Professional Documents
Culture Documents
@IotAscr;t-etr
h"fi.rltl,fl.1*"r*.,?t1
$.f.lrX,t
WELCOME
New Valve Guidelines Drive
Dear Colleague, Higher Standards of Care
Nofihwestem Memorial recently eamed Medicare approval for heart kans- The committee based the new gr"ridelines, which
plantation after performing 15 heart transplants, including several medically are the first published since 1998. primarily
complex transplants, within a one-year timeframe with 100 percent survival. on peer consensus. beczruse r.vhile there was
To date, our team has performed 21 heaalt transplants while maintaining a a need for new guidelines. there was a lack of
100 percent sun ival rate. rzrndomized controlled clinicai trials on which
to base them. There are an estimatecl 15 to 20
Our cardiac catheterization laboratory is one of the premier invasive cardi-
rnilliorr people with ralve disease. Fiiepelcenr
ology programs in the country Over the past 10 years, there have been no
of the U.S. population has mitrtrl valve prolapse,
cardiac deaths and no myocardial infarctions related to performing diagnos-
the leading cause of mitral legLLrgitation. Two
tic catheterization at Norlhwestern Memorial.
percent of the U.S. population has bicuspid aortic
We are excited to announce the establishment of our new Center for valves. which can lead to either aortic stenosis
Women's Cardiovascular Health, which evolved out of the need to help or aortic regurgitation. In addition, trs the U.S.
\\omen and ther physicians recognize their risks for cardiovascular disease population ages, there is an increasing number
and to conduct gender-based research to improve teatments and outcomes. ol elclerlv patients presenti ng r.r,it h degenerative
Our cardiologists are committed to fomulating institutional evidence-based aortic and mitral valve disease. Approrimately
protocols as guidelines for the care of women. 95,000 surgical valve operations are perlormed
rn the Unrted States each year.
We hope you will find this issue of Cardiovascular Review informative and
heipful in practice. We look forward to collaborating with you as we con- "Conducting clinical trials in valve disease is
tinue to advance specialized cardiac care for patients who need it. not ensy because it is a mechanical problem and
a chronic process." says Dr. Bonow. "It is hard
Regards, to shor.v improvement in mortality with valve
inten entions unless patients are followed lor
a long time. The gurdelines in this case are an
W
RosERr O. BoNow, MD Plrnrcx M. McC,mrHv. MD
attempt to pull together what we kr-row based
on consenslrs opinion.''
0N THE CoVER: Patrlck l\4. Mccarrhy, IrID, Nalini M Ralamannan, MD and Robert 0. Bonow l\4D
2A07
diagnostic criteria, thresholds lor recommending There were several key changes w'ith regard Providing the Best Patient
surgery and referral considerations. In terms of to mitral regurgitation. "We chose an earlier Care and Outcomes
management strategy, the nes- _suideiines state stage of ventricular dysfunction, based on the At Northwestern Memorial
that in many situations there is no "correct" systolic volume, to recommend surgery because Hospital, the outcornes of
patients undergoing valve
management strategy and strongly recommend a the chronic overload that results from mitral and other cardiac surgery
frank discussion with the patient about the risks regurgitation can lead to heart faiiure," explains are carefully monitored. The
and benefits oltreatment options, which is crucial Dr. Bonow. "Sometimes this happens even before charts on Page 4 show the
in determining the best treatment p1an. patients experience symptoms, which means operative rnortal ity for
that by the time they do experience symptoms, patients undergoing a variety
The new guidelines also include the standards of valve operations since the
some may already have developed irreversible
for echocardiography, which have been set by left ventricuiar dysfunction, and it is now too
Bluhm Cardiovascular lnstitute
the American Society of Echocardiography. "We of Northwestern Memorial
late to expect a good outcome with mitral valve Hospitalwas formed in April
incorporated these standards into the new ACC/
repair or replacement." The guidelines emphasize of 2004. In comparison are
AHA guidelines because we feel that quantilication the calculated predicted
monitoring left ventricular dysfunction in patients
of valve disease severity is important for accurate mortality for each patient
with mitral regurgitation and recommend surgery
diagnosis and treatment strategies," says Dr. using the Society of Thoracic
when there is early evidence of left ventricular
Bonow. "The criteria adopted for use of echo help Surgeons (ST5), EuroSCORE
systolic dyslunction. The left ventricular systolic and the Ambler score from
to at least level the playing field in terms of how the
dimension is a good measure lor this. Circulation 2005.
