Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/215626211
CITATIONS READS
4 3,743
1 author:
Saleem Mir
University of Delhi
2 PUBLICATIONS 4 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Saleem Mir on 27 June 2022.
(GDP) and foreign exchange, and its rising trend, make this an indus-
try of vital importance. It can lead to the development of backward
areas without altering much of their ecology. Still, much emphasis is
not given to the field of tourism geography as only a few departments
offer courses on geography of tourism despite its job potential and
interdisciplinary nature.
The purpose of this chapter is to explore the trends and focus areas
of the research in geography of tourism in India. But, before examin-
ing the recent trends, it is necessary to have a brief look at the earlier
focus areas. The available literature shows that various aspects of
tourism have been addressed. Hill and mountain tourism has been an
important aspect of research for Indian geographers since its develop-
ment as a distinct field of academy. Comparative studies of different
hill resorts have been carried out by Negi (2002) and Pradhan (2000).
Impacts and prospects of tourism development in mountainous areas
have been focused upon by Arora (1998), Chander (1995), Mandal
(1989), Negi (1996), and Sattar (1997). Cultural and ethnic implica-
tions of tourism flow to isolated mountain regions are discussed by
Singh and Kaur (1985), and further prospects of developing ethnic
and folk traditions have been investigated by Kaur (1982). Singh
(1982) has brought forth the significance of sacred sites in Garhwal
Himalayas, while Joshi and Pant (1990) have analysed the implica-
tions of recent tourism development in Nainital, an important tour-
ist spot situated in the Himalayas. Grewal (1994) has examined the
sustainability of western Himalayas for international tourism devel-
opment. Lamichhane and Singh (2002) have examined the aspect of
sustainable management of tourism in Pokhara, Nepal. Sukumar et al.
(1996) have done an extensive study on the problems and prospects of
tourism in Kanniyakumari, Tamil Nadu.
Impact of tourism on social, environmental, and cultural aspects
has been studied by Kaur (2001), Misra (1999), Motiram (2002), Ram
(1996), Sewak (1996), and Verma (1995). Environmental degrada-
tion due to tourism development and the remedies are discussed by
Chakraborty (1999). Economic aspects of tourism development have
been emphasized by Mandal (1992), Rajak (2002), and Sood (1990).
Other arenas explored by geographers are coastal tourism (Kumar
1992), desert tourism (Gaur 2002), ecotourism (Sangeeta 1997), and
problems and prospects of international marine tourism (Jreat 1994).
44 URBANIZATION, INDUSTRY, AND DEVELOPMENT
So, it is obvious from this brief literature review that the research in
tourism geography in India has been more inclined towards the envi-
ronmental aspects. However, some works have emerged in otherwise
less-known fields, like marine and desert tourism.
The available literature from 2003 to 2009 is reviewed to look into
the emerging avenues of research in tourism geography. The review
covers largely published work. Although a wide range of material has
been used, but the limitations of availability or unintentional neglect
on my part restrains me from calling it an exhaustive study. I hope
the references and the research cited here are representative of the
main trends in the field and provide an insight to the geographers for
furthering their interest in the field.
Tourism is an interdisciplinary subject and it is very difficult to
place much of the research outputs under a specific discipline because
of their cross-cutting areas of interest. However, some major trends
are noticeable and can be classified under the following heads:
• globalization and tourism;
• trends of tourism;
• economic aspects;
• impact of tourism on environment and society;
• sustainable tourism development; and
• infrastructure and hospitality.
growth falls below 2 per cent, tourism growth tends to be even lower.
But this is not the case when correlation is run between tourist arrivals
to the states in India and their per capita net state domestic product,
meaning thereby that it is not the economy of the whole state that
lures the tourists to visit it but the availability of the tourism product
and the accessibility to it. The countries having per capita GDP more
than that of India contributed more than 80 per cent of total interna-
tional tourists that visited India in 2004. Out of this, more than 65 per
cent was shared by those countries having per capita GDP more than
US$ 10,000. Countries with per capita GDP less than that of India
shared just about 20 per cent of all international tourists to India. If we
exclude Bangladesh from the list, then the share of countries having
per capita GDP less than that of India comes down to a mere 6 per
cent (Mir 2008).
Raina and Jain (2004) have argued that tourism remains a First
World phenomenon despite its extraordinary growth, as 90 per cent of
the world travel market lies in developed countries. They have further
concluded that tourism flows extensively from one developed coun-
try to another. Tourism is perceived as a renewable resource and its
growth is associated with the revolution of transport and communica-
tion, which has been possible only due to technological revolution.
