PD) ¢ 5 ( Cmrmuntty. @ [i ARH HE % RAR FE£m RR RY RL FUR ARIE CemmunitySEHR B (CIP) FESR / (SE) BUD CBE ELE iB TCA ARGH MEHE 2003.5 WF 1G : Community ISBN 7—214—03565—0 Vode. WDM. OI... I) Selah a 5 LAPSE CIP BAR FEF (200398 026777 ‘Community: Seeking Safety in an Insecure World Copyright © 2001 Zygrmnt Bauman: Chinese simplified translation rights © 2003 by JSPPH Published by arrangement with Polity Press in association with Blackwell Publishing. Limited, Oxford A sights reserved TLD A ILI PERLE FA] ERLE : 10-2003-40 5 BR HIRE He Ta aE AY HE PAR S 8 (Rit ee % & KR sR 165 210009) Fuk utp: //www. book-vind com SADMAL TIMES CRITE eee 16s 210009) SEEN PALL TAISEN ARTA buy: // ww. ppm. en SALON aT TO PET BLY A PO ET 850 x 1168 EK 1/32 6.125 HE 4 120 F# 2003 *F 10 4 5 1 WR 2003 4 10 1158 1 EEE ISBN 7—214—-03565—0/10-542 12.00 ié COOSA LRBRIR 1 FLERE HR AEB HgeH SoHo ew + S fl Sh SERFEMA, BC HE: Wi BE BE AS IES ST WMA, A, CBR — AOR" (feel), “FEL” (community 4 Si] HRB HPA, “SER BA DSR IRMA i] 9 OC EE community , Ht 2eoF HK FE FETE BEE BE” HER. AEE AR 5 sh i 9 TH ES Se Fe HEY FAW Re HO 0H UD GE EE FD AE CT SS ES FES EGS) CAL ADAA ) TG IF BB I CH PAL 2 2%, BE dy ARNE AAR tO a EK EA TR a AES WAX — His Fat Ue AYA, BER SE Lf a SETA. BE OT HS ATI SE Wr) te YS ICT Hey SED AS RL HLA ad Hy SE TA YR BB A EAE a) A" ADA Sh SE BE PETE ATE BS OT AE Pa PCIe, A HE EAE AY ABE” ORE ABR BLAS TULA AN TE Pe PEP EAE ALTE LL. FAL AS AS FH community — i] 7 LAY” TET PR ASHE DK HSM «FY FS SF Hy Be BR ORL Be IGT) PA HT PP A ‘Ne « Ay DS ts PE SF 2 Sob. te PAS Pe es OE TE CRE YY BL RHE) ( Liquid Modernity, Polity Press, 2000) — 15 Sab tilt fe, Xf SLE Ht Se SO Se ALL: Ze Fad BOTA Hs AYE — Ab BZ TELA: AF CE Aa BIE tH THRE HG BN EA FT a SS] — i fet SPREE UAL, CEU TP, AE HES He RE a A LR) BAT LETRA, Be UH BP aE Ay TS BA SG EE AS BLAS, OT LE A A DD Ae AS AS ts Pe OD, EAP TAD SEG PFE AS 5 tt A CED 2 7 i Oe LE TE TEA BR , tL De RE LB (VA Be 1G bE AY AR Be WN) fy BR AR HL Ze ET TARA SPAR EY, AS STR 2a SSE BR EA TE Hy AS AG Ct AH AR t FEEL He Od ie ak CE ITA ARE — 5 RA RR AT. FARCE A FE OE A eH 9 HEATH. Cath AL CHE — 45 9 EAS CE ee i PR ot fi. —— RE2 ee WR RRR: LRT RAAT Ae LAO RAK RA FRE AP REE, RAAT EER RAH BEE YF ORY AT AE SOBA HE” (bad company), SOR # ABI TSE, PRE, H-B SH WAAR, RAS ee a eT Ht & (society) — IJ HE THAAR ME THX. A I HEF (company) 3k th 2 (soci- ely) TERI LEM MTA HAA". RMUAA, KB REPRE AR RT TA MO ARE HER Bk HA FARE MES HHA, SER RHE 239 Bio ERR — Roof), EN EB, A VAG ae HH ERE MEW EM Ry FE, ME, TR RAT WF. TREAD EL, AAR HH Em BR Aw Tet, Bay a RA TE RK a ot RS AT a A RAE EAA TS RRL. TRE RWS BERS AAP, RMN TUK RR —BPRNES SH 2D, MRARERG HABE URSA EM BIFE a, ae Rw OE A AR SST 3 DARA, KMPER ARR RRM KAM EE THRGHRALS SWRA WA, CHRAAKERMHK Og Ae aK — FE OR ay a SB, A A Ra A ER Fy RHE Oy RL A aR ATTA Md HABA MARCA MARNTARRW- RRR LBL TATRA Bae HRA A, WIR AA BH RAL BY OR SPER RAR RA MIT HR AT Le A OK, SA RI, eT Mes Ad 2a FF OT, FARR ARR AAS ABIEREC. ERMEGAKEWHR RAAAR RE EANNS. SRNBTART RARE SH my eA NERO RMR ARM, HKSAR AA BRK RE RT ARMAS BE, HKSAR A fT RARE HAT HEAT UE IRA Bh EB RATER Hh4 3k fel ik WLS FRFSAAERMN ZS eA Me ERA SLB), EAR ATR AE A SE AB aK — bt HD A HRN, MIME E, RPFRRDAHH, WA, RY AA te RA LH ae AR A OY HB By BR FL RE BR, A ASSERT RBA TE RR RABE PR EE AO FRA AT AR BU AY OR A REZ OP? RAT PHEBERBARMH AL, WEP eM BA 3% (one-upmanship) # At 4%, EIR SAT AR, RAL BL A a FOO RYAAR SHER HRMS ANE DM RIK RORY RITA RULRI EH REW WE RA SLE BF Ht AP ANT HE BY GR AT, Ea AT HE KAS WANREEN BRREEM MEE RR ENB ABA Rok, Aah at Rl ie SE Ra BTRRARAR. RPAKABRRWAHD, MARMARA AR SY — HRA ERA eH AE A A WRT SEY BRB A&A ROR ER” RR ER RR MARGE SER, RPA ABE RMAWER. BR - we ARM ( Raymond Williams) 2 f% St BOAT SR TF A AK ELBE AT it A SL oT RRPR MEL, BSC AR i LAR RAS BF 5 ADFT PL AD 36 BE eK HE MAL AR a TREMKRE—BELA-TRM AY HB BH AD AT RA Ae Ae Pt FR aT A He TT ir BE] AB RE wy 3 3 —— 89 5 & KR-PRETHRE MARR -PA NMA BR WARES MEARE RAF A-TPRIN EMRE, BPRBSMANE CHB HBA. RP RARER A,CFE-SAE. HEBWAWREFA, AGHA ERMAN ADARW HMR. BRR WA SAAS ty WLS RAL BAN Bi AR OY A Be Be, RNR A ER” RE, aS se ML fE ATE Bo ARRAY LE” RR KT GAY “ae SE BAH EERE AAR ARASH Re REM BL" a PE OY SE TG EE DI NA IR AT, HARM ERR HRA -RRHKRAARLER BSA. BAK — Ak, ie — ER OY CARR BY HE OY) SE EAE Be HF A Ko OB OR HY 7 RA BY — NR BAR AT BE AR 9 SE TB OK 5 “SE a EY SE KOZ DR. K-RARGEMHK A, RE PER6 _ ae LR AXAKHRA, CRAAAL, BRERELAERM HC K-KAKBRARREHELHA NERD ARR, FEA ZI ARUN TO ET ES AL WRAN BLA CHARA PY — BARRE BSE TRL AME BER AR ANT eH RAE, VAR EAR OR a NARS . GE YE (security) 5? BARR Bb, REDRRFRRA-BAW BH. RE ES? BA RR EE 8 (is Pt HE BY SE ADEN ET A RARE He Oe 37 MARKETA DERE, USERRA. KRE AKSUM RER HS? MARKER RIL RES RB HEGWALES REMARK. MEE SR (sale- ty) "5? ARAB MEAR, WHA CERT EAE FOTAME EAR, KHRRRS? FRAN P AFENA EC. RRET, WAR MR-HSHEAN WB MALFLWSIRRKKSRATHH, BARA, Et. AT EB KT Re a — A OE Ki —RBX-HAARERAPETERY CRRA, HERADH. HHHRHA AE, VAATE HK, “BE” “RRR MOR A BRAM”. Hie RETA,FF UN , BORE RK ADEE BRAS HB KP 7 Ho WE A ED ie way ET ARPA Pe BRT ARR RAAT ER Fi etl eR Ak A oR EA — (EAB ENS TRE SER He AE BY HE PR A a SN RARARES RH ZMH T REEL OARS HRA UBZ. Ap PE BSR A EE BT AR Oh A Hh A OE Eo SRAA HS, SRA RRMN AREA FEB R— TRA MARR EE BR RR RANS RPA RAG RL. AES Bobi & fel oy HR AMRAAAAS HAZ HR, AA AE A, FAMTRSERRRKAH MM EKMEE: RARER BAER Ap ik, UA BGK — AR ARR Op Ok OR HH HRSR ERM RHRE RERERMBAFH AA RATE ESAS TETRA BTA fe aE ft Z , DA BBE 3K — IR —§$ BRAT fe BHA E ABSA AB RTE, RANT OT LL HE OY — Eh PEL Fa AK IN AB op AE OY LG ee eT REARBAE RN EDT ARREMHA NHR, KML ARE LAR, EET A Oi BE He OB So a8 3 Tal BAR AAG KAA E—ATSUVWE, CREE Wy 3G 4b FE ——_ E RREKB PNA BR. RNFRARRAA REID A BRT AH AE WHRAAKBLANAA BEM. HARGIS HSE Hi wT RAMA S IE RR, HOGER wth). ET MR, ERR THOR BN A aT 2 BE OY he OE EAR a, EE TE Sa ae KAREN A -KKEL ERR. BH HAS PT fe ALT OY RA, ES RR Se (Bl Bt JE 4 BY Ber OY BA 2000 4 3AFRA, ABR UIEIR AMS I S-H BESPUGHNMRS 1 S-F BMARRRRZM 20 HEH HBNNK RA APMAAGARB 45 FOS RPAH 58 HES HAGKELMASAR 09 BARR ALM BHAN 89 KOM NESUWSEALLEN 109 BIE GRR 135 BAR SMU, AHA? 1538-H HUE OT ET ARE As WG PG, HES 9 — IT ( Zeus ) 5 MF HL HE (Pluto) OZ F , Si HAT BEAR AS BF BA AR, fA A A TAA TAD BPR DE SUT TT AL, ARTA aK PE tL AL EF HAS HE PEMA Fi tH AS 2 (AS BE? ) RY PTR ZT SE AB FETS 4S SOU FET PRT A HAY. 2B PB — BR PE AS DDE SEER BAS TR BA FT, AT A At dF IMLAPR vi SLA DR STB) is Be te Be 2s 0 DL, TSE FE. Fiabe Ai, fat POE FD, PERO be SENDA kas BE Ay BP EE Fak. A PR EAE DEAS IG We BH Tea SS TT SLA ae AS a 8 OY SEAM «TERN BRAT AT LA Fe BU EAS , YVR SEIS 9 IB TO DHS RC Tantalus). $2 ch #5 a GE Ha A A JL PAE BL BEE ET) AEA DFR CP TLE 47 AD FE NY RE aE TARE TLR, SR ROR SS HG ee a AY te, BU AAA PE HG PY AP AA. PRE2 _ cam maa FEASTS CE 3 = TIE Pte 01 SE 9 DL SERRE) HAS BAL FT RAG / 5d ER —§_ ei’ A tb, SEER HH PE BY LAB AR BE 3S FT —$ 119 AP RE EO EAT SSE WS PF Ue PER EZR 3 FEN ‘SBCA TT 1 Hie AEA HP AAR FE SE BY AR LR — AMR Se Fi 37 BN WE aT 5 DL te BB , Dy JE, BS) FR DLR UD RAAT A A — Ab FY A BB HS PMH, ERE — +P A WALI (object-lesson) . HU Hi SEE FEE PRBS Bit 7K $18 4 HAR Sk AS AS, RA HET. TEAMASA DLE REE — AE A SER F— 18 C6 fe sp At ARLE Bs AE “EA BR TL ARR If, BS AS — REE PAI BS ASERE RUNDE KE. (PAL JOH TAY, EPR Ta SRE 18 BUFF BS BE 1S BY EZ, BBE AR PEE ST FF ATH 2S BERK