Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TextoFinal - Rio Oil Conference 2016 - 24 - 05 - 2016 - Final
TextoFinal - Rio Oil Conference 2016 - 24 - 05 - 2016 - Final
Abstract
Biocorrosion or Microbial Induced Corrosion (MIC) is a process caused by anaerobic microorganisms, especially
sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB). Checking the presence and concentration of these microorganisms is part of the
preventive measures routine against corrosion in several stages of oil and gas exploitation. In this article, the
development process of an impedimetric biosensor to rapidly detect SRB using specific antibody is described. The
target is the APS-reductase enzyme, which is involved in the biocorrosion process and presents common characteristics
into the SRB group, allowing the indirect detection and quantification of SRB. Specific monoclonal and polyclonal
antibodies were successfully obtained after animal immunization using a synthetic peptide as antigen, which is
representative of APS-reductase enzyme. Both monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies (anti APS-reductase) proved to be
SRB specific by Dot Immuno Binding Assay (DIBA). Monoclonal antibodies anti APS-reductase was immobilized in
commercial Screen-Printed Electrodes (SPE), which were first modified at the surface by a self-assembled monolayer
(SAM) technology using cysteamine coupling. Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) was selected as the
analytical tool for evaluating the biosensor performance. Results have shown that this type of sensor is suitable to detect
different antigen (APS-reductase synthetic peptide) concentration. At this point, anti APS-reductase biosensors are being
prepared to be tested with SRB lysate from pure culture and from SRB field sample. Main challenges are related to
ensure repeatability of results using commercially available SPEs, and also to overcome possible interferences present in
field samples.
Resumo
Biocorrosão ou corrosão induzida por microrganismos (Microbial Induced Corrosion – MIC) é um processo causado
por microrganismos anaeróbios, especialmente bactérias redutoras de sulfato (BRS). O monitoramento da presença e da
concentração destes microrganismos auxilia na determinação de medidas para a prevenção da corrosão em vários
estágios da exploração de petróleo e gás. Neste artigo, o processo de desenvolvimento de um biossensor impedimétrico
para a detecção acelerada de BRS usando anticorpos específicos é descrito. O alvo da detecção é a enzima APS-
redutase, a qual está envolvida no processo de biocorrosão e apresenta características comuns ao grupo das BRS,
permitindo a detecção indireta e até mesmo a quantificação de BRS. Anticorpos monoclonais e policlonais específicos
para a detecção de BRS foram obtidos com sucesso após imunização de animais utilizando como antígeno um peptídeo
sintético representativo da enzima APS-redutase. Ambos os tipos de anticorpos, monoclonal e policlonal (anti APS-
redutase), provaram especificidade para as BRS por meio do teste DIBA (Dot Immuno Binding Assay). Os anticorpos
do tipo monoclonal anti APS-redutase foram imobilizados na superfície de eletrodos impressos (Screen-Printed
Electrodes – SPE), previamente modificada pela tecnologia de formação de monocamadas auto-organizadas (Self-
1
Ph.D., Biologist – Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – IPT/SP
2
M.Sc., Biologist – Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – IPT/SP
3
Ph.D., Biochemist – Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – IPT/SP
4
Ph.D., Materials Engineer – Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – IPT/SP
5
Ph.D., Electrical Engineer – Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – IPT/SP
6
Chemical Technician – Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – IPT/SP
7
Clinical Analysis Technician – Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – IPT/SP
8
B.Sc., Pharmaceutic – Hospital das Clínicas /SP
9
Undergraduate Student, Pharmaceutic – Fundação do Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – FIPT/SP
10
Ph.D., Mechanical Engineer – Instituto de Pesquisas Tecnológicas – IPT/SP
Rio Oil & Gas Expo and Conference 2016
Assembled Monolayer – SAM) usando cisteamina para acoplamento do anticorpo. Espectroscopia eletroquímica de
impedância foi a ferramenta analítica selecionada para avaliação do desempenho do biossensor. Os resultados mostram
que o biossensor é capaz de detectar diferentes concentrações de antígeno (peptídeo sintético da APS-redutase). No
momento, os dispositivos biossensores anti-APS estão sendo preparados para testes com lisados de culturas puras de
BRS e com BRS provenientes de amostras de campo. Os principais desafios estão relacionados à garantia da
repetitividade dos resultados utilizando SPEs disponíveis comercialmente, e também a superar possíveis interferências
em amostras de campo.
