Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Material Handling Equipment Selection: New Classifications of Equipments and Attributes
Material Handling Equipment Selection: New Classifications of Equipments and Attributes
Abstract – This paper analyses the existing literature (27 [26], Velury and Kennedy [27], Welgama and Gibson [28],
articles) on material handling equipment selection through and Yaman [29].
equipments and attributes aspects. It is found that the
maximum material handling equipment types used by Those papers have developed solutions organized in
developed systems for resolving the selection problem is 50 5 groups: optimization models (4), expert systems (10), hybrid
equipment types. The greatest number of attributes used systems (2), multicriteria decision methods (4), and systemic
in one article is 42 attributes. However, systems should be framework approaches (2) [30]. They became new alternatives
more robust and practical by being close to the reality of for handling systems designers. Otherwise, they dispose few
the selection problem. According to the continuously decision making tools to select optimal material handling
growing market, much more material handling equipments for specific material handling operations in a
equipments exist. Therefore, more complete new factory or in a logistic warehouse. They are currently facing
classifications of individual unit load material handling three choices: (1) using their own experiences while seeking in
equipment types and attributes are provided. Equipment material handling books and handbooks, (2) trusting an
categories, classes and types are clarified. Reasons of the equipment seller and its catalogs, (3) requesting
necessity for new lists are discussed. recommendations from an external consultant [5]. The
selection process is discussed in detail in the literature review
Keywords - Material handling equipments, attributes, new of Ahmed Bouh and Riopel [30].
classifications, material handling equipment selection
This work comes to begin exploring one axe of the
research opportunities identified by the late literature.
I. INTRODUCTION Classifying material handling equipments and attributes is a
preliminary task between other in the process of developing a
A material handling system is constituted of methods solution for warehouse material handling equipment system.
using material handling equipments [1]. It could be a source of
cost savings or excessive expenditure if it is not efficiently However, various schools of thought exist concerning
designed. Its design goes through material handling equipment “material handling equipment" definition. This expression
selection. It is an obligatory passage and a phase among returns to the definition of “material handling”. In certain
others in warehouse design [2]. Moreover, selecting material papers which treat material handling equipment selection
handling equipments requires facilitating more efficient tools problem, it is regarded as being the fact of moving product
rather than consulting equipment vendors or doing thinks as from a point to another, while storing it on racks or
usual. manipulating it [31]. But, there is a difference between
product manipulation, handling it, transporting it, and
A literature review of the last 30 years researches on warehousing it. Material handling is "the process and systems
material handling equipment selection has identified 27 that transfer and manage the transfer of goods from one place
articles on this subject: Bookbinder and Gervais [3], to another" [32]. On the other hand, "manipulating is the
Chakraborty and Banik [4], Chan, Ip and Lau [5], Cho and action to move automatically, mechanically or manually
Egbelu [6], Chu, Egbelu and Wu [7], Fisher, Farber and Kay products in a work station. Transportation is the external long
[8], Fonseca, Uppal and Greene [9], Gabbert and Brown [10], distance travel of goods towards other places. Storage is the
Hassan [11], Hassan [12], Hassan, Hogg and Smith [13], Kim action to gather and have goods constituting stocks under
and Eom [14], Kulak [15], Malmborg, Krishnakumar, Simons material conditions favorable to their conservation and their
and Agee [16], Maniya and Bhatt [17], Matson, Mellichamph taking away” [33]."Material handling equipment cannot be
and Swaminathan [18], Mirhosseyni and Webb [19], Onut, used to store products. Similarly a pallet rack is not designed
Kara and Mert [20], Park [21], Raman, Nagalingam, Gurd and for moving a pallet in a distance"[30]. This is one of
Lin [22], Sharp, et al. [23], Telek [24], Trevino, Hurley, constraints in developing effective and practical systems for
Clincy and Jang [25], Tuzkaya, Gülsün, Kahraman and Özgen material handling equipment selection problem resolution.