HY Hs OG STA” fh FT TS) GIF PGR , Te BN PE 1 9 BERS HA: US SIR AME RE A ERS Fo SEL SOT Oi ESR TRE A AS RE «OR AT AS EH ZAP BREE > BT VA FER TG SB HEB As, RE REE AY ABS PEAT, 1 BR EBL A BE SSE RR ASE TN ASR A SE py 619 AS IR, AS BE ak PB Hh BEE AT, SESBH USS M I 3 SARA E (14S HEF, A, AR A ESR SH HH 111 ORE A HE FE BIG LUM TE AR ORAS BO AT AE REZ AR. PRAY A PATIO IM. DRT AAA, Fath A 2 it is GX — ok fe BE ANK AS BEG EY ok fH I, A TE OE BD 5 Ar HEE A SAG He AAT BA AJ SLL TR ORS SB BaP Baath TX — Be SUI EK RR AA A ABBY To MA 2 AA SZ te —§ 4h (11 eT (the Tree of Knowledge) HYSEF , fi 34 2028 1 Ke 89 4 17] C—§ BSC AST — AR AA A BI «PREZ SER 2 FLT 4 A BE AC SE ES BE, AAT AS WIR SEAT ZR AS EE ( BR BFR eR) TTT PE HEEL FONTS 15 Hy 9 BR PRG A FG HR, EBT EC BR 9 BOREAS Heh €6, , ME 4 ABLE AY aed HGS AE, Ee LE I HOT the A &— Kh ZS, CRERWHK BRAB SWS ELISE TUR TUBE I , AEE BIE Ye SOUT i TEL «7 BE 8 2 As 09 TB 4.” ER AIX BE ZH, DAA ThA ines TO RT TEA AT a TT EE ABAE( be) A RAT AM RAM, BAe etiC). PRE QO ARETE WN Rt. iE4 fal AAR BS FE a 9 AR, a — TS A) OBR AE SUFEL SF 8 3 CE Et 2BY (the Tree of Life) fi BA PRK 2 FAN BP ET), HE th AT LT AR FEA YS BRIT kk, 2 AS A PA 6 FE BF SR AIT HIRE AD FEE ETE NY SE AE Ps BE AAT, — BA FARA T , ORS a the EAS TT USL eT REZ BZ. RAT HG a WS A EE AK, HE GE AA AT heh FE A FR FS RE EB Ie A aS HEA RATA SR A SS SP AE a; TE — Re EA HGRHOS OZ BIEL SNR. RELA RS AE BRE BRIAR TTES ART DA BIE BS 2 BR , et AS AL — 7 PUES AB BURY AES AREA. Faith & HARA Ti ASS FARIA IY EE PP Ds BE TE ARE SB DA Bap PSS ST TT A TT AE HO BUT LAUER. MTL ALIA RB A HR EIR + A WH EREL AEF OY GA ASU TERER ) (E38 FR + BR JE (Ferdinand Tonnies )° Hs 15 1, (47 BE DD GAME Sy OU AC AeA TL DA i PA eh SB RENO PAAR BCG. PRE Ferdinand Tonnies, Gommunity and Society, tans. Charles P, Loomis (New York: Harper, 1963), pp. 47, 65BH MURR TT 5 BR FG REMY) BER “FE [el fA” ( Gemeinschaft ) RUT: BA BYE TE BEAL AD PSP A (les pouvoirs intermédiaires ) (BAT) Bk 4 BE 9 OR Fi AL Se Bs BK , FFE FRAT Ae) A ER ES PRAMS. PEMA, HA SERRE (BUR )IL SS ( Gesellschaft) — PEW EWS M, Bile TPE ARE 9 KS FE, “EY ARR BAST SE AS SF (understand ing) o 3X SUBSEA UR, CIF AS ALABIEIA (consensus) : SEHR AE iy ey EAB SAR ARR A ATI RB, ER ERY FUZL OPT FE UF UR AR A A 9 EH FREER SA TL (A BRU (09) AN AE FRR Be YO A T TOKE IEPA CET ACA THI TF HE [ zuhanden }) , 34 7S a BE AIG OR BAAS FA ih ies EE VBS eT AB NE BE AE SM RUN) FT LA BG 48 FT] ——$ PB a BR TT AS og BE BEATE, EEL FEAR. DA AB ig BE Sak 1H TB] s “A EAT Ze ESE AE SL PEE FE TA I — BA SP RAP SH FRET BY PS AB SE A ER) ER — iS A TERR” J“ BB 2 oi TE — BB AH 4) EES AO RENE” 5 38S LAP A, TL RA A, TESLA OP, AMV" AS AGRA AR AS HE BS SS EB dD BR Je S07 ve PE“ SE TAF” (common understanding) ,“ Fl 94th ct6 ae ed #38” (coming naturally ) F595 [el (5X 5) FAY Pe Wh Ae BEE TANITES TT OTE OP A A APE. SEU, Fit FR — 1A HS 9 SPT ED BRAHAM (Goran Rosenberg) , E 2000 4F 48F La Nouvelle Lettre Internationale 6'\— Fei CHEF Gs SEPA” (warn circle MEG , EAA LEP AS A A Ab PAR BRAS 0 RC AIRED, BS 2 AT REE AT IR aS ABLES FR, BOK A ES PBT AE. FE — FSR ASA PT) AAT aR, “ARE SP AB WO+h ei A, tA LR HE A A ak BT” SCAT RL BE TSI — TF” BY Ss ER Tt FC AS VA LAL FE HEA TL AR aS ok kK a TEL RAE AE” EES A ALG TATA EEO A ok FA MNAE ZB AB DB — A WY DF St i A A RHEE Fe A RA. CEG“, AM TAS EFA E451 FRE, TH LICIE AKT HA, AB AT AEA {ASST BH. BA EAE D0 we AS ASE BA RT”, HE BE TB (BS BE AE bi, BB A”) 9 SE TE TOT BY SE RE FRAT ILAP MRE HEE FRAT ER 2s “RAB FRAT FASE PS IF OF RBS A Mo 28 SL) TE RUBE EIU TASES “CS RE“ AS a TI a BY” CFA RAs 8 RO BEBe URNA T BREE BE HEAN” ) ARR, AP A) SS SA TY AE RL TGF EA BR AR BY , BC ae A AT BB Re ER BAG TAM. WAAR HITT RET RU UNRATE AB PRAY RA. Cte EER —AA EO S BR FRG BE A ALA, AS DR Pak i 3 BR ME EINER TE ABE 9B IR” , PE SRT A BB SE DNS AEA 3 TT TE: RAR ARERR HAR RB EAA RIE 0 ot 3 5B AB OY oe HE AH KR RREAH ie el 2 a BY BAR“ Te] A” RRR a — Bb a RTT PRB” RT A” FETAL BORE, — EB E18 AR BOR, Fie BER PO BE TIMES RRA BF HEB DS 5 FF PE BR OS AR EE, FE, REMY , PAARL“ AEF AAA Ii 4 ZE” (zuhanden) A) AR ASHE Hm T “Sb EFA RTM FE FE” (vorhanden) HAR AS, BEAR T BR. UE EHD PERT SEI EL RY URS RI. —BEA MRR EMT BA, PRE JWG HLTH MIDS , IF ME SE EE 0 HS, DITKA BRE FY A BABE EE BAY Ey a, IF BE A Ht AE EE BEB8 st PAYOR SZ, PT AS ae Ae, 3X — SE TL a RAS ae ST T (SRL, FIERA HE — PSE TBA). “PERE” SED A HEME BEE: —~ PICA E AS), WEDD, EE Ge : BS Ah SL IF OSE TAT AR, Ee ice OR ER A Sl eB” RRMA PHRAA IFRAKSULASBAR-HET. # {EVE FH PEE ARE (Robert Redfield) OFF AY BRE HF HY LAS, BOLE AP LIE MISE TAA As FE Any I HH BR AY oh fb SCC AP RE, BOPP TOL AE BS, RA ELA 9 FB, SE FAA AVE BOAR RAE — ANE A AE (groupings) (4B BA SE, “FETE (A AE TE Se FEI 89") EEA AY CE AB Me SN, PAB E EY PE Aa RBA 'p, ERA) (AC 8 A GE, TE a BSE BEIT EFI EY “CE SE TL PR A BE IT BY TRS Te EE oN NSE DM SE — TP AGE TE FUSE BE HE” ) o TRGB AE 6 BT SE DA) PE EE, 1 HE EE. “TiUREHE” (distinctiveness) BRE : ES} 5 “FRAT” FAA" FESS END, UE REY , AN FEE “RY HO HES Fe“ BATT i — BA” , AE SD TT LY , AN FP PENAL AR AS, HO D Robert Redfield, The Little Community and Peasant Society and Culture (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1971), pp. 4.SR JSP MT 9 AE AL AYE $282 RE 9 BB ASE, LT FE ASSE BAR HE 5 “ZIV” (smallness ) 38 ORM : FETAL AA RB AIT (1) Sek eB) SS «BN td PEE A Bie AE (RE ARR RRS SRB) Ob aR” BE eS BS SLA TAD ENS A” SR as AGT” A LP HY FT DEANS OLS: BE Ze PAY. TEA BE PRP SE I] AB DR BR Ss PRESET ATT) Hy SA Pe PE EMT RRR. RBS 1 — RPE RA CRE FCA AB ZLB AH Ae , BES ALLF AST AE EE BLY PUB BSE FR GBAE AR TE” SE IBA” 9 EHF FET KY — BOVE OAT EAS (ATT TL TE SY 30 HII REA 218 BEE. SET AR — BC Ne Pe HIB Fe I BE SA a SLA 9 FSS TOT RA” AT) SH 9 «BO 177 #8 22: th FF) Chomogeneity ) EFFI HE ( sameness ) 7 Fy RY ELVES TT Re ASE TERR AO Be A PRLS HF SCARS, BP SAS Ta) BS 3 TT GT] (AR Py BB Sj Ob BAS” SE Hk ZT YB , a BE Ey HST i AT HAT afte A” TD BA KS, AB Ag Sb aE FE FSSC Ht EAS LON AB AT A EL 56 it EE IF Ra WEG RH ABA MITE ATH RE HABE, BE AF LR I BG SC A BL, SGT] PR — BP10 _ 2k fel oe RAPE TBR LRT — PSU ZF A a PR J 5 BE, MAS FEL E, ANTAL i 9 BT (BR BE A —— TE 1 AE, AREAS SE IRV Ps BT ABI AY) VA DL Be Ah SB (AB) REESE AAT" BSR PR” 19 I FF OSA MERA RABE. “HRT ARSE ‘PAB ABD A FF a YH AB RS, BE EE BT PYAAR Lo TEBE AR AY EH BL, SRF SE A A SRT YR HE” VA Be ats HT abi = fea DA BS HP Tf. — Bf BT DA thor FE ROAR IF ee PA FEE AB PTE B19 3S GH AY SIE HE A A CRIT BLE BT AEA ABATE PHP HPAL Se) PLB” OB” TL BD FE RIE , BABE PAT. SA SIE HEE , OTT 115 Vd BR HE Ds 7 LSE SHER BA FAR AR ALIS & BEE PH He OE 5 TA A — Bk hs EE Us “AAG EAT” AEE — 17 27 BUTE SX. FETE BL FRE AL — FRU ( achievement ) , HIF RR, MITE MT EACH Pe AUDEN THE DAB AES GB BM th De EE TR PATE TSA SLY , PT AT TE EE AB SHR | AAT TE, EL 8 — HE LE EA BB Aas AL hs SY) CE TET. BEA PBR BBE Pa ta RS) AE SAT) Dp. WEL AMIS EIT PH — BS AI, ACER SB BERE HES MMR i HYPE DSF HY HAZ AE SLE AT SEP a #. AK ARERWRSAEA, BCE MICE AME (BE At AiR A ER BR IE WT AB OR AE As PT FB “ELAR TITRA” “ANTS TDMA” , LAN eT LBP. EER BR AR TH-LHRE HESHE REC OHR, CTE R— FEE GIA” (rolling contract) OMPRAS , XA AG SE BEY PL MABE RA ER , AE fe] — UR EB BEE ABA RE PR EF — te BE PAE 4 Pe, SE re 2 a 9 JET) PR BD BE ST, tH eh SY DE GEORAS, CA EBM TELA. ABLE TALE SE TRV AD ARE Se HS He BB ft PTs BE EI FB SE TA FREI CEF HS LE PITS HOR