Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DEDICATION
This work is solely dedicated to my mother for warm hugs, comforting words and beautiful
I begin by thanking GOD for seeing me through this work. Special acknowledgement goes
to my supervisor Mr Lamin Suwareh for his patience and guidance. I would be an ingrate
if I did not thank these accommodating individuals, : Mr. Alkali jabbieM. Jabbie, Lamin O
Beyai, Omar Ceesay, and Yakub Jabbie and Muhammed Sillah. A I extend my most
FGM/C is a topic that has received a great deal of attention and has been debated all
around the world. itIt is the collective term given to any cutting or alteration done to the
female genitalia for non-medical reasons (source). FGM/C is seen both as a serious health
risk which usually births a series of long and short term complications for women and girls
All around the world, nations have enacted laws which make the practice of FGM/C illegal
(source) and this research aimed at discovering the perceptions of the ban within my study
area. One thing we have learnt from history is that laws alone are not enough to bring
about behavioral change a sometimes they tend to produce results that are opposite to why
The study found that anti-FGM/C laws are not appreciated or welcome by the community
who regard FGM/C as an integral part of their cultural, social and religious identities.
Incomplete
Table of content
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Female Genital Mutilation or cutting (FGM/C) refers to all procedures that involve the
partial or total removal of female external genitalia and or injury to the female genital
Female’, 2010). It is a harmful traditional practice associated with immediate and long
term consequences on the health of women and girls. The term “mutilation” while
reinforcing the idea that the practice is a violation of women and girls’ rights is perceived
individuals who have undergone the procedure so in light of this, “ FGM/C” will be used
throughout my work which is currently the term being used by all United Nations (UN)
agencies.
On estimate 200 million women and girls have been subjected to FGM/C while 3
million remain at risk every year (Al-Nagar et al., 2017). This practice is mostly
concentrated in Africa, Asia, the Middle East and migrant populations within Europe
and South America(Marcusán et al., 2016). Africa alone accounts for 125 million of
recorded cases. In The Gambia the prevalence of the FGM/C is 74.9% in women aged
between 15 and 49; this is close to three quarters of the female population despite
state laws to ban the tradition in the country (Wassu Gambia Kafo, 2018).
Health workers all over the globe have been found to be engaged in the practice. This is
considered one of the biggest setbacks to the fight to eradicate FGM/C all around the
world. Medicalization of the act is proposed by some health workers as a solution to reduce
/ C : a Qualitative Study of Parents and Health’, 2018). This is however not a solution
against the long term complications and have no benefit to the females (Wassu Gambia
Kafo, 2018).
Various strategies have been employed to eradicate the practice including state legislations
criminalizing the act. The Gambia in 2015 became the 29th African country with laws
Female genital mutilation is a highly practiced, deeply rooted traditional practice with no
health benefits whatsoever. It entails any form of alteration to the external female genitalia
for non-medical reasons. FGM/C puts the life and health of women and girls at high risks
and it can breed complications which can be either long or short term. They include severe
bleeding, septicemia, infection and low self-esteem and sometimes death(WHO, 2010).
The majority of FGM/C practice is concentrated in 29 Africa, Asia and the Middle East
with countries like Egypt, Somalia and Sudan being categorized as high prevalence
nations(Berg, 2014)
Female Genital Mutilation / Cutting has been put on the Human Rights agenda meriting
recognized as being a violation of women’s and girls’ reproductive and human rights(28
The research will be conducted in Bundung, an urban settlement within the Kanifing
males=27,936). My study will be narrowed down to one of the sub settlements, Bundung
Bantaba. Within the settlement are different ethnic groups including the Mandinka, Fula,
Jola and Serers. Percentile distribution of these different ethnic groups is not available but
the Mandinkas are most likely to have the uppermost practice rate FGM/C as they have
1.3 AIM
To explore the various perceptions of Bundung Bantaba residents on the ban placed on
FGM/C practice
1.4. OBJECTIVES
To identify how many people, believe FGM/C should not be banned within Bundung
bantaba
To identify how many people, agree with the ban on FGM/C practice within Bundung
bantaba
What are the different views and perceptions on the FGM/C ban?
