Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • EU-PIL Chapter 2

    Uploaded by

    Madis Priediens
    27 views47 pages

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    27 views47 pages

    EU-PIL Chapter 2

    Uploaded by

    Madis Priediens

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 47
    ay tam ty ymca, stm iy requirements (Ch Sew fed (Ch 3 and {which goers a given ths ls, yt coin of cra i he sense sie Gin the ee ' ousa io ths sone 1 somejurisitions. as = rich Engh and Norwe (Sjoseand Mea arent IL ete ew femme srw the EULPIL tide the eerie of exto= oni mates i 28h 324B as eas tes (om), see Ch saison by cous i 40323, CHAPTER? Jurisdiction 2.4 nrodvetion 2.1.4. dutdlton to Adjedeate ‘When seo ins gen Slt XI ie aha decd ven tomamscal dts berwcen vo pate contacting. pares (and Byte fr sc fo be esived is hs tht cou fae jain to auc the dpe (Ch 13). A sou ‘wh has uraiouon wo aja has th uteri andthe oer © ded the coe frog bor iI the coum ack iigion, has wo ach ana ov poet, and st thorefve damise the cise widow making 8 din oF the arson wo ajuda i alvays a fundamen consi rato. n bth domestic and intratonl contest. ough ‘he Tous inthis ptr conse raion in dts wih an itratina komo we can gin wih domes esa ‘else to Monvation fish 13) ration 2a: Sle A (in Sete X) and bye in Sats 1X) ake conc fe the livery of ees goods in X on Jawary 2 The comet species the tate of the bods o he dlr, awl the prc fo Be poi, Butt doesnot dsignateaforum forthe esolaion adapts ‘hich mip are. When A dives the goods on Jane 3°, B ese to accept op br them Aso to etl the dispute amiably Ti and A asks a lawyer to com ence el proceedings ais 8 na cou in Sate X Saks. Teal abn (evs) Iie hy alas ives the subrision oF document (eg 2 his frm) the cour and % md ofpmcedings ‘own ot evn aes cpp Seles. ‘imiadcion an oficial noice fe "ue of pres) a th Fendi Apart rm ts fn the es com imencrsat of poussins li ly Baa the ios EU Nmber Sse. As weave son in Ch 3) the Xo wil swt ein fave jrsdcon to aut an ston Heth, sily b= ‘se the defendant (Bs cn ora St. Merron 2b Sa at in raion 2, at taser Bis dss ina diferent Soe (V Although he inkmatonl clams the dendan's Si ‘hen uri 2b wal prove sige he 82 ‘thse th Xoo jean to ite tm ‘Seay nem by rls nt rom he ei ply in ‘heianon 2a, Tis is base the power a Ste The X19 ‘eis cours he ig w adja devia oe tie dle (8) general seo 5a ptf th Fr real ight of yous Skt gover ad le hin the Contin fie own for, Aer ll what pes on 8 an X- fu goes i Sate X Tas, however ony the ting i In prats. the ato ven coo exer jr to ing eve wa foreign elon it be ites by eth maton and ineraina(r spaatons ves, When it ees juritiction wo aan cses whan ines rata eluent he great majority of sovereign Stas Show ome volnary messi of Seles. Mes. Sts eine Some concrete At forthe exercise of jarani Sul {Gace sone soit or comecion Bete the Sia i ‘Sours on he ee Had and the nate of he ition a he Shit’ acini on th oor Goth exo on ag he procs ct il slot coaily ‘om ike this, simp ins foram Sate, Imraton 20, eso Suie(YE peove igi theise ‘nsdn a Hom hse whch apy ower oa Ste tke X10 dpe inv 4 Be scan asp of the fins ose au wit the AL what ges on ina ‘enum (exer jr Us ely to be ied by srt te a with a ine of soversin Sis sae tint. Mos Stes roe of jain i sac Ione the Ste and srs ofthe ign oe the exc of jrcon igs fr example fe bse on He ee ssh comes ing for athe prance of a crac ce he commission ‘of ton win he terol rds oft fon Se. Local (slPinposed)fimitons a not he only Hains. In sais brought fn an EU Manber Sate our against de nt cai bana EL Membr Sta, we ind importa onl (EU) Hinton onthe json of opal Kestawes ae cour Asgard sth doendan he Brave | Regulation st for Hit of excise) errs (connecting Stor) which EU Membr Sit ar rs se fs th us ftir erase of esata json. AS resins deine vor domi s the EU. bower, the Sirs (Relative ions fe jualin ‘heii Memb Stn, ‘Sb there coment! ro tog he Sein oer commer bjt mar of ca Sin ett ap om 7 EU resins ‘onl re Chpner2Siticion The Bl Regul ison beyond 211.2, ase of Jarsiton Survey of European La Ac orane the eerese oF adcion over EU domi wn sv an coer mater, the ih of (pein 5 ‘ei EU Member Sis deemine thr ov rls oF {hsdkton fs Boe subced 4 Brsachnig estas By Bruises | Replaon ot tation and Jadpmens. Un ‘er th ional sgn se oly panmiible base of arr Commit jrvadtion i ei aM commnecal mars ae thon rama the Regulation sen ie Lag Con ini ec ty ses ‘he Mrwls {Regul dace mt, Powever gonna: de privet indi EU Member Sasso thi i 1 epi tc bases junio which each yond the our bounds esoftheEarpson Unio eta cmap According to Arie 6 of the Regulation, in the absence of forum accent the jradicion of the cours i mater vere the denon s domi ets the European Urion is pons determin by he domes proce a a the Forum, Given thi ination ofthe sop he Regulate, ad the fc tht EU meant este engage in commer fective which ested beyond Union borders cach EU Mem ter Stas on (domes) jurstonal coe esis highly ‘abst nhs rr tnstol eons ‘So. tore udoaking clas esainaion of the most sigan es-ormmsty s(n O22) re bein wal 2 ‘note neal sor, enphaing some of he main pencils tpn Shih he pero addict sound, acai {of Earapenn Law mover EU domiaris Fight of (pesos. tie ther own ras of rescingYestictns By Shon an mene. Ur tint tae of nmol matte ae {gsc ep rds rower. goer bo yond th outer Bounds ston, nthe bsene of the cours in mates side the ropa Union tte procul ae of Spe ofthe Regulation a in commer ch EU Mer tl eode vers bight Ch 22). we begin with mcf the min piss 1 founds inlding the sain has of jst er he mona fhe nd aye comin 0 gover ma} jaresonl he Base of gone json provide cours wih he omer to acd any and al raters heres bases of spe i ison compas stuston where the sea 0 pve 1 adit lied to meters arin ot (or a Ted ote aliating ceumetances om wi he ur jets ims esd A deena’ domi within the Sate wh te fan ot fens san impor expe of 9 gens base, That mens tat ou in Ste X as dhe pone oad just any eli wich a given plait? (A) might have jas gen defendant (Bs log 25 is domed in Site The pesibe din of the wm domi ler some ‘wht am sytem o syste, bu the base once of de note the connston of mara eran ih pris pbc: smal uni wins putea Sie, The fc that domicile provis a geno! Bsi of iis io & of pra praca! siacans, sine celerdins ate ‘ly sod inthe cons ofthe Sie whe thy edo ‘el (aor sein frm) This te Bho eas ury national proceedings, a wel prosaling ivaing on craton cement Donic for kg persone Comraceelaad Forum deli ‘As og leg po (sch company of exptation) the consyt oF dete smny tines a comet b= teen th lea pon and gis plase, Und the Brasil Region thne sah coorstons re revised (se Ashe (6 (a) see sci (h) cel lmsston and) pn ‘Si pice of bois Reon a oe anne ei be ot 2 os AAs weit th execne of pvc json in cont felted actions. te Bnssle | Regulation entsis ant fora provin whereby EU dnicires may be stdin therm somos (he fom of perfomance atthe ee ‘of pevomanc: ofthe obligation ia question”: Ane 1. STs ale i dbcssed mor lyn Ch, 221A) Dow. AS regan ont actions again nowFU. demic, frowenes the Hamber Sas tee to mitin oe (0 Ines) rok of juin, sch 38 (eg) the English “on tos ade win orion eth. 14D, As opt theese of speciation in mais {ng om mst oft eign] EC Meniber Sts exmpnsed the boss of json Koen a or le emis he Forum ofthe commision of th om) andi thelre not ses hatthe syhesized Brel tor in Arce 712) regarding EU dsfndanis resembles the ratio bases sill plicable as saint