Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wen 2012
Wen 2012
895
Abstract: ZnAlLa-CO3 layered double hydroxides (LDHs) with different Zn/Al/La molar ratios were prepared by the constant pH coprecipi-
tation method. The synthetic materials were characterized by X-ray diffraction (XRD), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), scan-
ning electron microscopy (SEM), Brunauer-Emmett-Teller method (BET) and particle analysis. The results showed that the hydrotalcite-like
materials had a layered structure. The ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs as stabilizers were mixed with PVC resin. The tests of thermal aging, mass loss test
and Congo red for the PVC composites were carried out at 180±1 ºC, respectively. The results showed that ZnAlLa-CO3- LDHs used as sin-
gle thermal stabilizers could enhance both the long-term thermal stability and initial thermal stability of PVC, and 2.4 phr (parts per hundred
PVC resin) ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs with Zn/Al/La (molar ratio)=20/8/2 had a better stabilizing effect on PVC than others. Compared with single
thermal stabilizers, the composite thermal stabilizers including 0.3 phr calcium stearate (CaSt2), 0.4 phr -diketone and 2.4 phr
ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs significantly enhanced the thermal stability of PVC sample. And rare earth ion could optimize the conformation of PVC
and refrain the initiation of the thermal stability and the thermal stable time was over 220 min. The main reason could be concluded to the spe-
cial structure of rare earth ion, which had longer atom radius and more coordination numbers. So the rare earth ion (RE+) could react with the
labile chlorine atoms (Clr–) to form a stable coordinate complex.
Keywords: ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs; thermal properties; poly(vinyl chloride); characterization; degradation; synergetic effect; rare earths
Chlorine-containing polymers such as poly(vinyl chloride) poor initial stabilization effects except for their combination
(PVC) are widely used in many fields for their advantages of with other stabilizers to get a remarkably improved stabiliza-
non-flammable nature, good performance and low price[1]. tion effect[10,11].
However, PVC and its products are undesirable to decom- Layered double hydroxides (LDHs) thermal stabilizers are
pose. It is assumed that PVC, under the influence of tem- given a great research potential and application prospect for
peratures and energy rich radiation, undergoes an autocata- their acidic and alkaline characteristics, memory effect, large
lytic dehydrochlorination reaction and an initial reaction of surface area, high anion exchange, and good thermal stabil-
dehydrochlorination at a lower temperature probably auto- ity[12–14]. The reason why LDHs served as efficient additives
accelerates the evolution of HCl[2,3]. Moreover, the degrada- to enhance PVC thermal stability is that HCl produced in the
tion temperature and yield temperature of PVC are so close degradation of PVC can be scavenged by the hydrotalcite
that many problems would occur during further processing. structure of LDHs.
Therefore, it is necessary to utilize thermal stabilizers for According to the special structures and thermal stabilizing
improving the thermal stability of PVC[4]. Currently, a mechanisms of rare earth elements and hydrotalcite-like ma-
trend of thermal stabilizers with low toxicity or terials, based on our previous work[15,16], the MgAl-CO3-
non-toxicity, such as metal soaps, rare-earth stabilizers, LDH can not react with labile chlorine atoms (such as allyl
hydrotalcite-like materials, and other nontoxic thermal sta- chloride), so it is difficult to restrain the initial coloring and
bilizers are developed[5]. prevent the growth of ‘‘polyolefin structure’’ when it is used
Although metal soaps have excellent transparency and lu- alone. Therefore, the initial coloring is very serious when the
bricity[6], the thermal stability is not favorable when metal MgAl-CO3-LDH is used as thermal stabilizer individually.
soaps are used alone. So they are always used as the assistant Compared with MgAl-CO3-LDH, the long-term thermal sta-
thermal stabilizers in combination with others[7,8]. As a bility of the PVC samples with MgAlCe-CO3-LDH is en-
new-type thermal stabilizer with high efficiency, non-toxic hanced although the initial coloring is restrained just a little.
and a good synergetic effect with other stabilizer, rare earth As in the case of ZnAl-CO3-LDH served as thermal stabi-
thermal stabilizers share a great research potential and a fas- lizer for PVC, it is significant for it to restrain the initial col-
cinating prospect[9]. Unfortunately, rare earth stabilizers have oring and prevent the growth of "polyolefin structure" by
Foundation item: Project supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (91023031)
Corresponding author: YANG Zhanhong (E-mail: zhyang@mail.csu.edu.cn; Tel.: +86-731-88879616)
DOI: 10.1016/S1002-0721(12)60151-3
896 JOURNAL OF RARE EARTHS, Vol. 30, No. 9, Sep. 2012
reacting with allyl chloride. However, the long-term stabili- aging test box at 180±l ºC and subjected to static thermal
zation effects of PVC composites containing ZnAl-CO3- aging. The strips were taken out of the box every 20 min and
LDH are suppressed. The unsuitable production ZnCl2 could subjected to visual examination. Synchronously, the mass
catalyze the degradation of PVC, leading to the malignant change determination was taken. The mass loss and time that
degradation of PVC and making PVC samples turn black black decomposition started to emerge was defined as the
suddenly, i.e. "zinc burning"[17,18]. In order to satisfy both thermal stability time of PVC.
