Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HoloMask
The Future of Face Masks
Brief Outline Design a novel interactive wearable device for citizens to interact with a
smart city to enable a sustainable future
Problem Statement How might we mitigate the need for single-use facemasks in the city of
Melbourne?
02 Covid-19 in the Context of
Melbourne 2020-2022
The COVID-19 pandemic has affected the world in unprecedented ways. This virus has caused
significant loss and deterioration on human life, public health, food systems, and work-life all over
the world (World Health Organization et al., 2020). Nevertheless, the pandemic has also shown
the importance of proper governance in building resilient health systems. It emphasised the
capabilities of modern day medical science and technology in responding to urgent situations.
The COVID-19 vaccines were the fastest vaccines to be developed in human history, pathogen
identification to vaccine development happened in less than twelve months (Cohen, 2020). This
pandemic reminded us how important it is to be prepared. However, some measures we took for
the sake of health and safety compromised other areas of human life, such as sacrifices made to;
Motivations
Social Impacts
3/ Front-Line
Healthcare Workers
02 / Motivations
SEPTEMBER 2020
AUGUST 2020
Australians Who Wear Face Masks
58.3% 60.3%
(Statista, 2020)
JUNE 2020
MAY 2020 12.5%
13.5%
02 / Motivations
The enforcement of face masks during the pandemic also affected people
socially.
90.2%
of Australian adults surveyed “agreed
communication”
These repor ts included an increase in the need for clarification and repetition,
Fur thermore, cer tain minority groups such as those with hearing or speech
mask essentially acts as a physical barrier that prevents access to facial cues
02 Communication and lips when communicating — an impor tant aspect of communication that is
proving to be a major pain point for those with speech impairments (Hampton
et al., 2020). Due to this, it is imperative that alternative ways of face coverings
and Social Impact should be explored that will be both comfor table and inclusive.
02 / Motivations
03 Frontline
Healthcare Workers
The recent pandemic has shown the strength and resilience of frontline healthcare
workers. However, it also highlights the fact that this demographic is the most vulnerable
when it comes to pandemics. Healthcare workers put their lives at risk for the safety of all.
“The fact that as many nurses have In fact, four out of five health care or aged care workers who were infected by COVID-19
acquired it from their own workplace (Wahlquist, 2020). Within Australia, the World
died during this pandemic as died Health Organization estimates that around 1,300 healthcare workers died during the
reporting period of the pandemic (Woodley, 2021). Sadly, this number is only
during World War I is shocking. Since representative of the reported cases during a specific reporting period and is expected to
be much higher (Woodley, 2021). As healthcare workers are the demographic that make
May 2020 we have been calling for the use of face masks in their daily life, regardless of a pandemic, it is important to note that
any advancements in the area of PPEs would be a big help to them – be it an
standardised and systematic collection improvement in comfort, accessibility, or the like.
KN95 masks are deemed as one of the most effective “face masks” that is widely available to the
consumer market (University of Maryland Medical System, 2022). It has a particulate filtration
efficiency of 83-99% (Sankhyan et al., 2021). Ranking very close to the KN95 masks are its close
counterparts N95 and KF95 (see tbl. 1).
Current Approaches
Furthermore, the specific face masks that are provided for and used by healthcare professionals
are surgical masks (UNICEF, 2021). While this is effective in physically blocking particles, its
filtration efficiency scores significantly lower than that of the X95-class (see tbl. 1). It can be
argued that healthcare professionals deserve more efficient masks for everyday use in their
profession. Furthermore, surgical face masks are primarily made up of polymeric materials, this
means that when disposed of, these masks contribute a significant amount of microplastic waste
(Aragaw, 2020).
Current
On the other hand, the options for more sustainable and reusable face masks (such as the cloth
mask) often have to sacrifice its filtration efficiency and require constant cleaning and
Approaches
maintenance. Face shields, on the other hand, are extremely effective as they are one solid
material — it completely blocks particulates rather than filtering them (Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention, 2020). However, they are extremely uncomfortable for prolonged usage and still
require proper sanitation after each use. Suffice it to say, a new solution is vital. One that makes no
compromise in its filtration, sustainability, and comfort.
The Double Diamond Method was used throughout the iterative process to help the researchers consolidate their thoughts during the conceptual phase of the design
process. By using this model as a framework, a solution was created by bridging findings from the problem space (overconsumption of single use face masks) to the
solution space (discovery of Photonic crystal filtration)
Problem
Design Brief Statement Solution
Primary Low and High
Research Fidelity
Sketches
Findings, problem Final Showcase, Video,
statemenmt Report
Upon receiving the brief our group conducted a brainstorming exercise in order to fully comprehend each of the
Brainstorming four mandatory components that make up the novel technology we’re designing.