FGM/C practice, in addition to being a serious threat to the life and health of women and
girls has also been established as a violation of a series of human rights. Legislations
banning the practice have been a topic of controversy with critics claiming bans will reap
rebellion in the population and drive the act underground (UNFPA,2013). My research will
provide information on how people really perceive the ban placed on this deeply rooted
traditional practice and hopefully help individuals and organizations who fight this
practice.
CHAPTER TWO
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
Concept of compliance
Compliance is an important idea when discussing regulations or laws and it may be defined
RATIFICATION.
This is the process by which proposed laws, treaties and agreements are officially
PROCEDURAL COMPLIANCE
. This Iinvolves executing laws against a defined set of standard even when it is possible
that alternative approaches could achieve the same or better results. When standards are
arbitrary we get chaos especially in an environment where infinite possibilities exist and
This means adherence with the essential requirements of a law or agreement that satisfies
its purpose its objective even though its formal requirements are not complied with.
DE JURE COMPLIANCE
which are legally recognized regardless whether the practice exists in reality.
DE FACTO COMPLIANCE
De facto compliance is a Latin word meaning for “in fact” and deals withrefers to
situations that exist in reality even if they are not necessarily recognized by the law.
…
PROBLEM STATEMENT
Female genital mutilation is a highly practiced, deeply rooted traditional practice with no
health benefits whatsoever. It entails any form of alteration to the external female genitalia
for non-medical reasons. FGM/C puts the life and health of women and girls at high risks
and it can breed complications which can be either long or short term. They include severe
bleeding, septicemia, infection and low self-esteem and sometimes death(WHO, 2010).
The majority of FGM/C practice is concentrated in 29 Africa, Asia and the Middle East
with countries like Egypt, Somalia and Sudan being categorized as high prevalence
nations(Berg, 2014)
Female Genital Mutilation / Cutting has been put on the Human Rights agenda meriting
recognized as being a violation of women’s and girls’ reproductive and human rights(28
RESEARCH SETTING
The research will be conducted in Bundung, an urban settlement within the Kanifing
males=27,936). My study will be narrowed down to one of the sub settlements, Bundung
Bantaba. Within the settlement are different ethnic groups including the Mandinka, Fula,
Jola and Serers. Percentile distribution of these different ethnic groups is not available but
the Mandinkas are most likely to have the uppermost practice rate FGM/C as they have
AIM
To explore the various perceptions of Bundung Bantaba residents on the ban placed on
FGM/C practice
OBJECTIVES
To identify how many people, believe FGM/C should not be banned within bundung
bantaba
To identify how many people, agree with the ban on FGM/C practice within bundung
bantaba
RESEARCH QUESTION
What are the different views and perceptions on the FGM/C ban?
SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDY
FGM/C practice, in addition to being a serious threat to the life and health of women and
girls has also been established as a violation of a series of human rights. Legislations
banning the practice have been a topic of controversy with critics claiming bans will reap
rebellion in the population and drive the act underground (UNFPA,2013). My research will
provide information on how people really perceive the ban placed on this deeply rooted
traditional practice and hopefully help individuals and organizations who fight this
practice.
CHAPTER THREE
LITERATURE REVIEW
complications violates a series of human Rights. Efforts to end the practice have been long
and extensive dating all the way back to the early 20th century (Wassu Gambia Kafo,
2018). Over the years resolutions and statements condemning the act have been made at
challenging. In many of the countries around the world with anti-FGM/C laws perpetrators
are rarely successfully prosecuted for a smattering of reasons one of which is that the act is
highly under reported. In the UK where a research was conducted among FGM/C
survivors, most of the participants stated that people don’t report FGM/C because they
perceives this as an act of betrayal. There are also those who simply would not like to
make their family affairs public which usually is the result of any case brought before the
criminalization of the act despite aiming to end it has turned it into a secret affair that is
now carried out on infants who will not remember the experience and usually only the
closest relations of the child know about it (Gangoli et al., 2018). This only goes to show
that the wider community, despite having an idea of the complications and violations of the
act still perceive it as a necessary piece of their identity and worth the risk of prosecution.