initial coloring and long-term stabilization effect of PVC 1.4.2 Congo red test PVC and other different stabilizers
composites, the rare earth element La[19,20] was introduced were mixed absolutely in the mortar. The resultant mixtures
into the ZnAl-CO3-LDH in this paper. were put into a tube with Congo red test paper located at 2 cm
ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs were prepared. As the thermal stabil- above the sample. The tube was immersed into an oil bath at
ity of mixture of PVC, ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs was examined 180±l ºC for evaluating static thermal stability of PVC com-
by static thermal aging test, mass loss test and Congo red test. posites. The time required for the color change from red to
And the synergistic effect of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs with CaSt2 blue was taken to be the stability time. Each sample was
and -diketone, as well as the detailed thermal stabilizing measured three times and the average time was obtained.
mechanisms of thermal stabilizers was discussed.
2 Results and discussion
1 Experimental
2.1 Characterization of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs
1.1 Materials 2.1.1 XRD analysis of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs The XRD pat-
The PVC resin (SG-5 type, suspension grade) was kindly terns of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs are shown in Fig. 1. From Fig. 1,
provided by Beijing Huaer Company Limited. All the the characteristic absorption peaks at 2=11.7°, 23.5°, 34.6°
chemical reagents used in this study were of A.R. grade. The and 61.7° of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs, which correspond to the
deionized water was distilled twice to get rid of carbon di- reflections of (003), (006), (009) and (110) respectively, in-
oxide (CO2). dicating that the as-grown ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs share a hy-
drotalcite structure. These diffraction peaks are sharp, nar-
1.2 Preparation of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs row and symmetrical with a low and stable baseline, sug-
The Zn(NO3)2·6H2O solution was added into an aqueous gesting that the sample is well-crystallized. It can be found
mixture containing Al(NO3)3·9H2O and La(NO3)3·6H2O with that the XRD patterns of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs with different
the total concentration fixed at 1 mol/L. Then, the aqueous Zn/Al/La molar ratios are similar. The results indicated that
mixture above and a mixed solution containing NaOH and the ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs can be successfully synthesized with
Na2CO3 were added to the deionized water at a speed of 1 different Zn/Al/La molar ratios. According to Fig. 1, the dif-
drop/s, respectively. The resultant solution was stirred for 4 h fraction peak of curves C and D are sharper than that of A
at 85 ºC under a constant pH value of 10. Subsequently, the and B, indicating that the ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs have high
resulting slurry was aged for 20 h at 65 °C. After being fil- crystallinity and integrated crystalline structures with M2+/
tered and washed, the precipitate was dried and ground to M3+=2/1. However, a higher diffraction peak of the sample
fine powder. with Zn/Al/La=20/9/1 was located at about 56.5°, which can
be attributed to the characteristic peak of La(OH)3 (PDF06-
1.3 Characterization techniques for ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs 0585).
X-ray diffraction (XRD) was performed on a Rigaku
D500 (Siemens) diffractometer (36 kV, 30 mA) using Cu K
radiation at a scanning rate of 2=8(º)/min. FTIR spectra
were conducted on a Nicolet Nexus-670 FTIR spectrometer
(as KBr discs, with wavenumber 4004000 cm–1, resolution
0.09 cm–1, and the mass of measured sample 2 mg). The sur-
face morphology of as-synthesized ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs was
observed using a scanning electron microscope (SEM,
JSM-6360LV).
2.1.2 FTIR analysis of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs Fig. 2 presents The particle size distribution curve is shown in Fig. 4. It
the recorded FT-IR spectra of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDH and can be observed that the particle size range is narrow and in
ZnAl-CO3-LDH. It can be seen from Fig. 2 that there is a a normal distribution, which demonstrates that the as-syn-
hydroxyl vibrational peak at 3434 cm–1 for ZnAlLa-CO3- thesized sample is very uniform and in accordance with
LDHs, which shifts to a lower wavenumber in comparison SEM images. Besides, the porous structure of ZnAlLa-CO3-
with the free hydroxyl group (3650 cm–1). The reason for LDHs was measured by Brunauer-Emmett-Teller method.
this is that the interlaminar H2O, CO32– or –OH in hydrotal- The specific surface area is confirmed to be 31.5277 m2/g
cite structure react through the association of hydrogen- with a pore volume of 0.2201 cm3/g.