Components
City of
Wearable Smart City Sustainability
Sustainability
Melbourne
How to contribute to
Glasses Information Provided Current initiatives
sustainable future?
Once our concept of making a face-mask was recognized through the low-fidelity sketches, high-fidelity
sketches helped us determine the more specific details, such as placement, specific technology and how the
device would operate.
High Fidelity
Sketches
04 / Design Processes
First Iteration
Our first iteration was built using Fusion 360 and brought Fusion Sketches
our conceptual vision to life. This was imperative to the
design making process because it helped us recognise 01 02
there weren’t enough interactions available between the 03
device and the user.
Fusion 3D
Considerations to these additional interactions was incredibly beneficial to the
Models overall design and functionality of our wearable technology. This process
encouraged us to consider ourselves as the user and assess their needs
further.
For instance, previously the device would activate without informing the user
3D Printed Models as to why. This likely would have caused confusion and panic as user’s
questioned what contaminants were in their area. Adding an assistive AI that
communicates with real-time data resolved this problem and also
personalised the experience; as did the face-mapping function.
Additionally a case was designed to securely house the technology. Being that
the earpieces are not protected by the holographic face-mask, it was the
logical conclusion that the technology should also be filtered of any harmful
Charging Case contaminants while it was being charged. The case therefore incorporates
UV-C light for device filtration.
Smart Masks
During the height of the pandemic mask instantly became an essential part of daily
life, at the time a few companies tried their hands at giving smart functionality to a
mask. The smart features need to be balanced for the user’s experience in mind.
Because with more functionality comes the problem of weight, comfort & bulk.
smart masks
Figure 2: Set criteria provided by a previous study regarding smart mask
For this case we took a look at these 3 smart mask from major brands:
(Hyysalo et al., 2022)
All of the products in question take on a reusable mask shell with replaceable filters The product on the existing market doesn’t touch upon the sensory possibility that a mask
and a fan to help with airflow. Each product boils down to the same product with offers to the users, rather it focuses more on user comfort and replaceability of the filters
different focus in mind such as phillips focus on wearability and razer’s N95 while costing more than your disposable mask. While smart masks have different sensory
certification for the filter. These features, while could be argued as the first iteration possibility, the product on the current market might be hindered by the current
for the mass market, could be quite easily interpreted as a trendy product during the technological level of consumer tech.
time while giving user’s small reason to actually adopt the product for long term
usage.
05 / Reference Projects
LG Tone UV Case
LG’s 2019 offering for True Wireless Earphone tried to cover a niche market of cleanliness conscious Personal in-ear headphones averaged
119,186 CFU
consumers. The case that the earphones come in has a UV light that is certified to kill 99.9% of
bacteria on the earphones after 10 minutes of being in the case. While niche by nature, wearable
technologies might have potentially high Colony Forming-Units (CFU) based on some testing. (UL
Solutions, 2020). See Figure 3.
More bacteria
330X
More bacteria
2,708X
More bacteria
Designed to be a platform for usability researchers to test out the possibility of than a kitchen than a kitchen than an average
the features that can be implemented into a standalone wireless earphone, tap countertop cutting board
eSense has audio, motion, and proximity sensors within it to gather data from
the user.(Fahim Kawsar et al., 2018)
Figure 3: SeniorLiving.org Team, 2021
HoloMask is a state-of-the-art holographic face mask that uses the power of photonic crystal
Introducing HoloMask sensors to detect and mitigate airborne diseases and pollution.
The researchers aim to tackle waste and supply issues by creating a reusable and rechargeable
mask. Through the distribution of such a technology, there will be little to no need for the mass
overconsumption of single use face masks. This also means ease of comfort and communication
for its users due to the projection of an intangible and see through Photonic crystal-based
filtration. Hopefully, streamlining the lives of frontline healthcare workers who need PPEs daily.
01 Reusable 02 Breathable
Holomask is
Holomask does not
a rechargeable
physically cover the face
and portable device or hinder communication
03 Sanitary 04 Seamless & Comfortable
HoloMask is a wearable holographic face mask that utilises the combinations of photonic
crystals with holography. Photonic crystals are structures that control the propagation of
photons between energy bands, allowing for the prevention or allowance of different
HoloMask Overview wavelengths of light to cross the gap and pass through materials (Maka et al., 2003). HoloMask
employs this effect to distinguish between different wavelengths of light associated with
potentially harmful substances and clean air, allowing for the filtration of contaminants and an
efficient, non-invasive user experience.