1. Introduction
1.1. Problem characterization
Prevention of corrosion processes has fundamental importance to the oil industry, since the costs related to
such events result in additional spending on petroleum exploitation, transportation and refining. Critical problems come
from microbial induced corrosion (MIC), caused by anaerobic microorganisms (Muyzer & Stams; 2008).
An important group of microorganisms involved in most of the biocorrosion cases are the sulfate reducing
prokaryotes (SRP), conventionally known as sulfate reducing bacteria (SRB), which occur in aqueous environments in
the absence of oxygen. The hydrogen sulfide (H2S), produced as a metabolite from the sulfate to sulfide reduction
process, contaminates gas and stored oil, precipitates ferrous sulfide found at injection wells and promotes corrosion.
Therefore, the risk of corrosion can be directly associated with the concentration of these microorganisms (SRB) present
in the environment. SRB detection and quantification during the oil extraction, storage and transportation, as well as
during oil products processing, is an important task, since the result will define the routine of preventive measures,
which includes the use of PIG (Pipeline Inspection Gauge) cleaning and biocides application.
In general, conventional methods for monitoring the SRB population are based on the estimation of the most
probable number (MPN) of microorganisms, determined after a growth step in multiple tubes with selective medium,
which needs about 28 days of incubation. The extended growth time does not allow the application of an immediate
corrective action against the biological corrosion process. Moreover, the method is dependent on the operator ability for
sample processing, inoculation, and analysis of results, which is based on visual observation of a black precipitate,
mainly represented by ferric sulfide resulting from microbial metabolism.
Therefore, more effective, accurate and fast measuring methods are being studied. Technologies involving
immunoassays using antibodies against conserved proteins could allow high sensitivity and selectivity for the detection
of SRB. Such approach has been already explored by some research groups, leading to the development of commercial
kits (Modernwater, 2012, Saniv Check, 2007, Strategic Diagnostics Inc., 2005).
The technique of Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) is an analytical tool extensively used in
corrosion studies (Wang et al, 2014), characterization of charge transport through membranes (Montalvillo et al, 2014),
development of batteries ( Noack et al, 2014), and its usefulness in detecting interfacial events is known for over two
decades (K'Owino, et al, 2005). Recently, the development of biosensors and the integrated use of EIS are becoming
more common as a potential solution to contribute in these monitoring processes (Wan et al, 2009; 2010).
1.2. Biosensor
A biosensor is an analytical tool used for the detection and/or quantification of biochemical elements, and is
characterized by the presence of a biological component, as a recognition molecule, fixed on the surface of a transducer.
This latter generates a signal proportional to the intensity of the reaction in course on its surface, when in contact to the
sample containing the element to be detected, i.e., the target (Nirsch et al, 2011 & Collings et al, 1997).
The recognition molecules may be enzymes, cellular receptors, antibodies, DNA sequences, microorganisms,
cells/tissues of animals or plants (Daniels et al. 2007).
According to the type of signal transducer, a biosensor may be electrochemical (impedimetric, potentiometric,
potentiometric by stripping, amperometric or conductimetric), acoustic (surface acoustic wave, quartz microbalances
and piezo-electric acoustic elements), optical or colorimetric (absorbance, chemiluminescence, SPR - Surface Plasmon
Resonance, optical fibers) and thermal, among others (Collings et al, 1997 & Sua et al, 2011).
2
Rio Oil & Gas Expo and Conference 2016
Commercial Interdigital Electrodes (IDEs) from Dropsens, G-IDEAU5, have been chosen as the transducer.