bond[21,22]. The O–C–O asymmetric stretching vibration ap-
pears between 1350 and 1550 cm–1. And a considerably 2.2 Thermal stability testing of prepared PVC composites
lower shifted absorption peak at 1363 cm–1, as compared 2.2.1 Effect of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs with various Zn/Al/La
with CO32– of CaCO3 (1430 cm–1), shows that there was an molar ratios on the thermal stability of PVC The effect of
intercalation between CO32– and interlayer H2O through the mixtures containing 100 g PVC, 70g DOP, and 2.4 g
strong hydrogen bonding. The lower wavenumber bands at ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs with different Zn/Al/La molar ratios on
400–700 cm–1 is due to LDH lattice vibrations (Zn–O, Al–O, the thermal stability of PVC are illustrated in Fig. 5 by static
La–O, La–O–Zn). The bands at 779 and 552 cm–1 can be as- thermal aging test and the Congo red test data of the mix-
signed to Al–O stretching modes. These Al–O peaks of tures with the same mass ratio are listed in Table 1. Syn-
ZnAlLa–CO3–LDHs are weaker than those of ZnAl–CO3– chronously, the mass loss data are shown in Table 2.
LDH, which probably resulted from the partial replacement As shown in Fig. 5(a), pure PVC without any stabilizer
of La3+. The strong band at 428 cm–1 belongs to the layered begins to color and becomes black after only 20 min at 180±1
skeleton structure of hydrotalcite. It was basically the same ºC. As shown in Table 2, the mass loss percentage is the
as that of the LDHs containing no element La[23]. Hence, it is largest one and there is the maximum mass loss rate in this
safe to conclude that La had been introduced into the lattice sample, which indicated that loss of HCl made the greatest
of hydrotalcite. increase in mass. It is well known that PVC, under the in-
2.1.3 SEM analysis of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs Fig. 3 gives fluence of temperatures and energy radiation, suffers from
SEM images for the ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs sample. It is clear the autocatalytic dehydrochlorination reaction and the
that the as-obtained particles were in a well-distributed dis- HCl-catalytic reaction, which is fulfilled by the ionic mecha-
persion state on the whole and display a shape of sphericity. nism[24]. At the beginning, the formation of a double bond
And the particle size is assumed to be 2–20 m. activates the subsequent chlorine atoms, i.e. allyl chloride,
2.1.4 Particle size and BET analysis of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs and loss of HCl from an adjacent unit may form a conju-
gated bond system and cause mass loss of the PVC sample.
Secondly, the primary HCl molecule takes part in the forma-
tion of a dehydrochlorination transition state, which results
in an autocatalytic dehydrochlorination. These two processes
may be expressed as below:
(1) PVC autocatalytic dehydrochlorination reaction:
cellent. The thermal stability of the PVC samples becomes reported in Fig. 6 and listed in Table 3, Table 4, respec-
better with the increasing of Zn/Al/La molar ratio. When the tively.
ratios of Zn/Al/La became higher than 20/8/2, however, As shown in Table 3 and Fig. 6, the discoloration time of
there was a slight decrease in thermal stability. The result is PVC is prolonged with the increasing amounts of ZnAlLa-
consistent with that in Congo red tests and the mass loss tests. CO3-LDHs from 1.2 to 3.0 phr (parts per hundred PVC res-
So it is suggested that the optimum molar ratio of Zn/Al/La ins), revealing that the thermal stability of PVC is improved
is 20/8/2. And the mass-loss percentage and mass loss rate significantly. However, further increment of ZnAlLa-CO3-
are the entire minimum. LDHs in PVC cannot enhance the thermal stability any more,
Compared with the PVC strips containing ZnAl-CO3- but weaken it instead, suggesting that the optimum amount
LDH, the long-term stabilization effect of PVC composites
containing ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs are more excellent. The main
reason is attributed to the strong complexation property of
rare-earth elements which have longer atom radius and more
coordination numbers[26]. So the rare earth ion (RE+) can
react with the labile chlorine atoms (Clr–) to form a stable
coordinate complex[27]. After chlorine atoms coordinates
with rare earths, the catalysis effect of HCl is refrained.
Consequently, ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs are very effective in co-
ordinating with allylic chlorine atoms and suppressing deg-
radation of PVC resin. As stated previously, the rare earth
ions enhance effectively the initial thermal stability. Simul-
taneously, it is worthy noticing that the undesirable ZnCl2
could be consumed by an exchange reaction between ZnCl2
and La3+. Conversely, LaCl3 production does not promote
rapidly dehydrochlorination. The synergistic effect might be
expressed as below:
3ZnCl2+2La3+3Zn2++2LaCl3 (4)
Relevantly, the synergistic effect might be explained by
the orbit theory[28]. Bonding orbitals including 6s, 6p, 5d and
a large ionic radius in rare earth ions La endow them more
coordination number, which form ionic coordination bonds
by electrostatic interaction. The outermost d orbitals of La3+
are "unoccupied orbitals", on which there are no electrons.
