News Media Publications Job Board CME/CE Partners Resources Subscribe

ADHD | Addiction & Substance Use | Anxiety & Stress Disorders | Bipolar Disorder | Bipolar I Disorder | COVID-19 | Cannabis | Case Discussions | Comorbidity View All >>

SPOTLIGHT- Expert Perspectives on the Unmet Needs in the Management of Major Depressive Disorder | Novel Delivery Systems Utilized in the Treatment of Adult ADHD

Psychiatry’s New Brain-Mind and the Legend of the “Chemical Imbalance”

Jul 11, 2011
Ronald W. Pies, MD

The legend of the “chemical imbalance” should be consigned to the dust-bin of ill-informed and malicious caricatures.

“Everything should be made as simple as possible, but no simpler.”

Recent Content
      -attributed to Albert Einstein (probably a paraphrase)
The Week in Review: June 19-
23
“Mind and body do not act upon each other, because they are not other, they are one.”

     -Philosopher Will Durant, on Spinoza’s monism1 Psychiatry Comic: Gone Mad

I am not one who easily loses his temper, but I confess to experiencing markedly increased limbic activity whenever I hear
someone proclaim, “Psychiatrists think all mental disorders are due to a chemical imbalance!” In the past 30 years, I don’t Too Tired for More: How Best to
Treat Multifactorial Fatigue
believe I have ever heard a knowledgeable, well-trained psychiatrist make such a preposterous claim, except perhaps to
mock it. On the other hand, the “chemical imbalance” trope has been tossed around a great deal by opponents of
Border Boy
2
psychiatry, who mendaciously attribute the phrase to psychiatrists themselves. And, yes-the “chemical imbalance” image
has been vigorously promoted by some pharmaceutical companies, often to the detriment of our patients’ understanding.3
In truth, the “chemical imbalance” notion was always a kind of urban legend- - never a theory seriously propounded by View More Recent Content

well-informed psychiatrists.

Fortunately, recent advances in cognitive psychology and neuroscience are now converging, with the result that psychiatry
may be on the brink of a unified model of so-called mental illness. (The term itself, as we shall see, is belied by the new
research). As described at the APA’s 2011 annual meeting by NIMH Director Thomas Insel, MD, neuropsychiatric research is
pointing to a complex interplay between factors traditionally dichotomized as “biological” and “psychosocial”.4

As Insel describes the new model, conditions such as schizophrenia or bipolar disorder are attributable to rare, but highly
potent, genetic variations that lead to dysfunction in multiple, complex brain circuits. However, the particular symptomatic
manifestations in a given individual--the disease phenotype-is partly dependent on the person’s experiences and
environment. We may hypothesize (and this is my view, not necessarily Dr. Insel’s) that given developmentally-based
“biases” in various neurocircuits, the young boy or girl may be predisposed to the use of certain dysfunctional cognitive
strategies; for example, viewing everyone in the environment as uniformly threatening or “rejecting.” These tendencies
could easily be exacerbated by, say, childhood traumata or parental neglect.

We can imagine that the “irrational cognitions” so prized by cognitive therapists may develop on this abnormal, biogenetic
substrate, and eventually become woven into the very fabric of the individual’s personality and world-view. Thus, rather
than remain ensnared by the terms “mind” or “brain”, we would be better served by what Dr. Dan Stein calls, the “brain-
mind.” Indeed, “…the two constructs are, in fact, impossible to disentangle.”5 This is essentially what the philosopher
Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677) argued more than three centuries ago: “mind” and “brain” are not two substances, but one-
variously understood in “mental” terms for some purposes, and in “physical” terms, for others.  And, as Dr. Stein observes,
the brain-mind “. . .is not a computational, apart-from-the-world, passive reflector, but rather a thinking-feeling-actor-in-
the-world…"5

In short, we cannot afford to view our patients’ afflictions in the balkanized terms of “mental” vs. “physical”, “mind” vs.
“body”, “psyche” vs. “soma”. Neither can we afford the luxury of supposing that only one type of treatment-medication or
psychotherapy-will be effective for the illnesses we treat. On the contrary, the best available evidence suggests that each
modality, or their synergistic combination, may be effective-depending on the specific illness.  To be sure, as my colleague,
Nassir Ghaemi MD, has cautioned, we must not be drawn into a haze of promiscuous eclecticism in our treatment; rather,
we must be guided by well-designed studies and the best available evidence.6 Nonetheless, there is room in our work for
both motives and molecules, poetry and pharmacology. The legend of the “chemical imbalance” should be consigned to
the dust-bin of ill-informed and malicious caricatures. Psychiatry must now confront the mysteries and miseries of the
brain-mind.

References:
1. Durant W. The Story of Philosophy. New York: Pocket Books;1953.
2. See, eg, “The cornerstone of psychiatry’s disease model today is the theory that a brain-based, chemical imbalance
causes mental illness.”

3. Lacasse JR, Leo J. Serotonin and Depression: A Disconnect between the Advertisements and the Scientific Literature.
PLoS Med. 2005; 2(12): e392. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0020392
4. Moran M. Brain, Gene Discoveries Drive New Concept of Mental Illness. Psychiatric News. June 17, 2011.
5. Stein DJ. Philosophy of Psychopharmacology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2008: x.
6. Ghaemi SN. The Rise and Fall of the Biopsychosocial Model: Reconciling Art and Science in Psychiatry. Baltimore: Johns
Hopkins University Press; 2009.

Related Videos

Early Intervention Strategies Clinical Insights Regarding the Clinical Impressions From the Case Presentation: A 23-Year- Takeaways for Bipolar Disorder
for Bipolar Disorder: Identifying Management of Bipolar Patient Case Old With Bipolar Disorder Management
Warning Signs Disorder

Related Content

Couch in Crisis | Bipolar Disorder | Schizophrenia/Psychosis

The Week in Review: June 19- A Forensic Psychiatrist Takes

23 the Stand
June 24th 2023 September 28th 2021
Article Podcast

Clozapine-Induced Weight Treating ‘Morally

Gain: Is It Dependent on Dose? Objectionable’ Patients
June 20th 2023 September 27th 2021
Article Podcast

rTMS and Bipolar Depression: The Week in Review: June 12-

Predicting Clinical Response 16
June 18th 2023 June 17th 2023
Article Article

Contact Info
Advertise Contact Us Editorial
2 Clarke Drive
Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy Do Not Sell My Personal Cranbury, NJ 08512
Information
609-716-7777

© 2023 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.