As a country gets richer, people normally work less hours and
enjoy greater leisure time, and as the people acquire more dispos-
able income, the demand for travel and tourism grows exponentially.
In fact, travel is the first priority of an income earner after the basic
requirements of home, food, and essentials (Ranga 2003).
Pais (2006) has calculated the employment coefficient of tourism
(number of jobs created for a unit of foreign tourist expenditure) in
India and has come to the conclusion that it is declining. However,
due to the overall growth in tourism inflow and the receipts generated,
there has been an increase in total employment generated. Anbalagan
et al. (2005) make the point that the role of technology and communi-
cation has speeded up the tourism industry to serve different sectors,
thereby transforming the society and economy. Apart from monetary
benefits, tourism can help in national integration and international
understanding. Its spread effect is wide and its returns are much
higher than agriculture and manufacturing sectors. Indian tourism
industry is growing fast, but it is losing the Chinese outbound tourism
GEOGRAPHY OF TOURISM IN INDIA 49
problem. Likewise, Joshi and Dhyani (2009) have argued that tourism
in Sikkim is in the developmental stage and projections have shown
a high growth in the near future. This growth is definitely going to
bring with it the ill effects on fragile environment, infrastructure, and
culture of this Himalayan tourist resort. Declining trends of livestock
population, foodgrain output, and change in agricultural pattern are
the price that Sikkim is paying to sustain tourism. Chaudhary (2004)
has also focused on Sikkim while dealing with the development and
utilization of tourism resources, while Thathang (2005) has analysed
the social, economic, and environmental impacts due to the develop-
ment of tourism in the mountainous country of Nepal.
Along the trails of camping sites, informal solid waste dumping
spots have emerged. High erosion-prone Zaskar region is vulnerable
to soil erosion, while Changthang wetlands are prone to underground
water pollution. Wildlife habitats are threatened by fragmentation and
grasslands seem overgrazed in patches. Off-road driving, concentrated
in few regions, has also has a very bad impact on the environment.
Urban development in and around the Leh city, on poorly suitable
lands of riverbanks or hilly areas, is one of the emerging problems that
has come out through a study (Geneletti and Dawa 2009). Problems
arise due to unrestrained arrival of tourists and uncontrolled devel-
opment of facilities beyond the level of tolerance. Effects on natural
environment like fauna and flora, due to pollution, erosion, etc., and
effects on built-up environment, due to architectural aspects, change
of land use, and burden on infrastructure, have been underlined
repeatedly (Bhattacharya and Sankar 2005).
Farooquee et al. (2008) have carried out a study to assess the socio-
cultural and environmental impacts of tourism on the local inhabit-
ants due to camping and white-water rafting on Ganga River. They
have considered tourism as a double-edged activity, with positive
impacts being the increase in income generation, employment, and
infrastructure and improvement in social services. And the negative
repercussions include degradation of environment, decline of water
quality, and land use changes. Nainital, an important hill station,
faces the problems of pollution of the lake, the main attraction for
tourists. Moreover, the open spaces are being occupied by increasing
encroachment of tourism infrastructure and other facilities. Apart
from the environmental problem, the unorganized growth of tourism
GEOGRAPHY OF TOURISM IN INDIA 51
Ecotourism
The focus currently is on how sustainable tourism can be developed,
especially in regions that are remote but have a high potential for
tourism development. There is a need to investigate the region’s devel-
opment potential through ecotourism and review the sustainability of
such development process. Ecotourism is a useful path for destination
development in India (Pechlaner and Reuter 2009).
Sustainability of tourism at currently known resorts is necessary.
Abreu (2008) has dealt with this in the context of increasing tourist
52 URBANIZATION, INDUSTRY, AND DEVELOPMENT
Mountain Tourism
Research in mountain tourism has been carried out by Indian geog-
raphers from a much earlier time (Mitchell and Murphy 1991). Ratti
(2007) has devoted a chapter to the study the geography of tourism in
Himalayas. He has traced the development of tourism in Himalayas
back to the Vedic period. All Hindu religious scriptures are full of
praise of Himalayas. Holy men took journeys to Himalayas and it
turned out to be a heaven of pilgrimage tourism for Hindus, Sikhs,
and Buddhists centuries ago. Then, explorers and mountaineers
started exploring the beauty and might of these huge mountains.