on-£U defendant place wher the arf even ocd or may acer” This ule cused snore fly in Ch 2.2.3 Blow “et | atin pv eer re of Stout yan employe as ens apy ean fh ome (Sree ket epg ume com prt Ane » ‘lines @ connsctin be tse, Under the Briel recogni So Article sation, nd) pri jisition in cont tilaie may be Sd Formanes} atthe lee sqosson Anil 11). Gh. 22214) below. AS non-EU domes, fo mini or (de (eee) the Fgh “en eich Lan, “edition n mater elt fener Ste rcopised va dt commis Us and i therefore nt ‘tome in Ail 10) the rtlonal Bay il sng the place where the This le ede mon hae of i (yas employe Jeroen I shel not he suprising 8 find gens! Ssoplaes of scomsenheed jeri in European bt, Pre he ‘Setondoe at gpally“esher pany fic a conse tere emposec) thet wil aly be ie reason oxi frp defend who Vinay els comp 2 plus aquest to appear and le map fo ‘Consent jarition is oln ston in ans, an te ‘ellen bs god eon enfin ch an expres mise ia eons ete, A loam agrerin is arr ‘tween ps sub Hei dsp to a speci coat oF tothe cous psc coy. Even ma commensal coe fest however the ppiabe sts sy ie tha ein A ents onda who voluntary eters a appear ‘ance in the frig fou ou wil dnl be dso Baxe given hr mpd onset to the riiton ofthat ‘cour provided tht the apperance was aa ered fr the purpose of consi sch jrdicon: Ale 26h Br S31 Regulation. “The various bases of jasiction dscns thf alley a gat degre of tanstional acceptance and appeal ade Tin exanpe flo them nner al possi, ‘Cenain other jusdiconal bass, howtver, reach beyond ‘wily ecogniecestonable mis, Thee bases oars ‘on ate sommes esrb 3 exon -Accurdingw the Suse | Regulation, te only permissible ‘bases oFina-Conmuniy jist in ei and commer utes re lose pnt enueraed inthe Repltion NomEU domiciiny deena, howesse ot enay the ‘sm poston ad i thei sgt ote end a peers ‘ident Bhan nes fiiaiton Brac Dames caer (Cap 2 iter satel Gade civ Propenytenet dart nish: mos Eopean doen asd cad posi for theucof ane ormae sori! bse a jit ethips most oro aman the soba bases of ri Acton née is Aik [4 ofthe eh Cl Cade Wich uhoies Fetch curs 0 escae jin in all is “vee the panties, Morten 2c Seba Gin Fae) ad bayer Btn on EU Ment Soe X} he #conat fr the delivery of erin gods Sia Z.The contrat does ot site 2 Fon the esto of dpi ei ay aise. When ‘lv the gods B elses ok delivery OF pay or the Athen ses or damages ma cour in Fane Sine the deendaa B & not domed in a EU Member Ste the frum State (Fane) fs fo apply anal rules of jristion, inning the extn provision of [Rite 14 afd French Cit Cae. Unless posed 3 treaty ste Franc ad tte X, he Fen cour wl ave {raison adjust te aton (Xs lai aint Band tees e tera adm reed byte French court will beens inal EU Mane Sass (Ch 522), Ale fie Fac Chi Cadi wba” gd of ri: iyi cara ‘eBay ea ab en Pec i an comercial Cea ah Aree 9 {be Col Cerner ne ea eu ming ‘ong iio sal retina Besides joielan tae on mains, cnain rope ‘sed povsins, suchas Ail 25 ofthe German Code of Gist Procare, ies ejoyed 3 considerable mesure of Inman bsp Accog 1 thse rus, the mere presence o 2 no EU domiciliary defendant's pope ok Forum soi autores he frum cour a exert peel oe ado, Se sho! Geman) 18 Dee 2012 282821 Sng ft peas Carman dom pv heres ‘Sma oA 2 ces he Spa es 2 ssl css provide for sovbiant bass of ui Fron i Code which jursdision all ne, tat forte dele of Fae docs nt designate» hich ay ase Wher 1 uke deer pay for sil in an EU Meme Foe 10 apply is mao oct provision of ‘Unless preted by 2 te cnt cou wil is 2s clam agaist Ban rendre by the Frnt ber Sues (Ch $22) nai, seri propery Sof the Geman Cade of comiderable masse of to thse eves te mee tip exsrese psc jo The Bol I Regu Aan 2 Seer tin Sse X} ng 1G EU Mem Ste ¥) ke a conc fo the delve ‘ein goods n Skt Z, The coat es ot Js fanam forthe rite of dias which na ae Whe 2 liver the gods, Betis o acceptor iy tr da A thn se B for damages 3 cout is Denar. 2 Sate ‘nlc Bois rope. Sins he efandant snot domi jy an EU Member Sse, Donna i ee 1 aply WS nan ls of june ton ncadng the evoriian provision set fr it Aric 2463) of te Dash Admunton of soe Ae (retype love, hich roi jraiton to aioe 2 aim on ts oso th presen of prope ith he arate he lam tas no connection the rope anor the ale ofthe tls ened the ale othe proper) Unless pele By {tay between Denk and State V he Banh eoun wi ve rion toate the aston agaist. an any jjndgnnt rendered by the Banish coun wil be nfs fn AI EU Member Sates (Ch. 522), Asin by the amps the Brust 1 Rea [ann profibis the application of sich eset is guint EU domicians (Ai 8), bat ntioal euch ‘Acie 14 of he Fre Cade and Arie 28 of the Gena Code (wich provides for propery-bee jrsition sila to the Danish ul just noted) continue apy 2s ais ‘efits who ano EU domes (Ai, 2.2. The Brussels | Regulation 2.21. Regulation Overview ‘The ool (1987) Tray of Rome provided the basic on ito cere forthe esono integration a the Eopsar (Conuruniy, bt it id nota rovde a mchanism forthe {ial nsolaion of pate tbr cit or fr the trial recogni and exes fmt ofthese ‘us cov of he Member Stake. ‘According to Arise Member Sais underook, to the eMent nosy 0 ee Arasch pres EU dictions ome Trt Braet t seguro Devan Paro! tyrone ino motions 2 al. aro snp te fomalies toveminy the ecgnion ad enforcement fags. This Sumit ae adoption te Brass Comenton on Serio and Fafoemt of alzmonts in Cis and {Commer Mateo 1988 which creed rn fe in 1973 (int original sis EC Member Sas). Avis aume sages, th Scope of he Brussels Convention ‘extowed nel beyond the comnts dd in the Tea {pol Roms a the Consetion aa ony applied retin nd wfrcement bat junsdition aswel 1h wnt ands sn oh Come s a l {Soul a ma amino ais: se ply C32 ‘Tisdatona i Bane Comat piel he epeon (oh en Sop at be pa oom Sad aint ae Comin is ne ltd wn Couto he Espa ea 2 Pace SNe Goce ae etm os “Comyn hh Pons nae eel ie ‘uss ssn he Cena fo ig ing ening he don Zhe» Pi (se 190th th mec poi yh Coun a8 mp Spon meat nl ie ‘homme pal’ aS (0n 22 December 200, te Council of Mins oF ie Ea oor Usion adopted © Repti on jrisiction ond the ‘Rotpon snd eforcement of jms in cil aad com teria mats (Regulation No 42001). The Regulation, ‘conmonly known athe Brasel 1 Repulaton, ened into fore on March 2002, AS oF that date the Regulation ¢s loc! th Basle Convention as been all Member Sas Ihe exepion of Dena ue w Denmark's nonpaicpation in EU leit con ‘ring cv ats ase Ch 321, the Brass | Reglton {oot enter nn force ox Deck ut some 5 yeas ts, pon the inplementtion of apa “Pale Agron ‘tv July 2007 2 snp the formals ‘ment fugit This ‘ruses Convention on vdgrans im Chil ard sr foe 973 d at dow nthe Tee sal “ ome» Pie's (ase of Ministers of the Euro ‘on jusition and the messin cil nd con Pa). The Regulation Regulation, ened into _aveanall Member Sis in EU legislation con the Brice Rulon uni sme $year ster, fa Pale Agreement tween enn cay he ot Ment Sg Dama Jn 202 a ecast veson othe Regulation came inf. replacing the po version regal prosalngs nt tut on orate 10 Janay 2015 I ecrdance with he evant provisions f the Danish Pa allt Agreet (oncerming Tre amendmen he (200) Basel Regulation, Desk fas dled tha clin plemant the 2012 reas nt Danish nts string tht ‘nominal Menke Sis, Even is posent (cast fom the Brussel Regulation ally the Brvsls Cosmin in ne ui. Some in The supe of the Reputon se oth in Ace I arian to his Arie, the Reguaon pli oe abd comme rats dso ext in prc, 1 revenue cu tore or adnate ts rt the Uli of the Sat foe as and omissions in the eerie of Sat uy (ct lave