System requirements in knowledge base and rules approaches specialized devices through variable programmed motions
are different from material handling to warehousing or for the performance of a variety of tasks.” [32],
transporting. • Automated guided vehicles system: "a self-controlled
vehicle that follows specified paths in a plant floor to
With equipments analysis, it is found that the move material, tools, and other items. Although most
maximum material handling equipment types used by systems are directed (guided) through a set of predefined
developed systems which are resolving the selection problem (fixed) paths, new guidance systems can plan paths and
is 50 types, while the minimum is zero type. This is far from control the vehicle dynamically" [32],
the reality since much more material handling equipment types • Unit load conveyor: "a horizontal, inclined or vertical
exist in the market. So, it is made possible to propose a more device for moving or transporting bulk materials,
complete new list of the material handling equipment types for packages or objects in a path predetermined by the design
particularly individual unit load manufacturing plants and of the device and having points of loading and discharge
warehouses. This work was completed by using existing fixed, or selective; included are skip hoists and vertical
technical literature in this field (encyclopedia, specialized reciprocating and inclined reciprocating conveyors;
dictionaries, handbooks, books, magazines, reports, courses typical exceptions are those devices known as industrial
notes). In addition, as requested by Ahmed Bouh and Riopel trucks, tractors and trailers, tiering machines (truck type),
[30], another more complete new list of attributes for cranes, hoists, monorail cranes, power and hand shovels,
identifying suitable equipment for material handling tasks is power scoops, bucket drag lines, platform elevators
provided. designed to carry passengers or the elevator operator, and
highway or rail vehicles." [32] ,
This new classification is relevant because it takes in • Bulk load conveyor: this equipment has the same
account all material handling equipment selection aspects definition as unit load conveyors except that the products
without limitation to any situation while previously are handled in bulk.
researchers limited their systems in some context and so
unusable elsewhere. Hence it will be possible to propose a Table 1 presents material handling equipment
generic system of material handling equipment selection using categories used in the 27 papers. Eleven papers in material
a harmonized synthesis of published attributes. handling equipment selection problem have added in their
studies related equipment categories which are not intended
After a recall on schools of thought on material for handling. Some authors have specified the whole material
handling concept, material handling equipments and related handling system. Moreover, five other papers did not precise
equipments used in material handling equipment selection used equipment types (Chakraborty and Banik [4], Hassan,
research papers are analyzed. Then, a new classification of Hogg and Smith [13], Hassan [12], Raman, Nagalingam, Gurd
material handling equipments is described. Published and Lin [22], and Telek [24]).
attributes in aforementioned articles are analyzed, followed by
their more complete new list in order to deal with selection
problem effectively. Finally, we answer why new B. Related equipments analysis
classifications are necessary for material handling equipments
and attributes respectively before concluding. By mentioning related equipments, authors are
interested in all devices in a material handling system.
Certainly, there are connexions and ongoing contacts between
II. MATERIAL HANDLING AND RELATED EQUIPMENTS static and dynamic technologies in warehouse environment.
A. Material handling equipments analysis For example, Hassan [11] states that the hierarchy of
equipments presented in his article reflects all equipments
found in the material handling system of pharmaceutical
The number of material handling equipments
sector. Related equipments found in papers but not concerned
available on the market increases continuously. It is possible
are as following.
to determine categories, classes, types and models of those
which currently exist. Material handling equipments
• Grippers: "a device by which a robot may grasp and hold
categories treated in scientific research articles are as
external objects" [32] ,
following.
• Identification and communication devices (scanner,
printer et terminal),
• Manual: "operated by people rather than automatically."
[32] • Manipulators: "a mechanism typically consisting of a
series of segments, jointed or sliding relative to one
• Hoist: “mechanism for lifting and lowering loads.” [32]
another, for the purpose of grasping and moving objects,
• Industrial truck: “a wheeled vehicle, primarily for the
usually in several degrees of freedom. It may be remotely
movement of objects or materials, and usually associated
controlled by a computer or by a human." [32],
with manufacturing, processing, or warehousing, but not
• Sortation systems: "an automated conveyor system with
including vehicles intended primarily for earth-moving or
diverters used for sorting items in a warehouse." [32],
over-the-road hauling.” [32],
• Warehousing systems (racks),
• Pipe : "pipings in which a fluid circulates." [34],
• Unit loads: "Any load configuration handled as a single
• Robot: “a robot is a reprogrammable, multifunctional
item" [32].
manipulator designed to move material, parts, tools, or
six pallet truck types. A total of 122 unit load material
C. New classification of material handling equipments
handling equipment types is listed. Bulk load equipments such
as pipes and bulk load conveyors are discarded since
Gu, Goetschalckx and McGinnis [2] address the need individual unit load manufacturing plants and warehouses are
for more widespread classification of equipments used in considered in this paper.
warehouse. One track would be to use technical literature and
research in this field to extract a new list adapted to the Each device has specific attributes. Questions
warehouse. Indeed, the Dictionnaire illustré des activités de addressed to user are designed in order to know values of
l'entreprise : industrie, techniques et gestion : français-anglais these attributes. In fact, they are simply requirements of the
(Édition mise à jour) of Riopel and Croteau [33], the material handling operation to perform.