BS TA SW SE HE A AE TBS FE DAL PB HA A A HO ASHE AE T , ARTES PRB ADT, tHE I VARI” Cuntil further notice) HMIRAAF AIS Fo GFL SE Bae ESE DF SP EAB BE ATT PT BA 7D Ae Ha FEAR Le RL I~ ER TTR BE” Hw BI” «EAN RO ASE Es ERB AR — Be FB OS, TP HG SE HE BS BSBA, (GSE BOA HE HS FE TCT 69 ) BD ae, TT LP BRA BB A O BRAMAN EMM AR KATA BRM PRA. Sp EHH AYIA AL“ EAA TA" (fixed term contract), ——iF IE12 St FS GE BIAS BR RAS Se BT TD AH PS HS BS SRR PRI EERE AVE ETA ASAE AB ERE LAB SRE) IME IT « SRT AR — EL RRLAR” , Ce apht AS BE RL LD SR — P TERE BA BO 10 UT EAR 3 BY FT VAR AER IC. MRE AEE CLANS VRE TEAC IZ +P BY AB PIE, SX A (BE 2 a, LD — AB SAF BORR ATT SK HY WL, TX ALB HY SL FR DS HG SE AS i EEE PUT) , TTR AE AE Ea AL ER PB — ET AFT EF) HED ARPA AIR S| AIRE IB RT A 3 BE SFB EY SB AEA EWP SE 1 i a YER ET 0) SB BAe ARR ALA SE AY SP AD EIR ANE Wb TLE nF AT Wea BEAT BEG), RATT AT FS ES) EA es OG A, (ATT SEB AO AS BEMBKA. EGU FE 1 397 HE AEE (Evie: Hobsbawm) si UE 748 44 AG,“ EEF] fas — iii] AS 2 Ee BE JL BOR CAEL EE, CE SE AE "Pt MEDS BU BL ee BE SE TR AS ) By AS oT BR SHS as 2 SHEE BEA FO; MBERIC DE “HE TIE th PAT AR PEPE 3 Bh FAVE He FO TA AS AS ie BRP Ne A A D Erie Hobsbawin, The Age of Extremes (London: Michael Joseph, 1994) , p. 428.i SADE NOE _ 13 CE FAR ABLE ATT AT DAA FE HV EPA, eve $8 (Jock Young) Xt Hi 15 1 UE WLS APP IE ET TE WS AL a AY Pa Za “GE By HE Td AR LA BUTE identity) Ak B28 HH Ko” “ARAB XT SREB ERRCGRES HG TALE WE HS WOE RK, EHV] A EE ASA AO, VAD CREST A — AE AR is EAB TTT HY” RR” FREAK, HE ABT AS Sb TH FES, HR PL VT A Re DYE PR CEFR ANTI A AG APRA ER CB HE ESC, TCH FL FS AB ANAT SERS , 1 ALTE Ik — REA CH LR 4 BRE BRE HAR BA — PFO EVES fr HK IPP TE FX — TRA, EAA RT TA BISBOR ARP SRT, PE WYSE aT BRB ST 8 Be a EF TE — BI BEE ATE FB, Se A TD ths es OL YE BD AL as Hs SE TA AR) EDRAGUAE APE Ra” —— Ee is FA EE FF GCA 9 3 — 5 ET] PS ST A Ye Ro FPA TES A SE FERRARA EE SPA ®D Eric Hobsbawm, “The cult of identity polities”, New Left Review 217 (1996), p. 40 ® Jock Young, The Exclusive Society (London: Sage, 1999), p. 164.14 PERE BAKER LE ADRS SN. BTA IA” GE BE RE FEN Pe SS PBR A io “SOA” BRS ATER: CRSA, SS — $5 RAST ( BE SF) HR Zit — Fe aS , TS RE A ASE RAR SBLS . MRA, MAS AIR A ESS HE AR A 5 GTA FA BENE ( identity-building) £4) 75 #8 2 VE, (EAE A TA AROSE SAE ATT De FR ATT REE EF OB HL 5 HR ET Fob, WT CER ZG, PERL AWA S ALEL F RE RR MRP E FTIR (exorcism {XH o KET FEA PR” (peg communities ) FE REDE BE As EE (1B EHS As, DE AN RE PERO SEAATHERY PRIME, 8 Se — HS 9 TD (2 FE ea Sek St — BA AE, th A — i FETE AIRE PK — TK 3X YE IR ST AB A TUE ZOL, NER RE BE AER, Bb FLERE BT s MITA AGB ERED Or PB ATL FRAT Pl — 2, Ate FRAN ay 4 Se —— IE FF SAE + H8 VBS (Jonathan Friedman) MF #5321] }— 1 RES PREHAD “SERA ROAR AAA HU, ET AB TE PEER AT HB FP PT TE A 1G 9 BTi aki 8 SPIER.” FRE A PR TLD BER, (LH TSE RD 9 ik th AFFORD EFF END TRAE (distinctiveness) HL FRIGATE TE ROB REACH A SAE AH BR et» (Frederick Barth) St fi PRASABE E2955 Te AS ROL « ene] LE PUSS EN” Se A TD , RA HE TE AAR TB RU ae GF SHH ee Ae EAT SAE) PERSO. RATER EAE Bl ERAS OT Ee IE AY I AA BG HEELA OR, TEE TAREE HY 4 A OR , th BE“ Ee” PELE i. A — RMS SS Hy EE ame 5 ES (S| FS AS 45 FBAR[ Stuart Hall] A965 )Os 2 VA Tel 9 EB AB IF AY BE AR KAVA, —h RS ARNE RO, A BAER AE AC Hb EDL OK, FF SERRA DG T EBAY 2 ETE” PTET DAB OR A TE oe BE HE ISK AY aS A {1189 Ba ete ne ARABS HR, TE JETT RR EE BH DY SE A) TELE EEE D YE ESE. EY AAAS BS HM, AAT SPOR ASE FAR PR BY, 1 ATT AB BSE © Jonathan Friedman, “The hybridization of roots and the abhorrence of the bush”, in Mike Featherstone and Scott Lash (eds), Spaces of Culture (London: Sage, 1999), p. 241 ® Stuart Hall, “Who needs ‘ identity’?”, in Stuart Hall and Paul du Gay (eds), Questions of Cultural Identity(London: Sage, 1996), p. 1.16 Email EAE ROSE TAG A, BAS A A WBe AE IS AN IA Be A is aE To DD Bi ST OM aH HELLIS I RS Ss AVIA TT 0 “SEPRFFCEMISE TAL PR” 5 HATTA BRAS AS I , TT BEAR CATE OE Ne 5 EE DAT A AS ET AS J ZOP BUF Ib. “EE BERAE 24 |v ht BY 105 BE ERK HF AB ATI SI, BOR LUA SE A HS 1 FEB AE ABLE 1 9b HE A GE TRA RB HRGE. BGA UL RR A EE, RAE AH - 4 MRT” YY ALR Hy RD , BEE SET PR FU — PFE Ta AA HY RE, AP BE — ELK BE TEL TAS TR AMIE BE VA Me HELE TR A FOR AEE EY TRS SR ALLE BR AE AB AS 1 HE a Bd FI HY «HB ZEB IL FETE AE HEE EEG 9 ERE MS EBLE ADT AK, EAB BY LA BRA I — $1 SWOT Kt a AS TT FD HERA ANKE RMR — SROKA. FRAT AS FH 5 RTI AAT) FAS HO GR I FT PE 9 ir 3 ABLE SEAS TT AE ABE BR ATE A EI PAE BEG PAT AULA HE A Fe LE PP TAO, ALF BRAS AT AE. D PAPE SEIT (Sisyphus) , Ay i AB AY SE, FE MET A HR, BEE EAE BB LWT SR TE FE VE TARY. 32 PER REF oh BD, A HE AU PAC. FREESR Ie 17 TRAR BF + AR HE BA (Walter Benjamin) MR 2 + 32 Fil ( Paul Klee) Day 22 imi 2 AACA) (the Angel of History ) RAL, Hr RYH SE AIRED BEAT TOOK Stee A I HY He ach CE RT EE — HP OY St Ty, We A Bl thy Hee Ae, DH SH AR HS ARH A BE FH KBR -WRE, KHBEETRERS, HR BHF BR TAL ON EIR ER GE-RENEKAS OR; EMR EMT ARN KRRARAAAEHS LB WB AE AR FT i 2B Hae fe HE a te PP AT 1A HEAR AY BOE RM RE TO SG SEEN) HABE WL RE UB AS 0) AS OM TT A YR BMNT GEL Ss 5 AAMT TIE Je Dy aS FEC AE EI Pk BK Ht AR BA BL AL VALE ft ir EB I A BP D (RB SEFC Paul Klee, 1879—1940) , Hit 1: A PL VE Bi BE, HL ea, MPI AVE 8 NST BO A ATR. 1933 SE ON JH EIR) MBA) SE BE AE is Fa He he Be) TK ED . RE @ Walter Benjamin, Illuminations, ed. Hannah Arendt (New York: Schocken, 1969), p. 257.FELASA AR BEER AR BT AREAL IE BAS AR A ft 8 PE A RA A SZ DR «At A 1 RE aE DS A A AH TD AS AEB a AST BS UH AS I FE BE A A OE PB AE TE ORR UE IA — ESS PK SINT A, Re — Fi RS TERA RH EHR HEP 6 GOR ASHE WY A “EAE” (progress ) BE AY FL AR AE an BU WOE LE HY, HB A —— at AS 9 Hs BR —— oS BBE AR FRR AAR RS WY PENG EAU” BT A FABRE FE-PE. FRR TSE GRR, AE 2 BT BERGHE A BH Tt AL ASS eh AAT CE ARE 2 SF Ae AFT AV ASS A BER Be 198A, 5) Ht A TAS i ARRARBEFE FEF AS, Ey ft 01 CE FR — Ae RA Be HP Hee tt ATT PSA NIELS WG SRE As E.R EE MR ABLES HR ATVB Aa FS BAS BEA RE (EL , BC i BY aie a BER” ARR TEARS ADR AR a R EE £93 eh CLE AS HL BEBE AS A] BUS) ) , AS A TE AE TAP, BAP PRLBARE KAFFEE 0 ESD FEA ER BEBE — RY BZ, TE EWE ON A TREE TE ATT TE PEP RS — Bi, HT BP — BUFR ZA ISE Fe EMA EE A EY. BILE CE BY $5 —-PAT AG eA AT SE DS SK TG TAHOE HE He RTE a 0 26" FH GR RU BE” ADE AMHP AT 19 FRIAS AB. abst DS A BELLE BPP YAR AS SEY BL, ABLE FC AT EY SRA VAT FE SD EY) BE ba SLI Se HE AE ASR — ARS ROPE, ANGE He FA Te RE MEA TP A EE, LEE AB TAL PE BY AS RR AY EL A FEE SE Al — BA — i EK SB HA EAT Td ABSA TE UME ES Ae Fh EAD AS AT FY 5 ATI A PS BY FT AE HE FE HO CE SL DS HE ES, BR Ele AL FT RTE PE. RTE REE EZ xt ZEAE AMV ESE SRUE TF SER LTE AR — PE BIE SREY APRIL ELIE “AR FT ESE IMLAY” (squaring the circle) {£3 Wie be — TET RD. We ME Re BORE TT 3 EE PVA BED Ho LIRA A HH AY oe HE SRT TE Eb, WARE HEP PTA AE , SBR A TE A J TR AS 9 WE HEE) 5 TG Aa a ae PEAY es th SE Ee FE CR a DA HE HEME A, SATE RRS Ah) A DAT NE RIDE OG LS EAE REN SH 9 AMPOLIE (EAE A SAG SL FE OE, Lg Ba SOR Ya EE YE, FEE EA A BA 5 I 8 HE ES IE Det EERIE AR B oh.Se BRM ZL EFL (Pico della Mirandola) FYI FS — Fe RIE AS TT ICR LG APRA A, EW 4 MRR, BRA BARI BK. ART BCR FEET a Bs ABA — 7 Ba PRE AE EMT AT WR 8 BE DR DRE CATT FE BR B+ Bh Be Oa PATTY VAR TE AS ATT A BY AS BB OR RH ATT BY TE AS” BK BE ALICE EE ATR HG 19 BS EO A AE AOR ET RAE ADA Hie AS 07 