igri, By yving the one of ii and comercial ‘mater an auonomeus meaning independent of eatin imspetiv of the moa Tom concerned — the rls will sas be apled in 2 aifrm wy Cee fing ade te 8 Binscs Revue Giitand ter 2 eric cluded mas Dove come those comers hick wold sadonlly ie within dhe rssh of prise’ ~ 35 opposed “pubic a: bt the hey tition the rete of the Kgl relations betwee the arts othe action or ofthe sob mater of the aon ane thei olsen of a public audony dos moi a of rane th Regulation gheble 1 TKD vt ishoanh Su se C2 Fe nae ‘Ss lb hese soo feos nthe Nad ‘Moni Nerinds Se tng Aton fe Sens be ‘etree pom te gu ti he eu oe Netra ere wee ser by he Brae Come. The om oe oe ot hl tp acne tre ‘Sentra br mcs fp oso a oh See ‘ait eth acc owe ng bn ing dt thers peste si ect pea dns Ca ‘a ints Coenen id sma Fede Rb of Goma es C2205) ies nce M9 a eg psn ee pat ‘Gera fr ones ep taal os nea ‘Sie mn ang The Coto ce a he le ‘omen tna sp ap stn agin Ste Se an anagem gan cs ppl yd Grea nthe gene a, Teche ees 86) he Co sie el at ‘he puna ps te eget aeons of Siok ‘fact rt oan a kro py ah nt ee Se steps wh jag hesina incl na “The Regulation excl cena il and eo mates From ib scope, such 3d within the anit of Tai Jaw and bankrupt (Ancie 12).Arbraon lo el bat hore the wily rata New York Contention it ‘uly apply (08 Ch 63 and 64: sx ao Hill & Chong. “eration Comarca Dies 264), In procedural teminlogy. te Brsstls Convention was a ite coments goed bot) joraeon oe ours and (i Tecopstio ad enfcement ef judgment ‘ther Convating Slate. The Regulation floss in hat resect. % inal he win the lationship Bewcen the ter ofthe aon aed ss iano se ety 3 Heh warame euro] CES aed comma mates hin the amit of ay brio sao exc York Conventon ill sc aso Hil Chong. ssn. sels Convention was ft ( uriditin of the recent of jolene i ation flows st a Tint ofall se Replton segs the Jisition of the inva EU Meher Sates aed thi out (Caper Under Ais of he Brssel fReplton. te evens of EL ‘Member State X monly eerie jristion vet a don ‘Stary ie EU Menor Sate Y purwan to 2 Reglaion- thor jostle, Secon he Reguaton ts fort the coins ues which SON EU Sera Sot sll esogise and care judges Face bythe cots of oer Member Ses (Chap {Capri ofthe Reyelato ays doen what (booing ‘Ameen pase) afen elle lth and ee ime th simp staring ois tha al judgment mating From the cours of te varus EU Member Sas sal Be ‘meni an afwsed i al her Member Sats. and ~ as Nes pelt fin Chater 8) =the evant exceptions to (hed efraemnt ele at ew al fr etc, fe me of lamers sn fir ig om We bein wih Chop ofthe Brus IR {kal wth he uridition of EU national ours and the Rey finipeon fee fs onthe satu of the efendan in the arian case. Mest (hough otal of the provisions in {Chater It which hy down he jurstoa ses othe EU Member Sante eur apy onto ests wer he deat ‘Sdomiia in an Member Sat. the dsfendat is no FU domly. these Chop bases donot py nd sch {coe conn to be opin By the indi proesdura ‘ade of he EU Member Ss. or dm ek er eon he pe thd ‘Sup cc pce he Ruin’ Chapter Mas wo ‘Steno ai lms ede he ous oF Uta a ection od sition over EUdomcares Chg 2 oii Joe satan Oumn drko sped secypunee “Sinem fitness snl copie sn fa Eoin tacoma aig beeline As reals EU domi delndans. the Chae 1 aig po em Ha lsh ref tr sega: fr rt face Ace 4), Domi the gent nition bas, thstuhe denon may Bel hi fru (whee eo he is domi wher theese of ction gat bm or er rye As std prosoul in CH. 21.1) te ass aoe > ‘ally doc aot eng he ones a forum com Sih concep andescod and api ens Engl Taso roe la This wa confined Oh vc Som (ease C281ND wher the Cou of este ued tha the ‘Brasels Conon pris a court of Contacting See Fre sing to execs the jrton conrad en i by ‘rice 2 f he Canvetan (how Ace 4 the Regulation) ‘anf ground th court of a non-Coaacing Ste woul be 2 ar spore fru? for the el Fhe ation ven iF thejonsdicten of mo ther Contacting Sta sin so he orsdings ave no comeing itr to anyother Cntr Ine Ste, Aics ofthe Bret Repuaon is undobiely tote stad nthe sme way on his point AHovever, the Bassls Conention and he 2000 Brussels 1 Repulaton mad no mean of bo 3 court ef Membr State faving jardin under the ComentonRepation souk! or Shu atthe same ston beeen these pais Ws led pening hn ano Conracting St (has is pe thn sitions ae between two oF ore Conrating Sats ‘ve (and a) expel deal with ee Bel) Tre-Ovia, mos comments argd that cours could ined soy prosedings in such fr pecs sttons (382 Hat, sveton 5 note 18, ching English, Geman, anc and Stes autores). Onis the Cont of Jose espe eth gueton open, st 035 mt ea to be cave (oo scion Bing ponding inthe non-Conracting Sui ia gust Jamis) “The Bruel | Regulin now (ater te 2012 nas) con. tins expres rs om this, Under Anil 3, whee rs as as, the Chap stating ‘ctr eq forum sl jars bse. Feira (tere be ose Seton aginst him or the Bresson ‘ode unde Enaish fm Or ack Ao Jie rll that the ti of» Contacting Sat tele # of th Regulation) ‘onrating Ste ul ho thal of the an, even if ing Sat sin oe the (rloany other Contacte Regulation sunbed ths po td the 2000 Brel Scout of Mente Site nonfeglton could 0 vg Ste (whereas fs pore ‘hore Contacting Stes seb) gual that cous could Spondon sttos (82 ing English, German Ov ete Com oF en as it at nt elena inthe non-Catating fle he 2012 ess co nicl 33, wher jie: vio ted nh defendant dba in Ate ro Als 7. 8 or 9} of the Regulton and previ ere ewig Deore or of tl Sue 3 he teh ovr in Memer la sed uf an ation imo the sone caine of ett and been te sme pes 36 the rossengs he cou ofthe tid Ste thst Mb Sate foxst maint cretion st proses He (2) vnc that he out of the hid Site il ve aoe ‘ual of ncognton an, whe applica. eeforesment ‘Ste tt 9 tay is mess forte pus anaton {is doo: of from me coms een ye at ‘Suto td Sew ges fale ee et “ier i ey Nay = In do wo the rl of gene uridine let the Regulation povides a umber of specie erate bass of urine the urinal Base ts othe faricub ype of el commercial mater conser For ‘ample in ate reating to conc, aut maybe bought Tet only nih courts of th elena’ ami, at, stan fo Ariel 71) ~ ths eur rhe place of pe Toomanee ofthe obligato n ierton” Similan mates often ist) an alerts forum i roi te place ‘shoe te karl eve curt ry es Ale 72) ‘Te rles in Ales 11) and 72) are dncused in at ui tlow GinCh 22214) and 223) 1 san impo jut eons hat dhs an ‘eras bai of rdictionpursnt to Aric 7a the Rep- ‘lation, th pl hae fe choice betwen the or po Section nde licle Chaper2 derton Pla of coal Peformance Sapna thse agrsonen ‘ey Ai andere rm prove by A= 7 Acondng to teshrsohos tab ee 18 ‘acnang ue ch ec eh tesa sot rat he toi pl ne he ah, “The Roplt o) sman m f clswih rge ‘the Abc acon en a to none cove engine nes Arte 302) a ean obey ‘Son coma An i ni 24) of Rep ch Sad win enh sao i eins ch eo ‘tj hs eas ofc pe The Ce a SOR ste ova oman ‘pe mmeks htc n oat aer So cn hfe 51899) she wn spa eer = creme CO) aise 4) ba mney ne ps reo of ian ach retin ees {er ds ea. se apes st peng Se era ro nas ihe he we hae Sogo fe pig eng secon Pah at as pe eet ‘mor pow ous pow ping ‘nin ben leat BU deme ybem m e Fine wh ors atv do fen tors pend aia ec he ‘gon depending nse ugg bythe tigation whi ts fr has raced the Cour ‘Jase ofthe Eoropcan Union hereon jin in ‘onal ater st fo in Arise 1) of pancla ‘commercials gifcance, and tht pace of perfomance ‘il zcive ci atenton below (Ch. 221A) efor moving oa impact opi, we do wll that Anite T() ihe the tbe Chap I bases of jridition onsidrd tha fe (ence Fr Aric 24, ch