01 02 03
Selective Wavelength
03
01
03
Photonic Crystals 01
02
Holography 03
06 / Our Technology - Breakdown
Photonic crystals are nanostructures containing structural features that exist on a size-scale
Photonic Crystals similar to that of the wavelength of light. These nanostructures interact with photons in a way
that grants control over their propagation, prevention and behaviour (Olyaee et al., 2017).
Different arrangements within photonic crystals allow them to exhibit unique and wide-
ranging optical properties and effects (Kou et al., 2019) .
The photonic bandgaps created by photonic crystals allow for the sensitivity to and filtration
Photonic Bandgaps of targeted contaminants. This is achieved by tailoring the properties of the nanostructures,
such as by altering the periodicity of the structure or its refractive index contrast (Fangfang et
al., 2023). Through this they can be specified towards the absorption or scattering spectra of
specific airborne pollutants.
Speaking specifically of quality monitoring and filtration, the photonic band gaps allow the
selective detection of specific airborne contaminants via the elimination of their
Selective Wavelength corresponding absorption bands or spectral signatures (Andres-Arroyo et al., 2011). For
example, pollutants such as harmful gases like Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) or volatile organic
compounds (VOC’s), have specific absorption or scattering wavelength peaks in the visible
Detection & Filtration light, infrared and ultraviolet regions of the electromagnetic spectrum (Martin et al., 2019) .
Production of photonic crystals with bandgaps specific to these contaminants’ spectra allows
for the filtration of the pollutants as only the desired wavelengths are able to pass through the
facemask. The mask’s detection is incredibly specific and precise as a result, as the crystal-
based sensor is tuned to detect the targeted contaminants.
06 / Our Technology - Breakdown
The size-scale on which photonic crystals are produced make them a perfectly
Miniaturisation & implementable technology in use with HoloMask as they offer the potential for miniaturisation
and integration, allowing the product to be compact and portable (Qi et al., 2004). Traditional
air quality monitoring systems with any in-built specificity towards contaminants often require
Integration large and complex equipment, making them tedious to carry. Photonic crystals’ innately
smaller size-scale makes them perfect for integration into a portable and wearable device.
HoloMask utilises holographic projector modulators to generate and project the holographic
mask. These projectors operate through the use of spatial light modulation, which
manipulates light waves and creates the interference patterns necessary for the production of
the hologram (Cho et al., 2021). When working in unison with the photonic crystal structures
Holography allows for the manipulation of light at a nanoscale level, providing minute control over the
holographic projected mask, guaranteeing there are no physical gaps or entry points between
the mask and the user (Zewe, 2022). This combination ensures the highest level of safety
and security possible and creates an immersive user experience while maintaining a constant
and unbroken physical barrier between the user and their environment.
The integration of photonic crystals into HoloMask will also allow for the opportunity to deploy
Communication with
sensor networks for distributed monitoring of pollutant and contaminant levels which can be
integrated with the City of Melbourne’s existing sensory infrastructure. This will allow for more
thorough and precise air quality assessments and will be able to enhance contaminant-
Smart City Data detection in real time. This information can then be used in return to dynamically adjust the
photonic crystals’ filtration properties in order to optimise performance in accordance with the
detected contaminants. HoloMask’s adaptability allows for a rapid response to changing
environmental conditions and provides effective filtration to the specific air quality status.
06 / Our Technology - Systems Interior
01
02
Optical Sensors: Optical sensors are provided to notify the device when the user
02 has successfully put on or removed the earpieces
01
Proximity Sensors: Proximity sensors determine whether the device is being worn
06
correctly by the user or if one earpiece has been removed, thereby risking the 03
connectivity of the projected hologram mask and jeopardising the user’s health.
03 Our device is equipped with haptic feedback and an AI voice that will gently
remind the user an earpiece is not in place and needs to be adjusted for
maximum protection/mask functionality. 01
Haptic Feedback Chip: Located in each device, the haptic feedback chip is
responsible for delivering any haptic feedback back to the user; such as gentle 04 02
04 vibrations when the battery is low, when face-mapping is activated and volume-
control. At any point, the delivery of haptic feedback can be clarified to more
05
novice users by simply asking ‘Holo’ the purpose behind any vibration.
