Professional Documents
Culture Documents
All Project Adeo
All Project Adeo
This is to certify that this project was carried out by ADEKIYA, ADEOLA FADEKEMI
of the Faculty of Education, the Department of Arts and Language English
Education, Ekiti State University, Ado-Ekiti, Nigeria.
…………………………………………. ……………………………
Supervisor
1
DEDICATION
This project work is dedicated to God Almighty, the only wise God, the owner of
wisdom and knowledge and life for he has given me the inspiration and strength to
complete this work successfully.
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
From the bottom of my heart I appreciate God Almighty, the Alpha Omega, my
present help and my all in all who has made it possible for me to record success in
this project work in His infinite mercy and has kept me alive till this day.
My sincere appreciation goes to my ever loving and caring parents, Mr. and Mrs.
Adekiya for their support in all ramifications since my birth to this present
moment. I appreciate my siblings, you guys are wonderful and to my extended
family I say a big thank you.
I will like show my appreciation to my able dynamic supervisor Dr. Mrs. Ofodu
for her support, guidance, and effort which culminated into the success of this
project. May God bless you and your family. (Amen)
Finally, I will also like to show appreciate to my friends and colleagues, Alokan
Adebola, Olaiya Oyindamola, Adebayo Oluwaseun and others for their love and
care. God bless you all.
3
ABSTRACT
This study identifies Effect of Bibliotherapeutic on Senior Secondary School
Students Learning outcomes in Literature-in-English in Ado Ekiti Local
Government Area, Ekiti State. The purpose of the study is to determine the effect
of Bibliotheraphy on secondary school students.
Relevant literatures were reviewed and appropriate theories. To achieve the study
objectives, survey research method was used. Questionnaire served as the research
instrument. 100 respondents were chosen, 100 respondents were given
questionnaires. The research carried out shows that Bibliotheraphy has a positive
effect on students learning.
The study also confirmed that Literature can be used to solve societal problems
such as Cultism, Prostitution, cultism and rape. These are the major problem in the
society which literature could help solve.
The findings confirmed that literature books have helped students to achieve their
goals, and also helped to improve sensitivity and also their spoken English.
The findings also revealed that Bibliotheraphy had helped students to be more
creative and active in all areas, it was revealed that students who failed to spend
time reading books are less creative and active in school. Also, students were able
to think and make good decisions on their own.
Based on the findings, it was recommended that Government and all other
institution responsible for managing Education of younger generations should
come together and find a lasting solution to the education sector, conduct research,
and prescribe practicable educational policies that will move the nation's education
forward. Also, Parents should encourage their children by providing literature
books and other appropriate books for them.
4
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE PAGE i
CERTIFICATION ii
DEDICATION iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT iv
ABSTRACT vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS vii
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION
Background of the study 1
Statement of the Problem 10
Objectives of the Study 11
Research Question 11
Research Hypothesis 12
Societal Problems 16
Bibliotherapy 30
Advantages of Bibliotherapy 34
Disadvantages of Bibliotherapy 35
Bibliotherapy in a School Settings 36
5
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH METHOD
Research Design 40
Population 40
Data Analysis 42
CHAPTER FOUR: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Results 43
Discussion 48
Summary 49
Conclusion 50
Recommendations 51
References 53
Appendix I: Questionnaire 56
6
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Background to the Study
Childs, T & Moore, J. (2014) defines literature as any collection of written
work, but it is also used more narrowly for writings specifically considered to be
an art form, especially prose fiction, drama, and poetry. In recent centuries, the
definition has expanded to include oral literature, much of which has been
transcribed. They posits that, literature is a method of recording, preserving, and
transmitting knowledge and entertainment, and can also be have a social,
psychological, spiritual or political role.
Literature as an art form, can also include works in various non-fiction genres,
such as biography, diaries, memoir, letters and the essay. Within its broad
definition, literature includes non-fictional books, articles or other printed
information on a particular subject. Cornett, C. (2003).
Green, B. (2002). In one of his works, A literacy project of our own ,says
etymologically, the term derives from Latin Literatura/litteratura “learning, a
writing Grammar”. In Western Europe, prior to the 18 th century, literature denoted
all books and writing. Then, during the Romantic period, a more restricted sense of
the term emerged that emphasized the idea that” Literature” was ‘imaginative
writing’.
7
The 19th century critic Walter pater referred to “the matter of imaginative or artistic
literature” as a transcript not of mere fact but of fact in its infinitely varied forms.”
But such definitions assume that the reader already knows what literature is.
Literature is first and foremost humankinds entire body of writing belonging to a
given language or people, then it is individual pieces of writing. As an art,
literature might be described as the organization of words to give pleasure. Yet
through words, literature elevates and transforms experience beyond mere
pleasure. Literature also functions more broadly in society as a means of both
criticizing and affirming cultural values. Literature, can be categorized under three
types namely Poetry, Prose and Drama. They are also referred to as genres of
Literature.
Poetry perhaps pre-dates other forms of literature, early known examples include
the Sumerian Epic of Gilgamesh (dated from around 2700 B.C) parts of the Bible,
the surviving works of Homer and the Indian epics Ramayana and Mahabharata. In
cultures based primarily on oral traditions the former characteristics of poetry.
Language and tradition dictate some poetic norms: Persian poetry always rhymes,
Greek poetry rarely rhymes, Italian or French poetry often does, English and
German poetry can go either way. In recent years, digital poetry has risen and takes
advantage of the artistic, publishing and synthetic qualities of digital media.
8
Prose consists of writing that does not adhere to any particular formal structures
other than simple grammar, non-poetic writing. The term sometimes appears
pejoratively, but prosaic writing simply says something without necessarily trying
to say it in a beautiful way or using beautiful words. Prose writing can of course
take beautiful form, but less by virtue of the formal features of
words(rhymes,alliteration,metre) but rather by style, placement or inclusion of
graphics. Prose is divided into fiction and non-fiction. A fiction is a literary type
using invented or imaginative writing, instead of real facts. Non-fiction is a written
work intended to give facts or true accounts of real things and events.
A drama or play offers another classical literary form that has continued to evolve
over the years. It generally comprises chiefly dialogue between characters and
usually aims at dramatic rather than reading.
