Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TYPES OF ERRORS ON
TRIAL BALANCE
COURSE-MBA (2022-24)
SUBJECT NAME-ACCOUNTING FOR MANAGERS
SUBJECT CODE-ACCT602
SUBMIITED BY-
SOHINI CHAKRABORTY-A91801922116
LABONITA CHATTERJEE-A91801922073
SONALI PATIKAR -A91801922052
SUZZAINE AHAMED-A91801922084
ANKITA AGARWAL- A91801922061
RUCHIRA DAM ROY- A91801922088
1
INDEX
15 Conclusion Labonita 30
2
DEFINITION OF TRIAL BALANCE
A trial balance is a financial report showing the closing balances of all accounts in the
general ledger at appoint in time . Creating a trial balance is the first step in closing the books
at the end of an accounting period.
All the ledger accounts are listed on the left side of the report. It can be omitting any accounts
that haven’t been used during the period. Then there’s a columns with debit balances, and one
with credit balances . The total debits and credits should match .
3
OBJECTIVES OF TRIAL BALANCE
The Trial Balance provides a useful check upon the ledger postings. If a trial balance tallies,
it is proved that the posting to the ledger accounts is correct. In other words, it ensures that
both the aspects of each transaction have been posted into the ledger i.e., debit aspects have
been posted on the debit side and the corresponding credit aspects on the credit side.
If a trial balance does not tally, it indicates that some errors have occurred and the accountant
will then proceed to locate such errors. Even a small difference in the trial balance is to be
given the same importance and attention as a large difference because it may be possible that
there may be a number of errors which have offset the effect of one another, resulting in a
small composite difference.
A Trial Balance serves as a summary of all the ledger accounts. Scanning the Trial Balance
enables one to know the assets, liabilities, expenses, incomes, etc.
As the trial balance contains the list of all the Ledger accounts, it provides a basis for further
processing of accounting data, that is, preparation of final accounts namely Trading and
Profit & Loss Account and a Balance Sheet.
4
GUIDELINES FOR TRIAL BALANCE
A trial balance is a conglomerate of or list of debit and credit balances extracted from various
accounts in the ledger including cash and bank balances from cash books. The rule to prepare
trial balance is that the total of the debit balances and credit balances extracted from the
ledger must tally. Because every transaction has a dual effect with each debit having a
corresponding credit and vice versa.
Therefore, at the end of the accounting period or at the end of each month, the balances of the
ledger accounts are extracted, and trial balance is prepared to test as to if the total debits are
equal to total credits or not.
★ REAL ACCOUNT:
In Real accounts, for example building, machinery, furniture, opening stock, investment, bills
receivable, cash in hand, cash at bank all will be debited.
★ PERSONAL ACCOUNT
Personal accounts related to assets, for example, debtors, prepaid expenses, drawing,
outstanding incomes, loans, advances made, etc are always to be debited.
★ NOMINAL ACCOUNT
Nominal accounts representing losses and expenses for example, wages, carriage, purchases,
salary paid, discount allowed, etc will be debited.
★ PERSONAL ACCOUNT
Personal accounts related to liabilities, for example capital, creditors, loan taken, bills
payable, reserves, outstanding expenses, etc will be credited.
5
★ NOMINAL ACCOUNT
Nominal accounts representing incomes and gains, for example commission received,
discount received, profit, sales, etc, will always be credited.
Provision for bad debt, provision on stock, purchase return, etc will be credited.
6
REQUIREMENTS OF TRIAL BALANCE –
The trial balance usually includes a list of totals of accounts of the general ledger. The
general ledger accounts should include the description of the account, the account
number, and the final debit/credit balance.
Along with the above, the trial balance should include the accounting period of the
report being created.
Companies initially record their business transactions in bookkeeping accounts within
the general ledger. Depending on the kinds of business transactions that have
occurred, accounts in the ledgers could have been debited or credited during a given
accounting period before they are used in a trial balance worksheet.
Furthermore, some accounts may have been used to record multiple business
transactions. As a result, the ending balance of each ledger account as shown in the
trial balance worksheet is the sum of all debits and credits that have been entered to
that account based on all related business transactions.
A company’s transactions are recorded in a general ledger and later summed to be
included in a trial balance.
