Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Subhash Kak
Chapman University
2023
Subhash Kak
Foreword
Think of the most puzzling questions of personhood and life: Who controls
the mind and speech, and directs the eyes and the ears? And how do we know
that we know, or if others know?
These questions are posed most directly in the Kena Upaniṣad, one of
the major Upaniṣads that is in the last section of the Talavakāra Brāhmaṇa of
the Sāmaveda. It explains that the Ātman (Brahman) is the light of the mind,
the seer behind the eyes, the hearer behind the ears, and the witness that tells
us if things are in accordance with the truth.
There is a tension between the mind as an instrument in the brain and
the light that illuminates it, which is consciousness. One’s experience is a
dance between these polarities and unless one knows how to move between
them, one can lean too heavily on one side or the other and get a meaning that
is not quite true.
An excellent example of this is in the Īśāvāsya Upaniṣad, where it is
taught that one must embrace both avidyā and vidyā, i.e., the outer and the
inner, the seen and the seer.
The Upaniṣads teach through enigma and paradox. Look at these
mysterious statements in the Kena Upaniṣad:
I do not think I know it well, nor do I think I do not know it. He among us
knows it truly who knows this: that neither do I know, nor I know it not.
It is known by those who know it cannot be known; they know it not if they
think they know it.
These statements prod us to get away from our zone of comfort and
ask as to who this “I” is. It is shown that there indeed is a perfectly rational
explanation for such riddles, meditation on which takes us to the very nature
2
Kena Upaniṣad
The Kena Upaniṣad also instructs on the layers of the mind and how
they are a mapping of the elements (bhūtas) that constitute reality. In doing
so, it explains the mystery of Agni, Vāyu, and Indra who preside over these
layers, which makes the contents of these wisdom books more accessible.
They open the door on the triplicate nature of reality as seen through body,
breath, and consciousness that mirrors the outer triad of earth, atmosphere,
and the sun.
Stillwater
June 6, 2023
3
Subhash Kak
Invocation
॥ अथ केनोपननषत् ॥
ॐ आप्यायन्तु ममाङ्गानन वाक्प्राणश्चक्ुुः
श्रोत्रमथो बलनमन्द्रियानण च सवाा नण ।
सवं ब्रह्मौपननषदं
माऽहं ब्रह्म ननराकुयां मा मा ब्रह्म
ननराकरोदननराकरणमस्त्वननराकरणं मेऽस्तु ।
तदात्मनन ननरते य
उपननषत्सु धमाा स्ते मनय सन्तु ते मनय सन्तु ।
ॐ शान्द्रन्तुः शान्द्रन्तुः शान्द्रन्तुः ॥
|| atha kenopaniṣat ||
Om. May my limbs, speech, breath, eyes, ears, strength, and all the senses
thrive. All taught by the Upaniṣads is Brahman. May I never deny Brahman,
may Brahman never abandon me, and let there be no turning away. Let there
be no faithlessness from my side, may all the dharmas commended by the
Upaniṣads shine in me. May they shine in me. Om! Peace! Peace! Peace!
4
Kena Upaniṣad
1.1
1.1 Om. Directed by whose wish does the mind proceed to its object? At
whose command does the foremost prāṇa do its duty? At whose wish do we
utter speech? Who is the god that directs the eyes and the ears?
1.2
1.2 It is the ear of the ear, the mind of the mind, the speech of speech, the
breath of breath, and the eye of the eye. Thus freed [by this knowledge], the
steady ones, having gone from this world become immortal.
5
Subhash Kak
1.3
1.3 The eye does not go there, nor speech, nor the mind. We do not know, we
do not understand, how may one teach it?
6
Kena Upaniṣad
1.4
1.5
1.5 That which cannot be conceived by the mind, but by which, they say, the
mind is conceived, know that alone as Brahman and not this that people here
worship.
7
Subhash Kak
1.6
1.6 That which cannot be seen by the eye, but by which the eye is seen, know
that alone as Brahman and not this that people here worship.
1.7
1.7 That which is not heard by the ear, but by which the hearing is perceived,
know that alone as Brahman and not this that people here worship.
8
Kena Upaniṣad
1.8
1.8 That which cannot be breathed by the breath, but by which the breath is
led, know that alone as Brahman and not this that people here worship.
9
Subhash Kak
2.1
2.1 If you think you know Brahman well, then surely you know but little of
its appearance; you know only what is in you, or in the deities. By inquiry,
they are known in the mind.
10
Kena Upaniṣad
2.2
2.2 I do not think I know it well, nor do I think I do not know it. He among
us knows it truly who knows this: that neither do I know, nor I know it not.
2.3
2.3 It is known by those who know it cannot be known; they know it not if
they think they know it. It is not known to those who know and known to those
who do not know.
11
Subhash Kak
2.4
2.4 It is really known when experienced in all states of the mind; by such
knowledge one attains immortality. By the Ātman one obtains strength; by
vidyā (knowledge), immortality.
2.5
इह चेदवेदीदथ सत्यमन्द्रस्त
न चेनदहावेदीन्महती नवननटुः ।
भूतेषु भूतेषु नवनचत्य धीराुः
प्रेत्यास्माल्लोकादमृता भवन्द्रन्त ॥ ५॥
2.5 If a man knows it here, then there is truth; if he does not know this here,
there is great destruction. Having realized (the Ātman) in every being, the wise
upon leaving the world become immortal.
12
Kena Upaniṣad
3.1
3.1 Once Brahman, they say, obtained a victory for the gods (senses); and by
that victory of Brahman the gods became elated. They thought: “Truly, this
victory is ours; truly, this glory is ours only.”