Greek drama exemplifies the earliest form of drama of which we have substantial
knowledge. Tragedy, as a dramatic genre developed as a performance associated
with religious and civic festivals, Tragedy generally presents very serious themes,
Tragedy is usually tense, with unhappy ending. Comedy is a dramatic work that is
light and humorous in tone.
However, Literature plays a vital roles in our society. The benefits of Literature
includes:
1. It help the readers to acquire speed and skills they will need for practical
purpose when they leave school. Mcgregor (2000:132) further notes that reading
goes beyond conversion of print of sound with some level of comprehension to
skills of book selection, the use of reading, critical reading, comparing texts,
location references and so on.
9
2. General knowledge comes through reading and, the more understanding a
student has the ' more books he can read. The knowledge further helps to sharpen
the reader's insight, widen her experience and provides occasions for exercise of
judgement about man which makes such a reader capable of the appropriate
response to life.
11
discussing those problems (self-management and relationship management),
gaining new norms and values (self-awareness and social awareness), gain
conscience that others can experience the same problems as you (social awareness)
and gain the ability to think of different solutions for those problems (responsible
decision making) (McCullis & Chamberlain, 2013).
12
components: hedonic reading attitude and utilitarian reading attitude (Stokmans,
2006).
Rozalski, Stewart and Miller (2010) also found that bibliotherapy can have a
positive influence on behaviour towards others, for example to fellow students.
The role of the trainer is important in order to achieve this change in behaviour
among students following the bibliotherapy. The trainer has to be open and
involved in the group process and make it possible for each student to speak freely.
By creating a safe and trustworthy environment, the relationship between the
trainer and the students will grow stronger and will increase school engagement
(Durlak et al., 2011; Polleck, 2010).
13
proposed treatment. Opportunity to read about emotional and behavioral disorder
outside the therapist’s office facilitates active participation in the rehabilitation
process and promotes learning. Books used as therapies have been instruments of
change, development and effective decision-making since time immemorial. No
wonder then books have continued to be relevant from one generation to another.
According to Ajayi (2016), the use of books in the treatment of mentally sick
people dated back to 300 BC when Aristotle delineated the influence that book had
on the psyche, especially the purifying or purgative effect on tragedy.
The librarian must have rapport with the patient and have a large selection of
books and other reading materials (Brown, 2017). The science of bibliotherapy was
what started the trend toward using books with patients. According to Pardeck
(2003), the informational purposes of bibliotherapy can be helpful for patients who
are experiencing clinical problems that are unfamiliar to them. This literature may
help them change things in their lives.
The art of bibliotherapy is when a professional uses a book to help their client or
patient solve a problem. This requires a person knowledgeable about books, a large
collection of books and good rapport between the counselor and client (Brown,
2013). This is the type of bibliotherapy that most professionals are familiar with
using. Rubin (2010) placed this in the clinical category of bibliotherapy. A third
area that bibliotherapy has moved into, is using books for preventative aspects.
15
This is the developmental category from Rubin (2010). Anticipating
developmental milestones or problems and using a book to make that transition go
smoothly is the hallmark for preventative bibliotherapy (Cornett and Cornett,
2005). This type of bibliotherapy is very useful in the schools.
For the purpose of this Research, bibliotherapy will be described in two senses,
why it should be used, how it has been used in assisting students in schools and to
know whether it is applied in teaching by teachers of some selected secondary
schools in Ado Ekiti. The definition of bibliotherapy for this research combines
two current definitions, for problem-solving and developmental purposes. As noted
earlier, Webster's third dictionary said it was the "guidance in the solution of
personal problems through directed reading," (Babock& Pardeck 2010, p.212) add
that it is the use of literature to help students with developmental changes, growth
and adjustment. This definition focuses on both using it to solve problems and for
developmental purposes.
16
This study therefore is an attempt to investigate this possibility. That is, using
Literature teaching and learning to enhance sustainable students' motivation for
academic achievement and to solve societal problems. The investigation will
involve finding out how much reading of books can impact and communicate
specific messages to readers and library users, especially those who lack
motivation for academics.
ii. to determine whether reading books can actually influence and increase students
motivation for achievement.
Research Question
17
3. Do students who use/read library resources/books acquire their own personal
reading collection?
Research Hypothesis
The study will provide an additional approach for enhancing reading habits and
techniques in students who lack it. Furthermore, the findings will provide deeper
insight and revelations into the problems of academic underachievement resulting
from low reading habits amongst secondary school students in Ado Ekiti.
Furthermore, the findings and knowledge generated from this study will be an
addition to the existing body of knowledge.
Ordinarily, this research should covered all the secondary schools in Nigeria.
However, for logistic reasons, it will be limited to some selected private and public
senior Secondary Schools in Ado Ekiti local Government
Definition of Terms
18
1. Bibliotherapy: The process of reading for the purpose of identifying with
characters and observing how the characters face challenges in order to further
one’s emotional good health (Gavigan, 2012; Heath, Sheen, Leavy, Young, &
Money, 2005; Jack & Ronan, 2008; Pardeck, 1994b)
CHAPTER TWO
19
Societal Problems
Bibliotherapy
Advantages of Bibliotherapy
Disadvantages of Bibliotherapy
Bibliotherapy in a School Settings
20
It provides ample opportunities for learners to develop their creativity, sharpen
their critical and analytical skills, and enhance their language proficiency.
The intellectual, aesthetic and emotional qualities, which learners develop through
studying Literature in English, prepare them for further study or work, particularly
in areas such as publishing and the media, where creativity, critical thinking and
intercultural understanding are highly valued.
Curriculum Aims
The aims of the Literature in English curriculum are to enable learners to:
appreciate and enjoy a wide range of literary or creative texts and other
related cultural forms;
develop their capacity for critical thinking, creativity, self-expression,
personal growth, empathy and cultural understanding;
enhance their awareness of the relationship between literature and society;
develop a greater sensitivity to the nuances of the English language;
be adequately prepared for areas of further study or work, where qualities
promoted in the study of literature, such as creativity, critical thinking and
inter-cultural understanding, are highly valued.