The decade of the 1950s was the golden era of mountaineering in the
Himalayas. Today, many of our holy Hindu pilgrimage sites are in
Himalayas only, like Bedrinath, Kedarnath, Vaishno Devi, Gangotri,
Amaranth cave, Rishikesh, and the like. Besides, there are clusters of
mountain peaks which tourists dream of climbing. Many sanctuaries
and national parks are located there. Rivers, glaciers, natural springs,
and exotic flora and fauna are all attractions for the tourists.
GEOGRAPHY OF TOURISM IN INDIA 53
Singh and Mishra (2004) have dealt with the aspects of cultural and
ethnic changes due to tourism development in mountainous regions,
along with the environmental implications. Human vulnerability and
risks in mountain regions due to tourism development are high. They
argue that these problems should be addressed before any tourism
activity is encouraged in such delicate surroundings. Bhattacharya
and Bhagabati (2005) have tried to identify and assess the potential
sacks of tourism activity in the area of hill districts of Assam. Based
on the criteria of importance, accessibility, seasonality, popularity,
and fragility, tourism potential index is calculated and subsequently,
seven potential pockets are identified for the development of tourism.
Categorization has been done by calculating tourist potentiality index
using both the demand and supply components of these pockets.
Assam has a meagre share in the proportion of tourism as compared
to the country as a whole, and such tourism is confined to Kaziranga
and Guwahati only. Its hill districts are not being promoted, which
leads to the over-utilization of the few known tourism spots there.
Adventure Tourism
Of late, India has also started to offer adventure tourism to inter-
national and domestic tourists. There is great scope for developing
this type of tourism, which the young and enthusiastic tourists have
an inclination for. India has much to offer to adventure tourists, for
example, rock climbing, white-water rafting, skiing, and cycling on
hilly roads. Even tourism ministry has approved some of the adven-
ture tour operators. There were 15 such operators in the country in
2005. Out of these 15 adventure tour operators, 13 were in Delhi only,
with one each in West Bengal and Uttaranchal (Mir 2008). The study
by Kuniyal (2005) shows how visitors, host communities, and gov-
ernment can reduce waste creation and earn income from waste in
various ways. Two case studies representing Himalayas—one for trek-
king (in and around the valley of flowers, 1,830–4,330 metre) and the
other for expeditions (Pindari Valley, 2,300–5,500 metre)—have been
researched in depth. Visitor inflows during the four months’ annual
activity period of both locations ranged from 25,000 in expedition
to 116,392 in trekking areas. Non-biodegradable waste dominated
biodegradable waste at 66.4 per cent for expedition and 85.0 per cent
54 URBANIZATION, INDUSTRY, AND DEVELOPMENT
Wildlife Tourism
Sekhar (2003) has done a commendable work relating to the devel-
opment potential of tourism in protected areas (Sariska Tiger
GEOGRAPHY OF TOURISM IN INDIA 55
Agritourism
Rural or agritourism development has been given emphasis recently
in some destinations in India. There is a high demand to promote
rural tourism because of the tremendous competition that Indian
agriculture is facing due to globalization and uncertain climatic con-
ditions. We need to examine the key issues involved in the develop-
ment of agritourism in India, the challenges faced by this industry,
and suggest recommendations for the success of this industry. To
develop agritourism, a village/agricultural farm should offer a vari-
ety of animals, birds, and local culture to attract tourists. Then, the
tourists should be involved in farm practices and finally, rural crafts,
etc., should be available for tourists to purchase (Gopal et al. 2008;
Husain 2004). This would also promote nature-based accommoda-
tion, instead of investing in hotels. Alternatives of mass tourism are
health and village tourism, sports and games tourism, etc., which
should reduce seasonality of tourism (Chakrabarty 2006; Hans 2008).
price, availability, and location of a holiday spot but also the clients
can take a virtual tour of the hotel they would be staying in and the
rainforest they would be walking in. Improved telecommunications
make it simpler to keep in touch with home, thereby making the tour-
ists worry less. Infrastructure is one of the most important factors
affecting tourism, both domestic and international. Accommodation
includes hotels, boarding houses, motels, inns, holiday villages, tour-
ist complexes, camping sites, private apartments, etc. Hotel is the
most popular form of accommodation, while air transport is the
most important form of transportation for international tourism (Mir
2008). Tourism product includes the ‘amalgam’ of transport, accom-
modation, attraction, and entertainment. Accommodation sector is
central to international tourism and tourism flow is directly depen-
dent on the quality of this sector (Purba 2004; Raj 2003).
