Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/50255012
CITATIONS READS
4 2,310
7 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Lysimachos Papazoglou on 27 September 2015.
ABSTRACT
Sixty dogs underwent regional or unilateral mastectomies for the management
of mammary tumours. These were randomly allocated into three groups;
conventional mastectomy closure (with closed suction drainage), skin-only
closure (with closed suction drainage) and a conventional closure group
without any drain placement. Conventional mastectomy closure was with a
combination of absorbable sutures for dead space elimination and skin
sutures. On days one, six and 10 after surgery each incision was graded
according to a clinical scale. All dogs were re-examined one month after
surgery. Duration of surgery was significantly shorter in the group with skin
closure alone, compared to the conventional mastectomy closure groups with
drainage (P=0.014) or without (P=0.008). No significant differences were
found in respect of complications over time among the three closure
techniques. Drain presence or absence had no effect on the outcome.
[Papazoglou LG et al (2006) Aust Vet Practit 36:156]
156 — Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 — 156
MASTECTOMY INCISION CLOSURE
158 — Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 — 158
MASTECTOMY INCISION CLOSURE
TABLE 2. Surgical Data in 60 Mastectomies. Groups (n=20 each) were: CMC – conventional mastectomy closure; OSC –
skin-only closure; CNDC – conventional non-drain closure. Data are presented as mean ± SD.
Analgesia was provided with postoperative procedure, volume of fluid collected in the reservoir bag,
administration of pethidine (3-6mg/kg im) and fentanyl duration of drainage and duration of hospitalisation, as
(2-4µg/kg iv) or morphine (0.5-1 mg/kg im) and fentanyl well as to determine the effect of mastectomy site (right
(2-4µg/kg iv) for the first 24 hours. Caprofen13 (4 mg/kg vs. left) to the volume of fluid collected in the reservoir
iv) was administered 30 minutes before surgery followed bag in either group.
by 2mg/kg orally twice daily for four days. Cefazolin14 The Kruskal-Wallis test was also used to analyse the
(30mg/kg iv) was also administered pre-operatively. effect of mastectomy type (regional vs. unilateral) to the
Dogs were observed closely in the immediate post- volume of fluid collected in the reservoir bag in either
operative period and discharged from the hospital from group. The number of dogs per clinical grade on Days 1,
the first to fourth post-operative day. 6 and 10 were analysed using Pearson chi-square test and
All dogs were re-examined for incisional complications Friedman test to determine any differences among or
one month after surgery. within groups, respectively. Values of P<0.05 were
considered significant.
Data recorded during the process included age, weight,
site of mastectomy (right vs. left), type of mastectomy RESULTS
(regional 3-5, regional 4-5 and unilateral), length of Clinical parameters of dogs of all groups are presented in
incision, duration of surgical procedure (from skin Table 2. There were no significant differences regarding
incision to skin closure), volume of fluid collected in the age (P=0.428) and weight (P=0.286) among groups.
reservoir bag, clinical grade of incision, histologic type Overall, 34 dogs had left site and 26 dogs had right site
of the tumour, duration of drainage and duration of mastectomies. Thirty-five dogs had regional mastectomy
hospitalisation. of glands 3-5, 15 of glands 4-5 and 10 had unilateral
mastectomies (Table 3). Mastectomy types had a homo-
Data are presented as mean ± standard deviation (SD). geneous distribution among the groups (P=0.08). No
Kruskal-Wallis statistics were performed to compare differences were found among groups regarding length
differences among groups in age, weight, and length of of incision (P=0.746). Duration of surgical procedure
incision and to detect homogenous distribution of the was shorter in OSC compared to CMC (P=0.014) and to
mastectomy type among the groups. CNDC (P=0.008) but no difference was present between
The Mann-Whitney test was performed to compare groups CMC and CNDC (P=1). No differences were
differences among the groups in duration of surgical determined for volume of fluid collected in the reservoir
bag (P=0.127) and duration of drainage (P=0.527)
between groups CMC and OSC. Duration of hospital-
13Rimadyl, Pfizer isation was not different between groups CMC and OSC
14Vifazolin, Vianex, Greece (P=0.973), but was shorter for group CNDC, compared
159 — Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 — 159
MASTECTOMY INCISION CLOSURE
TABLE 4. Clinical Grades after Mastectomy. Groups (20 each) were: CMC – conventional mastectomy closure; OSC – skin-
only closure; CNDC – conventional non-drain closure. Clinical grades modified from Freeman et al 1987.