21
The senior secondary Literature in English curriculum aims to capitalise on
students’ learning of English at the junior secondary level to further enhance
their language proficiency and develop their critical abilities, aesthetic sensitivity
and cultural awareness. To enable learners to effectively meet the challenges of the
senior secondary Literature in English curriculum, a solid foundation of knowledge
and skills in English Language has to be laid at the junior secondary level. Schools
are encouraged to:
Enhance the learning of English in the Experience Strand through the use of
language arts materials to help learners to develop a range of knowledge, skills and
qualities critical for the study of Literature in English, including:
By broadening and enriching learners’ knowledge, skills and experience, the senior
secondary Literature in English curriculum also provides a firm foundation for
further study, vocational training or work. It opens up a variety of post-secondary
education and career pathways, particularly in the areas of media production,
performing arts, teaching, law and social sciences.
SOCIETAL PROBLEM
22
Standard "textbook" definitions of social problems are generally grouped into three
categories, with the second two categories most often used by sociologists
themselves. As we will consider in the following, however, there are many more
underlying assumptions about the nature of society and humans that shape what
sociologists as well as the general public come to define as social problems.
The public generally sees a social problem as any condition that is harmful to
society; but the matter is not so simple, for the meanings of such everyday terms as
harm and society are far from clear. Social conditions that some people see as a
problem harm some segments of society but are beneficial to others.
A social problem is an issue within the society that makes it difficult for people to
achieve their full potential. Poverty, unemployment, unequal opportunity, racism,
and malnutrition are examples of social problems. So are substandard housing,
employment discrimination, and child abuse and neglect. Crime and substance
abuse are also examples of social problems. Not only do social problems affect
many people directly, but they also affect all of us indirectly. The drug-abusing
driver becomes the potential traffic accident that doesn’t choose its victims by race,
color, or creed but does so randomly. The child of abusive parents all too often
becomes the victim or perpetrator of family violence as an adult.(
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story?storyId=4946028)
Social problems tend to develop when we become neglectful and fail to see that
serious problems are developing. Between 1988 and 1993, for example, the United
States saw a phenomenal increase in youth violence. In a book about children who
commit violent acts (Glicken, 2004b), he says that children younger than age 12
cause one third of all fires resulting in death and that the average age of children
who sexually abuse other children is younger than age 10. According to Osofsky
and Osofsky (2009), “The homicide rate among males 15–24 years old in the
23
United States is 10 times higher than in Canada, 15 times higher than in Australia,
and 28 times higher than in France or Germany” (p. 287). These are troubling
examples of social problems that affect all of us.
Could these problems have been prevented if our social institutions had been
working well? I think so, but this is where political philosophies are important to
understand. Some people believe that government should be very involved in
providing services to people most at risk. I don’t know if the labels liberal and
conservative have much meaning anymore, but in times past, we might have called
these folks liberals. Liberals believe that where our usual institutions fail, the
government and the private sector should help out. Conservatives believe that
intruding in people’s lives often leads to a weakening of social institutions and the
values that have served us well in the past.
However, there are several kinds of societal problem, but just a few would be
discussed below:
Drug Abuse
24
(Oshikoya and Alli, 2006;Oshodi, Aina, Onajole, 2010) in their studies on
perception of Drug Abuse amongst Nigerian undergraduates identified
dependence and addiction as one of the major consequence of drug abuse,
characterized by compulsive drug craving seeking behaviours are use that
persist even in the face of negative consequences. These changes are
maladaptive and inappropriate to the social or environmental setting, therefore
may place the individual at risk of harm. Drug use among youth’s and
adolescents should be a matter of concern to all Nigerians especially the
society, government, school heads, religious leaders, groups and other NGOs.
1. Peer group Influence: Peer group pressure plays a major role in influencing
many youth’s into drug usage. This is because peer pressure is a fact of
25
teenage and youth’s life. In Nigeria, and other parts of the world, one may
not enjoy the company of others unless he conforms to their norms.
2. Environment: Many young people live in communities which suffer from
multiple deprivations, with high unemployment, low quality housing and
where the surrounding infra-structure of local services is splintered and
poorly resourced. In such communities drug supply and use often thrive as
an alternative economy often controlled by powerful criminal groups.
3. Lack of Parental Supervision.
4. Self- medication of primary psychological disorders.
5. Pathological family background
6. Broken homes, illegitimate relationships, alcoholic parents or parent’s
7. Involvement in antisocial and illegal activities.
8. Ignorance of the dangers of illegal drug use.
CULTISM
26
9. The desire to belong or not to look odd
10 .Poor law enforcement
CAUSES OF CULTISM
What makes people join organizations that endanger their own lives and people
around? Consider several significant factors.
For a strange reason, some students do not want to assert themselves by winning in
the mathematics or sports competitions - they just show strength through violence.
Youthful maximalism forces them to assert authority in rather dangerous ways.
Participation in the cult gives a false sense of superiority.
3. Popularity and recognition. Many want to create the image of a big boy or girl
who has high status in student communities. O
4. Often young people enter sects following their peers. Friends' beliefs have a
strong influence on students' worldview. That's why it's important to choose the
right friends that will not make a person turn off the right path. Read more:
https://www.legit.ng/1151827-causes-consequence-cultism-nigeria.html
27
5. Lonely people seek to establish fraternal relations because they lack spiritual
affinity with like-minded individuals. No matter how unhealthy the atmosphere in
the company is, it seems better than loneliness. The words about mutual love and
protection sound pretty beautiful until this all turns into violence Read
more: https://www.legit.ng/1151827-causes-consequence-cultism-nigeria.html.
Consequences of cultism
1. Whatever eloquent are the slogans propagated by the cults’ leaders, in the
majority of cases the result of their activities is negative:
2. Innocent people die during the violent clashes.
3. The philosophy of most cults refutes traditional human values and imposes
negative patterns of thinking.
4. The crime rate noticeably increases as the cultists are ready to use any means
to achieve their goals, even if they are contrary to the law. The activities of
the cults are a huge danger for all members of society.
5. Youth becomes more violent. In their eyes, human life has no value. The
culture of peaceful resolution of conflicts is lost. Instead brute force is used.
6. Society acquires a negative image. The country loses its favorable
appearance and is likened to a medieval community.