The tourism industry has not flourished in proportion to the
natural and cultural tourism products available in India. The reason
lies in poor infrastructure and marketing. Increasing investments in
tourism infrastructure are needed to tap the full potential of tourism
industry. Access, accommodation, and activity are the three critical
areas because of which tourism in India is in a poor condition. Singh
(1996) has quoted Ron Wynn saying that ‘the charm of Indian temples
and wildlife is such that any international traveller would love to be in
India. All he or she needs is a comfortable transfer, good accommoda-
tion and safe stay.’ Not only is it necessary to develop international
air transport but also domestic transport, both surface and air. It is
not only that a tourist is brought into a country and the job is done,
but he has to be provided with easy and comfortable access to all the
attractions to make him stay longer (Mir 2008).
Infrastructure is the problem and hotel capacity acts as a bottleneck
for tourism development in India and there is pressure for accom-
modation (Kumar 2006). Weak infrastructure leads to short visits
because of non-availability of good-quality hotel rooms to stay longer.
Hence, the areas with well-developed infrastructure have a flourish-
ing tourism industry (Babu 2006; Ringzin 2004).
Chakrabarty (2006) explains, in detail, the tourism resources of
Pachmarhi, Madhya Pradesh, and analyses the status of accommoda-
tion and transport—two vital requirements for tourism. Lack of infra-
structure and dearth of trained manpower are the main reasons for
58 URBANIZATION, INDUSTRY, AND DEVELOPMENT
RESEARCH GAPS
Although interest in the field of tourism is growing, there are still
some areas that are largely neglected. Medical tourism is one such
area. It is one of the fastest-growing sectors in India. Another category
that needs to be addressed is cultural (including heritage) tourism.
One more aspect that needs to be highlighted is the image of country
as one tourism destination, in spite of India being the land of variety
of tourism activity. Geographers can play an important part here.
***
REFERENCES
Abreu, N.D. 2008. ‘Sustainable Tourism in Goa: A Pictorial View of Tourism’,
Paper presented in ‘Conference on Tourism in India—Challenges Ahead’,
Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode, 15–17 May.
GEOGRAPHY OF TOURISM IN INDIA 59
Dhar, P.N. 2006. International Tourism: Emerging Challenges and Future Prospects.
New Delhi: Kanishka.
Dutta, M. 2000. ‘Tourism and Terrorism: A Case Study of Kashmir Valley’, Spatio-
Economic Development Record, 7(4).
Farooquee, N.A., Tarun K. Budal, and R.K. Maikhuri. 2008. ‘Environmental
and Socio-cultural Impacts of River Rafting and Camping on Ganga in
Uttarakhand Himalaya’, Current Science, 94(5).
Gangopadhyay, N. and P. Chakraborty. 2003. ‘Tourism in Digha: A Blessing or a
Blight’, Indian Journal of Regional Science, XXXV(1).
Gaur, S. 2002. ‘Development of Tourism Industry in Western Rajasthan: A
Study in its Prospects and Problems’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional
Development, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
Geneletti, D. and D. Dawa. 2009. ‘Environmental Impact Assessment of Mountain
Tourism in Developing Regions: A Study of Ladakh, Indian Himalaya’,
Environment Impact Assessment Review, doi: 10.1016/j.eiar.2009.01.003.
Gopal, R., V. Shilpa, and G. Rashmi. 2008. ‘Rural Tourism Development:
Constraints and Possibilities with a Special Reference to Agri Tourism: A
Case Study of Agri Tourism Destination—Malegaon Village, Taluka Baramati,
District Pune, Maharashtra’, Paper presented in ‘Conference on Tourism in
India—Challenges Ahead’, Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode, 15–17
May.
Grewal, B.S. 1994. ‘International Tourism and Sustainable Development: A
Case Study of Western Himalayas’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional
Development, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
Gupta, R.C. 1999. ‘Physical Planning for Tourism Areas: Basic Issues and
Concepts’, Spatio-Economic Development Record, 6(3).
Hall, M. and Stephen J. Page. 2006. Geography of Tourism and Recreation:
Environment, Place and Space. London: Routledge.
Hans, V.B. 2008. ‘India’s Tourism Industry: Progress and Emerging Issues’, Paper
presented at state-level seminar on World Tourism Day, ‘Contemporary Issues
in Tourism Industry’, 27 September…..place/insti/organiser.
