Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Recycling of Construction Wastes For Manufacturing Sustainable Bricks
Recycling of Construction Wastes For Manufacturing Sustainable Bricks
Recycling of Construction Wastes For Manufacturing Sustainable Bricks
http://dx.doi.org/10.1680/jcoma.16.00046
Recycling of construction wastes for Paper 1600046
Received 27/07/2016 Accepted 16/08/2017
manufacturing sustainable bricks
Keywords: conservation/demolition/environment
Rojas-Valencia and Aquino
The purpose of this study was to manufacture sustainable bricks, based on three types of wastes generated in the
building industry: wood-cutting residues, wastes from the excavation process and recycled aggregates (RA). Water
was added as the kneading material, and Opuntia ficus-indica extract (mucilage) was supplemented as a natural
additive to improve the workability of the mixtures. The conventional firing process was substituted by drying in a
solar drying chamber. Nine mixtures were prepared using 62% excavation wastes, 5% wood-cutting residues and
33% RA. These mixtures were classified into two groups depending on their granulometries: the first one
denominated cementitious RA only having granulometries from 3/8 inch (0·95 cm) and 1/4 inch (0·63 cm) to fines and
the second group denominated all-in-one RA having granulometries from 1/4 inch to fines. The quality of the
sustainable bricks was evaluated according to compressive strength and water absorption parameters. The results
showed that the ecological bricks manufactured with the mixture of cementing RA only of 3/8 and 1/4 inch to fines
meet the standard requirements, providing compressive strength values of up to 8 MPa; moreover, the use of
O. ficus-indica extract as a natural additive notably improved the workability of the mixture.
1. Introduction 3000 t of CWs (Rivera, 2007) was reported for the year 2003,
The environmental problem generated by construction wastes reaching 5000 t/d in 2008 (Hernández et al., 2008) and accord-
(CWs) mainly derives from their growing volume and their ing to estimates provided by the political delegations of the
inappropriate treatment. Moreover, the limited supply of raw Mexico City, the generation of these residues currently reaches
materials reinforces the need to recover and exploit the wastes 7000 t/d (NADF-007-RNAT-2013, 2013), 1000 t/d of which
generated in the construction industry (Yang et al., 2016). are recycled. To make matters worse, there is little confidence
In the last few years, this situation has led to the enactment of in the products derived from CW. Thus, there exists the need to
legislative guidelines that are currently at various stages of analyse them and determine whether they offer the same
implementation. CW recycling started in Germany at the quality as products made from recently extracted aggregates.
beginning of the 1980s. In 2008, the European Parliament
approved a technical report of the waste framework directive, Because of the poor disposal of these CWs and the environ-
in which the member states were requested to take the mental problems they cause, it is necessary to look for efficient
measures necessary to ensure that before the year 2020, 70% solutions for their adequate management in order to reduce
by weight of CW will be reused, recycled or submitted to their impact and promote the recycling and reuse of these
other treatments to replace first-use materials (Barroso, 2013). materials as competent raw materials that can be re-incorpor-
ated in the productive cycle. The growing interest in sustainable
Holland, Denmark and Belgium are among the countries with buildings has led to the promotion of construction processes
the highest percentages of CW recycling, mainly due to a shortage that integrate soil. The objective of engineers should therefore
of raw materials and the difficulty of finding final disposal sites. be to develop new ways of integrating residues into new pro-
ducts through the three ‘R’s of the environment: reduce, reuse
Moreover, some of the factors that have promoted CW and recycle (Muñoz et al., 2014).
recycling in countries with a significant percentage of
recycling such as Finland, the UK and Austria, relate to a The construction industry is currently facing the twin challenges
policy of waste management that has combined economic of a growing interest in the environment and the search for less-
instruments such as taxes, legal instruments such as mandatory contaminating alternative materials (Sodupe-Ortega et al., 2016).