They are composed of two connection tracks, all made of gold/chrome sputtered on a glass substrate, with bands/gaps of
5 μm, number of digits of 250 x 2 and digit length of 6760 μm.
The IDE is connected to a potentiostat AUTOLAB / PGSTAT302N with frequency analyzer suitable to
perform Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS). Gold electrodes are already used for the immobilization of
enzymes and antibodies. IDEs offer advantages, such as, increased sensitivity, fast dynamic response, high aspect ratio,
and also increased signal to noise ratio for impedimetric measurements using impedance spectroscopy (Wang et al,
2012).
2. Experimental
2.1. Antibody production
Monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies anti APS-reductase were obtained from immunized animals against a
synthetic peptide representing a consensus sequence of APS-reductase from SRB group. The structure of the synthetic
peptide was determined from the characteristics of the target enzyme. Using a preliminary alignment, the antibodies
supplier (Rheabiotch) employed appropriate software and selected the most promising amino acid sequence. The chosen
sequence was synthesized, resulting in a 24 amino acid peptide (Rheabiotch). Polyclonal antibodies were obtained after
IgG purification of serum from immunized rabbits and monoclonal antibodies were obtained by hybridoma technique
using cells from immunized mouse. Monoclonal antibody secreted by hybridoma was purified from culture supernatant.
3
Rio Oil & Gas Expo and Conference 2016
biosensor was treated with 2% of BSA-PBS solution for 2 hours, under agitation at 37°C, to block the nonspecific sites.
Then, the electrodes were washed with PBS and immediately used.
Polyclonal antibodies usually have greater affinity for the target molecule than monoclonal antibodies. On the
other hand, their production is dependent on the provided immunization of animals, so each new batch produced can be
different from the previous one, resulting in non-reproducibility of the experiments. Despite the restricted recognition of
a small and unique target fragment, monoclonal antibodies have the advantage of being suitable for continuous
production in laboratory through cultivation of antibody secreting hybridoma cells (Roitt &Delves, 2001). Here,
monoclonal antibody anti APS-reductase was applied to detect SRB at impedimetric biosensor. This is the first report of
monoclonal antibodies being explored for SRB recognition and detection as well as used to construct a sensor device.
Impedance results for modified surfaces in the presence of Fe(CN)63-/ Fe(CN)64- redox couple in phosphate
buffer solution, exposed to different antigen (APS-reductase synthetic peptide) concentrations ranging from 0.8 µg/mL
to 4.0 µg/mL, is shown is Figure 2. A significant change in the semicircle diameter in the Nyquist plot, and hence in the
charge transfer resistance (Rct), was observed at each step of the interface fabrication (results not reported here),
considering the bare state conditions, including the SAM formation, and the antibody immobilization step.
4
Rio Oil & Gas Expo and Conference 2016
1:2500
1:500
1:1500
The charge transfer resistance corresponding to the situation in which the SAM is already formed and the
antibody is immobilized on the surface is designated as Rct(0), as presented in Figure 3. A further increase in Rct was also
observed after the subsequent exposition and resultant attachment of different concentrations of the antigen APS-
reductase synthetic peptide. This increase of the charge transfer resistance may be justified based on a barrier effect that
hinders the ability of the redox molecule from accessing the electrode surface. The Randles circuit used to fit the
Nyquist plot, includes the solution resistance (Rs), the charge transfer resistance (Rct), the double layer capacitance,
treated as a constant phase element impedance (Cdl) indicating the depressed semi-circle obtained, and the Warburg
impedance element (Zw) which is the consequence of the ionic diffusion from the bulk of the electrolyte to the electrode
interface. Results indicated that the Rct is a suitable signal for sensing the interfacial properties of the prepared biosensor
during all the assembly procedures.
Figure 3. The Randles equivalent circuit for the impedance spectroscopy measurement and the respective
experimentally determined charge transfer resistance (Rct) using APS-reductase synthetic peptide as antigen.