160 — Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 — 160
MASTECTOMY INCISION CLOSURE
may be minimised by following Halsted’s principles: BRODEY, RS, GOLDSCMIDT, MH & ROSZEL, JR (1983) Canine
careful tissue handling, dead space obliteration and mammary gland neoplasms, J Am Anim Hosp Assoc 19:61
CHANG, SC, CHANG, CC, CHANG, TJ & WONG, ML (2005)
meticulous haemostasis (Mason 1993). Prognostic factors associated with survival two years after
surgery in dogs with malignant mammary tumors: 79 cases
In a human study, reporting the effect of dead space (1998-2002), J Am Vet Med Assoc 227:1625
closure on seroma formation after mastectomy, it was COVENEY, EC, O’DWYER, PJ, GERAGHTY, JC & O’HIGGINS,
found that closed suction drainage was significantly less NJ (1993) Effect of closing dead space on seroma formation
after mastectomy – a prospective randomized clinical trial, Eur
compared to the control group; dead space was J Surg Oncol 19:143
decreased in the group that had flaps sutured to under- DORN, CR, TAYLOR, DN, FYRE, FL & HIBBARD, HH (1968)
lying muscle and fewer patients in this group developed Survey of animal neoplasms in Alameda and Contra Costa
Counties, California. I. Methodology and description of cases,
seromas (Coveney et al 1993). In the present study, dead J Nat Cancer Inst 40:295
space was minimised by using closed suction drainage FOSSUM, TW (1997) Small Animal Surgery, p539, Mosby, St
units (group OSC), a combination of tacking sutures and Louis
FOX, JW & GOLDEN, GT (1976) The use of drains in
closed suction drainage units (group CMC) or tacking subcutaneous surgical procedures, Am J Surg 132:673
sutures alone (group CNDC). Drains may themselves FREEMAN, LJ, PETTIT, GD, ROBINETTE, JD, LINCOLN, JD &
incite fluid formation, depending on the size of the drain PERSON, MW (1987) Tissue reaction to suture material in the
feline linea alba. A retrospective, prospective, and histologic
and the size of the wound. As much as 50mL of fluid study, Vet Surg 16:440
production can be caused over time by the presence of a HARVEY, HJ (1998) Current Techniques in Small Animal Surgery,
drain in a large subcutaneous wound (Fox & Golden Ed Bojrab, 4th edn, p579, Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia
1976, Lee et al 1986). KITCHELL, BE (1995) Kirk’s Current Veterinary Therapy XII, Ed
Bonagura, p1098, Saunders, Philadelphia.
In the present study, in order to identify the necessity of LEE, AH, SWAIM, SF & HENDERSON, RA (1986) Surgical
Drainage, Comp Cont Educ Pract Vet 8:94
drainage in mastectomy incisions and the effect of the MASON, LK (1993) Surgical Complications and Wound Healing in
drain on fluid formation a group that had the the Small Animal Practice, Ed Harari, p33, Saunders,
conventional technique without drain placement was Philadelphia
MacEWEN, EG, HARVEY, HJ & PATNAIK, AK (1985) Evaluation
included and comparisons among groups CMC, OSC of effects of levamisole and surgery on canine mammary
and CNDC were performed. The findings of the present cancer, J Biol Response Mod 4:418
study support the view that when the conventional MISDORP, W, ELSE, R & LIPSCOMB, T (1999) Histological
Classification of Mammary Tumors of the Dog and Cat, p11,
technique is used for mastectomy closure, and provided Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, Washington DC
that Halsted’s principles are followed, placement of a MORRIS, JS, DOBSON, JM, BOSTOCK, DE & O’FARRELL, E
drain is not necessary. (1998) Effect of ovariohysterectomy in bitches with mammary
neoplasms, Vet Rec 142:656
