Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. UNWRITTEN
The first important feature of the British Constitution is its unwritten character. It is true that
there are several written parts of the British Constitution, like the Magna Carta, Bill of
Rights, Reforms Acts, Parliamentary Act of 1911, etc. But the unwritten parts far
outweigh the written ones. As a matter of the fact, there is no single document which
can be said to contain the general principles of political governance. These principles
have remained scattered and no attempt has ever been made to embody these principles
in a documentary form.
2. EVOLVED CONSTITUION
The British Constitution has evolved gradually and developed from age to age,
expressing itself in different charters, statutes, precedents, usages and traditions. It is
the oldest among all existing constitutions. The British Constitution has not undergone
drastic or radical transformations and whatever changes have taken place, they have
been made in conformity with the basic constitutional structure.
3. FLEXIBLE
The power to make and amend the constitutional law is vested in Parliament and the
procedure is the same as that required for the enactment of an ordinary bill. There is
no special law for passing a constitutional law. It must be mentioned here that despite
the simplicity of its amending process, any government would bring about changes to
the constitution with utmost caution as it remains responsible to the people.
4. UNITARY FORM OF GOVERNMENT
The British Constitution is a unitary and not a federal one like that of the United States of
America or India. Although there is devolution, yet all authority flows from the Central
Government centred at London. In recent years, a national Parliament in Scotland, a
national Assembly in Wales and a national Assembly in Northern Ireland have been
created. This process transferred varying levels of power from the British Parliament
to these assemblies. However, the final authority over the devolved institutions rests
with the British Parliament itself. Parliament is constitutionally supreme. The local
areas, as they exist in Britain, derive their powers from the Acts of Parliament which
may be enlarged or restricted at its will. The local government machinery is merely an
agent of the Central Government. If The Parliament so desires, the Parliament can
abolish the whole complex structure of local government by a single enactment.
5. PARLIAMENTARY FORM OF GOVERNMENT
The British Constitution provides for a Parliamentary form of government as distinct from the
Presidential form of government. The Monarch is the nominal head of the State. He
has been deprived of all his powers and authority. The real executive is the British
Cabinet headed by the Prime Minister. The Cabinet is composed of Ministers who
belong to the majority party in the House of Commons and they remain in office so
long as they enjoy its confidence.
6. CONSTITUTIONAL MONARCHY
Britain has a constitutional monarchy and a constitutional monarchy is not incompatible with
democracy. This is because essentially the powers of the monarch as head of the state
– currently Queen Elizabeth II – are ceremonial. The most important practical power is
the choice of the Member of Parliament to form a government, but invariably the
monarch follows the convention that this opportunity is granted to the leader of the
political party or coalition, which has majority in the House of Commons.
8. BICAMERAL LEGISLATURE
The House of Lords is the second chamber, or upper house, of the United Kingdom’s bi-
cameral (two chamber) Parliament. Together with the House of Commons and the
Crown, the House of Lords form the UK Parliament. In comparison to Rajya Sabha,
the House of Lords is a weak house. Rajya Sabha has equal powers with Lok Sabha,
as far as an ordinary bill is concerned
9. DELEGATED LEGISLATION
Secondary legislation is law created by ministers (or other bodies) under powers given to them
by an Act of Parliament (primary legislation).Secondary legislation is also known as
'delegated' or ‘subordinate’ legislation and often takes the form of a statutory
instrument.
10. COMMITTEE SYSTEM
Committees may be of three kinds – committees of the whole house, special committees and
standing committees. At one time all bills were referred to committee of the whole
House, but since the reform of the standing committee system in 1968 most of them are
now referred to standing committees. Special committees are appointed on an ad hoc
basis and consist of not more than 15 members. The standing committees are the
essence of the present committee system and they have three distinct functions which
may be described as legislative, financial and investigative.
11. SPEAKER OF THE HOC IS NO PARTY MAN
Unlike the Speaker in the US House of Representatives, the post is non-political and indeed,
by convention, the political parties do not contest the Parliamentary constituency held
by the Speaker .The position of the Speaker is a position of great prestige and dignity.
In UK, there is a convention that once a Speaker, always a Speaker. It means that a
Speaker’s constituency is unchallenged. Once a person is appointed as a Speaker he
gives formal resignation from his political parties. He has a casting vote and ultimate
disciplinary powers with respect to the conduct of the House and MPs.
According to Dicey, is due to the existence of the Rule of Law. It implies, firstly, that no one
in the United Kingdom can be punished arbitrarily. The powers of the government are
exercised according to settled and binding rules. It guarantees security of life, liberty
and property. Secondly, Rule of Law implies that no one is above the law. It means that
irrespective of their social and official status all citizens are equal before law and that
every one is amenable to the ordinary court for any violation of the law. That is why
there is no separate administrative court for the government officials in Britain. The
citizens, the courts, the administrative officials, the Monarch are all subject to the
ordinary law of the land. Accordingly, the judiciary is the guardian of the liberties of
the people in Britain.