It is because of this that critics of legislations that ban the act argue that legal prohibitions
will only drive the act underground which will consequently make it more difficult to
instrument of abandonment for it build trust and promotes peace between the public and
the government and all NGOs fighting to end FGM/C (Gangoli et al., 2018)
27 of the 30 African countries where FGM/C is practiced have laws criminalizing the act,
The Gambia included. In 2015 sections 32A and 32B were introduced into the Women’s
Act of 2010 (Report et al., 2018). According to the country’s constitution all practice,
requests, promotion and/or aiding of the act in any way is considered criminal as is failure
however does not specifically criminalize medicalization or cross border FGM/C (Report
et al., 2018). In cross border FGM/C individuals travel across the borders of their country
to have it practiced.
The table below is a list of some statements and resolutions on FGM/C worldwide (Berer,
2015).
1990 The Convention on the Elimination of General recommendation No.14 calls for
all forms of Discrimination Against eradication of FGM/C
Women (CEDAW)
1990 Organization of African Unity African Charter on the Rights and Welfare
of the Child
2011 Committee on the rights of the child General comment No.13 : children should
be free from harmful practices including
FGM/C
…
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
3.0 INTRODUCTION
The population of the study consisted of adult males and females residing in bundung
Bundung bantaba involving different age groups from 18 above and this allowed me access
A sampling size of 10 participants was used and judgement sampling technique was
employed which is extremely convenient, less time consuming, offers no barriers while
Adult mMales and females residing in Bundung and that consented to participate in the
study will be taken. Any individual who did not fit all of the criteria mentioned was
automatically excluded.
Data was collected using an in-depth interview guide and an audio recording device.
The digitally recorded Data data was analyzed using the thematic approach. Data was
digitally recorded, transcribed, organized, coded and combined into themes which were
The Alkalo of Bundung was visited and my intention of conducting a study within his
villageit was explained to him my intention of conducting a study within his village and his
consent was sought. As for the participants, the pPurpose of the study was explained to
respondents and their consent was also soughttaken. Since FGM/C is a controversial issue
dealing with the law, confidentiality was maintained and respondents’ were given
4.0 INTRODUCTION
During the interviews, discussions were digitally recorded while notes were taken.
Afterwards recordings were transcribed and themes were isolated, explored and patterns
between them were identified. Later on basic themes were grouped into central or
overarching themes.
Quite a number of themes arose during interviews which were grouped into three main
themes, : driving forces behind the practice, politics, awareness and perception of ban
4.1 THEME 1
A plethora of reasons and rationales have been provided as the motivations behind the
As one of our respondents (no. ?) described summarised in this very common sentenceas,
“… this practice, we found it here. Our ancestors were doing it and they passed it
For most of the respondents FGM/C is a huge part of their cultural identity.
One of the more interesting beliefs I came across is the perception that FGM/C eases birth
for the circumcised woman. It is believed that if the clitoris is not cut it would cause
multiple complications for the woman in labor and this notion was shared by four of the
4.1.1.3 RELIGION.
This was the most pointed out motivation behind the practice. one of the male participants
“this act was being practiced during the time of the Holy Prophet (PBUH). He
knew about it and I heard my ustadh Ustadh (religious teacher in Islam) say
that someone under his (the Prophet PBUH) care underwent it”.
A lot of trust and significance is placed on the preaching of religious leaders especially the
iImams in the Muslim faith. For most of the respondents, practicing FGM/C is fulfillment
of a religious requirement because not circumcising a girl would mean that they are impure
as one of the female respondents explained “when a woman is uncut, she is impure. She is
just travelling around with filth and she will not be pure unless she undergoes the practice.
“when a woman gets married and she is uncircumcised, she will play around
said one of the male respondents. The notion that FGM/C prevents promiscuity, I
discovered is still widely shared. According to most of our respondents, circumcised girls
are thought the proper way to behave especially with regard to the opposite gender so the
“circumcisionCircumcision isn’t what it used to be. Back in the days, our young
practicing it.” Pointing to his son who had sat down beside us the respondent said
“in the olden days, this would not have happened. He would not have come
and sat between us while we spoke because he would have known that it isn’t
Majority of participants had very strong views on the complications of FGM/C and the
ban. All of the participants knew about the ban either from radio shows or the TV and none
of them with the exception of one agreed with the ban and that was a young mother of one
aged 22 who claimed to not know enough about FGM/C to be able to say whether or not
there should be a ban placed on it. Different reasons were cited for their opposition to the
ban…
“the west is trying to fight and divide us so they cooked up all of these stories
A lot of skepticism was displayed where complications of FGM/C was concerned. Some
“if it was harmful the prophet (PBUH) would have condemned it, but he did
not. the west is trying to end Islam and this is why they are attacking this
“Sunnah” of ours.”