A more diluted sample containing a 0,8 µg/mL (1:2500) antigen concentration resulted in 50% increase of
the experimentally determined charge transfer resistance once compared to the surface modification represented by the
adsorbed SAM and immobilized antibody. Incubating the surface in a solution of 1.3 µg/mL (1:1500) resulted in only
30% increase in reference to Rct(0). These limited results indicate that once increasing the concentration of the antigen, a
progressive reduction of charge transfer resistance was evidenced. Once increasing the concentration to 4,0 µg/mL
(1:500) the relative Rct variation is almost negligible, corresponding approximately to 0.8%.
In order to compare the different electrode performance when exposed to different antigen concentrations in
a quantitative base, the relative values ([(Rct(i)-Rct(0)]/Rct(0)) were used as the argument function for the y axis. Rct(i) is the
charge transfer resistance of the modified surface after reaction with antibodies for predefined period of time. Despite
the limited concentration range studied in the present work and also the limited number of experimental points analyzed,
preliminary results indicate that the sensing interface can detect APS-reductase synthetic peptides with a promising
potential to be used as a quantitative analytical tool for SRB determination.
5
Rio Oil & Gas Expo and Conference 2016
Although a linear relationship between the electron transfer resistance and the APS synthetic peptide
concentration was found (R2 factor is approximately 94% in Figure 4), it is highly recommended to expand the
concentration range and also to include other experimental data to ensure that the linear fit is valid.
Several authors, such as Shervedani et al. (2006), cite the equation Rct=RT·(n2·F2·A·kct·[S])-1 to explain the
relation between bulk concentration of the redox probe and charge transfer resistance, where R is the ideal gas constant,
T is the absolute temperature, n is the number of transferred electrons per one molecule of the redox probe, F is the
faraday constant, A is geometric surface area of the electrode (cm2), kct is potential dependent charge transfer rate
constant and [S] corresponds to the concentration of the redox probe (mol/cm3). By applying a simplification to the
presented equation, one may replace [S]=k1·[analyte], where k1 is a constant. If all other parameters are set constant, a
linear relationship as 1/Rct=k·[analyte] is simply found, in which k includes all constants. As a function of this, a
calibration plot represented by 1/Rct=f(concentration) is proposed and widely used. The option to use relative values
([(Rct(i)-Rct(0)]/Rct(0)) as done in this work and supported by Liu et al.(2012) appears as an alternative to overcome
reproducibility problems concerning the variability of Rct(0) typical of commercially available sensing platforms
represented by disposable screen-printed electrodes from a single production batch. This critical issue is severely
discussed by Kadara et al. (2009) and still represents a challenge to enable a laboratory development to turn into a
commercial product.
Further studies will be conducted with a focus on improving repeatability of the developed device. Future
challenges are also related to overcome possible interferences inherent to field samples.
4. Conclusion
In this work monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies (anti-APS) were obtained using as antigen a synthetic
peptide representative of APS-reductase enzyme, common to the target microbial group (SRB). Both types of antibodies
showed reaction against the tested antigen and specificity to SRB group. Impedimetric immunosensor was developed by
immobilizing anti-APS antibodies on self-assembled cysteamine monolayers via covalent coupling on commercial
screen-printed electrodes (SPE). Immunosensor test results are preliminaries but it is possible to show that the antibody
was properly immobilized and impedimetric measures are proportional to different antigen (APS-peptide synthetic)
concentration. This result indicates that the immunosensor can detect APS reductase enzyme present in SRB lysate in a
rapid way. This technique represents a promising alternative to the traditional MPN method for a rapid monitoring of
microbial populations involved in biocorrosion, thus supporting the faster application of preventive measures.
5. Acknowledgments
The authors thank Professor Hideko Yamanaka and Dr. Antônio Pupim Ferreira from the Institute of Chemistry at
Unesp-Araraquara for the contribution on the sensor preparation, and IPT/FIPT/Governo do Estado de São Paulo for the
financial support.