manor ‘is supplementary (ta) re, nd sue els apy (by ‘sfinton) only i th abence of binding jonsetonsl sgeonent, 0 frum provide by Ane mite foe oc te ack deen gh hoe ar has riche the Coit the ele or jr rile 7() 8 of paricuar pice of pone” re fon22 5a) pic, we do wll nt that fr bases of jaristicion ian sucks apy (by 19 binding jrsdctonl Sele Afin EU Mme Sts ) an 1 Membr Ska) ake onc forthe dinero erin gods in Xo Janay 2 The cona ‘poss the mates of he ooo divs wl the pele wo be pa it so designates 9 coum i EI Me fer Site Za the oe forum fr the resolution of dispey ch ight ars. Whom A deines the woods on Jay 5B reftses io acop or pay fr hem, A hop sues B for Sainaes ins eur in Sate X Acconing to Arle 25 ofthe Briss 1 Regul, she paris have ace ha given EU nana eu ew ate Jomeiton inthe case concer then tis ream wi take presedetce over the Regeltion'ssuplementny 7 “This mens that oly the designated Z-cout ean exec je sittin in seo 2 Se cn Se ema sri slack arti When «dispte aes between two pais domiciled in i= Fern EU Member Sines, several ts of urn may be valle depending onthe cieustaoes (6 the denis Alo ner Arise 4a an alma frie er Ar e-forum agreement ay give exclusive jrsicion 3 single cour (othe cours ofa singe EU Metter Sa) ut fspenence sows tat onracing parties omcimes gee sto whether ald ad binding frum ape hn oo enc. The ost fal this stat he paristo 8 sven spt (A&B) wl Sometines ck wo brig a eon Sexe fn coualabe Ls pondo Cpr 2.Jisloon differen EU Member States &Y), ‘The Brus Regulation das with hs even pos sons whi git pei to the fra action. Under Anti 29, ‘see’ posed nso the sume cause oF ation Bet secon the nme pose ous fr! EU ee ‘Stat he court sed sco mist of so Hn a rwsedings wi 1 fas Bao determined shat the cur Fin sce as rer. Once de jin dhe cour it see has Boon sas te cout Sond ed Pak ling jsction ‘le 32 dis hr m2 oe am ie insane pct ah kw don bapa wp der a nt aoa ‘tee tame hn a oo ‘ther acuerdo yn Tere tel ur ia tga El ‘Senge huacrqur oes ae he cu le et ‘Sur ess re 2 spp bts ain Eger Tn ihr hi st he cnesin wit dei of na nti Ak 3 ov pk ls eb fate an mS Se cu nce ‘inc am 2 poy aot EU Mears, Whee ae Heroine keen sun psig) ‘costal ti ct ted Seo ges ‘Sneetimand sae wp re ees Set {sto Mar ecu st ha 9 eran Fee mms fe Th em he Member Sete a ot cara crews pornge ee 3 ‘nu cr fei Soh our oe emi a ‘npc tgs Wi Senne icra napalm of ep een ‘icemaker Sua np omer Sep el Noni ua ga, he ‘ncgrnoenoma cond Sos pean 3) of te 3m ti ‘Snes inp fale Ch 5 on bie the ous this ese by pon ston, Under Arie 8 ‘nero EU eb ned whether the cout ‘justin the ot ite doce ae sn hi oe gees pce ape of seein he cee 2.22, Jursition in Contract Cases 1 Plage of Performance The anes to a en cone wil penal aeing a de Substantive le wich sores tht conc) eos comic ‘etc formulates tes ott conto, Sian hose contacting partis any coisa ea terns the Frum i whl dpa eating thir oe toa can he resale Suh parce may or evap. ape that any dap rating to tr core rt bg bain a spsifed cour or the courts ofa poi county (Cu 22.218). As am seme, many comming pts. inching mecianis ‘who det! neatly. gee pt © gat in any cou fi at io else er esas anbarion (Ch. 8, In he absence of any agree been the pats on de pate rslaton, the gaping pose ras wll ermine the foam (tn cou) i eich Iigton my Be ore ewe: Under ihe widely esol pin of tor set ‘ar frm sh he forum oft defends damier genoa usc, e.jusiction ver any mtr. nag onal msi. Ta addain wo this ener juiadctionl bss, te rst Regultion nls a provision spay deste Yo m= ses rein coma: Ae 70), Like ote ap Pemuniry bas of juradton nthe Regulation, Ale 1) Spies only when the defendant i domiciled in aothsr EL Mnber Sise ‘Anele 11) ofthe Brae | Regulation i an esarp o ‘ese bas of radon, te the desgnated forum hs place f the foram Alii invoking Ale Ti he for eure to esis ink batwecn the pica "ter feng loa contact in disputes the plac of the cout Called yon to decide the dispute. And scowing to Aree {1 the ely evant nk he plc of prfmnane os tigation in question” ‘Wii sh Or 1 Resi’ ll 0 pin Ai 10) soy cnc need ep ce ron Hepat Na ot oto a uy a Sinplom ate Speier are ple of pein Cag 2 dion Plaeof perormance Str dein cr by Arie 0-6. ent eras ares he Aes EGS tm wm sa Teton: Fy ae C- tin daias tab ‘Sn Geran iso taal Gens whe sb tug 2 ‘Sas ot Lie mig tr alee ‘Anelka ra pci eon ‘Hou sh hs penn po ms Assuming or no that Aik 71) piss othe comet spate at hand iil who ices hs proviso must sali tht th place of perfomance ofthe lization in ‘ston’ Bs within the ae ovr wi he cue see fs ‘emt jurisdiction, Judging by fe wording of Anil Ufa as well 36 he nerpeiaion othe Cot of Joie of ‘he corespoing Bssls Comentario 0 Asingush on the one band. Recent ple of peor. ‘mance ad onthe ther had, "the iin gues” ‘Admit, the discon has bene somes Bled = dm Tes kvm ~ in the wry Common cass cas ing contacts forthe divery of gos or the provision of serie beease the Regoltion coins 2 aa sory ‘etna of “te plae of pefomatce ofthe obligation in ‘qustoe” applicable i thse to inp ase-caogois According athe express wording of Ace MIND unless others arcd, the ple of performance oF the blgaton in question shale: ‘nthe eas ofthe sale of goods he place ma Member ‘hte where, under the eon he goods were ‘dor should have Bsn dived ~ inthe case ofthe provision of serves, the place in 2 ember State where, under te cnc, the sores ‘sere prod shoul uve bse sid J aples tthe contrat oles ths provision must ‘ich the cout seed bas the wording of ARK ofthe Cour of ase of feral, isconveient 0 onthe ‘place of peso. ‘ign in queion” some soma lad — foods oF the provision of lance ofthe obligation a Import cas-tegors "Asicle 11) sce of performance ofthe 4s the place na Member 1 the yous were deli rst tne coma. the series tn provide. 1s sited tht emo ton way akan his provisos i thats» an umecesariy cumbersome in Some fespetseileal way of pribing (spleens Biases) jrsieton forthe cou loca tthe place of diver of goods ur provision of services n ms eling tects forthe prison of gos ser. lemtawe th eligi ngustn she pa] wh fo ic nr eed ae ee fats gas” Fr uml incr 3 alg Mon ns ey Vg ue pa int pt cs Xo be ep cp ers Kon a fs thn ee ‘As we sal as, he ovis (Regulation ven of Anish 240) eaves sme qutons ananswsnd, bo pat fo this (and notvthtaoingthe pletion jst nt), the eid ‘esion also repsens 3 cri simplification nese vol ing pods and sere under Ane 100), ‘Masveton 2 Soler (a Engl) and boys B in Poe ‘aga make cori Oth delivery of xin gods fn Pongal on Jan 2° The contact spc the ie ‘ofthe gods, el she pris ob pi bt os rot esate he appleale subway no dee ei nate Frum forthe rslton of das ich mht abe When A deivers the goods (hn Poza on danuy [3°06 cess ep xp forthe A hon ss Bf oymentinanEngishcour, ‘Sine the detent in this ilusration (8) i doce father EU Member Stat (Porat English coun my ‘etch jordin ony in acerdance withthe bases of wisi ad dona bythe Greets Regul, Aric Camber Defend: bv ‘our, place of dno Sie of Regain “Apparent fom loos. bestow jin en i English cour beste [Amile# provi tht tee ie jedi Uke Member Stat ofthe dledan’s domi ik in his ose Pre ‘al-Lats examine wether Arle 7) peovies av aa five tas of siti frthe Engh cour “The chim oncums contn, 0 Arie 11 aps. The ores fo the sal of ood. 50 jrsitin es with he ‘out a he ple of diney of the poo. Daley’ did at take pe in England (no dl the cont provi thatthe soods sould have been delved here so he English cout Feo jarsition under Arties 1) Since no eb