Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dretske - Explaining Behavior - Reasons in A World of Causes
Dretske - Explaining Behavior - Reasons in A World of Causes
ye01q
‘Aa ‘spalgo asayy 0} uaddey ose S8uIy “op 03 pey 22u0 sBulaq weLIMY
yey) sung aangadar ‘suiosazy yj jo Auew op mou s
pue ‘dn sn ayem spop uueye
‘ayy woss ysnp ayy dn sy
sn
ayy yes 0} SUD,SAS au UT
244 Sum}a8 10}—spayp 2
-aWOS st Sq,“
ued ‘op 1 Sunipawios st yeyy "Jo aoard e dn pid pu 4940 puag [J] SOUP
“our pue sjuauinuysur ynoge pres aq ue> siuejd ynoge pres ancy | IU,
{ueAay
[re 2m se ‘syesoqyap 3,ust 3] LTeY ano pays am aye Bur
Jupan 98 am jupqnoys Ay ‘soineyaq pug jo uu} v st SufOU J! PUE "UDYS
nay pays Kau vaya Sunygowos SuIop 103 pa. 423 saxeus
yo aoaid v ‘saop uewi e Bunyawos st 3 ‘sassan0ud peorBoI01s
JO 3Insau alg se ‘Janamoy ‘Kem [euLiOU a4} Ur S3nODO 5%
‘uogy yo 31s] 20 yo STE 508
Sluouue $90} sey aquosop uo 2m '&qUOURUOD OS Op YOU Op aM YOK, #0}
pavaddey pey xy Sumyjawios 9q pjnom 3! ‘uop pey aH} ayy SumypewOs aq
yom sy. s9aea St pays axe JOU PROM 994} aX} —901) 24) WOH WAY
Uenoyg pey suring © 30 soxpuexq ay} UO} ENA PayPAIA ey ueLIspoor
fyi some ousopxo Jo asneDaq poysedap ey s9Ae3] 9 JT Aeriuana
fo au) J9pun 59489] 9) YEU SO 5
ueypou 24 jo Buuayeas &asne 205) ayy UTA
Suyunos0 soBueyp [eDoy> UlEI9> 391) 94) UNM wo} sowIO> Feaotos
Jeo} Jo asne> Aseulid ayy asnednq ‘ToIAeYq 29n Jo uO} e SBOP 2013
J rdousw Sunpowos st soavot six Susppays"98EY> Jo ane ay 30 TeWO}x®
39 [ews shoo} ay s[euUe 203s 3 Se tes ay 510} suaddey yey WHOM
Soop ued ayy ey SuaysinSusip 303 siseq Burd popun ax ae y>Ro Ul
‘wowp 07 uaddey yey Bun as€
aay "umop yo pur sojoaq q poxpene Buunysiy Aq ¥pnss 8 ose Au,
‘op S003) Suny axe asoy“sease patewep yo Huyjea dq anlar wos soaps
-asayy pap $23 sya pas S2an} aos
(caz 4 ¥961 1989) 8
pimbs “#2) spodopeyd
bp coup Sunypowos sr yeyy‘sassoiSoud uoreas ay) se 20j09 a8UEYD SIOMOY
raadey otgua} eso1seyaq Suoue aoueydaooe api poured sey |]>} Ue> | se 155
\aPyaq Jo auny>id Bumjaduso> e syuasaud (¢) pue
[puooes siyy ut ‘os pur) ajqisia jou Sunpaus , uapy
“9AOU 24 JO 9889 24}
si Sump ayy out 8
‘asneo yeuroqut (9yetsdosdde) awios fig pampoud quauzaaow (med)
ue (1) uaamyaq ng