Dictionary of industrial engineering terminology [32], the
Encyclopedia of material handling [35-37], different
handbooks of material handling [38] and [39-53], the books III. ATTRIBUTES
[54-56], and the courses notes [57, 58] provide sufficiently the
A. Attributes analysis
material needed for this work. With these collections, it is
possible to try to be comprehensive and address the selection
problem with a more complete list of main equipments types, Attributes used in material handling equipment
which was not the case until now. selection are grouped into several families. Titles of these
families are: product, movement, equipment, environment,
The list is organized in Table 2 into three levels: infrastructure, method, process, general, data processing,
category, class and type. Some categories are not divided into direct, inferred, and direct / inferred. It appears that some
two subgroups (class and type), but rather in one, then they go names of these groups almost mean the same things as their
straight from category to type. In total, we consider 122 types content, but authors change only in name. In addition, some
of material handling equipments for this selection problem attributes are found in different categories of an article to
under nine different categories. another, for example they pass from "movement" family to
"operation" or to "environment" and vice versa. This shows
However, each type has many varieties depending on that material handling equipments and their attributes are not
its mechanical characteristics and accompanied accessories. very well mastered. Some papers distinguish an attribute
Each variety is sold in several models depending on brand, group called "operation" [5, 6, 15, 19, 21]. It includes
mechanical performance and embedded options. variables that indicate if the desired equipment is intended for
handling or storage or manipulating. But this question does not
arise in this case because we cannot put together all these
D. Why a new material handling equipment types different devices belonging to different operation categories.
classification? Thus we particularly specify material handling equipments.
Beside the fact that largest material handling We propose a list of attributes that would be
equipment types number used in resolution material handling comprehensive and may be used in future researches.
equipment selection is 50 types by Chan, Ip and Lau [5], Collecting a comprehensive data concerning material handling
existing classification is confused. It is current to see one equipment and attributes is the first step for designing a
equipment name for several equipment types or even for system of material handling equipment selection. We describe
classes. For example, pallet jack is a device "used to lift, here the data and its organization. We also explain what
maneuver, and transport a pallet load of material in short conducted to propose this new classification and makes it
distances. The pallet jack can be either manual or battery relevant.
powered for both lifting and transporting. The lifting B. New classification of attributes
capability is typically from 6" to 10"." [56]. This definition
returns to equipment class aggregating several equipment
types. Some papers [6-8, 21] have used it, so their systems are We classify the attributes of material handling
proposing equipment classes and not equipment types. equipments in four main groups. Research has not used them
Material handling selection problem is a decision between yet in this complete way. They are unit load attributes,
equipment models knowing the equipment type. Systems movement attributes, equipment attributes and environment
should be able to select firstly equipment category, secondly attributes.
equipment class, thirdly equipment type and finally equipment
model. The selection process is more analysed in [30]. • Unit load: characteristics of single item handled,
• Movement: characteristics of desired transfer the material
The new classification is a comprehensive list of handling equipment is supposed to do,
material handling equipment types and it is able to facilitate • Equipment: built-in characteristics of required material
more practical solutions. Proposed material handling handling equipment,
equipments types are the most used. Industrial truck category • Environment: characteristics of workplace.
is exploded and privileged categories are provided. They are :
35 lifting equipment types, eleven elevators types, 31 Table 3 provides most significant attributes
industrial hand truck types, eleven self-propelling truck types, illustrating requirements of material handling tasks.
six stackers types, fourteen unit load conveyor types, three
automatic guided vehicle system types, five tractor types, and
C. Why a new attributes classification? solutions, which do not imply their applicability to all material
handling system design problems.