standards and planning and control agreements. This study relates to sustainable alternatives for recycling
CWs, focusing on the manufacture of sustainable bricks using
In Mexico, about 33 600 t of CWs are generated daily recycled aggregates (RA), excavation wastes, basically soil
(Granell, 2014). In the Mexico City, a daily generation of (a material that has been tested for thousands of years and
Downloaded by [ University of Liverpool] on [03/10/17]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Construction Materials Recycling of construction wastes for
manufacturing sustainable bricks
Rojas-Valencia and Aquino
that, combined with additional modern techniques, could offer A mixture of water and O. ficus-indica mucilage in a 3:1 ratio
interesting ecological solutions), and wood-cutting residues as was left to stand for 3 d prior to the manufacture of the
raw materials, in order to mitigate the environmental impact sustainable bricks and then the liquid mixture of mucilage and
through the reduction of the energy and raw materials required water was extracted.
for making hard-burnt sustainable bricks, and Opuntia ficus-
indica extract as a natural additive for its gum-like character- Mucilage consists of carbohydrates, lipids and proteins.
istics that enable it to form a viscous dispersion in contact with Qualitatively, it is a viscous substance extracted from O. ficus-
water. indica, with union-enhancing properties that favour particle
binding.
The idea behind the manufacture of these sustainable bricks is
to promote raw soil as a building material because it is their The material ratios were based on the percentages used in
major constituting element. Moreover, it could contribute to handicraft manufacturing according to the Spanish technical
mitigating some environmental problems such as the overexploi- standard NTE 0.80 for adobes. Preliminary designs to deter-
tation of virgin material quarries, and reduce air pollution mine the approximate behaviour and integration of the
because solar brick drying does not generate emissions, in con- materials were prepared and the basic dosage was established
trast to brick burning in kilns. In Mexico, approximately 17,000 (see Table 1).
artisanal manufacturers that operate informally generate air pollu-
tion problems and emit greenhouse gases (INECC, 2016). Simultaneously, the percentage of the water–mucilage fluidising
mixture was determined for each one of nine manufactured
As opposed to what occurs in developed countries, the back- mixtures. Basically, this percentage varied based on the
ground of building waste reuse and recycling in Mexico is conditions and characteristics of the mixture at the time of
limited, and to date the present authors have found no reports its manufacture. The dry-weight percentages are detailed in
on the manufacture of sustainable bricks as described herein. Table 2.
Downloaded by [ University of Liverpool] on [03/10/17]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Construction Materials Recycling of construction wastes for
manufacturing sustainable bricks
Rojas-Valencia and Aquino
Table 2. Material dosing and percentage of water–mucilage used during manufacturing, per mixture type
Wood-cutting RA 1/4 inch RA 1/4 inch RA 3/8 inch RA 1 inch Water +
Clay: residues: (0·63 cm) (0·63 cm) (0·95 cm): (2·54 cm): O. ficus-indica:
Mixture % kg % kg AO: % kg CMO: % kg % kg % kg % m3
1 62 5 33 — — — 0·0025
2 62 5 — 33 — — 0·0022
3 62 5 — — 33 — 0·0033
4 62 5 — — — 33 0·0020
5 62 5 33 — — — 0·0020
6 62 5 17 — 17 — 0·0020
7 62 5 — 17 17 — 0·0020
8 62 5 11 — 11 11 0·0021
9 62 5 — 11 11 11 0·0021
The sizes of the sustainable bricks may vary depending on the needs of the constructor
Plywood lined with aluminium sheet can be seen at the time of failure in Figure 2. The results
0·6
8m offered by the test equipment corresponded to the maximum
Glass cover
load prior to brick failure.
m
Downloaded by [ University of Liverpool] on [03/10/17]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Construction Materials Recycling of construction wastes for
manufacturing sustainable bricks
Rojas-Valencia and Aquino
Figure 2. Photograph taken at the time of sample failure Figure 3. Saturated reference sustainable brick
Then, the test brick was placed in contact with the water,
immersing a smooth finish face 0·005 m under water for 600 s,
the initiation of the contact time was taken from the instant
the sample touched the water surface. During the contact
period, care was taken to maintain the water level within the
above established limit.