RAPE
28
Rape is defined as any form of sexual intercourse without free mutual
consent between those involved. Ezere et al (2009). It is a sexual intercourse
that involves force, threat, blackmail, deceit or coercion. Hornby (2006)
define rape as a crime of forcing somebody to have sex with one especially
using violence. Under Nigerian law, rape is defined as forcible unlawful
sexual intercourse, without a woman’s consent (Imoukhuede 2007). It is the
crime of forcefully having sex with someone against the person’s wish
(Chiedu, 2012). In a simple language rape may be define as a sexual
intercourse between a man and a woman or a girl against the will or consent
of the female partner.
Type of Rape
Theft Rape: this happen when a woman is abducted, in most cases to be used as a
slave or a prostitute.
Ceremonial/Traditional Rape: this occurs during ritual, this give men a greater
power to select activities or isolated locations that are conducive to rape such as
“parking” or “making out” in a car (Muehlenhard and Linton, 1987).
29
Rape by Deception: is another type of rape that occurs when the perpetrators gain
the victims consent through fraud. A man pretended to be an official for a
government who had power to cause negative impacts on a woman to pressure her
into sexual activities (Di Silvio, 2011). This includes the rape of children in
institutional care such as orphanages.
War Rape: is a forced sexual relationship that occurs during wars by soldiers on
female victims. Rapes in war are often systematic and thorough, and military
leaders may actually encourage their soldiers to rape civilians. (Wikipedia).
Anger Rape: this rape is where the main aim of the rapist is to hurt, humiliate and
debase their victims through physical violence and profane language using sex as a
weapon to defile and degrade their victim by grabbing, striking, knocking, beating,
tearing clothes and raping them.
Despite decades of feminist activism, men continue to rape girls and women at
appalling rates. Rape is one of the more pervasive forms of violation against
women in which the assailant uses sex to inflict humiliation on the victim or exert
power and control over the victim. There is no doubt that rape is prevalent across
all sectors of Nigerian society.
30
Testimony of girls and women who have been raped and reports by Nigerian
human rights organisations identify the Nigerian police force and other members of
the security forces particularly the military as the principal actors. Amnesty
International (2007), Rape at times was used strategically by police and security
forces to coerce and intimidate entire communities. Amnesty International has met
some women and girls who have been raped, some of whom have been abducted
by the security forces in areas of the country where violence is rife and have
documented their harrowing experiences.
PROSTITUTION
31
Furthermore, young adolescent girls experience a higher risk of infection and long‐
term damage because their immature reproductive tracts are more sensitive
(Chatterjee, Chakraborty, Srivastava, & Deb, 2006).
Also the presence of commercial sex workers, pimps and patrons in an area tends
to attract crime, illegal substance use, and violent activities, all of which negatively
impact businesses and create an unsafe and unhealthy environment for children and
families (Nokomis Foundation, 2002). Despite these risks, most of commercial sex
workers still continue to indulge in the trade. This situation calls for worry among
social workers including adult and non-formal educators. The focus of this paper
therefore, is to examine reasons why prostitutes engage in sex work with a view to
understanding how non-formal education can be used to address the menace.
In African society prostitution is dated back to stone-age where female slaves were
used by their masters as sex toys. Prostitutes apart from female slaves were seen as
social outcast and hardly women with nobility were involved (Yusuf, 2013).
Naanen (1991) traced the rise of commercial sex activities during the first half of
19th century in West African countries particularly in Nigeria to the colonialism
and the sexual habits of the colonialists. There was, in fact, only a very small
colonial population in Nigeria.
Reasons why youths get involved in prostitution are numerous. Researches and
observations have shown reasons why youths especially women selling their
bodies for money or for other gratifications. Some of these reasons are discussed
under the following sub-headings.
Poverty is described as inability to meet the basic necessity of life such as food;
clothes; education; health; etc. Stephen (2012) submitted that the women’s
32
involvement in prostitution though can be linked to poverty is not limited to it.
Also most of the money generated from prostitution is expended on the sustenance
of family, education, etc. Most women and children are not freely choosing to
work in prostitution, “it is a choice based purely on economics of food and
shelter”.
Sexual Abuse Prostitution is frequently alluded to as one of the possible long term
effects of the sexual abuse of children (Bagley & King, 1990). Sexual abuse is to
regard it as inappropriate sexual involvement between a minor (under 18) and a
sexually maturer person (at least 5 years older) (Louw, 2015)
Illiteracy
With the high rate of illiteracy in Nigeria, many parents can neither read nor write.
The youths are not left out in this illiteracy problem. This has resulted in their
being deceived into believing that in big cities, milk and honey flows, only to be
forced into sex work when they get to the city (Ewah, 2010). Illiteracy is a disease
and a person is illiterate can easily been deceived into anything including
prostitution. Meanwhile lack of literacy skills can put anyone into disadvantage of
no job.
Peer group pressure has also been identified as one of the reasons why people
engage in prostitution. Maria (2007) is of the view that, many young women and
girls fall prey to pressure from their peers, who they perceive as having made it.
The young girls and women want to make it too and be able to flaunt their
influence like those people not knowing or caring how they made it.
BULLYING
33
Bullying and harassment are not new issues that students and schools face. In
fact, over the years, it has been viewed as being so commonplace in schools that it
has been overlooked as a threat to students and reduced to a belief that bullying is a
developmental stage that most youth will experience then get over (Ross, 2015, p.
107). But not everyone gets over the personal trauma that can come with bullying
both for the victim and the bully. This is why it is seen happening by adults in
work places, in homes, and in the community. Therefore, this harassment is not
isolated to schools alone. But schools are the best place to actively intervene.
Teachers, administrators, counsellors, and even students have the greatest access to
the most students through a school system. It is here that school staff can
intervene, support and educate students about ending bullying behaviours directly
and indirectly; breaking the bullying-cycle.
In defining what bullying is, many researchers have quoted Olweus’ work, which
defines bullying as occurring when a student is exposed to negative actions
repeatedly and over time by one or more students (Ross, 2015, p.106). While this
definition is widely accepted around the world, it leaves some researchers wanting
more clarification. If the same person repeats similar negative actions, one time, to
multiple people; is it bullying? If one person receives a negative action, one time,
from someone who has done this to other students; have they been bullied?