At the end of an accounting period, the accounts of asset, expense, or loss should each
have a debit balance, and the accounts of liability, equity, revenue, or gain should
each have a credit balance.
However, certain accounts of the former type also may have been credited and certain
accounts of the latter type also may have been debited during the accounting period
when related business transactions reduce their respective accounts’ debit and credit
balances, an opposite effect on those accounts’ ending debit or credit balances.
On a trial balance worksheet, all of the debit balances form the left column, and all of
the credit balances form the right column, with the account titles placed to the far left
of the two columns.
7
USES OF THE TRIAL BALANCE SHEET –
A trial balance can be used to detect any mathematical errors that have occurred in a
double entry accounting system. If the total debits equal the total credits, the trial
balance is considered to be balanced, and there should be no mathematical errors in
the ledgers.
While it is not a financial statement, a trial balance acts as the first step in preparing
one. Accountants use the trial balance spreadsheet as the basis while preparing a
financial statement.
A trial balance is made in accordance with the double-entry concept of bookkeeping.
This means that for every entry recorded in the debit column, a corresponding credit
entry will also be recorded in the credit column. Since it involves recording all the
entries from the ledgers of the organization in this manner, it also helps to identify and
rectify errors.
For example, if there is a mismatch between the debit and credit account totals at any point, it
indicates an error. However, since most companies use software tools, their system may not
allow new entries to be added if there is a mismatch between the values, leaving no room for
error. This helps to achieve mathematical accuracy.
With the help of the trial balance, one can also ensure that the account balances are
accurately extracted from accounting ledgers.
Being a summary sheet, it helps to give a bird’s eye view of the accounting
transactions of the company.
A trial balance can be an important tool for auditors as they can analyse the trial
balance prior to scrutinizing the ledgers.
Adjustments can be made easily even after a trial balance has already been prepared
because it provides the accountants with tallied columns.
8
PURPOSE OF TRIAL BALANCE SHEET –
The purpose of a trial balance is to ensure that all entries made into an organization’s
general ledger are properly balanced. A trial balance lists the ending balance in each
general ledger account.
The total dollar amount of the debits and credits in each accounting entry are
supposed to match. Therefore, if the debit total and credit total on a trial balance do
not match, this indicates that one or more transactions were recorded in the general
ledger that were unbalanced.
From a practical perspective, accounting software packages do not allow users to
enter unbalanced entries into the general ledger. This means the trial balance is not
needed by entities that have computerized systems.
If a business is still using manual record keeping, then the trial balance has more
value, since it is possible to create unbalanced entries in such a system.
When a manual recording keeping system is used, the trial balance is also used to
create the financial statements. This means that the account balances in the trial
balance are manually aggregated into the line items found in the financial statements.
Auditors also use the trial balance. They request it early in an audit, and transfer the
ending account balances from this report into their auditing software. They then use
audit procedures to test these balances.
9
LIMITATIONS OF TRIAL BALANCE
A trial balance is not a conclusive proof of absolute accuracy of the books of accounts. If the
trial balance agrees, it does not mean that there are absolutely no errors in the books of
accounts. A tallied trial balance merely indicates that equal debits and credits have been
recorded in the books of accounts. Even when trial balance agrees, some errors might remain
1. Errors of principle, i.e., errors which arise due to incorrect application of the principle
2. Compensating errors, i.e., group of errors which are committed in such a way that one
mistake is compensated by the other and the Trial Balance still agrees.
detected.
5. Posting correct amount on the correct side but in the wrong account is not reflected by
6. Wrong amount recorded I the books of original entry and same amount is debited and
10
TYPES OF TRIAL BALANCE ERRORS
The unadjusted trial balance may contain a number of errors, only a few of which are
easy to spot in the trial balance report format. Here are a few common errors, with
1. Entries Made Twice - If an entry is made twice, the trial balance will still be in
balance, so that is not a good document for finding it. Instead, for an ongoing
transaction, you may have to wait for the issue to resolve itself. For example, a
duplicate invoice from a supplier will (hopefully) be spotted during the invoice
approval process.
2. Entries Not Made at All - Impossible to find on the trial balance, since it is not
there (!). Your best bet is to maintain a checklist of standard entries, and verify
3. Entries to the Wrong Account - This may be apparent with a quick glance at the
trial balance, since an account that previously had no balance at all now has one.