TAS, PS EE AA a DATA HT) RR” Ae RE AT A eS” A AOR BE, MAE RUBS AS), 1486 FMA, CUE TAB DA BUTE PEEL 2G A Fe AAT EA AAT BAR SE ASEM F RUBIA) HEB TEI AT SR TE D KER PB HL- KX S412 (Pico della Mirandola, 1463—1494) , C2538 IU ROAATT ER, EAE EAI A IS — AY aE ET GE ANDRE) CE ADEE EX AE Et OE A) . —— REFo BHAA RZ 21 LATING FE MSO. ARPA BOM, SUR NER HE: CB ZED EA AE BRA AR A A ED FFE” AGB, AE AAR LAE TT. MC SE Ha Sk JPR H AG ARF SUL Rg 2 A AL A BRAM LE — R D L E HTT BH. MU RED A ARSE RE ABA A SE OC SH BAe TE A EASE CES. PERS BET AR BIAS FE TSE TT EP SRHE PA (Jean-Paul Fitoussi ) #9 #% BL {€ (Pierre Rosanvallon) Xt" BUC MAE XA JE HET TBR: Ape La, eS OR AE ok A ETH, (oY BEE, FF AE A AT RY A A AS, RT GM KF he EW PR, RAB PA AY ARR HH Hh ER PTE — RE, AER SOARS HE we Ob FRB 1 1 ty PB A FH a BREED AND BR LACIE AS AEB — PAE EB PRA EE DASA MEAT LR RS Al IO, TBE ® Jean-Paul Fitoussi and Pierre Rosanvallon, Le nowel age des inéqualités (Paris: Seuil, 1996), p.32.22 3 Fl HEA BR CERO PRIE (ZB > HE BE A) —— FE RAS HO ALES SAAT DS TP A AL UAT) ES th ABS hy eB Ste BO GS HT MAC TRARIAE MES. (RIE ft OTA MCSE TE” SC AE BA FARBER AR AI OT EDR BE, PRE — OOF SEYRET TEAM AAC TERE Pe Oe Oh BE HE: BE Wa PER SCHR AY Bee TEE th A} 93 PO SRA, A, ERE OK A LR A POR FUWIE TER ARAYA ORB AE AOR B BR HORT FA) SHE ABA UT AS “RE RB O” 95 e BDAS B L AOR EE IS. RPE TT OLB, EAT ET BGK THO (ei, 4 HR OE A A ASB 8 8 Be EB ANT — ER SUE 5 AS a TTR BS A YR Tc HE BSA , BI UT AP BL BL MRA FEE OE FY BE SEBUM HOU BEA HE AT Be HP 2, FEAR SR BEAT BS HORE, A ela — PH A BY AS FERRET TT BE ASE fod ft AB A 3X — 2 SS BS BER — BRIE » SRT, WORM BBE Ze BL TTAB AT PSA ER D ASA Janus), FEE MAPA TH. AIS BBR a oI TFL, At BE PR Af SP A a AE FE BAB HCA TA He 89 BE. PREBaw RAUB BBY i 1 HOR SR BS PE (GE HO SRY PATE «HS BER ATT Sh RE ee I TYR SO FE 2 At ATT I eT TE) BE A EA AL $1) 9 IE AS DA IS BE Be Ht AT BEE AA TIN A FESS YA A SF A AAT 9 BS FEI AA AER ABA oe Se PERI ARARARKREABR A. TRIE A B th FL ie Ae — Fi ES Et, M8 1G 2 at RE PE RE ASSN St) EL a el [rl i HEB) ARF 36 Bh RR EO PAE RM ABE, SER RASH Wi HE HAE 9 3 ) , HAS SE FFND. CARI REA PR EI NY A AALIYAH ETERS RB BBD A MR BH HBR AT RK) BEE E AE BI A HLS, RAR IEA PR WUE REI ABO A, AE BB 2 eT AY FEW, FUE eFC TE 9 SABE FE BY FE EAE re BP” PETERS AE YR Fes HE FIT A) AB I, AI AE AS RG PAE AG IXY , IE AN HF (Richard Rorty) WAH EY EL FE RPV EP RI FGF TR A" EA IPRA To JEFE ARB AS — BS PAT FAR BE ED BS EE A 15 FF ET AE PE G2 Se — AE SS a St AR BRE) A EE A 7S HG Be AO BE 0B (Sigmund Freud) TRAD IVR AVF PY LBA BSE 9 ERA SAAB Bi A BS24 3 al Hs (cahiers des doléances) , 3X #¢ A (iE ART Fb TH BITE , AD Az BLATT FRIES HEL AE 8 ATI 9 ab A) TEL Fe Ya He AE BYR AAS HY 23% 0 IBY MS TE (OC AB HEAR YA) ( Das Unbeha~ gen in der Kultur )—75*P ,YA24 T fe FUR : EE SIS A FO A EEK AE FLD, At ATT BE Dh 2A 3k HL Ee FREE HH OY Bea AD Pes A EH, OE PH SE RR. TES TERI ANY “AE BUG" © (life politics) Pp (3B FE IG TEA ARETE, LEAR i EAU TTA EA TS RAB EAL A) ABSCESS AMS, WITS MAAR TERME, FCM. ECC RAD — BP, te FURR HITE EME FASS REA OWS ER BI, SB TY A DE ET AST ESE. RTE A EME TER IPB , RA BE UREA TEL” YS DO TE ESTED RBI ke — AE Ty SC Ba, — BR SC BLADHOA FETS POR ASI. EU SRO Ba Pe ET EF He FSS IL EP POS | A TB AT), ZH BL, PR AY BR a AA 2) ARTY Be EE BEI he, TL, AFR SE LY ah AR Se OB) ER A HY “ELTA EE AV APPR PS] LAR * FR ATT PE Eh PHBE GE ABT CIA TEI 5 PARE RAH BLE HP , Ae TA Ye wf ALIS THAI M IT & UR, Et BOR GE SAY EAL E.R A EH BAG SoD TB A, Ds YR BER — Ba wa HC AY Bw Se TE BCG Bb 9 7B “ECBO a) i BIA. SCRE RIS SRO SB te fe Ae TBH WY RR”. EAR RIT BF. A, Eh a 2000 “Fi. ——FREEBoe RHARMRRSD 25 SAO TaVGEE , eT Ls BE AY 3 0H A A WE AAD TE TE TPR OS ARLE EAB a BER WTR 14 ER) AS a) PR Be Le OA sn My PES CSW BSAA ASA 1 HRT ABA A 0 SBT PETE CIB AIED ( Die Zukunft einer Hlusion).. 33 DA RBEEAE FRAC IETF OCB HY FB ACHE SCI EY COURS CE SE TOE CR AP TCR BL HN ESET NHC EIS, ELBIT RAL TTS A BEE A CAC TAR, CCH EAS OEY by 25 eH adh Re 3k — Fe BE TE ET HERI OT A HORE EE A PE HR, GRAAL IRMA) — TELA TE I. TE SLB. EGR ER a Bat ACB Fa B29 AE AT HE PSEA OTE GX TOI SL ARE VCE LT AT BE MO ALBA} BEI DIESE AY A GHEE "LAD BE” A LE BE ie PSEA AD ACIS BIE IS ZEB ULI BA ABER AT RAT TOT BO RL HEL TE A A) BH EE — HSH BRICTIEAY BERETTA OE” IARI BE PP TIRE | CES ST PRENATAL RHE 8 BLAS » BO PESYE Tale cott Parsons) BRERA FAY" SH AERIHE” (the functional prerequi- sites) PAT IB 38 OH ME Gta Se Fe TR A26 3k BEE WT EAE AA aah Bo ce De Be A” CBE SB TAME EY BR TFL f& 38 ) B19 Jez 2 47 UT ( post-Hobbesian ) #9 4# 18 6 PUK HRA , KA BE— BOM IS TR A He ak OR AT VLA BR eB DAS CET SH bh A Bs A 19 FEC BELL AT RAS BPA, FP ATE A AN Be TEE SEER hl FER (KIRA A AYO TAD EF 109 HBL, 13 — BL A Bea TSCA AS THE) — Ta BE EC at ASHI THY FE Hl) 0 fal KG AE” SR TH, I eB BRS CE” DP YO 3) EAA AR 2 5 — A tO PAB Fe BE EMAHUEEZ "1S AE A ELE. Po — ZS PEVAL ISEB Be AL WAR TE OCH BLAS TR) — PE 45 TAFE 6S Ha 3B ——$ ts FT a HE A SEE A EAE SY AIT ME HD A A AT 09 ER AY), SR TTT fh ST SAEZ ABA AAS HOR BTS HR ROPE A EAT ICP ERB, TT YS at a RE A FY EPR PEN IRF BAA) BZ, ROR TIX— ESE, BIE RENO TEE WS SAA, ASP ATO EE RE XP PB OY AY EB Hl, TT EL th FA ERY — AB PA © Sigmund Freud, The Future of an Mlusion, tans. W. D. Robson-Scott (London: Hogarth Press, 1973),PP.3- 6.Ae Bie 27 ffl HB Se eh GF A, DS — APS PT EZ OC HORM RY ARAL AAT BI. HAE FP SCH AS TE BS — BP ES BRE, OK SE A HO PEL 3 FL DB OS ARR ER ae A FH OWL AU KBR FEB AYE ot 5 FAD FPR ER oP BEAT HC Hl, HT ELA SH BEAR He 111 4A Hd a HR fie oF 3b BY SS RE UR ARR, EE EY AT Ft BORA oO HB MTL FEMA Pe AME APE TE MK ab — SE HH A, RO REE HAREM ADS BRS HOE Lah at Pt fh 1 BY a NE HE & 2 fe 41 1 —— A RBA FEO ASE BUG FATE «Dh LI , TB BS a ME” C deux poids, deux mesures) Bh" KAR” Hive, RAE HOES ARS BME BS PEPE AND, WA Be HL ta 240 Ae A ATT Ae WR TO, 3 RELAPSE SE, IRR DOR BUI, CATR ARR) AS BT REIN RAY SOLS AC EAS STR EAS Se I AB PR FE AY28 3t Fel te BLT RG WE AT A IB KDA AR A RAB OD BTS TP BUA) PR PR SE AN 1S BR SCR FEBS SETA TS Se PDS AR A SE 2 AS A SPT EAT FES TALE HOE SH « APSA BAAR 5 RE ( BYE ASE SA RE), tH AZ AS — PEAT DATE s — TL Sd aR, — AS HT ALIAS TAL ABP. eK MS Behr A TD EO OCH (RAC ABR” TRUE A PEE SKY ER te SCH ER FFA — PART HR SEL SHEA HOR HA BE AE, (LG St MEL AEST OAR OT. RE ABC 32H Oe CH BR” SOWA PT AE EIS AS MBE HA 25 ETT IG AS a A a BL AB Faz 3 Bk FREES, OO SRRE AAC HE OK So RS AT RF ASE Aah RP Le EH BAAR ST TF, BESTT HY FR Se SK A BE BOR HY 20 HH ANTAL EC PUI BE i HY BEART Ww bE. SRSA A fh BC (emancipation ) 5 AN FF AT ~~ #6 AF FRB (suppression). BORA NT AEE 28 RE T ADA HP HELA LM Me ti” 3 DG A BR OE OT A AR A SIVA “FBR” BT ToT He as EA) (TT LR BY ABT RAY SR AAA A a 19 Od RR A BE) TT SE 11 FD Ae BL a BT RF CP RE SAE ALAR EAS BF FR mE At AF TY ad, TtAe EPHR BRR 29 Be FIXER Hd BY ES. VB) Ot ATE A RAE Mat TBE, REN AC RAN A AS SH FY ECB SCR TT LAAT ABA 9 EA ABR oR HR EE PT PAB A| SH LE — ib, VACHE fh FE — RR BW EK SRSA Ae DEAR, PAL abe, “41 A, Af HS ll BE Aj FUEI HE MIA AE APL EY AE 08 PE A AN QB BE ARAN TI TA, GIL RE — BE 9 HY FUER) BA) Ta) BL Se AS Be — A A AE 4 ET AR PAZE ADEE Hl ABE PE HL PE TA Fa T 3B A A ARABS FRB), ARO ND SF Bh TT FR HEI HAR” BEDS COR) SOTA VFL SE DY HE DO YS CFRBE) o AESEIAA ATER Je ERE RAY KEE ES RAPHE. (ARE, AN ri mB , AB — BR Fe A CTE A) gE Be HY BR Fel aD TT «AR TE PD SE A PB EY J BL LAE BEET