The problem with this definition is that this can become a very blurred line of
intent versus perception and the power differential that was experienced by both
parties in this one-time event.
For schools that are implementing zero tolerance policies for bullying, when do the
teachers and administrators act on these behaviours? As Ross points out (2015, p,
106), “the problem with the repeated occurrence requirement is that the waiting
period heightens the negative effects on the victim, allows the bully to feel
34
rewarded, increases fear in onlookers, and makes intervention a more lengthy
process”. Therefore, more diligence in acknowledging negative behaviours and
language in the hallways and classrooms is needed by staff and students. Perhaps
by pointing out a one-time behavior, it will prevent it from becoming a bullying
behavior.
Unfortunately, witnessing the negative actions is not always obvious for staff or
other students because bullying can be physical, relational or psychological. There
can be direct behaviors such as “teasing and taunting, racial, ethnic, and sexual
slurs or harassment, threatening, hitting, and stealing” (Harris, Petrie &
Willoughby, 2002, p.4), is what most people think of when bullying is mentioned
and can be acted on immediately. But indirect behaviours such as spreading
rumours, socially excluding students, and dirty looks in passing are much harder to
catch or prove. Research shows that middle school has the highest rates of
bullying than any other school level. At this level, bullying is both direct and
indirect and the percentages of incidents that occur are approximately the same for
both males and females, however males were slightly higher for both bullying and
being bullied. Harris & Hathorn (2006, p. 55) quote a study indicating that “86%
of junior high students indicated that they had been bullied”.
35
(Harris & Hathorn, 2006, p. 51). Verbal bullying is the most common form.
Combine verbal bullying (action) with racial bullying / minority bullying (reason)
and it is the majority of bullying taking place in secondary schools.
However, all these problems are what we face in the society today especially in
schools all because we neglect some therapy which could solve these problems.
Literature has had a major impact on the development of society. It has shaped
civilisations, changed political systems and exposed injustice. Literature gives us a
detailed preview of human experiences allowing us to connect on basic levels of
desire and emotion. But what is today’s youth reading? Are they reading at all?
“The foundation of every state is the education of its Youth” said Kevin Nawn,
assistant Professor of English at the American University in Dubai. “The Youth
should be educated in the great ideas of not only its own culture and time, but other
cultures and time as well” However, the disregard for Literature is a main
component of ignorance and constituents like stereotypes, judgments and
preconceived notions about different people and cultures.
If students are well taught and well knowledgeable, they wont be involved in all
these menace, some Teachers teach but didn’t make use of some strategies that can
help the students. However, this research suggests Bibliotherapy as a remedy to the
societal problems listed above.
Bibliotherapy
36
the dilemmas of a third person, followed by individual or group discussion in a
non-threatening environment. Sometimes referred to as, biblioguidance,
bibliocounseling, literatherapy, bookmatching or reading therapy, bibliotherapy
involves the use of books and other media to facilitate both normal development
and clinically significant problems (Rubin, 2017).
37
Sometimes, because those issues are considered personal issues, these challenges
are not readily expressed to people around the persons bearing the pain, then, it
continues to hurt them. Remember, anything that hurts or brings pain is likened to
sicknesses. The best thing to do to a sickness is for it to be treated by a specialist;
one of the ways of treating such problems is to consult a librarian who will
recommend a book or other electronic resources for you to read and digest. That
service is called bibliotheraphy.
Advantages of Bibliotherapy
40
The benefits are immediate and can be practiced as soon as the person starts
reading the book.
It can be reassuring to identify that you are not alone in dealing with a
particular problem. This can help breakdown any isolation that you are
feeling.
It helps in learning about an issue that might give someone the right words
and confidence to seek additional help, such as talking with friends, family
members, teachers, bosses, and also at interviews.
Bibliotherapy helps readers to gain new insight on the challenging situation
they are facing and how it could be managed.
Bibliotherapy helps students to improve on their academic performances and
competences.
Some of these books accessible to readers for free and they may be
borrowed at no cost.
Disadvantages of Bibliotherapy
41
Inability of the reader to directly apply the ideas, as obtained from success
stories of others, may further compound the problem at hand. This is
because such can lead to frustration.
The proposed solutions to the problems that have been obtained by the
person may make him/her become desperate to come out of the problem.
This may make him to be over ambitious, over react, or restless.
42
To increase an individual understanding of human behaviours or motions.
Jack and Ronan (2008) echo this sentiment in their assertion that bibliotherapy is,at
its heart, an educational pursuit focused on both academic and psychological
achievement. Schools provide the permissive reading environments necessary for
bibliotherapy to take place (Russell & Shrodes, 2009), and literature is already
being utilized in schools as an instructional tool to influence the total development
of students (Cook et al., 2006; Russell & Shrodes, 2008), so it stands to reason that
the next logical step would be to deliberately expand the use of literature in schools
for therapeutic purposes.
43
Although many school professionals could deliver a bibliotherapy program,
including teachers, counselors, psychologists, librarians, and nurses (Jack &
Ronan, 2008; Mumbauer & Kelchner, 2017; Prater et al., 2006; Sullivan & Strang,
2003), Prater et al. (2006) assert that even if schools have specialized staff such as
a school counselor or psychologist, those individuals may not have time to conduct
bibliotherapy for all of the individual students who need it.
Shrodes (2009) supports this idea, stating that the more familiar a teacher is with
the dynamics of reading, the more successful he or she will be when harnessing the
power of literature for healing purposes, and Rosenblatt (2012) claims that teachers
of literature often deal with subjects “thought of as the province of the sociologist,
psychologist, philosopher, or historian” (p. 5). With training from a school
counselor or psychologist, ELA teachers could easily and successfully implement
bibliotherapy as part of a general education curriculum (Prater et al., 2010;
Sullivan & Strang, 2012).
When a teacher initiates bibliotherapy, it may be helpful for him or her to refer to
the program as “bibliocounseling” or “biblioguidance” to present the concept in a
way that other stakeholders will understand (Gladding & Gladding, 1991, p. 9).