Conversely, the 3d orbitals of Zn2+ are full of electrons,
which are called "occupied orbitals". It is clear that the ther-
mal stability is excellent when the "unoccupied orbitals" are
combined with the "occupied orbitals". According to the
Hund’s Rule, the relatively stable complex is probably due
to the fact that the outermost d orbitals of La3+ are combined
with the 3d orbitals of Zn2+. In the complexes, the d orbitals
were all under the condition of "half-occupied". Conse-
quently, the unsuitable zinc chloride was changed into a
more stable d-d complex. Thus, the time of "zinc burning"
Fig. 6 Effects of different amounts of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs on ther-
was delayed effectively. According to the unique synergetic
mal stability of PVC composites
effect of rare earth La3+, it is not sufficient for excessively
(a) 1.2 phr; (b) 1.8 phr; (c) 2.4 phr; (d) 3.0 phr
low dosage of La to produce a desired synergetic effect and
excessive La addition leads to damage on the structure of Table 3 Effect of various amounts of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs on the
LDHs. Consequently, it is indicated that the optimum molar thermal stability of PVC at 180± l ºC (as determined by
ratio of Zn/Al/La is 20/8/2 and the sample with this Congo red test)
Zn/Al/La molar ratio has the most integrated crystalline PVC composite Amount of Thermal stable time of
structure as demonstrated clearly in Fig. 1. ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs/phr PVC composite/min
2.2.2 Effect of various amounts of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs on PVC+ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs 1.2 138
the stability of PVC 100 g PVC, 70 g DOP and various PVC+ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs 1.8 157
amounts of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs with the optimum molar ra- PVC+ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs 2.4 186
tio of Zn/Al/La (20/8/2) were mixed. The results of static PVC+ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs 3.0 158
thermal aging test Congo red test, and mass loss test are
900 JOURNAL OF RARE EARTHS, Vol. 30, No. 9, Sep. 2012
2.3.2 Effect of various amounts of CaSt2 on the stability of Table 6 Mass-loss percentage (%) of different amount of cal-
PVC 100 g PVC, 70 g DOP, 2.4 g ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs cium stearate on the thermal stability of PVC compos-
with the optimum molar ratio of Zn/Al/La, 0.4 g E-diketones ites (a) 0.0 phr; (b) 0.1 phr; (c) 0.2 phr; (d) 0.3 phr; (e)
0.4 phr
and various amounts of CaSt2 (in the range of 0–0.4 phr)
were mixed. The results of the static thermal aging test and Time/min (a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
mass loss test are presented in Fig. 8 and Table 6. 20 0.11 0.10 0.11 0.09 0.10
From Fig. 8, it can be found that there is a remarkable im- 40 0.12 0.11 0.12 0.10 0.11
provement in thermal stability of PVC with the increasing 60 0.12 0.12 0.13 0.10 0.11
amount of CaSt2 from 0.1 to 0.4 phr (parts per hundred res- 80 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.10 0.12
ins). The same result is shown in Table 6. However, further 100 0.13 0.14 0.14 0.12 0.13
increment of CaSt2 in PVC can not enhance the thermal sta- 120 0.14 0.15 0.14 0.12 0.14
bility any more, suggesting that the optimum amount of 140 0.17 0.16 0.15 0.13 0.15
CaSt2 is 0.3 phr. On this occasion, the mass loss is the opti- 160 0.18 0.17 0.16 0.14 0.15
mal. 180 0.28 0.19 0.17 0.14 0.16
200 0.30 0.24 0.19 0.16 0.19
220 0.33 0.26 0.23 0.17 0.23
240 0.35 0.30 0.27 0.18 0.26
(6)
3 Conclusions
ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs were prepared by co-precipitation
method under constant pH. And the results showed that the
hydrotalcite had a layered structure. The PVC composites
containing ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs only showed a better thermal
stability when the amount of ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs filler was
2.4 phr and the molar ratio of Zn/Al/La was 20/8/2. The
PVC composites containing 100 g PVC, 70 g DOP, 0.3 g
CaSt2, 0.4 g E-diketones and 2.4 g ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs pre-
sented a significant enhancement in the thermal stability.
The reason could be that ZnAlLa-CO3-LDHs was very ef-
Fig. 8 Effects of different amounts of calcium stearate on thermal fective in coordinating with allylic chlorine atoms and sup-
stability of PVC composites pressing degradation of PVC resin. Simultaneously, it could
(a) 0.0 phr; (b) 0.1 phr; (c) 0.2 phr; (d) 0.3 phr; (e) 0.4 phr suppress the catalysis of HCl. On the other hand, it could op-
902 JOURNAL OF RARE EARTHS, Vol. 30, No. 9, Sep. 2012