diagnosis is made. That's important because when
Northwestern Memorial's
considering surgery for patients with valve disease, Another key change involving mitral regurgitation
observed mortality is better
we usually don't recommend surgery if the valve is that in asymptomatic patients it now is considered than the benchmarks for
satisfactory to recommend surgery if the valve has all qroups by all measures
severe regurgitation demonstrated quantitatively by including patients
"We chose un earlier stage of ventriculur undergoing coronary artery
echocardiography and there is a 90 percent certainty
dysfunction, based on the systolic volume, to bypass grafting. Overall,
that the valve can be repaired successfuily.
recommend surgery because the chronic overloud patient rnortalities predicted
that results from mitral regurgitation cun lead The new guidelines make a strongrecommendation by the risk calculations are
to heart failure." between 1.5 to nine times
for valve repair instead of replacement for severe
less likely to occur at
mitral regurgitation. Of the patients in the United Northwestern Memorial
disease is mild. However, surgery is often indicated States who require surgery for mitral regurgitation, as generally expected.
when a patient has severe disease, especially if it is roughly 95 percent have valves that are potentially
causing problems. So echocardiographic criteria repairable. About 50 percent of these patients
are crucial and must be standardized." actually receive surgery to repair the valve. "That
matters because the mitral apparatus is a very
The thresholds for recommending surgery have complicated structure that not only prevents
been lowered in many cases in the new guidelines. the valve from leaking but also contributes to
The changes include patients with aortic stenosis, ventricular shape, volume and function," explains
mitral regurgitation and aortic bicuspid valve. The Dr. Bonow. "So when the mitral apparatus is
1998 guidelines allowed for aortic valve replacement disrupted and replaced with an artificial valve,
in patients with aortic stenosis for three primary this can cause left ventricular dysfunction."
indications: symptoms, evidence of left ventricular
dysfunction or patients with a stenotic valve who had The new guidelines state that if the ventricle is
another indication for surgery such as a coronary showing progressive signs of enlargement over
artery bypass operation. The new guidelines include time, a lower threshold of left ventricular dilatation
the above indications, but add that if the patient is a satisfactory indication for surgery. 'Although
has severe stenosis with no symptoms and normal the left ventricle dilates in response to the volume
left ventricular function, and there is evidence that ioad as a compensatory mechanism to augment
the valve may progress rapidly over the course systolic function, severe enlargement increases the
of the next couple ol years, it is satisfactory to risk of heart failure," says Dr. Bonow.
recommend surgery.
zoh
patients with bicuspid aortic valves ir'ho Feinber-e School. "Working as partners
0orb have associated disease of the aortic in managing these patients is the best
lsolaied AV Repla(ement AVR wifi CAB
in 09)1 (n = 68) root or ascending aorta. In many such \\.a]' to achieve optimal outcomes."
Procedure patients, the aortic enlargement becomes
r Norfiwesiem Memorlal obserued mortality
r 5T5 predicted
more of a problem than the valve itself.
EuroSC0RE
risk (Northwestern Memorial population)
"In these patients. one has to perform "Our teontwork upproach includes performing
Ambler predicted risk valve replacement plus aortic root repair echocardiogrums on every patient in the oper-
3bs:ryic€xpected: isolated AVR = 0.20i AVR wirh CAB = 0
or. hopefully. a valve-sparing aortic root ctting room, before discharge and periodically
repair," says Dr. Bonow. after disclturge. This allows ,ts to track our
Mitralvalve Repair +/- Other
results ttnd msintain our level of care,"
16!,"
'r49tr
The Center for Valve Disease
12.6,,;
I t10 10.3% Cardiac surgeons on the medical stalf at
10%
Northwestern Memorial repair 95 percent "We chose Dr. Rajamannan because of
gok
6% of the mitral valves that are referred for her research accomplishments in how
4% surgery. Northwestern Memorial surgical valve disease develops and how to slow
2a/o
00k
volumes have doubled in the past two years its progression as well as her advanced
Repai'. with CAB- AFAblaiion' predominately because of the surgical training in echocardiography. She has the
- 78)
1n
(n .45) (n = 92)
treatment of patients with valve disease. background and ability to pull together all
Procedure
These surgeons use a minimally invasive of the various people who see patients with
r Northweslern Memorial observed mortality
EurosC0RE approach with more cosmetically appealin-e valve disease and those who do research
Ambler predicted risk incisions lor appropriate candidates. "Our into a cohesive team," says Dr. Bonow. "We
*To
date - 5Ts does not calculate predicted risk for mitral valve repair
are not only focusing on excellent patient
teamwork approach includes performing
0bserued/expeared: MVR = 0.52; MVR with CAB = 0.27; MVR with
AF ablation = 0.1 0 echocardiograms on every patient in the care, but also research'and education so we
operating room, before discharge and can conlribute beyond our own patients
lsolated Coronary Artery Bypass (CAB) periodically after discharge. This allows to the greater community."