44
the main bibliotherapy practitioner ascertain student problems, create goals,
recommend books, implement strategies, and evaluate the effectiveness of the
program (Baruchson-Arbib, 2006; Prater et al., 2006; Russell & Shrodes, 2005b).
During deployment, the teacher should consider individual students’ struggles and
areas of concern when planning units, then select texts and activities that, with the
teacher’s guidance, will encourage the identification, catharsis, and insight phases
of bibliotherapy (Russell & Shrodes, 2005b). Discussions meant to assist in the
catharsis and insight phases could take place in the classroom as well as one-on-
one with a school counselor for at-risk students (Prater et al., 2006). Most
importantly, bibliotherapy implementation must be deliberate and undertaken with
a plan of action as it may be ineffective if not employed with prudence (Prater et
al., 2006).
Knowing the reader. The teachers who lead bibliotherapy programs must be
familiar with a variety of books, but even more importantly, they must know the
student or students for whom the bibliotherapy program is implemented (Russell &
Shrodes, 1990b). As Jack and Ronan (2008) state, “If guidance is to be more than a
very superficial service, the reader must be understood as a whole personality” (p.
168), and Prater et al. (2006) argue that the relationship between the teacher and
students must be strong enough for the students to feel comfortable divulging
sensitive information. In order to create the environment necessary to facilitate
effective bibliotherapy sessions and to tailor the bibliotherapy experience to the
students’ specific needs, the teacher must know the following information about
each of the students involved:
The usual characteristics and behaviors of children in the students’ age range
(Russell & Shrodes, 1950b).
45
The students’ reading habits and abilities (Ackerson, Scogin, McKendree-
Smith, & Lyman, 1998; Pardeck, 2009b; Russell & Shrodes, 1990b).
The students’ interests and talents (Pardeck, 2009b; Russell & Shrodes,
1990b).
The nature of the students’ family and home lives (Heath et al., 2015;
Russell & Shrodes, 2008b).
From the review of literature, it is clear that Bibliotherapy can play a vital role in
societal problem. It has effect on students, in specific terms, scholars agreed that
teachers need to be more involved in giving instructions to students and also help
to recommend some literature books that can help solve personal problems.
46
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHOD
Research methodology refers to a set of skills that are applied to carry out social
and scientific investigations. The term methodology also describes all processes
involved in the collection of data required for the research subject
This Chapter presents the Research Design, Population of the Study, Sample and
Sampling Technique, Research Instruments, Validity of the Instrument, Reliability
of the Instrument, Administration of the Instrument and Method of Data Analysis.
Research Design
This research is of a survey type, it uses descriptive analysis through the aid of
questionnaire to elicit information from the representation sample of the population
in order to arrive at a meaningful conclusion. This would enable the researcher to
describe systematically the facts, events on area of interest as factual and accurate
as possible so as to answer the questions raised for the purpose of the study
Population
The population for the study consists of all Secondary Schools in Ado Metropolis
including Private and Public Schools. They are Schools under the control of the
Ministry Of Education. There are about 20 Public secondary schools in Ado Ekiti,
and there are more than 6000 students in those public schools. There are more
private schools in Ado Ekiti than public schools. There about 4000 students in the
private secondary schools.
47
sample class will be used. The three types of non-probability samples are Quota
sampling, convenience sampling and judgmental sampling. Convenience sampling
will be used because it involves choosing respondents at the convenience of the
researcher
The sample consists of hundred (100) respondents. The simple Random technique
was used. 10 secondary schools in Ado Ekiti was selected from the population for
the study. Meanwhile, 5 public secondary schools were selected, and 5 private
schools respectively. The public schools selected within Ado Ekiti are Anglican
Grammar School, Christ Boys, Christ Girls, Mary immaculate, Muslim Grammar
school. While the selected private schools are Jokotayo senior secondary school,
Fountain High School, Nova Group of Schools, Happy Day Group of Schools,
Beautiful Beginning High School.
Research Instrument
The instrument that was used for the study is questionnaire developed by the
researcher. The questionnaire was drawn to collect relevant information on the
effect of Bibliotherapeutic on Senior Secondary School students learning outcomes
in Literature-in-English in Ado Ekiti Local Government Area, Ekiti State.
It consists of two sections which are section A and B. Section A was based on
background, length of services while section B consists of items drawn from
research objectives.
The items are based on the kind of gadget used by teachers to teach the students.
The instrument will have four point Likert- response scales organized into four
clusters. The scale used were categorized into SA-Strongly Agree, A- Agree, D-
Disagree and SD- Strongly Disagree on a scale point of 4, 3, 2 and 1 respectively
A test re-test method of reliability was used to establish the reliability of the
instrument. The instrument was administered to the respondents who were not part
of the respondents for the study within an interval of two weeks. The data collected
on the administrations were correlated and analyzed using t-test method and the
reliability coefficient of 0.73
The researcher seeks permission room the principal/ head-teacher of the selected
secondary schools before the administration of questionnaire. Hundred (100)
copies of the instrument were administered to the respondents with the help of
research assistant.
Data Analysis
49
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
This Chapter describes the analysis of data and discussion of the research findings.
The findings relate to the research questions that guided the study. For clarity and
logical presentation purposes, the analysis was organized around the respective
research questions, hypotheses and objectives of the study as presented below.
Variable
items Frequency Percentage
Male
40 40.0
Gender Female 60 60.0
Total 100 100.0
Christianity 85 85.0
Religion
Islamic 15 15.0
Total 100 100.0
50
It was also revealed that 85% of the respondents were Christians, 15% were
Muslims
The analysis of Table 1 also showed that 40% respondents both disagreed and
strongly disagreed the claim that they do not offer literature because of the volume
of books to read. Item 2 also revealed that 70% of the respondents disagreed and
strongly disagreed. In item 3, 25% 0f the respondents disagreed and strongly
disagreed. In item 4, 60% of the respondents disagreed and strongly disagreed with
the statement. In item 5, 15% of the respondents disagreed and strongly disagreed
with the statement. Item 6 claims that 18% of the respondents disagreed and
strongly disagreed with the statement.
Table 2: Percentage analysis on how students are influenced by the books they
read.