(1) uaamaq jou st uonenbo 3ySis ayy “uayy “BuPyuNY Jo ouy
Dy ‘asne> 14811 a4 SurAey syusWIaAow e\d
ye pure auuy e ye sanooo 3] ‘poads © pue ‘(sjuouraAow pauute Jo ase a4
1a) Adeanove ue "yy Sua.}s & UORDANIP e sey ‘ajdusexd 205 UawBAOUL Y ‘jaf
to spdso Kuous sey ‘s98M0y ‘DAY Uy “9sNeD feUsDyU! BOS £q Pay BwI0s
Je wowonpo.d ayy s}“ua0s aaey am se ‘soraeyag "quaUeAN Aur pazuOpereYD
Sey 08 sey yeyy AWEOYTIE alp Jo autos enouias Pinoys uoIssnosIp as0ym
auo ‘paypa|Sou 2} os ancy | ey ZO1AEYaq Jo amyeo} zOKOUR S| 2:0y]
‘Joos 0} $1030 54! 303 Siuyoor ‘Bumyyoutos Surop se paquosap Aadosd
st aumypews ayy way} ‘uoryerado aumsal oy yBnouD pajoo> Aay3 rar yo
[pouiny 910% si0joul a4} asne20q ‘PayEaYsOA0 siO}OU! a4 asnovaq Sumuaddey
1 Sunjou ‘puey sao ay) uo ‘yf “BunpAue op zusoop 3 “suaddey But
AMON "una 3 op srojOUW! S3f ‘Yo pay>y!as JOAaU St aUIyPeU auf J] AYIONO
‘Aaip uoyM SJ0}0W 31 Yo BuAIMYs Kuerodwra) 10} wsnweyoUur aHewOIMe
ue yas autypeu v ut puy axe yeu Se aUes ayy st yseNUOD SHY “TE Ie sopsM
‘say Jo uoHeAIBUU! OU pu s2/JsnUt jsJuoBEyUE pu stUOBE Jo UOHEAZOUUT
paouejeg © uaaMjaq aouaiayIp snouHOUS UE AIsnoIAgo St 215K
lu sim220 quawanou ou yBnoy, sorneyaq se Apenb you op AaeqourU jo
suuio} s9}, 2824) ‘20ua}4 “WuaUIaAOUI OU jo siaUTEjUTEUA aanDe se papseso1
jou aie ‘aaoge pagursap sioleyaq ayy ayiyun ‘Ing “syuauIaAoUI Isne ou
‘op “2Aoge paquDsap siolAeyq ay) Ul asoKR ay] ‘suIsEYDOUI pure s936a901d
yeuroyu ypiyat ur (qyeap pue “2ouery ‘ewI0> ‘sIsAyezed se pM) sa}EIS YatM
pajserjuo> ag 03 st o1Aeaq ypAG ,;azmjde> 0} asuodsas ut [1q“y—duu] 08
10} &poq au Bursne> “21 waysAs sour autua ayy Bunenuarodap A/SUOHS
saajonul aPyaq © st peap Surdeyd yey, paziseydusa AjBu0%}s 00}
‘aq jouue> 31, 31 sind ‘suaxpnp jo soMeyaq peep Buike|d, 249 uo (FZ61)
dnyjes jo 20M ayy BunD “roe “A ‘OBer) [PISITED SV “aAoUr 0} jou APOG
ayy Suomen swistueypaus [euiayur Jo saoueysur fe ase unNB w uste 03 10 21njsod
{@8uey> jou “21) ump 04 sayesgayan ur Buys syuauHsnipe se[n>
smu queysuo> ayy pur soyepaid © &q aunyde> 0} asuodsas wi peap BuLkeld
lunssod & 10 uaypp e spoys 2upaj9 ue 0} asuodsa: ur ,Burzaay, yeuTUe
uy 3sne [eWIB}U! Ue Sey UaUIAAOU Jo aDUASqE ay) aseD SKN UE "MORI
tio yeurayxo ayy asnedaq 2O1AEYaq 5!
{A Bursne> you s, uaamyaq ysmniunsip 03 yueyoduut sty! uoseat siyt 70
jewiayxa £q Buixour wo poyonaud axe soy pu suze
juBuIDAOUF-uoU Jo asne> rewtud ayy ‘puEY J9U}O 94} UO ‘| YaAaqeYNA 10 “BU
ply ‘Sunpyem ‘Burwye ‘Sunuod ‘Suysar Bunrem ‘yreasq soy SuIpfoy HS
Suspurys s1 uosiad ayy ‘Jeussqur st asne> oy) Uaye pur ‘Sasme> sy Sey
juOWIBAOUF-UON "WwOUIDAOUE Jo 2>u2SqN B43 10} PUR}S UDAB WED PY’ TEURE aU
Jo Squauoaow se jo uy) dqueurpso aM yeyM you yng [aaa] Ae|MDdIOU 943
Je squouranous asmbax Aeur y>ryM soBueyp ‘aunssaid 10 ‘aanjesadwiay‘40]0>
uy aBueyp e aq YB 3] ‘sywaWeAoUI Kpoq weYY Joy}O sBuNYy 205 pues ued
6 so1eypg Jo ompnas oy,
Z pur 1 sandy ut jy yey) aj0u Ajduu
you saop so1Aeyaq 0} AuSs909u ou
Bumsau
“BurprenS ‘(op 0} aw paSBeu sowzous Aw Bunyowos) pasa 3889 30
Surypyey ayp 103 poumbas Sqpe>x80] 30u are squowiaAous YpNs Jeyy St WIOd OY,
jueaafaus st pouid sip SuLmp Burrows prone jouue> ‘ARojorsAyd sy waar
‘pur ‘saxour ping e eq Pe} ay “uaUIaAous armbas yUs9OP TEKH 01AeYIq
puig jo uuoy ajqepadsax Appayiad e st $889 Sunpyey “Azessaoau jou Aurea
“uno20 uagjo juaWaAOU YBNOMRTY ‘PUR, aUHOs Jo juswIEAOU! SurAjOALT
se J01Aeyaq Jo uayods sempe ‘uonssodxa jo aoualuaAuo> 10) ‘aAey |
‘aye quazedde au0D9q [tM oP
‘am yey op am Ayo Jo uoReUE|dxa axp spay 31 MOH “Ayxo}duH0> [eusO,UE
snp qn BuIop se sanypsino aquosap am sBunyy ayy Jo ySOW! Jey) apo
-|MoUpe Ajpiaw | uaWoW axp 204 uIod yueysodu sty OF UsMyDI“sOrAeYOq
Jo uoreurjdxa ayy ut amBy suosear Gem at SurUTUeXd UOyM ‘EM |
(1961 posuueaf) amypnzs josjuED ua SH YAM Y>eD “(Burdsei8 ‘Sunypeas)
squauodwoo jesorseyaq yqiyx® 0} apeus aq ue> ypuad e dn Suppid se
srosnauew uewny ajduns £|puazedde ypns aaa ‘yBnoua dn pau; s! uoreD
-yuSew je>r jeu ayy JJ "uo os pue “umeds 0} saaudn Sumuyar uoWES ©
‘feuray e SuRmo> saddoysse8 afew e ‘wep e BuIpjing soneaq e—suo\Aeyoq
painyxa} Aypu UMO zay} aAey sfeuNUE ‘asino> jo “puy “sjuouodulo>
JProvaeyaq s9jduns oqut'sissappua ysour ‘pazsqeue ag ue> saded v SuIpeos
ue om 0} Bulaup ‘Buiddoys ayy sontanoe ueumy AepAzoAg “sora yaq
‘Asequauia[p asous jo saouanbas painjpnuys are suoiaeyaq Weuiny pue [eure
se ssed yeuy sBunyy Auews yeyp ‘puodex ayy 104 Kuo yr "ysinoyy Buraseydira
yuoM st 4] "uruypads auyua ay jo anrequasaidas a1am yep sojdusexo
an18 0} pau aney | “orseyaq (aunpew pue yueld uoquaUr o} Jou) UEWIMY