Serious incisional complications were seen in very few PAVLETIC, MM (1999) Atlas of Small Animal Reconstructive
Surgery, 2nd edn, p41, Saunders, Philadelphia
dogs of all groups of this study. However, the seroma PHILIBERT, JC, SNYDER, PW, GLICKMAN, N, GLICKMAN, LT,
formation that developed, on Day 10 in one dog of group KNAPP, DW & WATER, DJ (2003) Influence of host factors on
CMC, might be attributed to inadequate drainage, survival in dogs with malignant mammary gland tumors, J Vet
possibly because of premature discontinuation of the Intern Med 17:102
RUTTEMAN, GR, WITHROW, SJ & MacEWEN, EG (2002) Small
drain or its obstruction. In addition, the seroma Animal Clinical Oncology, Eds Withrow & MacEwen, 3rd edn,
formation that developed on Day 10 in two dogs of group p455, Saunders, Philadelphia
CNDC might have been caused by inadequate dead SCHNEIDER, R, DORN, CR & TAYLOR, DN (1969) Factors
influencing canine mammary cancer development and
space elimination and not the lack of drainage. postsurgical survival, J Nat Cancer Inst 43:1249
Moreover, the dehiscence that developed at the caudal SOREMNO, KU, SHOFER, FS & GOLDSCHMIDT, MH (2000)
end of the incision in one dog from group OSC might be Effect of spaying and timing of spaying on survival of dogs
with mammary carcinoma, J Vet Intern Med 14:266
attributed to an increased tension in the inguinal region. STONE, EA (2000) Saunders Manual of Small Animal Practice,
Duration of hospitalisation was significantly shorter for Eds Birchard & Sherding, 2nd edn, p222, Saunders,
dogs of group CNDC compared to the other groups and Philadelphia
SWAIM, SF (1976) A “walking” suture technique for closure of
this might be attributed to the absence of management large skin defects in the dog and cat, J Am Anim Hosp Assoc
issues associated with wound dressing and drain in this 12:597
group compared to groups CMC and OSC. SWAIM, SF (1980) Management of skin tension in dermal surgery,
Comp Cont Educ Pract Vet 2:758
In conclusion, in terms of surgical time, closure of SWAIM, SF & HENDERSON, RA (1997) Small Animal Wound
mastectomy incisions with skin apposition alone, Mangement, 2nd edn, p387, Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore
TAYLOR, GN, SAHESTARI, L, WILLIAMS, J, MAYS, WA &
combined with a closed drainage device, was superior to McFARLAND, S (1976) Mammary neoplasia in a closed
conventional closure techniques. Drain placement or beagle colony, Cancer Res 36:2740
absence of drain had no effect on the outcome. WALDRON, DR (2001) Diagnosis and surgical management of
mammary neoplasia in dogs and cats, Vet Med 96:943
WHITE, RAS (2003) Textbook of Small Animal Surgery, Ed Slatter,
REFERENCES 3rd edn, p339, Saunders, Philadelphia
ALLEN, SW & MAHAFFEY, EA (1989) Canine mammary WILSON, GP & HAYES, HM (1983) Current Techniques in Small
neoplasia: prognostic indicators and response to surgical Animal Surgery, Ed Bojrab, 2nd edn, p414, Lea & Febiger,
therapy, J Am Anim Hosp Assoc 25:540 Philadelphia
BIRCHARD, SJ (1995) Kirk’s Current Veterinary Therapy XII, Ed WITHROW, SJ (1975) Surgical management of canine mammary
Bonagura, p462, Saunders, Philadelphia tumors, Vet Clin Nth Am 5:495
BRIGHT, RM & ABERLE, S (1979) Mammary Neoplasia, Comp YAMAGAMI, T, KOBAYASHI, T, TAKAHASHI, K & SUGIYAMA, M
Cont Educ Pract Vet 1:774 (1996) Influence of ovariectomy at the time of mastectomy on
BRIGHT, RM & PROBST, CW (1985) Textbook of Small Animal the prognosis for canine malignant mammary tumours, J Small
Surgery, Ed Slatter, p431, Saunders, Philadelphia Anim Pract 37:462
162 — Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 Aust Vet Practit 36(4) December 2006 — 162