Professional Documents
Culture Documents
REVIEW
How does hypertension affect your eyes?
M Bhargava1, MK Ikram1,2 and TY Wong1,3
1
Singapore Eye Research Institute, National University of Singapore, Singapore; 2Department of
Ophthalmology, Erasmus Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands and 3Centre for Eye Research
Australia, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Hypertension has profound effects on various parts one of the major risk factors for development and
of the eye. Classically, elevated blood pressure results progression of diabetic retinopathy, and control of
in a series of retinal microvascular changes called blood pressure has been shown in large clinical trials
hypertensive retinopathy, comprising of generalized to prevent visual loss from diabetic retinopathy. In
and focal retinal arteriolar narrowing, arteriovenous addition, several retinal diseases such as retinal vas-
nicking, retinal hemorrhages, microaneurysms and, in cular occlusion (artery and vein occlusion), retinal
severe cases, optic disc and macular edema. Studies arteriolar emboli, macroaneurysm, ischemic optic neu-
have shown that mild hypertensive retinopathy signs ropathy and age-related macular degeneration may also
are common and seen in nearly 10% of the general be related to hypertension; however, there is as yet no
adult non-diabetic population. Hypertensive retinopathy evidence that treatment of hypertension prevents vision
signs are associated with other indicators of end-organ loss from these conditions. In management of patients with
damage (for example, left ventricular hypertrophy, renal hypertension, physicians should be aware of the full
impairment) and may be a risk marker of future clinical spectrum of the relationship of blood pressure and the eye.
events, such as stroke, congestive heart failure and Journal of Human Hypertension (2012) 26, 71 – 83;
cardiovascular mortality. Furthermore, hypertension is doi:10.1038/jhh.2011.37; published online 21 April 2011
Figure 1 Generalized and focal arteriolar (white arrow) narrow- Figure 3 Arteriolar narrowing, AVN, with flame-shaped (blue
ing with moderate opacification of arterioles (black arrow). arrow) and dot blot hemorrhages: moderate retinopathy.
Figure 2 AVN: mild retinopathy. Figure 4 Arteriolar narrowing, AVN, flame-shaped hemorrhages
along with cotton wool spots (white arrow) and hard exudates
(black arrow): moderate retinopathy.
can be detected even in children with hyperten-
sion.2 If the blood pressure remains chronically pathy signs reflecting the ‘exudative’ stage (for
elevated, there is compression of venules by struc- example, retinal hemorrhages) may be seen in eyes
tural changes in the arterioles, resulting in arterio- without features of the ‘arteriosclerotic’ stage (for
venous nicking (Figure 2). Severe hypertension example, AVN). In fact, hypertensive retinopathy
leads ultimately to progression to an ‘exudative’ signs can be frequently detected even in adults who
stage in which flame-shaped retinal hemorrhages are not known to have hypertension.5
and cotton wool spots are observed (Figures 3 and 4); It is important for physicians to be aware that
and finally to a ‘malignant’ stage with optic disc some retinal microvascular signs of hypertension
and macular edema.3 These pathophysiological may also be seen in other systemic and ocular
changes and clinical features are depicted in detail conditions, such as diabetic retinopathy, radiation
in Table 1. retinopathy, anemic/leukemic retinopathy, trauma,
Chronic blood pressure elevation can lead to human immunodeficiency virus and other infec-
hypertensive choroidopathy generally seen in tions. Thus, in atypical situation, appropriate
younger patients with pliable vessels that are not investigations may be necessary to rule out other
yet sclerotic from long-standing hypertension. important diseases that may masquerade as hyper-
Acute elevations in blood pressure that overwhelm tensive retinopathy.6
the compensatory tone actually harm the choroidal
circulation more than the retinal circulation due to
the sympathetic innervation of choroid. As a result, Epidemiology
the choroidal arterioles constrict considerably initi- With increasing use of retinal photographs since the
ally, which further increases the blood pressure and 1990s, population-based studies have provided data
