PEER REVIEW RUBRICS (DEBATE)

Group No. _____

Topic and Position:
___________________________________________________________________

3 2 1 SCORE
VIEWPOINT Viewpoints are Most viewpoints Viewpoints are
clear and are clear. unclear and
organized. disorganized
USE OF FACTS AND Arguments are Most arguments Arguments lack
EXAMPLES supported with are supported factual
facts and with facts and information
examples examples
RELEVANCE OF All supporting Many, but not Few supporting
SUPPORTING arguments are all, supporting arguments are
ARGUMENTS relevant arguments are relevant.
relevant.
STRENGTH OF All arguments Some Arguments are
ARGUMENTS are strong and arguments are not convincing.
convincing. convincing.
PREPARATION The group is The group The group is
well prepared. needs more unprepared to
preparation. defend the
argument.

TOTAL SCORE:

PEER REVIEW RUBRICS (DEBATE)

Group No. _____
Topic and Position:
___________________________________________________________________

3 2 1 SCORE
VIEWPOINT Viewpoints are Most viewpoints Viewpoints are
clear and are clear. unclear and
organized. disorganized
USE OF FACTS AND Arguments are Most arguments Arguments lack
EXAMPLES supported with are supported factual
facts and with facts and information
examples examples
RELEVANCE OF All supporting Many, but not Few supporting
SUPPORTING arguments are all, supporting arguments are
ARGUMENTS relevant arguments are relevant.
relevant.
STRENGTH OF All arguments Some Arguments are
ARGUMENTS are strong and arguments are not convincing.
convincing. convincing.
PREPARATION The group is The group The group is
well prepared. needs more unprepared to
preparation. defend the
argument.

TOTAL SCORE: