Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E-mail: kpsurendran@niist.res.in
Abstract
In this paper, we investigated the simulation and fabrication of an E-shaped microstrip patch
antenna realized on multilayered polyester fabric suitable for WiMAX (Worldwide
Interoperability for Microwave Access) applications. The main challenges while designing a
textile antenna were to provide adequate thickness, surface uniformity and water wettability to
the textile substrate. Here, three layers of polyester fabric were stacked together in order to obtain
sufficient thickness, and were subsequently dip coated with polyvinyl butyral (PVB) solution.
The PVB-coated polyester fabric showed a hydrophobic nature with a contact angle of 91°. The
RMS roughness of the uncoated and PVB-coated polyester fabric was about 341 nm and 15 nm
respectively. The promising properties, such as their flexibility, light weight and cost
effectiveness, enable effortless integration of the proposed antenna into clothes like polyester
jackets. Simulated and measured results in terms of return loss as well as gain were showcased to
confirm the usefulness of the fabricated prototype. The fabricated antenna successfully operates
at 3.37 GHz with a return loss of 21 dB and a maximum measured gain of 3.6 dB.
Keywords: screen-printed textile antennas, dielectric, patch antenna, conductive ink
The stability of the geometrical dimension and superior performance of the screen printed textile antenna prototype,
dewetting property are additional requirements for textile such as the reflection coefficient and gain measurements, were
antennas [5]. In principle, a thicker substrate (up to a tenth of compared with the simulated ones.
the EM wavelength) with a low dielectric constant (εr
between 1 and 2) is a good choice for an antenna substrate
[6]. Polyester fabric is seen to be ideal among the fabric Experimental
materials available on the market because of its low dielectric
loss and moisture regain value (<0.4%) [7–10]. To enhance
Substrate preparation
the radiation efficiency of the conductive part of the textile
antenna, a protective coating is usually provided which can A commercial grade 100% pure polyester fabric was
diminish the surface roughness and also provide hydro- employed in the present investigation whose structure was
phobicity [11]. characterized by wide angle XRD (XEUSS SAXS/WAXS
Research on wearable electromagnetic antennas realized system) using a Genix Microsource from Xenocs operated at
on textile materials started in the early 21st century, where the 50 kV and 0.6 mA. In order to provide adequate thickness to
first report was from Salonen et al [12]. To date, a variety of the antenna substrate, three textile layers with two adhesive
fabrication techniques, such as weaving, embroidering, sheets were alternately stacked together using an isostatic
laminating, printing, etc, have been widely employed for lamination press (ILS-46, Haikutech, The Netherlands). The
developing textile antennas [13]. The super fine metal fila- adhesive films used here were polyacrylate-based sheets
ments or metal-coated polymer yarns can be woven into (IndiaMART, Mumbai) which provided very good adhesion
textile materials to develop antennas [13]. But these antennas between the polyester layers without significantly compro-
are unreliable since weaving may sometimes cause wrinkling mising their flexibility. In order to provide surface uniformity
of the textile material. Machine embroidering is another prior to the screen printing of the conductive layer, the mul-
successful technique to fabricate electronic circuits on textile tilayered textile material was dip coated (KSV NIMA Dip
substrates, but it offers high tension in the yarn which may Coaters) with 20 wt% polyvinyl butyral (PVB) (Butvar B-98,
adversely affect the quality of the circuit [14, 15]. In yet Sigma–Aldrich) in ethanol solution. Here, the coating was
another method, the antenna patterns can be easily laminated done at a withdrawal speed of 50 mm min−1 with five con-
on to the textile substrate using suitable polymer adhesives secutive dip steps at a dwell time of 1 min each. These con-
but the high dielectric loss factor caused by the adhesive may ditions are optimally sufficient enough to yield a flexible
also deteriorate the dielectric properties of the textile sub- uniform PVB-coated textile substrate. The microstructure of
strate. Besides, delamination of the conductive film occurs the textile material was studied using SEM (JEOL-JSM 5600
during bending which is not recommended for flexible LV, Tokyo, Japan). The surface roughness of the coated and
antennas. As a feasible practical solution, printing is sug- uncoated polyester fabric was analyzed using an AFM
gested as one of the most efficient and cost effective methods (Bruker Nano Inc., USA) operating in the tapping mode
of creating conductive patterns on different textile substrates regime. The wettability and contact angle of the modified
[14]. The screen printing technique, in particular, is highly surface of the substrate was measured through the sessile drop
recommended since it can simplify the fabrication of textile method using a Goniometer (OCA 20, Dataphysics,
antennas. The screen printing process consists of printing a Germany).
viscous conductive ink or paste through a patterned stencil
followed by a curing process depending on the substrate and
Antenna design and fabrication
the property of the ink used [4, 16].
WiMAX technologies, especially mobile WiMAX The dielectric properties of polyester textile along with other
(3.3 GHz), can significantly contribute to the field of E-health commercially available textile materials were characterized
(tele medicine applications), defense and environmental using a split post dielectric resonator (SPDR, QWED, Poland)
monitoring as it provides QoS, broadband remote access and operating at 5.155 GHz with the help of a vector network
intrinsic mobility support [17]. Our goal is to develop cost analyzer (8753ET, Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA) at
effective water-resistant wearable E-shaped antennas at room temperature (23 °C) and an approximate relative
3.3 GHz specifically for WiMAX applications [18, 19]. It humidity of around 73%. The results are tabulated in table 1.
should be noted that a variety of coats and jackets are made From the table, it is evident that the textile materials have very
using finely woven polyester fabric. Developing a WiMAX low dielectric constants in the range εr∼1.4–2.1. It should
antenna integrated on a thick polyester fabric is a promising be noted that the polyester fabric has a better dielectric
concept, since the antenna is flexible, light weight and robust. property with low dielectric loss among different commer-
To realize the proposed textile antenna, the conductive pattern cially available textile materials such as linen, cotton and silk.
was screen printed on a surface modified multilayered The dielectric property of the fabrics not only depends on the
polyester fabric. Polyester was selected as the antenna sub- type of material used, but is mainly influenced by the di-
strate due to its excellent dielectric characteristics and low electric behaviour of the fibres used in the fabric, yarn density
moisture regain values. The theoretical simulation of the and also weaving pattern [20, 21]. Furthermore, the adhesive
proposed polyester antenna was conducted by Ansys high polymer sheet used to glue the three polyester fabrics together
frequency structure simulator (HFSS) software. The radiation had only a marginal influence on the effective dielectric
2
Smart Mater. Struct. 26 (2017) 105011 S B Roshni et al
3
Smart Mater. Struct. 26 (2017) 105011 S B Roshni et al
Figure 4. SEM images of the surface of (a) uncoated polyester fabric and (b) PVB-coated polyester fabric and cross section of (c) uncoated
polyester fabric and (d) PVB-coated polyester fabric.
Figure 5. 3D view of tapping mode AFM image of (a) uncoated and (b) coated polyester fabric.
Figure 6. (a) Contact angle value of corresponding coated textile substrate and (b) water droplets sitting over the coated textile substrate.
4
Smart Mater. Struct. 26 (2017) 105011 S B Roshni et al
5
Smart Mater. Struct. 26 (2017) 105011 S B Roshni et al
Figure 9. (a) Simulated 3-dimensional radiation pattern and (b) simulated and measured gain of E-shaped antenna on polyester textile
substrate.
shift its resonant frequency to unnecessary low values [26]. A limits of experimental error. Marginal disagreements between
contact angle measurement can provide vital information the simulated and measured results may be due to inaccura-
regarding the degree of wettability when a solid and liquid cies in the fabrication process and may also be due to dif-
interact. In general, materials are classified into super ferences in the relative humidity conditions in the antenna
hydrophilic (θ<5°), hydrophilic (θ<90°), hydrophobic characterization and that of the material characterization
(θ=90°–150°) and super hydrophobic (θ=150°–180°) cabinet [11].
[27, 28]. We found that the uncoated fabric was hydrophilic An evaluation of antenna performance after undergoing
in nature where the water droplet was completely absorbed different bending cycles is critical for a wearable antenna
making the contact angle apparently 0°. The polyester fabric since worn fabrics which act as substrates to antennas are
after dip coating with PVB solution exhibited a hydrophobic subject to a lot of flexing and bending. In order to understand
nature with an observed contact angle of 91o, and is depicted the post flexing performance of an antenna, the antenna was
in figures 6(a) and (b). bent systematically along the E-plane and its return loss and
A prototype of the WiMAX patch antenna was simulated frequency were measured for a cycle of ten flexes. A plot of
using Ansoft HFSS software, screen printed on the novel the return loss versus frequency for different bending cycles is
substrate and then evaluated for the practicability of the plotted in figure 8. The variation of the central frequency of
proposed design. The simulated and measured reflection radiation and the return loss is also tabulated in table 3.
characteristics (S11) of the proposed E-shaped antenna are Evidently, even after several periodic bending cycles, the
depicted in figure 7. The return loss of the simulated antenna antenna showed an excellent impedance match with a return
is 19 dB at a frequency of 3.3 GHz whereas the fabricated loss of always less than −17 dB. No significant shift in center
antenna successfully radiated at 3.37 GHz with a return loss frequency was noted up to 100 bending cycles. Even though
of 21 dB. A reasonably good agreement was observed there was a small detuning in the center frequency, it is within
between the simulation and measurement results within the the intended frequency band [29, 30]. However, it is advised
6
Smart Mater. Struct. 26 (2017) 105011 S B Roshni et al
that the bending of an antenna along the E-plane should be measurements. The authors are also grateful to Dr P Prab-
avoided as it may affect its directional characteristics. hakar Rao and Mr M R Chandran for providing the SEM
The 3-dimensional radiation pattern of a simulated patch facilities, Dr Yoosaf Karuvath and Mr Aswin for AFM and Dr
antenna is shown in figure 9(a). An omnidirectional radiation E Bhoje Gowd for the WAXS measurement facilities.
pattern with a maximum gain of 5.34 dB is achieved. A plot
of the simulated and measured gain as a function of frequency
for the proposed antenna is illustrated in figure 9(b). The
fabricated textile antenna gives a maximum measured gain of References
3.6 dB at 3.37 GHz while the disparity between the measured
and simulated gain is not more than about −1.7 dB. Never- [1] Batchelor J C and Swaisaenyakorn S 2012 Antennas and
theless, the gain obtained by the newly designed E-shaped Propagation for Body-Centric Wireless Communications vol
antenna on polyester fabric is well above the requirement for 2 (Boston: Artech House)
practical wearable antenna applications. Photographs of the [2] Kaija T, Lilja J and Salonen P 2010 Exposing textile antennas
proposed screen printed textile antenna clearly show that the for harsh environment MILCOM Conf. Proc. pp 737–42
[3] Hertleer C, Rogier H, Vallozzi L and Van Langenhove L 2009
fabricated antenna has a high degree of flexibility (see A textile antenna for off-body communication integrated
figure 10). into protective clothing for firefighters IEEE Trans.
Antennas Propag. 57 919–25
[4] Stoppa M and Chiolerio A 2014 Wearable electronics and
Conclusion smart textiles: a critical review Sensors 14 11957–92
[5] Purohit S and Raval F 2013 A review on wearable-textile patch
antenna IJSER 4 696–702
An E-shaped microstrip patch antenna was designed and [6] Hertleer C, Tronquo A, Rogier H and Van Langenhove L 2008
fabricated on polyester fabric for WiMAX applications. In The use of textile materials to design wearable microstrip
order to examine the phase purity of the commercial polye- patch antennas Text. Res. J. 78 651–8
ster, WAXD analysis was conducted. The insufficient [7] Salvado R, Loss C, Gonçalves R and Pinho P 2012 Textile
materials for the design of wearable antennas: a survey
hydrophobicity and inadequate thickness of a single layer Sensors 12 15841–57
polyester fabric is too inferior for it to act as a substrate for [8] Roy B, Bhatterchya A K and Choudhury S K 2013
antenna applications. Hence three layers of polyester fabrics Characterization of textile substrate to design a textile
were hot pressed with polyacrylate sheets in between them, antenna ICMAP Conf. Proc. pp 1–5
which acted as an efficient adhesive. The effect of water [9] Sankaralingam S and Gupta B 2010 Development of textile
antennas for body wearable applications and investigations
absorption on the electromagnetic properties of the textile on their performance under bent conditions PIER. B 22
antenna was reduced to a greater extent by providing a 53–71
coating of PVB using the dip coating technique. This surface [10] Kazani I, Declercq F, Scarpello M L, Hertleer C, Rogier H,
modification was found to result in significant improvement Vande Ginste D, De Mey G, Guxho G and
in surface smoothness and hydrophobicity. A contact angle Van Langenhove L 2014 Performance study of screen-
printed textile antennas after repeated washing Autex Res. J.