6
Rio Oil & Gas Expo and Conference 2016
6. References
COLLINGS A. F. & CARUSO F., Biosensors: recent advances, Reports on Progress in Physics, V. 60, N. 11, p. 1397-
1445, 1997.
DANIELS J. S. POURMAND N., Label-Free Impedance Biosensors: Opportunities and Challenges, Electroanalysis,
v. 19, n. 12, p. 1239 – 1257, 2007.
KADARA, R. O., JENKINSON, N., BANKS, C. E. Characterization of commercially available electrochemical sensing
platforms. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical, v. 138, p. 556-562, 2009.
K'OWINO IO, SADIK OA, Impedance Spectroscopy: A Powerful Tool for Rapid Biomolecular Screening and Cell
Culture Monitoring. Electroanalysis, v. 17, p. 2101-2113, 2005.
LIU, G., IYENGAR, S. G., GOODING, J. J. An electrochemical impedance immunosensor based on gold nanoparticle-
modified electrodes for the detection of HbA1c in human blood. Electroanalysis, v. 24, n. 7, p. 1509-1516, 2012.
MODERNWATER. QuickCheck - Detection of SRB via a rapid enzyme immunoassay method. Guildford:
ModernWater, 2012. 2 p. (Catalog).
MONTALVILLO M, SILVA V, PALACIO L, CALVO JI, CARMONA FJ. Charge and dielectric characterization of
nanofiltration membranes by impedance spectroscopy. Journal of Membrane Science, v. 454, p. 163-173, 2014.
MUYZER, G., STAMS, A. J. M. The ecology and biotechnology of sulphate-reducing bacteria. Nature reviews.
Microbiology, v. 6, n. 6, p. 441-54, 2008.
NIRSCH M., REUTER F.& VÖRÖS J., Review of Transducer Principles for Label-Free Biomolecular Interaction
Analysis, Biosensors, v. 1, p. 70-92, 2011.
NOACK J, CREMERS C, BAYER D, TÜBKE J, PINKWART K. Development and characterization of a 280 cm2
vanadium/oxygen fuel cell. Journal of Power Sources, v. 253, p. 397-403, 2014.
ROITH, M.I. & DELVES, P.J. Essential Immunology, Tenth edition. Blackwell Publishy, 2001.
SANIV CHECK. SRB. Test sytems for counting sulfate reducing bacteria. Warren: Biosan Laboratories, 2007. 1 p.
(Catalog).
SHERVEDANI, R. K., MEHRJARDI, A. H., ZAMIRI, N. A novel method for glucose determination based on
electrochemical impedance spectroscopy using glucose oxidase self-assembled biosensor. Bioelectrochemistry, v.
69, p. 201-208, 2006.
SUA L., JIAA W., HOUB CH. &LEI Y., Microbial biosensors: A review, Biosensors and Bioelectronics, v. 26, p.
1788–1799, 2011.
STRATEGIC DIAGNOSTICS INC. RapidCheek - SRB Detection System. Newark: SDIX, 2005. 5 p. (Catalog).
WAN Y., ZHANG D., HOU B., Monitoring microbial populations of sulfate-reducing bacteria using an impedimetric
immunosensor based on agglutination assay, Talanta v. 80, p. 218–223, 2009.
WAN Y., ZHANG D., WANG Y., HOU B., A 3D-impedimetric immunosensor based on foam Ni for detection of
sulfate-reducing bacteria, Electrochemistry Communications, v. 12, p.288–291, 2010.
WANG L, KANG B, GAO N, DU X, JIA L. Corrosion behaviour of austenitic stainless steel as a function of methanol
concentration for direct methanol fuel cell bipolar plate. Journal of Power Sources, v. 253, p. 332-341, 2014.
WANG Y., YE Z. & YING Y. New Trends in Impedimetric Biosensors for the Detection of Foodborne Pathogenic
Bacteria, Sensors, v. 12, p. 3449-3471, 2012.