jue jewnue jo Ayssonip pue {ayer snouuous ayy 3988s 0} OHS Ue UL
dojanyag fo spy 911
randy 9pod ponoied a4)
J woH28ap 9 pu
Ro wep ue 0} asuodsa,
Ur diy coomaog ysr@upp of em asa uoras aus 40g "DGGE AMUN) 296“
uy Aaqp 31 (8261 Uo3]O) poos 10} BurBex0j wt ABa}ENS YIYS-uIM w 0} pasod
“sip Aqeoyauad aes ‘ajdusexo 103 ‘sjey “L861 1940s) 101A8YAq JO 5}208)
juasayip 9504p ede asvay 0} (9198804 40) Ase9 aq sKempe you Avus 9
‘3uop 40 uop
1 1 aaayon ‘auop st 4} uayor :paureydxa Bulag st so1weyag ayp Jo s200f yeyM
Luo spuadap orjeuejdxo aaruBoo e 40 uoneunjdxa a7auas e sey x014eYOq
ayy sO\RaY DUD} “(HST sBRqUaGIOY) Fednd paseasip BumIEUO>
sje jo uondaoiad ay) Aq—poulwiajap Ajjequed aouay pue—paro83uy
‘1 (20ue}su) 10} ‘S99q JOM Jo soIAeY>q BuIddeouN-y—D ayy) auas
2jSuis e Jo joruod ayy sapun st} Jeyy JO1AEYaq ang OIARYaq Jo suIAAEd
Pourwwiaap Aijeonouad ‘adeys 0} sauawos pue "yDY2 0} Aressapou
sid&y st 2ouauiadxa ‘azouuzoyying “sioweyaq ayeuur Jo suOEUEA pur ‘su
-ua}xa ‘Santjeauap axe ssoineypq paused] ues asne32q 's9}0u (9¢ “d ‘OR6T)
nzeyy Se ‘0s SaUHaWIOS st Si] PUR “(Z86I JOLWY Pue PINON) pasmnboe
up pu paurea| ayy yum poss
‘yj ‘s2ouangut [ejuOtuUONTAUD pur 2AIUDB uddM4oq UORPEID;L! EUs
1 Jo spnpoid ayy st soraeyag ‘ajduns 09) st KwoyOY>YP aimnU-ameU plo
ay, “suO;>e} AubuL jo amp v st sowneyaq ‘fe sdeysod “Ysour yey) jo
Sujuiod jo puoy ase systuaps yeioraeyag “amosqo ureuras jm ‘sioidey>
juanbasqns uy laseapp ayeus 0} adoy | 78up afor v “ioraeyaq jo uoReUE|dxo
‘343 ur suosver Jo ajox ayy pe} siyy saqeDaidde auo ssapun 304 -poure|dxo
aq 0} sSuyy juzaffip “ysea] ye Ayjequajod ‘ave azoxy yey) azTuBODa1 aM
3e4} St uepoduu st yey, ‘sHo}AeYaq yUaLayIp Se 10 soIAEYEG Jo a>ard ajSuIs
aos Jo sjuauodwoo juarayKp 6[psdUH Se 1OLAEYG JO SY—>e} 1Uax2pIP 2524
JO YUKA am somaya quepodia Sepoqsed 3st “Sosodind Aut 40g
(oc6r weUpIoD)
ym, Surge, poe Bunge) waampeq YB 0} wom am AY 61003
‘sIW “G10 }>ej a4aUaS Aq paxy Ajaanej) Spy] Ye v jsf Moy puE (SunLTED]
4q ajqeurpow) syp¥] yer © uo] Moy (ETT “A “OLET MIPYDEY) UaaMyaq Pur
“(&xequmjon) 2424 jap pue (AzeyuNjoaut) dou YoHED%ap (99T “d “F861
quaiayip ayn aumbas Kew ayy yey, “2}—uosear siyy Appexe 104
349 are quowonow ayy pue 3 ylog jt wera g Ayodoud ypta juowanow &