Battery: Our device utilises a high-capacity and rechargeable lithium battery. With
05 energy efficiency and sustainability in mind, our battery is rechargeable via a
USB-C chord which reduces the waste of single-use batteries
Speaker Driver: Each earpiece is fit with a speaker driver close to the inner ear in
06 order to hear any output from our assistive AI
06 / Our Technology - Functions & Interactions
Assistive AI
Our technology has an in-built assistive AI to Face Mapping
compliment the user experience. This AI is local Face mapping is available to each individual user
to the device and communicates to the user upon setting up their device. An indented button is
information related to relevant Smart City data via provided which, when pressed for a duration of
bluetooth. For instance, our AI ‘Holo’ will always longer than 3 seconds, activates the devices face-
inform the user the reason their mask was mapping interaction. This long hold and indented
activated when in ‘automatic mode' so the user is button is designed to ensure the button isn't
aware of any contaminants in their surrounding accidentally pressed. The device will then proceed to
environment. ‘Holo’ can also respond to use holographic sensors to measure the specific
questions asked by the user. Additional dimensions of the user's face to ensure there are
information includes announcing the devices absolutely no areas of entrance between the
battery percentage and any smart city data holographic mask and the user.
Navigate to RIGHT ear Which setting would Manual (Force ON) Flick switch DOWN
piece you like to change?
Design Considerations The toggle switch to switch between “auto-mode” and “manual-mode” was a design choice
to prevent any accidental clicks. As HoloMask is designed with healthcare workers in mind,
the group opted for a more tactile and secure way of ensuring the users of what mode they
are in. For instance, a healthcare worker in the middle of their shift would not want to be
fiddling around with their ear piece on the job (especially if they are already wearing their
Toggle Switch
PPEs that they do not want contaminated). A singular button to change modes can cause
confusion and can be accidentally pressed given enough pressure. A toggle switch provides a
more tactile reassurance (you can feel if the switch is at the “top” or at the “bottom” state).
01 Priority of Comfort
Holomask offers effortless interactions, enhancing learnability and ensuring ease of use, while also
promoting memorability.
01
02
03
Ear pieces were modelled to accommodate people The shape of the charging case is slim enough to fit in Small crevices were added into the model of the
wearing glasses. It also does not hinder in-ear access pocket. Ear pieces are laid out in a space-efficient charging case for ease of access when taking the ear
for people who want to use earphones. manner to keep a small form factor. pieces out of the case.
07 / Comfort Considerations
The device securely attaches to the user without the need for
any ear inserts, ensuring that the user's hearing abilities are
not hindered. Its semi-circular shape wraps safely around the
user's ears, featuring a top-heavy design for optimal balance.
Ensuring the device never unintentionally detaches is crucial
to maintaining user safety. In the event that the device is not
properly positioned or starts to slip off, proximity sensors and
a haptic feedback chip will promptly notify the user to
readjust its placement.
Comfort
Holomask, we have addressed the issue of potential discomfort
associated with long-term wear. We recognise that individuals,
especially healthcare workers, often need to wear the device for
extended periods, and it is crucial to minimise any discomfort
Considerations they may experience. Our goal is to ensure that our target users
experience significantly less long-term wear discomfort
compared to currently available masks in the market.
01 Social Adaptation 07 / Additional Considerations
To collect secondary data on customer satisfaction, conducting background research on Apple's AirPods
provided valuable information (Apple, 2019). This research focused on factors such as wearability, durability,
performance, and comfort. The insights gained from this secondary research heavily influenced our design
decisions, considering that a significant portion of Melbourne's population is already familiar with this
technology or similar ones. Consequently, we can reasonably expect that our target audience, sharing a
preference for the strengths of this existing technology, will also adopt our technology. At the same time, we
aim to address any weaknesses that have had a negative impact on the overall user experience, ensuring a
more robust and satisfying user experience overall.
02 Seamless Communication
Non-verbal communication plays a crucial role in regulating the flow of conversation. It encompasses various
means of expression such as the head, face, body parts, and the body as a whole (Uzun, 2020). According
to De Stefani and De Marco's (2019) research, manual and facial gestures serve as communicative signals
that, in conjunction with language, convey emotional messages during social interactions. Facial expressions
are particularly significant in facilitating effective communication.
With Holomask's holographic projection, users can display their facial expressions, enabling seamless and
effective communication with others. This feature ensures that the face remains visible to enhance the
overall communication experience.
03 Improved Breathability
Filtration
According to a study by Kwong et al. (2021) that reviewed the breathability and filtration efficiency of various
household materials used in face masks, it was found that as breathability increases, filtration decreases. This
study highlights the importance of wearing face masks correctly, as individuals who are unable to wear
masks or coverings properly become more vulnerable to disease or pollutants.
