 to John Foster, founder of the band.
Programme Notes
‘Three Impressions For Brass Op 36
Scenes from Nineteenth-Century
Northumberland
‘Commissioned by the Mid-Northumberland Arts Group
with funds provided by the Northem Arts Association
and first performed at the Morpeth Arts Festival by the
Northumberland County Youth Band, conducted by
Kenneth May.
‘The Brass Band movement grew up alongside the
Industrial Revolution and thus became one of the
significant cultural manifestations of that age. This
impressionistic work For brass band is intended to
convey something of the spirit of that heroic era, the
three movements presenting contrasting pictures of the
impact made by the new iron-age on the rural seene of
Northumberland in the mid-1800's.
I. "Wylam Colfiery” was suggested by one of Hairs
1816 sketches of coal-mines evoking a darkened
landscape with ceaseless ereakings of crude machinery
amidst the smoke and steam of coal wagons hauled by
"Puffing Billy”,
IL. "Deserted Farm" (1840) portrays a derelict small-
holding, forlorn and decayed, encroached on all
sides by new colliery workings, quarries and
railways, the former pastoral landscape now scarred
by industrial turmoil
Til. "The Royal Border Bridge, Berwick-on-Tweed"
(1850).Buill by George Stephenson, the bridge at
Berwick-on-Tweed became one of the greatest
symbols of railway-engineering, as an apotheosis of
more than a century of continual motion, One is
conscious of the rhythm and energy of trains toiling
over the years, pulling coal and iron, steel and stone,
men and mail. through the bitter snows of winter
nights, windy March days, hot summer afternoons,
or misty September evenings - of flame, smoke, heat
and cold in the clear, dark northern skies.
Passacaglia for Brass Op.87
on a theme of Brahms
‘The Passacaglia is a musical form almost
indistinguishable from the chaconne, or old English
“chacony’. It was originally a dance in triple time and
usually of stately nature. It is invariably built upon a
ground bass which in itself is a musical term by which
the form is sometimes known. The ground bass consists
of a repeated phrase, generally eight bars long. ‘The
repetition of this theme provides a firm and rigid
framework on which the whole piece is constructed. The
‘main intention is that the ground bass itself acts asa bass
line to the harmony but for variety it is sometimes
transferred to the upper mefodic parts at various points
during the course of the movement. The basic harmony
is still retained in outine providing a logical thread or
unity throughout, Older examples of the passacagliat or
chaconne usually followed this plan quite strictly. There
‘are many well-known, indeed fine specimens: Purcell
air "When 1am laid in earth" (trom Dido and Aeneas),
Bach's famous Chaconne for Violin alone—a tour-force
in musical construction as well as purely violin technique
~and the great and solemn Passacaglia in C minor for
organ amongst many others,form the passacaglia adopted a more serious
character particularly appropriate to the organ and
church music in general, it's stately progress
lending an air of dignity and poise.
Bach's church cantana no. 150, "Nach Dir, Herr.
verlangt mich” (For Thee, Lord, do I yearn)
contains a passacaglia of striking power and effect.
Brahms must have been drawn to this theme- he
was after all intensely devoted to Bach's music so
much so that he conceived the idea of using Bach's
original as the basis for a passacaglia of his own.
What is surprising is that Brahms chose to use the
notion of introducing a passacaglia into a most
unusual situation: as the last movement of a
symphony. Now, symphonic form has its own
traditions and forms of classical usage, but the
ground bass or passacaglia is not one of them so
itmust have caused some interest to observe how
aglia could be turned to good effect -all
those repetitions- in a long drawn-out symphonic
movement composed in the latter part of the
nineteenth century using the full resouces of a
large modern orchestra. This highly original idea
resulted in one of the finest of all symphonic
movements which Brahms, or indeed any other
composer was able to conceive. It forms the finale
of the Fourth Symphony in E minor, and its opening
on the full wind band of the orchestra, the strings
being silent, is especially notable for the first
appearance in the work of the trombones. Brahms
withholds the trombones until this moment, their
previous silence making the effect of this delayed
entry all the more striking. The first performance
took place in 1886, Bulterworth's Passacaglia for
Brass, however, is not a copy of Brahms's own
theme, but merely inverts it and extends the idea of
the Bach/Brahms chorale. Only towards the end is
Brahms's powerful original quoted in full and shown
how it relates to this recreation of it for bras
Sinfonia Concertante Op.111
1- Pastorale Il - Scherzo
IIL - Night Music IV - Rondo Alla Caccia
Tenor Horn Soloist Lesley Howie
Baritone Soloist Robert Blackburn
Of the multifarious wind instruments invented by
Adolphe Sax, the ubiquitous saxophone is the most
familiar, However, the brass band owes its existence
to a whole family of brass instruments devised and
elaborated by Sax: the cornet, flugel, tenor horn,
baritone, euphonium and tuba: only the trombone
originated from earlier times. Most of these saxhorns
have at one time or other found a place in wind bands
and even oceasionally as additional brass in the ranks of
the orchestra. Two of this family of homs however, have
become almost exclusively associated with the brass band,
and have rarely been utilised in other kinds of wind bands;
the tenor hom, pitched in the key of E-flatand the baritone
in B-flat. Consequently these two ‘middle of the band’
instruments, unlike the comet or euphonium, have often
tended to be overlooked as solo instruments.
This symphonic piece invest both hom and baritone with
a concertante réle that takes account of their particular
characteristics and timbres.