Conventions are known as unwritten maxims (rules) of the Constitution. They provide
flexibility and avoid amendments.Most constitutions of the world have conventions. A
necessary corollary to the unwritten character of the British Constitution is that
conventions play a very vital role in the British political system. For example, while the
Queen has the prerogative to refuse assent to a measure passed by the British
Parliament, but by convention, she doesn’t do so and the same has become a principle
of the constitution itself.However, the legal status of conventions is subordinate to the
written law. Courts in Britain retain certain powers:
The upper chamber or the House of Lords is primarily composed of hereditary peers.
The existence of these hereditary institutions may seem to go against the democratic
ideals so dearly cherished by the British people. Yet the British have never been in a
mood to abolish these historic institutions.
1. WRITTEN CONSTITUTION
American constitution is a written constitution framed in 1787 and enforced in 1789. It consists
of seven articles; three of them related to structure and powers of Legislative (Article
1), Executive (Article 2) and Judiciary (Article 3) and the other four dedicated to
position of states (Article 4), modes of amendments (Article 5), supremacy of national
power (Article 6) and ratification (Article 7). It also holds that constitution is the
supreme law of the land. Article one is the longest and cannot be amended. Like other
constitutions, it also consists of preamble; a single sentence that introduces and defines
purpose of the document.
2. BRIEF CONSTITUTION
While American Constitution is the shortest (of any major government in the world) and the
first written constitution, India’s Constitution is the lengthiest written constitution in
the World. It is a brief document of 15 pages containing only 4000 words. If we add
the amendments, the total number of words becomes 6000. The Constitution consists
of just 7 Articles and only 27 amendments. When we compare it with the Constitution
of India, Constitution of Japan, Constitution of Switzerland, and other major
Constitutions of the world, we find the American Constitution a very brief constitution.
The makers of the Constitution made it brief to avoid any controversies which may
unnecessarily lead to further problems. Since the Constitution is brief it has helped it to
mould itself according to the changes of time.
3. RIGID
It is one of the most rigid constitutions in the world which means that for amending it,
special and difficult procedure has to be followed. It consists of 2 steps;
Proposal for Amendment:
Either two-third (67%) of both the houses (Senate and House of Representatives)
shall propose for amendment to constitution or on the application of legislatures of two-third
(67%) states shall call a convention for proposing amendment.
Ratification of Proposal:
The amendment shall be ratified by the legislatures of three fourth (75 %) of all states
or by the convention of three fourth of states.
It is because of this rigidity that American constitution has been amended only 27 times in
over 200 years.
Congress has the power to make laws which outline general policies and set certain
standards. President can enforce, execute and administer law. He is assisted by his
cabinet but is solely responsible for all actions of Executive branch. Judicial
Powers are exercised by the Supreme Court which interprets laws and decided cases
and controversies in conformity with the law and by the methods prescribed by law.
9. CHECKS AND BALANCES
The system of Checks and Balances laid down by the separation of powers prevents misuse
of powers. The powers are provided in such a way that it provides a check upon other
institutions.
Examples:
a) President can veto a bill passed by the Congress. The congress can pass legislation
over president’s veto by two third majority.
b) President has the power to appoint judges of the Supreme Court subject to
approval of the Senate.
c) The constitution has vested the powers of “Judicial Review” in Supreme Court.
Supreme Court can approve, reject or review any action taken by the President or
laws made by the Congress as it did in Marbury Vs Madison Case
10. JUDICIAL REVIEW
This is a very significant feature of the U.S constitution. It is the power of the Supreme Court
to re examine the laws made by the legislature, and the policies made by the President.
If it finds any law or any policy unconstitutional it can reject such laws and policies.
This power of the judiciary has enhanced the position of the American judiciary. It has
the power to finally determine the meaning and scope of the Constitutional provisions.
11. INDEPENDENT JUDICIARY
The courts in the USA, whether federal or state courts, are independent of the control of the
legislature and the executive. Supreme Court is the highest court of appeal in the USA.
The judges of the Supreme Court are appointed by the President with the approval of
the Senate. The judges hold office for a very long term, and can be removed from office
only through a difficult process of impeachment. Judges are men of high qualifications
and they get good salaries and other service benefits.
12. BILL OF RIGHTS
The first ten amendments to the constitution are called “Bill of Rights”. The BOR provides for
the rights of a person’s property, liberty, freedom of speech, press, religion and
assembly.
13. LIMITED GOVERNMENT
The Constitution limits the power of the federal government in at least three key ways:
● As expressed largely in the First Amendment and throughout the rest of the Bill of
Rights, the government is prohibited from directly interfering in certain areas of the
lives of the people, such as religion, speech and expression, and association.