Holomask effectively addresses this issue and offers a reliable solution that prioritises user safety while Breathability
addressing concerns related to breathability and filtration efficiency.
Holistic User Experience 07 / Design Considerations
Addressing
of Melbourne, 2022). Example of datasets that could
be used for our product is the Development Activity
Monitor (DAM) to figure out which areas have heavy
fully integrated HoloMask with CoM data will create
a symbiosis relationship between the city and the
product with even further integrations with special
the Brief
constructions alongside that CoM has made live datasets if the city is willing to cooperate.
updates of their sensors (such as one for air quality)
available in the API.
08 / Smart City Data
The City of Melbourne has a multitude of initiatives in HoloMask aims to not only make use of the data Combining the data gathered from the HoloMasks
progress with the aim of developing into a Smart City, provided by the Micro-Climate Sensors, but and the Micro-Climate Sensors, real time heat maps
ranging from new technologies, free wi-fi, re-imaging additionally:
[ Ambient air temperaturp [ Particulate matter 2.³ Due to the restricted range of wavelength detection
[ Relative humidit [ Particulate matter 1± in photonic crystals, accessing this data ensures an
[ Barometric pressure [ Average wind speed extra layer of security for our users.
08 / Sustainability
Holomask aligns with Melbourne's commitment to prioritise sustainability in its smart city initiatives (City of
Holistic Sustainability Melbourne, 2022b). The city's goals, derived from the United Nations' sustainable development goals
(United Nations, 2015), serve as a guiding framework to ensure that Holomask contributes to
comprehensive sustainable development. As Melbourne strives to recover from the effects of COVID-19,
Objections it presents an opportunity for Holomask to evolve and minimise waste, specifically by addressing the issue
of single-use masks. Furthermore, the data output from the device will assist in monitoring and managing
environmental factors such as air quality and pollution, further supporting the city's sustainability efforts.
Wearable Technology
01 / Definition
While there is no hard definition of what wearable tech is, for this instance
we will define it as a piece of technology that can be worn and also
process and communicate information autonomously while being on the
go (Wright & Keith, 2014). Like any tool a wearable needs to be useful but
alongside that a consideration of ergonomics needs to be taken into
account due to the nature of the prolonged time that it will be worn in the
user's body. Taking into consideration both the engagement and
manipulation interface that the technology will use to mediate the users
and the task, ensuring that the usage will be easy, safe, and comfortable
to ensure adoption of the technology (Lin & Kreifeldt, 2001).
Figure 6: Wearable Design Framework viaHuman System Design (Lin & Kreifeldt, 2001)
02 / Adoption Criteria
For a new technology to be adopted on scale by users it will need to fill Perceived Benefits Social Factors
various needs and roles to justify their incorporation into the user’s life.
01 04
What these criterias are has been a discussion in the field of technology
acceptance with various proposed models such as Technology
Acceptance Model (TAM) and Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of 02 Technology Characteristics 05 Perceived Risks
Technology 1 & 2 (UTAUT1 & UTAUT2) with each focusing on different
aspect of technology adoption. Based on a literature review done by
Kalantari (2017), adoption of wearable tech could be summarise into:
03 Individual Characteristics
08 / Wearable Tech
Health management product (Sergueeva et al., 2019) Lifestyle/Smartwatches (Kranthi & Ahmed, 2018)
01 Performance expectancy 01 Hedonic motivation 04 Personal innovativeness
Motivations for
only two unique cases (The Guardian, 2022). Comparatively, our innovative technology offers a
more accurate and cost-effective solution for managing air pollution and improving air quality data.
Here, the integration of smart city sensors with our wearable devices ensures a continuous and
Adopting our
comprehensive stream of real-time data on air quality. This eliminates the need for manual data
input and minimises the risk of data gaps, resulting in more accurate and reliable information for
decision-making. These targeted interventions and protective measures will surmount to a
Technology
decrease in healthcare expenses associated with respiratory illnesses and contribute to an overall
improvement in public health outcomes
09 - Financial Motivations
By demonstrating an initiative towards environmental sustainability we can also better advertise the City of
Sustainable & Liveable City Melbourne as a forward-thinking and liveable city. These initiatives will inevitably attract new businesses, tourists,
investors and ultimately drive economic growth therefore generating new revenue streams for the city.
Productivity Gains
Economic Growth
First-Mover Advantage
Ltd, 2023).