Otherwise, the best form of correction is preventive - use standard journal entry
and vice versa. This issue may be visible on the trial balance, especially if the
entry is large enough to change the sign of an ending balance to the reverse of
5. Transposed Numbers - The digits in a number may have been switched. This is
easy to find, since the underlying entry is unbalanced, and so should not have
11
journal entry totals must be compared to the totals in the trial balance. This
environment, where entries must be balanced or the system will not accept them.
If you are using a manual system, then the issue will be apparent in the column
totals of the trial balance. However, locating the exact entry is vastly more
difficult, and will call for a detailed review of every entry, or at least of the
totals in every subsidiary ledger that rolls into the general ledger.
Error Correction Best Practices - Whenever you correct an error, be sure to use a
clearly labeled journal entry with supporting documentation, so that someone else
12
METHODS TO PREPARE TRIAL BALANCE
There are three methods in which a Trial Balance can be prepared. Which are as follows :
Under this method, two sides of the accounts are totalled. The total of the debit side is called
the “debit total” and the total of the credit side is called the “credit total”.
All the debit totals are entered on the debit side of the Trial Balance while the credit total is
entered on the credit side of the Trial Balance
If any particular account has a total on one side, it will be entered either in the debit column
or the credit column as the case may be.
Advantage
It promotes the arithmetical accuracy of the accounts.
Extraction of ledger balances is not required at the time of
preparation of Trial Balance.
Disadvantage
Preparation of final accounts is not possible.
Under this method, all the ledger accounts are balanced. The balancing figure may be
either a “debit balance” or “credit balance”.
Advantage
o It helps in the easy preparation of final accounts.
o Time and labour can be saved in constructing a Trial
Balance following this method.
Disadvantage
o Errors may remain undisclosed irrespective of the
agreement of Trial Balance.
Compound Method:
13
Under this method, totals of both the sides of the accounts are written in the separate
columns. Along with this, the balances are also written in the separate columns. Debit
balances are written in the debit column and credit balances are written in the credit
Advantage
o It offers the advantage of both methods.
Disadvantage
o Lengthy process and more time consumed in the
preparation of a Trial Balance.
14
METHODS OF PREPARING TRIAL BALANCE (WITH SPECIMEN)
1. Total Method:
In this method, ledger accounts are not balanced. They are totaled. These totals are entered in
the debit and credit columns. The grand total of debit column will be equal to the total of the
credit column.
2. Balance Method:
Under this method, the closing balances of ledger accounts are tabulated in a separate
All debit balances are shown in the debit column and all credit balances in the credit column.
15
Important Note: All debtors’ accounts, Assets or Properties accounts, all expenses or losses
accounts will always show debit balances. They will be shown in the debit side/column of the
trial balance.
All creditors’ accounts, Liabilities’ accounts, Income or gains accounts will always show
credit balances. They will be shown in the credit side/column of the, trial balance.
16
SUMS IN TRIAL BALANCE
SUM-1: we will prepare the trial balance on NSBHandicraft as per the transactions shown
below table for the firm on March 31st , 2019 .
17
no. Dr . Cr .
9 Rent 15,000
As per the trial balance prepared for NSBHandicraft as of march 31st 2019 we can see that the
total of the debit side is the same as the total of the credit side in the trial balance .
18
SUM-2: to understand the method of preparation of trial balance . Below are the balances
from the books of Jyoti Enterprises as of March 31st , 2019 .
2 Machinery 2,00,000
19
7 Stock in hand 50,000
20
As per the trial balance prepared for Jyoti Enterprises , we can see that both sides of the trial
balance are the same indicating no error in ledger posting during the financial year . the trial
balance shows all debit and credit balances in one statements .
SUM-3: prepare a trial balance for Go Green Pvt . Ltd as per the balance is shown below .
21
4 Sundry creditors 14,000
8 Drawings 22,000
9 Sales 3,00,000
As per the trial balance prepared for the Go Green Pvt . Ltd . we can see that both sides of
the trial balance are the same . Hence a trial balance is not an account but a schedule of all
the balances of all ledger accounts on a particular date . The trial balance will have Debit and
credit columns , the account with a debit balance will be written on the debit side and the
account with a credit balance will be posted on the credit column side with the actual balance
amount .
