Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The French King Louis XVI was despotic and due to his indiscreet policies, the
colonies of India and America were removed from France, and France was
crushed in the Seven Years’ War. Added to this the king and the rest of the
nobility’s extravagant lifestyle were commenced through the treasury.
France had an absolute monarchy in the 18th century – life centred around the king,
who had complete power. Whilst theoretically this could work well, it was a system
heavily dependent on the personality of the king in question. Louis XVI was indecisive,
shy and lacked the charisma and charm which his predecessors had so benefited from.
The court at Versailles, just outside Paris, had between 3,000 and 10,000 courtiers living
there at any one time, all bound by strict etiquette. Such a large and complex social set
required management by the king in order to manage power, bestow favours and keep
a watchful eye over potential troublemakers. Louis simply didn’t have the capability or
iron will necessary to do this.
Louis’ wife and queen, Marie Antoinette, was an Austrian-born princess whose
(supposedly) profligate spending, Austrian sympathies and alleged sexual deviancy
were targeted repeatedly. Incapable of acting in a way which might have transformed
public opinion, the royal couple saw themselves become scapegoats for far more issues
than those which they could control.
French society was split into three categories. The first estate included
clergy, the second was aristocracy and the third included the peasant-
laborer and the middle class incorporating the merchants and the
intelligentsia. The first and the second estate were the privileged class, the
third was the exploited one. They were exploited by kings, feudatories, and
clergy. This divided them into two classes the exploiting and the exploited class
and increased the discontent between them.
The Estates System was far from unique to France: this ancient feudal social structure
broke society into 3 groups, clergy, nobility and everyone else. In the Medieval period,
prior to the boom of the merchant classes, this system did broadly reflect the structure
of the world. As more and more prosperous self-made men rose through the ranks, the
system’s rigidity became an increasing source of frustration. The new bourgeoise class
could only make the leap to the Second Estate (the nobility) through the practice of
venality, the buying and selling of offices.
3.Religious Discontent
There were more than a hundred thousand religious priests in France at that
time. The life of some of the priests was so opulent, while some did not even
have arrangements for two meals a day. The Churches held more than 40% of
the total land, the poor people were running out of land for agriculture. A
religious tax called Tithes, which was voluntary, was collected
forcibly. This increased the discontent among the public
4. Inherited problems
By no means did Louis XVI inherit an easy situation. The power of the French monarchy
had peaked under Louis XIV, and by the time Louis XVI inherited, France found herself
in an increasingly dire financial situation, weakened by the Seven Years War
and American War of Independence.
With an old and inefficient taxation system which saw large portions of the wealthiest
parts of French society exempt from major taxes, the burden was carried by the poorest
and simply didn’t provide enough cash.
From the economic point of view, at that time the condition of France was
worse than the rest of Europe. The primary reason for this was the grave
expenditure of warfare, corruption, overbearing taxation, and the
extravagant life of monarchy. The first and the second estate were kept
tax-free. There was no computation of income and expenditure of the first
two estates.
The seven years war emptied the treasury of the state. When King Louis XIV
got the throne he inherited an empty treasury. Under Louis XVI’s rule,
France was supporting American colonies in the freedom struggle. The war
expenditure increased an extra debt of 1 billion livres (the unit of
currency in France till 1794) to preexisting 2 billion livers.
The 10% interest in the war debts kept increasing and pressurized the
French government to increase the tax rates in the country. Along
with several indirect taxes on daily use articles like salt and tobacco,
direct taxes called Taille was collected by the government.
The first and the second estate were exempted from paying the taxes and
the whole burden fell on the third estate. On one hand, where the peasants
had to bear the burden of taxes the working class didn’t get their wages on
time which pushed them further into poverty.
French finances were a mess by the late 18th century. The taxation system allowed the
wealthiest to avoid paying virtually any tax at all, and given that wealth almost always
equalled power, any attempt to push through radical financial reforms was blocked by
the parlements. Unable to change the tax, and not daring to increase the burden on
those who already shouldered it, Jacques Necker, the finance minister, raised money
through taking out loans rather than raising taxes. Whilst this had some short term
benefits, loans accrued interest and pushed the country further into debt.
In an attempt to add some form of transparency to royal expenditure and to create a
more educated and informed populace, Necker published the Crown’s expenses and
accounts in a document known as the Compte rendu au roi. Instead of placating the
situation, it in fact gave the people an insight into something they had previously
considered to be none of their concern.
With France on the brink of bankruptcy, and people more acutely aware and less
tolerant of the feudal financial system they were upholding, the situation was becoming
more and more delicate. Attempts to push through radical financial reforms were made,
but Louis’ influence was too weak to force his nobles to bend to his will.
7.The Enlightenment
9.inflation
Many of these issues were long term factors causing discontent and stagnation in
France, but they had not caused revolution to erupt in the first 15 years of Louis’ reign.
The real cost of living had increased by 62% between 1741 and 1785, and two
successive years of poor harvests in 1788 and 1789 caused the price of bread to be
dramatically inflated along with a drop in wages.
This added hardship added an extra layer of resentment and weight to the grievances of
the Third Estate, which was largely made up of peasants and a few bourgeoise.
Accusations of the extravagant spending of the royal family – irrespective of their truth –
further exacerbated tensions, and the king and queen were increasingly targets
of libelles and attacks in print.
The farmers and workers could not resist the French elite. The newly emerged
middle class of the society made up for this shortcoming. This middle class
included thinkers, teachers, traders, lawyers, doctors, etc. They were neither
extremely rich nor poor, thus they held unique political importance similar to the
merchants of the Roman Empire.
On June 20th, 1789 the members of the third house wanted to hold a joint
sitting of the three houses. When the members of the Third House came for
the meeting, they weren’t allowed inside. Therefore, the members took the
meeting in the tennis court outside the hall and took an oath that the assembly
would not be dissolved without opting for a new constitution to France. On 14
July 1789, the enraged mob attacked the Bastille and freed the prisoners,
which marked the onset of the French Revolution.