1ZYo1
us to track our resuits and maintain our
10%l
level of care." says Dr. Bonow.
New research initiatives include
8%l imagrng protocols integrating standard
60/o
2D echocardiography with advanced
4ah-
2cto 1.5"r "We work with patients in u consultative 3D echocardiography, MRI and CT to
0'lo
0.0qt I manner, in conjunction with their primary evaluate valve morphology, hemodynamic
lsolated tAB (n - 394)
Procedure care physicians. Working us partners in severity and left ventricular and left atrial
r Northwestern N4emorial observed mortality managing these patients is the best geometry and function. Surgical studies
r 5T5 predicted risk (Norlhwestern Memorial population)
way to achieve optimal outcomes." include development and evaluation
EuToSCORE
Ambler predicted risk
of new annuloplasty rings and repair
3bserued/expectedi lsolated CAB = 0 techniques. Northwestern Memorial
Northwestern Memorial provides a also has embarked on genetic studies
Gold. J. B. Society of Thoracic Surgeons National comprehensive approach to care of in collaboration with Northwestern
Database. September 26. 2006. www.sts.org/sections/
stsnationaldatabase/riskcalculator/ patients with valvular heart disease University and basic research in
Nashel S.A., Roques. F.. Michel. P, Gauducheau. E., from diagnostic clinical evaluation mechanisms of valve degeneration
Lemeshow. S., Salamon, R. European System for Cardiac
Operative Risk Evaluation (EuToSCORE). Eur J
and imaging to directing the treatment and calcification. Clinical trials in
Cardiothorac Surg. 2005 Jrnl'2'7(6):1129;. author reply options for these patients. "We work percutaneous aortic valve replacement
1129-32.
with patients in a consultative manner, treatments are planned for the future. r
Ambler, G., Omar. R.2.. Royston. P. Knisman.
R., Keogh, B.E.. Taylor, K.M. Generic. simple risk
stratificatiol nodel for heart valve surgery. Circulation
2005 l u\ 121 1 2(2):22-4 -31.
for five leading medical lournals. above), who is known as the father
of modern nritral valve repair for
his pioneer work in the development
of tissue heart valves and mitral
Mark D. Morasch, MD, is co-director of
valve repair techniques.
Jeffrey J. Goldberger, MD. is medical director the Thoracic Aortic Surgery program in the
of the Cardiac Electrophysiology section at Bluhm Cardiovascular Institute's Center for
Cardiovascular Conference
Northwestern Memorial and professor of Vascular Disease and associate professor of
Medicine at the Feinberg School. He is board Vascular Surgery at the Feinberg School. He is board certified The 2007 ACCF HeartValve
certified in internal medicine, cardiovascular disease and cardiac in general surgery and vascular surgery and is a distinguished Symposium
electrophysiology. He is a fellow of the American College of fellow of the Society for Vascular Surgery. June 7-9,2007
Cardiology and the American Heart Association.
Dr. Morasch has a strong interest in complex extracranial Boston
Dr. Goldberger's research focuses on pacemaker and beta cerebrovascular arterial reconstruction as well as 'in Course Directors: David H.Adams,
blockertherapy in post-myocardial infarction patients, cardiac treating complex aortic pathology, including thoracic and MD; Robert.0. Bonow, MD; Patrick
parasympathetic effects in exercise and recovery vagus nerve T.O'Gara, MD and Patrick M.
thoracoabdominal aneurysms. His research interests include the
McCanhy, MD
stimulation, catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation and device use of MR technology in atherosclerotic plaque characterization.
therapy. He is an editorial consultant and abstract reviewer He has published 48 peer-reviewed manuscripts,26 textbook
for more than 20 medical journals. He also is on the editorial chapters and seven online publications.
boards of three major journals.
Nalini M. Rajamannan, MD
Nalini M. Rajamannan, MD is directorof the
Jon S. Matsumura, MD, is a vascularsurgeon Bluhm Cardiovascular lnstitute's Center for
on the medicalstaffat Northwestem Memorial HeartValve Disease and assistant professor
and associate professor of Surgery at the of Medicine at the Feinberg School. She
Feinberg School. He is board certified in received her training at the Mayo Clinic and is board certified
general surgery and vascular surgery. in internal medicine and cardiovascular disease.