And that,
“if it was harmful then our grandmothers would not have kept on practicing it”
(Respondent no. ?)
It was staunchly believed by at least three (3) of the respondents that these harmful effects
of FGM/C were made up by the west to sabotage “us and our traditions”.
Among the participants was a sense of betrayal by our authorities for “siding with the
west” against their kind. This was best summarized by respondent no. ? as follows:
“our governments are letting the west bribe them with money and they are
doing whatever the west wants including placing bans on our culture and
traditions”
There was a huge sense of indignation regarding the criminalization of the practice It was
perceived, as stated by a 28-year-old mom of one (Respondent no. ?) that the ban was…
“…. imposed on us. The government did not even bother to ask what we
She, like two other participants believed the ban would not have been so offensive if NGOs
and government bodies responsible for lawmaking and abolishing FGM/C had gone to the
communities and initiated dialogue between them and the rest of the public.
Another similar opinion emerged whereby respondent number 10, and mother of 4
mentioned that the ban is “right” but “premature”. She believed it should be the last option
rooted within them and threaten them with punishments if they refuse to
4.3 THEME 3
4.3.1 COMPLIANCE
When asked whether or not they intended to comply with the criminalization of FGM/C, it
was very interesting to discover that the elderly who were perceived to be the most likely
to insist on performing and advocating for FGM/C actually turned out to be the most
cooperative.
An 80+ year old TBA (Respondent no. ?) who used to circumcise girls stated
“I am not happy with the ban, I am not. But no one can contest the authority
of “mansaMansa” (leader). No matter how much you dislike it, you have to
And this was basically the opinion of four other respondents but the majority stated quite
firmly that they intend to uphold their traditions and religious beliefs regardless of the
consequences. One partaker (Respondent no. ?) who is a traditional healer indicated that he
“will not give sacrifice my traditions and religious beliefs out of fear of man
DISCUSSION OF FINDINGS.
All around the globe, researchers have discovered quite a number of motivations behind
FGM/C practice but there are a few that are almost always cited wherever you go and the
respondents for this study were no different. During the interviews, three main themes
were identified, 1(driving forces behind the practice, awareness and perception of ban and
believed to be integral in shaping and maintain a cultural identity and an essential tool in
passing down important values and wisdom of elder (Shell-duncan Duncan et al., 2018). It
is regarded as a fundamental part of a female’s life and claiming they should not undergo
the practice almost equates to robbing them of an essential right. The study determined that
there is a lot of doubt and an almost complete rejection of health risk messages. Claims of
medical harms related to the practice are disregarded because for those who are driven by
religious reasons, it would mean that their faith endorsed a harmful practice and that is a
notion none of them were willing to accept. Some are also of the concept that FGM/C is
actually a healthful practice and this is a widely shared view. It is believed to ease birth for
women, keep them clean and rid them of a “heavy” burden in the form of the clitoris.
Another reason for refuting FGM/C related health complication claims is that
acknowledging this would equate to challenging the wisdom of elders and denigrating the
principal importance of respecting our ancestors and the customs they pass down to us
Concerning the ban, there was an almost absolute disagreement and displeasure regarding
it. Most of the blame was placed on the west for interfering in matters regarded as private
and our leaders for allowing themselves be bribed into fighting their own. This sense of
betrayal was raw and sparked a lot of resentment towards the government specifically. The
study found that there was not a specific pattern when it came to which age or gender
groups were more open to embracing the desertion of FGM/C. majority of the elderly and
some of the younger generation were willing to comply with abandonment laws and
seemed more open to discussions and negotiations and with the senior generation this may
be a bit surprising since they have been regarded as the key advocates for the act which
allows them authority and reverence within their societies and so that would make them
unwilling to support the abandonment of the act according to (Shell-duncan Duncan et al.,
2018).