22
STEPS TO LOCATE THE ERRORS
STEP-1: Check the totals of both the debit and credit amount columns of Trial balance.
STEP-2: Apply trial and error techniques such as scanning all the entries of amount
equivalent to the amount of difference or 50% of the amount of difference (if the difference is
divisible by 2). On scrutiny of the books, errors such as transposition of the figures, positing
of an amount on wrong side of ledger account etc. may be discovered.
EXAMPLE 1- If the total of credit side of the Trial balance exceeds by Rs 1800, it is
possible that positing of Rs 1800 on the debit side has been omitted. To detect such type of
errors, the accountant should scan all the entries of an amount of Rs 1800.
EXAMPLE-2- If the total of credit side of the Trial balance exceeds by Rs 1800, it is possible
that a debit item of Rs 900 has been posted in the ledger as a credit item. It may be noted that
if amount of difference is Rs 1300.51, it is not possible that an item of Rs 650.255 has been
posted on the wrong side of the ledger amount. To detect such type of errors, the accountant
should scan all the entries of an amount equal to 50% of the amount of difference (if divisible
by 2).
EXAMPLE-3- If the debit item of Rs 3195 has been posted as Rs 1395, the credit side of the
Trial balance will exceed by Rs 1800 which is divisible by 9. Thus, a difference in the trial
balance divisible by 9 helps in detecting the error involving the transposition of figures.
EXAMPLE-4- If the debit item of Rs 12000 has been posted as Rs 1200, the credit side of the
Trial balance will exceed by Rs 10800 which is divisible by 9. If the difference is divided by
9, a quotient of Rs 1200 will be obtained and all amounts of Rs 1200 should be scanned to
detect such type of error.
STEP-3: Check with the help of ledger to ensure whether the balance of each and every
account including Main Cash and Bank account and Petty Cash Account has been included in
the correct amount column with correct amount in the Trial balance.
STEP-4: Check whether totals of the Sundry Debtors and Sundry Creditors are correct.
STEP-5: Check whether the Cash and Bank balances have been correctly ascertained.
STEP-6: Check whether all the opening balances appearing the previous year’s Balance Sheet
have been correctly brought forward.
STEP-7: Check whether balancing of all the accounts is correct.
23
STEP-8: Check whether the posting to ledger accounts has been done correctly.
STEP-9: Check whether the casting and carrying forward of books of original entry are
correct.
EXAMPLE
Mr X started his small business on 1.4.2017 and since he is weak in accountancy, he requests
you to tell him whether the following Trial balance prepared by him is correct or not. He
provides you the following information:
(i) There is no credit sale/purchase.
(ii) There is no returns inwards/outwards.
(iii) Only cash book and ledger are maintained
24
300 16,000 22,000 -- 16,000 21,000
SOLUTION
In such a case, the following steps should be taken to find out the errors:
25
During the process of balancing the various accounts one will find that the balance of bank
column has been taken as Rs 5,100 instead of Rs 4,100 thus, reduce the balance of the bank.
Now the difference is reduced to NIL. Though the agreement of two sides of the trial balance
is a prima facie test of arithmetical accuracy, yet it is not a conclusive proof of the accuracy
of records since the trial balance may agree without disclosing some errors, the examples of
such errors are as under:
(1) Error of Omission i.e omission of recording the transactions in the books of original
entry.
(2) Error of recording in the books of original entry.
(3) Error of posting to wrong account but on correct side with correct amount.
(4) Error of principle.
(5) Compensatory error.
26
CLASSIFICATION OF ERRORS
All accounting errors may be classified as follows:
(1) On the basis of their of their effect on Trial balance.
(a) Errors affecting the agreement of Trial balance.
(b) Errors not affecting the agreement of Trial balance.
ERROR OF OMISSION
27
For example-Transaction correctly recorded in the books of original entry(other than Journal
proper) but not posted in the ledger at all; {e.g A Credit sale of goods to Shyam recorded in
the Sales book but omitted to be posted in Shyam’s account}.