Husain, A. 2004. ‘Rural Tourism: Panacea for Environment and Resource
Sustainability’, Journal of Contemporary Asia and Europe, I(2).
Joshi, R. and P.P. Dhyani. 2009. ‘Environmental Sustainability and Tourism:
Implications of Trend Synergies of Tourism in Sikkim Himalaya’, Current
Science, 97(1).
Joshi, S.C. and P. Pant. 1990. ‘Environmental Implications of the Recent Growth
of Tourism in Nainital, Kumaun Himalaya, U.P., India’, Mountain Research and
Development, 10(4).
Jreat, Manoj. 1994. ‘International Marine Tourism: Problems and Prospects in
South Asia’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional Development, Jawaharlal
Nehru University, New Delhi.
Kaur, J. 1982. ‘Using Himalayan Ethnic Attractions and Folk Traditions for
Tourism’, Tourism Recreation Research, 7(1).
GEOGRAPHY OF TOURISM IN INDIA 61
———. 2001. ‘Cultural Dimension of Tourism in India and Tunisia: A Case Study
of Goa and Tunis’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional Development,
Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
Khan, S. 2006. ‘Wildlife Tourism and Sustainable Development: A Critical Spatial
Analysis of Ranthambore Tiger Reserve in India and Kruger National Park
in South Africa’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional Development,
Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
Kumar, R. 2006. ‘Trends in World Tourism and Optimal Business Strategy: An
Indian Context’. In D.S. Bhardwaj et al. (eds), International Tourism—Issues
and Challenges. New Delhi: Kanishka.
Kumar, R.B. 1992. ‘Coastal Tourism and its Ecological Impact in Third World
Countries: A Case Study of Western Coast of India’, Thesis, Centre for the
Study of Regional Development, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
Kumar, S.V. and K.S. Chandrasekar. 2004. ‘Sustainable Development and Tourism’,
South Asian Journal of Socio-Political Studies, 5(1).
Kuniyal, J.C. 2005. ‘Solid Waste Management in the Himalayan Trails and
Expedition Summits’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 13(4).
Lala, M.F. and M.B. Anisa. 2008. ‘The Prospects of Developing Kashmir as an
Adventure Tourism Destination’, South Asian Journal of Tourism and Heritage,
1(1).
Lamichhane, D.B. and S.B. Singh. 2002. ‘Planning for Sustainable Tourism in
Pokhara, Nepal’, National Geographic Journal of India, 48(1–4).
Mandal, R.K. 1989. ‘Geography of Tourism and Development: A Case Study of
Western Himalayas’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional Development,
Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
———. 1992. ‘Spatial Pattern of International Tourism and its Foreign Exchange
Capabilities for Development in South Asian Region’, Thesis, Centre for
the Study of Regional Development, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New
Delhi.
Martin, M.B.G. 2005. ‘Weather, Climate and Tourism: A Geographical Perspective’,
Annals of Tourism Research, 32(3), doi: 10.1016/j.annals.2004.08.004.
Mir, M.S. 2008. ‘Emerging Trends of International Tourism in India’, Thesis,
University of Delhi, Delhi.
Misra, C.T. 1999. ‘Impact of Tourism on Sustainable Development: Asian
Perspective’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional Development, Jawaharlal
Nehru University, New Delhi.
Mitchell, L.S. 1979. ‘The Geography of Tourism: An Introduction’, Annals of
Tourism Research, July/September.
Motiram. 1996. ‘Mass Tourism and Impact Assessment: A Comparative Study of
Thailand, Indonesia and Singapore’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional
Development, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
———. 2002. ‘The Impact of International Tourism in Thailand: A Spatial
Analysis’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional Development, Jawaharlal
Nehru University, New Delhi.
62 URBANIZATION, INDUSTRY, AND DEVELOPMENT
Thathang, V. 2005. ‘Tourism in Nepal since 1980: Impact on the Economy, Society
and Environment’, Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional Development,
Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.
Verma, M.K. 1995. ‘Emerging Trends of Tourism in India: A Sociological Study’,
Thesis, Centre for the Study of Regional Development, Jawaharlal Nehru
University, New Delhi.
Xiao, H. and Stephen L.J. Smith. 2006. ‘The Making of Tourism Research: Insights
from a Social Sciences Journal’, Annals of Tourism Research, 33(2), doi:
10.10616/j.annals.2006.01.004.