● Certain powers forbidden to the federal government are granted exclusively to the state
and local governments.
● Powers and rights not reserved by either the federal or state governments are retained
by the people.
14. VETO POWER OF THE PRESIDENT
Under the Constitution, the President may respond to a bill passed by the Congress in one of
the three ways. He may sign it, veto the bill by returning it to Congress, or do nothing.
If he does nothing, the bill becomes a law after the passage of ten days, excluding
Sundays. However, if the Congress adjourns sooner than ten days, the bill dies, under
the “pocket veto” provision. If the President vetoes a bill, the Congress can still enact
it into a law bypassing the measure again with two-thirds majority in both the houses.
15. COMMITTEE SYSTEM
A congressional committee is a legislative sub-organization of the United States Congress.
Both the House of Representatives and Senate have their own committees. There are
three main types of committees in Congress: standing; select or special; and joint. In
the Senate, there are Standing Committees for: Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry
,Appropriations, Armed Services, Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, Budget, etc .
The Special, Select, and Other Committees of the Senate are: Indian Affairs, Select
Committee on Ethics, Select Committee on Intelligence, and Special Committee on
Aging. The Joint Committees of the Senate are: Joint Committee on Printing, Joint
Committee on Taxation, Joint Committee on the Library, and Joint Economic
Committee.
16. BI CAMERAL SYSTEM
The constitution of USA provides for bicameral legislature i.e. two houses in the centre.
According to Article 1, “All legislative powers are vested in Congress.” Congress
consists of two houses i.e. Lower House or House of Representatives and the Upper
HouseorSenate.
HOR:
The House of Representatives has 435 members who are elected by the people through
adult franchise method for a period of two years on population basis i.e. state with larger
population gets more seats in this house like California has 53 members.
Senate:
The members of Senate are elected by the state legislatures. Each state has two senators
meaning that each state has two votes in senate. These senators are elected for a period
of six years on parity basis. The total number of senators is 100 as the total states are
50
17. SPEAKER OF THE HOR IS A PARTY MAN
Under both Republican and Democratic majorities, Speakers have played similar roles as
leaders of their parties. A Speaker's role as leader of the majority party is manifested
in two ways: within the party conference or caucus and on the House floor.
18. NO DELEGATED LEGISLATION
On the one hand, the doctrine of separation insists that the legislative function be kept aloof
and distinct from the executive function. On the other hand, as already noted, the
exigencies of modern Government make it practically impossible to concentrate all
legislative power in the hands of the Congress which cannot possibly dispose of all
legislative work by itself in the sense of turning out a comprehensive legislation
complete in all details on every subject it undertakes to legislate upon.
19. SENETORIAL COURTESY
Senatorial courtesy is related to the approval of presidential appointees. It is not a law or a
rule, but simply a customary procedure that has traditionally been followed in the U.S.
Senate. If the president nominates someone for a position, and there is a Senator from
the same state as the appointee who does not approve of the nomination, under
senatorial courtesy, the Senate would not confirm the nomination.
20. DUAL CITIZENSHIP AND DUAL CONSTITUTION
The constitution provides for dual citizenship i.e citizen of United States and the state where
one is domiciled. Britain and Pakistan provides for single citizenship. America has
adopted the doctrine of dual ship in respect of its Constitution and citizenship. It has two
Constitutions, one, for America as whole and another for each State.
21. BI PARTY SYSTEM
The US political system has naturally provided an opportunity for the rise and development of
several political parties, out of which two parties have become dominant and major
political parties. They are the Republicans and the Democrats. These two parties are
directly and continuously involved in the struggle for power in the US political system.
They have made it possible for the Americans to work their democratic system in a
successful and efficient way.
22. SPOILS SYSTEM
When a president is elected, he does appointment of public offices. If in elections, President
elected is of the opposition party, he dismisses the public office bearers and makes
fresh appointments. Under this system, a civil servant appointed by one president on
political consideration cannot retain his office when an opposition President secures
victory in polls
23. GERRY MENDERING
2. LENGTHY DOCUMENT
The new constitution of Switzerland is a more detailed Constitution. It has 196 Articles
while the 1874 Constitution had only 123 Articles. It now contains a detailed Bill
of Basic Rights of the people and a more detailed description of Federal powers and
Federal-Cantonal Relations.
3. RIGID
In either case, the proposal becomes a part of the constitution only when it is
approved in a referendum by a majority of Swiss voters as well as by a majority of
the Cantons. The procedure of amendment of the Swiss constitution is, by all
standards, a rigid one. The total revision of the Constitution in 1999 incorporated
all the previous amendments in it, and thereafter, no new amendment has been made
till date.