poonpoud >) kyya Surujdxa se atues ayy jou st y Aadoud ype guawsosous
® paonpoid >) quand yeusoyut AY SuUTE|axg “01AEYOq dUUeS ay} Jo (83298)
Te soeyag yo amanag 94,
juasaytp Sure we | yey) spadse aiqeysinBunsip yse9] ye 40 “siorAEyoq,
jua.aYp axe asay, “aq plnoys ayy) uoseas ou s} aiayy, "uoreue|dxa
ums aup aq Ou [aM asayp ang, ‘aia BuNa8 ut pip ay yyed sejM>qIed
‘yy Yoo} 31 Ayss 40} uoreurjdxa ue pur a104} 0} A104, WO} yuoM feUITUE
ay Ayo 10) uoneueidxa ue aq Aew aay] (ose “d “8261 [azuay\) saanjonuys
oman seau wap sdaoy yeux yjed e Jajaid pue sadeqd uado jo snowne>
ase Kay ‘Soye1qay9A ySoUr ayf7 “Poo a4} Yeas O} a}N0: SNOIARP aI0W ©
24e) uayo ym syeunue Bunof “eueueg a4p 03 3yB'eNS Yyed payonysqoun ue
st asoyp jt ang “PueUEG v Y>}9} 0} ar04) OF a1ay WOH S908 aazuEdumTUD y
suoseat e soy pue asoddind v yim ‘asauy Ley
syjer ‘ray soupye29s 31 3Nq “APpARKaBAL YPHEDS Kew Zop y ‘suoneUR|dxa
juazayrp ancy fe ‘A{Sumpioo>e “Kew pue sun quarayyp [fe axe “doys 0} nos
payse uosrad ayy uayy pur ‘a s,uosiad e ut ‘f|daap Sunpeaiq ‘Buryy au0
st Sunpeaig soraeyag Jo aoaid uani8 Aue ynoge urejdxa oF sBunyy uaiayP
Je Aqauea v aq Aeur aiauy yey} ‘uoMeuejdxa st puey ye ssautsng ayy ays
‘a8paymounpe yea] ye YSN aUo ‘SIOIAEY|aq yUALAYIP se JO1AeYaq Jo sppadse
juatayip asauy jo Sunyuny ayy] 3usa0p auo 4! 3C) “pay pronposd Aye
“apyut ain Jo ppadse ypea 203 so1Aeyaq juaraysp vse 38 Ajequdyod ‘oAeY
ant ‘rayyoue Sursne s,8uny} auo YIM payHuapy Buraq SI s01Aeyaq aus
__g WoUIDACW 34) j0 s}908j 10 soxpodosd
aiqeysimBunsip are aiouy se yuaworow ayy 30 suoreueydxa Cueus se '3q
‘Keut so ‘axe arauy, uoreue(dxa afSus v Jo paou ut KyHUD 9(BuIse se 109947
Jo W-urBaout ay} 1891} 0} Yst}O0} aq pInoM 3 TUaUIAAOWE a4 J0 uaUOdLO>
Jeouien Sumzel-yj99) 249 20} peor axp ur szfouod ayy pur ‘sosned yuoyTUr
“1a}u ayy 40} Joya yp ayy ‘paads ayp 10} aqqysuodsa1 st 300} Kavay,
AWN “wonDaurp 34) ul aq 0} yuauianout ydureg ayy SasneD yy “ayy "yd
{£9 Je AAoU O} $69] Yr ‘dAOW! 0} 28> Au asnED }USBOP ‘SDUEySU! 10} “TED
Kut jo [Baym Suuaays ayy uo $ny APY ‘Py JO y9De4 yUaLOYIp y>ed 404 ssa01d
IN© 2 jnauapip © st azoyy ‘aouap] “Sasme> Jewioyu {UOIa}IP oney ‘SOP
Luayo pue “ued JaDey ype asmeDaq SIOMNEYaR IUAIaAP
1 Siowseyag quozaprp Ayes pe axe Aauy pyar ast9s
nq “ioraeyag auf Jo sjo>e/jUaLaBEP ToD [EYE | Jeys axe Asay, "yuaUIOAOW!