measurement of the coated polyester fabric showed a hydro- 14 47–54
phobic nature with a contact angle of 91o. The proposed [11] Scarpello M L, Kazani I, Hertleer C, Rogier H and Ginste D V
E-shaped antenna was simulated using Ansys HFSS software. 2012 Stability and efficiency of screen-printed wearable and
In order to develop a stable operation of the textile antenna, a washable antennas IEEE Antennas Wireless Propag. Lett. 11
radiative patch and ground plane was screen printed on either 838–41
[12] Salonen P, Yang F, Rahmat-Samii Y and Kivikoski M 2004
side of the substrate using commercial silver ink. The fabri- WEBGA-wearable electromagnetic band-gap antenna IEEE
cated antenna successfully radiated at 3.37 GHz with a return AP-S Conf. Proc. pp 451–4
loss of −21 dB. The measured and simulated results match [13] Tsolis A, Whittow W G, Alexandridis A A and
well within the experimental error limits. The fabricated Vardaxoglou J C 2014 Embroidery and related
textile antenna gives a maximum measured gain of 3.6 dB and manufacturing techniques for wearable antennas: challenges
and opportunities Electronics 3 314–38
it is adequate for practical wearable electronic applications. [14] Roh J-S, Chi Y-S and Kang T J 2010 Wearable textile antennas
Since the fabricated antenna is thin, flexible and water resis- Int. J. Fashion Des. Tech. Edu. 3 135–53
tant, it can be easily integrated into new generation clothing [15] Gimpel S, Mohring U, Muller H, Neudeck A and Scheibner W
like jackets that can sense and communicate data in a non- 2004 Textile-based electronic substrate technology J. Ind.
intrusive way. Text. 33 179–89
[16] Khaleel H R, Al-Rizzo H M and Abbosh A I 2013
Advancement in Microstrip Antennas with Recent
Applications ed A Kishk (Rijeka: InTech) p 363
Acknowledgments [17] Katz M D and Fitzek F H P 2009 WiMAX Evolution: Emerging
Technologies and Applications 1st edn (New York: Wiley)
The authors are grateful for the financial support from the [18] Interconnect Communications, Spectrum for WiMAX in
Europe http://icc-uk.com/download/papers/Spectrum-for-
Department of Science and Technology, the Government of WiMAX-in-Europe.pdf (Accessed 17 July 2017)
India, New Delhi (Ref: SR/S2/CP-114/2012). The authors [19] IndiaMART, 3.3 GHz WiMAX LTE Solid Dish Antenna
thank Dr K Prabhakaran of the Indian Institute of Space http://indiamart.com/proddetail/3-3ghz-wimax-lte-solid-
Science and Technology, Trivandrum for the contact angle dish-antenna-2107734991.html (Accessed 17 July 2017)
7
Smart Mater. Struct. 26 (2017) 105011 S B Roshni et al
[20] Florin St. C M and Mustata A 2014 Dielectric behavior of [25] Hertleer C, Van Laere A, Rogier H and Van Langenhove L
some woven fabrics on the basis of natural cellulosic fibers 2009 Influence of relative humidity on textile antenna
Adv. Mater. Sci. Eng. 2014 216548 performance Text. Res. J. 80 177–83
[21] Bal K and Kothari V K 2009 Measurement of dielectric [26] Osman M A R, Abd Rahim M K, Azfar Abdullah M,
properties of textile materials and their applications Indian J. Samsuri N A, Zubir F and Kamardin K 2011 Design
Fibre Text. 34 191–9 implementation and performance of ultra-wideband textile
[22] Singh A K 2005 Advanced X-ray Techniques in Research and antenna PIER. B 27 307–25
Industry (India: IOS Press) [27] Nuraje N, Khan W S, Lei Y, Ceylan M and Asmatulu R 2013
[23] Abou-Elela S I, Ibrahim H S, Kamel M M and Gouda M 2014 Superhydrophobic electrospun nanofibers J. Mater. Chem. A
Application of nanometal oxides in situ in nonwoven 1 1929–46
polyester fabric for the removal of bacterial indicators of [28] Mahltig B and Böttcher H 2003 Modified silica sol coatings for
pollution from wastewater Sci. World J. 2014 950348 water-repellent textiles J. Sol-Gel Sci. Technol. 27 43–52
[24] Chauraya A, Whittow W G, Vardaxoglou J C, Li Y, Torah R, [29] Agneessens S and Rogier H 2014 Compact half diamond dual-
Yang K, Beeby S and Tudor J 2013 Inkjet printed dipole band textile HMSIW on-body antenna IEEE Trans.
antennas on textiles for wearable communications IET Antennas Propag. 62 2374–81
Microw. Antennas Propag. 7 760–7 [30] Zhu S and Langley R 2009 Dual-band wearable textile antenna
on an EBG substrate IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 57
926–93