52
S/N ITEMS A SA D SD Total
Table 2 shows that literature books have improved the students in many areas. It
has improved their creativity, increase their reading skills, help them to
comprehend well, improve their spoken English and sensitivity. Item 1 shows that
40% and 48% respondents believes literature books have helped to increase their
reading speed and skill. Item 2 reveals that 85% respondents agreed and strongly
agreed that Literature books have helped them to be more creative. Item 3 shows
53
that 79% respondents agreed and strongly agreed that literature books helped them
to comprehend easily and fast. Item 4 on table 2 revealed that 50% respondents
agreed and strongly agreed that literature books have helped them to identify
whom they are. Item 5 revealed that 65% respondents agreed and strongly agreed
that reading of literature books have helped them achieve their aims. Item 6
revealed that 92% respondents agreed and strongly agreed that literature text has
helped to improve their spoken English and sensitivity.
Item 1 revealed that 12% respondents disagreed and strongly disagreed the
statement. Item 2 revealed that 15% respondents disagreed and strongly disagreed
the statement. Item 3 revealed that 21% respondents disagreed and strongly
disagreed the statement. Item 4 revealed that 50% respondents disagreed and
strongly disagreed the statement. Item 5 revealed that 35% respondents disagreed
and strongly disagreed the statement. While item 6 revealed that 8% respondents
disagreed and strongly disagreed the statement.
54
Prose % 45 30 15 10 100%
Table 3 shows that respondents prefer to read prose books, drama and comics book
than poetry.
Item 1 shows that 75% respondents agreed and strongly agreed that they prefer to
read prose books. Item 2 shows that 89% respondents agreed and strongly agreed
that they prefer to read Drama books. Item 3 shows that 15% respondents agreed
and strongly agreed that they prefer to read poetry. Item 4 shows that 97%
respondents agreed and strongly agreed that they prefer to read comic books. Item
5 shows that 76% of the respondents agreed and strongly agreed that they prefer to
read epic books. Item 6 shows that 27% of the respondents agreed and strongly
agreed that they prefer to read fictional books.
55
Item 1 revealed that 25% of the respondents disagreed and strongly disagreed the
statement. Item 2 revealed that 11% of the respondents disagreed and strongly
disagreed with the statement. Item 3 revealed that 85% of the respondents
disagreed and strongly disagreed with the statement. Item 4 revealed that 5% of the
respondents disagreed and strongly disagreed with the statement. Item 5 revealed
that 24% of the respondents disagreed and strongly disagreed the statement. While
item 6 revealed that 76% of the respondents disagreed and strongly disagreed the
statement.
DISCUSSION
The result in table 2 revealed the opinion of the respondents how they are
motivated by the books they read. Majority of the respondents agreed and strongly
agreed that Literature texts have helped them to increase their reading speed and
skills, it has helped them to be more creative and help them to achieve some
certain goals. The finding was supported by Jack & Ronan 2008.
56
The result in table 3 revealed the opinion of the respondents on the type of books
they read. Due to this, majority of the respondents strongly agreed and agreed that
they prefer to read some certain literature books. The finding was supported by
Pehrsson and McMillen 2007, Reading Prose books is recognized as a means to
help individuals deal with deep concerns and can offer strategies specific to
developmental issues.
CHAPTER FIVE
Summary
57
Bibliotherapy, Advantages of Bibliotherapy, Disadvantages of Bibliotherapy, and
Bibliotherapy in a School Settings.
Chapter three presented the Research methodology, it stated the instruments and
method used to gather all data of this research. The population for the study
consists of some Secondary Schools in Ado Metropolis including Private and
Public Schools. The sample consists of hundred (100) respondents. The simple
Random technique was used. 10 secondary schools in Ado Ekiti was selected from
the population for the study. Meanwhile, 5 public secondary schools were selected,
and 5 private schools respectively. The public schools selected within Ado Ekiti
are Anglican Grammar School, Christ Boys, Christ Girls, Mary immaculate,
Muslim Grammar school. While the selected private schools are Jokotayo senior
secondary school, Fountain High School, Nova Group of Schools, Happy Day
Group of Schools, Beautiful Beginning High School.
Chapter four analyzed and interpreted data collected from respondents. They were
analyzed in tabular form and the results were calculated in percentage.
CONCLUSION
However, Research question two which showed that students are motivated by the
books they read was significant. The findings justify that literature books serve as
guide which influence students morally and academically.
Finally, Based on the findings of this research, Bibliotherapy should not only be
embraced in schools at all levels by way of providing students with good books to
read, bibliotherapy should be viewed and adopted as a serious subject of
considerable importance by all stake holders in the education sector, including the
students themselves, this will go a long way in arresting the persistence mass
failure problem and other consequences such as examination malpractices, school
dropout etc . Also the rate of crime will be reduced to the barest minimum.
Furthermore, the quality of man power in the country will improve by and by.
Reading shapes the mind and thinking of readers. It shapes their attitude towards
people, towards life and ways of doing things. The implication is that students
should be exposed to good reading materials that will help them handle academic
challenges.
Recommendations
Based on the findings of the study, the following recommendations were made:
59
3. Parents should encourage their children by providing literature books and other
appropriate books for them.
4. Librarians should work with school teachers ·and counsellors to know the
reading needs and challenges of students; this will assist in acquiring relevant
reading materials in addition to academic books.
5. Book club programmes packaged with giving of awards to best readers and most
frequent users of library resources should be encouraged in schools.
7. Teachers should encourage students by advising and telling them the dividends
of reading.
8. Nigerian authors should write and publish books that are readers' friendly,
especially for the young ones.
REFERENCE
Abe, T.O. (2014). “The effect of teachers’ qualification on students’ performance
in Mathematics”. Sky Journal of Educational Research, 2,(1), 10-14.
Adeyemi, A.M. &Adeyemi S.B. (2014), “Institutional factors as predictors of
60
students’ academic achievement in Colleges of Education in
South-western Nigeria”, International Journal of Educational
Administration and Policy Studies, 6, 8, 141- 153.
Ajayi, N. A. (1997). Bibliotherapy in Health Care Delivery. Nigeria Journal of
Physical Education and Research, 3, 442-446.