si Jo stuauodwon quaraysp ureidxa 04 ue Kew am ‘(ajdusexa 205 "su
110} eq 88a ue Burjos wt) pray s.as008 ©
(Gesu0 snymuays rye an990 0} »pad a4} 00) 11 BuO] Moy) AOUD}E]
sit 20 »pad ayy Jo ozo} ayn u paysaiaqur aq Kew am ‘Kay v ye pad v st
uawanou! ay 3] s}uawanow Ja490 0} sarysuoreyar aseyd Sit 40 ‘apnayduse
ramdeyy of‘Apoq ayy £q uondiosqe 531 205 jenuasso aye}s jeorueypaur-jeoruiayp wIEya> &
‘oqur 1yn0xq 54 pos y>rye ul ssad0ud v st ‘jdurexo 104 "uonsaBiC] OBEY
0} aua¥ ;uaaey nod “OBea1y 03 188 nok
in aja[dwoour sureuras Aausnol e se ysnf Butag oyu1 yySn03q,
ay {Hun ayaydusoour surewar ssa>0ud oy, b ut ssa00ud ay)
“onpoid asoym sousoayno 0 ‘syjnsau ‘syonpoud Bussey sassad0id
-o1a pur "uoH29}26 [esnyeu ‘sisoyut od “UoRso8Ip ‘siso4
soso 17
‘suoseas £q,
uoneurjdxs 0} ajqeuaue st “paniaouos os ‘solAeyaq Moy Moys 0} ydusO}
pornjuce mo voHvou 0} you) ueysryuo> squoueddo amok wo) poysin
sea 51 yuauoddo snox Sussnju0> "9035 Jo apa mouy yuanbasuo>
sauo onpoid ayy woxy qussaip Azseap st ‘ssanoud e pais) Sune
‘yBnoua sholago ureuias Ayje1aua8 s2ouaiaylp ay—pnpoud pue ssao01d
ipuo>
\y}0q 40) pasn s} (Ae>ap “2) pom owes ay} vaya Aqjepadso—u
420 ‘DyRyS “juaAa awWoS st ppMpoid a4} uaYyM 9se—:9U UOISNIUOD 10},
sea axe sassa90ud SON,
yoo JO aounos © Sy
poud e jou 'ss200id e—sa4}0 ayy Sunposd auo ay} st
Ayppog sayya axe spay yeussyxa asayy “sase> Jeo1d4y ul -sasmea yeu}
‘hq, sjaaye fewsa}xa jo uoKpnposd ay) YIM pagnuap! uaaq sey so1Aey>g
ssado1g Se JOLARYag
z sydeyD
suoyjeny[s yons ur uns 0} puay Kay Ayes
410 sBop 0 preaye ase sye> Kym puersiopun 03 sn djay Aaya ypmus sa.aMoy
y8ty 5,389 ay jo adse sn ure|dxa sn djay 3,u0M souOUOY pur souOS sy]
‘uor2euIp ureyHa9 © uy sunu HY AYM 04 WADE 1 JDC} SH Jo BBPa|MOU 5,402
‘ayy Afaans ‘auaup st aan at pur asay si Sop ay ‘Ie 1ayyy “sBurpunoumns sy
|oge sMOU }89 ay Je4M Jo SUID} UI JOLAEYAG STI Jo aUuIOs UNE|dxD 0} a1qe
'23q .UpoYs am Ayo Uoseas ou aas | “op snok wos} suns ye Aus UOYAA
{op suewiny pur sjeusue yey Jo spadse wos ure|dxa Kau)
ang “Buyop st 41 yeyM Jo padse Arona urejdxo jou Ayaans jpm—BunypAue
quem pue smouy 3! #1 ‘S]UCM PU SMOL{ ainyeaId e yeYM—SuOSEAL ‘IE
BBYY -aBeyped fero1Aeyaq 19810] Jo jade} ajBuls auios ‘uoHuayye ayesedas
asap Jo Jayjo a\p 20 aUO YpIYAK ul siOTARYag °s
(68t 4 ‘0261 ony) , Beis ye4) 0} dn Aso4s1y feuaUIdojanap a4
jue ‘suorypuod (jeisKydorg pure feonuiayporg) feorBojorscyd ayy ‘Sanmede>
euoNpUR) sayy puE sauNy>RL}S POMWO,EUE Jo sAyEyS ayy x9qL0
uosiaua 303 a43 44 osye 3nq‘S}PaIqo BupeFmUITS JO UTAS a4 Aq uo you
pounuuiayap st suodsas Auona,, yey) ype pue spuey suo da sso. 0} But
a} saumauss st soLAeyaq s Jeurue 249 UI SpuELS ywasagHp asoyy ede
sea} 0} £3 ue, soypEY HaLafip se wzeus ay 3 UTE Ue AyHUDPI O} ‘ABO}EHS
sig quowiogduat oy yer ax ajgeua yey} siO}Pey aarmuo> ayy Aq. Ap
pue