This makes possible to develop a generic system for
selecting material handling equipments which is independent The greatest number of attributes used till today by
largely applicable. an article is 42 attributes under four groups (general, product
movement, operation and data treatment) by Cho and Egbelu
Researchers have not specifically addressed the same [6].
material handling selection case. Some have worked for
specific companies or a specific industry sector or a particular Proposed attributes in this paper concern unit load
category of equipment such as conveyors and then they have equipments. They are 81 attributes: fifteen of unit load, 36 of
restricted their study with the necessary attributes. Others movement, 23 of equipment, and 7 of environment.
preferred to simply give illustrative examples of their
Legend:
When it comes to choose a model among several of evaluation criteria are: adaptability, steering angle, load
the same equipment type, evaluation criteria are used. They capacity, fixed cost, variable cost, degree of freedom,
are inspired by the research of Kulak [15] who used them to usability, flexibility, lifting height, width, length, maximum
select between several equipment types and not between length of conveyor, load weight, precision, safety, driving
equipment models of the same equipment type. These speed, and also pick-up and set-down speed.
Table 3: NEW CLASSIFICATION OF ATTRIBUTES
Attributes
Unit load Movement
Bottom surface : rigid or not, flat or not Aisle length : meter or foot
Easy to clean : plastic container, metal container Aisle width : meter or foot
Height : short, medium, high Automation level : manual, semi-automatic, automatic, required or not
Length : short, medium, high Available height : meter or foot
Nature : fragile, robust, compact, granular, block (bulk) Coverage area : point to point, confined to variable, fixed, variable, linear, 2D,
Production trend : increase, increase sharply, regression, strong regression, 3D
stable, Cross traffic : present or absent
Quantity to handle : low, medium, high Direction/plan : descent, horizontal / angled, vertical (up / decreasing)
Shape : regular, irregular Distance : short, medium, long
Size : regular, irregular, small, medium, large Flow : controlled or not
Temperature : °C Frequency : fixed, continuous, intermittent
Type : container, pallet, individual, tray handling, bar, bulk, reusable or not Handled load/time unit : uniform, variable, combination
Volume : m3 Interface handling equipment type : manual, semi-programmable, programmable
Warehousing properties : nestable and stackable Lifting height : meter or feet
Weight : light, medium, heavy Loading nature : simple, double or other
Width : short, medium, high Loading/unloading : alone, controlled or not
Location : indoor, outdoor, Mixed
Equipment Loop : open, closed
Accumulation : permitted or no Management mode : FIFO, LIFO
Acquisition cost : low, medium, high Movement configuration : continuous, intermittent
Bearing strength : newton Nature : transfer, rotate, capture, distribution, stacking, loading, unloading,
Design of the loading platform : roller, skatewheel, stationary, lifting conveying, transportation, lifting, wrenching, fixing, inserage, orientation, dock,
Engine type : diesel, gasoline, other order preparation, handling assets, outdoor handling
Equipment battery : low, medium, high Obstacle : yes or no
Equipment Compatibility with others : yes or no Operation accuracy : low, medium, high
Equipment profile complexity : straight line, composed, simple (continuous Operator lift height : low, high
handling) Origin/destination : fixed, variable, racks
External energy required : yes or no Output : low, medium, high
Gripping equipment : platform, skate, pallet fork, tractor, trailer etc ... Path : straight, curve, right angle
Lifting/ loading/unloading speed : low, medium, high Path variability : fix, variable
Loading capacity : Kg Route : fixed point to fixed point, fixed point to variable point, variable point to
Mode : manual, semi-programmable, programmable variable point
Operation control : alone, manual, automatic, yes or no Sequence : fix, variable
Operation cost : uniform, variable, irregular Speed : low, medium, fast, uniform, irregular, variable
Operator : accompanying, standing, sitting Tilt : degree
Power source : gravity, electrical Transaction data processing : manual, semi-automatic, automatic (barcode)
Primary function : movement, warehousing, manipulating, transportation Type : horizontal (above ground, overhead), inclined, rotational
Product protection : yes or no Unloading places : one place, several places at equal intervals, different places
Transportation method : carry, tow at unequal intervals
Wheel type : demountable tire, bonded tire, etc. Working level : ground, breast height, raised (horizontally, vertically, inclined)
Workstation types : one lane or two-way
Environment
Depth of the rack : simple, double
Floor space : available or no
Floor space nature : smooth, rough
Slope : degree
Space between column : m2 or f2
Warehousing : floor, pallet rack, automatic warehouse system
Working condition : noise, exhaust, dirt, debris, etc.