On the other end are those respondents who are not convinced of the adverse health effects
of the practice because they claimed to not have seen anyone suffer them and this might be
due to the fact that the most prevalent form of FGM/C practiced in The Gambia Is the type
1 or “clidoridectomy” and most medical complications are related to type 2 and 3 as shown
Parents and Health’, 2018). They perceive the ban as a betrayal and an abuse of power by
lawmakers and they stated that they have no intention of abandoning or calling for the
abandonment of the practice. This confirms predictions that criminalizing the act especially
before extensive communication and collaboration with the community could lead to
rebellion and drive the practice underground because even the participants who agree that
there should be a ban placed on FGM/C declared that it was too soon because there has not
been enough dialogue about it between NGOs, government bodies and the public (Gangoli
et al., 2018).
CHAPTER SIX
According to the findings of this research, FGM/C is considered an integral part of the
collective identities of community members for a variety of reasons ranging from religious
to perceived health benefits and majority of the participants in this study are unhappy with
the ban placed on the practice and are unwilling to comply with it. Since health
practitioners including nurses are part of society, there is a possibility that there are some
who would feel the same way. They might find themselves in a situation where they’d
have to choose between upholding their cultural beliefs and following the law and some
just might go ahead and participate in medicalization of the act. Medicalization entails any
partial or complete removal of any part of the female genitalia for non-medical purposes
done by health professionals. This would result in a nurse engaging in violating human
In the constitution, it states that anyone who is aware of FGM/C that is about to take place
is duty bound to report it and in a hospital setting refusing to perform the act on a girl child
at their relatives’ request will not be enough because there is a high chance that if you do
not perform it they’ll just find a traditional cutter to carry it out. In this situations health
workers again will find themselves in a dilemma because reporting a practice which might
be a deeply entrenched cultural belief might feel like a betrayal to one’s identity and
beliefs.
Health workers are usually seen as trustworthy and role models so in that light, all training
health personnel need to be educated on how to impart to the public the adverse medical
Female genital mutilation is a highly practiced, deeply rooted traditional practice with no
health benefits whatsoever. It entails any form of alteration to the external female genitalia
for non-medical reasons. FGM/C, in addition to putting the life and health of women and
girls at high risks is a violation of a series of women’s and girls’ rights. (WHO, 2010)
In 2015 sections 32A and 32B were introduced into the Women’s Act of 2010 of the
Gambian constitution banning all practice, requests, promotion and/or aiding of the act in
any way. failure to warn or inform authorities of any knowledge of FGM/C being or about
to be practiced is also considered criminal with penalties ranging from monetary fines of
This research sought to explore the various perceptions of the residents of Bundung
Bantaba on the ban placed on the practiced and it was discovered that majority of people
disagree and dislike that a practice which is deeply woven in the fabric of their identity has
been criminalized as the study discovered, most people intend to continue practicing
FGM/C because they believe they are doing it for the good of their female offspring and
RECOMMENDATION
FGM/C, I recommend to the lawmaking and implementation bodies of the Gambia and all
interventions like religious figures, traditional rulers, health workers, revered public
figures etc.
1. 28 Too Many (2018) ‘The law and FGM: An overview of 28 African countries’,
Red Sea State, Sudan’, Sudan Working Paper, 1(1), pp. 1–16. Available at:
https://www.cmi.no/publications/file/6229-weak-law-forbidding-female-
genital-mutilation-in.pdf.
3. Berer, M. (2015) ‘The history and role of the criminal law in anti-FGM
campaigns: Is the criminal law what is needed, at least in countries like Great
Britain?’, Reproductive Health Matters. Elsevier Inc., 23(46), pp. 145–157. doi:
10.1016/j.rhm.2015.10.001.
(August).
RIGHTS FOR THE PERIOD 1994 AND 2018 . AND INITIAL REPORT
pp. 1–169.
11. UNFPA (2013) ‘Driving Forces in Outlawing the Practice of Female Genital
https://www.unfpa.org/sites/default/files/resource-pdf/Legislation and
FGMC.pdf.
12. Wassu Gambia Kafo (2018) ‘the Gambia: the Law and Fgm’, (September), pp.