Dr. Matsumura has extensive experience in open and Dr Rajamannan has developed animal and in vitro models of valvular
endovascular treatment of aortic aneurysms, carotid artery heart disease. She currently is developing translational approaches
disease and stroke prevention. He is the first author of numerous for valvular heart disease to clinical medicine and practice. Her work
publications of endovascular procedures, and he is a course has received many prestigious awards, such as the 0utstanding
directoi for multiple endograft and carotid stent courses. lnvestigator Award from the Histochemistry and Cytochemistry
He leads several national and international clinical trials to Society and the Junior lnvestigatorAward fromAmerican Federation
study new treatments for thoracic aortic aneurysm, dissection, for Clinical Research. 5he also has grant support from the National
abdominal aortic aneurysm and carotid stents. lnstitutes of Health and theAmerican HeartAssociation,
Year
artery bypass surgery due to unsuccessful r Dx Cath
Coronary Disease at Northwestern Memorial
PCI was 0.2 percent, which remains below PCr
and professor of the dir.ision of Cardiology at
Northwestern University s Feinberg School
the ACC (1.9 percent) and NHLBI (1.5
percent); MI following PCI is 0.2 percent at Diagnostic Cardiac Catherization
Complications
the Bluhm Cardiovascular Institute, while the 0.s%
The incidence of mortality within the ACC National Data Registry (3.1 percent) 0.43y"
E 0.4"/"
B luhm Cardiovascular Institute fo llowing and NHLBI (2.8 percent) observed a higher
o!
o:x
PCI remuins exceedingly low (0.9 percent) incidence of orcurence. E 0.2o/o
and compares favorably with putient F
Lastly, the outcomes of patients presenting 0.1%
outcome datafrom the 233 clinicul research
to the Bluhm Cardiovascular Institute 0.0%
trials (7.0 percent).
undergoing PCI for acute MI have
Potential Compli€ations
been compared to a study of combined ' Northwestern Memorial Hospital
of Medicine. Both established and leading outcomes fuom 233 clinical research ,, American College of Cardiology
technologies are utilized in the cardiac trials'?. The incidence of mortality within
catheterization laboratory. In addition, the Bluhm Cardiovascular Institute Percutaneous Coronarv Arteru
lntervention Complicitions'
numerous clinical research trials are ongoing following PCI remains exceedingly low 3,50/o
to evaluate new therapies lor the non- (0.9 percent) and compares favorably with . 3.0%
F 2.5qo
surgical treatment of coronary and valr,ular patient outcome data from the 233 clinical
J 2.0"/,
hearl disease. research trials (7.0 percent). ? t.s'/"
g 0,1%
Diagnostic cardiac catheterization and The incidence of stroke and subsequent & 0.5% 0.2y"
percutaneous coronary artery intervention MI including aortic closure for this 0.00/o
lvlortality
procedures have doubled in volume within patient population also remains favorable Potential Complications
the past 10 years while maintaining positive compared to the 233 clinical trials. Bluhm r Northwestern lviemorial
American College of Cardiology
outcomes in comparison to nationally Cardiovascular Institute outcomes also i National Heart, Lung and Elood Institute
available benchmarks'. Specifically, in the demonstrated that the combined major
past 10 years, there have been no cardiac cardiac adverse events (i.e. mortality, Percutaneous Coronaru Arteru
lntervention Presentaiion of
deaths and no myocardial infarctions MI, stroke) following PCI for acute MI is Myocardial lnfarction Complications
(MI) related to the performance of approximately half of that reported in the 9o/o
80/,
diagnostic catheterization; there has been series of 233 combined research cliirical g 10k
approximately a one in 1,000 incidence of trials (8.0 percent). r
E rq"
vascular complications, which is in contrast 1 ? 4"/"
Compared Northwestern Memorial Hospital s Bluhm
to the American College of Cardiology Cardiovascular lnstitute clinical outcomes data to fi tv"
(ACC)-National Data Registry, which outcomes data from the American College of Cardiology
1o/o
noted four in 1,000 patients. With regard (ACC)-National Cardiovascular Data Registry (1999); 0%
to neulological events (i.e. stroke, transient Nationa Heart, Lung and Blood Institute Registry (NHLBI)
on Percutaneous Coronary Artery lntervention (2000);
ischemic attack), the Bluhm Cardiovascular
and to a study of combined outcomes from 233 clinical
Institute's results (0.04 percent) remain research trials (Keeley, et al. Lancet 2003;361: ll-20).
favorable compared to the ACC National z(Keeley, et al, Lancet 2003;361: 13-20)
''\\ ir-e n e hoped fbr 00 percent sr-u'r ir ai. :rch ier ir-ig
1
Cardiovascular Review is published by the Department of Communications, Division Northwestern Memorial Hospital
N01 iia:i ct5.
of Public Relat ons, IVarketing and Physician Services, Northwestern Memorial Hospital 25,I East Huron Street !.5. PaSlCE
PAID
ED T0Rs Dawn Martin, Jennifer Ecklund-Johnson Chicago, lL 6061 1 -2908 TH CAGO, L