Aiex, N. (2019). Bibliotherapy. Learning Disabilities Online. ERIC Digest 82
Retrieved February
Allison, J. A., and Wrightsman, L. S. (1993). Rape: The Misunderstood Crime.
Newbury Park: Sage.
Bagley, C., & King, K. (1990). Child sexual abuse. London: Tavistock-Routledge.
Babock, G. (ed). (2009). Webster's Third Dictionary. New York: G & C Merriam
Company
Brewster, E., (2008). 'Medicine for the soul: Bibliotherapy' APLIS 21(3)
September 2008 ppii5-l19
Brewster, L. (2008). Reader development and mental wellbeing: the accident
bibliotherapist. Australian Public Libraries and Information Services 22,
13-16.
Brown, E .. (2017). Bibliotherapy and Its Widening Applications Metuchen, NJ:
Scarecrow Press
Brown, H.D. (2012). Principles of language learning and teaching. New York:
Pearson.
Cook, G. (1994). Discourse and Literature: the Interplay of Form and Mind.
Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Crowthers, S.M.(1960) A Literacy Clinic. Atlantic Monthly. Vol.l18. pp.291-301
Chiedu, A. (2012). “Rape of Nigerians and Country: What shall we Do? Retrieved
fromhttp://www.guardian.co.uk./world2002/aug/20ganda. Islam on
February 2, 2015.
Cornett, C. and Cornett, C. (2010). Bibliotherapy· The Right Book at the Right
Ii.me.. Bloomington, IN: Phi Delta Kappa Educational Foundation.
61
Di Silvio, Lorenzo (2011). “Correcting Corrective Rape: Carmichele and
Developing South Africa’s Affirmative Obligations to Prevent Violence
against Women”. Georgetown Law Journal 99 (2011): 1469-515.
Fakeye, D. O (2019). Predicting students ‘achievement in English language from
teachers’ classroom behavior and teaching experience. European Journal of
Educational Studies 4, 2, 203-210.
Federal Republic of Nigeria (2013). The National Policy on Education
(6th Edition) Abuja: NERDC Press.
Gladding, S. and Gladding, C. (1991). The ABCs of bibliotherapy for school
counselors. The School Counselor, 39, (1) 7-13.
Giade, A. (2011,June 30). How Nigeria’s Latest Drug Abuse Defies Legislat. Daily
Trust NewsPaper . Retrieved from
http://www.dailytrust.com.ng/daily/old/index.php/feature/42852-how-nigerias-
latest-drug-abuse- defies-legislation
Harris, S., Petrie, G. & Willoughby, W. (2002) Bullying among 9th graders:
An exploratory study. NASSP Bulletin, 86 (630) 3-14.
Http://www.australiacouncil.gov.au/news/news_items/communique_-
australian literature in education roundtable accessed November 10 2008
Jack, S. and Ronan, K., (2008). Bibliotherapy: Practice and Research. School
Psychology International, 29(2), pp 161-182
Katz, & Watt, (2010). Advocated the need for Bibliotherapy. The Journal of
Abnormal and Social Psychology, 28, 280 – 290.
Muehlenhard, C. L., and Linton, M. A, (1987). Date rape and sexual aggression in
dating situations: Incidence and risk factors. Journal of counseling
psychology,34,186- 196
Lakhanpal, P. Agnihotri, A., K. (2007). Drug Abuse an International Problem:
A short Review with Special reference to African Continent. Journal of
Medicine and Toxicology, 1(1), 1-11
Oluremi, D. F. (2012). Drug Abuse among Nigerian Adolescents strategies for
counselling. Journal of International Social Research. 5(20), 342 – 347.
62
Oshodi, O. Y., Aina, O. F. and Onajole, A. T. (2010). Substance use among
secondary school students in an urban setting in Nigeria: prevalence and
associated factors. African journal of psychiatry, 13 (1), 52 – 57.
Oshikoya, K. A., Alli, A. (2006). Perception of Drug Abuse Amongst Nigerian
Undergraduates. World Journal of Medical Sciences, 1 (2), 133-139.
Pardeck. J., (2003). Using Literature to help adolescent cope with problems-
Bibliotherapy, Adolescence, (Online). Available at
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi m2248/is n114 v29/a i 15622147(Accessed
30 September 2009)
Pehrsson, D. E., & McMillen, P. (2007). Bibliotherapy: Overview and implications
for counselors (ACAPCD-02). Alexandria, VA: American Counseling
Association.
Russell, D. H., & Shrodes, C. (2009). Contributions of research in bibliotherapy to
the language-arts program part ii. The School Review, 58(7), 411-420.
Ross, D. (2002). Bullying. In J. Sandoval (Ed.), Hanbook of crisis counselling,
intervention, and prevention in the schools (electronic version) 2nd ed.
(pp. 105-135): Mahwah, NJ: L. Erlbaum Associates.
Rozalski, M., Stewart, A., & Miller, J. (2010). Bibliotherapy: Helping Children
Cope with Life’s Challenges. Record, 47, 33.
Rubin, R. J. (2017). Using bibliotherapy: A guide to theory and practice. Phoenix,
AZ: Oryx Press.
Sullivan, A. K., & Strang, H. R. (2003). Bibliotherapy in the classroom. Childhood
Education, 79, 74-79.
Shrodes, C. (1949). Bibliotherapy: A theoretical and clinical-experimental study.
Doctoral dissertation, University of California at Berkeley
63
BIBLIOTHERAPY EFFECTS ON SENIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL STUDENTS: A CASE STUDY OF SOME
SELECTED SECONDARY SCHOOLS IN ADO EKITI
Dear Respondents,your response will be treated with utmost confidentiality and will be used
for academic purpose only. Thanks in anticipation of your co-operation
Please kindly tick in the appropriate space that reflects your personal data.
Please tick ( ) where Agree ( A ), Strongly Agreed (SA), Disagree ( D ) and Strongly Disagree (SD).
Section B: The followings are the problems of Literature teaching & learning in Schools.
S/N ITEMS A SA D SD
64
10 Literature books have helped me to identify who i am
13 Prose
14 Drama
15 Poetry
16 Comedy
17 Epic
18 Fiction
19 Non Fictional
65
66