Downloaded by [ University of Liverpool] on [03/10/17]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Construction Materials Recycling of construction wastes for
manufacturing sustainable bricks
Rojas-Valencia and Aquino
Downloaded by [ University of Liverpool] on [03/10/17]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Construction Materials Recycling of construction wastes for
manufacturing sustainable bricks
Rojas-Valencia and Aquino
90
80
Compressive strength: kg/cm2
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Mixture 1 Mixture 2 Mixture 3 Mixture 4 Mixture 5 Mixture 6 Mixture 7 Mixture 8 Mixture 9
3.2 Water absorption tests activities such as sifting the excavation material and leaving
In Table 5, the results obtained from evaluation of the sustainable the O. ficus-indica to stand in order to extract the necessary
bricks manufactured according to the above-described optimum mucilage. However, this production time may be improved
formulation are shown, as well as the comparison of these results based on experience and mass production, equalling the level
with the water absorption values obtained when performing the of handicraft manufacturers who report the production of
same test on commercial bricks, known as red bricks. 200–500 units per worker per day.
Table 6 summarises the test methods used, the limits indicated The potential of the unexploited raw materials generated in
in the standards and the results. the Mexican Republic is high (33 600 t/d), as well as the
need for recycling. The demand for bricks in Mexico, which
amounts to about 279·6 million bricks per year (Ortiz,
3.3 Feasibility 2012), leads to serious environmental problems, such as
The results showed that the sustainable bricks comply the immoderate exploitation and consumption of virgin
with the provisions of Mexican standards: NMX-C-038- materials. The Red de Ladrilleras (2013) (Brickmakers
ONNCCE-2013 (2013) as regards brick sizes, NMX-036- Network) estimates that, nationally, there are 16 953 handi-
ONNCCE-2013 (2013) as regards compressive strength, craft manufacturers that use, in the firing process, different
NMX-037-ONNCCE-2013 (2013) as regards initial water types of fuels including logs, tyres, dry O. ficus-indica, cloth
absorption, NMX-C-441-ONNCCE-2013 (2013) as regards and oil derivatives, and are thus classified as sources of
non-structural use and NMX-C-404-ONNCCE-2012 (2012) as greenhouse gases. In the case of the present study, sustain-
regards the structural use of sustainable bricks. able bricks are dried in a solar dryer that is also built from
CWs with the resulting removal of greenhouse gas emission
On average, two persons can manufacture ten sustainable from the process.
bricks per hour, after having performed the required prior
According to the Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía
Table 5. Initial maximum absorption values
(INEGI, 2010) 10 251 economic units manufacture non-refrac-
Maximum Maximum tory bricks, nationally. The same census indicates that the
limit for limit for block market represents 57·7% of the global quantity, while
Red exterior interior or
the brick market represents 42·3%, and thus there is a huge
Brick Sustainable brick: walls: coated
number brick: g/min g/min g/min walls: g/min potential for sustainable bricks.
Downloaded by [ University of Liverpool] on [03/10/17]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Construction Materials Recycling of construction wastes for
manufacturing sustainable bricks
Rojas-Valencia and Aquino
a
The sizes of the sustainable bricks may vary depending on the needs of the builder
It is also important to highlight the ratio between the dry The moulding process and the arrangement and compaction
mixture and the liquid material used, since it determines of the pieces determine the water absorption capacity of each
material integration, 23–26% being appropriate. brick during manufacturing.
Elimination of emissions because these bricks do not require firing Emission of greenhouse gases because the bricks are fired in ovens
through the burning of fuel
Because they are manufactured with recycled materials, there is a Exploitation of virgin material pits to extract the materials used in
reduction in the exploitation of virgin material pits their manufacturing
Reduction in the cost of acquisition and transportation of materials High cost due to the purchase and transportation of materials
Size and shape may be adapted to specific needs Standardised sizes
Excellent thermal insulator and thus energy demands are reduced The buildings require the use of energy to regulate their environment
Downloaded by [ University of Liverpool] on [03/10/17]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.
Construction Materials Recycling of construction wastes for
manufacturing sustainable bricks
Rojas-Valencia and Aquino
Downloaded by [ University of Liverpool] on [03/10/17]. Copyright © ICE Publishing, all rights reserved.