Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bioresource Technology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/biortech
Short Communication
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This study aimed to enhance hyaluronic acid (HA) production by a two-stage culture strategy based on
Received 2 January 2008 the modeling of batch and fed-batch culture of Streptococcus zooepidemicus. Batch culture had higher spe-
Received in revised form 24 February 2008 cific HA synthesis rate while fed-batch culture had higher specific cell growth rate. The lower specific HA
Accepted 27 February 2008
synthesis rate in fed-batch culture resulted from the competition of cell growth for the common precur-
Available online 7 April 2008
sors at a low substrate concentration. Based on the modeling of batch and fed-batch culture of S. zooep-
idemicus, a two-stage culture strategy was proposed to enhance HA production. S. zooepidemicus were
Keywords:
cultured in a fed-batch mode with sucrose concentration maintained at 1.0 ± 0.2 g/L during 0–8 h and
Modeling
Two-stage culture
then batch culture was performed during 8–20 h with an initial sucrose concentration of 15 g/L. With
Hyaluronic acid the proposed two-stage culture strategy, HA production was increased to 6.6 g/L compared with 5.0 g/
Streptococcus zooepidemicus L in batch culture with the same total sucrose. The enhanced HA production by the proposed two-stage
culture strategy resulted from the decreased inhibition of cell growth and the increased transformation
rate of sucrose to HA.
Ó 2008 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
1. Introduction due to the strong inhibitions caused by the substrates of high con-
centration (Ding and Tan, 2006).
Hyaluronic acid (HA) is a linear glycosaminoglycan polysaccha- With the advantage of reducing the time spent on reactor turn-
ride composed of repeating disaccharide units of alternative D-glu- over, continuous cultivation is attracting more and more attentions
curonic acid (GlcUA) and N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc) (Laurent to produce HA (Fong Chong et al., 2005). However, continuous cul-
et al., 1996). With unique physico-chemical properties, such as bio- ture is not a perfect choice for HA production due to the instability
compatibility, lubricity and hydrophilicity, HA has been widely ap- of the HA-producing phenotype of highly encapsulated strepto-
plied in biomedical, food, healthcare and cosmetic fields (Esposito cocci strains in high dilution rates (Armstrong et al., 1997).
et al., 2005; Lapcik et al., 1998; Morra, 2005; Park et al., 2003; Pey- Fed-batch culture is a batch culture fed continuously or sequen-
ron, 1993). tially with substrate without the removal of fermentation broth.
Conventionally HA was extracted from animal tissues like roos- Fed-batch culture is generally superior to batch and continuous
ter combs, and now is increasingly produced by fermentation of culture, and is especially beneficial when changing nutrient con-
Streptococcus zooepidemicus with the advantages of low production centrations affects the productivity of the desired products (Son
cost. Batch culture is a usual method for HA production, and there et al., 2007). However, as far as we know, there are few system-
are many studies concerning the optimization of culture conditions atic reports on the production of HA by fed-batch culture of S.
in batch culture (Johns et al., 1994; Kim et al., 1996, 2006; Krahulec zooepidemicus. In addition, we have only found two reports about
and Krahulcová, 2006). However, a major disadvantage of batch the modeling of HA fermentation process in the literature. Cooney
culture is that the production of aimed metabolites is limited et al. (1999) developed a structured, two-compartment model for
HA fermentation in anaerobic and aerated conditions. Huang
et al. (2007) developed an unstructured model for cell growth
* Corresponding authors. Address: School of Biotechnology, Jiangnan University, and HA production in batch culture. The model developed by Coo-
Wuxi 214122, China. Tel./fax: +86 510 85918309 (G. Du); tel.: +86 510 85913661;
ney et al. (1999) is obviously a complicated one and not suitable for
fax: +86 510 85910799 (J. Chen).