urise= dona sis of the Brass | Reputation aps e = ‘am the Engh coat should dss the acto Lie ack of Jricin (ons B apps wo defend wit eomesing th Sursicion ofthe English coun: Arete 2). In Car mw Kee Sst ease C3818) he Cour ‘of Josie dtermined tthe atosomy ofthe ink tors provided for im Article 10ND) pret aplicatn of the Fulks of rst tration I ofthe Membr Sse whore tho acto is bough andthe sustnive which woul be ‘splice trun ete "Tesi an x Blo 3 ‘gins ther conc Car Trin concerned» sak of goods (args and the Court Josie so dena the auton io a the pls of daivey” forthe pupses ofthe fest indent of Arle 16) The tron lls nwo pars Fi, le co sid ist deine hater the ple of elven &“appreafom the povons of the intact ‘Whereis pss w iemy the place of dive in tat enya teens tthe sob appli othe ‘ova, Hat place wh fo be wears De ace ‘where scr de contrac, th goods were deliver or ato ane bron diver Forth purposes oF theft inst of Ariel. Th pop ners a apie of hi trie ld {aban Sec cred Ee El Com See 2 The Brae Rego English cour, because Ironkr ei where pie a oe ean al ou hen ee bic inthis case is Ports ‘aging plac tcl stn nd ceva ae gene “AU roids an aoe ‘sopmd ander eg fmein! ‘sheour Stowe acho lover ans opp be tre Chante Atle 71) apis. The amit is wi the Scand croatian neh the const sw came Pl ot ‘Fagonia wot ‘a any prvikns eating. bot vtec heap contact pode that the tile sabsatve I the pris eto comming the ser) 0 the Enishi pce oF dele ofthe gods th las woe the gods were 7 Siac mo othr ariic- ssi ansered o souk fe Boon pysily was lation pas tbe ee Faved ote porch ind destinon or. ped ‘ise acum for bet of slghly ify he pce whee te pled ak of tou contesting the ths gods ook ple, 383 rs of which the phe tie shoud hav bans eal pose of disposal over thse goods a thei destination ~ is the plas of aliery case ©3808) the Cx Tera purpose of he snd Aa TN), toy ofthe inking ors aes optics of te vette ari tng ete ae cate the Menor Sie where Sith a, Br eta ms Bsa ave La wih wou Be 1 ths el 38 ‘ac (anh it Cr Fm wel ae can gests th fixe whether ft ea ee goods (oifags, andthe Sigsiebaer Seg C86 Ane ah San of te fot inde oF wun 2g Ancitet A, wt is doled and hs 9 cope eng std in Germany” and Ovaer B, who is do led ithe Neha doen prope Gsm tie wate the pice of make a cont forthe preparation uf pas er hee orate of te coe Station of hous Germany, Te conta os at de lace of dtvey a ‘ere the aplcble anne ls oe des designate tive aw aplieable the 2 Frum for the resoaton of dupes which might ae. be epuded a the poce ‘When A deters he pls Bris wo py forthe. A * were dls o old then sos B for paymen ina Gemma cou 13 ofthe Fin indo of Sine the defendant la shi istration (8) domiciled i Dd anaer EU Member Sate (he Netherlands), the Genmen stiay sf igsrsian wert our may exerise juin ony ia accordance wih he spe fal Come Spas tases ofjrticion i don by the Basel {Regulation wpe 2. ridion Le Fa “Onher acts Pheeof _peyormance of feat ‘gestion became Anise 4 provides tha here js jroo inthe Somer Sine ofthe doin domi, hic nthe cine {the Nethesands. Let's earn wheter Arle 71) p> ‘ussan atte bits trietin fethe Geman ur he sain concry 9 coat, Anke MU) apes. The cc is Tor ahs provision o series (preparation of ca Str pts, sori sw he out tthe pla fof provision of theses, Becnune the serves er 1 peprtion of plans. the Geman cou hs rt der Dict 71) trie on sel fr pasten unre ‘ome the pars were prepare Ger ‘ben 2 Slee A (i Deas) and Bayer B tn Seem) make a.conraet oth sl owe in Fae. ‘The conact dest dsignate te applicable sbstaice las. nor st dha Frum forthe ation fae moe which gare: Whor A tara esp ia the house BB ess 1 pay the fil ice bsg the ‘shi om alleged det. Athan os Tor payee of ‘hernia Dish cour Since the leg tin startin Ani T1Xb) fe Bas feb | Regulation = fe the dfn of te the pase of mance ofthe obligation in queston~ applies ony to cre tras fe the ae of goods oF he provision of services (ie nna sch a those in Mlirions 2 and 2), the Ae TUX) mated cannot be wed to provide a sia Single Selauon for dering the jursition in eases inven: ‘othr (hinds of contacts In Tet, tin cases concerns ‘tr contrat than cot fer the sale of goods o r= ‘Sono ers (ch the orc fr he sae of hase ‘asin 2) at heaton of Ack M1) ofthe Reg= tion fmt compe, Asters actions bse on sch eter conte (sich she ont forthe sl oa howe raion 2), jurson is wih th cout tthe pce oF perormance 0 he olga tin in question” Ws hie exprevsion in tbsecion (a) OF ‘Aicle 1) of he Regulation means can Be gleaned Fo he sed decided under Ail (1) ofthe Brussels Cam “6 eres junction the tris lich hase ‘hater Arik 71) yo Ale 70) apis. The we the semen wee he tor as jreicionwede ‘Sem. rk) ad Bayer 8 in ‘sl ofa house in Fane the applabesubstnive ‘forthe revlon of ie tse ori he fl rc, basing the sn cs B for pet of ‘ick 7011) ofthe Bs jon — apps onl 0c ison of series ins 27a 2) te Ale roving Bes in eas fave, itis in cies concering oF Arce 70) af the Reg hor ora (uc he "tration 2) istion elon of the bli ‘Sion in subsection (of ‘a be lene rom the ) of the Brissls Cove ion ioe tp rm epg nr, no: yorernd ty Amisha 18-21) the od fle in Arle ID) of the Cone tion as pleased esc some ee a the woe Regul Wn rain Avgle Talend in Feo Petting © Noe. tinhins (ese C-S3807) the Coun of lass con Fimed Hut wh is aou) Arial a) must Be iat in accordance with he Anse 51) Cosenton ese, So inorder deters whtbr he Dah ent rin 2h hs juicson under Anicle 1) of the Regulation we Tis ne ee the ovat Conventn ease “The case” Anil (1) maha” (hic msn apa insu ther eas under Atle 11) Fen Prati ler Lindwrat (ese C3807) best unesond ts 8 teptyap proces Ste we ca hal tin the poe ‘of perfomance’ ofa gen etigaon witout Knowing which Saigon we ae aking about the st sep mist Beto ignteh “egton ingestion In De Bla + Boer (ese 14196 hs Cou of asc eid hat he “obligation question fem tin Arie (0) ‘fhe Cone was he coat oligtion forming the bas ofthe eal pocelings” iste obligaion which cor responds contrac ah on wich he plas li te rt 2h the pals ee py a ee Spy cca las essa en Big etetrn nd 2 hnene D en Ba Spence Ama Hisbese tse OS Having dcermind the ‘obligation in question’ the Danish Forum cout in Msn 2h can the proceed 1 He est scp wtih is deemine which watnal fre) toe shouldbe appli deeming the pace of peronman” of that abligatn. Acco to Tes Dunlop, the Danish Forum cour mast apply the conice-ans hae) Sip fia fama bo of css Gives ofa esi metal ‘Sup 3: Darin ep of pePrmance es apie a ths foo ort determine he sph ble sane const a (a ery cy sige the mous Tol» Dal ae 1276) the Couto use decid that fr the parpoes of “Aric (1) of te Bro Camnetion pla of pf ‘rome of the blgaon 1 uti rust be tend in ‘Teorey tthe fh gave the obleaton in pon ascring tte so eto ws Fhe cout {Roe whic he ater browsht This teense in Tesi Deny athe law whic gover he ligation in ques ina eterence 1 he appicbe) nao sis cena fs And Bocuse sane cmt aw varies Hom ln to acter, the dis in Tes Drip esi a fle tat Forum coun mht well be resi 4 make = hoi of lo bore termining the ‘lao prorance ej pars, “the fm cont il ny ke ch ee a na eh opting ea esi bv ier on ewe (Bh beston n Ane Hh ete a alt ‘Soha wth tpn orem (he ot Ina comvaca ips sch sth ane seb in Ms 2h the chiceafaw res sppicabe in Desa ae Tho ofthe Rome Conneain (8 Ch. 3.2} Since the pans ‘ave made no aycement on the substantive fw apple © fico, the gaping ale in Ale 4 of te Rose onventon dtemies th pial bw ce Ch. 3.2440. UUnr that provision, tbe applicable Iw f