ERROR OF COMMISSION
This error arises due to wrong recording, casting, carry forward, posting, balancing, etc. Error
of commission may be classified as follows:
1. Error of Recording 2. Error of Casting 3. Error of Carrying forward 4. Error
of Posting
Error of Recording- This error arises when any transaction is incorrectly recorded in the
books of original entry. This error does effect the Trial balance.
Types of Error of Recording
S.N. Books of original Name of the Account with Whether affects
entry in which the account used in which the the Trial balance
transaction was recording transaction was
recorded recorded
1 Correct Correct Wrong No
2 Correct Wrong Correct No
3 Correct Wrong Wrong No
4 Wrong Correct Correct No
5 Wrong Correct Wrong No
6 Wrong Wrong Correct No
7 Wrong Wrong Wrong No
For example-Goods of Rs 500 purchased on credit from Ram are recorded in the purchases
book for Rs 5,500.
Error of Casting- This error arises when a mistake is committed in totaling. This error affects
the Trial balance.
For example-Purchases book is totaled as Rs 1,000 instead of Rs 100.
Error in Carrying Forward- This error arises when a mistake is committed in carrying forward
a total of one page on the next page. This error Affects the Trial balance.
Error of Posting- This error arises when information recorded in the books original entry is
incorrectly entered in the ledger. This error may or may not affect the Trial balance.
Types of Error of Posting
S.N. Account to which Side(debit/credit) on Amount with Whether affects
the posting was which posting was which posting was the Trial balance
made made made
1 Correct Correct Wrong Yes
2 Correct Wrong Correct Yes
3 Correct Wrong Wrong Yes
4 Wrong Correct Correct No
28
5 Wrong Correct Wrong Yes
6 Wrong Wrong Correct Yes
7 Wrong Wrong Wrong Yes
COMPENSATING ERROR
These errors arise when two or more errors are committed in such a way that the net effect of
these errors on the debits or credits of accounts involved is nil. In other words, compensating
errors refer to such a group of errors wherein the effect of one error is compensated by the
effect of other error or errors. These errors do not affect the agreement of the Trial balance
but may or may not affect the figure of net profit.
For example- If the total of purchases book is posted in the ledger as Rs 1,00 instead of Rs
100 and at the same time Ram’s account is credited in the ledger as Rs 1,00 instead of Rs
100, as a result of these errors, there is an excess credit of Rs 900 in Ram’s account and an
excess debit of Rs 900in Purchases account. Thus, these two errors nullify the effect of each
other. The first error will increase the figure of Purchases and consequently will reduce the
figure of profit.
ERROR OF PRINCIPLE
This error arises when the transaction is recorded ignoring the distinction between the capital
and revenue item. In other words, this error involves an incorrect allocation of expenditure or
receipt between Capital and Revenue. The correct allocation between Capital and Revenue is
of paramount importance because any incorrect allocation would disturb the final results as
disclosed by the Financial Statements. It may lead to under/over stating of Incomes or
Expenses of Assets or Liabilities. This error does not affect the Trial balance.
For example-Error-Freight paid for bringing a new machinery is debited to Freight A/c
Effects: (1) On Revenue Expenditure (i.e Freight)- Overstated (2) On Capital Expenditure
(i.e Cost of Machinery)-Understated (3) On Depreciation on Machinery-Under changed (4)
On Net Profit-Understated by the Net Effect (i.e the difference between the Freight and the
amount of Depreciation).
Note: The costs incurred on the acquisition, installation and commissioning of a fixed asset
up to the point the fixed asset is ready for use represent Capital expenditures.
29
CONCLUSION
The final result of accounting is access to financial information and position. To attain this
we have to prepare a Profit & Loss account and balance sheet for the period.
Trial balance is basically the summary of account balances with items of income, represented
by expense, Assets, Liabilities and capital either a credit or debit.
As far as books are concerned, Preparing a Trial balance helps in deducting the mathematical
errors in a Double entry system and provides the total debit equals the total credit.
Tallied Trial balance does not mean that it is free from Error of Omission or Error of
Commission or Principal Errors. The major conclusion from tallying a trial balance is that
account balances are free from arithmetic errors, free from transpose errors.
The goal is to confirm that the sum of all debits equals the sum of all credits and identify
whether any entries have been recorded in the wrong account.
30
31