E-mail addresses: gcdu@jiangnan.edu.cn (G. Du), jchen@jiangnan.edu.cn process control. The model developed by Huang et al. (2007)
(J. Chen). mainly dealt with the relationship between cell growth and HA
Nomenclature
synthesis, while the inhibition of substrate and lactic acid on cell 22.5 mL/h by a peristaltic pump coupled with a computer. The
growth and HA synthesis was not considered. Therefore, a simple feeding rate of 22.5 mL/h was selected to make the total sucrose
and comprehensive modeling of HA fermentation process is neces- in batch and fed-batch culture to be equal. The initial and final
sary for the process control and optimization. broth volumes for fed-batch culture were 3.2 and 4.0 L,
The present study aimed to enhance HA production by a two- respectively.
stage cultivation strategy based on the modeling of batch and In the two-stage culture strategy, by the feedback control of re-
fed-batch culture of S. zooepidemicus. Firstly, the modeling of batch dox potential, the sucrose concentration was maintained at Sopt un-
culture of S. zooepidemicus was carried out. Then the influence of til the cell concentration reached the maximum cell concentration
fed-batch culture on HA production was studied and modeled. Fi- of batch culture. Then the batch culture of S. zooepidemicus in the
nally, a two-stage culture strategy was proposed to enhance HA second stage was started with an initial sucrose concentration of
production based on the modeling of batch and fed-batch culture 15 g/L.
of S. zooepidemicus.
lmax S dV
l¼ ð1Þ ¼F ð8Þ
K S þ S þ S2 =K I dt
dX F
where l is the specific growth rate (h1), lmax is the maximum spe- ¼ lX X ð9Þ
dt V
cific growth rate (h1), S is the substrate concentration (g/L), KS is dP HA F
the substrate saturation constant (g/L) and KI is the substrate inhi- ¼ cHA X P HA ð10Þ
dt V
bition constant (g/L).
dP LA F
The product inhibited microbial growth can be described by ¼ cLA X P LA ð11Þ
dt V
S 1 dS F
l ¼ lmax ð2Þ ¼ kX þ ðPHA þ P LA Þ ð12Þ
K S þ S P=K IP dt V
where P is the product concentration (g/L) and KIP is the product where V is the broth volume (L), F is the feeding rate (mL/h), cHA is
inhibition constant (g/L). the specific HA synthesis rate (g HA/g cell/h), cLA is the specific lactic
In batch cultivation of S. zooepidemicus, cell growth is inhibited acid synthesis rate (lactic acid/g cell/h) and k is the specific sucrose
by both the substrate sucrose and the product lactic acid. There- consumption rate (g sucrose/g cell/h).
fore, the following model was proposed to describe the growth of
S. zooepidemicus in batch culture: 4. Results and discussion
lmax S 1
l¼ ð3Þ HA production by batch culture of S. zooepidemicus with an ini-
K S þ S þ S2 =K I 1 þ PLA =K ILA
tial sucrose concentration of 70 g/L was carried out. After 2 h of lag
where S is the sucrose concentration (g/L), KI is the sucrose inhibi- phase, cells entered the exponential growth phase until the end of
tion constant (g/L), PLA is the concentration of lactic acid (g/L) and 10 h and reached the maximum concentration of 13.2 g/L at 14 h.
KILA is the inhibition constant of lactic acid on cell growth (g/L). Sucrose was consumed for cell growth and metabolites synthesis,
and decreased to 8 g/L from an initial concentration of 70 g/L at
3.1.2. Product synthesis the end of fermentation. HA concentration reached the maximal
The main products in batch cultivation of S. zooepidemicus with value of 5 g/L at 16 h, and lactic acid was accumulated to 53 g/L
sucrose as carbon source are lactic acid and HA, and the synthesis at the end of batch culture. The maximum of specific cell growth
of HA and lactic acid are coupled with the cell growth. Further- rate was 1.21 h1. The average value of specific HA synthesis rate
more, lactic acid was inhibitive on the synthesis of itself and HA. was 0.024 (g HA/g cell/h) and that for lactic acid was 0.201 (g lactic
Therefore, the synthesis of HA and lactic acid can be described by acid/g cell/h). The yield of HA and lactic acid on sucrose were 0.08
Eqs. (4) and (5), respectively. (g HA/g sucrose) and 0.85 (g lactic acid/sucrose), respectively.