the of the ounuy wit which the contact is most clsly come td since the subject mater of the conti igh nin movable propery presumed that the contact i os oely conse withthe county where he imowabh Fropety ste, ve, hee rane fellows tht French Ta pis Unde Fen ns, deis are ger o Be pid at the bt fs residence, chin Maran 2h i in Swen. This Irene tat Soon (oat Denman the “alse pie 110 deseo the app $ Tesi Dunlop (ox that foe the purposes von. he place of par ‘vems the oigation iit offs ofthe co This etree Fel obligation in guest ‘et fw ates fom ne si Dal lary The eajced to ake a se lace of psfmanee one desert in ho splcable in Dona ae Eh, 3.2). Sie the pats tnt law apie Amick 4 of the Roe ok (ue Ch 324A), te ae isthe aw of the ‘ict consly eae eet a im y uhore the imeable {eI flows at Fesnch yw be plat de ee in 2h ie Sweden. This ie the “plce of per mance ofthe obo inquest (the bane’ ejtion to asthe pico ie hows) So he Dah our has no jistion under Arik i) 19 string A sin. Ad sn no ote rit bi the Brel | Regulation apps to be lean te Danish at shou sme the atom fr ak of uri (ks B apps to defnd witht cortating th ero f the sah cour stele 26 th Bisel Revaltoo) Sop to tb pl pies er pp a Asay emphasis he ease ofthe Cou ste a theabigaon a qeain’ part of Arle (ofthe Bross CCoevtion ws ply vertu bythe lege hen the Brel | Repltion we atapd. Only i thers category of “or eons i arian to be dee bry when contacts forthe delivery OF goad o te Provisin of series ae ao specify rogue Arik TuRbyat te Replat, ‘e's a Ch 2230) aa pment wo ep emacs ‘Spe rl leo rn (hese ew hoe by Tah er 20 53 1 tou be ler by oon that are ss be taken when nr pring Arce 7() ofthe Bross {Regulation an he basis Sr eases rating to Ate tL a the Dnt Conse tion Revers, many inporant pects ae al ood tw within 2 residual ace nas by the amend to Resoltion ‘ews ile Relesenesof ror Chap 2 doin Lamp af cha abe yet eh ‘acme ar Ds ars eral Ts Da ‘Shotts ag cms rs coma hs ‘hs Den Breed ol pile ow ‘one ar ic oe Soho ep ‘daa peo parooc ih te ting of rie ‘aria Cenc begin enn earn n= See fir ere fe comma ce i ‘Seta ere ph lg Ba a igen rig toa cts ping ee 3th ess pment es, Tey 2 ear ee oi tr ty te osc So rt 2 ‘se oti Dy Bn Bath ot Sh Ana aa te pif ca ue om a he ‘escany [en awe pcp cm ae eee ‘atts poesic cos pay aur rie crs nig me ‘eke og ool rn of ies sy a ce wa ‘hoi fr Snug sep on ed [Scraps clare ps a anc or ce Sober srs in ator le Atay re ms eng ‘tt tro ao gn rt ‘Sree Shou chr ie Blt pe on app ‘Seis amiedhy eames of i) Gar rock Lee € 66) lt ya sn pr fan gs pi Geos rey of Inte yee for wc ens Them asc Den le SEGA Grn tn sma na Arle 10 of eas Rein te cr into tees! le fr vin sn Math ‘Shi (empl an ch ene theca ni aston ‘ar cae hot cao ee ce eth thee le ery sch be Serine te ts ‘Sore ree aso ing so ehh ‘Repeal pce ef Ser hepsi mee ot me | ‘un frbepiccaalney oft in te ac Cpr oe C2000 Con | Sin ec pei a ng Cpa abetio a eal pm chai. 2 Decal Tosa Dato Sart tne goes tal av ined ‘eaten ete create aso te am pont oe an ‘Anil (1) ofthe Brass 3 Repution i ot all espe Seltesplansiog and hee ate hse icean nly be sc Ope ise ele alla to the ‘meaning ofthe wordy "ures okensse grein the opening Senlenee of supa razap (b) of Arce, Another the {uncon osu) fh) ks He aes es who rises el cee ahr ‘Miprasaph esl obo Ase i} en Sete: bt Bo ‘prepare ) a no Folate tows. stm on EU None Sia sa bose) oan fener De Bar Bow york ow eof pen oh fg cl of dio eon there act ster ea aide) ls ac Nebr Seo hp wd s he sel Re Caper 2 ert Speman te Alert e fatvem ream Prorat tong Anite ana se ons tpn of ae The pe oF Engl ie Are #06 Be Repo oI pera BS Asa “ens she gp Tain ov 2 “mtrani a C8 yee Cade mat a pacgogs isha a poy ‘sng ns eat ob mi ne whe mn {te ac dined 1 fe Ae Hone ‘ise at peng sa vn hee ase ‘nese aoe Arie ye i a wb oe Seiten ct a a Ther le ya ow le Aa Baio Clases “The discussion in Ch. 222A) has dea with te importante ‘supplementary ele ip Ave 1) ofthe Brus 1 Resa ior he specie jrsionl fase which apis slongside the general jarsdctonalrle of deinda's Som n mi testelaingtoa cone ‘he Ani 7) rei supplemonary aot only bees provides an alematve othe gen defendant's domicile Joraitonal bse, bu a beat bth of thos ridicton- a bases apply absent aecmcn, ie absent an acerent br he pac ay ow hi ana out shoud ave he ‘suthority. onthe excite autor, odd given di ‘Aricle 25 ofthe Brusett Regulation. which coors rus grcments, lls within the Regulation heating “Proogton of uriteon” Act, Anite 25 deals not ony with pro= ogi, Sch cones jasieion on a yen cou but so ‘wi eeagaron. whereby coun is deprived ofthe junsic- on which tree woul ae Ait 25 deals with eyes jurictoal agement choice ‘of for clases eens tse he as Aisle 6 s rte th ca srs pee ‘et a 5 et withthe impart ofthe Brel 1 Rosle -e which apps slngside e's deci tary not only Besse it veal deenduas domiie oth of thos tition ie absent an agreement ‘oma our shoud hae he say, odie a given di jon wich conc Fru don heading “Frovgation 5 deals ot oly wth pro ton a given cour bt also 1 deprived of te jr. fa etina apremens chice she th pares Ale 26 ls ih appearance: at appearance ya Selina ho ‘hes tenth juin othe x est ‘ern compo die the dpi ‘Geneely speaking the fa Us frum assem ar ered ‘hob cette pares a depending onthe eusane ‘rated eo, confine the widely apie ext 9 ‘nocual feedom As Sang pn th ps ne e842 take hi oun areca it supe thee Io eee the leter of ter etree ee nn pia Before procwding witha more deta esmintion ofan sgroments sr Arie 25. should be noted ta th Re Tati comin speci es (Ais 13, 19.23 an 24) which Ti the xt to wich artis ea contac pt ot ‘he junta les etre appliances ing to insures, consume cote, ons lym an trans of movable prop. In this wa. ‘stun juts prisons are ead the tts of ‘mardi rs om which the pis esta ors Anather preiiary pin to be nated once the fst of tm expres agrment nt 0 form ~ but hr 3 othe pac of prtomnce"of he obligation in question, The sue hee 1s wheter so an agree ese 10 the Ace 7) jraictonal tae, wll ander he eos f tha ple compete odie the spt, ths ecvey ypasing the Tonmal (ring te) reqorements of Ace 25 (docu below). The answer wo Ms question, scoring 0 dion he Coun of sien Zeger Sain (a. 1 es, Zur Sa 0, ome Sa pte ae etcen Me Ze tM Canaan Me it Mes a) ea {test sil be tg os an fe i Zo 6 aie pio ni, cot ‘ota ss jin $item es ta fra co ss reat Mahi de aie ‘greene le 2: Chee of EU cones deve 25 Conese per 2st onl ates - — sth Cot pac han aura hs ei Inpatient pe eam A ‘itt Rein wi ete zee tione 8 Aicle 25 ofthe Brusels | Regaton applies 1 fous sgrsmcls cole jrsction ov ane of mur COURS ‘more EU Member Stes, Uner Arie 2, the jr ‘ison conf on the court or mts chosen sensi, nes he pans ake aed eters. ‘Stance sto foc. petty aed (Ch. 388 ‘luc roubsher pclae he p as e Satan tamer eee cRipacin queen oy th re etm “Te coe of Aricle 25 ofthe Brel { Regulation sly sip Ihe patie, rear ofthe bile hae alta ‘cou orth cots of a Member Stat aes have ji font ste any dss whch have aren o whieh may tien eonaeton wih» pacar gal reatonship. ht ‘oun or those courts sal ive juriiction, ule the roonat nln oi oe Substance under he a Df hat Member Swe. Sch jrsiton shall be excisive ‘nes he pari ave aged eee Unser Amie 25. he pais — regress hr cance xjoy slot uated contact freedom to age om he Forum fr ipa esos. Prsied ein bs oie rent te t= (1 at the piss oacemed have age 2) tha the court or court chosn are nan EU Meer Sie or Ses. and (3) that he forum agent cones pacar ag rationsip~ the partis" chove of court must be gen fe. Conversl thee no reuse of sy euonestion borne the pais ote dispte andthe chase run. 22, The rose Regulation ert on fe eo pi ms es nina, panaro nagar ac wsapts ‘pation applies 4 fun Inder Act 25, he puis “hing to Anse 255) an seme ofan jettin ours chase is waite, ‘ith fom pat fp tl wae pc ‘son he et ne fhe peastsh $n. woman oe ‘huni a sel | Repltion fly The la semanc of Ace 281) ofthe Regulation enue: Revs 2c the yy in Which panies may Yall ke 2 Forum a ome, have apron tat gums these are tainly decribed ay rogues Sat are ob rise ‘vith pet oral veld Fe aur ase in quesion ‘ave ee o eh loos nt sts hese rien, frum spre na ular egal elatonship, tht omided 1 have buon vail condi To be foray ‘ve Jursiction, uns the ‘ald he aru apc in question mus be eitie: ‘esubstance unr he a fsdiction sal be exlsive (0) inwrag o [conc only and confined awit ernie (bi farm which ecords wih proces which th pa teas of tir cance tes ave eaablshed twee hemes oF 21 ccd to aceon the (6) insertional wade or comme, a3 form which fied ein basi ei accords witha wage of whch the parts ae o aught concerned have agree, 2) to have bom ae nd which in such tae or con an EU Member Sate of Ieee wily known to, and rely cbse by et cancers parila Paris 0 contact of te tp inva the partic dice of ourt mut be ten [Grade or commere concer. ‘Semen of any connection ‘nth chosee fm, 7 atin Emmi mae vig Solo Roting Th Regulation exes poids tht any communicate by come means Which provides © dale eed OF he ‘remorse Besa wring: Ake 26.2) “The foal rapa onan Arie 25 athe esl ‘a long deslopii inslving ba eine ond jail inerenton, The comsponing provision of the rial 41968) Brusseh Conceton lied th parts” choice of Foe on ares in ering” oan ofl gress on aed in wen “The ata Engh ef rte 240) he gto we ‘hang or teed msg Hwee ae a oe set) get lo aps fl a penn ig ‘ame apc atid rng aa 9H Ena Scat Cr othe ea dans ‘Be Cf be othe Ewen Un he op po ‘A leading se he iteration of the “in wing’ we ‘quien sil rev in cts where oe aloes id ‘kon by Atle 3) ofthe Reultion are aot abe i Sus © RCW (ese 24/7) aise. the pats had coe ‘hued rien const of sle of gos sig by bh partes, The sells standard condos, incline ‘Sats in Taaur of the gout in Colgne (Germany). were Printed onthe bck ofthe corr, wih, however di a ‘xpress condos. Prior othe consi of the conc thelr hd se writen oles whi exes felon othe std conn, The conc sg by th pais refemed to he aecompanying er with which those oe a ban se (On reir rm he Gena cour sis he has of the form us. he Court of use the Europsan Union te tha wheres cave conferingjurition Is inched song the gece condos of sk af ene of the paris ‘rid one hae os contr, the quirement of a weing nde (hat is ow) Anise 241K) of the Braet | Regul ton alle "on the ent sign sh paris on hans an espes moonce a those ger copdions” le he fous oF conc coneied ty serence lo oer oi a any communication by 2 dumber the ting: Ale 390, fn Ao 25 at the est ath loge adja frovison of the ogra ‘ean agreement cone Sina it ee ap of the in ring? = oe ter alomties id Talon are nt abi 5 Sos. the pf eo ‘of gmt. signed by bath Tins inci frase olgue (Genny, Were hehe, bower did mo Pre wo the ersasion of ton ofers whichespesly “The coma sid by the vg er wih ic tose ‘ut sie onthe ass of ‘of the European Union 1 jrsteon 5 ele Sle of ene a the paris, ‘© reuiement of ing Yotthe Bice | Repl signed by at pane eo bpeveral codons” In the rence to ear ofr swlck were thematic ands with sefeenes 4 te ami Contin of ane of he pac ncn lt comin Jon hen tng regimen st “os he reframe e4pes ani ca heteloe be cock 95 © pa xan esol ie Maran 2 Danish company A wakes avis 40 sell eran gods to Gamat base BB so nee acceptance WA. reerng wo A'S fer ands B's gett onions of wae Bs general coniton contin rns ‘tne in fvou ofthe Geman cous. B's wena end. ‘ons ate nt supe with te aeseptane, at a Bed ‘om B's Inmet whos, Whon dst consring pap aie A ings an actin in Denmark against saraon 3: Swish beer A sends a wsinen eatin ‘i 10 French sll Bo he pt’ or coms le, ‘The writ sntonation es wo A's sme xeone of tae, wich contin a Toru close fv of the Swash cous. B signs an tums As rien coli: ‘on of he contact thereby. assoring fo te gene ‘esto conimation,scepting the odin et Incase ie train 2, whore reference go on Aon conning a Fru clase sa sign By bth otis. the"inwetngreirement ner in Slr v ACMA, islet not sso. Thal raja woul, howe, BS ‘sf na ease ike Ml etn 3 ee am expres rel nce geen eomlton consining Tom cause signed by both pans In. Berghe Gn & Co KG ¥ ASA 54 ease 22118 the {Cour of Juice hell thal where justo is confee by 28 ‘ame orl agin ete Ihe pots oa give cna the formal requirements of Arle 17 (no 251) ae sai. edi one ny (iter ome) sens a writen confianaion of ‘mac aproment io ke eer (been ass mo eet). ‘sg end: pen ms ine ‘pei stn ice ht he ports ve maa ee ‘fo opr soa tere bic cai on le Tee ‘im ne a se yt par The ato » Oral erexment confi wre 1s pendens dk meni ‘wins nein Ba be as the hep ti b> Inprchodim wt eo “The engin! Ane 17 ofthe BrsslsConsetion was sbse- uel amen bythe 1978 Conveation a the Accesso Sf Dens land andthe United ing w th 1968 Convention and again bythe 1989 Congtion (onthe Ac ‘son of Spun an Port). Te 1973 version oF te ak feline th ting roe permting SO a ars Jn incmstions ade or commer in afr whe c= eds whe procter commese of which The pris are or ough oho Bsn ava “The 1989 erson expand the wording of is ue witht, however, aging ts subse, {anioyande. ewe ag ral O65 ve 0 ‘Seman ta or amen) 178 ad {ec tenal en ces soon nh Cente bd 6 aay es mt pee) Te is Se {eta sea wacom ramdonge he Br ‘ein Tacring i he dis fe 126 Asien Coon, te irae ft igo ron te he Com oc ‘Rape Ul cacy te cans ‘oreo te sha) dade dd “See sir mera sete ss panes ‘Statty tema frac acne mst acting make. Aor Ineo ean fh 98 Accson Cena he wade of ‘Minus (ane ws ied by Ane thse = ‘nen letra Sao Gast) nile 312)44) of the Repuation is a saplement to the Regal’ nea ls ponder re ia Arche 29 (ee Ch 2rT above). Aisle 312) ponds that wen form agree- nen under Aris 28 confer exclave urisiion on 2 ‘ember Sate cout. any cour of another Member Sate sha fey the pocecing nl sch ea th xt sigma by ry 22 The Buses! Reunion sn w die we se ‘he Fru are cares ht hs a juris ar A tne a Bremen Wh the coat desi in the run her ee a yreren has essed jrsdton in accotanes with he fghamem ay cout ol ather Member Sate sul line jardhton i vc srs 42-Pase Slots dergae reanthe genta sist frat ses in Arist 29: When ane Ft cours seed has else uri ie puseant ws forth spect under Aris 25 tha cout ests to dele hehe give tht agrees fs tepals of whathr it was the cs fk ace ss Common a - Sentioe fon the Assess lad King Yo the 558 9 Canon (othe A= ermitig als an ape ‘ade orconmer of which Shogercmspeuiion nn Amun shan siding f his re without, ih ele (ep The Brussels | Regu does ot preci from aes Cho nme iSelect es cui Eap atest Sly he Repation dc sek rep te des ona the chossn not EU Mb Sas cua fo what 7 Aceon Convene fr nt (he non-EU Membr Sine coun shoul give eet oat eo Omen to. forum agement which pps o con sition oo ‘Not undone om that our Absent resty rangers with the Sate gu Shun a aon nee ‘ion tha Stas ove a wl goer at sso, ‘nick ofthe Comet on Potapssuprsingy, the Regultion des no pap to = le the decison be tan by ah EU Monte Sate coat cosa wth sh form apexment itr Consus. itsscm tata Meme Sate whose cours wou have had juin aber greement cin apy