Although only the first movement is specifically described
as'pastorale' this establishes the nature of the whole work,
which is imbued with an archaic modal flavour faintly
suggestive of ancient rustic rites. In visual terms perhaps
to be compared with one of those scenes found in 17thcentury Dutch painting where simple rural lifeis evoked,
peasantsand country folk depicted inan allegorical
way, where there lurks a deeper meaning below the
innocent surface. The calm and innocent aspect of the
countryside hides unsuspected hazards, particularly to
nature's more gentle creatures, and especially after
darkness falls, when predators relentlessly pursure their
timid quarry.
In purely musical terms the two solo instruments might
be said to be pursued by the hue and cry of the full
band.
Johannes Brahms (1833-1897)
Variations & Fugue
ona theme of Handel, Op. 24
During the middle of the nineteenth century there
had been a revival of interest in music from the
baroque period; works by Bach and Handel
appeared more and more frequently in concert
programmes. Brahms was thoroughly in keeping
with the spirit of the time; his preoccupation with
the music of Bach was paralleled by an equal
interest in that of Handel.
The theme comes from the "Pieces pour le
clavecin” of Handel's Complete Edition. However
these Variation blend the baroque spirit with the
tonal language of nineteenth century romanticism.
Throughout his life Brahms had been fascinated
and challenged by the idea of variation, and these
Handel variations have since established
themselves as one of the great works in the piano
repertoire. They represent an immense challenge
{o pianists; technical, intellectual, emotional and
interpretative.
The original theme is a simple two-part, eight bar
aria which suggests a baroque trumpet tune,
which is profusely ornamented over the simplest
harmonic bass structure. Brahms took only the aria,
ignoring Handel's original five variations, replacing
them with twenty-five variations and concluding
fugue of his own, They tend to fall into groups
which suggests an underlying symphonic design
in the way they relate to each other; later ones
appearing to grow out of the texture of the preceding
ones regarding rhythm, melodie motif and general
character,
‘They were composed in 1861 as a birthday gift to
his beloved friend, Clara Schumann, but not being
finished in time for her birthday on 13th September,
she gave the first performance 7th December of that
year,
‘This transcription was first suggested by a mere
fragment of Variation 5 that had been used as an
tration of brass band scoring in Denis Wright's
“Scoring for Brass Band" published in 1935, but
it was not until the early 1970's when Butterworth
conducted several radio performaces of the
orchestral version made by Edmund Rubbra in
1938, that the notion of scoring it for brass band
began seriously to be considered. To make it a
practical proposition for brass band performace
regarding duration; the original variations 15 to
18 and a passage in the fugue have been omitted.
A radio talk by Rubbra en-titled ‘Re-creative
‘Orcheatration’ explained the thinking behind the
art of transcription, implying that the challenging,
indeed heroic, nature if the virtuoso piano writing
needs to find a counterpart in any such new
version in order to preserve the strong impact and
sense of musical purpose.“Composer's View"
Berlioz is reputed to have rarely been satisfied with other conductors’ interpretations of his music, preferring
always himself to be on the rostrum in charge of performances. There have been many distinguished composer/
Mendelssohn, Richard Strauss and Elgar come to mind. [also like to conduct my own music and
often do so; but the composer cannot do other than take an objective view of his music, whereas what is often
preferable is the objective interpretation achieved by a conductor who takes a wider perspective of the compos-
er’s creation. Nicholas Childs’ account of these works demonstrate the validity of this more objective view, and.
Tam captivated by the manner in which he has so intuitively sensed the nature of the music’s intention, resulting
in these magnificent and truly stunning performances.
Arthur Butterworth MBE
October 2001
DOYEN
Producers Paul Hindmarsh and Alison Childs
Sound Engineer Harold Barnes and Richard Scott Recorded at Morley Town Hall, during 2001
Digital Editing & Mastering R.E. Editing Layout & Typesetting D. R. Graphics
Front Cover Design Simion Baxter-Cox
For further information on the music of Arthur Butterworth please contact Michael Dennison at:
Comus Edition
Heirs House Lane, Colne, Lancashire
BB8 9TA England
www.comusedition.com
WARNING: Copyright subsists in all recordings issued under this label. Any unauthorised broadcasting, public performance,
copying or re-recording in any manner whatsoever will constitute infringement of such copyright.
Application for public performance licences should be addressed to Phonographic Performances Ltd.
Granton House, 14-22 Granton Street, London. WIV ILB Tel: 0207 437 0311.
DOY CD 130ACK DYKE BAND
BON TNICtOr
mciolas J. Childs) &EN Featuring the Music oj ea
ARTHUR BUTTERWORTH Die Dies)
1.-3. Three Impressions for Brass Op.36 Premiére Recording Arthur Butterworth 11.00
1. Wylam Colliery (1836) 4.30
as Deserted Farm (1840) 3.56
Se The Royal Border Bridge, Berwick-on-Tweed (1850) 3.52
z EMI Music
B 4. Passacaglia on a Theme of Brahis Op. 87 Premiére Recording Arthur Butterworth 11.55
z Comus Edition
3 5.-7._ Sinfonia Concertante Op. 111 Premiére Recording Arthur Butterworth 15.55
e ss 1 Pastorale 44]
2 6. II Scherzo 3.29
Ez Fe III Night Music IV - Rondo Alla Caccia 7.42
Tenor Horn Soloist Lesley Howie Baritone Soloist Robert Blackburn
Comus Edition
8. Variations & Fugue Premiére Recording Johannes Brahms 21.05
On a Theme of Handel Op. 24 Trans. Arthur Butterworth
Comus Edition
Total Playing Time 61.13
DOYCD130 Arthur
BLACK DYKE BAND
Doyen Recordings would like to acknowledge the
support and help of Arthur Butterworth who was
resent throughout the making of this recording.