In the present study, a series of unstructured models of batch
dPHA aHA dX
¼ ð4Þ and fed-batch culture of S. zooepidemicus were developed based
dt 1 þ PLA =K HA dt
on the characteristics of HA fermentation. In these models, the
dPLA aLA dX inhibitions of sucrose and lactic acid on cell growth and products
¼ ð5Þ
dt 1 þ PLA =K LA dt (HA and lactic acid) synthesis were considered. With the obtained
model parameters (Table 1), the effectiveness of the developed
where PHA is the concentration of HA (g/L), PLA is the concentration unstructured models was verified and the developed models could
of lactic acid (g/L), aHA is the coupling constant of HA synthesis with describe the batch cultivation of S. zooepidemicus well (the average
cell growth, aLA is the coupling constant of lactic acid with cell value of R2 was 0.995).
growth, KHA is the inhibition constant of lactic acid on HA synthesis As indicated by the obtained inhibition constants of sucrose and
(g/L), KLA is the inhibition constant of lactic acid on the synthesis of lactic acid on cell growth, lactic acid had stronger inhibition on cell
itself (g/L) and t is the culture time (h). growth than sucrose. Meanwhile, it could be found that lactic acid
had stronger inhibition on cell growth than on HA synthesis. How-
3.1.3. Sucrose consumption ever, at the initial phase of batch culture, the inhibition of sucrose
Substrate consumption kinetics can be described by the follow- with high concentration on cell growth was predominant while the
ing model, which considered substrate conversion to cell mass and inhibition of cell growth by lactic acid of low concentration was al-
product as well as substrate consumption for maintenance: most negligible. Therefore, the cell growth at the initial phase of
batch culture could be described by Eq. (1). For this kind of sub-
dS 1 dX 1 dP HA 1 dP LA
¼ þ þ þ me X ð6Þ strate inhibited cell growth, as indicated by Eq. (7), there is an opti-
dt Y X dt Y HA dt Y LA dt
mal substrate concentration Sopt, at which the growth rate of the
where YX is the yield of cell on sucrose (g cell/g sucrose), YHA is the cells reached the maximum. For the batch culture of S. zooepidem-
yield of HA on sucrose (g HA/g sucrose), YLA is the yield of lactic acid icus with sucrose as carbon source, the value of Sopt is 1.0 g/L.
on sucrose (g lactic acid/g sucrose), me is the maintenance constant The influence of fed-batch culture with constant feeding rate
(h1) and X is the cell concentration (g/L). (22.5 mL/h) on HA production was studied (Fig. 1). The developed
The model parameters were obtained by Runge–Kutta algo- unstructured models could describe the fed-batch culture well (the
rithm with MATLAB 6.5.1 software. average R2 value was 0.993). The highest cell concentration in con-
For substrate inhibited growth described by Eq. (1), the specific stant feeding rate fed-batch culture was 16.3 g/L, which was higher
cell growth rate reaches the maximum value at S = Sopt: 23% than that in batch culture. Unexpectedly, HA production in
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi fed-batch was only 4.0 g/L compared with 5.0 g/L in batch culture.
Sopt ¼ K S K I ð7Þ
The concentration of lactic acid was increased to 60 g/L compared
with 53 g/L in batch culture. The average specific HA synthesis rate
3.2. Model development for fed-batch cultivation of S. zooepidemicus in fed-batch culture was 0.014 (g HA/g cell/h) compared with 0.024
(g HA/g cell/h) in batch culture, while that for lactic acid in fed-
According to the substrate balance, the following models were batch culture was 0.208 (g lactic acid/g cell/h) compared with
proposed to describe the fed-batch cultivation of S. zooepidemicus: 0.201 (g lactic acid/g cell/h) in batch culture. The specific HA
L. Liu et al. / Bioresource Technology 99 (2008) 8532–8536 8535
Table 1
Model parameters
a 80 18 b 60 18
Cell and HA concentration (g/L)
15 50 15
Lactic acid concentration (g/L)
60
Feeding rate (mL/h)
12 40 12
40 9 30 9
6 20 6
20
3 10 3
0 0 0 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Culture time (h) Culrture time (h)
Fig. 2. Time courses of two-stage fed-batch and batch culture of S. zooepidemicus for HA production. Fed-batch culture was carried out in the first stage (0–8 h) and then the
sucrose concentration of culture broth was increased to 15 g/L to start the batch culture in the second stage (8–20 h). In the fed-batch culture process with the redox potential
level as the feedback control variable, the sucrose concentration of culture broth was maintained at 1.2 g/L by feeding concentrated sucrose solution (600 g/L). Fig. 2(a) s:
cell; : lactic acid; N: HA; Fig. 2(b) s: feeding rate; : sucrose.
8536 L. Liu et al. / Bioresource Technology 99 (2008) 8532–8536