damages the arterioles.4 about prevalence, risk factors and systemic associa-
The above-mentioned stages of hypertensive tions of hypertensive eye changes.2,5,7–15 The find-
retinopathy are usually not sequential, and retino- ings from some of the major studies are summarized
BDES 4926 persons aged 43–86 years, White 7.8–13.5 2.8–19.4% (MAs+RH ¼ 2.8%; AVN ¼ 5.8%; FAN ¼ 13.8%)
ethnicity, Wisconsin, USA
BMES 3654 persons aged 49 and older, White 7.9–9.9 6.8–15.4% (MAs+RH ¼ 9.9%; AVN ¼ 8.6%; FAN ¼ 7.9%)
ethnicity, Australia
ARIC Study 10 000+ persons aged 51–72 years, White 3.3–7.3 5.0–11.9% (MAs+RH ¼ 2.8%; AVN ¼ 5.8%; FAN ¼ 7.3%)
and Black ethnicity, four USA
communities
CHS 2400+ persons aged 69–97 years, White 8.3–9.6 9.0–12.3% (MAs+RH ¼ 8.3%; AVN ¼ 7.8%; FAN ¼ 9.6%)
and Black ethnicity, four USA
communities
Rotterdam Eye 5674 persons aged 55 and older, White 5 (MAs+RH) –
Study ethnicity, Holland
SiMES 3280 Malays aged 40–80 years, Asians, 4.7 (MAs+RH) 6% (MAs+RH ¼ 5.8%; CWS ¼ 0.3%)
Singapore
Handan Eye 6830 Chinese aged 430 years, China 8.6 12.1%
Study
Beijing Eye 4439 Chinese subjects aged 45–89 years, GAN ¼ 14.6%; GAN ¼ 25.4%; FAN ¼ 12.1%; AVN ¼ 12.3%
Study China FAN ¼ 6.2%;
AVN ¼ 6.1%
Funagata Study 1961 Japanese aged 35 or older, Japan 7.7% (FAN, AVN, MAs/RH)
MESA 6176 subjects aged 45–84 years, four 12.5% (11.9–17.2%) ¼ mostly MAs and RHs
ethnic groups (White, Black, Hispanic and
Chinese)
Abbreviations: ARIC, atherosclerosis risk in community; AVN, arteriovenous nicking; BDES, Beaver Dam Eye Study; BMES, Blue Mountains Eye
Study; CHS, Cardiovascular Health Study; CWS, cotton wool spots; FAN, focal arteriolar narrowing; GAN, generalized arteriolar narrowing; MA,
microaneurysms; MESA, Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis; RHs, retinal hemorrhages; SiMES, Singapore Malay Eye Study.
a
Includes GAN, FAN, AVN and RH/MA/CWS in non-diabetic persons.
in Table 2. These studies indicate that many of the (5.7–8%) with presence of cotton wool spots being
hypertensive retinopathy signs are commonly seen relatively uncommon (0.2%). Some studies suggest
in 6–15% of non-diabetic adults aged X40 years.13,10 that the incidence of generalized arteriolar narrow-
In particular, isolated retinal hemorrhages and/or ing is as high as 25% among hypertensive people,
microaneurysms are most commonly observed signs with FAN and AVN found in 12% of people with
Mild One or more of the following signs: generalized Weak associations with stroke, Routine care
arteriolar narrowing, focal arteriolar narrowing, coronary heart disease and Closer monitoring of vascular
arteriovenous nicking, arteriolar wall opacity cardiovascular mortality risk
(silver wiring)
Moderate Mild retinopathy with one or more of the Strong association with stroke, Exclude diabetes
following signs: retinal hemorrhage (blot, dot or congestive heart failure, renal Closer monitoring of vascular
flame shaped), microaneurysms, cotton wool dysfunction and cardiovascular risk
spot, hard exudates mortality Possible indication for
hypertension treatment and
other risk factors
Malignant Moderate retinopathy signs plus optic disc Associated with mortality Urgent hypertension treatment
swelling and macular edema
Diabetic retinopathy
Diabetes and hypertension are both vascular risk
factors with identical pathophysiological mechan-
isms.4 In the presence of hypertension, persons with
diabetes are more likely to have diabetic retinopathy
(Figure 5).71 Some studies have shown an associa-
tion between severity of diabetic retinopathy and Figure 5 Concurrent proliferative diabetic retinopathy and
systolic, but not diastolic blood pressure, being moderate hypertensive retinopathy.
stronger among the younger patients.72
Various studies have identified hypertension as
an important modifiable risk factor for diabetic the development of retinopathy in type 1 diabetics by
retinopathy to the extent that every 10 mm Hg 18–35%,76 with increase in regression of retinopathy
increase in systolic blood pressure is known to by 34% in type 2 diabetes.77 In the Renin–Angiotensin
increase the risk of early and proliferative retino- System Study,78 treatment with enalapril and losartan
pathy by 10 and 15%, respectively.73 In the United has shown to lessen the risk of retinopathy progres-
Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study,74 participants sion by 65 and 70%, respectively, in type 1 diabetes.