3.2
3.2 He (Brahman) understood that [false pride] and appeared before them. But
they did not know who that Yakṣa (being) was.
13
Subhash Kak
3.3
तेऽनिमब्रुवञ्जातवेद एतनिजानीनह
नकनमदं यक्नमनत तथेनत ॥ ३॥
te’gnimabruvañjātaveda etadvijānīhi
kimidaṃ yakṣamiti tatheti ||3.3||
3.3 They addressed Agni: “O Jātaveda, please find out who this Yakṣa is.”
“Yes,” said Agni.
3.4
तदभ्यद्रवत्तमभ्यवदत्कोऽसीत्यनिवाा
अहमस्मीत्यब्रवीज्जातवेदा वा अहमस्मीनत ॥ ४॥
tadabhyadravattamabhyavadatko’sītyagnirvā
ahamasmītyabravījjātavedā vā ahamasmīti ||3.4||
3.4 He [Agni] ran (to the Yakṣa), who asked him: “Who are you?”
[Agni]: “I am the famous Agni, I am Jātaveda.”
14
Kena Upaniṣad
3.5
तन्द्रस्मूँस्त्वनय नकं वीयानमत्यपीदूँ सवं
दहे यं यनददं पृनथव्यानमनत ॥ ५॥
3.5 “What power is in you of such fame?” (asked the Yakṣa). “I can burn
everything, whatever is on earth,” (replied Agni).
3.6
3.6 The Yakṣa placed a straw before him, (saying): “Burn this!” (Agni)
approached it with all might but was unable to burn it. He then returned (to
the gods), saying, “I was unable to know who the Yakṣa is.”
15
Subhash Kak
3.7
अथ वायुमब्रुवन्वायवेतनिजानीनह
नकमेतद्यक्नमनत तथेनत ॥ ७॥
atha vāyumabruvanvāyavetadvijānīhi
kimetadyakṣamiti tatheti ||3.7||
3.7 Then they [the gods] addressed Vāyu: “O Vāyu, please find out who this
Yakṣa is.” “Yes”, said Vāyu.
3.8
तदभ्यद्रवत्तमभ्यवदत्कोऽसीनत वायुवाा
अहमस्मीत्यब्रवीन्मातररश्वा वा अहमस्मीनत ॥ ८॥
tadabhyadravattamabhyavadatko’sīti vāyurvā
ahamasmītyabravīnmātariśvā vā ahamasmīti ||3.8||
3.8 (Vāyu) ran towards it (Yakṣa), and was asked: “Who are you?” Vāyu replied:
“I am the famous Vāyu; I am Mātariśvā (courser of the atmosphere)”.
3.9
3.9 “What power is in you of such fame?” (asked the Yakṣa). “I can take up all,
whatever is on earth,” replied Vāyu.
16
Kena Upaniṣad
3.10
3.10 The Yakṣa placed a straw before him [Vāyu], (saying): “Take it up!” He
approached it with all might but was unable to take it up. He then returned (to
the gods), saying, “I was unable to know who the Yakṣa is.”
3.11
3.11 Then the gods addressed Indra: “O Maghavan, find out who this Yakṣa
is.” “Yes,” said Indra, and ran to the Yakṣa, but the Yakṣa disappeared from
the view.
17
Subhash Kak
3.12
3.12 And in that very sky he (Indra) beheld a woman, the wondrously
beautiful Umā, daughter of the snow clad mountain, Himavat. And of her he
asked, “Who could this Yakṣa be?”
18
Kena Upaniṣad
4.1
4.1 “It was Brahman,” said she. “It is through the victory of Brahman, indeed,
that you have attained this glory.” From that (the words of Umā) that he
(Indra) understood that it [the Yakṣa] was Brahman.
Note: The Goddess opens the door to knowledge, for the Goddess represents
embodied reality, which is ultimately our only instrument.
4.2
4.2 So these gods [Agni, Vāyu and Indra] excel the other gods; for they
approached the Yakṣa nearest; they were the first to know that it was Brahman.
Note: Agni, Vāyu and Indra preside over the three layers of the mind: manas,
buddhi, and ahaṅkāra, which correspond to the three higher kośas.
19
Subhash Kak
4.3
तस्मािा इिोऽनततरानमवान्यान्दे वान्स
ह्येनन्नेनदष्ठं पस्पशा स ह्येनत्प्रथमो नवदाञ्चकार ब्रह्मेनत ॥ ३॥
tasmādvā indro’titarāmivānyāndevānsa
hyenannediṣṭhaṃ pasparśa sa hyenatprathamo vidāñcakāra brahmeti ||4.3||
4.3 And so Indra excelled the other gods; for he approached Brahman nearest,
and was first to know it.
Note: The Ātman suffuses all the elements, but it is closest to the
Ānandamaya kośa, where the ego, the principal sense, resides.
4.4
20
Kena Upaniṣad
4.5
4.5 Now its description with reference to the Ātman; the mind goes to it, as
it were; and this [Ātman] should be desired and remembered as being [very]
near.
4.6
Note: This is the view of the Ātman as personal deity, a personal friend.
21
Subhash Kak
4.7
4.7 “Sir teach me the Upaniṣad.” “The Upanishad has been told to you; we have
certainly told you the Upaniṣad about Brahman.”
4.8
4.8 Tapas (concentration of the energies of the mind and the senses), damaḥ
(self-control), and karma (self-less work) are its foundation, the Vedas
(knowledge) are its limbs, and Truth is its abode.
22
Kena Upaniṣad
4.9
4.9 He who knows it (knowledge of Brahman) thus, destroys evil and truly
attains the infinite, the blissful and the highest.
23