AR EB) AB i BEA a 39 HK KR. “SRR SARK AY THE” RE — 4 BIE BE SUF te CTE TA BRE LAFF A) ( Work, Consumerism and New Poor , 1998) —=f5 "F484 AY FIT MP AR AST PEE PRE” (work ethic) SE — FP MLE — PS 9 i HE HO EIR, ETE WY ATRL REP AL de > A DY ‘EPA A, TEE SIR BY SRE PAR HE 6 EO Ss AP 930 Je al fe UM CA wee TE 2A ee be 24 LEED A T PR RS BEAR BE HY AR PEE TTAB th, LE HY Se SLO AO" FETE FA A TEE RI AS Td EP WS A” 89° PEAR AE” (instinct of workmanship ) A F3#% DEBTS, 19 TS, oP AC AY BB ANY AF BE BE SBR ( disembedded- ness) #1 814% ( uprooting) B9 tH ck , fel] ts at — PAS Fv — St ak ARR BMRA BRM AM, REE E WAR T o “CPE AS AE” FE PLOY TE (AS OR FF EA FEAT PRAT YA EY ARS HY RAR” TSE WRF MVEA IIE ESS ROKER FUE SR A — BD 9 BE RE Ae E , CE ATLEAST POOF Oa TA A © AUPE Thorstein’ Veblen, 1857—1929) , 32 HER AML SE KE HERRERO he A. hie FALE 1G 1 AB) ASF IE TT FE EF NDE» BREA EE Aa AS DA RIED CAE MIE) CAR SCO BE HS {ELD LEITH AN Et ABH ISEB 28 BE OE AHR OP IE HY BR PEAR EASA Se SLES 5 a SE Hb EE nl JE A aS A St TE) FIAT TR LAM A SSE AE mE 9, TEU , ll EE SS AS A SAY Ht, VA AE RE A TA A ROE EAE = PE, BCH ARES 2A — RRO AR AE OS SD er Ay DT, ASE EH BE AT RABIES a MS A EN SP To BL CAT TP RIC —— 2 Fh BE FED HEE AVE TG Hs EDA HH 1964 FRR). ——PRE ® Thorstein Veblen, The Theory of the Leisure Class: an Economic Study of Institutions (New York: Random House, n.d.), pp. 15, 93.Rai ERS 3L MVR T RS EARL OR RATE FBTR BR F fe BRR BY AE Ree te aK SHHAMAER RAH ARERARA LEK WHER RAR REHEARSE RK EGKLAART TESA RRR S. DAE, LEY RUE FR ATT AB LAL oe £8 9 Se BI Fate RBH FOR LATE, RATA BP FRE BSHEVE 0 ME EL LAG CBE AS FE AY) CY A Fa EAA PF BGS — Be TE BE AK AR OE, tn RI LEHC RE 6, WBA TB T ARASH BBA BEDE EA EARS Se BE” 9 FT A BE AT eH ST ECAC T TAR eh BEET AY TSE SESE” ALTE TA RAB GRASS FT Wy BY 2 ES A$ EP TEAL AE AE HS Hy EA BY PEAT A BT HI BEG TT FEL A R/S, TEN PLB EVO, IE FEARS RM , A Ha TE a” CG REI AIEEE EE IE) A SFT” (ME AE RR A A FRAG RDE ) ZA) HEH Hy SEIN + AA BE HE , UAC AS FE BY RE AS ed RE SARE HYSYS —€§ (BA «92 JB [ Karl Polanyi ]82 31 AK -32, _. KA SEE HIME BA MT WE PET 28 Rb FE BEA) WD ta A ae AVAL TEE URE SPS AB — > A A BT HE AE BR TRE Yb 10 AAT ott BGT A ZO , BLT ACE FS SRM (ERE ab Ee BE TT Oy TAB 0 TARR SEA WHo FALE C A T RBL 3L AE ” SFA”. MPREICAY TOE AER UR BE, “TE FEF) AP CEL AE TELE OP LR RE” th AS A“ "RATE io ARM RK TRY A FIR BR I aS A PSP AT EB EH RE TAKE , HOLES EACH TT WY, RA PLAMR AS SSF TR, SENS BE A OE SW Cee, HE A DB EF IVE TER FIV" 5 TL FE Ss He LAE AB AE BEE ATT CEA AREY RABE AR RA AR. TE AR PRE SOW AFERE X , SERRE AER A AF — AT SES RS FF REI Wg HAR SA fb ATT BA DS As Sth a I Be TE A. RA LARS" RE” , I BATIK — BT AY EL SS PR BEY ARS BR JR Be. EASE Lh 6 PE 1 A AB a 0 A HTT Fis PSHE ATT i Fe BY “TE PE” SB AS A RE BRB LI LAF DPE BS 28 RA AF DC OE BE FT ANTE BK — “FOR SADT RS LE” et Je TEe Rann 33 LI — FEA A BF IB OR Pe 8" BY XP EMAC Ey, a ML A Be ee A PR TB TIC AY BLE RATT AE, RSA Bee tt Be BU AS IC 305 #9 HE dF SRE LE ft PR AY FE I ZEB I TB, BB SS "A Ae Ue OY a fea A, PR tt DR eae PE FLEA 4 9 TH FE AY TAL SE AS BE AE BM WSR AS SE HOS HE FY ARR AeATDO FEATS ) 0 HEAT SA AEE BS} RR —— 3 — BR B53 — TR) 25) AS A aR FR EA AS AR SE — A Fs SE FT A PR SSE FD CE RR AE THT EL BR 4 PF ARR ASE A RP REE. BARRA ATV RT AG Ws ZR AT OTT 245 Be ABA 01 4 hs BA aA A IB FR VAAE AE AS PEON TL Ye 04) BA ne HR. PA, BETH UR FE 7) BAY Ht , AS ff EC undetermination ) & FF EI AT US BAS PDP AS Ue 9 RET] SF 1 ee HY JEAN FEAR ALBIS A MEAS ABE EY , BUR EAS EO “RCM T FAT 226" (melted all solids); A #8 4 A A FR AE AE BHD Va) AS 480 J ep BE Dd HRS 46 CL A) CS EZ Ho HE BE) 24 D melted all solids 2 75 524 ALBUASIU TEC SESE Bt ADP FA — TE BL, AX PH] A PRR A PE A oh DFE «LA AF ne HE A EA SAC RAE BL 6 C7 PF ) DS 2: BEL AR EO FB ED PD 1 2h SRL HE AE AA CHE TEAS BEANE «ta I ICDL SCARE Cp 4500) 2002 4E ARS 1—12 GL). ——HRE34 3 A fk AOE ET SRT EG CELI) LEAR EAR ER: IIE (4 BE) BIEL CELE), BATE. be BEI 1 Be FET 1 SE) EOI FEL Wy ( £2 SE) RHE HE RN AR BEX A BBL A aE 9 LB FED AE BE) TT , SLICE B91 EB AE PR) Be SE TK A AFI BEI , BB ZR 28 He A AI By 1 BE) EBL, EA AT BR HAA Fi TE 8 Bae 0 A a SG Be BEB — Ve SOLE AVE Fa BE, — ESB HAT LAE AR CE — iB SE, AVA EW KS AR Se THR 9 AS Dd 9 FX LITRE Be AR BR RO SER ll ZS le SR IE EB 5 WY ERD RBA EE IMR IE Lo Fis EBA SF Be A ft ATVs 6 BB A ASE A AB RY 09 FAA Ly RS HS Be SE I PE HR He ED AT AGERE FLAS, NR OE HL LI HR ANAS SEED CL 4 RGR HY ASS , BB HO 2 eh — Se A” BR RH FRE” SCBA UERE . 298 - OR LR RAT BBE OAH A CORTUL , ABR RINAE )O: oO 6] - $28) (John Stuart Mill, 1806—1873) , SE BURT R Aer FR AUG ib LH A) ESA EB CR A, EEE He A GB BE AY GEA HD BOR EE OE) BIC AE DAF FEA MIT» BAY (James, Mil) 2. TRE ®@ John Stuart Mill, Principles of Political Economy, Vol. 4 (London: John W. Parker and Son, n.d. ), ch. 7Ae Rw eRRZ 38 EIT AD RE A A Ee RBA RAR TY ie, AAR AL#) Cw rie FeV RSF ae A 1 BY Ge HH RELSR BRN RE PAE HAT AT PAE Bere REARAR SHER Ce eR PHBA Be ABA BARE BA RE #4 BE A Cin Loco parentis ) , xt 18 KF — FER) he Se PTS LA SR CE LOE AS EC BR CAE 1 BBC HT HL FWY BILLA Ot, 5 SB SHUT EF (John Foster) OSE T tt KG AENISE I HH EH, FEB — WR OTE, AR ea AE Wr te — RH LE Nt ak HM ERR—-FIVHRAH MERROW TE REGR 18 (4 SE BY Fo I BL) FR AR Bo BK tk © John Foster, Class Struggle and the Industrial Revolution (London: Wei- denfeld and Nicolson, 1974), p. 3336 38 AL FE REA AR OFS AA AP ES TEL TE AR FU DAF SS SLAF 4h Zs Be HP BY BB BE BO TEP DD, BT OST WAAR BBE AE BE RE AE MF TL Se a” SB” TT E15 LETT ST ERY AT EE SH HES Vd AS FE aT BR FB BE DS a EE To TOL BY AEE IA PE PNT ICH Eb Ab PY AE OUR AS, ET EK HOA ER — FT PF HE TY HE BE FHL WUT PEDERI — EB “FE HEIR AE". ORR BRAG T eM AUS BATT, (ATT FB BP AS ROR TBE HFFA WIT FEO OH 1 A TA ADA BL WAS ENE - BROT ON Yb ER FE AeA] A GEIS A ANF TR 5 AE AY SC EAL A A, ZEB T OR ASAE EL AY BEA A oi 5 BPR BEF SE A URE EE 2 FT TRAD AAAS EP Re EAE ER DUD) 0 SEE AY ADE RE BLAS LO TAT RS FFX BP OE AE IF he BEB A TR AULA DLS 01 EF A Hes A ee AAT HEAR ( Alexis de Tocqueville, 1805-~1859) , #4: BL 4 WU BCT BEEG IG SE RE EPA WS FA ot HY Gy Ad ASU IRE EE AL eH, ERA a AT Cie SR AR AY BSE) CI i GE i> e TELESoe Da 37 PED, NRA FE, WATT TK EA TA AS BET CE SOARED E09 Ae ACY) + RE HE EM ROSE HD” BUSSES PF , LAS PSE A He PR ETT AL, WAT EE A LE SrA, ELMAR ASHE AS IU EE, AAT th ft — EL Xb FR HEAL AE Ain eka 5 J (0 BS ATS AS FBG Ss A HY TE Eo Fa TEAC AA THOSE PME ERA FDS, ME USE BB SBD TE] ARETE WS Eb ARSC BEAR BE AB FE FR FATT 9 BRAA— PSUR YAR IIR hE EE 2B) fa OT SH FE EF fm He FL BY A i BD 9 LAIRD ef eh A He Pt TA A FES HAE A AY Mh 7 Ee FT SEAWEED FS BE OT (RE — PO 2S ( engagement ) fi) IR PGEIA RE RAF SEI A ALE Te ae DE RP BE TAR. ARICA AREA, WL y BA ER 1 — i AE A AAS GREE Tn 5A Ea De ae BR EB OR ASF 3 FP HA ZO IRIA AN AT MG YEA] — Fr Ue, OY BS SP AE — PS FR. MEAL APE (Henry Ford) 2 BK, BUH ABT. A TBE HY BES SE RCE HBS LLB SA BR ASR GA A RA a BE LT 2 PER TA SE AE CARL LTT A 9 BL CIEE HY TED SE” AB St, Ue BOF AE, RY HF EN 45 OY 1995 FEM, 8 20 BO), —iFE38 dt Tl JM — P51 J SH DAR aS, ft SES ARS PH J CE — HE ER ALAS Be Ae He £8) BE —§ J ft Jk FR A BAT PR A 09 iE —— BE Fe AA ft 99 2 Ud 2 HR fei. AFH AU A EAA BLEAK SLI 39 Dy BOK ETA; SH AE fo — A AWABFCE IRE. TEDSTER SEN A RR ix — TORR ER ARK, (2-H Tk SE MARCA Ty (BED dH, J SE 9 OE ATS Hh) FY AN EAA eh EOF AST Le FEARS, RE AS TS