with tighter blood pressure control had 37% reduc- However, the antihypertensive treatment produced no
tion in the risk of microvascular disease, 34% decrease statistically significant changes in retinal blood vessel
in the rate of retinopathy progression by two or more caliber in these younger, normotensive, normoalbu-
levels on the ETDRS scale, and 47% decline in the minuric with type 1 diabetics in a randomized
deterioration of visual acuity by three or more lines controlled trial.79
on ETDRS charts. A recent meta-analysis on the
progression rates of diabetic retinopathy showed
that diabetics who had earlier initiation of medical Other eye conditions associated with
management of glucose, blood pressure and serum hypertension
lipids had lower rates of progression to severe visual
loss.75 However, strategies to improve awareness are Retinal vascular occlusion
needed among the Asians, in which more than Hypertension is associated with retinal vascular
three-quarters of diabetic patients were noted to occlusion, including retinal artery occlusion (RAO)
have poor glycemic and blood pressure control.11 and retinal vein occlusion (RVO).
Among the various antihypertensive treatment RAO is a visually disabling ocular vascular
trials, recent data suggest that drugs targeting the disorder with an estimated incidence of 0.85/
renin–angiotensin system are more efficient in redu- 100 000 population80 noted to occur frequently
cing the risk of diabetic retinopathy. Angiotensin- among hypertensives.81 As a rule, sudden, painless,
converting enzyme inhibitors have shown to prevent dramatic visual impairment occurs. Reduction in
factor for retinal arterial macroaneurysms, noted in pathy is strongly associated with hypertension and
up to 80% of patients.99–101 Hypertension can result other cardiovascular risk factors.102,103 Up to 50% of
in hyaline degeneration of vessel walls, loss of the patients with NAION may have hypertension, in
autoregulatory tone, and arterial dilatation. Hyper- contrast to AION, which is not associated with
tensive patients also have raised hydrostatic pres- hypertension.4 Furthermore, hypertension, diabetes
sures that might predispose to macroaneurysm and hypercholesterolemia appear to be more sig-
formation. nificant risk factors for AION in younger patients.102
The epidemiology of macroaneurysm is not well Few existing data on the incidence of non-arteritic
described in the literature, but data from large case AION have shown an estimated annual incidence of
series suggest that approximately one-fifth of macro- NAION to be 10.3 per 100 000 persons 50 years of
aneurysms are bilateral, and 1 in 10 are multiple.101 age and older.105
Macroaneurysm may be noted incidentally in No known successful management for NAION
asymptomatic patients, but can also present acutely exists. Surgical interventions like optic nerve sheath
with visual loss secondary to hemorrhage or exuda- decompression are proven to be potentially harmful
tion (Figure 9). Visual loss from macroaneurysm without any visual improvement.102,103 Few anecdo-
may be the initial presentation of patients with tal reports suggest that aspirin and intravitreal
uncontrolled hypertension.100 steroids/anti-vascular endothelial growth factor
Visual recovery typically occurs spontaneously agents have been tried without much success.102,103
with thrombosis of the macroaneurysm and resolu-
tion of the hemorrhage and exudates.100 However,
residual retinal damage from chronic macular Conclusion
edema and hard exudates deposition may lead to The diverse development of hypertensive organ
poor visual prognosis. Laser treatment could benefit damage and their correlation with changes in retinal
selected cases where exudation threatens or in- microvasculature preceding other signs of damage
volves the macula, which may lead to branch RAO. should promote more routine use of fundus photo-
graphy in assessing cardiovascular risk in hyperten-
sive individuals. However, there are still some gaps in
Ischemic optic neuropathy our knowledge of hypertensive retinopathy, which
Hypertension may compromise the optic nerve warrant further research. Ultimately, retinal vascular
perfusion in a similar manner to that seen in imaging has the potential to be used as non-invasive,
disturbances of the retinal circulation.102,103 Is- economical and reliable method for assessing the
chemic optic neuropathy is noted in patients over microvascular sequelae of hypertension and can be
50 years of age, most frequently as an acute considered as ‘biomarkers’ for target-organ damage.
phenomenon.104 In 90% of the patients, the anterior
segment of the optic nerve is affected and they
present with sudden visual loss and optic disc Conflict of interest
edema (Figure 10), which is absent in patients with
posterior ischemia. Ischemic optic neuropathy is The authors declare no conflict of interest.
classified as arteritic (AION) and non-arteritic
(NAION) types. Inflammatory diseases are usually
responsible for the arteritic type, with giant cell
References
arteritis being the most common.4 The non-arteritic 1 Wong TY, Mitchell P. Hypertensive retinopathy. N
or atherosclerotic variety of ischemic optic neuro- Engl J Med 2004; 351: 2310–2317.