own 40 dtr is 4 supplement to te le in Ace 29 (ee Ch, S aataas eros rie in which cicumsiances (i any) Hs cours should pve ‘the jrtictoa os 6 effete an agement esgtng a non-EU forum (nd di ‘other oie Se all rissa actin rot a at Member Sate fr ak of jor jeter drape Aon, joo tha Merber Sate cou cn spy sow a to determine in wich eeumstanees the fm 6 opr 2 tao Siemens rae a ocd should be ign a juition ascepie i avarice ‘ith poisons ofthe Relation ori acon wi fairl lw fhe defen snot diced in an EU Mem ber Stat) See Cored «Handi (ase C3898) 1 usage 19 open i On vc (ese UND), Ene provid that parson ‘om ina Mer Sate ny be sd in anor Meer Sate in mater rating wo ot delet quasi, in the ts fr the pice hte the ham evetaccured im ecw As vith he Anise 71) le hich pies to obiigatins of 2 ‘aca rate, te Ace 72) eserves 5 a supplement fo the dlendan's domi ron st fh in Ail 39 BU dominy may ao nly Be ua a th place he oe In soesng te place ofthe harm eceurene, the dates af th Bre Conenton hose a wel tor fos bleu bse, ad ins frmulaon comsponde ote tonal tons of many European jrsictions, Tere tao 8 iy fant eomecion fete his jure ss a the Wie ly seeped confictoF as principle aplible in cases of tor thereof kot dei, he ofthe eau which the elsatatsand evens ok place (Ch. @ » accep ascodane for in aceon vith domiciled nan EU Me ooo (ease C2810, aco Fh aa son proses tha person fot wr quate, the haem even gece 0 plist oligations of susowes 23 pement ‘nso fo in Arle ae teat the plea the ter. o 1 oceurenes he aes sella ene Te this comesponds oe ational te Teri ls i Sena base and he io le appieabie in aes of {ofa omy in which etch, As regan the stsuantve cope ofthis jason sb {Ca of Hse as red tht a ip nsstson tr be used wo termine which relat oe eit over al cons which sock t ess Hab sl wh arena rbd tea omit ihn te Maing Ack HU Kale Sear ese 1898 In same cases i ray not be eit in which pac the am fuleventcanbe si toss That fr insane te cane the at that eases the damage is eri ou 9 ile ‘sory rm wh the da occ, he fs B+ ‘ine ee posed ace (ease 276, oes com pny (Bin) in he Neheands clined to sian damage esse of politon ofthe rer Rhine cased By French mining conn foe up the wer Bor sd! the mining company in he Nethands. The justia! question was {hs Should "the ace where the harmfi event nese Bs tindersond obs wher the polation was allege commited (France) or wert antag an alee Ie Neth)? The Coun of Fuse ofthe Eurpcan Unione et whee the plc ofthe pening of he eve wich ype ie © ayn on, lito gsi athe place whee at ‘ventas in danage at not Mente th expres ple ‘shor the Rann even occured” mint te uRdon) 5 boing inend to cover both the place where the damage cued andthe ph ofthe ever giving st 20 a the efedae may be sed, a the oon othe pa. in he ‘sous forth thes pass o Ince Phae of han hur 2 Joie Toe wen aston 2° ce eine ioang 8 mery-£0 round in an anaetent pk in Don park the overs ‘rer A pis damages bey Whos Ben inured. The Inery-gorovid ad bos supe by compan he athens) and ennui by company Cin el ‘hm, Aegina the ache vases By 8 li the meres brings aio a Denmark gaint Bnd soking nes forthe ages pid oe os. Sins tis fa ar relng owt! the pit in Mas ti 2 in hoo to su in Denar where the dana he boys nj) acer. Aine « Pans foe C1) cece Hee aie Sly ol Sein sey sal Gamay The Seu tafe Ss by ne Asn Smet Kale ‘Grn. he Ct of ie ih he ae te i ‘Sth amage sth ewe eal ace pode atuen mamta Con oe neat tt ps ‘lingo qos hs pce eon srs iy ons Pan foe C2510) Cal fe ra na ag ope fen rea Str Ste ace af tee ane a eyed {ma rat surance web pring ia ums dui sar Mer Sie) a ‘She fer a Member ch ea ‘eke mpl i fame ot ows he Sei Sea Uiepine octet a enc ofc 5 “The words or may oe i Anil 12) wee ides by the 2000 Bruel Replat, bet this seems to reps a ‘lation and ciifeaton ofthe meaning of the cig Conseson re “Tus in Ss de pre ors, pi st ah {rice tam st hl nt eam ed pete ‘agit aul en Ferme Fre Ki Senor Hal fowe €16D. i cri the ‘een fe rence Cai, Cou of Desc a at {ie oonadmnt oe nt 0} naa ot orn. senna os 174 Sone tc st ge {Sbvint Ales tc Comes en sc be 6 nt xohing meng. Denar th one i ‘sho ass jr. Th wl by company 8 (nthe by compiny © tin 3 sss cated by a det in stan n Detar as amoes pd othe 1 the pin in Mase tk, whe the damage he Cepia ve ig © 12) were ited by this seems to reps 3 2 msning ofthe oral a the pai og bt ‘aly cored ad pene Se ‘tteaps a Defamation ibe slander i spect fon wht the damage sams’ rpuston) eset ange I s theelore sometimes diel to deaminase the hana et eccred” sich tac Ap ase ering defamation in newspaper ales wan gen By the (Courant in Shei «Pres tance ese C-6893, tree Min A nnd cm ames ii teat Satie engi . rin Ul nga le an ae ton urbe aor pe oars beh 2 eet Enon Wats oto) Pepin ose Eg Feteton dog es uc ne a oe “The Cour o sic el that he siti o's ibe by 2 nes paper snick distribute in sow Member Sas may’ ring De Bree Defias: print ‘med an ction oe daoges asthe publisher, ether (1) ane the cout te ember Ste ofthe place whe the publish fads lamas pbtcaion i exis. which he Scion w aval damages oral he hi ated byte ‘aman, (2) bre the courts of each Nem Se Schick the publication wt sited and where the vim ims to fave sul ij 1 is he eatin. which Fave jurtion orale in espe thc ar sed in the Sato th couse ‘Recent dane ocd coun he le the ‘en win ga rand et hc ig ha ae mak ‘Suet eran neo eas ap these eas fen ef oe droge ie se A hominy in rus it pen at go ame 2 ‘Srl pt oma vs rat abt Mh Co ‘i gre "ines i yep nie it see ‘hcg Sins te pao em ing ew age (Tee eee nr pr oe ne {pm nse at he ple se he el ‘Serhan mh Web ns lpi SS These hp whee ber of edt ‘ato ead en te ie ain a ‘one dargts be roby ee. [1 eps nrc dg cee pe a he “So shiny en dogs ing io el > ‘Rint abe bam ets api. Sine ee om nce Il tag pose ian oe 2 stn pion he ent et ed ‘Foams mr ep pan sein lcs ee ‘cto dar heb vier rowe ne pas. Sarit usar fh Cong See he ‘hin tr nee i eli ween ‘igen So es ti, Sitiocerams he soqemen of sand anita Jue tus ft ni of sparen ree 30 A {Seay nt Rep he ssf eh Contig St hc ibe tnney mat ow ra ne ‘im citm ohne steed ny repo ot Thebes pel meh lod a on Si ad Neier of creping ane, abies sits 0) bone ‘place wher the bl 5 cablshsd. which ve 3 arm catsed by he ech Member Stat ‘sland whee the von $e her rpusion, shit sect kar cael in "becom rtp he stb cot tegh hep he iy sane Are 43 32, AMG ae ali du gs 9 hn dt 1 shook be ned tse Sheil ing o hs joriston the couts of ea Stew rie soley hepato ey suse in ht Site applies wo ets zeal ano ju 0 detain sce) Spxring +H Hon! case CNT) In this way. Sheil» Pre lane costs important relnemen ofthe Bier ruling. makin ler ta the cue forth plas af th ve ging eto the dan hs uri icon in spt ofthe eine sage, wheres the cous fr tne pace whe te danage oe hae uration sy in pet of har ease in ths Sate ae eu see. OF ous, thi refinement Fkvan al i tho 98 whore rap: has eceured ia oe than oe Sa. Moscow 21: Dish company sks to wach crn music's in Geen and England, Sued com lain coyrgh o the is ction, ts thang 1's ates eater ino hensing agreements wih i ‘iba nthe said course. A etmmenes poses in Denmark guint B, claiming damages forte alps vind interne wih 4's makeing eons Ina case ike loan 2 here woul! not be 8 basso jsition in Der but the pun could shoo fo sa in England i spot ofthe eae ot sls) ina outs an in Gans regis he damage in at county A ately, the poi oul bring at action in Swe (he ek domi) Secking rode othe whol In 2011 the Coun of sce sed jog in which it

    You might also like