LT BE LS AB FASE EAR HAG OS T]HE LAB eH TE ike A AE — i BE A HB SKB AN, 2s RK AIA TE FEI BTL AY ART fe HE A FAS BENE LE, BLD AR AE DLE 119 ALT 9 3 APT BEE. BER Ti BFE IAL 9 TALE IRI — BY ESAS BE SESE 159 TELA A TT EA HE AT HB aT PE PP, AB RF SUNY. PA ERS A AY Oy ZA HE Se HB BE aT Di PPE AS TE PR a RA Ht, RAE Ai PEARS ITT OL PX BEAR AT PT Py RL BY SATA PEAT HSS © CAH PET fe Ae ET A DR JH TE BE, RY FA HR A J A BT A, a AP 4: 53 88 (schismogenetic) Hf” (“BESR TG HE BRE tt A EARRIK BMRA 39 TAB EER LE — AE , AB AN FI AOR ATT A JUANES”) LH , LE Ss A CAEL i 8 a So Pt th Se AR MIZE TASH HES RG. RW TIGA VALE — ERT AB RE ES A FE DI EE Bho TEBE BEAS SE CAEP SESE EAT ATA EA FRE Bl tt BAS NRA EE LR AOBEARE Mw PASS Ee FAA A BY oR FUSS LIU, SE IAS TAA A AR TT AR SE” HEF SR OR WL a 19 2 MY AS Bs A 1 Bh Oe EY he SRI SAE — FH EAS A EI Ho RE, GRU EE) CED DALAT BAAD HERA PR BE BG AE IF Bs 38 — a“ fs CARS” ALS AS Hs aE aE AR A EP AR HB TT TEL — AER T BD)» 20 TLE , SS — es Ee Pe He AS BY Ong “tf [] 45 3 BH DFE” BA TARAS BR” “PIS BT HA HEARS AY A He BRAGA PE BI AEP AES HATTA SL ERD JPR AE POORER GR CE BLES ASAE AH FST FES PB EH IS ® FF 8h (Taylor , Frederick Winslow, 1856—1915) , 36 FR) 8A RA LB OG VAA8 YS EG i IE By Hd TT WS “Ee FRIESE) RIC KGET) CTE RE). —— PEEMo BEY AE AR, TERRE — PAT TOA De aE Ct, WADE) A PEST. BH ARAMA ERIE, EB BLARPR TE AT SHEE” (LEDL BS BEI I PE) OP BS a APR SUS AER BBE A 7 ak EMS TE KR FM ARB Ay BLAE HK AR MIAE AH 1 RBA FE 9 Ae PE bY IT ASD RA, TEFAN TAR WA POTS BATT Bh 1 — BH, ABE Tl Fa ExT NE ER FE BT LM OF Bh Ao HP IH VA AS BE EH TB TB Bs BL Jaa ti BE AL aE ass ETO AR SS {ARH IAD SS BY BLS HEY PE, BE A WAR AEE 2a PR A EWE (irrelevancy ) , IXHEIL AK FR Al FLERE ERE TDA KREATID ZS Ti 9 EB) BELEN AAI AAT Zh AY BYES AS ER EY AS WAKE BM AO LE AS HE — FEAST SR A oe EE Mi), LAE AR BE AB OR HY ES BE Ot MBL A REP TT BE A HE, “ET TOR Fe A IE BY BRR) BoA SA — PRB IES AK BEF LP PREITY“ BEAT BE” (model villages) , XJ LALA BARGE A AY SRM TS LACE TB) RR BLE” RE AR BLO ATT AS Fe RAE HNL 9 LB 9 had HH A A eT AWS SEO ME 5 A BRE TE TA BO ARH TELL. REXL TEL) JE ERAS RET FE, a A TEE, thRIS Bees 41 ALBEE PE Be IEA YL 2 A FT FB TEASE A AIT. A EE HK LAE Ga IT ARSE HE HE TAL A, AAS IB) TE BB 9 BY AER JER. SSE REM ACHR TAD (CE A RE IDE SEL EF PA SE Bes A AE AG BR OA ATT YS Dd ah pL {UA LITA Ja BAS BRR 3 Hat FAB AE DB DN TH 3 HER fA Air 2 Bi 8 SE BL aR a RAE A te aE AG En — i, FE AE I” WR BAY Hei Pe SBS ARE OR AL A ORE 2 30 EY. th A FEAR A ASE AE. LA PE HG HE 9 9 FETE A) MEF BEATE MRE EAS YR. AR AU LLE Ce SO at I BE SR Da AS EH 9 ET I Die ART wae AY JS REE BE AAR SRK. BS 2K FRADE T KR MELE, 3 RE ER BE I — TFS AERA BAY 3S FT ULE) Ff AS Fb BR WE AS FE Th, AER — Mike EE, FL UE C1 BEAR ERR OAD ‘bo FE Fd 4 2 BR 20 The 30 FEAR, 38 Hil HEL (Elton Mayo) 7E HE Pb (Hawthorne Enterprises) ZE47 T ix Za, 4E Tb tt 22% pte42 a A T*ABRR KF IK” (human relations school ) OF) 3 HE , FEA} “Tf A BSE AY PF, BE A eS A A Ws HB JE HUSK , BBR AT BAH DBE AT Ae 7 HF A SY TBR IT PEE AD REO : TPES PTAC RE "FE BY” SL TESST ABA AS BE HE AD RUE YR BB PA BD ART ERY AE PIB BR MR RE SN ERE, EAT FB OK PE A RAHAR. AAW RES AUN, BBE BSE AS Rt EA FT oh A BE, VA PEAS EY BD TPE Ae LY Be BEE , BEG PETE BG RAS A EE FR SFE PHY JES IEMA 2 TH A BRAS LITE MILF ZV ER RT AR Hk fH I RE, FEB SE BE AR PRATT Aa FETA) — ZAR _L” RE, AE aM Hb EE At AT ZS 0 A D BARRA MA — Ths LH RA TOS. BR MEE HE (RS Fe FEAR HY iY, CE ABBE 20 tH 22 20 AECL FE RN FOTTHE RS TER. HES HY Ey a) te RLS WAI LT HG A EE PS BE A AH RTE A 309 Jo 7 LN HE A: fits AE ik — ta AY ME wt AES TAR Ui BK SURI EARL AR AE, BUF ADRS A BEA TS EE HE PERRI RE EG RT, TAD A ARAL AS PES AREY RAT A HB 9) AAT tt PS ah , GE GE LEY BEAT. ATU, GMS FILS TL Mb th Se AR ER, AB a aD a A — A HE a A FPF CARAT HEAT AL SE A - a AER CE SE BR PE AT ak PK OE it), ——PREBIE BHARRRRLY 43 (EATER IT A se US SE TS HT AR ETA PY OBS AIO, EH TE FIRE FC FA A FG ES TR il A AAR, IB ZK eB 7k IS FR BRAVE SR BE BY CAC BE AD) DAS PE He BE PR SCABAN RAR AS BBE A). CERES PEE A I Jad AE Eg) MS Bs TE A A AF TE BP POL IU Sd ATG PAS EB MA FB Ag DY SAS A YER (actuarial) WEE, ENT RE TBR UT TBA AOL” RCH TA — A SH BBN HE LT hee ik A , IF TN PEL HE-AT DAG 7 STUB ED AE ST fA > St AE BY 2 ae a] ARRAS AACE AEE AT AT RHE. FER ER ROR BE EA ‘by BEE“ Se PRE” ( Kitrwille ) Wh SELEY “AS EAR” ( We- serawille ) , BEHE] §B Ay 9) fil Se Sth TY HY 3 BT Oy BE SU RAL”. RAPER DAS, TOE HE PF Ba A BE WORE ARIA” AOS AE” FRE I" — FETA OE BEAR AE SC GEOR A HDI STE SX DRT SHY, — > 28 TF SB SR Ta) 9 — A AE EMDR FE SE TRAST AAD A A, BAC de TAS BH FE. (LEHI RUE FEA UE RE, UE LE ED, FEES TAS RET AE E17 Bt BH Js BA SE, RR TA4 a SEN. WIA IE — RUNS SLO” HY EEE SQ EULA Wa A 9 J Se HE — PG AB SY BE AREAS AE FORBES BUC HERE — Pk BB” (social engineering) HUAT{€ , FER TALC, Ae BUA ERE BEE PAB PE BAP AE 5 DI Aa BIT LA CL Zs 3 I FR FY Hh BE DS AR SLB , HE PT WARES 0 BRE A PO Sek FW (9 WA J De FO RFBSR SY SSG AR, BESS — Behe SRS GA AE BE SA SILL (CFF het DAK , FE BEAN — EB IE TT A ARNG Ho (ELE. TERIR AR + Fy GEAR PT PERRY, Xt — 487 3 FRAN TEER DE, DA MEER SAAT AT ESE 3 Ss RS DPT SETH AH Rs EL A BB EA AOR BE, tH BE ABA CREATE NY ASHE IS. ETAT, AAG RDA THER AIA ISK FOR ALE BR RE I A A A JY) SAH i tH YS PEL A HER TT AS A OR BG IT THE. BEAR HE Cie be RR BRA ER , (ATT BE LY Fi is SEH 3S 25 HBB FETS UA FER ARTF HT, FST» 1 BA James Burnham) aye RES 22585 TO 28 AR BE AR BE ft RE FA ir” A AE TR SL TH A TTT. A LARA My , Fil BT AS 2 REA HT — PPL A ATT 89 RAS ARS ECAR T ATL ARE CAAT TR. AE LE BM AY PE Aa ALA LT AEE ZS BT DA46 Bt Te PEATE EU Ay Bee BET A BT 9 PT 9 KALA ISAC RAEI A AEF RH BE ARLEBCH RENT A. AAR HEE 6 EP SARL AA LE A CE BEE tr) ( Manage- rial Revolution )¥T VB 7S BLES BUCA Be VA Be FALL SE BREE OT BEF AD FE TO UA A SIL, AREF AS AL WT BEA TL BA HY th AB EHESHU TMS, MK AEE EM aS th A RET As I FF SHEL TAR SA GX BE I AD AA BE HB DT ARER BBE — SBI AG BATS EUR AY Ae RE th 2 AX GSE — AG IGA OAD BE PRSAM WAGE Bit TRB a TUR IS BUA ARERR SA A HE Oy HL Ze OR oh 9 RRIF EEL ANN BRIE ARH BY FR, BRT Ss JA WTP PRTT SCH DA BE a BRIE BR it aE AE AY Se EY Dr EY NIE, MEH Hl EPEAT TAT 19 1B, eS TBE fi SEE FT BAN BE AB SE SR CE BE AB SE BE A HE OK AVIRA, HE SE A — AP a OE TUTE RAR SE TAR SR BE FO) 4 BERK — By YOK BH aE ZEMAN SENS E ATHY Sb FEF BE TY, 4 TE AGRS DRM, RRMA AE 47 FASE TE TRAY AL IE AS tA TR | AE PE AMT TILA — ELE EF ta AT FTE BUGAS . ANT, MIL ADB — Al , 1A te BEE Eh ET HUFF. “PEASE AT” (great engagement) HIP, MEST. FE/H BSN , ARLE Sh BPM T BOLT EER BY PB AAR Jes RAIL 14, SABA A SJE, AST) Ae A BE AAT BRAS A BCE At AT EY SR AS EE A FI th REA AERA. EP BASE A HOT AU “HBC FY BS” (great disengagement) MFT FRLIE BT RS a a EA ET AR J — PR SABR AY BT AG, AE — PS TE SS BE A Bi) BLE TA SP ABR DD” (outsourcing) PHIAT HE. BSE — PRE — i SY Te] AP SEE “EE F515 3A ALA BT” FE A SG SE TB)” SF] aE tS BRA HET IE. “Se BRAS hil” (deregulation ) DL 4E WR 1 53k 48 FE 9 A, wR TEAL TT PRO SF AL FS AR RE Sethi” PT VA aE AA, FE I AR TB) AR A Rf ATT 9 Pe SE BR, A AAT] AFT oe AE DFARS EAR MLAS RAB SEA 2S) FT SE, SRE ESD SE BE HE BR AA FEL AS AGIA TL. 22 9 HE SEER ©. ——PRLE48 3 Fe BULA RS 5 HS Dy ftbAT AS PP HB] AR ERP ERY AR SPR CAERT —PRE WWF, EAE BA FATED FETS LCE ALY FAD A FE TS TER AT HE BBB Pe EB FP Hi AT BEAR A, (ATT a 8 A EA BAS FEA FEN ALD RCE FEF] (domination) AR £2 BIG RES 5 RG, HLS FEAR SOE A BE A WLR SCT YF I RH A ATT A fe. ECARAT THN LARA AR Roe BEAR AG ih BRIA E BER BE 2b 4 HB S$ ( servicing) ——f9 Biot : 3 Py Wk EER BE Ab FAS Wa Baz BAR AS OP, PLAT BO SR BE AA BEASTE BR TS 298 1 A BE A BEB fil. TE RAG ANH (Pierre Bourdieu) —FE48 HY, ATEN AS BE ( précarité )ARAS——$ AL. Ze HO ATLAS FE EAA IR ETE IAB AE PSR BA) * FC FS ll BCE” 149 HE —— AR eT — A sat T SR SF He TP TE BY FB 24 ah} —— SU OB Le De ae he eT HE CUES EX — FL BE AE 1 ba A SEAR) AA Dr Ta BE, BRR PT 2 ARHS A SRLS 5 — 45 SE Mh a PE BB 2 OR AE HE A PA AA ie UY FL EDEL Ty HY HE TL, TS LTE FELASA PAS — BH A ld PE TT HY Le, BRE AF TSR LBC. PRR AR ATA BLD,RS SEAVER ER AUR TAG 49 Af 18 29> ERB BU os BEF A AT BY BEF AS ABBY, HOARE AD AAAS” 2 PEAS A RE FAN BRE UARAS B20 BAAR ME EFC HE” 3 AR 2S 1 JAR) kA RHE, FR FRE PY EAS IG BE AEE fo] 3k BR 2 BE Oe SEE AN TPB JRL FE. USES TR ES IE AS, TOL as 2 CS AR BE 9 LAT PRM EKER. BPO WH CREE PE SLASH SEE LE TE 9 FP SE a BL IS SHOE i AE AE EASY TEAS BR” RE AR TL YB a FF A SE MS HR HS itt) ARRAY. ATER «EE AB £08 9 Se BE Eh aH SIR ASE RAG TOPLAS BE", IESE TT AY REEL REP AV BE PAE Ay. SA TT, PU ah OnE ete A AE He ay Ses ESE AMAT AFT PE NY 7 ME ae EB) RE EE AU TPA AS SH a SE 49 FE HH REE EA TI a TE FEA EL 2 FE RT FLEA HESR , ZE 1X — HER PY, HS HS Jat SP MR Re HE 9 a BEIT WS A, UT A FE TB fe oC HF AT RP BE SRE ARR AY A SARK 5 FESS FB TE, 1B OF NY KY EAA SOK. BRR — Fy ABTA RE “$8 TE Fh”, Wi RAAT A ht, HBA RY Ry Ty, SORT WA SE HY50, a FAURE ATT AS Fak EL Sot SAR RR A PE ET BE BERIT SEP EE, SRE TR AS ANE BY BT EE BE JIRA AER MB SE AAT OW i ER ESS SO AES WSS Bh TAR FE BY BT AE BE Ab BE AY TAI A 5 FR A AAR A SE ALI AS A “(i id sk PA i — BB 9 FR Hd OK FBZ F AIEEE.) TEBE , oh“ SLI) TT” GE sl Se a 9 SH J SAT RAMBIRE . (ASE, TE ROPE AE PS + BEY TF (Richard Sen- nett) SE REAR THY , RBA MAW RAH SKREA BRT REA # TASK & & (the United Auto Workers Union) 4°28 Fi i #2 #l (General Motors) 4 7) A iE 8Y [5 BE 4 i KHPA CARALANHP A CH ERWHE, AN HET SE Be TR AE AB REAR A, TA RD AS TLR HH, Bt FTL a — A 30 FERRARA BR , BEE XLS EE AL AS FS EE 9 UROL TRE OR A HRS BR HT ® Richard Sennett, The Corrosion of Character: the Personal Consequences of Work in the New Capitalism (New York: Norton, 1998), pp. 42-3.Sak SERS HOET AE COR Bh SR Mo HA ae 51 FR oh 0 Sk a 28, SH SA BS ES 0 SS BO TE OE AEH HH AS, OR ET ASE HD” EE AT FEAR”, (EAD UE AER ASE BY FE AT HD oD AP A De EAS PN BR VA PR ae AEE LE, BRE be A EE, WOOP Es SHELA BR HE, Seo bE AS WT BE EY, BT ARTY ERTS CE IF UE TT FR ahi AR I ES IIR TE AL Se AB FS AR LE PRE PUETT , 1D EL AE AE IS A se TT EA — 71 8 1) PRITAM PAY BPD BE — BS HD SE AS Sb Hb A BAR HE i TT SH. BR a OP A bm th AR ES TE A FO, PUTER RTI — FB BBE HY Jy EE BA PO IRE, FEE PAA THE AL IAG SS | IY IZ AT A GE IB Hehe UM te AR LT LILA A OFT wh A Ho SEAMS ART, EL — RAT Wy SE Sol BE FE IE, HEIR TBS | AA EE P 5 URE RE BUS Pe eh TE AC AY SI AR UK ABE ST a BI — AN AL, A ASE a Oe BF Ste TE TL RATERS ESTE]. EVE ZS AR NaH, Fa — 2 ATT EH TE FOES RATT, FRAT BA RAT Wy EM BK — GK: BD ® Ibid, p. 45.Bo GAFERM AGIA P A. i AAR IEA JEDDAH BL AH DHE 99 OY a Be AT RS EP ey SE AF Hy EM BL FE A TA AS IY A SY AR IBEAT BAO ADL Ab BrP GL AR TE 919 3S, SAT Be SEAS a LL Be EY BE AB TL, AN OT AHL AS HY EB BH 5 AK ALAN 2 EY BO De SE BB SF 9 TL FRR LE PEXEA TY BAER AS EE I) CE CA) TE BFE i) LA 0 REIS TOR AAR. SR GY PRADA TP A RE, IP SAE ES AAS PA BE NY BY 1 AI SE Me Ss SZ Hl WBE S RATE FUE FIX BK T AS BIR TT ILE BOS ABFA BA IR — BM ARK — Ts SE ERORET BH Le 99 EE (DHE 99 BER ye HE SB TEA AS RY , THE: TPR Ay a ay 42 TL 9 “ES IRR, NG PPSUL EY WE CE ATT Ae YBa O03 ALE SAP A Be HE AD EP PEAR TA) AD BORG RAS AE HE Ai (Edmund Jabes) 2 168 19 AIBA eB BGK PBR ERE Be ASS CEE AH HY UE EB Ck AH BA RAR EN SE AER ARE FESR Dy Bi) ) FE ARM BEAT — 95 FF Ss Fk TI BY TR TE OMEN FE 21 TEC BO Be he AT AP 3 EP, BE ae IESRSA TPR, BR — Be fs RE 53 SR, FA ELA 6 5 Sh Sy 5 Hh Ha Os AT EB PRT VA BB , UT ARE ee FEMS A ATT BE Oh EY SEER TE AAG, JM, I SL HLT A PY St BPR BK MATT NF Ee 5 EB HR BR IL BE, PEA SE RSE YE TE Eh oe A A CAE AE a HE — es RH LH, BY PA A BOE HS HE LSE. ATR AT AR SAAS TE WY BRIN HA 1d 5 By BEE HY TL FR SE IE BRE STA BK EAR oh AE FRR TH — BL BER FIT SEAS, AA a 2 A PE EY se A BR TEAL IATA DARA DAL Ses Sek IS ET HEA (BAY LAE FETE RTL Eas AIDE AE A ASL. BRE HE UE T AB FOP TPE A AE A BR a PA RE AB it «FE PE — AR SS A 0 AB PSE NT AE ECR ABTA BE LI ALT. BUTE IA HY AGT HUT YT ES A IR AT a RLY AL Se Hs BAY Bo TE — RE A A RE” TT BA Sa BEA TE Zs DY A AE (A AS I ) FO AS oS LA EAE DB AR LE ——1ea EH EE A PEE ERICH TO, HET AE, MERE BCA AY AT A BU AEE DA SE HE AK TT EA YG TBE BYERS A a8 HBA ZS a) FOI ti EE SE — ZI A AT34 St Tel RR AEL ETERS BARA, PTR A HELA a 7ST o> BY “A AS4F" HITE (“cannot do without” jobs) 18% T ; YA BAA IE OR POR HE AB HES AE TE TEE 1 SFL Be ESL 9 “SA ALE AW ZARA REBRA AT ; LIE MERZ HORE ZC. “ARSE CE A Be BIS SB” EB Bs BRIBE IE BAIS BE, BAS LR 2S BL A a HS YE eA EI EK — A HE EE ER PRT, EAU TPS tL Se RIE AS HE — TE WG, FUP Eth i a 1 A AHS TE, 3 FRA REED TE BES , FE AE BR BEE AT i BE AT AD BEDS “WRT FP Be SEAT Ae A th Dy, FE RRR , WR LE (AZAR BEIE FAG”. TERRES Ie (RES A TT SAE Tk Mey, 01 SE SE YE BR) DA ARE TREAT ARATE” . PHOT BY A Eb BF AR ERAT EO 2s Me te FY A ES BS EAR HR AS Ra HE Fo 3 Ms , Hs BE A EA ATT AD AZ PY HS FEAEARY GEAR TE SE ZW EAT Ps EI A BEAL DT ER — AE Sb HY HF, SPAS A FBR HE TAL — DLA ASS HR AE BG HY BEEP, ESE, TERK HEMT ATT © Ibid. pp. 20-1RAR AAO, RON MR MOT AEE 55 CARPE AE IBA Sh CR BA ES, UE Aa AT AR OG BE AG SE AB A AGAVE BE SARE AFLAC AAT AAI RR Ve EHE DU AA TB HFC ee AT TER FF EY API BET REANEIS. ARENT AAG ABLE IND TAY SE He ETA oS A AA I) — SE HE RRB T CER FEMA Z PR , HEIR AS BUR KA EE FEAIAT o AC aE MY 4 Hh HEAT BR EARP HE DR oP Tt AS TEV Ha RR — Site BAR BAT AH HE ZB HL FORE ALE EM) ) EA EP BR AE A” PR TT FORRHEIE A I eT AP RR. PUR FEARS WE BE Jae BR CEE 04) AB LT BLE RARE ABLAZE BUG EA EA 4 FUE ARIE RAS RE EOE EE A PE FP OK (ELI Bt, SL VA FEL BU SL 38 TF] — 4S 5 SC AE DL Se BE AR iy FE BE FAR. WTR SH ER BE AN BB IE AS be 18K BG bE A JE 40 (AX (Yvonne Roberts) eA AIF EH : “TE 21 thee FFG ESA YER , FS A EG BY) FR SR AE I 9 AE I eT PEIBRER.” ( Observer, 13 Feb. 2000) ABE TEE BY IE fi AR BA ES JE REARS — 46 HY BT RE EE 1 E> Ts AEC TT, MR AS AEBS EAA. — PRT IIL BEF EAY56 St al te PLIERS Aa AY IRE BY Eh”, BE — 4 Eb BA * OL UY" 119 St A BAR AS TA A A HE HE RE BA ME RHE AE BUSEY “> AEE AI — PFE ME RRS FB KS ES eA FS FR A EB ARID , EGE ARE EAB BE EA Eis (BE BE FRA BRR BAA TAS RATE OH JSR” BRATDRE AE ASU AR BAD ET DP! — FEB ME, Pa AL BBE A BAR AY IAZ , WA RATES KA BENE, LEME Zak FR A) SF HR RAL BR AT ME A 19 32 A HE YE 5 HK FIR AR ATT AT Oy 19 25 FRG EFT yO 2S J BR EGFR TAA, BB ZR TA BY SEA A EN AS A AE HE , BB TA TORE EARS 2 LE A RA TAPHEPFE. ELBE AEE, , FAR EDA DQ ADB IBLE PA TS LH BO“ UAGLE HH” 5 I RE FE TD LA” ( closely knit com- munity 35 28 FF (8 FA A LIB AB RE —€ 2 — PA HEE BR “SE TA”, PRAR EEE 10 He (FP BSE De] AT BAK BG Se, BE AK a LSS EL HE FEL YY 5 SB Ae ir BS ER) OR 18)" —BAB ARS BS RP RA MOSER”. IE "EBS AAG BLE AB LT, TT ELIE BEE OAS BE ERASE FA]=e ST RHOT TE RR A A 57 PREY RGR" FET BRE” . GX AUNEHELELELZE 1960 “EE CREAR TS SERA ALY AE ET TG OE LOI JDC AR SETA ARIKAR B NUDO AR WEI FA BL SIGS HEA BRAID ei SA SO A A RAAT." OMB DISET: GX RRL AE IK TL AY REDE DE YL SS AERK AL Se RE DY EE RR AY THRE AS HE SA aR BE Ar YATE BN LETHE AR ALI 8 AL AND Shh ANY AS PE BITE UAL, I ISL AT Uae SE EAP ALE OK EHRAAT ANS FENG IAAT SEE A i WR I IPRA BUR Wer Ra ake ey — PbS Te Jy I — HOTTA AT LAE A IER AS JENA AE” HEUER CE Te VA 093 BY REE A A TELE FAY 5 ELF Lk ASAE SY LIE DHE LEP LA A OH EIR A PE — UVR Le NCAR D> ILA en BT ET 8 ASA ERK ND TH ARLE BR EU AT 2 OE BAR RE AEE RM SF A UC ET BE TE UIE BA A AEB © Maurice R. Stein, The Eclipse of Community: an Interpretation of Ameri can Studies, 2" edn (New York: Harper and Row, 1965), P. 329.S08 SOE 1 BE BS “RDNA BY BLES” (secession of the successful) 3% V1 , KE (4% - LAF (Robert Reich) 4 3448 ZEA LE) ( The Work of Nations ) : "E48 4 S86 A —— 0 FRE AB AB EAB AAS SAAT] SF BLY TE" AE” AT WAFL ATE , HE ARRAN ST ER ——$ IY BS POR BES ANSE SE EAPO PE “AE ACE”. A OU Sat 8 RS, BA — BOY AE Ab EK TP AR (the Great Depression) AIX — ft A NUK F , TE FE FEB 52 SE TT 6 eH 2b AE THE BB 6 09 0 SF ee SBR”. ASE HORTA LAM MIM, AT SRE ttt ee AEG AY DIED A AS BY SR HE OR TTD BET PA ® Richard Rorty, Achieving Our Country, Leftist Thought in Twenticth- Century America (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1998), pp. 86~7. @ 48 1929-1939 FF AeA He Bl Be Ht BE AS SE CB A 8 FC LP TCAL ES EPL” EAA WE 1929-1933 4F, RAE A TF 5 ~ 6 EAE). ——— PREUR RAS 59 EVER SATE, ft (TSH ASP BA RE i At ATT Sf 7 = 195 BaP AT RT] BC BE AB PE ET TD A FEAR FRR AH SAAS SR ATA. HATTIE AY ARR” ERR AAT AS Fs BE RC) ET BBR a ne“ A” CE ARSE AS AF BEC A CAL, BEAR ATF 9 28 EE BS 47) WY PF HE RE. AL, AP, ER RRP HAS A REE Bh LHL Ao i ED OY HR HE th 2B) — ANY Boe TAR” 89 Fe By SP TD FEB Ree MRAKBRAG KASH EWA UPA RY ASL AH Gl HB A ie AKRAM ARE, LERN TARR SHKA oF Hi ORR YE a GPE BY 2 Ba as OLE HL Hs BE OR Fh BR A ET HF FEBS MHD ROT RI at Rh Ae HES HAT AB BIA OY REESE. RARER A TE © Pals #29 (Menenius Agrippa, A 63—Ai 12), HP Be TAB YR EAA BP AE HG, ES PS ae SEA. —— i te60 St ie FP EOP ER TA Ty CRT De DB A BG He a BR FEE TELM J —— ELAS PST ITE) Bie a “ABR” «a PR HG 24 aE IE AS FEE oT ERS , BS ADEE EE ER TR OR AN BTR NE ‘a BE TE Va) A YR SH 5 He be, FS A at ATT A, SE At TR SAMBA — BW) Fe BE , AMAT A RB SH TR, {ERE ESE TAL PAR DE Sj FRA BE a HO TAR Da) he BR ft APs PE Ab 258 FR BEY is, AA TAN FE AS REA JAE - 2 AE BW (Dick Pountain) AK TD - B $2 Hi ( David Robins) OWE PRIX "BE" (cool) AT M4 PE Da * AR Dh A ABE BS” PERERA TE. RRA FE RS IR PRK AA TEI RAT FR HB ARF 1 PTE RT ORT, — PAI GEE RT BP FET FER BAAD EAT A AR TE. RTL HE, "AR" CART Ea AR WL Weltanschauung ) . WAAR EAS FEA BLE, JHE) (Gb A BY) FR OK UAE, BB A BRE HAT 9 R17 BE PRE ES ARPA ARSE. ABH A EAR SE AY SE iC A, 0 TH Bt 13H Ae 2 A EA LEA PT A ae BAN 1 EY @ Dick Pountain and David Robins, “Too cool to care”, extract from a forthcoming book Cool Rules: Anatomy of an Attitude, quoted after The Editor, U1 Feb. 2000, pp. 12-13.SBR MOR ORS 61 SA. WLS RE AAT BET RT TE CEs FALE EE ORL BO WY Be aS UT RE AR AE FSSC CTE SMART” IRR” RT CB IE 19 FB ER FRIST BE BEY, 1 Fe EB BNE PA TE SAE HHRAP". BT HMPH NK BAELBRSRA ES BME BARWH. RERSA ERM RANE S ml” Tee Re SRW OR AP AR AB BY sree ANA AL BRA A ROY HIS EE SKN ARARKEREM EH. REABEST AB EMG FARE RG RES B25 PA” BY SB BE AT AY SSP RAR SR SESE AT AY ER BR RAY FG RABI EE, ECT BA A BS FR PEE HP AE EB BE WYRE BOMBER IL OK BEAR EH RET BETO AT SBI AAR ATT — PE ASP Hf EL HY YE EDU Ee PAB A FR BB YB eB ak FA 4 ZR PEEPS 5 ERE SD BS 19 (BA Ae TE BRA BI Sb AR AK EWI Fe — PEAR FEE ME AST BY (TT ELT EES A BR FY) SUI. CAPS REPEATS, HE AR S| TEP Be62 de A DEALS UHL A AGRA A BEE AOR BEE RSET Bh POR ESET A A BEE. BEE A PURGE “LEA TB IAT” PT” CR TBA, AN ATL FRA 8 Fi Hak A) PL A St A A IT OE I OR AAT (HE IBAA IT PEIN AS GE ABI REL 2 > ak PEL AMDT TAA ASS OES AS EE 2 BT PE BIE TS RE, FPA ACK HS BEAR LFB ASD BEIM, CEA MD Es WBE HAE TE, GELS a A a PREETI AST EA RABY ME. TE A Fe AC LB AG I EY, FE HY SR SEALE GALA, GR OAT 5 ET AE A de ABA AT $0 8 ——$ fb 0 EF AI A DS — 2a BE ESTE BRAG AD bts BA BEAT 9 BSG FAT RHE A TG AB. g ST a Fm] Sie DUR AL EA A Ta J BE OR AR CY Fp CE TT AN HA , BS GK Bea SAA LAS HE EMER FA EE ES FEI, PRI RAE BE TP BK @® Soren Kierkegaard, Bither/Or, tans. David F. Swenson and Lillian Marvin Swenson (Princeton; Princeton University Press, 1994); here quoted after David L. Norton and Mary F. Kille (eds), Philosophies of Love (Totowa: Helix Books, 1971), pp. 45-8.FOR MINHA ES 63 RXL, ERA RRA, BH hh eR AE ETE Re, fe Ye A Re, bik a RRR FEFCREDA EPR S| A HE Ws EE AGE, RF A: TPS A — “MBSR PTE 5 ET RES 5 SH BAR Sa A TETRA AIM BURSTEIN. ERESERM, Mia MMi FAT Mh, SR FB Ae PES A SL TT Lt EAT Aas BBB SS Hh BE — BGG FFI — HE BER A PAE, BOR HE DER TAE OMB UBN BE, SR aE A PR a Tt FR PE — BURL SE ALAS HS BRR RAH GR Be TBE, E BE JERI AECE. EBERT EL BIE Ae SB BAA SA DT £0 BBL , 8h AS 2 BC EI AR : — BREE AN EL R—TIAK. SREBS T OMA BAKA PORES TAY AB FUL a) “TSR AR SER” A EE EAB ATTRA EB RBA A A FF KT , ft SK — GE ABRE 9 FE DA AR A AS BA PA I TAT ET AE JAAR BRA” » CATA ER BE A he BEE BZA AR Pri) AG AERA RE LA, CARE BILE TAA CRA WAS He A NAA SASHA PTA AS64 3% 7 tk PUA Fl AS ESS ALT DA Se PB A PR SEALE 5 TE FA EHD AR PR Fa OE ha” AV AT, ea AR” BR RAR AMA TIT TET BS” AN AE PRR HBS A EER AUR LA, Ti EL TE Ay BEA BE SSPE AT A —— 3 IG, Aa Ek — YEE A a GR Re (0 TR A BHR A 28S AR R$ BTV BRD SETALIASES HE SP TE 3k EE TA) TNO Be Teg A HF ZS) ZEA 9 TL Fr A A A CH (AF Sh BE aa BSR A SER SR TTD 33 Be Bir BO SI EYE FEAR EAR OK HL” (7 LANE 9 BY Be IE EA OR AEH. BRT e-mail hk AF OLS aH, ANT AY TH FDR AE Al a ASL” 6 BL TOA A HH Hh SO Es EE ELIE AY EH AB BE Fs FORM ZR EASE Te (RY EF eK BRT FEA HB SEY (1B AR AES A A PREY ) SE AE EA SAAR SS BA A “SEER YEAS SE” JE Ar BIC A AR 9 ICRF HY DSR — FBR CEH IB EE AE GFE EAT A MS BRAC ESTESE” DFP , UFR AT $19 BBE ARR PER AMA M135 — 2 FEAT PRE. AT&T 257] @D “The Cultural Globalization Project” , Insight (Spring 2000), pp. 3-5ROR Lo 65. — AR LER BR , (th ft BO PE A FE BA EAT BR SEAS EASA — ASE PR TRS BR” 5 TE A HR EP EPE ATT ARR WAC SRS AC HEE SY 4 HS “fe PT Ed FAA ER RP Re 21 th Se EAE PAT OF BS BOAR BH "Hi FE ( Nike) ZS Fi] — 15, 28 BH XS ft C9 BE RG AS SEB OLAB AH LA Ts Sh I Hy RS ALA A eB Be BS KOHR NWF” SRT, RR RE DAR BY IF AS RR SO — A BREE SCAR ETS , BERR TE ARE CE SC He KIRA 29 ZT SAR ANZ ALTA TE HR EB BEE HI” 5 ATG DR hE Habs B00 Ae BRAY Lae STA) AF CE A BB at A SB AS BE AB. TEMS TE WARIS A ATS MSD, BEAL TAR AY RE SEPIGE-+HEEEHSREAR TP UKREG Y L—§_ 1 FT HR ArH RATE FR TT TE eH Ob BH TB > PS Lm. YRBBHH, SRURAREES SU “Ay SR AL” HH BEE A A HY one Kit th Me BW Be EA OR GUE ORL FR aS ELOY. fA — AAG, 1166 3 TA tk AERA RR XZ HR BBY DK HE BY RAKE ZS Po BARA NED eH ROLREXH BR, AR - HRP BEAK Fo 5 tt ALR TK LER ATARI AS PEAT (LA 2 A AR SY FEAR AGH He TE ARB Ha 2 TW kA HEAL 4) FR) TE BBR A TE RATT IA] — FB “tit 4 FE SL” (cosmopolitanism ) BOP IRE ZS, EEE EE SH PIR ER 1” OY ERE Py RUA Be AAT SADLY a RGR. PE HET AY Te] SETS BFE A 2 Ds AB BP AAP? FEVER TB 1 RAFTS AS TL SES" ESE DT TT FEA MAE eR RAE EEE. AP PRE EA REE PRICE” AYA £6: ESR A HE BEY IZ 1 BS PE, ZEB 7S AAT NS 15 0S, BY) GE ir be , AN A FE Be 7 WO HEB SEAS STG EASA BR ANT a) FT EL BY SC 1 —— Sp “ATR AT” WS 4 AHS PE CE LL RB SHE SE VTE Ai Rk BS AE A “a” EPA ER” BRAY 2 ATA BR Ee A A YH EC DT REA BE KARA BY, TT ELL ES” EAS BE) A TEAR KE AAR — AEE. TTA TS